[ { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259171", "Detail": { "ID": 259171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3447579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318702", "Detail": { "ID": 318702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6697607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249462", "Detail": { "ID": 249462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9276816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321095", "Detail": { "ID": 321095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2020295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228363", "Detail": { "ID": 228363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7951752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281078", "Detail": { "ID": 281078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8050448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262832", "Detail": { "ID": 262832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6248715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288968", "Detail": { "ID": 288968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.166366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230544", "Detail": { "ID": 230544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3349636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269700", "Detail": { "ID": 269700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5592411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322523", "Detail": { "ID": 322523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6923698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295370", "Detail": { "ID": 295370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5092793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243129", "Detail": { "ID": 243129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0502006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227089", "Detail": { "ID": 227089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2670218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303096", "Detail": { "ID": 303096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.558433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244171", "Detail": { "ID": 244171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3418304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316356", "Detail": { "ID": 316356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1442794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326966", "Detail": { "ID": 326966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7877964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277171", "Detail": { "ID": 277171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7041479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264003", "Detail": { "ID": 264003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9200305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248613", "Detail": { "ID": 248613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6623642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294167", "Detail": { "ID": 294167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8858223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285337", "Detail": { "ID": 285337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3186693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231275", "Detail": { "ID": 231275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.587945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243589", "Detail": { "ID": 243589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3114482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254431", "Detail": { "ID": 254431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.255674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323418", "Detail": { "ID": 323418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9552809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290864", "Detail": { "ID": 290864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7754103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273034", "Detail": { "ID": 273034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3667249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262566", "Detail": { "ID": 262566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6074195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281816", "Detail": { "ID": 281816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1588228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298311", "Detail": { "ID": 298311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3402852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284951", "Detail": { "ID": 284951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0547254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219551", "Detail": { "ID": 219551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3042463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238257", "Detail": { "ID": 238257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4385963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225115", "Detail": { "ID": 225115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.745134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321937", "Detail": { "ID": 321937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4578277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292240", "Detail": { "ID": 292240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5252289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227583", "Detail": { "ID": 227583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.556383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313324", "Detail": { "ID": 313324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3904093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257820", "Detail": { "ID": 257820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0789921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271083", "Detail": { "ID": 271083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8417577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277952", "Detail": { "ID": 277952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9758365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288324", "Detail": { "ID": 288324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1299093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250637", "Detail": { "ID": 250637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2070885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221101", "Detail": { "ID": 221101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6751194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220093", "Detail": { "ID": 220093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3340187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252827", "Detail": { "ID": 252827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7549396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253741", "Detail": { "ID": 253741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0189551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324833", "Detail": { "ID": 324833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2397818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259404", "Detail": { "ID": 259404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6076586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239486", "Detail": { "ID": 239486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7458475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273629", "Detail": { "ID": 273629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.62861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302614", "Detail": { "ID": 302614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5321863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303983", "Detail": { "ID": 303983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8443336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221593", "Detail": { "ID": 221593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9394344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241825", "Detail": { "ID": 241825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7816683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223376", "Detail": { "ID": 223376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4552045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307893", "Detail": { "ID": 307893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8554751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272373", "Detail": { "ID": 272373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3325413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245138", "Detail": { "ID": 245138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5936798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315308", "Detail": { "ID": 315308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9060115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247475", "Detail": { "ID": 247475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4054361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275157", "Detail": { "ID": 275157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1440488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255477", "Detail": { "ID": 255477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5330164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276932", "Detail": { "ID": 276932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6872997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253487", "Detail": { "ID": 253487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9985497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276367", "Detail": { "ID": 276367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6625706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325298", "Detail": { "ID": 325298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4926737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233315", "Detail": { "ID": 233315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1189151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311737", "Detail": { "ID": 311737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8920838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229628", "Detail": { "ID": 229628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0898921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267523", "Detail": { "ID": 267523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0234964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313423", "Detail": { "ID": 313423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3947273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294452", "Detail": { "ID": 294452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1389157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319186", "Detail": { "ID": 319186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6961345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306177", "Detail": { "ID": 306177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3622919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309874", "Detail": { "ID": 309874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3546661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268081", "Detail": { "ID": 268081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0551694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292974", "Detail": { "ID": 292974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5662201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258498", "Detail": { "ID": 258498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3098469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263572", "Detail": { "ID": 263572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.895186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307404", "Detail": { "ID": 307404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8279938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280133", "Detail": { "ID": 280133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5428477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279501", "Detail": { "ID": 279501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5104303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260382", "Detail": { "ID": 260382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0744667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299353", "Detail": { "ID": 299353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6937991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302221", "Detail": { "ID": 302221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5149834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300214", "Detail": { "ID": 300214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9882979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224005", "Detail": { "ID": 224005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4879118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305690", "Detail": { "ID": 305690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.335211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320084", "Detail": { "ID": 320084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9609839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315774", "Detail": { "ID": 315774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9264295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237111", "Detail": { "ID": 237111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9663133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289704", "Detail": { "ID": 289704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4555878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234259", "Detail": { "ID": 234259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3695303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312877", "Detail": { "ID": 312877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1536866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261417", "Detail": { "ID": 261417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3564364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225565", "Detail": { "ID": 225565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9804987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265699", "Detail": { "ID": 265699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4504545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283008", "Detail": { "ID": 283008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.443823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252087", "Detail": { "ID": 252087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5019877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317306", "Detail": { "ID": 317306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4164371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254214", "Detail": { "ID": 254214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2458362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293945", "Detail": { "ID": 293945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8759359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235531", "Detail": { "ID": 235531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6818305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258066", "Detail": { "ID": 258066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0900836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228598", "Detail": { "ID": 228598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8060125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291032", "Detail": { "ID": 291032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7825601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311590", "Detail": { "ID": 311590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8854451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246820", "Detail": { "ID": 246820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1547864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297688", "Detail": { "ID": 297688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1204511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234029", "Detail": { "ID": 234029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1570701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274894", "Detail": { "ID": 274894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1266007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269999", "Detail": { "ID": 269999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5771804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317774", "Detail": { "ID": 317774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4367802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326532", "Detail": { "ID": 326532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7687335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241303", "Detail": { "ID": 241303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7521263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291113", "Detail": { "ID": 291113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7862564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248096", "Detail": { "ID": 248096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4418104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288164", "Detail": { "ID": 288164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9096826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222655", "Detail": { "ID": 222655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1982605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239668", "Detail": { "ID": 239668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7538178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283807", "Detail": { "ID": 283807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7243158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231758", "Detail": { "ID": 231758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6142546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237308", "Detail": { "ID": 237308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.198596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308944", "Detail": { "ID": 308944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2151, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 33, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08610", "ID": 8724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0848093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259446", "Detail": { "ID": 259446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6094488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317983", "Detail": { "ID": 317983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4519181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250162", "Detail": { "ID": 250162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.966068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320834", "Detail": { "ID": 320834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1836792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228469", "Detail": { "ID": 228469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8004144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281560", "Detail": { "ID": 281560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1480499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263097", "Detail": { "ID": 263097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6366339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290711", "Detail": { "ID": 290711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7689544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227519", "Detail": { "ID": 227519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5536321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270735", "Detail": { "ID": 270735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8208329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323025", "Detail": { "ID": 323025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7187898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297320", "Detail": { "ID": 297320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0946131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242689", "Detail": { "ID": 242689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.031377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM237001", "Detail": { "ID": 237001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9494975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301561", "Detail": { "ID": 301561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2678004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262024", "Detail": { "ID": 262024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.388319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316914", "Detail": { "ID": 316914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1688793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326583", "Detail": { "ID": 326583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7709961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277592", "Detail": { "ID": 277592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9599522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265015", "Detail": { "ID": 265015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1646773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250938", "Detail": { "ID": 250938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.220052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291166", "Detail": { "ID": 291166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7885333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285446", "Detail": { "ID": 285446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3236222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231384", "Detail": { "ID": 231384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5978557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243182", "Detail": { "ID": 243182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0576714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254001", "Detail": { "ID": 254001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0302395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321149", "Detail": { "ID": 321149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2043842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292437", "Detail": { "ID": 292437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5337465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273144", "Detail": { "ID": 273144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3714883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262859", "Detail": { "ID": 262859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6260533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282322", "Detail": { "ID": 282322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4078064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298947", "Detail": { "ID": 298947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3791833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287157", "Detail": { "ID": 287157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.621632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219639", "Detail": { "ID": 219639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3080731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239136", "Detail": { "ID": 239136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4968393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226279", "Detail": { "ID": 226279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2187289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322270", "Detail": { "ID": 322270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6755253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292300", "Detail": { "ID": 292300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5278298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227667", "Detail": { "ID": 227667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5604908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304520", "Detail": { "ID": 304520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0417252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257964", "Detail": { "ID": 257964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.085469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271729", "Detail": { "ID": 271729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0889433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279387", "Detail": { "ID": 279387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5055005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266463", "Detail": { "ID": 266463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7421875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250781", "Detail": { "ID": 250781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2132455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221247", "Detail": { "ID": 221247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9210929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226425", "Detail": { "ID": 226425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2308357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239772", "Detail": { "ID": 239772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7582521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266864", "Detail": { "ID": 266864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7653108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324398", "Detail": { "ID": 324398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2150117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260950", "Detail": { "ID": 260950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1049628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246088", "Detail": { "ID": 246088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8716985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276210", "Detail": { "ID": 276210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6493286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM303402", "Detail": { "ID": 303402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.813735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303616", "Detail": { "ID": 303616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8229785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222292", "Detail": { "ID": 222292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1824127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245577", "Detail": { "ID": 245577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8494262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224733", "Detail": { "ID": 224733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7175983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308377", "Detail": { "ID": 308377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.053329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272518", "Detail": { "ID": 272518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3388417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244698", "Detail": { "ID": 244698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5744414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314718", "Detail": { "ID": 314718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6524974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252525", "Detail": { "ID": 252525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7330042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275951", "Detail": { "ID": 275951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3980501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257428", "Detail": { "ID": 257428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0557737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282852", "Detail": { "ID": 282852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4371145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254076", "Detail": { "ID": 254076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0334822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278783", "Detail": { "ID": 278783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2340735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324887", "Detail": { "ID": 324887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2420627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231968", "Detail": { "ID": 231968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6235271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312349", "Detail": { "ID": 312349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1240067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233154", "Detail": { "ID": 233154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8992028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267753", "Detail": { "ID": 267753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0335005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314500", "Detail": { "ID": 314500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6426843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296656", "Detail": { "ID": 296656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.868346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319674", "Detail": { "ID": 319674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9364498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305797", "Detail": { "ID": 305797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.345747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310305", "Detail": { "ID": 310305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5647916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268687", "Detail": { "ID": 268687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2783587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293739", "Detail": { "ID": 293739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8668502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271431", "Detail": { "ID": 271431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0755262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269408", "Detail": { "ID": 269408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5462584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307290", "Detail": { "ID": 307290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8228439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280573", "Detail": { "ID": 280573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7730325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281287", "Detail": { "ID": 281287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1283452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245190", "Detail": { "ID": 245190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8239248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304799", "Detail": { "ID": 304799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0592244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301845", "Detail": { "ID": 301845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2857367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300272", "Detail": { "ID": 300272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9907978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224304", "Detail": { "ID": 224304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6931565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297546", "Detail": { "ID": 297546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.104843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321053", "Detail": { "ID": 321053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2002323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315363", "Detail": { "ID": 315363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9087606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237220", "Detail": { "ID": 237220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1948334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292593", "Detail": { "ID": 292593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5495143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233989", "Detail": { "ID": 233989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1550735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311955", "Detail": { "ID": 311955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9074626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261359", "Detail": { "ID": 261359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3539702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225676", "Detail": { "ID": 225676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9855813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265581", "Detail": { "ID": 265581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4453402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283954", "Detail": { "ID": 283954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7306623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258658", "Detail": { "ID": 258658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3169896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318272", "Detail": { "ID": 318272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6456335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256124", "Detail": { "ID": 256124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5716562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293876", "Detail": { "ID": 293876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8726226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235929", "Detail": { "ID": 235929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6990212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255972", "Detail": { "ID": 255972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5648695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229358", "Detail": { "ID": 229358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0783054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289445", "Detail": { "ID": 289445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4375549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310529", "Detail": { "ID": 310529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5748122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247115", "Detail": { "ID": 247115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1677003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298721", "Detail": { "ID": 298721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3693676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235839", "Detail": { "ID": 235839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6951654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275341", "Detail": { "ID": 275341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3659203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274139", "Detail": { "ID": 274139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6561457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316877", "Detail": { "ID": 316877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1672987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326097", "Detail": { "ID": 326097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.539753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241449", "Detail": { "ID": 241449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7584345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288675", "Detail": { "ID": 288675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1535949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248181", "Detail": { "ID": 248181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4467682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290066", "Detail": { "ID": 290066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4713093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222724", "Detail": { "ID": 222724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2014339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240826", "Detail": { "ID": 240826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3839403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284287", "Detail": { "ID": 284287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0198631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251699", "Detail": { "ID": 251699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4849343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247258", "Detail": { "ID": 247258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3958076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309757", "Detail": { "ID": 309757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2150, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551.4", "ID": 8688 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3436306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259445", "Detail": { "ID": 259445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6094086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317982", "Detail": { "ID": 317982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4518772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250161", "Detail": { "ID": 250161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9660143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320835", "Detail": { "ID": 320835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1837195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228470", "Detail": { "ID": 228470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8004557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281559", "Detail": { "ID": 281559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1480101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263098", "Detail": { "ID": 263098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6366755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290712", "Detail": { "ID": 290712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7689951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227520", "Detail": { "ID": 227520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5536722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270736", "Detail": { "ID": 270736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8208736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323027", "Detail": { "ID": 323027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7188724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297321", "Detail": { "ID": 297321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0946542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242690", "Detail": { "ID": 242690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.031417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM237000", "Detail": { "ID": 237000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9494572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301560", "Detail": { "ID": 301560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2677595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262023", "Detail": { "ID": 262023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.388279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316912", "Detail": { "ID": 316912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1687978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326582", "Detail": { "ID": 326582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7709315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277593", "Detail": { "ID": 277593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9599936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265014", "Detail": { "ID": 265014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1645343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249346", "Detail": { "ID": 249346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9226191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291165", "Detail": { "ID": 291165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7884928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285447", "Detail": { "ID": 285447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.323663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231385", "Detail": { "ID": 231385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5978979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243181", "Detail": { "ID": 243181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.057631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254002", "Detail": { "ID": 254002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0302983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321148", "Detail": { "ID": 321148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2043238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292454", "Detail": { "ID": 292454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5344806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273145", "Detail": { "ID": 273145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3715295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262842", "Detail": { "ID": 262842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.625306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282323", "Detail": { "ID": 282323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4078471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298945", "Detail": { "ID": 298945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3791039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287156", "Detail": { "ID": 287156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6215901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219673", "Detail": { "ID": 219673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3095542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239137", "Detail": { "ID": 239137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4968804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226278", "Detail": { "ID": 226278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2186874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322268", "Detail": { "ID": 322268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6754447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292299", "Detail": { "ID": 292299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5277895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227701", "Detail": { "ID": 227701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.56195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304519", "Detail": { "ID": 304519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.041685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257965", "Detail": { "ID": 257965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.085529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271728", "Detail": { "ID": 271728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0889028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279388", "Detail": { "ID": 279388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5055427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266462", "Detail": { "ID": 266462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7421469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250782", "Detail": { "ID": 250782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2132856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221248", "Detail": { "ID": 221248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.921155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226391", "Detail": { "ID": 226391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2293447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239771", "Detail": { "ID": 239771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7582119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266865", "Detail": { "ID": 266865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7653521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324399", "Detail": { "ID": 324399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2150717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260914", "Detail": { "ID": 260914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1034151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246087", "Detail": { "ID": 246087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8716552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276209", "Detail": { "ID": 276209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6492866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM303401", "Detail": { "ID": 303401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.813693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303617", "Detail": { "ID": 303617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.823037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222291", "Detail": { "ID": 222291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1765755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245576", "Detail": { "ID": 245576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8493865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224732", "Detail": { "ID": 224732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7175578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308375", "Detail": { "ID": 308375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0532291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272519", "Detail": { "ID": 272519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3389018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244699", "Detail": { "ID": 244699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5744818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314719", "Detail": { "ID": 314719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6525382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252526", "Detail": { "ID": 252526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7331376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275952", "Detail": { "ID": 275952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3980905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257429", "Detail": { "ID": 257429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0558334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282851", "Detail": { "ID": 282851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4370735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254075", "Detail": { "ID": 254075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0334236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278800", "Detail": { "ID": 278800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2347911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324886", "Detail": { "ID": 324886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2420223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231967", "Detail": { "ID": 231967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6234857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312347", "Detail": { "ID": 312347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1239209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233120", "Detail": { "ID": 233120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8977026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267752", "Detail": { "ID": 267752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0334603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314502", "Detail": { "ID": 314502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6427668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296657", "Detail": { "ID": 296657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.868386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319517", "Detail": { "ID": 319517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9293733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305796", "Detail": { "ID": 305796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3457062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310306", "Detail": { "ID": 310306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5648334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268688", "Detail": { "ID": 268688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2783998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293738", "Detail": { "ID": 293738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8667912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271430", "Detail": { "ID": 271430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.075484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269425", "Detail": { "ID": 269425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5469805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307289", "Detail": { "ID": 307289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8228032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280249", "Detail": { "ID": 280249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7525113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281286", "Detail": { "ID": 281286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1283032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245189", "Detail": { "ID": 245189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8238795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304801", "Detail": { "ID": 304801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0593062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301846", "Detail": { "ID": 301846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.285777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300271", "Detail": { "ID": 300271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9907575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224305", "Detail": { "ID": 224305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6931976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297547", "Detail": { "ID": 297547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1048838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321055", "Detail": { "ID": 321055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2003151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315362", "Detail": { "ID": 315362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9087203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237221", "Detail": { "ID": 237221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1948742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292592", "Detail": { "ID": 292592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5494737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233990", "Detail": { "ID": 233990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1551142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311954", "Detail": { "ID": 311954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.907422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261360", "Detail": { "ID": 261360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3540118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225677", "Detail": { "ID": 225677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.985641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265582", "Detail": { "ID": 265582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4453807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283971", "Detail": { "ID": 283971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7314071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258694", "Detail": { "ID": 258694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3186167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318274", "Detail": { "ID": 318274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.645716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256123", "Detail": { "ID": 256123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5716142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293877", "Detail": { "ID": 293877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8726631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235963", "Detail": { "ID": 235963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7004751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255971", "Detail": { "ID": 255971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5648107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229359", "Detail": { "ID": 229359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0783466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289446", "Detail": { "ID": 289446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4375957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310530", "Detail": { "ID": 310530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5748524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247116", "Detail": { "ID": 247116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.167741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298720", "Detail": { "ID": 298720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3693278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235838", "Detail": { "ID": 235838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6951267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275324", "Detail": { "ID": 275324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3651993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274138", "Detail": { "ID": 274138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6561032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316878", "Detail": { "ID": 316878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1673393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326098", "Detail": { "ID": 326098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5397936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241450", "Detail": { "ID": 241450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7584756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288676", "Detail": { "ID": 288676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1536362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248216", "Detail": { "ID": 248216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6363247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290049", "Detail": { "ID": 290049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4705722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222768", "Detail": { "ID": 222768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.20357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240825", "Detail": { "ID": 240825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3839001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284288", "Detail": { "ID": 284288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0199057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251698", "Detail": { "ID": 251698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4848744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246771", "Detail": { "ID": 246771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1527066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309759", "Detail": { "ID": 309759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2149, "AgendaID": 2956, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Finance", "Reference": "S4M-08551", "ID": 8670 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3437124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259141", "Detail": { "ID": 259141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3434932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319572", "Detail": { "ID": 319572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9317274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249492", "Detail": { "ID": 249492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9292098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320873", "Detail": { "ID": 320873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1853579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228352", "Detail": { "ID": 228352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7946842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281044", "Detail": { "ID": 281044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8036042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262799", "Detail": { "ID": 262799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6173299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288940", "Detail": { "ID": 288940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1648869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230518", "Detail": { "ID": 230518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3336415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269730", "Detail": { "ID": 269730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.560518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322556", "Detail": { "ID": 322556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6937907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295336", "Detail": { "ID": 295336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.507833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243030", "Detail": { "ID": 243030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0459124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235102", "Detail": { "ID": 235102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4194621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302474", "Detail": { "ID": 302474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5261416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244204", "Detail": { "ID": 244204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5444386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316336", "Detail": { "ID": 316336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.14343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327066", "Detail": { "ID": 327066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7973421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277138", "Detail": { "ID": 277138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7027371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264036", "Detail": { "ID": 264036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9214445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248662", "Detail": { "ID": 248662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6644453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294882", "Detail": { "ID": 294882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1827957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285303", "Detail": { "ID": 285303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.317202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230779", "Detail": { "ID": 230779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3451642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243688", "Detail": { "ID": 243688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3156066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254460", "Detail": { "ID": 254460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2570851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323519", "Detail": { "ID": 323519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9598854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290913", "Detail": { "ID": 290913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7774789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273001", "Detail": { "ID": 273001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.365036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262362", "Detail": { "ID": 262362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.598194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281848", "Detail": { "ID": 281848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.160199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298279", "Detail": { "ID": 298279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3389134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284987", "Detail": { "ID": 284987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.056359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219502", "Detail": { "ID": 219502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3020459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238285", "Detail": { "ID": 238285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4398082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225147", "Detail": { "ID": 225147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7464811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321904", "Detail": { "ID": 321904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4563481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292752", "Detail": { "ID": 292752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5566292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227227", "Detail": { "ID": 227227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5363328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313295", "Detail": { "ID": 313295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3891493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257790", "Detail": { "ID": 257790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.077728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271120", "Detail": { "ID": 271120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8433417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277986", "Detail": { "ID": 277986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9773018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287370", "Detail": { "ID": 287370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8613062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250607", "Detail": { "ID": 250607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1968533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221070", "Detail": { "ID": 221070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6737826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220142", "Detail": { "ID": 220142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3361502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252798", "Detail": { "ID": 252798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7537284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253755", "Detail": { "ID": 253755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.019555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324732", "Detail": { "ID": 324732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2355082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259609", "Detail": { "ID": 259609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6168259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239458", "Detail": { "ID": 239458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7376801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273662", "Detail": { "ID": 273662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6300159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302016", "Detail": { "ID": 302016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2934428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304012", "Detail": { "ID": 304012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8456069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221624", "Detail": { "ID": 221624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9407652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241855", "Detail": { "ID": 241855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7829347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223415", "Detail": { "ID": 223415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4568838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307862", "Detail": { "ID": 307862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8541317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272342", "Detail": { "ID": 272342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3312107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245041", "Detail": { "ID": 245041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5894765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315207", "Detail": { "ID": 315207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8985327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247503", "Detail": { "ID": 247503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4066225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275120", "Detail": { "ID": 275120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1424406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255507", "Detail": { "ID": 255507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5343041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276969", "Detail": { "ID": 276969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6891382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253458", "Detail": { "ID": 253458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9972922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276727", "Detail": { "ID": 276727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6785362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325399", "Detail": { "ID": 325399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4970194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233290", "Detail": { "ID": 233290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1176289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311706", "Detail": { "ID": 311706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8907536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229677", "Detail": { "ID": 229677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.091946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267489", "Detail": { "ID": 267489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0220328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313454", "Detail": { "ID": 313454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3960677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294949", "Detail": { "ID": 294949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1856797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319154", "Detail": { "ID": 319154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6947662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306279", "Detail": { "ID": 306279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.545225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310753", "Detail": { "ID": 310753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5845702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268115", "Detail": { "ID": 268115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0568228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292942", "Detail": { "ID": 292942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5648616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258529", "Detail": { "ID": 258529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3111704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263775", "Detail": { "ID": 263775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.904189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308735", "Detail": { "ID": 308735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0687282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279774", "Detail": { "ID": 279774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.522248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279535", "Detail": { "ID": 279535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5118841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260479", "Detail": { "ID": 260479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0786653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299384", "Detail": { "ID": 299384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6951211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306766", "Detail": { "ID": 306766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5664803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300569", "Detail": { "ID": 300569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0042526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223974", "Detail": { "ID": 223974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4866026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305588", "Detail": { "ID": 305588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3308474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320117", "Detail": { "ID": 320117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9624069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315875", "Detail": { "ID": 315875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9309804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236767", "Detail": { "ID": 236767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.939178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289738", "Detail": { "ID": 289738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4570309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234288", "Detail": { "ID": 234288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.370808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313135", "Detail": { "ID": 313135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1651605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289367", "Detail": { "ID": 289367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4341876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225372", "Detail": { "ID": 225372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.971876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265728", "Detail": { "ID": 265728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4519206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283213", "Detail": { "ID": 283213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6907208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252038", "Detail": { "ID": 252038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4999009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317338", "Detail": { "ID": 317338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4178236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254244", "Detail": { "ID": 254244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.247165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296269", "Detail": { "ID": 296269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8413639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235481", "Detail": { "ID": 235481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6796907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258037", "Detail": { "ID": 258037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0885936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228567", "Detail": { "ID": 228567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8046644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291059", "Detail": { "ID": 291059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7837067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311489", "Detail": { "ID": 311489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8810421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246790", "Detail": { "ID": 246790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.153521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298031", "Detail": { "ID": 298031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1353117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234062", "Detail": { "ID": 234062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1650035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274691", "Detail": { "ID": 274691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1175619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269965", "Detail": { "ID": 269965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5757119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317673", "Detail": { "ID": 317673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4325141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326431", "Detail": { "ID": 326431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7584348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241273", "Detail": { "ID": 241273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7508298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290400", "Detail": { "ID": 290400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7454782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248047", "Detail": { "ID": 248047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4394841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287498", "Detail": { "ID": 287498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8735832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222616", "Detail": { "ID": 222616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.196591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239851", "Detail": { "ID": 239851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7616577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283770", "Detail": { "ID": 283770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.722712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231769", "Detail": { "ID": 231769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6147197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237357", "Detail": { "ID": 237357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2007117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308975", "Detail": { "ID": 308975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2148, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Youth Sport Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-08546.1", "ID": 8661 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0861418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259140", "Detail": { "ID": 259140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3434341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319573", "Detail": { "ID": 319573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9317684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249494", "Detail": { "ID": 249494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9292908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320872", "Detail": { "ID": 320872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1853179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228350", "Detail": { "ID": 228350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7946015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281046", "Detail": { "ID": 281046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8037067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262797", "Detail": { "ID": 262797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6172497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288941", "Detail": { "ID": 288941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.164927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230516", "Detail": { "ID": 230516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3335376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269731", "Detail": { "ID": 269731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5605578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322550", "Detail": { "ID": 322550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6935484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295334", "Detail": { "ID": 295334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5077367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243012", "Detail": { "ID": 243012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.045146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235104", "Detail": { "ID": 235104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4195451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302466", "Detail": { "ID": 302466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5257934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244206", "Detail": { "ID": 244206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.544522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316338", "Detail": { "ID": 316338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1435126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327067", "Detail": { "ID": 327067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7974273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277136", "Detail": { "ID": 277136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7026356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264038", "Detail": { "ID": 264038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9215438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248664", "Detail": { "ID": 248664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6645454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294900", "Detail": { "ID": 294900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1835733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285301", "Detail": { "ID": 285301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3171104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230777", "Detail": { "ID": 230777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3450833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243706", "Detail": { "ID": 243706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3163441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254468", "Detail": { "ID": 254468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2574213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323520", "Detail": { "ID": 323520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9599262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290915", "Detail": { "ID": 290915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7775589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272999", "Detail": { "ID": 272999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.364862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262360", "Detail": { "ID": 262360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5981128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281846", "Detail": { "ID": 281846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1601176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298281", "Detail": { "ID": 298281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3389945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284986", "Detail": { "ID": 284986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0563185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219500", "Detail": { "ID": 219500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.301963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238286", "Detail": { "ID": 238286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4398486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225149", "Detail": { "ID": 225149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7465615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321910", "Detail": { "ID": 321910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4566155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292754", "Detail": { "ID": 292754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5567221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227225", "Detail": { "ID": 227225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5362497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313287", "Detail": { "ID": 313287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.388799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257788", "Detail": { "ID": 257788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0776266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271119", "Detail": { "ID": 271119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8433002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277984", "Detail": { "ID": 277984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9772201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287362", "Detail": { "ID": 287362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8609561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250605", "Detail": { "ID": 250605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1967717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221068", "Detail": { "ID": 221068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6737008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220144", "Detail": { "ID": 220144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3362318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252790", "Detail": { "ID": 252790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7533867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253753", "Detail": { "ID": 253753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0194566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324731", "Detail": { "ID": 324731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2354687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259611", "Detail": { "ID": 259611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6169086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239457", "Detail": { "ID": 239457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7376395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273664", "Detail": { "ID": 273664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6300976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302015", "Detail": { "ID": 302015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2934015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304020", "Detail": { "ID": 304020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8459539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221626", "Detail": { "ID": 221626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9408466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241857", "Detail": { "ID": 241857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7830159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223417", "Detail": { "ID": 223417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4569678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307864", "Detail": { "ID": 307864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8542141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272340", "Detail": { "ID": 272340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3311298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245023", "Detail": { "ID": 245023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5886892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315206", "Detail": { "ID": 315206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8984904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247504", "Detail": { "ID": 247504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4066631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275121", "Detail": { "ID": 275121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1424995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255508", "Detail": { "ID": 255508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5343446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276968", "Detail": { "ID": 276968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.689098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253457", "Detail": { "ID": 253457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9972507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276729", "Detail": { "ID": 276729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6786165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325400", "Detail": { "ID": 325400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.49706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233289", "Detail": { "ID": 233289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1175872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311708", "Detail": { "ID": 311708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8908539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229679", "Detail": { "ID": 229679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0920262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267491", "Detail": { "ID": 267491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0221432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313452", "Detail": { "ID": 313452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3959853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294947", "Detail": { "ID": 294947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1855963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319160", "Detail": { "ID": 319160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6950117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306297", "Detail": { "ID": 306297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5459993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310757", "Detail": { "ID": 310757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5847341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268113", "Detail": { "ID": 268113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0567133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292944", "Detail": { "ID": 292944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5649417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258531", "Detail": { "ID": 258531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3112695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263777", "Detail": { "ID": 263777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9042704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308731", "Detail": { "ID": 308731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0685266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279772", "Detail": { "ID": 279772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5221674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279537", "Detail": { "ID": 279537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5119645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260497", "Detail": { "ID": 260497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0794276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299382", "Detail": { "ID": 299382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6950396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306764", "Detail": { "ID": 306764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5663987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300571", "Detail": { "ID": 300571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0043336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223972", "Detail": { "ID": 223972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4865025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305571", "Detail": { "ID": 305571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.330108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320111", "Detail": { "ID": 320111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.962158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315876", "Detail": { "ID": 315876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9310216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236765", "Detail": { "ID": 236765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.939096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289740", "Detail": { "ID": 289740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4571118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234296", "Detail": { "ID": 234296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3711619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313152", "Detail": { "ID": 313152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1659016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289365", "Detail": { "ID": 289365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4341062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225370", "Detail": { "ID": 225370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9717946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265736", "Detail": { "ID": 265736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4522509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283215", "Detail": { "ID": 283215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6908302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252036", "Detail": { "ID": 252036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4998186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317332", "Detail": { "ID": 317332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4175586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254246", "Detail": { "ID": 254246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2472485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296267", "Detail": { "ID": 296267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8412803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235479", "Detail": { "ID": 235479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6796097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257719", "Detail": { "ID": 257719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0746293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228565", "Detail": { "ID": 228565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8045832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291067", "Detail": { "ID": 291067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7840553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311159", "Detail": { "ID": 311159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.608258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246788", "Detail": { "ID": 246788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1534397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298033", "Detail": { "ID": 298033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1353933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234064", "Detail": { "ID": 234064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1650858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274689", "Detail": { "ID": 274689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1174582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269967", "Detail": { "ID": 269967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5757943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317672", "Detail": { "ID": 317672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4324553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326430", "Detail": { "ID": 326430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7583707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241271", "Detail": { "ID": 241271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.750747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290382", "Detail": { "ID": 290382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7445311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248045", "Detail": { "ID": 248045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4393985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287496", "Detail": { "ID": 287496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8734994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222614", "Detail": { "ID": 222614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1965101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239853", "Detail": { "ID": 239853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7617467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283771", "Detail": { "ID": 283771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7227699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231771", "Detail": { "ID": 231771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6147999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237359", "Detail": { "ID": 237359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2007938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308973", "Detail": { "ID": 308973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2146, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 39, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Human Rights", "Reference": "S4M-08544.1", "ID": 8668 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.086059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259139", "Detail": { "ID": 259139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3433939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319574", "Detail": { "ID": 319574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9318094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249493", "Detail": { "ID": 249493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9292503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320871", "Detail": { "ID": 320871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1852773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228351", "Detail": { "ID": 228351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7946432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281045", "Detail": { "ID": 281045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8036446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262798", "Detail": { "ID": 262798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6172899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288942", "Detail": { "ID": 288942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.164986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230517", "Detail": { "ID": 230517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3335981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269732", "Detail": { "ID": 269732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5605988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322555", "Detail": { "ID": 322555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6937506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295335", "Detail": { "ID": 295335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5077906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243029", "Detail": { "ID": 243029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0458715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235103", "Detail": { "ID": 235103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4195043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302465", "Detail": { "ID": 302465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5257527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244205", "Detail": { "ID": 244205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5444801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316337", "Detail": { "ID": 316337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.143472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327068", "Detail": { "ID": 327068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7974715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277137", "Detail": { "ID": 277137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7026949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264037", "Detail": { "ID": 264037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9214858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248663", "Detail": { "ID": 248663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6644862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294883", "Detail": { "ID": 294883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.182837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285302", "Detail": { "ID": 285302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3171596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230778", "Detail": { "ID": 230778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3451237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243689", "Detail": { "ID": 243689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3156465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254469", "Detail": { "ID": 254469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2574635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323521", "Detail": { "ID": 323521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.959967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290914", "Detail": { "ID": 290914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7775193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273000", "Detail": { "ID": 273000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3649031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262361", "Detail": { "ID": 262361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5981532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281847", "Detail": { "ID": 281847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1601585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298280", "Detail": { "ID": 298280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3389542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284985", "Detail": { "ID": 284985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0562755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219501", "Detail": { "ID": 219501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3020049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238287", "Detail": { "ID": 238287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.439889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225148", "Detail": { "ID": 225148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7465216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321905", "Detail": { "ID": 321905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4563887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292753", "Detail": { "ID": 292753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5566807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227226", "Detail": { "ID": 227226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5362907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313286", "Detail": { "ID": 313286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3887589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257789", "Detail": { "ID": 257789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0776853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271118", "Detail": { "ID": 271118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8432574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277985", "Detail": { "ID": 277985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.977261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287361", "Detail": { "ID": 287361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8609159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250606", "Detail": { "ID": 250606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1968121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221069", "Detail": { "ID": 221069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6737421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220143", "Detail": { "ID": 220143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.336191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252789", "Detail": { "ID": 252789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.753347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253754", "Detail": { "ID": 253754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0194963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324730", "Detail": { "ID": 324730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2354292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259610", "Detail": { "ID": 259610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6168671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239456", "Detail": { "ID": 239456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7375969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273663", "Detail": { "ID": 273663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6300571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302014", "Detail": { "ID": 302014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2933425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304021", "Detail": { "ID": 304021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8459949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221625", "Detail": { "ID": 221625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9408062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241856", "Detail": { "ID": 241856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7829752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223416", "Detail": { "ID": 223416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4569252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307863", "Detail": { "ID": 307863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8541728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272341", "Detail": { "ID": 272341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3311707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245040", "Detail": { "ID": 245040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5894354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315205", "Detail": { "ID": 315205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8984465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247505", "Detail": { "ID": 247505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4067039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275122", "Detail": { "ID": 275122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1425418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255509", "Detail": { "ID": 255509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5343852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276967", "Detail": { "ID": 276967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6890571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253456", "Detail": { "ID": 253456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9972096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276728", "Detail": { "ID": 276728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6785766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325401", "Detail": { "ID": 325401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4971007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233288", "Detail": { "ID": 233288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1175466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311707", "Detail": { "ID": 311707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8908123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229678", "Detail": { "ID": 229678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0919864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267490", "Detail": { "ID": 267490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0220742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313453", "Detail": { "ID": 313453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3960266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294948", "Detail": { "ID": 294948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1856381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319155", "Detail": { "ID": 319155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6948072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306280", "Detail": { "ID": 306280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5452659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310752", "Detail": { "ID": 310752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5845297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268114", "Detail": { "ID": 268114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0567547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292943", "Detail": { "ID": 292943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5649017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258530", "Detail": { "ID": 258530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.311211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263776", "Detail": { "ID": 263776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9042296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308736", "Detail": { "ID": 308736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.068772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279773", "Detail": { "ID": 279773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5222079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279536", "Detail": { "ID": 279536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5119245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260480", "Detail": { "ID": 260480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0787066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299383", "Detail": { "ID": 299383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6950804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306765", "Detail": { "ID": 306765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5664398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300570", "Detail": { "ID": 300570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0042934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223973", "Detail": { "ID": 223973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4865432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305587", "Detail": { "ID": 305587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3308068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320116", "Detail": { "ID": 320116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9623658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315877", "Detail": { "ID": 315877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9310628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236766", "Detail": { "ID": 236766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9391373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289739", "Detail": { "ID": 289739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4570721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234297", "Detail": { "ID": 234297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3712029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313136", "Detail": { "ID": 313136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1652022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289366", "Detail": { "ID": 289366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4341472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225371", "Detail": { "ID": 225371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9718358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265737", "Detail": { "ID": 265737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4523097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283214", "Detail": { "ID": 283214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6907872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252037", "Detail": { "ID": 252037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4998594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317337", "Detail": { "ID": 317337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4177629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254245", "Detail": { "ID": 254245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2472065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296268", "Detail": { "ID": 296268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8413218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235480", "Detail": { "ID": 235480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6796501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257718", "Detail": { "ID": 257718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0745871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228566", "Detail": { "ID": 228566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8046236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291068", "Detail": { "ID": 291068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7840959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311488", "Detail": { "ID": 311488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8810011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246789", "Detail": { "ID": 246789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1534805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298032", "Detail": { "ID": 298032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.135353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234063", "Detail": { "ID": 234063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1650445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274690", "Detail": { "ID": 274690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1175191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269966", "Detail": { "ID": 269966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5757533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317671", "Detail": { "ID": 317671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4324154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326429", "Detail": { "ID": 326429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7583291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241272", "Detail": { "ID": 241272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7507883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290399", "Detail": { "ID": 290399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7454356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248046", "Detail": { "ID": 248046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4394431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287497", "Detail": { "ID": 287497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8735409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222615", "Detail": { "ID": 222615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1965504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239852", "Detail": { "ID": 239852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7617048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283772", "Detail": { "ID": 283772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7228134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231770", "Detail": { "ID": 231770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6147599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237358", "Detail": { "ID": 237358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2007531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308974", "Detail": { "ID": 308974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2147, "AgendaID": 2707, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 97, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "End Year Fish Negotiations", "Reference": "S4M-08540.1", "ID": 8663 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.086101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259170", "Detail": { "ID": 259170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3447178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318701", "Detail": { "ID": 318701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6697202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250211", "Detail": { "ID": 250211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1794077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321096", "Detail": { "ID": 321096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2020892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228378", "Detail": { "ID": 228378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7963916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281075", "Detail": { "ID": 281075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8049248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262833", "Detail": { "ID": 262833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6249133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288969", "Detail": { "ID": 288969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1664071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230545", "Detail": { "ID": 230545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3350051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269701", "Detail": { "ID": 269701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5592825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322525", "Detail": { "ID": 322525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6924839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295371", "Detail": { "ID": 295371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5093201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243130", "Detail": { "ID": 243130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0502628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227088", "Detail": { "ID": 227088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2669799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303095", "Detail": { "ID": 303095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5583747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244170", "Detail": { "ID": 244170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3417893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316355", "Detail": { "ID": 316355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1442386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326965", "Detail": { "ID": 326965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.787755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277172", "Detail": { "ID": 277172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7041893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264002", "Detail": { "ID": 264002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9199892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248612", "Detail": { "ID": 248612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6623222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294166", "Detail": { "ID": 294166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8857815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285338", "Detail": { "ID": 285338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3187113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231276", "Detail": { "ID": 231276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5879862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243588", "Detail": { "ID": 243588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3114057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254432", "Detail": { "ID": 254432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2557166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323417", "Detail": { "ID": 323417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9552391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290863", "Detail": { "ID": 290863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.77537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273035", "Detail": { "ID": 273035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3667659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262567", "Detail": { "ID": 262567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6074606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281817", "Detail": { "ID": 281817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1588649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298310", "Detail": { "ID": 298310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3402437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284950", "Detail": { "ID": 284950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0546845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219552", "Detail": { "ID": 219552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3042881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238258", "Detail": { "ID": 238258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4386376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225113", "Detail": { "ID": 225113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7450519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321935", "Detail": { "ID": 321935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.457723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292239", "Detail": { "ID": 292239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5251862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227584", "Detail": { "ID": 227584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5564241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313323", "Detail": { "ID": 313323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3903683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257913", "Detail": { "ID": 257913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0830766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271082", "Detail": { "ID": 271082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8417172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277955", "Detail": { "ID": 277955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9759599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288323", "Detail": { "ID": 288323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.129868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250732", "Detail": { "ID": 250732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2112034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221103", "Detail": { "ID": 221103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6752019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220092", "Detail": { "ID": 220092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3339772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252826", "Detail": { "ID": 252826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7548992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253723", "Detail": { "ID": 253723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0182146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324834", "Detail": { "ID": 324834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2398227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259403", "Detail": { "ID": 259403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6075993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239485", "Detail": { "ID": 239485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7458019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273628", "Detail": { "ID": 273628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6285676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302613", "Detail": { "ID": 302613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5321454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303984", "Detail": { "ID": 303984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8443934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221591", "Detail": { "ID": 221591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9393523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245628", "Detail": { "ID": 245628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8516433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223375", "Detail": { "ID": 223375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4551632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307892", "Detail": { "ID": 307892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8554337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272467", "Detail": { "ID": 272467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3365844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245139", "Detail": { "ID": 245139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5937215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315309", "Detail": { "ID": 315309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9060529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247476", "Detail": { "ID": 247476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4054778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275158", "Detail": { "ID": 275158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1440902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255478", "Detail": { "ID": 255478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5330575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276931", "Detail": { "ID": 276931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6872584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253486", "Detail": { "ID": 253486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9985075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276366", "Detail": { "ID": 276366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6625289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325297", "Detail": { "ID": 325297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4926133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233314", "Detail": { "ID": 233314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.118874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311736", "Detail": { "ID": 311736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8920428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229627", "Detail": { "ID": 229627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0898508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267520", "Detail": { "ID": 267520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0233759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313424", "Detail": { "ID": 313424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3947685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294453", "Detail": { "ID": 294453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1389746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319184", "Detail": { "ID": 319184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6960335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306176", "Detail": { "ID": 306176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3622507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309875", "Detail": { "ID": 309875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3547073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268084", "Detail": { "ID": 268084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0553242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292973", "Detail": { "ID": 292973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5661596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271483", "Detail": { "ID": 271483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0777613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263571", "Detail": { "ID": 263571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8951266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307403", "Detail": { "ID": 307403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8279525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280134", "Detail": { "ID": 280134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5428887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279500", "Detail": { "ID": 279500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5103889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260381", "Detail": { "ID": 260381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0744234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299354", "Detail": { "ID": 299354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6938409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302222", "Detail": { "ID": 302222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5150268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300213", "Detail": { "ID": 300213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9882559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224007", "Detail": { "ID": 224007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4880132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305691", "Detail": { "ID": 305691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3352518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320086", "Detail": { "ID": 320086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9610662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315773", "Detail": { "ID": 315773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9263875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237112", "Detail": { "ID": 237112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9663542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289703", "Detail": { "ID": 289703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4555474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234260", "Detail": { "ID": 234260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3695718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312876", "Detail": { "ID": 312876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1536236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261418", "Detail": { "ID": 261418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.356477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225566", "Detail": { "ID": 225566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9805407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265700", "Detail": { "ID": 265700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4504957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283007", "Detail": { "ID": 283007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4437628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252088", "Detail": { "ID": 252088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5020553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317308", "Detail": { "ID": 317308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4165244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256173", "Detail": { "ID": 256173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5737427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293946", "Detail": { "ID": 293946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8759792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235532", "Detail": { "ID": 235532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6818711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258065", "Detail": { "ID": 258065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0900264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229307", "Detail": { "ID": 229307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0710511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291033", "Detail": { "ID": 291033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7826015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311591", "Detail": { "ID": 311591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8854882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246914", "Detail": { "ID": 246914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1590168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297687", "Detail": { "ID": 297687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1204111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234028", "Detail": { "ID": 234028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1570283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274895", "Detail": { "ID": 274895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1266429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269996", "Detail": { "ID": 269996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5770563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317775", "Detail": { "ID": 317775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4368211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326533", "Detail": { "ID": 326533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7687745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241398", "Detail": { "ID": 241398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7562407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291114", "Detail": { "ID": 291114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7862974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248097", "Detail": { "ID": 248097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4418525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288165", "Detail": { "ID": 288165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9097241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222656", "Detail": { "ID": 222656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1983023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240877", "Detail": { "ID": 240877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3861247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283808", "Detail": { "ID": 283808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7243571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231743", "Detail": { "ID": 231743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6136313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237307", "Detail": { "ID": 237307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1985553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308945", "Detail": { "ID": 308945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2152, "AgendaID": 2404, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-08515", "ID": 8629 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0848501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259173", "Detail": { "ID": 259173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3448385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319560", "Detail": { "ID": 319560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.931212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249464", "Detail": { "ID": 249464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.927774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320885", "Detail": { "ID": 320885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1858664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228360", "Detail": { "ID": 228360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7950506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281060", "Detail": { "ID": 281060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.804298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262830", "Detail": { "ID": 262830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6247882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288966", "Detail": { "ID": 288966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1662845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230542", "Detail": { "ID": 230542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3348798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269698", "Detail": { "ID": 269698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5591586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322539", "Detail": { "ID": 322539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6930827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295368", "Detail": { "ID": 295368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5091958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243042", "Detail": { "ID": 243042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0464438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227091", "Detail": { "ID": 227091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2671024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303098", "Detail": { "ID": 303098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5585157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244173", "Detail": { "ID": 244173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3419115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316346", "Detail": { "ID": 316346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1438411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327054", "Detail": { "ID": 327054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7916045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277169", "Detail": { "ID": 277169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7040471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264005", "Detail": { "ID": 264005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9201298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248615", "Detail": { "ID": 248615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6624478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294870", "Detail": { "ID": 294870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1822732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285335", "Detail": { "ID": 285335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3185863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231273", "Detail": { "ID": 231273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5878431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243676", "Detail": { "ID": 243676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.315102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254429", "Detail": { "ID": 254429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2555903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323507", "Detail": { "ID": 323507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9593671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290866", "Detail": { "ID": 290866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7754896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273032", "Detail": { "ID": 273032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3666211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262564", "Detail": { "ID": 262564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6073383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281832", "Detail": { "ID": 281832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1595241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298295", "Detail": { "ID": 298295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3396058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284953", "Detail": { "ID": 284953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0548069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219549", "Detail": { "ID": 219549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3041639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238255", "Detail": { "ID": 238255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4385131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225117", "Detail": { "ID": 225117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.745214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321921", "Detail": { "ID": 321921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4570684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292764", "Detail": { "ID": 292764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5571544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227581", "Detail": { "ID": 227581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5563006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313326", "Detail": { "ID": 313326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3904905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257818", "Detail": { "ID": 257818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0789106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271085", "Detail": { "ID": 271085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8418567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277970", "Detail": { "ID": 277970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.976619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288326", "Detail": { "ID": 288326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1300121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250635", "Detail": { "ID": 250635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2070076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221099", "Detail": { "ID": 221099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6750372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220095", "Detail": { "ID": 220095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.33412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252829", "Detail": { "ID": 252829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7550375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253738", "Detail": { "ID": 253738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.018835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324744", "Detail": { "ID": 324744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2360115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259406", "Detail": { "ID": 259406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6077425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239488", "Detail": { "ID": 239488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7459269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273631", "Detail": { "ID": 273631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6286921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302616", "Detail": { "ID": 302616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5323482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303981", "Detail": { "ID": 303981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8442526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221595", "Detail": { "ID": 221595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9395151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241827", "Detail": { "ID": 241827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7817506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223378", "Detail": { "ID": 223378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4553049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307877", "Detail": { "ID": 307877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8547707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272370", "Detail": { "ID": 272370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3324178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245053", "Detail": { "ID": 245053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5899888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315219", "Detail": { "ID": 315219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8990664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247473", "Detail": { "ID": 247473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4053041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275155", "Detail": { "ID": 275155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1439662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255475", "Detail": { "ID": 255475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5329341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276934", "Detail": { "ID": 276934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6873803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253489", "Detail": { "ID": 253489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9986318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276369", "Detail": { "ID": 276369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6626516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325387", "Detail": { "ID": 325387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4964998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233317", "Detail": { "ID": 233317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1189969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311721", "Detail": { "ID": 311721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8914078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229630", "Detail": { "ID": 229630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0899716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267505", "Detail": { "ID": 267505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0227385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313439", "Detail": { "ID": 313439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3954089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294468", "Detail": { "ID": 294468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1396096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319170", "Detail": { "ID": 319170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6954415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306267", "Detail": { "ID": 306267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5447147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM308822", "Detail": { "ID": 308822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0727823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268099", "Detail": { "ID": 268099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0561114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292958", "Detail": { "ID": 292958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5655289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258501", "Detail": { "ID": 258501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3099706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263574", "Detail": { "ID": 263574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8952683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308721", "Detail": { "ID": 308721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0680859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280131", "Detail": { "ID": 280131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5427652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279503", "Detail": { "ID": 279503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5105105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260468", "Detail": { "ID": 260468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0781818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299369", "Detail": { "ID": 299369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6944725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306753", "Detail": { "ID": 306753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5659259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300582", "Detail": { "ID": 300582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0048029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224003", "Detail": { "ID": 224003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4878302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305600", "Detail": { "ID": 305600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.33136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320100", "Detail": { "ID": 320100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9616839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315863", "Detail": { "ID": 315863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.930314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237109", "Detail": { "ID": 237109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.966234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289706", "Detail": { "ID": 289706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4556872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234257", "Detail": { "ID": 234257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3694472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313123", "Detail": { "ID": 313123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1646408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289355", "Detail": { "ID": 289355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4336774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225563", "Detail": { "ID": 225563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9804105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265697", "Detail": { "ID": 265697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4503729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283010", "Detail": { "ID": 283010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.443906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252085", "Detail": { "ID": 252085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5019062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317322", "Detail": { "ID": 317322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4171262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254216", "Detail": { "ID": 254216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2459447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296257", "Detail": { "ID": 296257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8408411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235529", "Detail": { "ID": 235529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6817484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258068", "Detail": { "ID": 258068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0901839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228596", "Detail": { "ID": 228596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8059215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291030", "Detail": { "ID": 291030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7824575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311501", "Detail": { "ID": 311501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8815626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246818", "Detail": { "ID": 246818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1547056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297690", "Detail": { "ID": 297690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1205293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234031", "Detail": { "ID": 234031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1571513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274892", "Detail": { "ID": 274892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1265164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269981", "Detail": { "ID": 269981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5763986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317685", "Detail": { "ID": 317685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4330182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326443", "Detail": { "ID": 326443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7649294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241301", "Detail": { "ID": 241301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7520422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290412", "Detail": { "ID": 290412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7459927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248094", "Detail": { "ID": 248094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4417286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288162", "Detail": { "ID": 288162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9095974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222653", "Detail": { "ID": 222653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1981794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239670", "Detail": { "ID": 239670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7538979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283805", "Detail": { "ID": 283805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7242317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231761", "Detail": { "ID": 231761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6143765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237310", "Detail": { "ID": 237310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1986763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308960", "Detail": { "ID": 308960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2144, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470.2", "ID": 8615 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0854878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259172", "Detail": { "ID": 259172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3447979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319559", "Detail": { "ID": 319559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.931171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249463", "Detail": { "ID": 249463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9277317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320886", "Detail": { "ID": 320886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.185907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228361", "Detail": { "ID": 228361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7950915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281059", "Detail": { "ID": 281059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8042577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262831", "Detail": { "ID": 262831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6248294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288967", "Detail": { "ID": 288967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1663251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230543", "Detail": { "ID": 230543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3349215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269699", "Detail": { "ID": 269699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5592002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322540", "Detail": { "ID": 322540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6931229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295369", "Detail": { "ID": 295369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5092376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243043", "Detail": { "ID": 243043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0464855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227090", "Detail": { "ID": 227090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2670623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303097", "Detail": { "ID": 303097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5584748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244172", "Detail": { "ID": 244172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3418712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316345", "Detail": { "ID": 316345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1438006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326967", "Detail": { "ID": 326967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7878374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277170", "Detail": { "ID": 277170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7041061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264004", "Detail": { "ID": 264004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9200717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248614", "Detail": { "ID": 248614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6624067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294869", "Detail": { "ID": 294869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.18223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285336", "Detail": { "ID": 285336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3186274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231274", "Detail": { "ID": 231274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5879032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243675", "Detail": { "ID": 243675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.315043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254430", "Detail": { "ID": 254430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.255632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323419", "Detail": { "ID": 323419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9553226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290865", "Detail": { "ID": 290865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7754497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273033", "Detail": { "ID": 273033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3666819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262565", "Detail": { "ID": 262565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6073788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281833", "Detail": { "ID": 281833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1595648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298294", "Detail": { "ID": 298294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3395467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284952", "Detail": { "ID": 284952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0547664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219550", "Detail": { "ID": 219550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3042052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238256", "Detail": { "ID": 238256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4385545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225116", "Detail": { "ID": 225116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7451742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321920", "Detail": { "ID": 321920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4570283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292241", "Detail": { "ID": 292241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5252698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227582", "Detail": { "ID": 227582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5563412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313325", "Detail": { "ID": 313325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3904499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257819", "Detail": { "ID": 257819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0789513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271084", "Detail": { "ID": 271084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8417975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277971", "Detail": { "ID": 277971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9766617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288325", "Detail": { "ID": 288325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1299693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250636", "Detail": { "ID": 250636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2070483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221100", "Detail": { "ID": 221100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6750779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220094", "Detail": { "ID": 220094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3340779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252828", "Detail": { "ID": 252828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7549794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253739", "Detail": { "ID": 253739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0188749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324832", "Detail": { "ID": 324832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2397416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259405", "Detail": { "ID": 259405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6077019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239487", "Detail": { "ID": 239487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7458875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273630", "Detail": { "ID": 273630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6286519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302615", "Detail": { "ID": 302615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5322274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303982", "Detail": { "ID": 303982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8442931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221594", "Detail": { "ID": 221594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.939475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241826", "Detail": { "ID": 241826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.78171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223377", "Detail": { "ID": 223377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4552631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307876", "Detail": { "ID": 307876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.85473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272371", "Detail": { "ID": 272371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3324586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245054", "Detail": { "ID": 245054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5900303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315220", "Detail": { "ID": 315220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8991072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247474", "Detail": { "ID": 247474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4053881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275156", "Detail": { "ID": 275156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1440076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255476", "Detail": { "ID": 255476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.532975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276933", "Detail": { "ID": 276933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6873402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253488", "Detail": { "ID": 253488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9985908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276368", "Detail": { "ID": 276368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6626117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325299", "Detail": { "ID": 325299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4927161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233316", "Detail": { "ID": 233316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1189558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311720", "Detail": { "ID": 311720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8913671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229629", "Detail": { "ID": 229629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0899316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267504", "Detail": { "ID": 267504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0226983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313440", "Detail": { "ID": 313440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3954685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294469", "Detail": { "ID": 294469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1396503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319169", "Detail": { "ID": 319169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6954009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306266", "Detail": { "ID": 306266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5446738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309873", "Detail": { "ID": 309873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3546252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268100", "Detail": { "ID": 268100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0561527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292957", "Detail": { "ID": 292957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5654892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258500", "Detail": { "ID": 258500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3099298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263573", "Detail": { "ID": 263573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8952278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307405", "Detail": { "ID": 307405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8280351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280132", "Detail": { "ID": 280132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5428065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279502", "Detail": { "ID": 279502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5104706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260467", "Detail": { "ID": 260467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0781411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299370", "Detail": { "ID": 299370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6945319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302220", "Detail": { "ID": 302220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5149412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300215", "Detail": { "ID": 300215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.988339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224004", "Detail": { "ID": 224004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.48787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305601", "Detail": { "ID": 305601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3314004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320101", "Detail": { "ID": 320101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9617261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315862", "Detail": { "ID": 315862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9302732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237110", "Detail": { "ID": 237110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9662734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289705", "Detail": { "ID": 289705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4556279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234258", "Detail": { "ID": 234258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3694882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313122", "Detail": { "ID": 313122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1645998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261416", "Detail": { "ID": 261416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3563956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225564", "Detail": { "ID": 225564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9804571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265698", "Detail": { "ID": 265698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4504137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283009", "Detail": { "ID": 283009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4438649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252086", "Detail": { "ID": 252086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5019467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317323", "Detail": { "ID": 317323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4171663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254215", "Detail": { "ID": 254215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2458782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293944", "Detail": { "ID": 293944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8758763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235530", "Detail": { "ID": 235530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6817889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258067", "Detail": { "ID": 258067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0901348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228597", "Detail": { "ID": 228597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.805962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291031", "Detail": { "ID": 291031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7825176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311502", "Detail": { "ID": 311502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8816037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246819", "Detail": { "ID": 246819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.154746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297689", "Detail": { "ID": 297689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1204903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234030", "Detail": { "ID": 234030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1571109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274893", "Detail": { "ID": 274893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1265582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269980", "Detail": { "ID": 269980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5763576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317686", "Detail": { "ID": 317686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4330586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326531", "Detail": { "ID": 326531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7686925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241302", "Detail": { "ID": 241302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7520844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290413", "Detail": { "ID": 290413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7460331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248095", "Detail": { "ID": 248095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4417694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288163", "Detail": { "ID": 288163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9096405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222654", "Detail": { "ID": 222654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1982197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239669", "Detail": { "ID": 239669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7538578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283806", "Detail": { "ID": 283806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.724274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231760", "Detail": { "ID": 231760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6143363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237309", "Detail": { "ID": 237309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1986362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308961", "Detail": { "ID": 308961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2145, "AgendaID": 2896, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Housing", "Reference": "S4M-08470", "ID": 8591 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-04T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0855286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269191", "Detail": { "ID": 269191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3076214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318619", "Detail": { "ID": 318619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6659632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249847", "Detail": { "ID": 249847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9525889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320235", "Detail": { "ID": 320235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1508652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230329", "Detail": { "ID": 230329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3181158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281397", "Detail": { "ID": 281397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1330611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263697", "Detail": { "ID": 263697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9008443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289040", "Detail": { "ID": 289040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1694777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228763", "Detail": { "ID": 228763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8131203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270435", "Detail": { "ID": 270435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8076498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323530", "Detail": { "ID": 323530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.960368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296491", "Detail": { "ID": 296491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8513524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229022", "Detail": { "ID": 229022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8305225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236078", "Detail": { "ID": 236078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7102945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300390", "Detail": { "ID": 300390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9961353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260592", "Detail": { "ID": 260592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0835316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316421", "Detail": { "ID": 316421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.147143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326894", "Detail": { "ID": 326894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7846286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278713", "Detail": { "ID": 278713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2310935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264688", "Detail": { "ID": 264688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1446067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249002", "Detail": { "ID": 249002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6792984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294095", "Detail": { "ID": 294095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8824125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287809", "Detail": { "ID": 287809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8872737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233707", "Detail": { "ID": 233707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1426777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243507", "Detail": { "ID": 243507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3007074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252892", "Detail": { "ID": 252892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7577505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323180", "Detail": { "ID": 323180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.725811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301486", "Detail": { "ID": 301486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2642889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273471", "Detail": { "ID": 273471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6216746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263492", "Detail": { "ID": 263492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8917375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285742", "Detail": { "ID": 285742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3426121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298574", "Detail": { "ID": 298574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3519939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286497", "Detail": { "ID": 286497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5884031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220015", "Detail": { "ID": 220015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3306578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238836", "Detail": { "ID": 238836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4710901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225812", "Detail": { "ID": 225812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9914811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322048", "Detail": { "ID": 322048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.469075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290262", "Detail": { "ID": 290262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7392666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228940", "Detail": { "ID": 228940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8208244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304776", "Detail": { "ID": 304776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0579785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258434", "Detail": { "ID": 258434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.307077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272088", "Detail": { "ID": 272088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1110762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279861", "Detail": { "ID": 279861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5259753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267106", "Detail": { "ID": 267106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7757533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253693", "Detail": { "ID": 253693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.016781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221537", "Detail": { "ID": 221537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9370222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220485", "Detail": { "ID": 220485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.643377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240417", "Detail": { "ID": 240417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3589326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266369", "Detail": { "ID": 266369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7379024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324069", "Detail": { "ID": 324069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9908237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260104", "Detail": { "ID": 260104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6439208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246978", "Detail": { "ID": 246978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1618397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275247", "Detail": { "ID": 275247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3618408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302674", "Detail": { "ID": 302674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5351282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303890", "Detail": { "ID": 303890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8403553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221981", "Detail": { "ID": 221981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9619995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242205", "Detail": { "ID": 242205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0028484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224093", "Detail": { "ID": 224093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4917135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308157", "Detail": { "ID": 308157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8671843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272813", "Detail": { "ID": 272813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.35169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244062", "Detail": { "ID": 244062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3318009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM313968", "Detail": { "ID": 313968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4240498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251298", "Detail": { "ID": 251298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4574371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276472", "Detail": { "ID": 276472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6671275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256513", "Detail": { "ID": 256513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7859246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282486", "Detail": { "ID": 282486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4209517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254976", "Detail": { "ID": 254976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2918783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277686", "Detail": { "ID": 277686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9641298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325216", "Detail": { "ID": 325216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4887301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232367", "Detail": { "ID": 232367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8517756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312151", "Detail": { "ID": 312151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9159044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230945", "Detail": { "ID": 230945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3523043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267924", "Detail": { "ID": 267924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.048369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314874", "Detail": { "ID": 314874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6592513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297161", "Detail": { "ID": 297161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8903304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319297", "Detail": { "ID": 319297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9139884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306106", "Detail": { "ID": 306106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3592175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309027", "Detail": { "ID": 309027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0887145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268502", "Detail": { "ID": 268502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2699277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293127", "Detail": { "ID": 293127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5727624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261512", "Detail": { "ID": 261512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3607298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264425", "Detail": { "ID": 264425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1329309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307778", "Detail": { "ID": 307778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8445046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282899", "Detail": { "ID": 282899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4391033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280498", "Detail": { "ID": 280498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7698401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245497", "Detail": { "ID": 245497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8377521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM305150", "Detail": { "ID": 305150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0742914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303261", "Detail": { "ID": 303261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8072278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297013", "Detail": { "ID": 297013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8839629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224904", "Detail": { "ID": 224904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7255161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296470", "Detail": { "ID": 296470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8504485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321560", "Detail": { "ID": 321560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4413303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315692", "Detail": { "ID": 315692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9229159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238308", "Detail": { "ID": 238308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4407955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294180", "Detail": { "ID": 294180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8863894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233369", "Detail": { "ID": 233369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1212396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312796", "Detail": { "ID": 312796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1437327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287640", "Detail": { "ID": 287640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8799787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226628", "Detail": { "ID": 226628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2397261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258126", "Detail": { "ID": 258126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0932641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284537", "Detail": { "ID": 284537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0368666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259328", "Detail": { "ID": 259328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6041931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318804", "Detail": { "ID": 318804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6741087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255215", "Detail": { "ID": 255215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5212115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295161", "Detail": { "ID": 295161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1952041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236922", "Detail": { "ID": 236922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9461078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256903", "Detail": { "ID": 256903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8148521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239613", "Detail": { "ID": 239613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7512545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290938", "Detail": { "ID": 290938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7785262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309579", "Detail": { "ID": 309579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.335713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM249408", "Detail": { "ID": 249408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9253193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299232", "Detail": { "ID": 299232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6885894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234721", "Detail": { "ID": 234721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3968698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276287", "Detail": { "ID": 276287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6530204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273977", "Detail": { "ID": 273977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6489034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316243", "Detail": { "ID": 316243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1360616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325767", "Detail": { "ID": 325767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5206126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241761", "Detail": { "ID": 241761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7789289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM286955", "Detail": { "ID": 286955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6079762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248537", "Detail": { "ID": 248537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6505886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288245", "Detail": { "ID": 288245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1262695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223075", "Detail": { "ID": 223075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2275921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240514", "Detail": { "ID": 240514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3700973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284651", "Detail": { "ID": 284651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0417391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232771", "Detail": { "ID": 232771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8755307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245838", "Detail": { "ID": 245838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8605957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310899", "Detail": { "ID": 310899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2142, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462.1", "ID": 8589 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.596615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269190", "Detail": { "ID": 269190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3075804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318618", "Detail": { "ID": 318618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.665923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249846", "Detail": { "ID": 249846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9525494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320236", "Detail": { "ID": 320236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1509062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230987", "Detail": { "ID": 230987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3541115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281348", "Detail": { "ID": 281348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1309546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263698", "Detail": { "ID": 263698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9008853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289041", "Detail": { "ID": 289041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1695203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228764", "Detail": { "ID": 228764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8131613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270436", "Detail": { "ID": 270436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8076907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323371", "Detail": { "ID": 323371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9468732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296492", "Detail": { "ID": 296492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8513928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229023", "Detail": { "ID": 229023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8305633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236077", "Detail": { "ID": 236077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.710254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300389", "Detail": { "ID": 300389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9960948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260591", "Detail": { "ID": 260591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0834915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316428", "Detail": { "ID": 316428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.147453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326893", "Detail": { "ID": 326893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7845884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278714", "Detail": { "ID": 278714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2311517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264687", "Detail": { "ID": 264687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1445656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249001", "Detail": { "ID": 249001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6792579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294094", "Detail": { "ID": 294094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8823534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287810", "Detail": { "ID": 287810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8873159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233708", "Detail": { "ID": 233708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1427188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243506", "Detail": { "ID": 243506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3006673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252893", "Detail": { "ID": 252893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7577919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323179", "Detail": { "ID": 323179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7257708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301485", "Detail": { "ID": 301485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2642472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273472", "Detail": { "ID": 273472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6217153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263493", "Detail": { "ID": 263493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8917781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285791", "Detail": { "ID": 285791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3447109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298580", "Detail": { "ID": 298580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3522589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286496", "Detail": { "ID": 286496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5883622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220016", "Detail": { "ID": 220016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3306992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238837", "Detail": { "ID": 238837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4711302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225811", "Detail": { "ID": 225811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9914408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322055", "Detail": { "ID": 322055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4693846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290261", "Detail": { "ID": 290261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7392263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228941", "Detail": { "ID": 228941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8208652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304775", "Detail": { "ID": 304775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0579378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258435", "Detail": { "ID": 258435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3071177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272087", "Detail": { "ID": 272087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1110355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279910", "Detail": { "ID": 279910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5280972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267105", "Detail": { "ID": 267105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7757117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253694", "Detail": { "ID": 253694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0168212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221538", "Detail": { "ID": 221538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9370631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220484", "Detail": { "ID": 220484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6433363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240416", "Detail": { "ID": 240416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.358892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266328", "Detail": { "ID": 266328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.736132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324070", "Detail": { "ID": 324070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9908644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260103", "Detail": { "ID": 260103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6438797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246977", "Detail": { "ID": 246977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1617811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275246", "Detail": { "ID": 275246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3617994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302673", "Detail": { "ID": 302673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5350881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303891", "Detail": { "ID": 303891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8403955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221980", "Detail": { "ID": 221980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9619593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242204", "Detail": { "ID": 242204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0028063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224092", "Detail": { "ID": 224092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4916724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308163", "Detail": { "ID": 308163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8674521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272814", "Detail": { "ID": 272814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3517302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244063", "Detail": { "ID": 244063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3318411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM313969", "Detail": { "ID": 313969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4240946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251299", "Detail": { "ID": 251299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4574993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276473", "Detail": { "ID": 276473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6671683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256514", "Detail": { "ID": 256514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7859655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282485", "Detail": { "ID": 282485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4209114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254975", "Detail": { "ID": 254975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2918376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277685", "Detail": { "ID": 277685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9640899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325215", "Detail": { "ID": 325215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4886868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232366", "Detail": { "ID": 232366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8517348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312157", "Detail": { "ID": 312157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9161688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230944", "Detail": { "ID": 230944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3522638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267959", "Detail": { "ID": 267959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0498723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314866", "Detail": { "ID": 314866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6588969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297155", "Detail": { "ID": 297155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8900646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319306", "Detail": { "ID": 319306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9143903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306105", "Detail": { "ID": 306105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3591765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309028", "Detail": { "ID": 309028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0888927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268459", "Detail": { "ID": 268459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.268052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293084", "Detail": { "ID": 293084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5709266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261511", "Detail": { "ID": 261511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3606886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264424", "Detail": { "ID": 264424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.132873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307777", "Detail": { "ID": 307777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8444639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282900", "Detail": { "ID": 282900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4391436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280497", "Detail": { "ID": 280497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7698004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245496", "Detail": { "ID": 245496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8375947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM305144", "Detail": { "ID": 305144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.074028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303262", "Detail": { "ID": 303262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8072692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297012", "Detail": { "ID": 297012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8839223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224905", "Detail": { "ID": 224905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7255568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296471", "Detail": { "ID": 296471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.85049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321553", "Detail": { "ID": 321553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4410256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315691", "Detail": { "ID": 315691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9228752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238309", "Detail": { "ID": 238309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4408375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294179", "Detail": { "ID": 294179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8863485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233370", "Detail": { "ID": 233370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1212798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312795", "Detail": { "ID": 312795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1436913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287641", "Detail": { "ID": 287641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8800182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226629", "Detail": { "ID": 226629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2397666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258127", "Detail": { "ID": 258127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0933134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284536", "Detail": { "ID": 284536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0368082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259329", "Detail": { "ID": 259329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6042469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318795", "Detail": { "ID": 318795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6737218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255214", "Detail": { "ID": 255214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5211705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295162", "Detail": { "ID": 295162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.19526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236923", "Detail": { "ID": 236923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9461681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256902", "Detail": { "ID": 256902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8148119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239614", "Detail": { "ID": 239614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7512946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290939", "Detail": { "ID": 290939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7785663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309580", "Detail": { "ID": 309580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3357536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM249409", "Detail": { "ID": 249409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9253609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299231", "Detail": { "ID": 299231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6885478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234720", "Detail": { "ID": 234720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3968285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276288", "Detail": { "ID": 276288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6530807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273928", "Detail": { "ID": 273928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6417519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316244", "Detail": { "ID": 316244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.136103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325768", "Detail": { "ID": 325768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5206527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241762", "Detail": { "ID": 241762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7789875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM286956", "Detail": { "ID": 286956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6080166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248538", "Detail": { "ID": 248538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6506297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288246", "Detail": { "ID": 288246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1263112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223076", "Detail": { "ID": 223076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2276316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240513", "Detail": { "ID": 240513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.370056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284652", "Detail": { "ID": 284652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.041779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232729", "Detail": { "ID": 232729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8737194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245837", "Detail": { "ID": 245837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8605364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310893", "Detail": { "ID": 310893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2143, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Women and Work", "Reference": "S4M-08462", "ID": 8581 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5962978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269189", "Detail": { "ID": 269189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3075387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318617", "Detail": { "ID": 318617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6658829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249845", "Detail": { "ID": 249845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9525099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320237", "Detail": { "ID": 320237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.150948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230988", "Detail": { "ID": 230988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3541519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281347", "Detail": { "ID": 281347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1309141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263699", "Detail": { "ID": 263699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9009258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289042", "Detail": { "ID": 289042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1695617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228765", "Detail": { "ID": 228765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8132025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270437", "Detail": { "ID": 270437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8077315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323372", "Detail": { "ID": 323372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9469145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295966", "Detail": { "ID": 295966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5434299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229024", "Detail": { "ID": 229024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8306051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236076", "Detail": { "ID": 236076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7102124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300388", "Detail": { "ID": 300388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9960538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260590", "Detail": { "ID": 260590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.083451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316427", "Detail": { "ID": 316427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1474122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326892", "Detail": { "ID": 326892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7845479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278715", "Detail": { "ID": 278715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2311932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264686", "Detail": { "ID": 264686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1445254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249000", "Detail": { "ID": 249000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6792173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294093", "Detail": { "ID": 294093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8823121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287811", "Detail": { "ID": 287811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8873574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233709", "Detail": { "ID": 233709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1427619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243505", "Detail": { "ID": 243505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3006268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252894", "Detail": { "ID": 252894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7578325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323178", "Detail": { "ID": 323178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7257299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301484", "Detail": { "ID": 301484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2642058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273473", "Detail": { "ID": 273473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6217567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263494", "Detail": { "ID": 263494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8918194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285792", "Detail": { "ID": 285792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3447555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298579", "Detail": { "ID": 298579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3521999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286495", "Detail": { "ID": 286495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5883218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220017", "Detail": { "ID": 220017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3307406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238838", "Detail": { "ID": 238838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4711704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225810", "Detail": { "ID": 225810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9914005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322054", "Detail": { "ID": 322054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4693418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290260", "Detail": { "ID": 290260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7391853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228942", "Detail": { "ID": 228942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8209066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304774", "Detail": { "ID": 304774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0578969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258436", "Detail": { "ID": 258436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.307159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272086", "Detail": { "ID": 272086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1109936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279911", "Detail": { "ID": 279911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5281406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267104", "Detail": { "ID": 267104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7756703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253695", "Detail": { "ID": 253695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0168626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221539", "Detail": { "ID": 221539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9371048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220483", "Detail": { "ID": 220483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6432954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240415", "Detail": { "ID": 240415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3588514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266329", "Detail": { "ID": 266329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.736173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324071", "Detail": { "ID": 324071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9909239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260102", "Detail": { "ID": 260102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6438386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246976", "Detail": { "ID": 246976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1617403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275245", "Detail": { "ID": 275245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3617583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302672", "Detail": { "ID": 302672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.535046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303892", "Detail": { "ID": 303892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8404369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221979", "Detail": { "ID": 221979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9619179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242203", "Detail": { "ID": 242203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0027643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224091", "Detail": { "ID": 224091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4916317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308162", "Detail": { "ID": 308162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8674106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272815", "Detail": { "ID": 272815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3517707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244064", "Detail": { "ID": 244064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3318821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM313970", "Detail": { "ID": 313970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4241353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251300", "Detail": { "ID": 251300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4575422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276474", "Detail": { "ID": 276474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6672098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256515", "Detail": { "ID": 256515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7860068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282484", "Detail": { "ID": 282484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.420871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254974", "Detail": { "ID": 254974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2917969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277684", "Detail": { "ID": 277684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9640502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325214", "Detail": { "ID": 325214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4886442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232365", "Detail": { "ID": 232365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8516931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312156", "Detail": { "ID": 312156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9161283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230943", "Detail": { "ID": 230943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3522236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267958", "Detail": { "ID": 267958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0498312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314867", "Detail": { "ID": 314867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6589388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297156", "Detail": { "ID": 297156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8901054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319305", "Detail": { "ID": 319305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9143272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306104", "Detail": { "ID": 306104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3591363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM308854", "Detail": { "ID": 308854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0809088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268460", "Detail": { "ID": 268460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2681195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293083", "Detail": { "ID": 293083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5708862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261510", "Detail": { "ID": 261510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3606466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264423", "Detail": { "ID": 264423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1328328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307944", "Detail": { "ID": 307944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8576793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282901", "Detail": { "ID": 282901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4392016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280496", "Detail": { "ID": 280496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7697604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245495", "Detail": { "ID": 245495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8375488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM305145", "Detail": { "ID": 305145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0740684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303263", "Detail": { "ID": 303263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8073107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297011", "Detail": { "ID": 297011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8838814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224906", "Detail": { "ID": 224906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7255986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296472", "Detail": { "ID": 296472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8505308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321554", "Detail": { "ID": 321554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4410662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315690", "Detail": { "ID": 315690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9228336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238310", "Detail": { "ID": 238310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4408786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294238", "Detail": { "ID": 294238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1297371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233371", "Detail": { "ID": 233371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1213403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312794", "Detail": { "ID": 312794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1436503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287642", "Detail": { "ID": 287642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8800585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226630", "Detail": { "ID": 226630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2398077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258128", "Detail": { "ID": 258128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0933824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284535", "Detail": { "ID": 284535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.036768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259330", "Detail": { "ID": 259330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6042903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318796", "Detail": { "ID": 318796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6737806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255213", "Detail": { "ID": 255213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5211287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295163", "Detail": { "ID": 295163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1953111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236924", "Detail": { "ID": 236924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.94621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256901", "Detail": { "ID": 256901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8147709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239615", "Detail": { "ID": 239615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7513349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290940", "Detail": { "ID": 290940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.778607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309581", "Detail": { "ID": 309581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3357943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM249410", "Detail": { "ID": 249410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.925402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299443", "Detail": { "ID": 299443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6976399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234719", "Detail": { "ID": 234719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3967877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276289", "Detail": { "ID": 276289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.653124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273927", "Detail": { "ID": 273927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6417104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316245", "Detail": { "ID": 316245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1361439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325769", "Detail": { "ID": 325769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5206941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241763", "Detail": { "ID": 241763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7790291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM286957", "Detail": { "ID": 286957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6080569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248539", "Detail": { "ID": 248539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6506711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288247", "Detail": { "ID": 288247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1263521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223077", "Detail": { "ID": 223077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2276916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240512", "Detail": { "ID": 240512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3700145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284653", "Detail": { "ID": 284653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.041819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232728", "Detail": { "ID": 232728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8736791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245836", "Detail": { "ID": 245836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8604892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310894", "Detail": { "ID": 310894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2140, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 59, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461.1", "ID": 8584 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5963387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269188", "Detail": { "ID": 269188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3074789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318616", "Detail": { "ID": 318616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6658425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249844", "Detail": { "ID": 249844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9524696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320238", "Detail": { "ID": 320238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1509896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230989", "Detail": { "ID": 230989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3541929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281360", "Detail": { "ID": 281360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1314916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263700", "Detail": { "ID": 263700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9009661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289043", "Detail": { "ID": 289043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1696041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228766", "Detail": { "ID": 228766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8132627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270438", "Detail": { "ID": 270438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.807774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323361", "Detail": { "ID": 323361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9464436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295967", "Detail": { "ID": 295967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5434696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229025", "Detail": { "ID": 229025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8306464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236075", "Detail": { "ID": 236075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7101518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300387", "Detail": { "ID": 300387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9960132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260589", "Detail": { "ID": 260589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0834095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316438", "Detail": { "ID": 316438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1478881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326891", "Detail": { "ID": 326891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7845072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278716", "Detail": { "ID": 278716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2312335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264685", "Detail": { "ID": 264685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1444847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248999", "Detail": { "ID": 248999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6791765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294092", "Detail": { "ID": 294092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8822709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287812", "Detail": { "ID": 287812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8873984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233710", "Detail": { "ID": 233710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1428039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243504", "Detail": { "ID": 243504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3005862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252895", "Detail": { "ID": 252895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7578729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323177", "Detail": { "ID": 323177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7256888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301483", "Detail": { "ID": 301483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2641637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273474", "Detail": { "ID": 273474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.621798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263495", "Detail": { "ID": 263495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8918598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285779", "Detail": { "ID": 285779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3441703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298594", "Detail": { "ID": 298594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3529182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286494", "Detail": { "ID": 286494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.58828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220018", "Detail": { "ID": 220018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3307819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238839", "Detail": { "ID": 238839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4712113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225809", "Detail": { "ID": 225809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9913596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322069", "Detail": { "ID": 322069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.469986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290259", "Detail": { "ID": 290259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7391435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228943", "Detail": { "ID": 228943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.820948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304773", "Detail": { "ID": 304773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0578557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258437", "Detail": { "ID": 258437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272085", "Detail": { "ID": 272085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.110932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279898", "Detail": { "ID": 279898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5275581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267103", "Detail": { "ID": 267103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7756295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253696", "Detail": { "ID": 253696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0169038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221540", "Detail": { "ID": 221540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.937146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220482", "Detail": { "ID": 220482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6432538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240414", "Detail": { "ID": 240414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3588106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266334", "Detail": { "ID": 266334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7363982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324072", "Detail": { "ID": 324072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9909663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260101", "Detail": { "ID": 260101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6437977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246975", "Detail": { "ID": 246975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1616995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275244", "Detail": { "ID": 275244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3617167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302671", "Detail": { "ID": 302671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5349977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303893", "Detail": { "ID": 303893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8404779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221978", "Detail": { "ID": 221978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9618592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242202", "Detail": { "ID": 242202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0027222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224090", "Detail": { "ID": 224090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4915897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308177", "Detail": { "ID": 308177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8680536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272816", "Detail": { "ID": 272816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3518123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244065", "Detail": { "ID": 244065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3319239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM313971", "Detail": { "ID": 313971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4241999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251301", "Detail": { "ID": 251301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4575883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276475", "Detail": { "ID": 276475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6672507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256516", "Detail": { "ID": 256516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7860473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282483", "Detail": { "ID": 282483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4208296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254973", "Detail": { "ID": 254973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2917542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277683", "Detail": { "ID": 277683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9640101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325213", "Detail": { "ID": 325213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4885992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232364", "Detail": { "ID": 232364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8516523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312167", "Detail": { "ID": 312167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9165964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230942", "Detail": { "ID": 230942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3521823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267955", "Detail": { "ID": 267955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0497082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314854", "Detail": { "ID": 314854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6583802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297145", "Detail": { "ID": 297145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8896347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319318", "Detail": { "ID": 319318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9149061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306103", "Detail": { "ID": 306103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3590955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM308855", "Detail": { "ID": 308855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0809519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268467", "Detail": { "ID": 268467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2684113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293094", "Detail": { "ID": 293094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5713515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261509", "Detail": { "ID": 261509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3605885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264422", "Detail": { "ID": 264422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1327916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307943", "Detail": { "ID": 307943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8576199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282902", "Detail": { "ID": 282902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4392435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280495", "Detail": { "ID": 280495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7697198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245494", "Detail": { "ID": 245494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8374163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM305134", "Detail": { "ID": 305134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0736017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303264", "Detail": { "ID": 303264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8073521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297010", "Detail": { "ID": 297010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8838397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224907", "Detail": { "ID": 224907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7256403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296473", "Detail": { "ID": 296473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8505902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321543", "Detail": { "ID": 321543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.440598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315689", "Detail": { "ID": 315689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9227924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238311", "Detail": { "ID": 238311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.44092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294237", "Detail": { "ID": 294237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1296964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233372", "Detail": { "ID": 233372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1213821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312793", "Detail": { "ID": 312793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1436087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287643", "Detail": { "ID": 287643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.880099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226631", "Detail": { "ID": 226631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2398488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258129", "Detail": { "ID": 258129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0934392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284534", "Detail": { "ID": 284534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0367275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259331", "Detail": { "ID": 259331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6043319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318783", "Detail": { "ID": 318783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6732095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255212", "Detail": { "ID": 255212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5210868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295164", "Detail": { "ID": 295164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.195361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236925", "Detail": { "ID": 236925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9462515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256900", "Detail": { "ID": 256900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8147293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239616", "Detail": { "ID": 239616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7513752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290941", "Detail": { "ID": 290941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7786483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309582", "Detail": { "ID": 309582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3358353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM249411", "Detail": { "ID": 249411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9254431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299442", "Detail": { "ID": 299442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.697599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234718", "Detail": { "ID": 234718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3967466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276290", "Detail": { "ID": 276290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6531659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273940", "Detail": { "ID": 273940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6422657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316246", "Detail": { "ID": 316246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1361851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325770", "Detail": { "ID": 325770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5207534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241764", "Detail": { "ID": 241764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7790706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM286958", "Detail": { "ID": 286958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6080973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248540", "Detail": { "ID": 248540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6507124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288248", "Detail": { "ID": 288248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1263935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223078", "Detail": { "ID": 223078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2277334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240511", "Detail": { "ID": 240511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3699719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284654", "Detail": { "ID": 284654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0418593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232727", "Detail": { "ID": 232727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8736384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245835", "Detail": { "ID": 245835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.860449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310879", "Detail": { "ID": 310879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2141, "AgendaID": 2685, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 112, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Census", "Reference": "S4M-08461", "ID": 8580 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-12-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5955988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259174", "Detail": { "ID": 259174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3448793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319561", "Detail": { "ID": 319561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9312534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249465", "Detail": { "ID": 249465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9278163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320884", "Detail": { "ID": 320884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1858256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228359", "Detail": { "ID": 228359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7950099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281061", "Detail": { "ID": 281061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8043386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262829", "Detail": { "ID": 262829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6247467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288965", "Detail": { "ID": 288965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1662425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230541", "Detail": { "ID": 230541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3348391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269697", "Detail": { "ID": 269697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5591173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322538", "Detail": { "ID": 322538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6930421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295367", "Detail": { "ID": 295367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5091367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243041", "Detail": { "ID": 243041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0463844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227092", "Detail": { "ID": 227092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2671439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303099", "Detail": { "ID": 303099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5585573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244174", "Detail": { "ID": 244174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3419542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316347", "Detail": { "ID": 316347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1439034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327055", "Detail": { "ID": 327055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7916474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277168", "Detail": { "ID": 277168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7040065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264006", "Detail": { "ID": 264006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9201723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248616", "Detail": { "ID": 248616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6624893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294871", "Detail": { "ID": 294871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.182316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285334", "Detail": { "ID": 285334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.318545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231272", "Detail": { "ID": 231272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5878029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243677", "Detail": { "ID": 243677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3151444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254428", "Detail": { "ID": 254428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2555287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323508", "Detail": { "ID": 323508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9594086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290867", "Detail": { "ID": 290867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7755304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273031", "Detail": { "ID": 273031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3665804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262563", "Detail": { "ID": 262563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6072983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281831", "Detail": { "ID": 281831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1594832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298296", "Detail": { "ID": 298296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3396485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284954", "Detail": { "ID": 284954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0548493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219548", "Detail": { "ID": 219548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3041211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238254", "Detail": { "ID": 238254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4384717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225118", "Detail": { "ID": 225118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7452547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321922", "Detail": { "ID": 321922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4571343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292765", "Detail": { "ID": 292765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5571961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227580", "Detail": { "ID": 227580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5562602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313327", "Detail": { "ID": 313327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3905315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257817", "Detail": { "ID": 257817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0788698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271086", "Detail": { "ID": 271086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8418995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277969", "Detail": { "ID": 277969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9765583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288327", "Detail": { "ID": 288327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.130054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250634", "Detail": { "ID": 250634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2069665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221098", "Detail": { "ID": 221098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6749955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220096", "Detail": { "ID": 220096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.334162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252830", "Detail": { "ID": 252830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7550803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253737", "Detail": { "ID": 253737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0187955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324743", "Detail": { "ID": 324743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2359712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259407", "Detail": { "ID": 259407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.607784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239489", "Detail": { "ID": 239489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7460099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273632", "Detail": { "ID": 273632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6287332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302617", "Detail": { "ID": 302617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5323989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303980", "Detail": { "ID": 303980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8442123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221596", "Detail": { "ID": 221596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9395559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241828", "Detail": { "ID": 241828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7817917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223379", "Detail": { "ID": 223379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4553465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307878", "Detail": { "ID": 307878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8548133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272369", "Detail": { "ID": 272369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3323773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245052", "Detail": { "ID": 245052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5899482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315218", "Detail": { "ID": 315218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8990253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247472", "Detail": { "ID": 247472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4052642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275154", "Detail": { "ID": 275154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1439254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255474", "Detail": { "ID": 255474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5328929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276935", "Detail": { "ID": 276935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6874209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253490", "Detail": { "ID": 253490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9986733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276370", "Detail": { "ID": 276370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6626931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325388", "Detail": { "ID": 325388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4965419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233318", "Detail": { "ID": 233318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1190614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311722", "Detail": { "ID": 311722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8914489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229631", "Detail": { "ID": 229631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0900119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267506", "Detail": { "ID": 267506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0227809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313438", "Detail": { "ID": 313438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3953682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294467", "Detail": { "ID": 294467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1395687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319171", "Detail": { "ID": 319171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6954833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306268", "Detail": { "ID": 306268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5447558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310766", "Detail": { "ID": 310766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5851281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268098", "Detail": { "ID": 268098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0560699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292959", "Detail": { "ID": 292959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5655709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258502", "Detail": { "ID": 258502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3100125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263575", "Detail": { "ID": 263575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8953093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308722", "Detail": { "ID": 308722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0681283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280130", "Detail": { "ID": 280130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5427252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279504", "Detail": { "ID": 279504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5105515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260469", "Detail": { "ID": 260469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0782242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299368", "Detail": { "ID": 299368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6944324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306752", "Detail": { "ID": 306752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5658851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300583", "Detail": { "ID": 300583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0048439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224002", "Detail": { "ID": 224002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.48779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305599", "Detail": { "ID": 305599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3313194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320099", "Detail": { "ID": 320099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9616253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315864", "Detail": { "ID": 315864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9303566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237108", "Detail": { "ID": 237108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9661945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289707", "Detail": { "ID": 289707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.455729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234256", "Detail": { "ID": 234256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3694056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313124", "Detail": { "ID": 313124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1646824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289354", "Detail": { "ID": 289354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4336368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225562", "Detail": { "ID": 225562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9803438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265696", "Detail": { "ID": 265696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4503316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283011", "Detail": { "ID": 283011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4439472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252084", "Detail": { "ID": 252084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.501865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317321", "Detail": { "ID": 317321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4170849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254217", "Detail": { "ID": 254217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2459903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296256", "Detail": { "ID": 296256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8407989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235528", "Detail": { "ID": 235528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6817075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258069", "Detail": { "ID": 258069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0902394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228595", "Detail": { "ID": 228595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8058808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291029", "Detail": { "ID": 291029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.782417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311500", "Detail": { "ID": 311500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8815212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246817", "Detail": { "ID": 246817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1546645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297691", "Detail": { "ID": 297691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1205701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234032", "Detail": { "ID": 234032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1571927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274891", "Detail": { "ID": 274891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1264754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269982", "Detail": { "ID": 269982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5764594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317684", "Detail": { "ID": 317684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4329769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326442", "Detail": { "ID": 326442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7648847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241300", "Detail": { "ID": 241300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7519827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290411", "Detail": { "ID": 290411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.745952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248093", "Detail": { "ID": 248093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4416883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288161", "Detail": { "ID": 288161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9095321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222652", "Detail": { "ID": 222652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1981392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239671", "Detail": { "ID": 239671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7539391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283804", "Detail": { "ID": 283804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7241817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231762", "Detail": { "ID": 231762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6144347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237311", "Detail": { "ID": 237311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1987366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308959", "Detail": { "ID": 308959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2139, "AgendaID": 2795, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 43, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08422.1", "ID": 8548 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-28T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0854472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269193", "Detail": { "ID": 269193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3077039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318622", "Detail": { "ID": 318622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6660871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249905", "Detail": { "ID": 249905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9550432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320234", "Detail": { "ID": 320234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1508238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230327", "Detail": { "ID": 230327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3180348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281399", "Detail": { "ID": 281399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1331419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263695", "Detail": { "ID": 263695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9007634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289038", "Detail": { "ID": 289038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1693762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228761", "Detail": { "ID": 228761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8130377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270433", "Detail": { "ID": 270433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8075686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323325", "Detail": { "ID": 323325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9449051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296489", "Detail": { "ID": 296489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8512714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242465", "Detail": { "ID": 242465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0144421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236080", "Detail": { "ID": 236080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.710376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300392", "Detail": { "ID": 300392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9962385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260594", "Detail": { "ID": 260594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0836327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316628", "Detail": { "ID": 316628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1563648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326895", "Detail": { "ID": 326895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7846873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278711", "Detail": { "ID": 278711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2310132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264690", "Detail": { "ID": 264690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1446883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249004", "Detail": { "ID": 249004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6793818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293704", "Detail": { "ID": 293704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8653525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287807", "Detail": { "ID": 287807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8871566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233705", "Detail": { "ID": 233705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1425936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243420", "Detail": { "ID": 243420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2969903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252890", "Detail": { "ID": 252890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7576523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323181", "Detail": { "ID": 323181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7258515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301475", "Detail": { "ID": 301475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2638111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273469", "Detail": { "ID": 273469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6215489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263490", "Detail": { "ID": 263490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8916564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285740", "Detail": { "ID": 285740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3425315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298786", "Detail": { "ID": 298786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.372101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286499", "Detail": { "ID": 286499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.588484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220013", "Detail": { "ID": 220013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3305757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238834", "Detail": { "ID": 238834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4710093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225869", "Detail": { "ID": 225869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9939234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322108", "Detail": { "ID": 322108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4716623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290264", "Detail": { "ID": 290264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.739348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228938", "Detail": { "ID": 228938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.820742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304778", "Detail": { "ID": 304778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0580961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258431", "Detail": { "ID": 258431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3069321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272090", "Detail": { "ID": 272090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1111571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279859", "Detail": { "ID": 279859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5258935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267108", "Detail": { "ID": 267108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7758524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253691", "Detail": { "ID": 253691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0166992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221487", "Detail": { "ID": 221487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9348656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220487", "Detail": { "ID": 220487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6434773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240419", "Detail": { "ID": 240419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3590146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266367", "Detail": { "ID": 266367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7378203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324068", "Detail": { "ID": 324068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9907829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260106", "Detail": { "ID": 260106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.644002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246980", "Detail": { "ID": 246980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1619224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275249", "Detail": { "ID": 275249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3619447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302676", "Detail": { "ID": 302676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5352085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303888", "Detail": { "ID": 303888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8402739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222038", "Detail": { "ID": 222038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9646971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242255", "Detail": { "ID": 242255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0050452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224095", "Detail": { "ID": 224095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4917947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308215", "Detail": { "ID": 308215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0460138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272810", "Detail": { "ID": 272810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3515469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244149", "Detail": { "ID": 244149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3358557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314320", "Detail": { "ID": 314320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6346006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251296", "Detail": { "ID": 251296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4573552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276470", "Detail": { "ID": 276470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6670459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256511", "Detail": { "ID": 256511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7858424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282488", "Detail": { "ID": 282488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4210334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254978", "Detail": { "ID": 254978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.29196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277688", "Detail": { "ID": 277688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.96421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325217", "Detail": { "ID": 325217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4887719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232369", "Detail": { "ID": 232369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8518573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312202", "Detail": { "ID": 312202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1148403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230947", "Detail": { "ID": 230947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3524045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267926", "Detail": { "ID": 267926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0484507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314815", "Detail": { "ID": 314815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6566857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297111", "Detail": { "ID": 297111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8881808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319358", "Detail": { "ID": 319358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9224392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306023", "Detail": { "ID": 306023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3556749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309025", "Detail": { "ID": 309025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0884708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268500", "Detail": { "ID": 268500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.269847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293129", "Detail": { "ID": 293129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5728435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261515", "Detail": { "ID": 261515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3608515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264427", "Detail": { "ID": 264427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.133013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307780", "Detail": { "ID": 307780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8445878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282897", "Detail": { "ID": 282897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4390234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280500", "Detail": { "ID": 280500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7699214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245415", "Detail": { "ID": 245415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8338757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304946", "Detail": { "ID": 304946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0655751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303259", "Detail": { "ID": 303259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8071461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297015", "Detail": { "ID": 297015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8840444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224854", "Detail": { "ID": 224854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7229434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296858", "Detail": { "ID": 296858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8771053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321354", "Detail": { "ID": 321354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4245587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315605", "Detail": { "ID": 315605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9191914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238306", "Detail": { "ID": 238306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4407138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294182", "Detail": { "ID": 294182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8864909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233367", "Detail": { "ID": 233367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1211574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312510", "Detail": { "ID": 312510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1310305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287638", "Detail": { "ID": 287638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8798912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226626", "Detail": { "ID": 226626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.239644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258124", "Detail": { "ID": 258124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0931618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284526", "Detail": { "ID": 284526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0363997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259326", "Detail": { "ID": 259326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6040517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318588", "Detail": { "ID": 318588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6646279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255217", "Detail": { "ID": 255217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5212935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295159", "Detail": { "ID": 295159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1950829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236920", "Detail": { "ID": 236920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9460265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256905", "Detail": { "ID": 256905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8149333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239563", "Detail": { "ID": 239563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7491241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290936", "Detail": { "ID": 290936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7784459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309976", "Detail": { "ID": 309976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3590639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247667", "Detail": { "ID": 247667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4232651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299234", "Detail": { "ID": 299234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6886704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234723", "Detail": { "ID": 234723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3969729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276285", "Detail": { "ID": 276285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6529383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273979", "Detail": { "ID": 273979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6490064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316240", "Detail": { "ID": 316240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1359352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325766", "Detail": { "ID": 325766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.520573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241705", "Detail": { "ID": 241705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7762817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287042", "Detail": { "ID": 287042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6117277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248535", "Detail": { "ID": 248535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6504876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288256", "Detail": { "ID": 288256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1268488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223073", "Detail": { "ID": 223073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2275123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240570", "Detail": { "ID": 240570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3729536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284649", "Detail": { "ID": 284649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0416582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232773", "Detail": { "ID": 232773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8756307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245840", "Detail": { "ID": 245840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8606864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310226", "Detail": { "ID": 310226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2138, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407.1", "ID": 8535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5612929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269192", "Detail": { "ID": 269192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3076627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318624", "Detail": { "ID": 318624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.666234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249848", "Detail": { "ID": 249848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9526289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320232", "Detail": { "ID": 320232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1507394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230328", "Detail": { "ID": 230328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3180753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281398", "Detail": { "ID": 281398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1331017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263696", "Detail": { "ID": 263696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.900804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289039", "Detail": { "ID": 289039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1694178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228762", "Detail": { "ID": 228762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8130789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270434", "Detail": { "ID": 270434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8076093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323327", "Detail": { "ID": 323327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9449869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296490", "Detail": { "ID": 296490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8513117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229021", "Detail": { "ID": 229021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8304802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236079", "Detail": { "ID": 236079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7103351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300391", "Detail": { "ID": 300391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9961959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260593", "Detail": { "ID": 260593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0835723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316626", "Detail": { "ID": 316626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1562632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326897", "Detail": { "ID": 326897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7847694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278712", "Detail": { "ID": 278712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2310534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264689", "Detail": { "ID": 264689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1446476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249003", "Detail": { "ID": 249003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6793409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294096", "Detail": { "ID": 294096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8824543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287808", "Detail": { "ID": 287808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8872002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233706", "Detail": { "ID": 233706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.142636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243508", "Detail": { "ID": 243508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3007484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252891", "Detail": { "ID": 252891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7576918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323183", "Detail": { "ID": 323183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7259334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301487", "Detail": { "ID": 301487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2643298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273470", "Detail": { "ID": 273470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6216269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263491", "Detail": { "ID": 263491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8916967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285741", "Detail": { "ID": 285741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3425719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298631", "Detail": { "ID": 298631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3545007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286498", "Detail": { "ID": 286498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5884434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220014", "Detail": { "ID": 220014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3306168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238835", "Detail": { "ID": 238835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.47105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225813", "Detail": { "ID": 225813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9915219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322106", "Detail": { "ID": 322106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.471562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290263", "Detail": { "ID": 290263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7393076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228939", "Detail": { "ID": 228939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8207826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304777", "Detail": { "ID": 304777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0580521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258433", "Detail": { "ID": 258433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.307034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272089", "Detail": { "ID": 272089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.111117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279860", "Detail": { "ID": 279860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5259341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267107", "Detail": { "ID": 267107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7757941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253692", "Detail": { "ID": 253692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.016741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221536", "Detail": { "ID": 221536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.93698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220486", "Detail": { "ID": 220486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6434173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240418", "Detail": { "ID": 240418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3589736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266368", "Detail": { "ID": 266368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7378618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324066", "Detail": { "ID": 324066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9907011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260105", "Detail": { "ID": 260105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6439615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246979", "Detail": { "ID": 246979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1618822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275248", "Detail": { "ID": 275248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3619028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302675", "Detail": { "ID": 302675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5351683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303889", "Detail": { "ID": 303889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.840315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221982", "Detail": { "ID": 221982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9620398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242206", "Detail": { "ID": 242206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0029101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224094", "Detail": { "ID": 224094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4917543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308214", "Detail": { "ID": 308214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0459711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272812", "Detail": { "ID": 272812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3516496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244061", "Detail": { "ID": 244061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3317604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM313964", "Detail": { "ID": 313964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4238473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251297", "Detail": { "ID": 251297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4573957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276471", "Detail": { "ID": 276471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6670868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256512", "Detail": { "ID": 256512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7858841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282487", "Detail": { "ID": 282487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4209919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254977", "Detail": { "ID": 254977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2919191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277687", "Detail": { "ID": 277687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.96417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325219", "Detail": { "ID": 325219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4888548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232368", "Detail": { "ID": 232368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8518163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312200", "Detail": { "ID": 312200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9180005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230946", "Detail": { "ID": 230946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.352363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267925", "Detail": { "ID": 267925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0484103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314817", "Detail": { "ID": 314817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6567857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297112", "Detail": { "ID": 297112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8882214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319356", "Detail": { "ID": 319356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9223567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306107", "Detail": { "ID": 306107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.359276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309026", "Detail": { "ID": 309026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0885129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268501", "Detail": { "ID": 268501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2698877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293128", "Detail": { "ID": 293128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5728031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261513", "Detail": { "ID": 261513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.36077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264426", "Detail": { "ID": 264426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1329718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307779", "Detail": { "ID": 307779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8445459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282898", "Detail": { "ID": 282898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4390634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280499", "Detail": { "ID": 280499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7698805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245498", "Detail": { "ID": 245498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8378025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304947", "Detail": { "ID": 304947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0656156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303260", "Detail": { "ID": 303260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8071869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297014", "Detail": { "ID": 297014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8840035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224903", "Detail": { "ID": 224903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7254752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296469", "Detail": { "ID": 296469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8504078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321356", "Detail": { "ID": 321356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4246602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315696", "Detail": { "ID": 315696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9230993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238307", "Detail": { "ID": 238307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4407548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294181", "Detail": { "ID": 294181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8864488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233368", "Detail": { "ID": 233368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1211983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312800", "Detail": { "ID": 312800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1439186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287639", "Detail": { "ID": 287639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.879938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226627", "Detail": { "ID": 226627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2396849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258125", "Detail": { "ID": 258125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0932134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284538", "Detail": { "ID": 284538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0369093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259327", "Detail": { "ID": 259327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.604092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318590", "Detail": { "ID": 318590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6647101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255216", "Detail": { "ID": 255216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5212527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295160", "Detail": { "ID": 295160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1951339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236921", "Detail": { "ID": 236921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9460669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256904", "Detail": { "ID": 256904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8148926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239612", "Detail": { "ID": 239612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7512143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290937", "Detail": { "ID": 290937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7784857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309575", "Detail": { "ID": 309575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3355292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM249407", "Detail": { "ID": 249407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9252783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299233", "Detail": { "ID": 299233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6886302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234722", "Detail": { "ID": 234722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3969111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276286", "Detail": { "ID": 276286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6529792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273978", "Detail": { "ID": 273978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6489459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316238", "Detail": { "ID": 316238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1358327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325764", "Detail": { "ID": 325764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.520493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241760", "Detail": { "ID": 241760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7788888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM286952", "Detail": { "ID": 286952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.607852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248536", "Detail": { "ID": 248536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6505467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288244", "Detail": { "ID": 288244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1262275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223074", "Detail": { "ID": 223074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2275525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240515", "Detail": { "ID": 240515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3701582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284650", "Detail": { "ID": 284650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0416985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232772", "Detail": { "ID": 232772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8755717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245839", "Detail": { "ID": 245839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8606454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310227", "Detail": { "ID": 310227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2137, "AgendaID": 2269, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Independence White Paper", "Reference": "S4M-08407", "ID": 8525 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5613387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259254", "Detail": { "ID": 259254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6009529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318719", "Detail": { "ID": 318719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6704724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250219", "Detail": { "ID": 250219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1797613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321078", "Detail": { "ID": 321078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2013081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228459", "Detail": { "ID": 228459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7999807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281150", "Detail": { "ID": 281150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8081102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263079", "Detail": { "ID": 263079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6358708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288121", "Detail": { "ID": 288121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9010112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227459", "Detail": { "ID": 227459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5510672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269307", "Detail": { "ID": 269307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5418676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322448", "Detail": { "ID": 322448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.689059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295923", "Detail": { "ID": 295923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5416199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243110", "Detail": { "ID": 243110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0493401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227024", "Detail": { "ID": 227024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2641932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301037", "Detail": { "ID": 301037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0298619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238374", "Detail": { "ID": 238374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.443751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316391", "Detail": { "ID": 316391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1458657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326985", "Detail": { "ID": 326985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7886251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277575", "Detail": { "ID": 277575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9592233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263911", "Detail": { "ID": 263911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9161003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250934", "Detail": { "ID": 250934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2198876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294799", "Detail": { "ID": 294799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1788438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285429", "Detail": { "ID": 285429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3227189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231343", "Detail": { "ID": 231343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5908502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243608", "Detail": { "ID": 243608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.312228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254374", "Detail": { "ID": 254374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2529174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323436", "Detail": { "ID": 323436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9560773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300640", "Detail": { "ID": 300640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.007282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273127", "Detail": { "ID": 273127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.370746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262657", "Detail": { "ID": 262657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6112691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281743", "Detail": { "ID": 281743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1557554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298536", "Detail": { "ID": 298536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3503453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285051", "Detail": { "ID": 285051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0593194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219643", "Detail": { "ID": 219643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3082424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238174", "Detail": { "ID": 238174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2481236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226647", "Detail": { "ID": 226647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2405481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322012", "Detail": { "ID": 322012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4674677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292648", "Detail": { "ID": 292648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5518462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227671", "Detail": { "ID": 227671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5606568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304601", "Detail": { "ID": 304601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0453909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257906", "Detail": { "ID": 257906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0826859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271183", "Detail": { "ID": 271183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8460346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274323", "Detail": { "ID": 274323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0956404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266401", "Detail": { "ID": 266401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7392831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250724", "Detail": { "ID": 250724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2108625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221190", "Detail": { "ID": 221190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6789487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226421", "Detail": { "ID": 226421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2306659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239712", "Detail": { "ID": 239712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7556816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253181", "Detail": { "ID": 253181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.770164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324815", "Detail": { "ID": 324815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2390308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260945", "Detail": { "ID": 260945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.104756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246049", "Detail": { "ID": 246049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8699977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273536", "Detail": { "ID": 273536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.62461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301984", "Detail": { "ID": 301984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2920697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303678", "Detail": { "ID": 303678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8256354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223123", "Detail": { "ID": 223123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2296243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245636", "Detail": { "ID": 245636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8519894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223311", "Detail": { "ID": 223311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4523988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308119", "Detail": { "ID": 308119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8655422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272460", "Detail": { "ID": 272460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3362796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245121", "Detail": { "ID": 245121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5929387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315292", "Detail": { "ID": 315292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.905327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247391", "Detail": { "ID": 247391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.40181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275057", "Detail": { "ID": 275057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1393145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255084", "Detail": { "ID": 255084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2966046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277342", "Detail": { "ID": 277342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9441262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254039", "Detail": { "ID": 254039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0318821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278831", "Detail": { "ID": 278831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2361102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325317", "Detail": { "ID": 325317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4934737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231941", "Detail": { "ID": 231941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6223701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312118", "Detail": { "ID": 312118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9144896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233150", "Detail": { "ID": 233150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8990174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267595", "Detail": { "ID": 267595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0266577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313042", "Detail": { "ID": 313042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1611336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294380", "Detail": { "ID": 294380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1358502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319261", "Detail": { "ID": 319261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9124199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306193", "Detail": { "ID": 306193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3632357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310348", "Detail": { "ID": 310348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5666546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268009", "Detail": { "ID": 268009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0520576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293046", "Detail": { "ID": 293046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5692938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271490", "Detail": { "ID": 271490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0780695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269456", "Detail": { "ID": 269456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.548337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307247", "Detail": { "ID": 307247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.820986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280218", "Detail": { "ID": 280218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7511548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279098", "Detail": { "ID": 279098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2529253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260399", "Detail": { "ID": 260399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0751861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299281", "Detail": { "ID": 299281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6907082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301806", "Detail": { "ID": 301806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2840365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300311", "Detail": { "ID": 300311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9925718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224247", "Detail": { "ID": 224247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6906756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305674", "Detail": { "ID": 305674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3345382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320009", "Detail": { "ID": 320009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9574525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315791", "Detail": { "ID": 315791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9271596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237201", "Detail": { "ID": 237201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1939794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288843", "Detail": { "ID": 288843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1607691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234202", "Detail": { "ID": 234202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3665202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312894", "Detail": { "ID": 312894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1544607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261319", "Detail": { "ID": 261319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3522529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225630", "Detail": { "ID": 225630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9836156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265643", "Detail": { "ID": 265643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4480693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284157", "Detail": { "ID": 284157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7454718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258663", "Detail": { "ID": 258663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3172193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317232", "Detail": { "ID": 317232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.409527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256181", "Detail": { "ID": 256181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5740897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293376", "Detail": { "ID": 293376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8423512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235933", "Detail": { "ID": 235933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6991878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255911", "Detail": { "ID": 255911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5622817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229299", "Detail": { "ID": 229299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0706977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289507", "Detail": { "ID": 289507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4402151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311573", "Detail": { "ID": 311573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8846972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246906", "Detail": { "ID": 246906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1585324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297598", "Detail": { "ID": 297598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1070812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233806", "Detail": { "ID": 233806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1471328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274985", "Detail": { "ID": 274985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1361558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270071", "Detail": { "ID": 270071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5802932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317757", "Detail": { "ID": 317757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4360524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326513", "Detail": { "ID": 326513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.767917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241390", "Detail": { "ID": 241390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7558923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291096", "Detail": { "ID": 291096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7853926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248185", "Detail": { "ID": 248185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6348703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290020", "Detail": { "ID": 290020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4693196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222720", "Detail": { "ID": 222720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2012699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240885", "Detail": { "ID": 240885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3864686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283707", "Detail": { "ID": 283707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7198039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231048", "Detail": { "ID": 231048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3633908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247254", "Detail": { "ID": 247254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3956388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308871", "Detail": { "ID": 308871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2131, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-08364", "ID": 13133 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.081653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259253", "Detail": { "ID": 259253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6009123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318694", "Detail": { "ID": 318694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6694062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250218", "Detail": { "ID": 250218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1797204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321103", "Detail": { "ID": 321103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2023783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228460", "Detail": { "ID": 228460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8000216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281154", "Detail": { "ID": 281154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8082732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263078", "Detail": { "ID": 263078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.635829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288122", "Detail": { "ID": 288122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9010532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227460", "Detail": { "ID": 227460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5511251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269308", "Detail": { "ID": 269308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5419284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323377", "Detail": { "ID": 323377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9471204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295922", "Detail": { "ID": 295922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.54158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243111", "Detail": { "ID": 243111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0493811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227023", "Detail": { "ID": 227023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2641517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301039", "Detail": { "ID": 301039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0299738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238375", "Detail": { "ID": 238375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4437921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316393", "Detail": { "ID": 316393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1459493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326958", "Detail": { "ID": 326958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7874428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277574", "Detail": { "ID": 277574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9591834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263912", "Detail": { "ID": 263912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9161417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249377", "Detail": { "ID": 249377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9239767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294159", "Detail": { "ID": 294159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8854737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285428", "Detail": { "ID": 285428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3226667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231365", "Detail": { "ID": 231365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5917926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243607", "Detail": { "ID": 243607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3121881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254372", "Detail": { "ID": 254372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2528333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323410", "Detail": { "ID": 323410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9549459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300639", "Detail": { "ID": 300639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0072416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273126", "Detail": { "ID": 273126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3707052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262658", "Detail": { "ID": 262658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6113099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281739", "Detail": { "ID": 281739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1555737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298540", "Detail": { "ID": 298540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3505324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285050", "Detail": { "ID": 285050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.059278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219644", "Detail": { "ID": 219644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3082855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238175", "Detail": { "ID": 238175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.248166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226646", "Detail": { "ID": 226646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2405068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322014", "Detail": { "ID": 322014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4675517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292647", "Detail": { "ID": 292647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5518058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227672", "Detail": { "ID": 227672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5606986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304603", "Detail": { "ID": 304603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0454719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257907", "Detail": { "ID": 257907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0827264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271182", "Detail": { "ID": 271182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8459927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274319", "Detail": { "ID": 274319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0954707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266403", "Detail": { "ID": 266403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7393664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250725", "Detail": { "ID": 250725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2109029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221191", "Detail": { "ID": 221191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6789898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226420", "Detail": { "ID": 226420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2306063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239714", "Detail": { "ID": 239714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7557632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253177", "Detail": { "ID": 253177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7699976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324841", "Detail": { "ID": 324841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2401251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260944", "Detail": { "ID": 260944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1047156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246048", "Detail": { "ID": 246048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8699566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273537", "Detail": { "ID": 273537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6246511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301983", "Detail": { "ID": 301983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2920286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303676", "Detail": { "ID": 303676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8255534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223122", "Detail": { "ID": 223122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2295837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245635", "Detail": { "ID": 245635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8519491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223310", "Detail": { "ID": 223310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4523576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308123", "Detail": { "ID": 308123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8657107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272461", "Detail": { "ID": 272461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3363205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245146", "Detail": { "ID": 245146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5940289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315316", "Detail": { "ID": 315316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9063652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247392", "Detail": { "ID": 247392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4018513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275058", "Detail": { "ID": 275058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.139356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255085", "Detail": { "ID": 255085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2966462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277341", "Detail": { "ID": 277341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9440651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254038", "Detail": { "ID": 254038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.031841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278830", "Detail": { "ID": 278830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2360704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325290", "Detail": { "ID": 325290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4923228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231943", "Detail": { "ID": 231943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6224541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312122", "Detail": { "ID": 312122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9146557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233149", "Detail": { "ID": 233149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8989769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267599", "Detail": { "ID": 267599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0268286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313038", "Detail": { "ID": 313038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1609493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294376", "Detail": { "ID": 294376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1356827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319263", "Detail": { "ID": 319263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9125261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306169", "Detail": { "ID": 306169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3619441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310349", "Detail": { "ID": 310349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5666961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268005", "Detail": { "ID": 268005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0518666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293050", "Detail": { "ID": 293050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5694792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271489", "Detail": { "ID": 271489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0780291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269455", "Detail": { "ID": 269455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5482958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307246", "Detail": { "ID": 307246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.820945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280219", "Detail": { "ID": 280219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7511969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279099", "Detail": { "ID": 279099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.252966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260374", "Detail": { "ID": 260374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0741158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299277", "Detail": { "ID": 299277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6905404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301807", "Detail": { "ID": 301807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2840777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300310", "Detail": { "ID": 300310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9925024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224248", "Detail": { "ID": 224248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6907169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305698", "Detail": { "ID": 305698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3355569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320007", "Detail": { "ID": 320007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9573678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315766", "Detail": { "ID": 315766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9260766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237200", "Detail": { "ID": 237200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1939285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288844", "Detail": { "ID": 288844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.160828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234200", "Detail": { "ID": 234200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3664057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312869", "Detail": { "ID": 312869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.146886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261320", "Detail": { "ID": 261320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3522934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225631", "Detail": { "ID": 225631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9836562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265641", "Detail": { "ID": 265641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.447987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284156", "Detail": { "ID": 284156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7454301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258664", "Detail": { "ID": 258664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3172615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317230", "Detail": { "ID": 317230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4094399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256180", "Detail": { "ID": 256180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5740491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293377", "Detail": { "ID": 293377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8423929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235934", "Detail": { "ID": 235934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6992288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255913", "Detail": { "ID": 255913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5623622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229300", "Detail": { "ID": 229300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0707403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289505", "Detail": { "ID": 289505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4401334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311598", "Detail": { "ID": 311598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.885781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246907", "Detail": { "ID": 246907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1585733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297599", "Detail": { "ID": 297599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1071218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233784", "Detail": { "ID": 233784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1460458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274986", "Detail": { "ID": 274986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1362007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270075", "Detail": { "ID": 270075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5804588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317782", "Detail": { "ID": 317782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4371258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326540", "Detail": { "ID": 326540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7690794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241391", "Detail": { "ID": 241391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7559334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291121", "Detail": { "ID": 291121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7866048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248186", "Detail": { "ID": 248186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6349285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290021", "Detail": { "ID": 290021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4693792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222721", "Detail": { "ID": 222721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.201311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240884", "Detail": { "ID": 240884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3864095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283708", "Detail": { "ID": 283708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7198458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231047", "Detail": { "ID": 231047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3633501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247253", "Detail": { "ID": 247253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3955983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308867", "Detail": { "ID": 308867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2132, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.3", "ID": 8479 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0814838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259252", "Detail": { "ID": 259252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6008702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318695", "Detail": { "ID": 318695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6694524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250217", "Detail": { "ID": 250217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1796783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321102", "Detail": { "ID": 321102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2023368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228462", "Detail": { "ID": 228462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8001043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281567", "Detail": { "ID": 281567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1483582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263080", "Detail": { "ID": 263080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6359117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288123", "Detail": { "ID": 288123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9078122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227461", "Detail": { "ID": 227461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5511667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269309", "Detail": { "ID": 269309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5419717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323018", "Detail": { "ID": 323018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7184675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295924", "Detail": { "ID": 295924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5416599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243136", "Detail": { "ID": 243136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.050641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227022", "Detail": { "ID": 227022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2641093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301038", "Detail": { "ID": 301038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0299219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238373", "Detail": { "ID": 238373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4437096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316920", "Detail": { "ID": 316920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1691479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326959", "Detail": { "ID": 326959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7875036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277576", "Detail": { "ID": 277576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9592647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263756", "Detail": { "ID": 263756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9033669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249376", "Detail": { "ID": 249376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9239272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294160", "Detail": { "ID": 294160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8855292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285430", "Detail": { "ID": 285430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3227629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231366", "Detail": { "ID": 231366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.591833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243582", "Detail": { "ID": 243582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3111432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254373", "Detail": { "ID": 254373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2528761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323411", "Detail": { "ID": 323411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9549887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300638", "Detail": { "ID": 300638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0072008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273128", "Detail": { "ID": 273128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.370787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262659", "Detail": { "ID": 262659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6113502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282315", "Detail": { "ID": 282315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4074956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298954", "Detail": { "ID": 298954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3794824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285049", "Detail": { "ID": 285049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.059237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219645", "Detail": { "ID": 219645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3083463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238176", "Detail": { "ID": 238176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2482074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226335", "Detail": { "ID": 226335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2268696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322277", "Detail": { "ID": 322277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6758358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292646", "Detail": { "ID": 292646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5517651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227673", "Detail": { "ID": 227673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.560739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304602", "Detail": { "ID": 304602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0454314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257908", "Detail": { "ID": 257908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0827669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271181", "Detail": { "ID": 271181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.845934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279380", "Detail": { "ID": 279380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4996926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266402", "Detail": { "ID": 266402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7393253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250726", "Detail": { "ID": 250726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2109427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221192", "Detail": { "ID": 221192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6790307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226419", "Detail": { "ID": 226419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2305642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239713", "Detail": { "ID": 239713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7557221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266701", "Detail": { "ID": 266701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7528124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324840", "Detail": { "ID": 324840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2400846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260943", "Detail": { "ID": 260943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1046749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246047", "Detail": { "ID": 246047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8699156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273535", "Detail": { "ID": 273535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6245696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301982", "Detail": { "ID": 301982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2919859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303677", "Detail": { "ID": 303677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8255949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223121", "Detail": { "ID": 223121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2295432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245634", "Detail": { "ID": 245634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8519065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223309", "Detail": { "ID": 223309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.452316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308384", "Detail": { "ID": 308384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0536187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272462", "Detail": { "ID": 272462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3363611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245145", "Detail": { "ID": 245145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5939698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315315", "Detail": { "ID": 315315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9063238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247393", "Detail": { "ID": 247393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4018919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275059", "Detail": { "ID": 275059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1394162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255086", "Detail": { "ID": 255086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2966867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277340", "Detail": { "ID": 277340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9440245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254037", "Detail": { "ID": 254037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0318003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278829", "Detail": { "ID": 278829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2360292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325291", "Detail": { "ID": 325291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4923646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231942", "Detail": { "ID": 231942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6224127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312356", "Detail": { "ID": 312356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.124296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233148", "Detail": { "ID": 233148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8989346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267760", "Detail": { "ID": 267760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0338095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314493", "Detail": { "ID": 314493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6423705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296649", "Detail": { "ID": 296649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8680619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319681", "Detail": { "ID": 319681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9367613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306170", "Detail": { "ID": 306170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3619852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310350", "Detail": { "ID": 310350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5667368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268680", "Detail": { "ID": 268680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2780474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293746", "Detail": { "ID": 293746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8671374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271488", "Detail": { "ID": 271488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0779885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269454", "Detail": { "ID": 269454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5482539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307245", "Detail": { "ID": 307245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8209041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280220", "Detail": { "ID": 280220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7512388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279097", "Detail": { "ID": 279097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2528839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260375", "Detail": { "ID": 260375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0741574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300007", "Detail": { "ID": 300007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7323031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301808", "Detail": { "ID": 301808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.284121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300309", "Detail": { "ID": 300309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9924615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224249", "Detail": { "ID": 224249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6907583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305697", "Detail": { "ID": 305697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.335516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321046", "Detail": { "ID": 321046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1999265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315767", "Detail": { "ID": 315767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9261169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237202", "Detail": { "ID": 237202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1940323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288842", "Detail": { "ID": 288842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1607287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234201", "Detail": { "ID": 234201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3664651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312870", "Detail": { "ID": 312870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1469275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261321", "Detail": { "ID": 261321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3523336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225632", "Detail": { "ID": 225632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9836969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265642", "Detail": { "ID": 265642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4480281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284155", "Detail": { "ID": 284155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7453877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258665", "Detail": { "ID": 258665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3173031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318265", "Detail": { "ID": 318265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6453225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256179", "Detail": { "ID": 256179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5740074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293378", "Detail": { "ID": 293378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8424367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235935", "Detail": { "ID": 235935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6992694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255912", "Detail": { "ID": 255912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5623225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229301", "Detail": { "ID": 229301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0707818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289506", "Detail": { "ID": 289506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4401741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311597", "Detail": { "ID": 311597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8857386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246908", "Detail": { "ID": 246908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1586138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297597", "Detail": { "ID": 297597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1070405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233783", "Detail": { "ID": 233783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.146004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274987", "Detail": { "ID": 274987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1362431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274146", "Detail": { "ID": 274146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6564378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317781", "Detail": { "ID": 317781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.437065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326539", "Detail": { "ID": 326539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7690199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241392", "Detail": { "ID": 241392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7559754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291120", "Detail": { "ID": 291120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7865631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248187", "Detail": { "ID": 248187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6349834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290022", "Detail": { "ID": 290022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4694222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222722", "Detail": { "ID": 222722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2013518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240883", "Detail": { "ID": 240883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3863682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283709", "Detail": { "ID": 283709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7198873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM252167", "Detail": { "ID": 252167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5054859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247252", "Detail": { "ID": 247252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3955573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309750", "Detail": { "ID": 309750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2133, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348.1", "ID": 8472 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3433222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259251", "Detail": { "ID": 259251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6008081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318693", "Detail": { "ID": 318693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.669366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250216", "Detail": { "ID": 250216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1796366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321104", "Detail": { "ID": 321104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.202419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228463", "Detail": { "ID": 228463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8001452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281566", "Detail": { "ID": 281566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.148299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263081", "Detail": { "ID": 263081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6359534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288124", "Detail": { "ID": 288124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.907892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227501", "Detail": { "ID": 227501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5528614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269310", "Detail": { "ID": 269310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5420136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323019", "Detail": { "ID": 323019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7185087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295925", "Detail": { "ID": 295925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5416999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243137", "Detail": { "ID": 243137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0506822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227021", "Detail": { "ID": 227021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2640684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301087", "Detail": { "ID": 301087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0325833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238372", "Detail": { "ID": 238372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4436676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316919", "Detail": { "ID": 316919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1691048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326957", "Detail": { "ID": 326957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7874008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277577", "Detail": { "ID": 277577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9593049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263755", "Detail": { "ID": 263755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9033253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249375", "Detail": { "ID": 249375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9238858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294158", "Detail": { "ID": 294158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8853241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285431", "Detail": { "ID": 285431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3228046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231367", "Detail": { "ID": 231367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.591874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243581", "Detail": { "ID": 243581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3111029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254013", "Detail": { "ID": 254013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.030768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323409", "Detail": { "ID": 323409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9548801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300637", "Detail": { "ID": 300637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0071602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273129", "Detail": { "ID": 273129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3708285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262660", "Detail": { "ID": 262660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6114092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282316", "Detail": { "ID": 282316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4075567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298953", "Detail": { "ID": 298953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3794242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285048", "Detail": { "ID": 285048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0591957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219646", "Detail": { "ID": 219646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3083891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238177", "Detail": { "ID": 238177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2482484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226334", "Detail": { "ID": 226334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2268281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322276", "Detail": { "ID": 322276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6757944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292645", "Detail": { "ID": 292645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5517239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227674", "Detail": { "ID": 227674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5608024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304539", "Detail": { "ID": 304539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0426491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257909", "Detail": { "ID": 257909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0828075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271180", "Detail": { "ID": 271180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8458934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279381", "Detail": { "ID": 279381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4997534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266451", "Detail": { "ID": 266451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7416724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250727", "Detail": { "ID": 250727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2109827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221193", "Detail": { "ID": 221193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.679072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226418", "Detail": { "ID": 226418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2305227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239760", "Detail": { "ID": 239760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7577413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266702", "Detail": { "ID": 266702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.752854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324842", "Detail": { "ID": 324842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.240165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260942", "Detail": { "ID": 260942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1046339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246046", "Detail": { "ID": 246046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8698745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273534", "Detail": { "ID": 273534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6245285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301981", "Detail": { "ID": 301981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2919222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303628", "Detail": { "ID": 303628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8235054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223120", "Detail": { "ID": 223120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.229501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245633", "Detail": { "ID": 245633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8518461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223308", "Detail": { "ID": 223308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4522736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308383", "Detail": { "ID": 308383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.053578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272463", "Detail": { "ID": 272463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3364013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245147", "Detail": { "ID": 245147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5940711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315317", "Detail": { "ID": 315317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9064065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247394", "Detail": { "ID": 247394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4019333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275060", "Detail": { "ID": 275060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1394598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255087", "Detail": { "ID": 255087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2967274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277339", "Detail": { "ID": 277339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9439827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254036", "Detail": { "ID": 254036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0317593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278828", "Detail": { "ID": 278828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2359889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325289", "Detail": { "ID": 325289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4922817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231962", "Detail": { "ID": 231962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.623281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312355", "Detail": { "ID": 312355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1242553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233147", "Detail": { "ID": 233147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8988932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267759", "Detail": { "ID": 267759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0337682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314494", "Detail": { "ID": 314494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6424345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296650", "Detail": { "ID": 296650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8681037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319680", "Detail": { "ID": 319680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9367191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306168", "Detail": { "ID": 306168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3619031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310351", "Detail": { "ID": 310351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5667783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268681", "Detail": { "ID": 268681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2780883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293745", "Detail": { "ID": 293745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.867097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271487", "Detail": { "ID": 271487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0779478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269453", "Detail": { "ID": 269453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5482133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307244", "Detail": { "ID": 307244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8208625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280221", "Detail": { "ID": 280221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7512803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279096", "Detail": { "ID": 279096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2528426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260373", "Detail": { "ID": 260373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0740734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300008", "Detail": { "ID": 300008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7323436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301809", "Detail": { "ID": 301809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2841691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300308", "Detail": { "ID": 300308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9924198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224250", "Detail": { "ID": 224250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6908004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305699", "Detail": { "ID": 305699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3355984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321047", "Detail": { "ID": 321047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1999682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315765", "Detail": { "ID": 315765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.926036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237203", "Detail": { "ID": 237203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.194099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288841", "Detail": { "ID": 288841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1606882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234001", "Detail": { "ID": 234001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1557117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312868", "Detail": { "ID": 312868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1468441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261322", "Detail": { "ID": 261322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3523746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225633", "Detail": { "ID": 225633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9837374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265593", "Detail": { "ID": 265593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4458601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284154", "Detail": { "ID": 284154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7453284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258666", "Detail": { "ID": 258666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3173442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318266", "Detail": { "ID": 318266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6453644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256178", "Detail": { "ID": 256178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5739664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293379", "Detail": { "ID": 293379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8424777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235936", "Detail": { "ID": 235936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6993291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255960", "Detail": { "ID": 255960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5643461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229302", "Detail": { "ID": 229302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0708411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289457", "Detail": { "ID": 289457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.438067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311599", "Detail": { "ID": 311599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8858225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246909", "Detail": { "ID": 246909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1586891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297596", "Detail": { "ID": 297596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1069997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233782", "Detail": { "ID": 233782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1459618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274988", "Detail": { "ID": 274988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1362844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274145", "Detail": { "ID": 274145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6563968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317783", "Detail": { "ID": 317783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4371682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326541", "Detail": { "ID": 326541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7691209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241393", "Detail": { "ID": 241393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7560162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291122", "Detail": { "ID": 291122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7866454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248188", "Detail": { "ID": 248188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6350366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290023", "Detail": { "ID": 290023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4694631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222723", "Detail": { "ID": 222723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2013926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240882", "Detail": { "ID": 240882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3863277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283710", "Detail": { "ID": 283710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7199289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM252166", "Detail": { "ID": 252166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5054445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247251", "Detail": { "ID": 247251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3955166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309751", "Detail": { "ID": 309751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2134, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Future of the Defence Industry in Scotland", "Reference": "S4M-08348", "ID": 8465 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3433629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259249", "Detail": { "ID": 259249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6007264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318692", "Detail": { "ID": 318692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6693251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250215", "Detail": { "ID": 250215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1795938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321105", "Detail": { "ID": 321105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2024599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228464", "Detail": { "ID": 228464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8002075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281565", "Detail": { "ID": 281565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1482589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263082", "Detail": { "ID": 263082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.635995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288141", "Detail": { "ID": 288141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9086833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227502", "Detail": { "ID": 227502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5529021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269312", "Detail": { "ID": 269312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5420989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323020", "Detail": { "ID": 323020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.71855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295926", "Detail": { "ID": 295926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.54174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243138", "Detail": { "ID": 243138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0507241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227020", "Detail": { "ID": 227020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2640265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301086", "Detail": { "ID": 301086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0325324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238371", "Detail": { "ID": 238371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4436254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316918", "Detail": { "ID": 316918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1690436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326956", "Detail": { "ID": 326956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7873597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277578", "Detail": { "ID": 277578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9593452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263754", "Detail": { "ID": 263754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9032842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249374", "Detail": { "ID": 249374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9238448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294157", "Detail": { "ID": 294157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8851856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285432", "Detail": { "ID": 285432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3228457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231368", "Detail": { "ID": 231368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5919146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243580", "Detail": { "ID": 243580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3110603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254014", "Detail": { "ID": 254014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0308092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323408", "Detail": { "ID": 323408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9548384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300636", "Detail": { "ID": 300636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0071189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273130", "Detail": { "ID": 273130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.370888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262661", "Detail": { "ID": 262661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6114508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282317", "Detail": { "ID": 282317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4075992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298952", "Detail": { "ID": 298952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3793836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285031", "Detail": { "ID": 285031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0582545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219647", "Detail": { "ID": 219647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3084313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238178", "Detail": { "ID": 238178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.24829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226333", "Detail": { "ID": 226333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2267861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322275", "Detail": { "ID": 322275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6757531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292219", "Detail": { "ID": 292219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5243023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227675", "Detail": { "ID": 227675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.560845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304538", "Detail": { "ID": 304538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0425841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257910", "Detail": { "ID": 257910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0829342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271178", "Detail": { "ID": 271178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8458116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279382", "Detail": { "ID": 279382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5052542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266450", "Detail": { "ID": 266450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7416317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250728", "Detail": { "ID": 250728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2110224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221194", "Detail": { "ID": 221194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.679132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226417", "Detail": { "ID": 226417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2304815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239759", "Detail": { "ID": 239759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.757701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266703", "Detail": { "ID": 266703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7528951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324843", "Detail": { "ID": 324843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2402048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260941", "Detail": { "ID": 260941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1045917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246044", "Detail": { "ID": 246044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8697911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273533", "Detail": { "ID": 273533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6244845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301997", "Detail": { "ID": 301997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2926261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303629", "Detail": { "ID": 303629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8235475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223119", "Detail": { "ID": 223119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2294421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245632", "Detail": { "ID": 245632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8518055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223307", "Detail": { "ID": 223307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4522318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308382", "Detail": { "ID": 308382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0535373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272464", "Detail": { "ID": 272464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.336461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245148", "Detail": { "ID": 245148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5941129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315318", "Detail": { "ID": 315318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9064488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247396", "Detail": { "ID": 247396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4020149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275062", "Detail": { "ID": 275062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1395429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255089", "Detail": { "ID": 255089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2968671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277337", "Detail": { "ID": 277337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9439016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254034", "Detail": { "ID": 254034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0316763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278827", "Detail": { "ID": 278827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2359489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325288", "Detail": { "ID": 325288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4922394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231961", "Detail": { "ID": 231961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6232398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312354", "Detail": { "ID": 312354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1242146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233146", "Detail": { "ID": 233146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8988518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267758", "Detail": { "ID": 267758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0337274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314495", "Detail": { "ID": 314495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6424767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296651", "Detail": { "ID": 296651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8681443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319679", "Detail": { "ID": 319679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9366778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306167", "Detail": { "ID": 306167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3618618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309894", "Detail": { "ID": 309894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3555302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268682", "Detail": { "ID": 268682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.278129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293744", "Detail": { "ID": 293744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8670562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271486", "Detail": { "ID": 271486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0779061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269452", "Detail": { "ID": 269452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5481724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307384", "Detail": { "ID": 307384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8271284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280222", "Detail": { "ID": 280222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7513426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279095", "Detail": { "ID": 279095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.252801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260372", "Detail": { "ID": 260372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0740316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300009", "Detail": { "ID": 300009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7323852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302242", "Detail": { "ID": 302242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5159049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300193", "Detail": { "ID": 300193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7402902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224251", "Detail": { "ID": 224251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6908419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305700", "Detail": { "ID": 305700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3356395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321048", "Detail": { "ID": 321048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2000092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315764", "Detail": { "ID": 315764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9259956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237204", "Detail": { "ID": 237204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1941417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288840", "Detail": { "ID": 288840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1606473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234002", "Detail": { "ID": 234002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1557557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312867", "Detail": { "ID": 312867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1468029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261323", "Detail": { "ID": 261323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3524148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225634", "Detail": { "ID": 225634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9837973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265594", "Detail": { "ID": 265594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4459011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284153", "Detail": { "ID": 284153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7452873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258667", "Detail": { "ID": 258667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3173855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318267", "Detail": { "ID": 318267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6454248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256177", "Detail": { "ID": 256177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5739242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293966", "Detail": { "ID": 293966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8768436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235937", "Detail": { "ID": 235937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6993716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255959", "Detail": { "ID": 255959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5643054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229303", "Detail": { "ID": 229303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0708841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289458", "Detail": { "ID": 289458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4381075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311600", "Detail": { "ID": 311600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8859313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246910", "Detail": { "ID": 246910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1587324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297595", "Detail": { "ID": 297595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1069579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233781", "Detail": { "ID": 233781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1459201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274989", "Detail": { "ID": 274989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1363264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274144", "Detail": { "ID": 274144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6563558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317784", "Detail": { "ID": 317784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4372097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326542", "Detail": { "ID": 326542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7691622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241394", "Detail": { "ID": 241394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7560568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291123", "Detail": { "ID": 291123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7866859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248189", "Detail": { "ID": 248189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6350899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290024", "Detail": { "ID": 290024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4695041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222725", "Detail": { "ID": 222725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2014755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240881", "Detail": { "ID": 240881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3862872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283712", "Detail": { "ID": 283712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7200126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251704", "Detail": { "ID": 251704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4851369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247250", "Detail": { "ID": 247250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3954747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309752", "Detail": { "ID": 309752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2135, "AgendaID": 2221, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08327", "ID": 8443 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.343423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259232", "Detail": { "ID": 259232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6000034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318691", "Detail": { "ID": 318691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6692838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250214", "Detail": { "ID": 250214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1795321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321106", "Detail": { "ID": 321106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2025197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228483", "Detail": { "ID": 228483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8010142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281536", "Detail": { "ID": 281536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1470362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263083", "Detail": { "ID": 263083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6360364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288143", "Detail": { "ID": 288143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9087682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227503", "Detail": { "ID": 227503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5529605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269329", "Detail": { "ID": 269329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5428523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323048", "Detail": { "ID": 323048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7197814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295927", "Detail": { "ID": 295927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5417804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243139", "Detail": { "ID": 243139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0557766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227003", "Detail": { "ID": 227003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2632799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301085", "Detail": { "ID": 301085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.032461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238370", "Detail": { "ID": 238370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4435816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316737", "Detail": { "ID": 316737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1610464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326955", "Detail": { "ID": 326955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7873182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277579", "Detail": { "ID": 277579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9593853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263753", "Detail": { "ID": 263753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9032413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249365", "Detail": { "ID": 249365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9234496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294156", "Detail": { "ID": 294156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8851445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285433", "Detail": { "ID": 285433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3229161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231369", "Detail": { "ID": 231369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.591955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243579", "Detail": { "ID": 243579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.311008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254015", "Detail": { "ID": 254015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0308501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323407", "Detail": { "ID": 323407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9547967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292471", "Detail": { "ID": 292471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5352217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273131", "Detail": { "ID": 273131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.37093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262670", "Detail": { "ID": 262670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6118191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282346", "Detail": { "ID": 282346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4088635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298923", "Detail": { "ID": 298923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3781802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285029", "Detail": { "ID": 285029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0581716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219656", "Detail": { "ID": 219656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3088301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238195", "Detail": { "ID": 238195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4356808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226332", "Detail": { "ID": 226332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2267439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322247", "Detail": { "ID": 322247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6745316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292218", "Detail": { "ID": 292218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5242601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227684", "Detail": { "ID": 227684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5612339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304537", "Detail": { "ID": 304537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0425376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257911", "Detail": { "ID": 257911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0829926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271161", "Detail": { "ID": 271161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279411", "Detail": { "ID": 279411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5065559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266449", "Detail": { "ID": 266449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7415903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250729", "Detail": { "ID": 250729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2110813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221195", "Detail": { "ID": 221195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.679175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226408", "Detail": { "ID": 226408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2300811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239758", "Detail": { "ID": 239758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7576589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266887", "Detail": { "ID": 266887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7663159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324844", "Detail": { "ID": 324844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2402446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260932", "Detail": { "ID": 260932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1041992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246027", "Detail": { "ID": 246027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.869056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273532", "Detail": { "ID": 273532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6244427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301998", "Detail": { "ID": 301998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2926673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303630", "Detail": { "ID": 303630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8235887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223118", "Detail": { "ID": 223118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2294015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245631", "Detail": { "ID": 245631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8517642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223290", "Detail": { "ID": 223290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4474414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308353", "Detail": { "ID": 308353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0522895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272465", "Detail": { "ID": 272465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3365028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245149", "Detail": { "ID": 245149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.594154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315319", "Detail": { "ID": 315319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9064969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247413", "Detail": { "ID": 247413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.402754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275079", "Detail": { "ID": 275079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1402977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255106", "Detail": { "ID": 255106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2977457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277010", "Detail": { "ID": 277010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6972087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253549", "Detail": { "ID": 253549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0012051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278818", "Detail": { "ID": 278818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2355637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325287", "Detail": { "ID": 325287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4921798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231960", "Detail": { "ID": 231960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6231983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312325", "Detail": { "ID": 312325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1229512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233137", "Detail": { "ID": 233137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8984491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267729", "Detail": { "ID": 267729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0324845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314524", "Detail": { "ID": 314524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6437239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296679", "Detail": { "ID": 296679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.869316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319496", "Detail": { "ID": 319496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9284628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306166", "Detail": { "ID": 306166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3618212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309895", "Detail": { "ID": 309895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3555721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268711", "Detail": { "ID": 268711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2793891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293715", "Detail": { "ID": 293715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8658139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271485", "Detail": { "ID": 271485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.077865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269443", "Detail": { "ID": 269443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5477698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307383", "Detail": { "ID": 307383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.827087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280231", "Detail": { "ID": 280231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7517193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279094", "Detail": { "ID": 279094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2527599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260371", "Detail": { "ID": 260371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0739896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304823", "Detail": { "ID": 304823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0602522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302243", "Detail": { "ID": 302243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5159459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300192", "Detail": { "ID": 300192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7402497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224252", "Detail": { "ID": 224252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.690883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305701", "Detail": { "ID": 305701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3356803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321230", "Detail": { "ID": 321230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4192171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315763", "Detail": { "ID": 315763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9259549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237205", "Detail": { "ID": 237205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.194184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288839", "Detail": { "ID": 288839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.160607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234003", "Detail": { "ID": 234003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1559112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312866", "Detail": { "ID": 312866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1467613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261438", "Detail": { "ID": 261438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3573349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225651", "Detail": { "ID": 225651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9845187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265595", "Detail": { "ID": 265595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4459428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284144", "Detail": { "ID": 284144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7449133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258676", "Detail": { "ID": 258676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3177862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318451", "Detail": { "ID": 318451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6581329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256176", "Detail": { "ID": 256176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5738645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293967", "Detail": { "ID": 293967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8768858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235946", "Detail": { "ID": 235946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6997403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255958", "Detail": { "ID": 255958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5642651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229304", "Detail": { "ID": 229304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0709261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289459", "Detail": { "ID": 289459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4381487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311601", "Detail": { "ID": 311601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8859839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246911", "Detail": { "ID": 246911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1587738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297594", "Detail": { "ID": 297594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1069154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233780", "Detail": { "ID": 233780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1458772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274998", "Detail": { "ID": 274998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1367574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274115", "Detail": { "ID": 274115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6550852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317785", "Detail": { "ID": 317785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4372501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326543", "Detail": { "ID": 326543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7692036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241395", "Detail": { "ID": 241395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7560984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291124", "Detail": { "ID": 291124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7867263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248198", "Detail": { "ID": 248198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6355301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290032", "Detail": { "ID": 290032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4698526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222742", "Detail": { "ID": 222742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2023552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240880", "Detail": { "ID": 240880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3862462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283729", "Detail": { "ID": 283729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7207585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251684", "Detail": { "ID": 251684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.484286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247241", "Detail": { "ID": 247241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3950838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309781", "Detail": { "ID": 309781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2136, "AgendaID": 3035, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08326", "ID": 8442 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3446572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259256", "Detail": { "ID": 259256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6010367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318721", "Detail": { "ID": 318721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6705744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250221", "Detail": { "ID": 250221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1798445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321076", "Detail": { "ID": 321076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.201226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228438", "Detail": { "ID": 228438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7990576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281120", "Detail": { "ID": 281120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8068371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263054", "Detail": { "ID": 263054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6347695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288119", "Detail": { "ID": 288119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9009267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227457", "Detail": { "ID": 227457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5509857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269305", "Detail": { "ID": 269305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5417845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322446", "Detail": { "ID": 322446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.688976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295899", "Detail": { "ID": 295899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5406088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243108", "Detail": { "ID": 243108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0492385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227026", "Detail": { "ID": 227026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2642778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301035", "Detail": { "ID": 301035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0297778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238399", "Detail": { "ID": 238399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4448548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316394", "Detail": { "ID": 316394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1459921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326987", "Detail": { "ID": 326987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7887092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277550", "Detail": { "ID": 277550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9581654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263936", "Detail": { "ID": 263936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9171704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250936", "Detail": { "ID": 250936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2199706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294801", "Detail": { "ID": 294801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1789269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285405", "Detail": { "ID": 285405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3216085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231341", "Detail": { "ID": 231341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5907676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243610", "Detail": { "ID": 243610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3123288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254376", "Detail": { "ID": 254376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2530237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323438", "Detail": { "ID": 323438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9561626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300642", "Detail": { "ID": 300642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0073839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273102", "Detail": { "ID": 273102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3696716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262655", "Detail": { "ID": 262655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6111871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281774", "Detail": { "ID": 281774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1570593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298541", "Detail": { "ID": 298541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3505753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285053", "Detail": { "ID": 285053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0594028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219641", "Detail": { "ID": 219641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3081589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238172", "Detail": { "ID": 238172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2480227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226649", "Detail": { "ID": 226649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2406321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322015", "Detail": { "ID": 322015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4675936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292650", "Detail": { "ID": 292650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.55193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227669", "Detail": { "ID": 227669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5605746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304599", "Detail": { "ID": 304599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0453099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257904", "Detail": { "ID": 257904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0826032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271185", "Detail": { "ID": 271185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8461168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274352", "Detail": { "ID": 274352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1023496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266399", "Detail": { "ID": 266399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7391983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250722", "Detail": { "ID": 250722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2107823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221188", "Detail": { "ID": 221188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6788661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226423", "Detail": { "ID": 226423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2307526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239710", "Detail": { "ID": 239710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7555995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253211", "Detail": { "ID": 253211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9861763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324813", "Detail": { "ID": 324813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2389072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260947", "Detail": { "ID": 260947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1048394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246051", "Detail": { "ID": 246051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8700804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273561", "Detail": { "ID": 273561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6256974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301986", "Detail": { "ID": 301986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2921543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303680", "Detail": { "ID": 303680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8257196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223125", "Detail": { "ID": 223125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2297061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245638", "Detail": { "ID": 245638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8520723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223313", "Detail": { "ID": 223313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4525055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308124", "Detail": { "ID": 308124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8657534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272458", "Detail": { "ID": 272458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3361975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245119", "Detail": { "ID": 245119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5928562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315290", "Detail": { "ID": 315290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9052243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247389", "Detail": { "ID": 247389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4017273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275055", "Detail": { "ID": 275055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.13923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255082", "Detail": { "ID": 255082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2965215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277344", "Detail": { "ID": 277344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9442115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254041", "Detail": { "ID": 254041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.031966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278833", "Detail": { "ID": 278833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.236211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325319", "Detail": { "ID": 325319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4935573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231939", "Detail": { "ID": 231939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6222864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312123", "Detail": { "ID": 312123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9147171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233152", "Detail": { "ID": 233152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8991013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267566", "Detail": { "ID": 267566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.025388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313037", "Detail": { "ID": 313037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1609074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294375", "Detail": { "ID": 294375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1356238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319264", "Detail": { "ID": 319264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9125701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306195", "Detail": { "ID": 306195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3634651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310346", "Detail": { "ID": 310346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5665514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268038", "Detail": { "ID": 268038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0533075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293051", "Detail": { "ID": 293051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5695235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271492", "Detail": { "ID": 271492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0781544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269458", "Detail": { "ID": 269458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5484205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307249", "Detail": { "ID": 307249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8210721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280216", "Detail": { "ID": 280216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7510709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279123", "Detail": { "ID": 279123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2540238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260401", "Detail": { "ID": 260401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0752708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299276", "Detail": { "ID": 299276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6904991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301804", "Detail": { "ID": 301804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2839546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300313", "Detail": { "ID": 300313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9926615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224245", "Detail": { "ID": 224245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6905724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305672", "Detail": { "ID": 305672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3344537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320006", "Detail": { "ID": 320006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9573254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315793", "Detail": { "ID": 315793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9272614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237177", "Detail": { "ID": 237177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9690721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288867", "Detail": { "ID": 288867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1618043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234204", "Detail": { "ID": 234204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3666293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312896", "Detail": { "ID": 312896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1545458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261317", "Detail": { "ID": 261317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.352171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225628", "Detail": { "ID": 225628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9835332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265645", "Detail": { "ID": 265645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.448153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284159", "Detail": { "ID": 284159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7455549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258661", "Detail": { "ID": 258661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3171349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317229", "Detail": { "ID": 317229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.409358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256183", "Detail": { "ID": 256183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5741724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293374", "Detail": { "ID": 293374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8422687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235931", "Detail": { "ID": 235931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6991049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255909", "Detail": { "ID": 255909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.562201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229297", "Detail": { "ID": 229297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0706146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289509", "Detail": { "ID": 289509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4403193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311571", "Detail": { "ID": 311571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8846136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246904", "Detail": { "ID": 246904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1584505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297623", "Detail": { "ID": 297623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1081468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233808", "Detail": { "ID": 233808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1472177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274983", "Detail": { "ID": 274983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1360531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270042", "Detail": { "ID": 270042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5790392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317755", "Detail": { "ID": 317755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4359711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326511", "Detail": { "ID": 326511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7678349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241388", "Detail": { "ID": 241388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7558099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291094", "Detail": { "ID": 291094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7852673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248183", "Detail": { "ID": 248183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4468814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290018", "Detail": { "ID": 290018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4692378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222718", "Detail": { "ID": 222718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2011857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240887", "Detail": { "ID": 240887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.386553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283705", "Detail": { "ID": 283705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7196997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231069", "Detail": { "ID": 231069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3642859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247256", "Detail": { "ID": 247256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3957236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308866", "Detail": { "ID": 308866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2128, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.3", "ID": 8404 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0814415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259257", "Detail": { "ID": 259257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6010786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318722", "Detail": { "ID": 318722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6706172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250222", "Detail": { "ID": 250222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.179887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321075", "Detail": { "ID": 321075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2011832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228436", "Detail": { "ID": 228436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7989438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281121", "Detail": { "ID": 281121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8068782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263053", "Detail": { "ID": 263053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6347274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288118", "Detail": { "ID": 288118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9008551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227456", "Detail": { "ID": 227456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5509384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269304", "Detail": { "ID": 269304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5417422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322480", "Detail": { "ID": 322480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6904364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295898", "Detail": { "ID": 295898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5405479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243107", "Detail": { "ID": 243107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0491966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227027", "Detail": { "ID": 227027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2643383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301034", "Detail": { "ID": 301034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.029735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238400", "Detail": { "ID": 238400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.444915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316373", "Detail": { "ID": 316373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1450799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326988", "Detail": { "ID": 326988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7887513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277549", "Detail": { "ID": 277549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9581225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263937", "Detail": { "ID": 263937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9172134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250937", "Detail": { "ID": 250937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2200118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294802", "Detail": { "ID": 294802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1789888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285404", "Detail": { "ID": 285404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3215662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231340", "Detail": { "ID": 231340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5907248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243611", "Detail": { "ID": 243611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3123705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254377", "Detail": { "ID": 254377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2530673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323439", "Detail": { "ID": 323439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9562046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300643", "Detail": { "ID": 300643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0074252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273101", "Detail": { "ID": 273101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3696292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262654", "Detail": { "ID": 262654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6111461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281773", "Detail": { "ID": 281773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1570002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298507", "Detail": { "ID": 298507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3491122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285054", "Detail": { "ID": 285054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0594447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219640", "Detail": { "ID": 219640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3081163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238171", "Detail": { "ID": 238171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2479804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226650", "Detail": { "ID": 226650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2406735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321980", "Detail": { "ID": 321980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4597249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292651", "Detail": { "ID": 292651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.551972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227668", "Detail": { "ID": 227668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5605328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304598", "Detail": { "ID": 304598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.045269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257903", "Detail": { "ID": 257903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0825625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271186", "Detail": { "ID": 271186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8461584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274351", "Detail": { "ID": 274351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1023056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266398", "Detail": { "ID": 266398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.739138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250721", "Detail": { "ID": 250721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2107423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221187", "Detail": { "ID": 221187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6788245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226424", "Detail": { "ID": 226424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2307946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239709", "Detail": { "ID": 239709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7555587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253209", "Detail": { "ID": 253209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.986093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324812", "Detail": { "ID": 324812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2388662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260948", "Detail": { "ID": 260948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.104881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246052", "Detail": { "ID": 246052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8701226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273562", "Detail": { "ID": 273562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6257575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301987", "Detail": { "ID": 301987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2921957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303681", "Detail": { "ID": 303681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8257612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223126", "Detail": { "ID": 223126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2297467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245639", "Detail": { "ID": 245639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8521136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223314", "Detail": { "ID": 223314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4525486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308089", "Detail": { "ID": 308089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8642371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272457", "Detail": { "ID": 272457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3361555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245118", "Detail": { "ID": 245118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.592814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315289", "Detail": { "ID": 315289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9051821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247388", "Detail": { "ID": 247388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4016842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275054", "Detail": { "ID": 275054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1391883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255081", "Detail": { "ID": 255081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2964659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277345", "Detail": { "ID": 277345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.944253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254042", "Detail": { "ID": 254042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0320078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278834", "Detail": { "ID": 278834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2362533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325320", "Detail": { "ID": 325320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4936185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231938", "Detail": { "ID": 231938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6222444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311781", "Detail": { "ID": 311781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8939983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233153", "Detail": { "ID": 233153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8991429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267567", "Detail": { "ID": 267567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0254299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313071", "Detail": { "ID": 313071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1623799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294410", "Detail": { "ID": 294410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1371376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319229", "Detail": { "ID": 319229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9110282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306196", "Detail": { "ID": 306196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3635227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310345", "Detail": { "ID": 310345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5665099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268037", "Detail": { "ID": 268037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0532654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293016", "Detail": { "ID": 293016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5680022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271493", "Detail": { "ID": 271493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0781961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269459", "Detail": { "ID": 269459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5484821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307250", "Detail": { "ID": 307250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.821114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280215", "Detail": { "ID": 280215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7510286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279124", "Detail": { "ID": 279124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.254066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260402", "Detail": { "ID": 260402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0753297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299311", "Detail": { "ID": 299311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6919974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301803", "Detail": { "ID": 301803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2839129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300314", "Detail": { "ID": 300314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9927029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224244", "Detail": { "ID": 224244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6905302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305671", "Detail": { "ID": 305671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3343934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320041", "Detail": { "ID": 320041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9588524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315794", "Detail": { "ID": 315794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9273045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237176", "Detail": { "ID": 237176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9690317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288868", "Detail": { "ID": 288868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1618455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234205", "Detail": { "ID": 234205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.366683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312897", "Detail": { "ID": 312897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1545878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261316", "Detail": { "ID": 261316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3521297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225627", "Detail": { "ID": 225627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9834915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265646", "Detail": { "ID": 265646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4481956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284160", "Detail": { "ID": 284160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7455979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258660", "Detail": { "ID": 258660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3170747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317264", "Detail": { "ID": 317264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4109339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256184", "Detail": { "ID": 256184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.574214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293373", "Detail": { "ID": 293373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8422274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235930", "Detail": { "ID": 235930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6990625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255908", "Detail": { "ID": 255908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5621596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229296", "Detail": { "ID": 229296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0705713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289510", "Detail": { "ID": 289510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.440363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311570", "Detail": { "ID": 311570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8845711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246903", "Detail": { "ID": 246903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1584048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297624", "Detail": { "ID": 297624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.108188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233809", "Detail": { "ID": 233809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1472591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274982", "Detail": { "ID": 274982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1360103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270043", "Detail": { "ID": 270043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5790808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317754", "Detail": { "ID": 317754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4359299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326510", "Detail": { "ID": 326510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7677923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241387", "Detail": { "ID": 241387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7557664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291093", "Detail": { "ID": 291093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7852258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248182", "Detail": { "ID": 248182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4468221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290017", "Detail": { "ID": 290017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4691959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222717", "Detail": { "ID": 222717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2011429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240888", "Detail": { "ID": 240888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3865947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283704", "Detail": { "ID": 283704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.719658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231071", "Detail": { "ID": 231071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3643684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247257", "Detail": { "ID": 247257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3957655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308901", "Detail": { "ID": 308901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2130, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270.1", "ID": 8400 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0829645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259255", "Detail": { "ID": 259255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6009948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318720", "Detail": { "ID": 318720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6705136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250220", "Detail": { "ID": 250220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1798029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321077", "Detail": { "ID": 321077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2012675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228458", "Detail": { "ID": 228458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7999395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281151", "Detail": { "ID": 281151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8081518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263055", "Detail": { "ID": 263055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6348326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288120", "Detail": { "ID": 288120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9009697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227458", "Detail": { "ID": 227458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5510265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269306", "Detail": { "ID": 269306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5418264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322447", "Detail": { "ID": 322447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.689018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295900", "Detail": { "ID": 295900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.540652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243109", "Detail": { "ID": 243109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0492988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227025", "Detail": { "ID": 227025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.264236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301036", "Detail": { "ID": 301036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0298206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238398", "Detail": { "ID": 238398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4448132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316392", "Detail": { "ID": 316392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1459082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326986", "Detail": { "ID": 326986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7886677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277551", "Detail": { "ID": 277551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9582066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263935", "Detail": { "ID": 263935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9171285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250935", "Detail": { "ID": 250935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.219929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294800", "Detail": { "ID": 294800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1788854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285406", "Detail": { "ID": 285406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3216507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231342", "Detail": { "ID": 231342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5908099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243609", "Detail": { "ID": 243609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3122688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254375", "Detail": { "ID": 254375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2529598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323437", "Detail": { "ID": 323437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9561196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300641", "Detail": { "ID": 300641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0073417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273103", "Detail": { "ID": 273103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3697135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262656", "Detail": { "ID": 262656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6112283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281742", "Detail": { "ID": 281742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1557139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298537", "Detail": { "ID": 298537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3504061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285052", "Detail": { "ID": 285052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0593612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219642", "Detail": { "ID": 219642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3082009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238173", "Detail": { "ID": 238173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2480645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226648", "Detail": { "ID": 226648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2405907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322013", "Detail": { "ID": 322013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.46751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292649", "Detail": { "ID": 292649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.551888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227670", "Detail": { "ID": 227670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.560616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304600", "Detail": { "ID": 304600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0453507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257905", "Detail": { "ID": 257905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0826444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271184", "Detail": { "ID": 271184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8460758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274322", "Detail": { "ID": 274322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0955986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266400", "Detail": { "ID": 266400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7392421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250723", "Detail": { "ID": 250723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.210823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221189", "Detail": { "ID": 221189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.678908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226422", "Detail": { "ID": 226422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2307094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239711", "Detail": { "ID": 239711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7556406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253180", "Detail": { "ID": 253180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7701227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324814", "Detail": { "ID": 324814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2389681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260946", "Detail": { "ID": 260946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1047976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246050", "Detail": { "ID": 246050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8700389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273560", "Detail": { "ID": 273560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6256554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301985", "Detail": { "ID": 301985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2921121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303679", "Detail": { "ID": 303679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8256774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223124", "Detail": { "ID": 223124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2296653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245637", "Detail": { "ID": 245637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8520307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223312", "Detail": { "ID": 223312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4524412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308120", "Detail": { "ID": 308120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8655854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272459", "Detail": { "ID": 272459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.336239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245120", "Detail": { "ID": 245120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5928979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315291", "Detail": { "ID": 315291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9052662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247390", "Detail": { "ID": 247390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4017691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275056", "Detail": { "ID": 275056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1392736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255083", "Detail": { "ID": 255083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2965639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277343", "Detail": { "ID": 277343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9441692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254040", "Detail": { "ID": 254040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0319242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278832", "Detail": { "ID": 278832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2361513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325318", "Detail": { "ID": 325318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4935158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231940", "Detail": { "ID": 231940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6223285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312119", "Detail": { "ID": 312119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9145318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233151", "Detail": { "ID": 233151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8990593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267596", "Detail": { "ID": 267596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0266996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313041", "Detail": { "ID": 313041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1610741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294379", "Detail": { "ID": 294379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1358096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319262", "Detail": { "ID": 319262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9124617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306194", "Detail": { "ID": 306194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3634094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310347", "Detail": { "ID": 310347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5666124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268008", "Detail": { "ID": 268008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.052016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293047", "Detail": { "ID": 293047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5693367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271491", "Detail": { "ID": 271491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0781119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269457", "Detail": { "ID": 269457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5483785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307248", "Detail": { "ID": 307248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8210298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280217", "Detail": { "ID": 280217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7511131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279122", "Detail": { "ID": 279122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2539804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260400", "Detail": { "ID": 260400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0752291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299280", "Detail": { "ID": 299280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6906671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301805", "Detail": { "ID": 301805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.283996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300312", "Detail": { "ID": 300312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9926196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224246", "Detail": { "ID": 224246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.690633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305673", "Detail": { "ID": 305673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3344977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320008", "Detail": { "ID": 320008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9574107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315792", "Detail": { "ID": 315792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9272017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237178", "Detail": { "ID": 237178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9691126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288866", "Detail": { "ID": 288866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1617621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234203", "Detail": { "ID": 234203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3665754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312895", "Detail": { "ID": 312895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1545036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261318", "Detail": { "ID": 261318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3522128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225629", "Detail": { "ID": 225629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9835747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265644", "Detail": { "ID": 265644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4481114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284158", "Detail": { "ID": 284158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7455134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258662", "Detail": { "ID": 258662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3171782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317231", "Detail": { "ID": 317231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4094848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256182", "Detail": { "ID": 256182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5741315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293375", "Detail": { "ID": 293375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8423105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235932", "Detail": { "ID": 235932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6991465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255910", "Detail": { "ID": 255910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5622419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229298", "Detail": { "ID": 229298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0706566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289508", "Detail": { "ID": 289508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4402568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311572", "Detail": { "ID": 311572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.884656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246905", "Detail": { "ID": 246905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1584922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297622", "Detail": { "ID": 297622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1081054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233807", "Detail": { "ID": 233807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.147176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274984", "Detail": { "ID": 274984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1360946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270072", "Detail": { "ID": 270072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5803351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317756", "Detail": { "ID": 317756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4360124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326512", "Detail": { "ID": 326512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7678764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241389", "Detail": { "ID": 241389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7558518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291095", "Detail": { "ID": 291095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7853446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248184", "Detail": { "ID": 248184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6347999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290019", "Detail": { "ID": 290019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4692792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222719", "Detail": { "ID": 222719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2012281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240886", "Detail": { "ID": 240886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3865112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283706", "Detail": { "ID": 283706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7197613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231049", "Detail": { "ID": 231049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3634323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247255", "Detail": { "ID": 247255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3956818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308870", "Detail": { "ID": 308870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2129, "AgendaID": 2846, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 39, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Modernising Scotland’s Transport Infrastructure, Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century", "Reference": "S4M-08270", "ID": 8386 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0816115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259194", "Detail": { "ID": 259194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5981208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318724", "Detail": { "ID": 318724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6707076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250265", "Detail": { "ID": 250265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.181743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321073", "Detail": { "ID": 321073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2010793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228434", "Detail": { "ID": 228434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7988608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281123", "Detail": { "ID": 281123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.806978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263051", "Detail": { "ID": 263051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6346419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289002", "Detail": { "ID": 289002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1678347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227454", "Detail": { "ID": 227454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5508558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269677", "Detail": { "ID": 269677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5582522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322477", "Detail": { "ID": 322477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.690312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295896", "Detail": { "ID": 295896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.540466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243105", "Detail": { "ID": 243105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0491143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227071", "Detail": { "ID": 227071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2662568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301032", "Detail": { "ID": 301032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0296293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238402", "Detail": { "ID": 238402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4449992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316376", "Detail": { "ID": 316376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1452044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326990", "Detail": { "ID": 326990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7888346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277547", "Detail": { "ID": 277547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.958021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263939", "Detail": { "ID": 263939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9172959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250981", "Detail": { "ID": 250981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2218576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294804", "Detail": { "ID": 294804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1790731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285402", "Detail": { "ID": 285402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3214814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231338", "Detail": { "ID": 231338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5906167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243613", "Detail": { "ID": 243613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3124512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254379", "Detail": { "ID": 254379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2531508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323441", "Detail": { "ID": 323441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9562891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300689", "Detail": { "ID": 300689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0093882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273099", "Detail": { "ID": 273099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.369544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262611", "Detail": { "ID": 262611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6093217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281771", "Detail": { "ID": 281771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1569196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298509", "Detail": { "ID": 298509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3491944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284916", "Detail": { "ID": 284916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0532174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219594", "Detail": { "ID": 219594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.306117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238234", "Detail": { "ID": 238234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4376046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226692", "Detail": { "ID": 226692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2424804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321983", "Detail": { "ID": 321983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4598539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292653", "Detail": { "ID": 292653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5520544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227622", "Detail": { "ID": 227622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.558082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304596", "Detail": { "ID": 304596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0451866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257861", "Detail": { "ID": 257861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0807569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271048", "Detail": { "ID": 271048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8402772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274349", "Detail": { "ID": 274349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1021803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266088", "Detail": { "ID": 266088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4738302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250678", "Detail": { "ID": 250678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2088743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221144", "Detail": { "ID": 221144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6769624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226470", "Detail": { "ID": 226470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2327909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239707", "Detail": { "ID": 239707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7554752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253207", "Detail": { "ID": 253207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9859849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324810", "Detail": { "ID": 324810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2387845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261610", "Detail": { "ID": 261610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3649008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239509", "Detail": { "ID": 239509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7468443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273564", "Detail": { "ID": 273564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6258404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302649", "Detail": { "ID": 302649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5337655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303683", "Detail": { "ID": 303683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8258641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223170", "Detail": { "ID": 223170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2316266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245681", "Detail": { "ID": 245681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8539007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223358", "Detail": { "ID": 223358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4544452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308091", "Detail": { "ID": 308091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8643198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272414", "Detail": { "ID": 272414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3343103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245116", "Detail": { "ID": 245116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5927297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315287", "Detail": { "ID": 315287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9050981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247452", "Detail": { "ID": 247452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4044078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275502", "Detail": { "ID": 275502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3780168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255454", "Detail": { "ID": 255454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5320378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276897", "Detail": { "ID": 276897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6858122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253510", "Detail": { "ID": 253510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9995381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279185", "Detail": { "ID": 279185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2566799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325322", "Detail": { "ID": 325322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.493704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231936", "Detail": { "ID": 231936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6221582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311783", "Detail": { "ID": 311783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8941006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233198", "Detail": { "ID": 233198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9010976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267569", "Detail": { "ID": 267569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0255347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313069", "Detail": { "ID": 313069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1622962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294408", "Detail": { "ID": 294408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1370336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319232", "Detail": { "ID": 319232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.911181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306198", "Detail": { "ID": 306198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5416418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310343", "Detail": { "ID": 310343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5664263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268035", "Detail": { "ID": 268035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0531808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293018", "Detail": { "ID": 293018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5681042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271848", "Detail": { "ID": 271848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0940332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269813", "Detail": { "ID": 269813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5640425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307252", "Detail": { "ID": 307252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8212183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280176", "Detail": { "ID": 280176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.54468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279126", "Detail": { "ID": 279126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2541552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260404", "Detail": { "ID": 260404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0754143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299309", "Detail": { "ID": 299309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6919141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301801", "Detail": { "ID": 301801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2838299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300316", "Detail": { "ID": 300316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9929412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224201", "Detail": { "ID": 224201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4969273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305669", "Detail": { "ID": 305669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3343104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320038", "Detail": { "ID": 320038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.958729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315796", "Detail": { "ID": 315796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9273873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237174", "Detail": { "ID": 237174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9689502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288870", "Detail": { "ID": 288870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1619274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234207", "Detail": { "ID": 234207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3667881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312899", "Detail": { "ID": 312899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1546707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261314", "Detail": { "ID": 261314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3520277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225583", "Detail": { "ID": 225583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9816027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265648", "Detail": { "ID": 265648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4482776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284206", "Detail": { "ID": 284206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0160231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252128", "Detail": { "ID": 252128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5037854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317261", "Detail": { "ID": 317261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4107882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256686", "Detail": { "ID": 256686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7933656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293371", "Detail": { "ID": 293371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8421241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235885", "Detail": { "ID": 235885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6971346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255906", "Detail": { "ID": 255906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5620591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228639", "Detail": { "ID": 228639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8077862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289512", "Detail": { "ID": 289512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4404461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311568", "Detail": { "ID": 311568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8844853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246861", "Detail": { "ID": 246861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1565478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297626", "Detail": { "ID": 297626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.10827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233811", "Detail": { "ID": 233811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1473442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274938", "Detail": { "ID": 274938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.128512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270045", "Detail": { "ID": 270045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5791637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317752", "Detail": { "ID": 317752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4358473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326508", "Detail": { "ID": 326508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7677063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241345", "Detail": { "ID": 241345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7539359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291091", "Detail": { "ID": 291091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7851434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248137", "Detail": { "ID": 248137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4443357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289203", "Detail": { "ID": 289203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4267509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222673", "Detail": { "ID": 222673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.199032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240930", "Detail": { "ID": 240930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.388527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283995", "Detail": { "ID": 283995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7324421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231073", "Detail": { "ID": 231073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3644494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247301", "Detail": { "ID": 247301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3976842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308899", "Detail": { "ID": 308899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2126, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 35, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-08240", "ID": 8356 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0828805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259200", "Detail": { "ID": 259200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5984987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319535", "Detail": { "ID": 319535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.930148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250269", "Detail": { "ID": 250269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1819254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320896", "Detail": { "ID": 320896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1863392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228403", "Detail": { "ID": 228403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7975025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281098", "Detail": { "ID": 281098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8059066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263047", "Detail": { "ID": 263047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6344762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288996", "Detail": { "ID": 288996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1675671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230539", "Detail": { "ID": 230539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3347525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269671", "Detail": { "ID": 269671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.557979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322479", "Detail": { "ID": 322479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6903947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295892", "Detail": { "ID": 295892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.540306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243064", "Detail": { "ID": 243064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0473599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227075", "Detail": { "ID": 227075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2664225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301028", "Detail": { "ID": 301028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0294658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238406", "Detail": { "ID": 238406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4451631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316374", "Detail": { "ID": 316374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1451218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327031", "Detail": { "ID": 327031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7906125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277543", "Detail": { "ID": 277543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9578597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263943", "Detail": { "ID": 263943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9174782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250985", "Detail": { "ID": 250985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2220198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294847", "Detail": { "ID": 294847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1809267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285398", "Detail": { "ID": 285398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3213163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231334", "Detail": { "ID": 231334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5904546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243654", "Detail": { "ID": 243654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3141805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254446", "Detail": { "ID": 254446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2564554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323483", "Detail": { "ID": 323483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9583029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300693", "Detail": { "ID": 300693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0095484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273095", "Detail": { "ID": 273095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3693634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262607", "Detail": { "ID": 262607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6091611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281795", "Detail": { "ID": 281795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1579201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298486", "Detail": { "ID": 298486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3482101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231140", "Detail": { "ID": 231140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3673132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284922", "Detail": { "ID": 284922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0534646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219590", "Detail": { "ID": 219590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3059314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238228", "Detail": { "ID": 238228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4373527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226696", "Detail": { "ID": 226696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2426434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321981", "Detail": { "ID": 321981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4597655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292657", "Detail": { "ID": 292657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5522398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227618", "Detail": { "ID": 227618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5578629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304591", "Detail": { "ID": 304591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0449662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257857", "Detail": { "ID": 257857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0805951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271054", "Detail": { "ID": 271054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8405394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274375", "Detail": { "ID": 274375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1033527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287384", "Detail": { "ID": 287384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8618973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250674", "Detail": { "ID": 250674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2086367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221140", "Detail": { "ID": 221140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6767801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226474", "Detail": { "ID": 226474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.232976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252812", "Detail": { "ID": 252812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7543127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253234", "Detail": { "ID": 253234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9872606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324768", "Detail": { "ID": 324768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2370217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261614", "Detail": { "ID": 261614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3650618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239515", "Detail": { "ID": 239515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7471032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273568", "Detail": { "ID": 273568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.626003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302653", "Detail": { "ID": 302653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5339264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303687", "Detail": { "ID": 303687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8260285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223174", "Detail": { "ID": 223174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2318163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245685", "Detail": { "ID": 245685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8540609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223362", "Detail": { "ID": 223362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4546078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307915", "Detail": { "ID": 307915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8564208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272409", "Detail": { "ID": 272409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3340857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245075", "Detail": { "ID": 245075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5909292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315244", "Detail": { "ID": 315244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9001451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247446", "Detail": { "ID": 247446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4041657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275496", "Detail": { "ID": 275496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3777724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255448", "Detail": { "ID": 255448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5317739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276903", "Detail": { "ID": 276903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6860568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253516", "Detail": { "ID": 253516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9997842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279189", "Detail": { "ID": 279189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2568627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325363", "Detail": { "ID": 325363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4954667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233302", "Detail": { "ID": 233302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1181967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311759", "Detail": { "ID": 311759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8930374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233202", "Detail": { "ID": 233202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1137212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267543", "Detail": { "ID": 267543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0243759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313401", "Detail": { "ID": 313401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3937832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294431", "Detail": { "ID": 294431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1380405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319230", "Detail": { "ID": 319230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9110964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306242", "Detail": { "ID": 306242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5436525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310356", "Detail": { "ID": 310356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.566985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268061", "Detail": { "ID": 268061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0543215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292995", "Detail": { "ID": 292995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5671211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271853", "Detail": { "ID": 271853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0942547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269817", "Detail": { "ID": 269817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5642073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307239", "Detail": { "ID": 307239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8206322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280172", "Detail": { "ID": 280172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5445186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279130", "Detail": { "ID": 279130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2543186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260446", "Detail": { "ID": 260446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0772311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299332", "Detail": { "ID": 299332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6929026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301797", "Detail": { "ID": 301797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2836486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300320", "Detail": { "ID": 300320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9931102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224197", "Detail": { "ID": 224197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4967631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305625", "Detail": { "ID": 305625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.332421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320040", "Detail": { "ID": 320040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.95881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315838", "Detail": { "ID": 315838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.929243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237170", "Detail": { "ID": 237170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9687708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288874", "Detail": { "ID": 288874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1620884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234274", "Detail": { "ID": 234274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.370206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313098", "Detail": { "ID": 313098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1635652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261310", "Detail": { "ID": 261310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3518662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225579", "Detail": { "ID": 225579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9814157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265714", "Detail": { "ID": 265714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4511836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284210", "Detail": { "ID": 284210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0162105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252124", "Detail": { "ID": 252124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.503623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317263", "Detail": { "ID": 317263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4108917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256690", "Detail": { "ID": 256690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7935277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293367", "Detail": { "ID": 293367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8419605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235881", "Detail": { "ID": 235881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6969527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258051", "Detail": { "ID": 258051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0892589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228635", "Detail": { "ID": 228635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8076023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289516", "Detail": { "ID": 289516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.440608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311525", "Detail": { "ID": 311525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8826193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246857", "Detail": { "ID": 246857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1563672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297630", "Detail": { "ID": 297630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1084508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233815", "Detail": { "ID": 233815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1475313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274934", "Detail": { "ID": 274934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1283459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270019", "Detail": { "ID": 270019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5780442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317710", "Detail": { "ID": 317710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4340692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326467", "Detail": { "ID": 326467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7659555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241341", "Detail": { "ID": 241341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7537537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290435", "Detail": { "ID": 290435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7469719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248133", "Detail": { "ID": 248133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4441296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289199", "Detail": { "ID": 289199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4264257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222669", "Detail": { "ID": 222669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1988524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240934", "Detail": { "ID": 240934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3886902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283989", "Detail": { "ID": 283989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7321767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231104", "Detail": { "ID": 231104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3657928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247305", "Detail": { "ID": 247305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.397868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308922", "Detail": { "ID": 308922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2124, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 42, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173.2", "ID": 8312 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0838703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259197", "Detail": { "ID": 259197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5983393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319534", "Detail": { "ID": 319534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9301077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250268", "Detail": { "ID": 250268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1818834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320897", "Detail": { "ID": 320897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1863809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228431", "Detail": { "ID": 228431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7987347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281132", "Detail": { "ID": 281132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8073432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263048", "Detail": { "ID": 263048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6345176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288999", "Detail": { "ID": 288999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1677124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227451", "Detail": { "ID": 227451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5507345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269674", "Detail": { "ID": 269674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5581295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322467", "Detail": { "ID": 322467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6898841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295893", "Detail": { "ID": 295893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5403463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243065", "Detail": { "ID": 243065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0474194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227074", "Detail": { "ID": 227074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2663819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301029", "Detail": { "ID": 301029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0295067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238405", "Detail": { "ID": 238405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4451228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316379", "Detail": { "ID": 316379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1453267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327030", "Detail": { "ID": 327030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7905711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277544", "Detail": { "ID": 277544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9578998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263942", "Detail": { "ID": 263942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9174375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250984", "Detail": { "ID": 250984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2219794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294846", "Detail": { "ID": 294846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1808846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285399", "Detail": { "ID": 285399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3213574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231335", "Detail": { "ID": 231335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5904955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243653", "Detail": { "ID": 243653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3141388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254382", "Detail": { "ID": 254382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2532734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323482", "Detail": { "ID": 323482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9582622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300692", "Detail": { "ID": 300692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.009508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273096", "Detail": { "ID": 273096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3694035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262608", "Detail": { "ID": 262608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6092016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281762", "Detail": { "ID": 281762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1565377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298518", "Detail": { "ID": 298518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3495832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230640", "Detail": { "ID": 230640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3388771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284919", "Detail": { "ID": 284919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0533406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219591", "Detail": { "ID": 219591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3059915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238231", "Detail": { "ID": 238231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4374804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226695", "Detail": { "ID": 226695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2426029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321993", "Detail": { "ID": 321993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4602876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292656", "Detail": { "ID": 292656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5521982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227619", "Detail": { "ID": 227619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5579025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304593", "Detail": { "ID": 304593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0450474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257858", "Detail": { "ID": 257858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0806361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271051", "Detail": { "ID": 271051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8403981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274340", "Detail": { "ID": 274340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0963871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266085", "Detail": { "ID": 266085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.473709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250675", "Detail": { "ID": 250675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2086762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221141", "Detail": { "ID": 221141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6768384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226473", "Detail": { "ID": 226473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2329337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239704", "Detail": { "ID": 239704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7553523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253198", "Detail": { "ID": 253198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9855536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324769", "Detail": { "ID": 324769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.237062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261613", "Detail": { "ID": 261613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3650212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239512", "Detail": { "ID": 239512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7469833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273567", "Detail": { "ID": 273567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6259628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302652", "Detail": { "ID": 302652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5338866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303686", "Detail": { "ID": 303686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.825987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223173", "Detail": { "ID": 223173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2317533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245684", "Detail": { "ID": 245684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.854021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223361", "Detail": { "ID": 223361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4545668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308101", "Detail": { "ID": 308101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8647531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272410", "Detail": { "ID": 272410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3341467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245076", "Detail": { "ID": 245076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5909696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315245", "Detail": { "ID": 315245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9001858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247449", "Detail": { "ID": 247449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4042869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275499", "Detail": { "ID": 275499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.377895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255451", "Detail": { "ID": 255451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5319142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276900", "Detail": { "ID": 276900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6859358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253513", "Detail": { "ID": 253513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9996614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279188", "Detail": { "ID": 279188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2568203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325362", "Detail": { "ID": 325362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4954068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231933", "Detail": { "ID": 231933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6220156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311792", "Detail": { "ID": 311792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8944712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233201", "Detail": { "ID": 233201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1136688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267578", "Detail": { "ID": 267578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0259055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313060", "Detail": { "ID": 313060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.161899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294399", "Detail": { "ID": 294399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1366658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319242", "Detail": { "ID": 319242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9116169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306241", "Detail": { "ID": 306241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5436117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310340", "Detail": { "ID": 310340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5663049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268026", "Detail": { "ID": 268026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0527823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293027", "Detail": { "ID": 293027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5684732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271852", "Detail": { "ID": 271852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0942145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269816", "Detail": { "ID": 269816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5641665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307255", "Detail": { "ID": 307255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8213412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280173", "Detail": { "ID": 280173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5445587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279129", "Detail": { "ID": 279129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2542783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260445", "Detail": { "ID": 260445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0771884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299299", "Detail": { "ID": 299299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.691486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301798", "Detail": { "ID": 301798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2836891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300319", "Detail": { "ID": 300319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9930685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224198", "Detail": { "ID": 224198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4968042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305626", "Detail": { "ID": 305626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3324615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320028", "Detail": { "ID": 320028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.958296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315837", "Detail": { "ID": 315837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9292008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237171", "Detail": { "ID": 237171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9688295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288873", "Detail": { "ID": 288873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1620477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234210", "Detail": { "ID": 234210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3670091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313097", "Detail": { "ID": 313097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1635243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261311", "Detail": { "ID": 261311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3519063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225580", "Detail": { "ID": 225580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9814797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265651", "Detail": { "ID": 265651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4484192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284209", "Detail": { "ID": 284209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.016147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252125", "Detail": { "ID": 252125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5036635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317251", "Detail": { "ID": 317251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4103527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256689", "Detail": { "ID": 256689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7934876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293368", "Detail": { "ID": 293368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8420012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235882", "Detail": { "ID": 235882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6970113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255903", "Detail": { "ID": 255903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5619386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228636", "Detail": { "ID": 228636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8076618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289515", "Detail": { "ID": 289515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4405675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311526", "Detail": { "ID": 311526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8826606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246858", "Detail": { "ID": 246858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.156407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297629", "Detail": { "ID": 297629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1084103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233814", "Detail": { "ID": 233814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1474896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274935", "Detail": { "ID": 274935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1283865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270054", "Detail": { "ID": 270054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5795536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317711", "Detail": { "ID": 317711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4341095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326468", "Detail": { "ID": 326468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7659958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241342", "Detail": { "ID": 241342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.753794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290436", "Detail": { "ID": 290436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7470129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248134", "Detail": { "ID": 248134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4441813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289200", "Detail": { "ID": 289200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4264793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222670", "Detail": { "ID": 222670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.198893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240933", "Detail": { "ID": 240933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3886491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283992", "Detail": { "ID": 283992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7323185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231076", "Detail": { "ID": 231076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3645888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247304", "Detail": { "ID": 247304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3978275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308889", "Detail": { "ID": 308889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2125, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 60, "VoteAgainst": 43, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transport", "Reference": "S4M-08173", "ID": 8291 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0824482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259196", "Detail": { "ID": 259196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5982464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318717", "Detail": { "ID": 318717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6703917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250267", "Detail": { "ID": 250267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1818246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321080", "Detail": { "ID": 321080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2013914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228432", "Detail": { "ID": 228432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7987769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281125", "Detail": { "ID": 281125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8070606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263049", "Detail": { "ID": 263049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6345589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289000", "Detail": { "ID": 289000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1677537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227452", "Detail": { "ID": 227452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5507748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269675", "Detail": { "ID": 269675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5581708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322475", "Detail": { "ID": 322475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.690231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295894", "Detail": { "ID": 295894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5403861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243073", "Detail": { "ID": 243073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0477498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227073", "Detail": { "ID": 227073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2663406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301030", "Detail": { "ID": 301030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0295472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238404", "Detail": { "ID": 238404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4450815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316378", "Detail": { "ID": 316378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1452857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326983", "Detail": { "ID": 326983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7885432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277545", "Detail": { "ID": 277545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9579406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263941", "Detail": { "ID": 263941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9173964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250983", "Detail": { "ID": 250983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2219388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294838", "Detail": { "ID": 294838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.180534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285400", "Detail": { "ID": 285400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3213986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231336", "Detail": { "ID": 231336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5905357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243645", "Detail": { "ID": 243645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3137979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254381", "Detail": { "ID": 254381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2532329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323434", "Detail": { "ID": 323434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9559945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300691", "Detail": { "ID": 300691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0094687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273097", "Detail": { "ID": 273097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3694441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262609", "Detail": { "ID": 262609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6092412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281769", "Detail": { "ID": 281769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1568396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298511", "Detail": { "ID": 298511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.349275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230639", "Detail": { "ID": 230639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3388371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284918", "Detail": { "ID": 284918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0532998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219592", "Detail": { "ID": 219592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3060349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238232", "Detail": { "ID": 238232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4375214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226694", "Detail": { "ID": 226694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.242562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321985", "Detail": { "ID": 321985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4599355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292655", "Detail": { "ID": 292655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5521561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227620", "Detail": { "ID": 227620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5579425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304594", "Detail": { "ID": 304594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0450868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257859", "Detail": { "ID": 257859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0806764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271050", "Detail": { "ID": 271050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.840358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274347", "Detail": { "ID": 274347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1020977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266086", "Detail": { "ID": 266086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4737491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250676", "Detail": { "ID": 250676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.208734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221142", "Detail": { "ID": 221142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.67688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226472", "Detail": { "ID": 226472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2328737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239705", "Detail": { "ID": 239705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.755394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253205", "Detail": { "ID": 253205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.985902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324817", "Detail": { "ID": 324817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2391125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261612", "Detail": { "ID": 261612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3649815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239511", "Detail": { "ID": 239511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7469424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273566", "Detail": { "ID": 273566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6259224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302651", "Detail": { "ID": 302651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5338462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303685", "Detail": { "ID": 303685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8259464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223172", "Detail": { "ID": 223172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2317073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245683", "Detail": { "ID": 245683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8539806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223360", "Detail": { "ID": 223360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4545263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308093", "Detail": { "ID": 308093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8644025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272411", "Detail": { "ID": 272411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3341884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245084", "Detail": { "ID": 245084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5913173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315293", "Detail": { "ID": 315293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9053691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247450", "Detail": { "ID": 247450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4043271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275500", "Detail": { "ID": 275500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.377936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255452", "Detail": { "ID": 255452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5319555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276899", "Detail": { "ID": 276899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.685895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253512", "Detail": { "ID": 253512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9996206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279187", "Detail": { "ID": 279187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2567615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325315", "Detail": { "ID": 325315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4933923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231934", "Detail": { "ID": 231934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6220581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311785", "Detail": { "ID": 311785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8941827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233200", "Detail": { "ID": 233200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.113613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267571", "Detail": { "ID": 267571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0256173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313067", "Detail": { "ID": 313067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1622136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294406", "Detail": { "ID": 294406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1369528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319234", "Detail": { "ID": 319234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9112633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306233", "Detail": { "ID": 306233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5432649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310341", "Detail": { "ID": 310341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5663451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268033", "Detail": { "ID": 268033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0530987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293020", "Detail": { "ID": 293020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5681861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271851", "Detail": { "ID": 271851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0941747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269815", "Detail": { "ID": 269815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5641254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307254", "Detail": { "ID": 307254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8213005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280174", "Detail": { "ID": 280174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.544599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279128", "Detail": { "ID": 279128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.254237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260437", "Detail": { "ID": 260437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0768388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299307", "Detail": { "ID": 299307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6918332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301799", "Detail": { "ID": 301799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2837302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300318", "Detail": { "ID": 300318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.993027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224199", "Detail": { "ID": 224199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4968455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305634", "Detail": { "ID": 305634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3328089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320036", "Detail": { "ID": 320036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9586461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315789", "Detail": { "ID": 315789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9270771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237172", "Detail": { "ID": 237172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9688707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288872", "Detail": { "ID": 288872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1620077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234209", "Detail": { "ID": 234209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3669536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312893", "Detail": { "ID": 312893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1544194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261312", "Detail": { "ID": 261312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3519465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225581", "Detail": { "ID": 225581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9815216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265650", "Detail": { "ID": 265650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4483588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284208", "Detail": { "ID": 284208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0161053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252126", "Detail": { "ID": 252126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5037041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317259", "Detail": { "ID": 317259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4107068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256688", "Detail": { "ID": 256688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7934472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293369", "Detail": { "ID": 293369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8420418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235883", "Detail": { "ID": 235883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6970522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255904", "Detail": { "ID": 255904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5619787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228637", "Detail": { "ID": 228637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8077035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289514", "Detail": { "ID": 289514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4405269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311574", "Detail": { "ID": 311574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8847388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246859", "Detail": { "ID": 246859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1564657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297628", "Detail": { "ID": 297628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.10837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233813", "Detail": { "ID": 233813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1474472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274936", "Detail": { "ID": 274936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1284292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270047", "Detail": { "ID": 270047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5792643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317759", "Detail": { "ID": 317759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4361334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326515", "Detail": { "ID": 326515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7679989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241343", "Detail": { "ID": 241343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7538343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290444", "Detail": { "ID": 290444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7473578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248135", "Detail": { "ID": 248135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4442329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289201", "Detail": { "ID": 289201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4265311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222671", "Detail": { "ID": 222671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1989329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240932", "Detail": { "ID": 240932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3886083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283993", "Detail": { "ID": 283993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7323595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231075", "Detail": { "ID": 231075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3645299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247303", "Detail": { "ID": 247303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3977848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308897", "Detail": { "ID": 308897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2122, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172.2", "ID": 8311 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0827989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259195", "Detail": { "ID": 259195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5981903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318725", "Detail": { "ID": 318725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6707484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250266", "Detail": { "ID": 250266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1817837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321072", "Detail": { "ID": 321072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2010384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228433", "Detail": { "ID": 228433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7988189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281124", "Detail": { "ID": 281124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8070204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263050", "Detail": { "ID": 263050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6345997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289001", "Detail": { "ID": 289001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1677943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227453", "Detail": { "ID": 227453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.550815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269676", "Detail": { "ID": 269676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5582111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322476", "Detail": { "ID": 322476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6902714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295895", "Detail": { "ID": 295895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5404263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243104", "Detail": { "ID": 243104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.049074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227072", "Detail": { "ID": 227072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2662997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301031", "Detail": { "ID": 301031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.029588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238403", "Detail": { "ID": 238403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4450405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316377", "Detail": { "ID": 316377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.145245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326991", "Detail": { "ID": 326991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7888931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277546", "Detail": { "ID": 277546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9579806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263940", "Detail": { "ID": 263940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9173544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250982", "Detail": { "ID": 250982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2218978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294805", "Detail": { "ID": 294805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1791142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285401", "Detail": { "ID": 285401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3214401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231337", "Detail": { "ID": 231337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.590576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243614", "Detail": { "ID": 243614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3124915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254380", "Detail": { "ID": 254380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.253192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323442", "Detail": { "ID": 323442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9563643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300690", "Detail": { "ID": 300690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0094285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273098", "Detail": { "ID": 273098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3694856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262610", "Detail": { "ID": 262610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6092816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281770", "Detail": { "ID": 281770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1568799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298510", "Detail": { "ID": 298510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3492346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230638", "Detail": { "ID": 230638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3387958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284917", "Detail": { "ID": 284917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0532592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219593", "Detail": { "ID": 219593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3060759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238233", "Detail": { "ID": 238233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4375625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226693", "Detail": { "ID": 226693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2425218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321984", "Detail": { "ID": 321984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4598944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292654", "Detail": { "ID": 292654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5520954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227621", "Detail": { "ID": 227621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5579837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304595", "Detail": { "ID": 304595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0451453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257860", "Detail": { "ID": 257860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0807166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271049", "Detail": { "ID": 271049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.840318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274348", "Detail": { "ID": 274348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1021386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266087", "Detail": { "ID": 266087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4737896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250677", "Detail": { "ID": 250677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2087745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221143", "Detail": { "ID": 221143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6769206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226471", "Detail": { "ID": 226471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2328323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239706", "Detail": { "ID": 239706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7554346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253206", "Detail": { "ID": 253206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9859433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324809", "Detail": { "ID": 324809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2387446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261611", "Detail": { "ID": 261611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3649413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239510", "Detail": { "ID": 239510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7468838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273565", "Detail": { "ID": 273565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6258816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM302650", "Detail": { "ID": 302650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5338059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303684", "Detail": { "ID": 303684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8259055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223171", "Detail": { "ID": 223171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2316669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245682", "Detail": { "ID": 245682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8539409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223359", "Detail": { "ID": 223359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4544864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308092", "Detail": { "ID": 308092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8643608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272412", "Detail": { "ID": 272412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.334229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245115", "Detail": { "ID": 245115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.592689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315286", "Detail": { "ID": 315286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9050565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247451", "Detail": { "ID": 247451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4043672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275501", "Detail": { "ID": 275501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3779765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255453", "Detail": { "ID": 255453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5319962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276898", "Detail": { "ID": 276898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6858542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253511", "Detail": { "ID": 253511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9995791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279186", "Detail": { "ID": 279186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2567205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325323", "Detail": { "ID": 325323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4937451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231935", "Detail": { "ID": 231935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6220992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311784", "Detail": { "ID": 311784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8941419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233199", "Detail": { "ID": 233199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1135429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267570", "Detail": { "ID": 267570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0255762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313068", "Detail": { "ID": 313068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1622551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294407", "Detail": { "ID": 294407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1369931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319233", "Detail": { "ID": 319233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9112225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306199", "Detail": { "ID": 306199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5416992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310342", "Detail": { "ID": 310342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5663858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268034", "Detail": { "ID": 268034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0531396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293019", "Detail": { "ID": 293019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5681451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271850", "Detail": { "ID": 271850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0941332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269814", "Detail": { "ID": 269814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5640835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307253", "Detail": { "ID": 307253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8212591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280175", "Detail": { "ID": 280175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5446392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279127", "Detail": { "ID": 279127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2541963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260405", "Detail": { "ID": 260405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0754548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299308", "Detail": { "ID": 299308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6918734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301800", "Detail": { "ID": 301800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2837706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300317", "Detail": { "ID": 300317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.992985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224200", "Detail": { "ID": 224200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4968863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305668", "Detail": { "ID": 305668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3342697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320037", "Detail": { "ID": 320037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9586871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315797", "Detail": { "ID": 315797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9274278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237173", "Detail": { "ID": 237173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9689104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288871", "Detail": { "ID": 288871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1619673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234208", "Detail": { "ID": 234208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.366841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312900", "Detail": { "ID": 312900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1547113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261313", "Detail": { "ID": 261313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3519867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225582", "Detail": { "ID": 225582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.981562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265649", "Detail": { "ID": 265649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4483181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284207", "Detail": { "ID": 284207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0160643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252127", "Detail": { "ID": 252127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5037447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317260", "Detail": { "ID": 317260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4107473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256687", "Detail": { "ID": 256687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7934062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293370", "Detail": { "ID": 293370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8420831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235884", "Detail": { "ID": 235884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.697094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255905", "Detail": { "ID": 255905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5620187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228638", "Detail": { "ID": 228638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8077448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289513", "Detail": { "ID": 289513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4404869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311567", "Detail": { "ID": 311567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8844257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246860", "Detail": { "ID": 246860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1565077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297627", "Detail": { "ID": 297627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1083284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233812", "Detail": { "ID": 233812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1474051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274937", "Detail": { "ID": 274937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1284705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270046", "Detail": { "ID": 270046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5792224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317751", "Detail": { "ID": 317751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4358065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326507", "Detail": { "ID": 326507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7676458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241344", "Detail": { "ID": 241344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7538938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291090", "Detail": { "ID": 291090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7851026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248136", "Detail": { "ID": 248136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.444282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289202", "Detail": { "ID": 289202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4265842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222672", "Detail": { "ID": 222672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1989735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240931", "Detail": { "ID": 240931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3885678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283994", "Detail": { "ID": 283994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7324011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231074", "Detail": { "ID": 231074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3644895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247302", "Detail": { "ID": 247302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3977244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308898", "Detail": { "ID": 308898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2123, "AgendaID": 2343, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Justice", "Reference": "S4M-08172", "ID": 8290 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0828396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269198", "Detail": { "ID": 269198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5338182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318383", "Detail": { "ID": 318383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6552355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249908", "Detail": { "ID": 249908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9551649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320468", "Detail": { "ID": 320468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1676974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230324", "Detail": { "ID": 230324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3179114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281402", "Detail": { "ID": 281402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1332633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263692", "Detail": { "ID": 263692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9006408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289035", "Detail": { "ID": 289035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1692528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228686", "Detail": { "ID": 228686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8098051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270428", "Detail": { "ID": 270428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8073589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323322", "Detail": { "ID": 323322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9447613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296486", "Detail": { "ID": 296486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8511484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229101", "Detail": { "ID": 229101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8345172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236137", "Detail": { "ID": 236137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7130729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300963", "Detail": { "ID": 300963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0264298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260597", "Detail": { "ID": 260597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0837563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316631", "Detail": { "ID": 316631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1564871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326815", "Detail": { "ID": 326815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7812601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278708", "Detail": { "ID": 278708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2308907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264693", "Detail": { "ID": 264693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1448289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249075", "Detail": { "ID": 249075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6828055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294016", "Detail": { "ID": 294016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8789849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287804", "Detail": { "ID": 287804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8870085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233702", "Detail": { "ID": 233702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.142449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243423", "Detail": { "ID": 243423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2971123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253262", "Detail": { "ID": 253262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9887406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323096", "Detail": { "ID": 323096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7218383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301477", "Detail": { "ID": 301477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2638926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273466", "Detail": { "ID": 273466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.62141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263267", "Detail": { "ID": 263267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8819718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285737", "Detail": { "ID": 285737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3424087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298789", "Detail": { "ID": 298789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3722223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230573", "Detail": { "ID": 230573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.336233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286504", "Detail": { "ID": 286504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5886878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219944", "Detail": { "ID": 219944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3214062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238771", "Detail": { "ID": 238771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.468315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225872", "Detail": { "ID": 225872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9940685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322111", "Detail": { "ID": 322111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.471786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290267", "Detail": { "ID": 290267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7394702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228876", "Detail": { "ID": 228876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8180489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304679", "Detail": { "ID": 304679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0487471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258373", "Detail": { "ID": 258373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3044257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272095", "Detail": { "ID": 272095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1113641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279856", "Detail": { "ID": 279856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5257687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267043", "Detail": { "ID": 267043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7730187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253639", "Detail": { "ID": 253639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0051218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221484", "Detail": { "ID": 221484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9347422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220556", "Detail": { "ID": 220556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6464537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240354", "Detail": { "ID": 240354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3561397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266364", "Detail": { "ID": 266364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7376768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324153", "Detail": { "ID": 324153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9944654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260177", "Detail": { "ID": 260177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6470983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247037", "Detail": { "ID": 247037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.164353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275252", "Detail": { "ID": 275252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3620688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303752", "Detail": { "ID": 303752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8341875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222041", "Detail": { "ID": 222041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9648228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242258", "Detail": { "ID": 242258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0051691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224158", "Detail": { "ID": 224158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4946507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308218", "Detail": { "ID": 308218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0461362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272758", "Detail": { "ID": 272758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3491272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244146", "Detail": { "ID": 244146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3357325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314316", "Detail": { "ID": 314316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6344353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251233", "Detail": { "ID": 251233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4545977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276463", "Detail": { "ID": 276463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6667257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256506", "Detail": { "ID": 256506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7856172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282495", "Detail": { "ID": 282495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.421339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254981", "Detail": { "ID": 254981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2920819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277758", "Detail": { "ID": 277758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9671887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325132", "Detail": { "ID": 325132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2575287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232355", "Detail": { "ID": 232355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8512613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312205", "Detail": { "ID": 312205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1150095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231481", "Detail": { "ID": 231481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6024757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267929", "Detail": { "ID": 267929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0485758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314812", "Detail": { "ID": 314812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.656564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297108", "Detail": { "ID": 297108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.888058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319361", "Detail": { "ID": 319361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9225881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306027", "Detail": { "ID": 306027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3558374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309022", "Detail": { "ID": 309022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0882879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268497", "Detail": { "ID": 268497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2697257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293132", "Detail": { "ID": 293132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5729652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261572", "Detail": { "ID": 261572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3632649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264498", "Detail": { "ID": 264498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1361051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307937", "Detail": { "ID": 307937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8573704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282895", "Detail": { "ID": 282895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4389434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280503", "Detail": { "ID": 280503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7700601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245418", "Detail": { "ID": 245418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8339983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304943", "Detail": { "ID": 304943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0654528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303256", "Detail": { "ID": 303256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8070211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297018", "Detail": { "ID": 297018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8841874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224851", "Detail": { "ID": 224851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7228215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296855", "Detail": { "ID": 296855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.876983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321351", "Detail": { "ID": 321351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4244355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315609", "Detail": { "ID": 315609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9193752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238150", "Detail": { "ID": 238150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2470667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294185", "Detail": { "ID": 294185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8866146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233578", "Detail": { "ID": 233578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1370367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312514", "Detail": { "ID": 312514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1311956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287635", "Detail": { "ID": 287635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8797505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226563", "Detail": { "ID": 226563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2369267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265154", "Detail": { "ID": 265154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1708027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284528", "Detail": { "ID": 284528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0364824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259108", "Detail": { "ID": 259108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3420729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318585", "Detail": { "ID": 318585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6645053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255577", "Detail": { "ID": 255577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5373407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295156", "Detail": { "ID": 295156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1949305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236849", "Detail": { "ID": 236849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9429458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256850", "Detail": { "ID": 256850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8125633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239560", "Detail": { "ID": 239560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7490045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290511", "Detail": { "ID": 290511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7502479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309972", "Detail": { "ID": 309972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3588999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247664", "Detail": { "ID": 247664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.423145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299237", "Detail": { "ID": 299237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6887928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234726", "Detail": { "ID": 234726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3970978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275906", "Detail": { "ID": 275906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3960609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273982", "Detail": { "ID": 273982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.649133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316479", "Detail": { "ID": 316479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1496845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325851", "Detail": { "ID": 325851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5241862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241702", "Detail": { "ID": 241702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.77616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287039", "Detail": { "ID": 287039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6116042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248473", "Detail": { "ID": 248473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.647537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288254", "Detail": { "ID": 288254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1267291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223016", "Detail": { "ID": 223016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2251123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240573", "Detail": { "ID": 240573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3730783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284642", "Detail": { "ID": 284642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0413538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232776", "Detail": { "ID": 232776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8757538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246209", "Detail": { "ID": 246209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1188245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310223", "Detail": { "ID": 310223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2119, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.2", "ID": 8102 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5592341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269199", "Detail": { "ID": 269199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5338767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318382", "Detail": { "ID": 318382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6551944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249907", "Detail": { "ID": 249907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9551251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320469", "Detail": { "ID": 320469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1677635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230325", "Detail": { "ID": 230325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3179526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281401", "Detail": { "ID": 281401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1332233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263693", "Detail": { "ID": 263693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9006822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289034", "Detail": { "ID": 289034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1692107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228687", "Detail": { "ID": 228687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8098462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270427", "Detail": { "ID": 270427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8072978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323323", "Detail": { "ID": 323323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9448022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296487", "Detail": { "ID": 296487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8511892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229102", "Detail": { "ID": 229102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8345584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236082", "Detail": { "ID": 236082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7104572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM292167", "Detail": { "ID": 292167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.159193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260596", "Detail": { "ID": 260596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0837157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316630", "Detail": { "ID": 316630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1564462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326814", "Detail": { "ID": 326814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7812196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278709", "Detail": { "ID": 278709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2309319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264692", "Detail": { "ID": 264692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1447868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249006", "Detail": { "ID": 249006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6795535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293706", "Detail": { "ID": 293706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8654322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287805", "Detail": { "ID": 287805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8870492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233703", "Detail": { "ID": 233703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.14249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243422", "Detail": { "ID": 243422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2970719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253260", "Detail": { "ID": 253260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9886383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323095", "Detail": { "ID": 323095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7217976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301479", "Detail": { "ID": 301479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2639944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273467", "Detail": { "ID": 273467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.621462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263488", "Detail": { "ID": 263488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8915747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285738", "Detail": { "ID": 285738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3424504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298788", "Detail": { "ID": 298788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3721817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230572", "Detail": { "ID": 230572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3361905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286505", "Detail": { "ID": 286505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5887468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220011", "Detail": { "ID": 220011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3304927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238829", "Detail": { "ID": 238829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4707816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225871", "Detail": { "ID": 225871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9940261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322110", "Detail": { "ID": 322110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4717455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290266", "Detail": { "ID": 290266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7394298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228936", "Detail": { "ID": 228936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.820659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304968", "Detail": { "ID": 304968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0665117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258374", "Detail": { "ID": 258374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3044669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272096", "Detail": { "ID": 272096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1114235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279857", "Detail": { "ID": 279857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5258112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267045", "Detail": { "ID": 267045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7731028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253640", "Detail": { "ID": 253640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0051635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221485", "Detail": { "ID": 221485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9347833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220489", "Detail": { "ID": 220489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6435602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240356", "Detail": { "ID": 240356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3563235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266365", "Detail": { "ID": 266365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7377178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324154", "Detail": { "ID": 324154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9945068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260108", "Detail": { "ID": 260108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6441018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246983", "Detail": { "ID": 246983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.162045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275251", "Detail": { "ID": 275251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3620281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303958", "Detail": { "ID": 303958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8432744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222040", "Detail": { "ID": 222040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.964782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242257", "Detail": { "ID": 242257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0051287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224097", "Detail": { "ID": 224097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4918821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308217", "Detail": { "ID": 308217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0460953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272759", "Detail": { "ID": 272759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3491675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244147", "Detail": { "ID": 244147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.335774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314317", "Detail": { "ID": 314317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6344761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251291", "Detail": { "ID": 251291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4571448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276462", "Detail": { "ID": 276462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6666834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256505", "Detail": { "ID": 256505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.785576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282496", "Detail": { "ID": 282496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4213806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254982", "Detail": { "ID": 254982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2921229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277690", "Detail": { "ID": 277690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9643099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325131", "Detail": { "ID": 325131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2574883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232356", "Detail": { "ID": 232356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8513028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312204", "Detail": { "ID": 312204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1149661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230949", "Detail": { "ID": 230949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3524866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267928", "Detail": { "ID": 267928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0485344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314813", "Detail": { "ID": 314813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6566045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297109", "Detail": { "ID": 297109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8880989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319360", "Detail": { "ID": 319360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9225451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306026", "Detail": { "ID": 306026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3557965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309023", "Detail": { "ID": 309023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0883296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268498", "Detail": { "ID": 268498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2697659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293131", "Detail": { "ID": 293131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5729244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261571", "Detail": { "ID": 261571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3632251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264429", "Detail": { "ID": 264429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1330934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307936", "Detail": { "ID": 307936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8573292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282894", "Detail": { "ID": 282894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4389032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280502", "Detail": { "ID": 280502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7700018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245417", "Detail": { "ID": 245417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8339575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304944", "Detail": { "ID": 304944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0654936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303257", "Detail": { "ID": 303257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8070636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297017", "Detail": { "ID": 297017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8841465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224852", "Detail": { "ID": 224852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7228617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296856", "Detail": { "ID": 296856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8770245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321352", "Detail": { "ID": 321352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4244767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315608", "Detail": { "ID": 315608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9193327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238304", "Detail": { "ID": 238304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4406299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294184", "Detail": { "ID": 294184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8865737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233576", "Detail": { "ID": 233576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1369326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312513", "Detail": { "ID": 312513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1311545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287636", "Detail": { "ID": 287636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8798098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226624", "Detail": { "ID": 226624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2395605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258187", "Detail": { "ID": 258187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0968536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284530", "Detail": { "ID": 284530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0365644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259324", "Detail": { "ID": 259324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6039703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318586", "Detail": { "ID": 318586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6645459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255576", "Detail": { "ID": 255576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5372989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295157", "Detail": { "ID": 295157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1949846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236918", "Detail": { "ID": 236918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9459456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256852", "Detail": { "ID": 256852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8126447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239561", "Detail": { "ID": 239561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.749045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290509", "Detail": { "ID": 290509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.750166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309973", "Detail": { "ID": 309973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.358941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247665", "Detail": { "ID": 247665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4231853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299236", "Detail": { "ID": 299236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.688752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234725", "Detail": { "ID": 234725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3970564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276283", "Detail": { "ID": 276283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6528548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273981", "Detail": { "ID": 273981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.649091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316480", "Detail": { "ID": 316480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1497256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325852", "Detail": { "ID": 325852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5242274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241703", "Detail": { "ID": 241703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7762006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287040", "Detail": { "ID": 287040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6116453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248533", "Detail": { "ID": 248533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6504058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288252", "Detail": { "ID": 288252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1266473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223071", "Detail": { "ID": 223071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2274316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240572", "Detail": { "ID": 240572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3730372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284641", "Detail": { "ID": 284641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0413136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232775", "Detail": { "ID": 232775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.875713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245842", "Detail": { "ID": 245842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8607666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310224", "Detail": { "ID": 310224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2120, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 79, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974.1", "ID": 8099 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5592759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269194", "Detail": { "ID": 269194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3077446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318381", "Detail": { "ID": 318381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6551537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249906", "Detail": { "ID": 249906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9550848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320470", "Detail": { "ID": 320470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1678071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230326", "Detail": { "ID": 230326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3179934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281400", "Detail": { "ID": 281400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1331828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263694", "Detail": { "ID": 263694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.900723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289037", "Detail": { "ID": 289037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1693352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228760", "Detail": { "ID": 228760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8129959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270432", "Detail": { "ID": 270432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8075266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323324", "Detail": { "ID": 323324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9448633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296488", "Detail": { "ID": 296488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8512308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242464", "Detail": { "ID": 242464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236081", "Detail": { "ID": 236081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7104165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300399", "Detail": { "ID": 300399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9965261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260595", "Detail": { "ID": 260595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0836746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316629", "Detail": { "ID": 316629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1564053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326813", "Detail": { "ID": 326813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.781179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278710", "Detail": { "ID": 278710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.230973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264691", "Detail": { "ID": 264691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1447286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249005", "Detail": { "ID": 249005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6794231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293705", "Detail": { "ID": 293705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8653924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287806", "Detail": { "ID": 287806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8870896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233704", "Detail": { "ID": 233704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1425501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243421", "Detail": { "ID": 243421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2970317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM252908", "Detail": { "ID": 252908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.758422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323094", "Detail": { "ID": 323094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.721757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301476", "Detail": { "ID": 301476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2638518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273468", "Detail": { "ID": 273468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6215057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263489", "Detail": { "ID": 263489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8916158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285739", "Detail": { "ID": 285739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3424911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298787", "Detail": { "ID": 298787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3721418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230571", "Detail": { "ID": 230571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3361291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286500", "Detail": { "ID": 286500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5885245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM220012", "Detail": { "ID": 220012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3305348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238833", "Detail": { "ID": 238833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4709687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225870", "Detail": { "ID": 225870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9939642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322109", "Detail": { "ID": 322109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.471705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290265", "Detail": { "ID": 290265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7393891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228937", "Detail": { "ID": 228937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8207003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304759", "Detail": { "ID": 304759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0571387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258375", "Detail": { "ID": 258375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3045076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272091", "Detail": { "ID": 272091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.111198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279858", "Detail": { "ID": 279858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5258523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267092", "Detail": { "ID": 267092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7751461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253641", "Detail": { "ID": 253641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0052045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221486", "Detail": { "ID": 221486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9348241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220488", "Detail": { "ID": 220488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6435193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240400", "Detail": { "ID": 240400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3582127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266366", "Detail": { "ID": 266366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7377776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324155", "Detail": { "ID": 324155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9945484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260107", "Detail": { "ID": 260107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6440423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246981", "Detail": { "ID": 246981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1619631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275250", "Detail": { "ID": 275250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3619868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303881", "Detail": { "ID": 303881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.839967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222039", "Detail": { "ID": 222039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9647402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242256", "Detail": { "ID": 242256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0050871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224096", "Detail": { "ID": 224096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.491835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308216", "Detail": { "ID": 308216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0460548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272760", "Detail": { "ID": 272760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3492072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244148", "Detail": { "ID": 244148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3358154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314318", "Detail": { "ID": 314318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6345169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251295", "Detail": { "ID": 251295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4573137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276469", "Detail": { "ID": 276469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6670045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256510", "Detail": { "ID": 256510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7857823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282489", "Detail": { "ID": 282489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4210741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254979", "Detail": { "ID": 254979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2920005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277689", "Detail": { "ID": 277689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9642689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325130", "Detail": { "ID": 325130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2574478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232357", "Detail": { "ID": 232357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8513439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312203", "Detail": { "ID": 312203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1149124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230948", "Detail": { "ID": 230948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3524461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267927", "Detail": { "ID": 267927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0484918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314814", "Detail": { "ID": 314814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6566452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297110", "Detail": { "ID": 297110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8881396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319359", "Detail": { "ID": 319359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9224803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306025", "Detail": { "ID": 306025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3557562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309024", "Detail": { "ID": 309024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0884209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268499", "Detail": { "ID": 268499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2698063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293130", "Detail": { "ID": 293130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.572884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261570", "Detail": { "ID": 261570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.363185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264428", "Detail": { "ID": 264428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.133053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307935", "Detail": { "ID": 307935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8572859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282896", "Detail": { "ID": 282896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4389839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280501", "Detail": { "ID": 280501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7699615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245416", "Detail": { "ID": 245416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8339164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304945", "Detail": { "ID": 304945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0655342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303258", "Detail": { "ID": 303258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8071051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297016", "Detail": { "ID": 297016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8841044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224853", "Detail": { "ID": 224853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7229024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296857", "Detail": { "ID": 296857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8770649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321353", "Detail": { "ID": 321353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4245175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315607", "Detail": { "ID": 315607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9192732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238305", "Detail": { "ID": 238305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4406727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294183", "Detail": { "ID": 294183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8865329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233381", "Detail": { "ID": 233381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1217499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312512", "Detail": { "ID": 312512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1311125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287637", "Detail": { "ID": 287637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.879851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226625", "Detail": { "ID": 226625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2396024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM258139", "Detail": { "ID": 258139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0939726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284527", "Detail": { "ID": 284527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0364415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259325", "Detail": { "ID": 259325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.604011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318587", "Detail": { "ID": 318587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6645871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255575", "Detail": { "ID": 255575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5372583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295158", "Detail": { "ID": 295158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1950341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236919", "Detail": { "ID": 236919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9459859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256892", "Detail": { "ID": 256892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8143824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239562", "Detail": { "ID": 239562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7490844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290620", "Detail": { "ID": 290620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7648582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309974", "Detail": { "ID": 309974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3589814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247666", "Detail": { "ID": 247666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4232251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299235", "Detail": { "ID": 299235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6887107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234724", "Detail": { "ID": 234724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3970152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM276284", "Detail": { "ID": 276284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6528964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273980", "Detail": { "ID": 273980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6490491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316481", "Detail": { "ID": 316481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1497677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325853", "Detail": { "ID": 325853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5242679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241704", "Detail": { "ID": 241704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7762411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287041", "Detail": { "ID": 287041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6116861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248534", "Detail": { "ID": 248534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6504463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288255", "Detail": { "ID": 288255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1268012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223072", "Detail": { "ID": 223072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2274717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240571", "Detail": { "ID": 240571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3729959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284648", "Detail": { "ID": 284648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0416176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232774", "Detail": { "ID": 232774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8756725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245841", "Detail": { "ID": 245841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8607262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310225", "Detail": { "ID": 310225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2121, "AgendaID": 2281, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Carbon Capture and Storage", "Reference": "S4M-07974", "ID": 8087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5612398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259175", "Detail": { "ID": 259175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3449384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319562", "Detail": { "ID": 319562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9312941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249466", "Detail": { "ID": 249466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9278569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320883", "Detail": { "ID": 320883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1857839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228358", "Detail": { "ID": 228358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7949673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281038", "Detail": { "ID": 281038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8033569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262828", "Detail": { "ID": 262828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6247048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288964", "Detail": { "ID": 288964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1661976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230540", "Detail": { "ID": 230540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3347966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269696", "Detail": { "ID": 269696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5590755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322562", "Detail": { "ID": 322562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6940535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295366", "Detail": { "ID": 295366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5090962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243040", "Detail": { "ID": 243040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0463431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227093", "Detail": { "ID": 227093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2672079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303082", "Detail": { "ID": 303082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5578226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244175", "Detail": { "ID": 244175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3419949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316330", "Detail": { "ID": 316330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1431641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327056", "Detail": { "ID": 327056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7917061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277167", "Detail": { "ID": 277167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7039651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264007", "Detail": { "ID": 264007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9202128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248617", "Detail": { "ID": 248617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6625302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294872", "Detail": { "ID": 294872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1823568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285333", "Detail": { "ID": 285333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3185015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231271", "Detail": { "ID": 231271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5877615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243678", "Detail": { "ID": 243678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3151846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254445", "Detail": { "ID": 254445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2564142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323509", "Detail": { "ID": 323509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9594492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290868", "Detail": { "ID": 290868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7755878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273030", "Detail": { "ID": 273030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3665388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262562", "Detail": { "ID": 262562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6072567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281854", "Detail": { "ID": 281854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1604655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298273", "Detail": { "ID": 298273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3386636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231139", "Detail": { "ID": 231139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3672733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284955", "Detail": { "ID": 284955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.05489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219547", "Detail": { "ID": 219547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3040613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238253", "Detail": { "ID": 238253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4384303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225119", "Detail": { "ID": 225119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7452949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321898", "Detail": { "ID": 321898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4560763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292766", "Detail": { "ID": 292766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5572362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227579", "Detail": { "ID": 227579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5562165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313309", "Detail": { "ID": 313309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3897526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257816", "Detail": { "ID": 257816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0788285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271087", "Detail": { "ID": 271087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8419398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277992", "Detail": { "ID": 277992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9775766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287385", "Detail": { "ID": 287385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.861956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250633", "Detail": { "ID": 250633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2069226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221097", "Detail": { "ID": 221097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6749359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220097", "Detail": { "ID": 220097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.334203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252813", "Detail": { "ID": 252813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7543536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253761", "Detail": { "ID": 253761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0197988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324742", "Detail": { "ID": 324742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2359291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259408", "Detail": { "ID": 259408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6078245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239490", "Detail": { "ID": 239490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7460541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273633", "Detail": { "ID": 273633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6287736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303998", "Detail": { "ID": 303998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8450157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221597", "Detail": { "ID": 221597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9395972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241829", "Detail": { "ID": 241829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7818322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223380", "Detail": { "ID": 223380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4553871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307856", "Detail": { "ID": 307856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8538643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272368", "Detail": { "ID": 272368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3323359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245051", "Detail": { "ID": 245051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5899066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315217", "Detail": { "ID": 315217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8989831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247471", "Detail": { "ID": 247471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4052227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275153", "Detail": { "ID": 275153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1438838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255473", "Detail": { "ID": 255473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5328501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276936", "Detail": { "ID": 276936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.687462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253491", "Detail": { "ID": 253491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9987144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276371", "Detail": { "ID": 276371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6627338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325389", "Detail": { "ID": 325389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4965826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233303", "Detail": { "ID": 233303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1182377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311700", "Detail": { "ID": 311700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8905111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229632", "Detail": { "ID": 229632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0900524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267483", "Detail": { "ID": 267483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0217843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313460", "Detail": { "ID": 313460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3963143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294955", "Detail": { "ID": 294955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.185945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319148", "Detail": { "ID": 319148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6945004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306269", "Detail": { "ID": 306269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5447964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310771", "Detail": { "ID": 310771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5853536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268121", "Detail": { "ID": 268121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0570734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286454", "Detail": { "ID": 286454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5799111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258503", "Detail": { "ID": 258503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3100538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263576", "Detail": { "ID": 263576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.89535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308716", "Detail": { "ID": 308716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0678795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280129", "Detail": { "ID": 280129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.542684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279505", "Detail": { "ID": 279505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5105923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260470", "Detail": { "ID": 260470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.078265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299391", "Detail": { "ID": 299391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6954057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306751", "Detail": { "ID": 306751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5658429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300584", "Detail": { "ID": 300584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.004886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224001", "Detail": { "ID": 224001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4877487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305598", "Detail": { "ID": 305598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3312779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320123", "Detail": { "ID": 320123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9626766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315865", "Detail": { "ID": 315865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9303977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237107", "Detail": { "ID": 237107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9661531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289708", "Detail": { "ID": 289708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4557693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234273", "Detail": { "ID": 234273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.370162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313125", "Detail": { "ID": 313125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1647241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289353", "Detail": { "ID": 289353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4335951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225561", "Detail": { "ID": 225561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9803017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265713", "Detail": { "ID": 265713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4511423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283012", "Detail": { "ID": 283012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4439875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252083", "Detail": { "ID": 252083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5018237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317344", "Detail": { "ID": 317344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4180725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254218", "Detail": { "ID": 254218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2460323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296255", "Detail": { "ID": 296255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8407571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235527", "Detail": { "ID": 235527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6816652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258052", "Detail": { "ID": 258052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0893331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228594", "Detail": { "ID": 228594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.805839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291045", "Detail": { "ID": 291045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7831148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311499", "Detail": { "ID": 311499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8814792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246816", "Detail": { "ID": 246816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1546225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297692", "Detail": { "ID": 297692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1206097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234033", "Detail": { "ID": 234033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1572336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274890", "Detail": { "ID": 274890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1264335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269959", "Detail": { "ID": 269959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5753243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317683", "Detail": { "ID": 317683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4329175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326441", "Detail": { "ID": 326441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7648122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241299", "Detail": { "ID": 241299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7519412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290410", "Detail": { "ID": 290410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7459092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248092", "Detail": { "ID": 248092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4416466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288160", "Detail": { "ID": 288160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9094902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222651", "Detail": { "ID": 222651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1980957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239672", "Detail": { "ID": 239672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7539987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283803", "Detail": { "ID": 283803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7241211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231763", "Detail": { "ID": 231763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6144762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237312", "Detail": { "ID": 237312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1987776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308981", "Detail": { "ID": 308981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2118, "AgendaID": 2895, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07952", "ID": 13109 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0863865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259747", "Detail": { "ID": 259747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6228001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318291", "Detail": { "ID": 318291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6464634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250030", "Detail": { "ID": 250030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9603877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320549", "Detail": { "ID": 320549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1712022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229547", "Detail": { "ID": 229547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0864171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281626", "Detail": { "ID": 281626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1508373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263364", "Detail": { "ID": 263364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8862426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290637", "Detail": { "ID": 290637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7658354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227958", "Detail": { "ID": 227958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5782426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270588", "Detail": { "ID": 270588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8142671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322962", "Detail": { "ID": 322962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7112608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296601", "Detail": { "ID": 296601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.856057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242549", "Detail": { "ID": 242549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0251525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236562", "Detail": { "ID": 236562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.930357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301629", "Detail": { "ID": 301629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.270708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261267", "Detail": { "ID": 261267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3500084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316972", "Detail": { "ID": 316972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.17617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326725", "Detail": { "ID": 326725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7774173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278192", "Detail": { "ID": 278192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9910008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264888", "Detail": { "ID": 264888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1590382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249221", "Detail": { "ID": 249221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9172312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293618", "Detail": { "ID": 293618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8616882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285582", "Detail": { "ID": 285582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3354885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232131", "Detail": { "ID": 232131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6359608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243332", "Detail": { "ID": 243332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2928104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253867", "Detail": { "ID": 253867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.02427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321455", "Detail": { "ID": 321455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4365871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292392", "Detail": { "ID": 292392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5318298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273271", "Detail": { "ID": 273271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6080849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262969", "Detail": { "ID": 262969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6310178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282257", "Detail": { "ID": 282257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4049761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299013", "Detail": { "ID": 299013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3819571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230595", "Detail": { "ID": 230595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3371684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286586", "Detail": { "ID": 286586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5921664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219796", "Detail": { "ID": 219796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3150348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238991", "Detail": { "ID": 238991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4780857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225993", "Detail": { "ID": 225993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0054475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322334", "Detail": { "ID": 322334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6783019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292182", "Detail": { "ID": 292182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1598522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228273", "Detail": { "ID": 228273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7857375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304480", "Detail": { "ID": 304480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0400203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258250", "Detail": { "ID": 258250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2990094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271779", "Detail": { "ID": 271779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0910913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279013", "Detail": { "ID": 279013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2489726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266749", "Detail": { "ID": 266749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7548918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250901", "Detail": { "ID": 250901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2185027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221366", "Detail": { "ID": 221366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9291729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220857", "Detail": { "ID": 220857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6599753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240061", "Detail": { "ID": 240061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7710637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266990", "Detail": { "ID": 266990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7707383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324245", "Detail": { "ID": 324245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2081819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260323", "Detail": { "ID": 260323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0719274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246529", "Detail": { "ID": 246529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1326192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275765", "Detail": { "ID": 275765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3895935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303547", "Detail": { "ID": 303547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8200351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222163", "Detail": { "ID": 222163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9704719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242378", "Detail": { "ID": 242378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0104479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224435", "Detail": { "ID": 224435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7046973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308597", "Detail": { "ID": 308597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0627484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272639", "Detail": { "ID": 272639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3440464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244392", "Detail": { "ID": 244392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5527298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314409", "Detail": { "ID": 314409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6387025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251917", "Detail": { "ID": 251917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4947034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276061", "Detail": { "ID": 276061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4087943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256974", "Detail": { "ID": 256974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.817897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282741", "Detail": { "ID": 282741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4321292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254522", "Detail": { "ID": 254522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2597681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278368", "Detail": { "ID": 278368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2094228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325040", "Detail": { "ID": 325040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2488188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232014", "Detail": { "ID": 232014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.63076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312923", "Detail": { "ID": 312923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1556999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232540", "Detail": { "ID": 232540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8652558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267627", "Detail": { "ID": 267627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0280645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314434", "Detail": { "ID": 314434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6397892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296129", "Detail": { "ID": 296129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5506427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319739", "Detail": { "ID": 319739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9392471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305936", "Detail": { "ID": 305936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3518031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309917", "Detail": { "ID": 309917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3565221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268813", "Detail": { "ID": 268813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2841298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293804", "Detail": { "ID": 293804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8696101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262161", "Detail": { "ID": 262161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3941678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268988", "Detail": { "ID": 268988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2987167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307361", "Detail": { "ID": 307361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8259685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280681", "Detail": { "ID": 280681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.777621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281008", "Detail": { "ID": 281008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7917826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245329", "Detail": { "ID": 245329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8301703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299948", "Detail": { "ID": 299948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7298039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302279", "Detail": { "ID": 302279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5175381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300156", "Detail": { "ID": 300156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7387168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224577", "Detail": { "ID": 224577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7108049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297406", "Detail": { "ID": 297406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0985831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320988", "Detail": { "ID": 320988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1970001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315516", "Detail": { "ID": 315516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9153735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237651", "Detail": { "ID": 237651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2200062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293466", "Detail": { "ID": 293466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8465915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233866", "Detail": { "ID": 233866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1497396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312420", "Detail": { "ID": 312420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1270657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286800", "Detail": { "ID": 286800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6011941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226131", "Detail": { "ID": 226131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.011367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265294", "Detail": { "ID": 265294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4329594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283910", "Detail": { "ID": 283910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.728765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258965", "Detail": { "ID": 258965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3358693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318207", "Detail": { "ID": 318207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6426959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255697", "Detail": { "ID": 255697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5530137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294003", "Detail": { "ID": 294003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8784314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236395", "Detail": { "ID": 236395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9150182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256401", "Detail": { "ID": 256401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7809118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229939", "Detail": { "ID": 229939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1039136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288450", "Detail": { "ID": 288450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1353634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310066", "Detail": { "ID": 310066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3630237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247544", "Detail": { "ID": 247544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4083851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299130", "Detail": { "ID": 299130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3886611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235703", "Detail": { "ID": 235703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6894279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275451", "Detail": { "ID": 275451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.375829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274204", "Detail": { "ID": 274204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0904804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316571", "Detail": { "ID": 316571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1538906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325943", "Detail": { "ID": 325943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5282195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241579", "Detail": { "ID": 241579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7708606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287907", "Detail": { "ID": 287907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8917137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248330", "Detail": { "ID": 248330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6413229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290111", "Detail": { "ID": 290111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4732768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222898", "Detail": { "ID": 222898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2094373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240695", "Detail": { "ID": 240695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3783746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284397", "Detail": { "ID": 284397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0245772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233081", "Detail": { "ID": 233081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8959854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246657", "Detail": { "ID": 246657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1477253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309692", "Detail": { "ID": 309692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2117, "AgendaID": 2106, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 78, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce: Interim Report", "Reference": "S4M-07939.2", "ID": 8064 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3405349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259580", "Detail": { "ID": 259580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6152513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318310", "Detail": { "ID": 318310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6472858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250065", "Detail": { "ID": 250065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9618841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320530", "Detail": { "ID": 320530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1703861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229543", "Detail": { "ID": 229543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0862542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281630", "Detail": { "ID": 281630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1509965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263360", "Detail": { "ID": 263360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8860783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290650", "Detail": { "ID": 290650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7664038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227926", "Detail": { "ID": 227926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5716315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270601", "Detail": { "ID": 270601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8148226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322958", "Detail": { "ID": 322958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7110942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296597", "Detail": { "ID": 296597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8558932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242531", "Detail": { "ID": 242531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0243734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236607", "Detail": { "ID": 236607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9322955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301611", "Detail": { "ID": 301611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2699413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261271", "Detail": { "ID": 261271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3501919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316976", "Detail": { "ID": 316976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.176359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326742", "Detail": { "ID": 326742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7781295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278188", "Detail": { "ID": 278188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9908358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264892", "Detail": { "ID": 264892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1592035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249225", "Detail": { "ID": 249225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9173967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293637", "Detail": { "ID": 293637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8625073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285578", "Detail": { "ID": 285578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3353262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232127", "Detail": { "ID": 232127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6357662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243350", "Detail": { "ID": 243350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2935853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253887", "Detail": { "ID": 253887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0251233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321474", "Detail": { "ID": 321474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.437633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292396", "Detail": { "ID": 292396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5320124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273267", "Detail": { "ID": 273267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6079018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262965", "Detail": { "ID": 262965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6308332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282253", "Detail": { "ID": 282253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4048097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299017", "Detail": { "ID": 299017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3821178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230599", "Detail": { "ID": 230599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3373306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286573", "Detail": { "ID": 286573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5916189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219792", "Detail": { "ID": 219792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3148496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239034", "Detail": { "ID": 239034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4799085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226182", "Detail": { "ID": 226182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0135365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322338", "Detail": { "ID": 322338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6784647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292186", "Detail": { "ID": 292186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1600176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228269", "Detail": { "ID": 228269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7855708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304461", "Detail": { "ID": 304461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0392115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258214", "Detail": { "ID": 258214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2974483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271766", "Detail": { "ID": 271766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0905339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279009", "Detail": { "ID": 279009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2488052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266730", "Detail": { "ID": 266730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7540753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250865", "Detail": { "ID": 250865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2168671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221331", "Detail": { "ID": 221331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9275084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220861", "Detail": { "ID": 220861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6601378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240041", "Detail": { "ID": 240041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7702072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266986", "Detail": { "ID": 266986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7705556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324227", "Detail": { "ID": 324227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2073715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260327", "Detail": { "ID": 260327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0721076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246486", "Detail": { "ID": 246486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1307885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275769", "Detail": { "ID": 275769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3897759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303565", "Detail": { "ID": 303565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.820808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222197", "Detail": { "ID": 222197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9719157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242412", "Detail": { "ID": 242412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0121377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224636", "Detail": { "ID": 224636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7133562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308601", "Detail": { "ID": 308601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0629094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272603", "Detail": { "ID": 272603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3424832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244374", "Detail": { "ID": 244374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5519633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314390", "Detail": { "ID": 314390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6377012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251960", "Detail": { "ID": 251960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4965338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276074", "Detail": { "ID": 276074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4093693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257017", "Detail": { "ID": 257017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8197397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282573", "Detail": { "ID": 282573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4247248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254167", "Detail": { "ID": 254167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0375084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278372", "Detail": { "ID": 278372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2096077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325058", "Detail": { "ID": 325058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2542153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232010", "Detail": { "ID": 232010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6253271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312927", "Detail": { "ID": 312927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1558842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232544", "Detail": { "ID": 232544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8654737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267631", "Detail": { "ID": 267631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0282296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314430", "Detail": { "ID": 314430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6396183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296125", "Detail": { "ID": 296125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5504612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319743", "Detail": { "ID": 319743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9394312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305955", "Detail": { "ID": 305955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3527519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309913", "Detail": { "ID": 309913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3563334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268809", "Detail": { "ID": 268809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2839666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293808", "Detail": { "ID": 293808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8697724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262196", "Detail": { "ID": 262196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5908968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268992", "Detail": { "ID": 268992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2988804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307365", "Detail": { "ID": 307365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8261339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280677", "Detail": { "ID": 280677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7774597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281012", "Detail": { "ID": 281012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.791945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245348", "Detail": { "ID": 245348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8309726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299944", "Detail": { "ID": 299944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7296244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302275", "Detail": { "ID": 302275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5173738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300160", "Detail": { "ID": 300160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7388799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224543", "Detail": { "ID": 224543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7093482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296925", "Detail": { "ID": 296925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.879919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320984", "Detail": { "ID": 320984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1967926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315535", "Detail": { "ID": 315535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9161931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237647", "Detail": { "ID": 237647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2198424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293470", "Detail": { "ID": 293470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8467744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233886", "Detail": { "ID": 233886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1505869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312439", "Detail": { "ID": 312439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1279401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286796", "Detail": { "ID": 286796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6010147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226085", "Detail": { "ID": 226085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0093908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265469", "Detail": { "ID": 265469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4405305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283914", "Detail": { "ID": 283914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7289479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258805", "Detail": { "ID": 258805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3286797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318203", "Detail": { "ID": 318203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.642474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256040", "Detail": { "ID": 256040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5678377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293999", "Detail": { "ID": 293999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8782661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236391", "Detail": { "ID": 236391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9148287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256382", "Detail": { "ID": 256382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.780119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229905", "Detail": { "ID": 229905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1024593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289395", "Detail": { "ID": 289395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4353979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310047", "Detail": { "ID": 310047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.36219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247201", "Detail": { "ID": 247201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3933496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299134", "Detail": { "ID": 299134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3888825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235707", "Detail": { "ID": 235707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6895882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275447", "Detail": { "ID": 275447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3756355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274208", "Detail": { "ID": 274208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0906515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316552", "Detail": { "ID": 316552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1530909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325926", "Detail": { "ID": 325926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.527424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241545", "Detail": { "ID": 241545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7694232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287888", "Detail": { "ID": 287888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8908704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248326", "Detail": { "ID": 248326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6411587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290107", "Detail": { "ID": 290107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4730863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222853", "Detail": { "ID": 222853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2075085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240729", "Detail": { "ID": 240729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3798157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284410", "Detail": { "ID": 284410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0251696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233085", "Detail": { "ID": 233085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8961508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246661", "Detail": { "ID": 246661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.147936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309688", "Detail": { "ID": 309688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2116, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 32, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.3", "ID": 8027 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3403718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259750", "Detail": { "ID": 259750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6229243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318309", "Detail": { "ID": 318309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6472271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250064", "Detail": { "ID": 250064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9618229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320531", "Detail": { "ID": 320531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1704263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229544", "Detail": { "ID": 229544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0862946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281629", "Detail": { "ID": 281629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1509571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263361", "Detail": { "ID": 263361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8861192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290634", "Detail": { "ID": 290634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7657139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227927", "Detail": { "ID": 227927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5716736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270585", "Detail": { "ID": 270585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.814125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322959", "Detail": { "ID": 322959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7111372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296598", "Detail": { "ID": 296598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8559339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242532", "Detail": { "ID": 242532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0244142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236565", "Detail": { "ID": 236565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9304802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301626", "Detail": { "ID": 301626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2705663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261270", "Detail": { "ID": 261270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.350132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316975", "Detail": { "ID": 316975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1763175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326741", "Detail": { "ID": 326741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7780892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278189", "Detail": { "ID": 278189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9908766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264891", "Detail": { "ID": 264891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1591622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249224", "Detail": { "ID": 249224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9173555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293636", "Detail": { "ID": 293636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8624662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285579", "Detail": { "ID": 285579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3353666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232128", "Detail": { "ID": 232128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6358071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243349", "Detail": { "ID": 243349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2935433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253885", "Detail": { "ID": 253885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0250164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321473", "Detail": { "ID": 321473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4375809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292395", "Detail": { "ID": 292395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5319721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273268", "Detail": { "ID": 273268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6079423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262966", "Detail": { "ID": 262966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6308742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282254", "Detail": { "ID": 282254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4048515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299016", "Detail": { "ID": 299016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.382078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230598", "Detail": { "ID": 230598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3372905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286589", "Detail": { "ID": 286589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5922863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219793", "Detail": { "ID": 219793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3148917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238988", "Detail": { "ID": 238988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4779444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226181", "Detail": { "ID": 226181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0134959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322337", "Detail": { "ID": 322337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6784245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292185", "Detail": { "ID": 292185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1599761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228270", "Detail": { "ID": 228270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7856122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304477", "Detail": { "ID": 304477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0398973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258215", "Detail": { "ID": 258215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2974913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271782", "Detail": { "ID": 271782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0912137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279010", "Detail": { "ID": 279010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2488466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266746", "Detail": { "ID": 266746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7547484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250866", "Detail": { "ID": 250866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2170056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221332", "Detail": { "ID": 221332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9275489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220860", "Detail": { "ID": 220860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6600967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240043", "Detail": { "ID": 240043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7702885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266987", "Detail": { "ID": 266987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7705961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324228", "Detail": { "ID": 324228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2074132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260326", "Detail": { "ID": 260326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0720489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246532", "Detail": { "ID": 246532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.13276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275768", "Detail": { "ID": 275768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3897345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303550", "Detail": { "ID": 303550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8201567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222196", "Detail": { "ID": 222196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9718749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242411", "Detail": { "ID": 242411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0120965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224438", "Detail": { "ID": 224438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.704838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308600", "Detail": { "ID": 308600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0628696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272604", "Detail": { "ID": 272604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3425239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244375", "Detail": { "ID": 244375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5520047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314391", "Detail": { "ID": 314391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6377427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251914", "Detail": { "ID": 251914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4945783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276058", "Detail": { "ID": 276058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4086698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256971", "Detail": { "ID": 256971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8177556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282744", "Detail": { "ID": 282744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4322496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254525", "Detail": { "ID": 254525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2599186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278371", "Detail": { "ID": 278371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2095668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325057", "Detail": { "ID": 325057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2541745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232011", "Detail": { "ID": 232011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6253672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312926", "Detail": { "ID": 312926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.155843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232543", "Detail": { "ID": 232543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8654319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267630", "Detail": { "ID": 267630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0281885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314431", "Detail": { "ID": 314431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6396615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296126", "Detail": { "ID": 296126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5505018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319742", "Detail": { "ID": 319742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9393895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305954", "Detail": { "ID": 305954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3527114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309914", "Detail": { "ID": 309914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.356374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268810", "Detail": { "ID": 268810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2840072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293807", "Detail": { "ID": 293807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8697327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262195", "Detail": { "ID": 262195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5908411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268991", "Detail": { "ID": 268991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2988398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307364", "Detail": { "ID": 307364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8260922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280678", "Detail": { "ID": 280678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7775002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281011", "Detail": { "ID": 281011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7919047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245347", "Detail": { "ID": 245347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8309309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299945", "Detail": { "ID": 299945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7296646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302276", "Detail": { "ID": 302276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5174142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300159", "Detail": { "ID": 300159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7388396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224544", "Detail": { "ID": 224544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.709389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296926", "Detail": { "ID": 296926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8799593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320985", "Detail": { "ID": 320985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.196837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315534", "Detail": { "ID": 315534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9161518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237648", "Detail": { "ID": 237648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2198828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293469", "Detail": { "ID": 293469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8467136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233884", "Detail": { "ID": 233884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1505044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312438", "Detail": { "ID": 312438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1278981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286797", "Detail": { "ID": 286797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6010547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226128", "Detail": { "ID": 226128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.011224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265297", "Detail": { "ID": 265297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4331034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283913", "Detail": { "ID": 283913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.728888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258806", "Detail": { "ID": 258806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3287206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318204", "Detail": { "ID": 318204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6425336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256039", "Detail": { "ID": 256039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.567797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294000", "Detail": { "ID": 294000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.878308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236392", "Detail": { "ID": 236392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.914892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256384", "Detail": { "ID": 256384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7802013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229906", "Detail": { "ID": 229906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1024998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288453", "Detail": { "ID": 288453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1354851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310048", "Detail": { "ID": 310048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3622317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247202", "Detail": { "ID": 247202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3933906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299133", "Detail": { "ID": 299133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3888283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235706", "Detail": { "ID": 235706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6895486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275448", "Detail": { "ID": 275448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3756766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274207", "Detail": { "ID": 274207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0906087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316553", "Detail": { "ID": 316553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1531327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325927", "Detail": { "ID": 325927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5274651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241546", "Detail": { "ID": 241546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7694635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287889", "Detail": { "ID": 287889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.890911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248327", "Detail": { "ID": 248327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6411995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290108", "Detail": { "ID": 290108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.473152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222895", "Detail": { "ID": 222895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2093137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240728", "Detail": { "ID": 240728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3797749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284394", "Detail": { "ID": 284394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0244328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233084", "Detail": { "ID": 233084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8961101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246660", "Detail": { "ID": 246660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1478951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309689", "Detail": { "ID": 309689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2113, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.2", "ID": 8025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3404133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259749", "Detail": { "ID": 259749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6228835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318308", "Detail": { "ID": 318308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6471858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250063", "Detail": { "ID": 250063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9617826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320532", "Detail": { "ID": 320532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.170467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229545", "Detail": { "ID": 229545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0863351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281628", "Detail": { "ID": 281628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1509174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263362", "Detail": { "ID": 263362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8861611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290635", "Detail": { "ID": 290635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.765754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227956", "Detail": { "ID": 227956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5781221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270586", "Detail": { "ID": 270586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8141667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322960", "Detail": { "ID": 322960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7111778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296599", "Detail": { "ID": 296599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8559745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242533", "Detail": { "ID": 242533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0244547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236564", "Detail": { "ID": 236564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9304395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301627", "Detail": { "ID": 301627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2706066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261269", "Detail": { "ID": 261269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3500906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316974", "Detail": { "ID": 316974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1762761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326740", "Detail": { "ID": 326740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7780485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278190", "Detail": { "ID": 278190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.990918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264890", "Detail": { "ID": 264890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1591214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249223", "Detail": { "ID": 249223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9173137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293635", "Detail": { "ID": 293635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.862426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285580", "Detail": { "ID": 285580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.335407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232129", "Detail": { "ID": 232129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6358479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243348", "Detail": { "ID": 243348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2934836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253869", "Detail": { "ID": 253869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0243505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321472", "Detail": { "ID": 321472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4374069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292394", "Detail": { "ID": 292394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5319302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273269", "Detail": { "ID": 273269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6079831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262967", "Detail": { "ID": 262967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6309153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282255", "Detail": { "ID": 282255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4048929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299015", "Detail": { "ID": 299015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3820381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230597", "Detail": { "ID": 230597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3372495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286588", "Detail": { "ID": 286588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5922465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219794", "Detail": { "ID": 219794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.314932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238989", "Detail": { "ID": 238989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4779849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226180", "Detail": { "ID": 226180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0134548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322336", "Detail": { "ID": 322336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.678384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292184", "Detail": { "ID": 292184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.159935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228271", "Detail": { "ID": 228271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7856532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304478", "Detail": { "ID": 304478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0399376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258216", "Detail": { "ID": 258216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2975321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271781", "Detail": { "ID": 271781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0911729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279011", "Detail": { "ID": 279011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2488881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266747", "Detail": { "ID": 266747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7547904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250867", "Detail": { "ID": 250867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2170521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221333", "Detail": { "ID": 221333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9276139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220859", "Detail": { "ID": 220859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6600565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240059", "Detail": { "ID": 240059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7709808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266988", "Detail": { "ID": 266988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7706371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324229", "Detail": { "ID": 324229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2074548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260325", "Detail": { "ID": 260325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0720086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246531", "Detail": { "ID": 246531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1327003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275767", "Detail": { "ID": 275767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3896741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303549", "Detail": { "ID": 303549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8201164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222195", "Detail": { "ID": 222195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9718319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242410", "Detail": { "ID": 242410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0120557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224437", "Detail": { "ID": 224437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7047788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308599", "Detail": { "ID": 308599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0628292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272605", "Detail": { "ID": 272605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3425824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244376", "Detail": { "ID": 244376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5520461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314392", "Detail": { "ID": 314392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6377824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251915", "Detail": { "ID": 251915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4946201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276059", "Detail": { "ID": 276059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4087111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256972", "Detail": { "ID": 256972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8177962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282743", "Detail": { "ID": 282743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4322098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254524", "Detail": { "ID": 254524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2598513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278370", "Detail": { "ID": 278370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2095243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325056", "Detail": { "ID": 325056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2541338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232012", "Detail": { "ID": 232012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6254078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312925", "Detail": { "ID": 312925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1558022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232542", "Detail": { "ID": 232542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8653884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267629", "Detail": { "ID": 267629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0281473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314432", "Detail": { "ID": 314432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6397036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296127", "Detail": { "ID": 296127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5505419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319741", "Detail": { "ID": 319741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9393476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305953", "Detail": { "ID": 305953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3526694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309915", "Detail": { "ID": 309915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3564381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268811", "Detail": { "ID": 268811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2840479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293806", "Detail": { "ID": 293806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8696931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262194", "Detail": { "ID": 262194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5907687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268990", "Detail": { "ID": 268990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2987984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307363", "Detail": { "ID": 307363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8260513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280679", "Detail": { "ID": 280679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7775399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281010", "Detail": { "ID": 281010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.791864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245346", "Detail": { "ID": 245346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8308903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299946", "Detail": { "ID": 299946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7297046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302277", "Detail": { "ID": 302277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5174544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300158", "Detail": { "ID": 300158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7387991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224545", "Detail": { "ID": 224545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7094476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296927", "Detail": { "ID": 296927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8799984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320986", "Detail": { "ID": 320986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1968789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315533", "Detail": { "ID": 315533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9161103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237649", "Detail": { "ID": 237649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2199231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293468", "Detail": { "ID": 293468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8466737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233868", "Detail": { "ID": 233868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1498227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312437", "Detail": { "ID": 312437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.127857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286798", "Detail": { "ID": 286798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6011121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226129", "Detail": { "ID": 226129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0112652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265296", "Detail": { "ID": 265296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4330621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283912", "Detail": { "ID": 283912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7288473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258807", "Detail": { "ID": 258807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3287613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318205", "Detail": { "ID": 318205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6425882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256038", "Detail": { "ID": 256038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5677554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294001", "Detail": { "ID": 294001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8783485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236393", "Detail": { "ID": 236393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.914934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256399", "Detail": { "ID": 256399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7808298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229907", "Detail": { "ID": 229907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1025403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288452", "Detail": { "ID": 288452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1354443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310049", "Detail": { "ID": 310049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3622727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247203", "Detail": { "ID": 247203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3934319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299132", "Detail": { "ID": 299132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3887788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235705", "Detail": { "ID": 235705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.689508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275449", "Detail": { "ID": 275449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3757185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274206", "Detail": { "ID": 274206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0905656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316554", "Detail": { "ID": 316554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1531733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325928", "Detail": { "ID": 325928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5275058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241547", "Detail": { "ID": 241547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7695034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287890", "Detail": { "ID": 287890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8909518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248328", "Detail": { "ID": 248328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6412393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290109", "Detail": { "ID": 290109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4731942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222896", "Detail": { "ID": 222896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2093543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240727", "Detail": { "ID": 240727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.379734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284395", "Detail": { "ID": 284395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0244929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233083", "Detail": { "ID": 233083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8960687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246659", "Detail": { "ID": 246659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1478512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309690", "Detail": { "ID": 309690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2114, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892.1", "ID": 8023 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3404538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259748", "Detail": { "ID": 259748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6228422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318307", "Detail": { "ID": 318307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6471444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250062", "Detail": { "ID": 250062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9617419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320533", "Detail": { "ID": 320533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1705276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229546", "Detail": { "ID": 229546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.086376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281627", "Detail": { "ID": 281627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.150877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263363", "Detail": { "ID": 263363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8862014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290636", "Detail": { "ID": 290636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7657942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227957", "Detail": { "ID": 227957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5781972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270587", "Detail": { "ID": 270587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8142073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322961", "Detail": { "ID": 322961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7112187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296600", "Detail": { "ID": 296600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.856015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242534", "Detail": { "ID": 242534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0244953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236563", "Detail": { "ID": 236563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9303987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301628", "Detail": { "ID": 301628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2706475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261268", "Detail": { "ID": 261268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3500494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316973", "Detail": { "ID": 316973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.176231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326717", "Detail": { "ID": 326717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7770713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278191", "Detail": { "ID": 278191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9909592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264889", "Detail": { "ID": 264889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1590802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249222", "Detail": { "ID": 249222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9172726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293634", "Detail": { "ID": 293634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8623857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285581", "Detail": { "ID": 285581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.335447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232130", "Detail": { "ID": 232130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6358886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243347", "Detail": { "ID": 243347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2934433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253868", "Detail": { "ID": 253868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0243106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321471", "Detail": { "ID": 321471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4373645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292393", "Detail": { "ID": 292393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5318703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273270", "Detail": { "ID": 273270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6080243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262968", "Detail": { "ID": 262968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6309738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282256", "Detail": { "ID": 282256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4049341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299014", "Detail": { "ID": 299014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3819976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230596", "Detail": { "ID": 230596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3372092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286587", "Detail": { "ID": 286587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5922066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219795", "Detail": { "ID": 219795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3149917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238990", "Detail": { "ID": 238990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4780255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226024", "Detail": { "ID": 226024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0067818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322335", "Detail": { "ID": 322335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6783432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292183", "Detail": { "ID": 292183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1598931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228272", "Detail": { "ID": 228272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7856942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304479", "Detail": { "ID": 304479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.039979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258248", "Detail": { "ID": 258248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2989252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271780", "Detail": { "ID": 271780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0911318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279012", "Detail": { "ID": 279012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2489297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266748", "Detail": { "ID": 266748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7548488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250868", "Detail": { "ID": 250868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2170994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221334", "Detail": { "ID": 221334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9276562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220858", "Detail": { "ID": 220858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6600161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240060", "Detail": { "ID": 240060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7710219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266989", "Detail": { "ID": 266989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7706956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324253", "Detail": { "ID": 324253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.208538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260324", "Detail": { "ID": 260324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0719683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246530", "Detail": { "ID": 246530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1326596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275766", "Detail": { "ID": 275766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3896343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303548", "Detail": { "ID": 303548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8200756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222194", "Detail": { "ID": 222194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9717725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242409", "Detail": { "ID": 242409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0120136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224436", "Detail": { "ID": 224436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7047377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308598", "Detail": { "ID": 308598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.062789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272637", "Detail": { "ID": 272637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3439422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244377", "Detail": { "ID": 244377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5520876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314393", "Detail": { "ID": 314393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6378239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251916", "Detail": { "ID": 251916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4946619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276060", "Detail": { "ID": 276060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4087526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256973", "Detail": { "ID": 256973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8178366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282742", "Detail": { "ID": 282742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4321694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254523", "Detail": { "ID": 254523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2598101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278369", "Detail": { "ID": 278369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2094639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325032", "Detail": { "ID": 325032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2484882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232013", "Detail": { "ID": 232013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6254487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312924", "Detail": { "ID": 312924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1557604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232541", "Detail": { "ID": 232541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8653334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267628", "Detail": { "ID": 267628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0281071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314433", "Detail": { "ID": 314433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6397462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296128", "Detail": { "ID": 296128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.550582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319740", "Detail": { "ID": 319740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9392884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305952", "Detail": { "ID": 305952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3526016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309916", "Detail": { "ID": 309916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3564806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268812", "Detail": { "ID": 268812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2840882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293805", "Detail": { "ID": 293805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8696526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262163", "Detail": { "ID": 262163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3942497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268989", "Detail": { "ID": 268989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2987577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307362", "Detail": { "ID": 307362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8260102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280680", "Detail": { "ID": 280680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.77758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281009", "Detail": { "ID": 281009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7918235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245345", "Detail": { "ID": 245345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8308501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299947", "Detail": { "ID": 299947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7297452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302278", "Detail": { "ID": 302278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5174961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300157", "Detail": { "ID": 300157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7387578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224546", "Detail": { "ID": 224546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7094892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296928", "Detail": { "ID": 296928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8800381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320987", "Detail": { "ID": 320987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1969205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315532", "Detail": { "ID": 315532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9160672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237650", "Detail": { "ID": 237650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.219964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293467", "Detail": { "ID": 293467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8466324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233867", "Detail": { "ID": 233867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.149782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312436", "Detail": { "ID": 312436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1278159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286799", "Detail": { "ID": 286799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6011534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226130", "Detail": { "ID": 226130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0113057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265295", "Detail": { "ID": 265295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4330198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283911", "Detail": { "ID": 283911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7288064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258964", "Detail": { "ID": 258964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3358271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318206", "Detail": { "ID": 318206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.642641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256037", "Detail": { "ID": 256037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5677054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294002", "Detail": { "ID": 294002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8783891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236394", "Detail": { "ID": 236394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9149761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256400", "Detail": { "ID": 256400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7808706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229908", "Detail": { "ID": 229908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1025802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288451", "Detail": { "ID": 288451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.135404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310050", "Detail": { "ID": 310050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3623139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247204", "Detail": { "ID": 247204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3934731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299131", "Detail": { "ID": 299131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3887274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235704", "Detail": { "ID": 235704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6894678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275450", "Detail": { "ID": 275450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3757599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274205", "Detail": { "ID": 274205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0905232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316555", "Detail": { "ID": 316555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1532147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325951", "Detail": { "ID": 325951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5285904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241548", "Detail": { "ID": 241548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7695631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287891", "Detail": { "ID": 287891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8909925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248329", "Detail": { "ID": 248329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6412803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290110", "Detail": { "ID": 290110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4732352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222897", "Detail": { "ID": 222897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2093959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240726", "Detail": { "ID": 240726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3796923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284396", "Detail": { "ID": 284396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0245352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233082", "Detail": { "ID": 233082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246658", "Detail": { "ID": 246658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1477665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309691", "Detail": { "ID": 309691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2115, "AgendaID": 2055, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Common Agricultural Policy", "Reference": "S4M-07892", "ID": 8003 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-03T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3404939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259550", "Detail": { "ID": 259550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6139425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318026", "Detail": { "ID": 318026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4537609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250066", "Detail": { "ID": 250066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9619257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320795", "Detail": { "ID": 320795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1820292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229542", "Detail": { "ID": 229542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0862137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281631", "Detail": { "ID": 281631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1510362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263359", "Detail": { "ID": 263359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8860378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290743", "Detail": { "ID": 290743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.770304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227925", "Detail": { "ID": 227925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5715887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270631", "Detail": { "ID": 270631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8161094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322957", "Detail": { "ID": 322957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7110343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296596", "Detail": { "ID": 296596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8558521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242649", "Detail": { "ID": 242649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0294441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236608", "Detail": { "ID": 236608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9323366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301610", "Detail": { "ID": 301610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2699009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261272", "Detail": { "ID": 261272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3502342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316977", "Detail": { "ID": 316977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1763994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326623", "Detail": { "ID": 326623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7727035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278187", "Detail": { "ID": 278187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.990795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264893", "Detail": { "ID": 264893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1592449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249259", "Detail": { "ID": 249259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9188597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291205", "Detail": { "ID": 291205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1088131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285577", "Detail": { "ID": 285577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3352846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232126", "Detail": { "ID": 232126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6357254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243226", "Detail": { "ID": 243226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2882613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253888", "Detail": { "ID": 253888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0251635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321192", "Detail": { "ID": 321192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2062487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292324", "Detail": { "ID": 292324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5288623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273266", "Detail": { "ID": 273266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6078602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262929", "Detail": { "ID": 262929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6292987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282252", "Detail": { "ID": 282252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4047684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299018", "Detail": { "ID": 299018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3821573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230600", "Detail": { "ID": 230600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3373772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287220", "Detail": { "ID": 287220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8547947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219759", "Detail": { "ID": 219759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3132972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239033", "Detail": { "ID": 239033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4798673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226183", "Detail": { "ID": 226183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0135769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322339", "Detail": { "ID": 322339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.678525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292187", "Detail": { "ID": 292187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1600583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228236", "Detail": { "ID": 228236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7841362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304460", "Detail": { "ID": 304460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0391703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258213", "Detail": { "ID": 258213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2973866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271630", "Detail": { "ID": 271630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0844539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279008", "Detail": { "ID": 279008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2487628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266729", "Detail": { "ID": 266729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7540344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250864", "Detail": { "ID": 250864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2168271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221330", "Detail": { "ID": 221330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9274675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220894", "Detail": { "ID": 220894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6615455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240040", "Detail": { "ID": 240040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7701666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266985", "Detail": { "ID": 266985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7705151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324355", "Detail": { "ID": 324355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2131891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260828", "Detail": { "ID": 260828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0996607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246487", "Detail": { "ID": 246487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1308289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275770", "Detail": { "ID": 275770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3898172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303566", "Detail": { "ID": 303566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8208488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222198", "Detail": { "ID": 222198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9719559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242413", "Detail": { "ID": 242413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0121786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224637", "Detail": { "ID": 224637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7133971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308602", "Detail": { "ID": 308602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0629501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272602", "Detail": { "ID": 272602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3424429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244654", "Detail": { "ID": 244654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5725629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314676", "Detail": { "ID": 314676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6506787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251959", "Detail": { "ID": 251959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4964924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275577", "Detail": { "ID": 275577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3815228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257016", "Detail": { "ID": 257016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8196993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283069", "Detail": { "ID": 283069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4509908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254168", "Detail": { "ID": 254168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0375497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278408", "Detail": { "ID": 278408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2175046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324930", "Detail": { "ID": 324930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2438923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232009", "Detail": { "ID": 232009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6252861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312928", "Detail": { "ID": 312928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1559252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232577", "Detail": { "ID": 232577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.866893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267632", "Detail": { "ID": 267632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0282709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314429", "Detail": { "ID": 314429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6395584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296124", "Detail": { "ID": 296124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5504208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319744", "Detail": { "ID": 319744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9394726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305836", "Detail": { "ID": 305836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.347428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309912", "Detail": { "ID": 309912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3562928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268808", "Detail": { "ID": 268808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2839252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293809", "Detail": { "ID": 293809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8698122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262197", "Detail": { "ID": 262197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.590951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269028", "Detail": { "ID": 269028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3004048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307366", "Detail": { "ID": 307366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8262058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280641", "Detail": { "ID": 280641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7759277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281013", "Detail": { "ID": 281013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7920041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245230", "Detail": { "ID": 245230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8256513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299943", "Detail": { "ID": 299943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7295843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302274", "Detail": { "ID": 302274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5173334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300161", "Detail": { "ID": 300161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7389202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224542", "Detail": { "ID": 224542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7093077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297507", "Detail": { "ID": 297507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1031792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320983", "Detail": { "ID": 320983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1967365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315405", "Detail": { "ID": 315405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9106127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237646", "Detail": { "ID": 237646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2198012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293471", "Detail": { "ID": 293471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8468167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233887", "Detail": { "ID": 233887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1506463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311998", "Detail": { "ID": 311998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9093374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286795", "Detail": { "ID": 286795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6009747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226084", "Detail": { "ID": 226084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0093491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265470", "Detail": { "ID": 265470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4405718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283842", "Detail": { "ID": 283842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7258109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258769", "Detail": { "ID": 258769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3271531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318202", "Detail": { "ID": 318202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6423564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256041", "Detail": { "ID": 256041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5678786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293998", "Detail": { "ID": 293998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8782059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236358", "Detail": { "ID": 236358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9133805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256381", "Detail": { "ID": 256381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7800766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229904", "Detail": { "ID": 229904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1024182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289396", "Detail": { "ID": 289396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4354383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310486", "Detail": { "ID": 310486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5729486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247200", "Detail": { "ID": 247200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.393308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299135", "Detail": { "ID": 299135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3889645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235708", "Detail": { "ID": 235708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6896276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275411", "Detail": { "ID": 275411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3740898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274209", "Detail": { "ID": 274209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0906926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316835", "Detail": { "ID": 316835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.16551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326053", "Detail": { "ID": 326053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5378155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241544", "Detail": { "ID": 241544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7693826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288631", "Detail": { "ID": 288631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1517253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248292", "Detail": { "ID": 248292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6396232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290791", "Detail": { "ID": 290791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.772329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222852", "Detail": { "ID": 222852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2074681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240730", "Detail": { "ID": 240730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3798563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284071", "Detail": { "ID": 284071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7417509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233086", "Detail": { "ID": 233086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8961918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246694", "Detail": { "ID": 246694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1494407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309687", "Detail": { "ID": 309687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2112, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 88, "VoteAgainst": 24, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-07877", "ID": 13108 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3403298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259530", "Detail": { "ID": 259530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6130835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318029", "Detail": { "ID": 318029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4539002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250069", "Detail": { "ID": 250069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9620466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320792", "Detail": { "ID": 320792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1818889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229511", "Detail": { "ID": 229511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0849018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281660", "Detail": { "ID": 281660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1522522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263312", "Detail": { "ID": 263312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8840321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290733", "Detail": { "ID": 290733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.769881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227922", "Detail": { "ID": 227922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5714458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270651", "Detail": { "ID": 270651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8169538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322927", "Detail": { "ID": 322927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7097676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297384", "Detail": { "ID": 297384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0976354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242615", "Detail": { "ID": 242615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.027954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236611", "Detail": { "ID": 236611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9324791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301595", "Detail": { "ID": 301595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2692498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261938", "Detail": { "ID": 261938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.384659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM317007", "Detail": { "ID": 317007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1776897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326626", "Detail": { "ID": 326626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7728439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278141", "Detail": { "ID": 278141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9887967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264940", "Detail": { "ID": 264940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1612628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249262", "Detail": { "ID": 249262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.918982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291208", "Detail": { "ID": 291208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1089426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285532", "Detail": { "ID": 285532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3333601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232079", "Detail": { "ID": 232079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6336181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243260", "Detail": { "ID": 243260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2897064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253903", "Detail": { "ID": 253903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0257922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321195", "Detail": { "ID": 321195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2063727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292007", "Detail": { "ID": 292007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1518662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273219", "Detail": { "ID": 273219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6058239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262926", "Detail": { "ID": 262926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6291707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282223", "Detail": { "ID": 282223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4035035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299049", "Detail": { "ID": 299049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3839174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230603", "Detail": { "ID": 230603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3374989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287223", "Detail": { "ID": 287223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8549405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219756", "Detail": { "ID": 219756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3131754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239053", "Detail": { "ID": 239053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4807332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226186", "Detail": { "ID": 226186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0137177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322369", "Detail": { "ID": 322369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6797917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292190", "Detail": { "ID": 292190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1657248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228233", "Detail": { "ID": 228233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7839933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304445", "Detail": { "ID": 304445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0385351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258210", "Detail": { "ID": 258210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2972571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271633", "Detail": { "ID": 271633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0845759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278979", "Detail": { "ID": 278979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.24253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266714", "Detail": { "ID": 266714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7533693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250861", "Detail": { "ID": 250861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2166702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221327", "Detail": { "ID": 221327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.927344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220897", "Detail": { "ID": 220897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.661687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240025", "Detail": { "ID": 240025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7695263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266956", "Detail": { "ID": 266956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7692874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324352", "Detail": { "ID": 324352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2130482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260831", "Detail": { "ID": 260831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0998042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246160", "Detail": { "ID": 246160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8747799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276124", "Detail": { "ID": 276124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4114918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303581", "Detail": { "ID": 303581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8214825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222201", "Detail": { "ID": 222201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9720773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242416", "Detail": { "ID": 242416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0123032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224640", "Detail": { "ID": 224640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7135214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308633", "Detail": { "ID": 308633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0642715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272599", "Detail": { "ID": 272599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.342321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244465", "Detail": { "ID": 244465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5559275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314673", "Detail": { "ID": 314673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6505546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251979", "Detail": { "ID": 251979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4973633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275574", "Detail": { "ID": 275574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3813813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257037", "Detail": { "ID": 257037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8205969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283072", "Detail": { "ID": 283072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4511138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254148", "Detail": { "ID": 254148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0365689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278411", "Detail": { "ID": 278411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2176271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324933", "Detail": { "ID": 324933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2440135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232006", "Detail": { "ID": 232006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6251643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312958", "Detail": { "ID": 312958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1572179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232580", "Detail": { "ID": 232580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8670379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267661", "Detail": { "ID": 267661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0295412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314244", "Detail": { "ID": 314244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6285724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296093", "Detail": { "ID": 296093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5490851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319774", "Detail": { "ID": 319774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9407672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305839", "Detail": { "ID": 305839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.347551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309909", "Detail": { "ID": 309909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3561707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268779", "Detail": { "ID": 268779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2823131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293838", "Detail": { "ID": 293838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8710352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262200", "Detail": { "ID": 262200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5911593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269341", "Detail": { "ID": 269341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5433717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307369", "Detail": { "ID": 307369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8263578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280638", "Detail": { "ID": 280638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7758074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281213", "Detail": { "ID": 281213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1251336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245233", "Detail": { "ID": 245233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8257946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299912", "Detail": { "ID": 299912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7282716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302271", "Detail": { "ID": 302271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5172114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300164", "Detail": { "ID": 300164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7390616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224539", "Detail": { "ID": 224539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7091849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297504", "Detail": { "ID": 297504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1030391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320953", "Detail": { "ID": 320953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1887978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315408", "Detail": { "ID": 315408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9107345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237600", "Detail": { "ID": 237600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2177812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292529", "Detail": { "ID": 292529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5379253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233902", "Detail": { "ID": 233902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1512949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312001", "Detail": { "ID": 312001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9094588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286792", "Detail": { "ID": 286792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6008553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226081", "Detail": { "ID": 226081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0092282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265485", "Detail": { "ID": 265485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4412076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283833", "Detail": { "ID": 283833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7254237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258766", "Detail": { "ID": 258766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3270126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318172", "Detail": { "ID": 318172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4601584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256044", "Detail": { "ID": 256044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.568001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293995", "Detail": { "ID": 293995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8780843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236355", "Detail": { "ID": 236355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.913252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256366", "Detail": { "ID": 256366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7794232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229901", "Detail": { "ID": 229901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1022976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289411", "Detail": { "ID": 289411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4360948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310483", "Detail": { "ID": 310483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5728263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247197", "Detail": { "ID": 247197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3931776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298657", "Detail": { "ID": 298657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3556293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235754", "Detail": { "ID": 235754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6915747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275408", "Detail": { "ID": 275408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.373966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274238", "Detail": { "ID": 274238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0919619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316832", "Detail": { "ID": 316832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1653885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326050", "Detail": { "ID": 326050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5330702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241541", "Detail": { "ID": 241541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7692614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288628", "Detail": { "ID": 288628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1515831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248289", "Detail": { "ID": 248289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6394806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290800", "Detail": { "ID": 290800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7726973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222849", "Detail": { "ID": 222849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2073469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240733", "Detail": { "ID": 240733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3799764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284068", "Detail": { "ID": 284068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7416262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251578", "Detail": { "ID": 251578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4698747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246697", "Detail": { "ID": 246697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1495814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309656", "Detail": { "ID": 309656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2109, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.4", "ID": 8007 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3390155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259531", "Detail": { "ID": 259531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.613124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318070", "Detail": { "ID": 318070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4556311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250070", "Detail": { "ID": 250070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9620868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320760", "Detail": { "ID": 320760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1805417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229510", "Detail": { "ID": 229510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0848614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281661", "Detail": { "ID": 281661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1522919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263311", "Detail": { "ID": 263311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8839895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290732", "Detail": { "ID": 290732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7698405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227921", "Detail": { "ID": 227921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5714045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270650", "Detail": { "ID": 270650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8169127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322926", "Detail": { "ID": 322926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7097267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297383", "Detail": { "ID": 297383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0975944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242607", "Detail": { "ID": 242607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0276119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236612", "Detail": { "ID": 236612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9325201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301594", "Detail": { "ID": 301594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2692093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261939", "Detail": { "ID": 261939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3846993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM317008", "Detail": { "ID": 317008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.177731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326666", "Detail": { "ID": 326666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7748769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278140", "Detail": { "ID": 278140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9887554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264941", "Detail": { "ID": 264941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1613045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249263", "Detail": { "ID": 249263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9190415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293559", "Detail": { "ID": 293559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8505782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285531", "Detail": { "ID": 285531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.333319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232078", "Detail": { "ID": 232078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6335592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243268", "Detail": { "ID": 243268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2900556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253904", "Detail": { "ID": 253904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0258321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321389", "Detail": { "ID": 321389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4337481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292008", "Detail": { "ID": 292008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1519082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273218", "Detail": { "ID": 273218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6057823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262925", "Detail": { "ID": 262925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6291301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282222", "Detail": { "ID": 282222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4034619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299050", "Detail": { "ID": 299050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3839699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230604", "Detail": { "ID": 230604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3375389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287224", "Detail": { "ID": 287224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8549814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219755", "Detail": { "ID": 219755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3131339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239052", "Detail": { "ID": 239052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4806926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226187", "Detail": { "ID": 226187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0137582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322370", "Detail": { "ID": 322370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6798327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292191", "Detail": { "ID": 292191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1657686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228232", "Detail": { "ID": 228232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7839522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304444", "Detail": { "ID": 304444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.038495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258209", "Detail": { "ID": 258209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2972049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271634", "Detail": { "ID": 271634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0846359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278978", "Detail": { "ID": 278978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2424874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266713", "Detail": { "ID": 266713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7533282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250860", "Detail": { "ID": 250860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2166299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221326", "Detail": { "ID": 221326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9272959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220898", "Detail": { "ID": 220898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6617277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240024", "Detail": { "ID": 240024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7694649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266955", "Detail": { "ID": 266955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7692274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324312", "Detail": { "ID": 324312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2113375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260832", "Detail": { "ID": 260832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0998456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246468", "Detail": { "ID": 246468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1300276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276125", "Detail": { "ID": 276125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4115321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303582", "Detail": { "ID": 303582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8215233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222202", "Detail": { "ID": 222202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9721174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242417", "Detail": { "ID": 242417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0123441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224641", "Detail": { "ID": 224641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7135624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308634", "Detail": { "ID": 308634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0643112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272598", "Detail": { "ID": 272598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3422807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244457", "Detail": { "ID": 244457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5555622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314632", "Detail": { "ID": 314632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6484634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251978", "Detail": { "ID": 251978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4972918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275573", "Detail": { "ID": 275573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3813403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257036", "Detail": { "ID": 257036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8205571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283073", "Detail": { "ID": 283073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4511561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254149", "Detail": { "ID": 254149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0366095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278719", "Detail": { "ID": 278719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2313561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324973", "Detail": { "ID": 324973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2457346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232005", "Detail": { "ID": 232005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6251237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312959", "Detail": { "ID": 312959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1572583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232581", "Detail": { "ID": 232581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8670798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267662", "Detail": { "ID": 267662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0295828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314243", "Detail": { "ID": 314243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6285312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296092", "Detail": { "ID": 296092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5490451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319775", "Detail": { "ID": 319775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9408082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305877", "Detail": { "ID": 305877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.349193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309908", "Detail": { "ID": 309908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3561303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268778", "Detail": { "ID": 268778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2822729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293839", "Detail": { "ID": 293839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8710753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262201", "Detail": { "ID": 262201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5912116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269342", "Detail": { "ID": 269342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5434132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307370", "Detail": { "ID": 307370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8263994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280637", "Detail": { "ID": 280637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7757674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281214", "Detail": { "ID": 281214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1251743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245271", "Detail": { "ID": 245271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8276502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299911", "Detail": { "ID": 299911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7282316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302270", "Detail": { "ID": 302270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.51717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300165", "Detail": { "ID": 300165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7391035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224538", "Detail": { "ID": 224538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.709144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297465", "Detail": { "ID": 297465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1013814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320952", "Detail": { "ID": 320952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1887572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315449", "Detail": { "ID": 315449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9124961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237599", "Detail": { "ID": 237599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2177405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292530", "Detail": { "ID": 292530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5379661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233903", "Detail": { "ID": 233903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1513359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312041", "Detail": { "ID": 312041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.911176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286791", "Detail": { "ID": 286791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6008156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226080", "Detail": { "ID": 226080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0091876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265486", "Detail": { "ID": 265486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4412488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283834", "Detail": { "ID": 283834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7254638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258765", "Detail": { "ID": 258765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3269722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318171", "Detail": { "ID": 318171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.460116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256045", "Detail": { "ID": 256045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5680417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293994", "Detail": { "ID": 293994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.878043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236354", "Detail": { "ID": 236354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9131957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256365", "Detail": { "ID": 256365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7793828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229900", "Detail": { "ID": 229900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1022563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289412", "Detail": { "ID": 289412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4361366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310444", "Detail": { "ID": 310444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5709134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247196", "Detail": { "ID": 247196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3931361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298658", "Detail": { "ID": 298658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.355672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235755", "Detail": { "ID": 235755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6916141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275407", "Detail": { "ID": 275407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3739042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274239", "Detail": { "ID": 274239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0920028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316791", "Detail": { "ID": 316791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1636427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326010", "Detail": { "ID": 326010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5313637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241540", "Detail": { "ID": 241540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7692209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287972", "Detail": { "ID": 287972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8945077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248288", "Detail": { "ID": 248288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6394395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290799", "Detail": { "ID": 290799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.772658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222848", "Detail": { "ID": 222848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2073066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240734", "Detail": { "ID": 240734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.380017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284067", "Detail": { "ID": 284067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.741583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251579", "Detail": { "ID": 251579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4699167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246698", "Detail": { "ID": 246698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1496215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309655", "Detail": { "ID": 309655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2108, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.3", "ID": 8006 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.338975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259529", "Detail": { "ID": 259529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6130427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318028", "Detail": { "ID": 318028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4538417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250068", "Detail": { "ID": 250068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9620066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320793", "Detail": { "ID": 320793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1819474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229512", "Detail": { "ID": 229512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0849417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281659", "Detail": { "ID": 281659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1522128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263313", "Detail": { "ID": 263313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8840734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290734", "Detail": { "ID": 290734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7699211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227923", "Detail": { "ID": 227923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5714879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270652", "Detail": { "ID": 270652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8170692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322928", "Detail": { "ID": 322928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7098089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297385", "Detail": { "ID": 297385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0976758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242647", "Detail": { "ID": 242647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0293523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236610", "Detail": { "ID": 236610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9324367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301596", "Detail": { "ID": 301596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2692903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261937", "Detail": { "ID": 261937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3846188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM317006", "Detail": { "ID": 317006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1776489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326625", "Detail": { "ID": 326625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.772785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278142", "Detail": { "ID": 278142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9888555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264939", "Detail": { "ID": 264939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1612038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249261", "Detail": { "ID": 249261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9189411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291207", "Detail": { "ID": 291207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1089007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285533", "Detail": { "ID": 285533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3334008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232080", "Detail": { "ID": 232080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6336605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243228", "Detail": { "ID": 243228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2883422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253902", "Detail": { "ID": 253902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0257517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321194", "Detail": { "ID": 321194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2063321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292326", "Detail": { "ID": 292326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5289438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273220", "Detail": { "ID": 273220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6058648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262927", "Detail": { "ID": 262927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6292122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282224", "Detail": { "ID": 282224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4035462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299048", "Detail": { "ID": 299048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3838494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230602", "Detail": { "ID": 230602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3374586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287222", "Detail": { "ID": 287222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8548994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219757", "Detail": { "ID": 219757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3132163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239054", "Detail": { "ID": 239054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.480774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226185", "Detail": { "ID": 226185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0136765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322368", "Detail": { "ID": 322368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6797499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292189", "Detail": { "ID": 292189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1656456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228234", "Detail": { "ID": 228234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7840349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304446", "Detail": { "ID": 304446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0385752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258211", "Detail": { "ID": 258211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2973039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271632", "Detail": { "ID": 271632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.084536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278980", "Detail": { "ID": 278980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2425704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266715", "Detail": { "ID": 266715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7534276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250862", "Detail": { "ID": 250862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2167405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221328", "Detail": { "ID": 221328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9273853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220896", "Detail": { "ID": 220896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.661646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240026", "Detail": { "ID": 240026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7695684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266957", "Detail": { "ID": 266957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7693292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324353", "Detail": { "ID": 324353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2130888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260830", "Detail": { "ID": 260830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.099762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246159", "Detail": { "ID": 246159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8747394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276123", "Detail": { "ID": 276123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4114517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303580", "Detail": { "ID": 303580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8214425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222200", "Detail": { "ID": 222200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9720369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242415", "Detail": { "ID": 242415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0122616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224639", "Detail": { "ID": 224639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7134796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308632", "Detail": { "ID": 308632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0642312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272600", "Detail": { "ID": 272600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3423621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244652", "Detail": { "ID": 244652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5724816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314674", "Detail": { "ID": 314674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6505952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251980", "Detail": { "ID": 251980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4974057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275575", "Detail": { "ID": 275575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3814222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257038", "Detail": { "ID": 257038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8206372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283071", "Detail": { "ID": 283071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4510737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254147", "Detail": { "ID": 254147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0365281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278410", "Detail": { "ID": 278410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2175863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324932", "Detail": { "ID": 324932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2439732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232007", "Detail": { "ID": 232007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6252048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312957", "Detail": { "ID": 312957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1571772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232579", "Detail": { "ID": 232579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8669764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267660", "Detail": { "ID": 267660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0295006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314245", "Detail": { "ID": 314245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6286143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296094", "Detail": { "ID": 296094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5491253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319773", "Detail": { "ID": 319773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9407244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305838", "Detail": { "ID": 305838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.34751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309910", "Detail": { "ID": 309910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3562118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268780", "Detail": { "ID": 268780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.282354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293837", "Detail": { "ID": 293837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8709947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262199", "Detail": { "ID": 262199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5911053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269340", "Detail": { "ID": 269340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5433293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307368", "Detail": { "ID": 307368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8262934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280639", "Detail": { "ID": 280639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7758473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281212", "Detail": { "ID": 281212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1250929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245232", "Detail": { "ID": 245232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8257528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299913", "Detail": { "ID": 299913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7283113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302272", "Detail": { "ID": 302272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5172519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300163", "Detail": { "ID": 300163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7390025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224540", "Detail": { "ID": 224540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7092262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297505", "Detail": { "ID": 297505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.10308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320954", "Detail": { "ID": 320954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.188839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315407", "Detail": { "ID": 315407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.910694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237601", "Detail": { "ID": 237601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2178213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292528", "Detail": { "ID": 292528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5378841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233901", "Detail": { "ID": 233901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.151254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312000", "Detail": { "ID": 312000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9094181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286793", "Detail": { "ID": 286793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6008947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226082", "Detail": { "ID": 226082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0092681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265484", "Detail": { "ID": 265484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4411673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283844", "Detail": { "ID": 283844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7258914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258767", "Detail": { "ID": 258767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3270532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318173", "Detail": { "ID": 318173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4602984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256043", "Detail": { "ID": 256043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5679605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293996", "Detail": { "ID": 293996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8781246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236356", "Detail": { "ID": 236356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9132962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256367", "Detail": { "ID": 256367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7794636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229902", "Detail": { "ID": 229902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1023375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289410", "Detail": { "ID": 289410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4360351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310484", "Detail": { "ID": 310484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5728672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247198", "Detail": { "ID": 247198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3932177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298656", "Detail": { "ID": 298656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3555703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235753", "Detail": { "ID": 235753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6915338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275409", "Detail": { "ID": 275409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.374008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274237", "Detail": { "ID": 274237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0919215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316833", "Detail": { "ID": 316833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1654298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326051", "Detail": { "ID": 326051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5331104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241542", "Detail": { "ID": 241542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7693013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288629", "Detail": { "ID": 288629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1516422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248290", "Detail": { "ID": 248290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6395219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290789", "Detail": { "ID": 290789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7722311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222850", "Detail": { "ID": 222850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2073867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240732", "Detail": { "ID": 240732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3799365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284069", "Detail": { "ID": 284069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7416675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251577", "Detail": { "ID": 251577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4698326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246696", "Detail": { "ID": 246696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1495404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309657", "Detail": { "ID": 309657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2110, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872.1", "ID": 8002 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3390555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259551", "Detail": { "ID": 259551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6139834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318027", "Detail": { "ID": 318027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4538013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250067", "Detail": { "ID": 250067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9619661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320794", "Detail": { "ID": 320794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1819886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229513", "Detail": { "ID": 229513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0849817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281658", "Detail": { "ID": 281658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1521731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263358", "Detail": { "ID": 263358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8859972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290742", "Detail": { "ID": 290742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7702639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227924", "Detail": { "ID": 227924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5715295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270630", "Detail": { "ID": 270630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8160503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322955", "Detail": { "ID": 322955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7109535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296595", "Detail": { "ID": 296595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8558116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242648", "Detail": { "ID": 242648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0293951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236609", "Detail": { "ID": 236609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9323774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301597", "Detail": { "ID": 301597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2693496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261273", "Detail": { "ID": 261273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3502764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316979", "Detail": { "ID": 316979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1764801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326624", "Detail": { "ID": 326624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7727446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278186", "Detail": { "ID": 278186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9907526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264894", "Detail": { "ID": 264894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1592855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249260", "Detail": { "ID": 249260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9189005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291206", "Detail": { "ID": 291206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1088571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285576", "Detail": { "ID": 285576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3352256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232102", "Detail": { "ID": 232102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6346035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243227", "Detail": { "ID": 243227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2883016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253901", "Detail": { "ID": 253901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0257121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321193", "Detail": { "ID": 321193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.206291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292325", "Detail": { "ID": 292325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5289036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273265", "Detail": { "ID": 273265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6078194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262928", "Detail": { "ID": 262928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.629253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282225", "Detail": { "ID": 282225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4035875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299047", "Detail": { "ID": 299047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.383787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230601", "Detail": { "ID": 230601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3374186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287221", "Detail": { "ID": 287221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8548567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219758", "Detail": { "ID": 219758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3132567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239032", "Detail": { "ID": 239032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4798271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226184", "Detail": { "ID": 226184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0136178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322341", "Detail": { "ID": 322341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6786081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292188", "Detail": { "ID": 292188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1655819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228235", "Detail": { "ID": 228235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7840764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304447", "Detail": { "ID": 304447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0386156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258212", "Detail": { "ID": 258212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2973452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271631", "Detail": { "ID": 271631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0844945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278981", "Detail": { "ID": 278981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2426109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266716", "Detail": { "ID": 266716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7534697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250863", "Detail": { "ID": 250863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2167861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221329", "Detail": { "ID": 221329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9274267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220895", "Detail": { "ID": 220895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.661604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240027", "Detail": { "ID": 240027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7696088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266958", "Detail": { "ID": 266958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7693703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324354", "Detail": { "ID": 324354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2131299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260829", "Detail": { "ID": 260829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0997022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246488", "Detail": { "ID": 246488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1308887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275771", "Detail": { "ID": 275771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3898575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303579", "Detail": { "ID": 303579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8214022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222199", "Detail": { "ID": 222199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9719967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242414", "Detail": { "ID": 242414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.012221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224638", "Detail": { "ID": 224638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7134383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308631", "Detail": { "ID": 308631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0641909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272601", "Detail": { "ID": 272601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3424024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244653", "Detail": { "ID": 244653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5725227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314675", "Detail": { "ID": 314675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6506369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251958", "Detail": { "ID": 251958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4964516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275576", "Detail": { "ID": 275576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3814639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257015", "Detail": { "ID": 257015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8196592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283070", "Detail": { "ID": 283070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4510328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254169", "Detail": { "ID": 254169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0375899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278409", "Detail": { "ID": 278409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2175459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324931", "Detail": { "ID": 324931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2439328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232008", "Detail": { "ID": 232008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6252454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312956", "Detail": { "ID": 312956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1571348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232578", "Detail": { "ID": 232578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8669342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267659", "Detail": { "ID": 267659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0294597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314246", "Detail": { "ID": 314246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.628655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296095", "Detail": { "ID": 296095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5491653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319746", "Detail": { "ID": 319746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9395544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305837", "Detail": { "ID": 305837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.347469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309911", "Detail": { "ID": 309911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3562521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268781", "Detail": { "ID": 268781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2823943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293836", "Detail": { "ID": 293836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8709364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262198", "Detail": { "ID": 262198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5910032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269339", "Detail": { "ID": 269339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5432695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307367", "Detail": { "ID": 307367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8262523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280640", "Detail": { "ID": 280640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7758879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281014", "Detail": { "ID": 281014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7920455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245231", "Detail": { "ID": 245231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8256924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299914", "Detail": { "ID": 299914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7283516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302273", "Detail": { "ID": 302273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5172927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300162", "Detail": { "ID": 300162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7389605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224541", "Detail": { "ID": 224541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7092672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297506", "Detail": { "ID": 297506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1031214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320981", "Detail": { "ID": 320981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1900131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315406", "Detail": { "ID": 315406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.910653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237645", "Detail": { "ID": 237645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2197593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293472", "Detail": { "ID": 293472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8468571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233900", "Detail": { "ID": 233900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1512123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311999", "Detail": { "ID": 311999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9093776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286794", "Detail": { "ID": 286794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6009344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226083", "Detail": { "ID": 226083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0093087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265483", "Detail": { "ID": 265483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4411265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283843", "Detail": { "ID": 283843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7258511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258768", "Detail": { "ID": 258768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3270936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318200", "Detail": { "ID": 318200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4615594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256042", "Detail": { "ID": 256042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5679194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293997", "Detail": { "ID": 293997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8781651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236357", "Detail": { "ID": 236357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.913339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256368", "Detail": { "ID": 256368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7795039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229903", "Detail": { "ID": 229903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1023779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289409", "Detail": { "ID": 289409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4359943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310485", "Detail": { "ID": 310485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5729085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247199", "Detail": { "ID": 247199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3932595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299136", "Detail": { "ID": 299136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3890199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235709", "Detail": { "ID": 235709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6896678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275410", "Detail": { "ID": 275410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3740487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274236", "Detail": { "ID": 274236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0918801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316834", "Detail": { "ID": 316834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1654699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326052", "Detail": { "ID": 326052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5331697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241543", "Detail": { "ID": 241543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.769342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288630", "Detail": { "ID": 288630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.151684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248291", "Detail": { "ID": 248291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.639582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290790", "Detail": { "ID": 290790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7722711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222851", "Detail": { "ID": 222851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.207428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240731", "Detail": { "ID": 240731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3798965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284070", "Detail": { "ID": 284070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7417092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251576", "Detail": { "ID": 251576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4697828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246695", "Detail": { "ID": 246695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1494804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309658", "Detail": { "ID": 309658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2111, "AgendaID": 2996, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "The Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-07872", "ID": 7985 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-10-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3390964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269281", "Detail": { "ID": 269281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5407021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318387", "Detail": { "ID": 318387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6554159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249912", "Detail": { "ID": 249912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9553314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320464", "Detail": { "ID": 320464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1675342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230292", "Detail": { "ID": 230292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3165129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281464", "Detail": { "ID": 281464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1439588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263632", "Detail": { "ID": 263632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8980167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289072", "Detail": { "ID": 289072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1708572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228682", "Detail": { "ID": 228682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8096412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270345", "Detail": { "ID": 270345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8036489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323259", "Detail": { "ID": 323259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9420175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296511", "Detail": { "ID": 296511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.85221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229089", "Detail": { "ID": 229089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8339946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236149", "Detail": { "ID": 236149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7135861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300959", "Detail": { "ID": 300959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0262664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261141", "Detail": { "ID": 261141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1135875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316688", "Detail": { "ID": 316688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1589232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326819", "Detail": { "ID": 326819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.781423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278629", "Detail": { "ID": 278629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2274991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264766", "Detail": { "ID": 264766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1479391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249079", "Detail": { "ID": 249079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6829692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294020", "Detail": { "ID": 294020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8791495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287725", "Detail": { "ID": 287725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8835775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233469", "Detail": { "ID": 233469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1318979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243435", "Detail": { "ID": 243435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.297632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253266", "Detail": { "ID": 253266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9889073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323100", "Detail": { "ID": 323100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7220218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300779", "Detail": { "ID": 300779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0185081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273393", "Detail": { "ID": 273393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.618224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263263", "Detail": { "ID": 263263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8817904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282419", "Detail": { "ID": 282419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4120575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298853", "Detail": { "ID": 298853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3749497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230577", "Detail": { "ID": 230577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3363949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286478", "Detail": { "ID": 286478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.587567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219940", "Detail": { "ID": 219940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3212426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238747", "Detail": { "ID": 238747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.467301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225876", "Detail": { "ID": 225876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9942313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322177", "Detail": { "ID": 322177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4747171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290271", "Detail": { "ID": 290271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7396511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228872", "Detail": { "ID": 228872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8178846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304675", "Detail": { "ID": 304675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0485857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258369", "Detail": { "ID": 258369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3042624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274437", "Detail": { "ID": 274437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1065038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279483", "Detail": { "ID": 279483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5096563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267039", "Detail": { "ID": 267039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7728371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253635", "Detail": { "ID": 253635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.004949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221480", "Detail": { "ID": 221480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9345549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220560", "Detail": { "ID": 220560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6466377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240350", "Detail": { "ID": 240350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3559759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266581", "Detail": { "ID": 266581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7473194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324149", "Detail": { "ID": 324149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9943013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260181", "Detail": { "ID": 260181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6472608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247060", "Detail": { "ID": 247060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1653389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275640", "Detail": { "ID": 275640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3842323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303756", "Detail": { "ID": 303756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8343502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222045", "Detail": { "ID": 222045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9650084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242262", "Detail": { "ID": 242262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0053536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224326", "Detail": { "ID": 224326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6998262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308283", "Detail": { "ID": 308283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.048931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272754", "Detail": { "ID": 272754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3489471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244142", "Detail": { "ID": 244142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3355505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314312", "Detail": { "ID": 314312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6342707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251210", "Detail": { "ID": 251210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4535828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276494", "Detail": { "ID": 276494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6685393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256273", "Detail": { "ID": 256273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7754713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282464", "Detail": { "ID": 282464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4200105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255059", "Detail": { "ID": 255059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2954562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277762", "Detail": { "ID": 277762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9673489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325136", "Detail": { "ID": 325136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2576922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232351", "Detail": { "ID": 232351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8510963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312266", "Detail": { "ID": 312266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1201914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231485", "Detail": { "ID": 231485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6026402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267869", "Detail": { "ID": 267869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0387565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314749", "Detail": { "ID": 314749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6538358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296739", "Detail": { "ID": 296739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8718506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319427", "Detail": { "ID": 319427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9254459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306031", "Detail": { "ID": 306031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3560194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309031", "Detail": { "ID": 309031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0890264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268560", "Detail": { "ID": 268560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2725236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293192", "Detail": { "ID": 293192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5755478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261576", "Detail": { "ID": 261576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3634442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264502", "Detail": { "ID": 264502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1362859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307774", "Detail": { "ID": 307774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8443399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282669", "Detail": { "ID": 282669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4290814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280884", "Detail": { "ID": 280884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7864943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245422", "Detail": { "ID": 245422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8341602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304882", "Detail": { "ID": 304882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0627862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303252", "Detail": { "ID": 303252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8068377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297022", "Detail": { "ID": 297022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.88435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224847", "Detail": { "ID": 224847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7226574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296851", "Detail": { "ID": 296851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8768037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321288", "Detail": { "ID": 321288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4217159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315613", "Detail": { "ID": 315613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9195402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238078", "Detail": { "ID": 238078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2386111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293549", "Detail": { "ID": 293549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8501461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233582", "Detail": { "ID": 233582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1372019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312518", "Detail": { "ID": 312518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1313809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287631", "Detail": { "ID": 287631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8795908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226551", "Detail": { "ID": 226551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2363343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265158", "Detail": { "ID": 265158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1709893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284449", "Detail": { "ID": 284449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0330337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259104", "Detail": { "ID": 259104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3418924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318519", "Detail": { "ID": 318519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6616746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255581", "Detail": { "ID": 255581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5375029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295152", "Detail": { "ID": 295152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1947284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236845", "Detail": { "ID": 236845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9427651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256846", "Detail": { "ID": 256846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8124001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239556", "Detail": { "ID": 239556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7488448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290515", "Detail": { "ID": 290515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7504117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309968", "Detail": { "ID": 309968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3587358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247660", "Detail": { "ID": 247660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4229824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299218", "Detail": { "ID": 299218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6879722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235266", "Detail": { "ID": 235266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6630503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275902", "Detail": { "ID": 275902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3958985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274043", "Detail": { "ID": 274043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.651911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316475", "Detail": { "ID": 316475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1494981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325847", "Detail": { "ID": 325847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5240217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241698", "Detail": { "ID": 241698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7759953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287035", "Detail": { "ID": 287035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6114191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248469", "Detail": { "ID": 248469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6473548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289113", "Detail": { "ID": 289113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.172604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223004", "Detail": { "ID": 223004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2246041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240577", "Detail": { "ID": 240577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3732433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284673", "Detail": { "ID": 284673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0426683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232954", "Detail": { "ID": 232954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8838115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246213", "Detail": { "ID": 246213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1189891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310158", "Detail": { "ID": 310158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2104, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791.3", "ID": 7918 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3670138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269280", "Detail": { "ID": 269280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5406563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318386", "Detail": { "ID": 318386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6553569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249911", "Detail": { "ID": 249911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9552915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320465", "Detail": { "ID": 320465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1675754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230293", "Detail": { "ID": 230293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3165535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281463", "Detail": { "ID": 281463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1439182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263633", "Detail": { "ID": 263633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.898057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289073", "Detail": { "ID": 289073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1708989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228683", "Detail": { "ID": 228683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8096822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270346", "Detail": { "ID": 270346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.80369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323263", "Detail": { "ID": 323263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.942212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296494", "Detail": { "ID": 296494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8514739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229098", "Detail": { "ID": 229098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8343937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236148", "Detail": { "ID": 236148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7135462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300960", "Detail": { "ID": 300960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0263077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261140", "Detail": { "ID": 261140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1135468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316687", "Detail": { "ID": 316687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1588822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326818", "Detail": { "ID": 326818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7813822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278630", "Detail": { "ID": 278630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2275403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264765", "Detail": { "ID": 264765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1478985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249078", "Detail": { "ID": 249078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6829287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294019", "Detail": { "ID": 294019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8791082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287799", "Detail": { "ID": 287799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.886803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233470", "Detail": { "ID": 233470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1319399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243426", "Detail": { "ID": 243426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2972543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253265", "Detail": { "ID": 253265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9888661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323099", "Detail": { "ID": 323099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7219811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300778", "Detail": { "ID": 300778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.018467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273394", "Detail": { "ID": 273394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6182661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263264", "Detail": { "ID": 263264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8818307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282420", "Detail": { "ID": 282420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.412099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298852", "Detail": { "ID": 298852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3749097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230576", "Detail": { "ID": 230576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3363543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286477", "Detail": { "ID": 286477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5875256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219941", "Detail": { "ID": 219941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.321283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238748", "Detail": { "ID": 238748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4673411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225875", "Detail": { "ID": 225875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9941908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322173", "Detail": { "ID": 322173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4744556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290270", "Detail": { "ID": 290270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7396097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228873", "Detail": { "ID": 228873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8179256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304676", "Detail": { "ID": 304676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0486263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258370", "Detail": { "ID": 258370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3043032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274436", "Detail": { "ID": 274436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1064451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279484", "Detail": { "ID": 279484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.509697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267040", "Detail": { "ID": 267040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.772878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253636", "Detail": { "ID": 253636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0049918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221481", "Detail": { "ID": 221481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9345955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220559", "Detail": { "ID": 220559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6465949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240351", "Detail": { "ID": 240351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3560167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266582", "Detail": { "ID": 266582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7473602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324150", "Detail": { "ID": 324150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9943427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260180", "Detail": { "ID": 260180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6472204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247059", "Detail": { "ID": 247059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1652987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275639", "Detail": { "ID": 275639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3841715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303755", "Detail": { "ID": 303755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8343098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222044", "Detail": { "ID": 222044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9649671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242261", "Detail": { "ID": 242261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0053123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224325", "Detail": { "ID": 224325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6997846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308282", "Detail": { "ID": 308282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0488902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272755", "Detail": { "ID": 272755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3489876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244143", "Detail": { "ID": 244143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3355915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314313", "Detail": { "ID": 314313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6343119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251211", "Detail": { "ID": 251211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4536239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276495", "Detail": { "ID": 276495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6685806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256274", "Detail": { "ID": 256274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7755131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282463", "Detail": { "ID": 282463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4199703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255058", "Detail": { "ID": 255058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2954136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277761", "Detail": { "ID": 277761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9673089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325135", "Detail": { "ID": 325135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2576516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232352", "Detail": { "ID": 232352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8511373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312265", "Detail": { "ID": 312265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.12015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231484", "Detail": { "ID": 231484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6025993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267868", "Detail": { "ID": 267868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0387159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314750", "Detail": { "ID": 314750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6538769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296740", "Detail": { "ID": 296740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.87189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319423", "Detail": { "ID": 319423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9252553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306030", "Detail": { "ID": 306030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3559772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309029", "Detail": { "ID": 309029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.088942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268561", "Detail": { "ID": 268561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2725647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293191", "Detail": { "ID": 293191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5755067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261575", "Detail": { "ID": 261575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3634032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264501", "Detail": { "ID": 264501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1362453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307776", "Detail": { "ID": 307776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8444229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282670", "Detail": { "ID": 282670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4291209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280883", "Detail": { "ID": 280883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7864521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245421", "Detail": { "ID": 245421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8341199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304883", "Detail": { "ID": 304883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0628264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303253", "Detail": { "ID": 303253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8068786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297021", "Detail": { "ID": 297021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8843098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224848", "Detail": { "ID": 224848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7226979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296852", "Detail": { "ID": 296852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8768435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321292", "Detail": { "ID": 321292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4219024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315612", "Detail": { "ID": 315612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9194992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238079", "Detail": { "ID": 238079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2386533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294177", "Detail": { "ID": 294177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8862672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233581", "Detail": { "ID": 233581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1371612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312517", "Detail": { "ID": 312517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1313385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287632", "Detail": { "ID": 287632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8796306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226552", "Detail": { "ID": 226552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2363749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265157", "Detail": { "ID": 265157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1709479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284448", "Detail": { "ID": 284448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0268078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259105", "Detail": { "ID": 259105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3419335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318523", "Detail": { "ID": 318523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6618412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255580", "Detail": { "ID": 255580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5374625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295153", "Detail": { "ID": 295153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1947808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236846", "Detail": { "ID": 236846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9428049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256847", "Detail": { "ID": 256847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8124407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239557", "Detail": { "ID": 239557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7488849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290514", "Detail": { "ID": 290514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7503696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309969", "Detail": { "ID": 309969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3587778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247661", "Detail": { "ID": 247661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4230233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299228", "Detail": { "ID": 299228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6883803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235265", "Detail": { "ID": 235265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6630074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275903", "Detail": { "ID": 275903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3959394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274042", "Detail": { "ID": 274042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6518499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316476", "Detail": { "ID": 316476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1495579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325848", "Detail": { "ID": 325848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5240629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241699", "Detail": { "ID": 241699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7760372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287036", "Detail": { "ID": 287036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6114599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248470", "Detail": { "ID": 248470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6473961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289114", "Detail": { "ID": 289114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1726449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223005", "Detail": { "ID": 223005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2246439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240576", "Detail": { "ID": 240576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3732023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284674", "Detail": { "ID": 284674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0427085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232953", "Detail": { "ID": 232953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8837708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246212", "Detail": { "ID": 246212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1189484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310159", "Detail": { "ID": 310159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2105, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 23, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Corroboration", "Reference": "S4M-07791", "ID": 7896 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3670542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259532", "Detail": { "ID": 259532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6131655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318071", "Detail": { "ID": 318071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.455672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250071", "Detail": { "ID": 250071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9621277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320759", "Detail": { "ID": 320759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1804755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229509", "Detail": { "ID": 229509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0848211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281662", "Detail": { "ID": 281662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1523317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263310", "Detail": { "ID": 263310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8839153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290731", "Detail": { "ID": 290731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7698001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227920", "Detail": { "ID": 227920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5713634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270649", "Detail": { "ID": 270649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8168713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322925", "Detail": { "ID": 322925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7096843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297382", "Detail": { "ID": 297382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0975538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242606", "Detail": { "ID": 242606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0275713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236613", "Detail": { "ID": 236613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9325615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301593", "Detail": { "ID": 301593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.269169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261940", "Detail": { "ID": 261940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3847399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM317009", "Detail": { "ID": 317009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1777716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326667", "Detail": { "ID": 326667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7749181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278139", "Detail": { "ID": 278139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9887148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264942", "Detail": { "ID": 264942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1613461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249264", "Detail": { "ID": 249264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9190834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293560", "Detail": { "ID": 293560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8506197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285530", "Detail": { "ID": 285530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3332781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232077", "Detail": { "ID": 232077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6335187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243269", "Detail": { "ID": 243269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.290097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253905", "Detail": { "ID": 253905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0258724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321390", "Detail": { "ID": 321390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4337893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292009", "Detail": { "ID": 292009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1519492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273217", "Detail": { "ID": 273217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6057392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262924", "Detail": { "ID": 262924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6290889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282221", "Detail": { "ID": 282221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.40342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299051", "Detail": { "ID": 299051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3840194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230605", "Detail": { "ID": 230605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3375997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287225", "Detail": { "ID": 287225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8550226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219754", "Detail": { "ID": 219754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3130927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239051", "Detail": { "ID": 239051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4806517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226188", "Detail": { "ID": 226188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0137998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322371", "Detail": { "ID": 322371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6798738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292192", "Detail": { "ID": 292192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1658108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228231", "Detail": { "ID": 228231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7839109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304443", "Detail": { "ID": 304443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0384546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258208", "Detail": { "ID": 258208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.297152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271635", "Detail": { "ID": 271635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0846787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278977", "Detail": { "ID": 278977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2424456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266712", "Detail": { "ID": 266712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7532873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250859", "Detail": { "ID": 250859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2165874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221325", "Detail": { "ID": 221325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9271939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220899", "Detail": { "ID": 220899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6617687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240023", "Detail": { "ID": 240023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7694244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266954", "Detail": { "ID": 266954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7691868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324311", "Detail": { "ID": 324311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2112951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260833", "Detail": { "ID": 260833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0998872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246469", "Detail": { "ID": 246469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1300687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276126", "Detail": { "ID": 276126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4115741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303583", "Detail": { "ID": 303583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8215644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222203", "Detail": { "ID": 222203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9721583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242418", "Detail": { "ID": 242418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.012406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224642", "Detail": { "ID": 224642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7136223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308635", "Detail": { "ID": 308635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0643526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272597", "Detail": { "ID": 272597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.34224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244456", "Detail": { "ID": 244456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.555521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314631", "Detail": { "ID": 314631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6484219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251977", "Detail": { "ID": 251977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4972517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275572", "Detail": { "ID": 275572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3812989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257035", "Detail": { "ID": 257035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8205163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283074", "Detail": { "ID": 283074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4512165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254150", "Detail": { "ID": 254150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0366506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278720", "Detail": { "ID": 278720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2313967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324974", "Detail": { "ID": 324974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2457757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232004", "Detail": { "ID": 232004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6250822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312960", "Detail": { "ID": 312960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.157299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232582", "Detail": { "ID": 232582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8671225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267663", "Detail": { "ID": 267663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0296236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314242", "Detail": { "ID": 314242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6284892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296091", "Detail": { "ID": 296091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5490042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319776", "Detail": { "ID": 319776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9408493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305878", "Detail": { "ID": 305878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.349235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309907", "Detail": { "ID": 309907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3560896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268777", "Detail": { "ID": 268777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2822323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293840", "Detail": { "ID": 293840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8711162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262202", "Detail": { "ID": 262202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5912639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269343", "Detail": { "ID": 269343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5434555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307371", "Detail": { "ID": 307371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8265487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280636", "Detail": { "ID": 280636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.775727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281215", "Detail": { "ID": 281215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.125216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245272", "Detail": { "ID": 245272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8276913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299910", "Detail": { "ID": 299910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7281913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302269", "Detail": { "ID": 302269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5171053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300166", "Detail": { "ID": 300166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7391448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224537", "Detail": { "ID": 224537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7091031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297464", "Detail": { "ID": 297464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1013377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320951", "Detail": { "ID": 320951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1887165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315450", "Detail": { "ID": 315450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9125374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237598", "Detail": { "ID": 237598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2177002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292531", "Detail": { "ID": 292531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5380069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233904", "Detail": { "ID": 233904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1513784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312042", "Detail": { "ID": 312042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9112178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286790", "Detail": { "ID": 286790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6007754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226079", "Detail": { "ID": 226079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0091473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265487", "Detail": { "ID": 265487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4412898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283835", "Detail": { "ID": 283835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.725505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258764", "Detail": { "ID": 258764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3269307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318170", "Detail": { "ID": 318170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4600524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256046", "Detail": { "ID": 256046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5681757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293993", "Detail": { "ID": 293993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8780024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236353", "Detail": { "ID": 236353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9129571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256364", "Detail": { "ID": 256364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7793426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229899", "Detail": { "ID": 229899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1022147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289413", "Detail": { "ID": 289413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4361782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310443", "Detail": { "ID": 310443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5708723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247195", "Detail": { "ID": 247195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3930929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298659", "Detail": { "ID": 298659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3557134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235756", "Detail": { "ID": 235756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6916544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275406", "Detail": { "ID": 275406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3738629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274240", "Detail": { "ID": 274240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0920439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316790", "Detail": { "ID": 316790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1636019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326009", "Detail": { "ID": 326009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5313214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241539", "Detail": { "ID": 241539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7691797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287971", "Detail": { "ID": 287971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8944675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248287", "Detail": { "ID": 248287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6393983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290798", "Detail": { "ID": 290798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7726182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222847", "Detail": { "ID": 222847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2072642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240735", "Detail": { "ID": 240735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3800577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284066", "Detail": { "ID": 284066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7415069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251580", "Detail": { "ID": 251580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4700982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246699", "Detail": { "ID": 246699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1496618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309654", "Detail": { "ID": 309654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2103, "AgendaID": 2136, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 28, "VoteAgainst": 77, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "New Learning Disabilities Strategy, The keys to life", "Reference": "S4M-07787.2", "ID": 7901 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3389332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269279", "Detail": { "ID": 269279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5405923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318385", "Detail": { "ID": 318385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6553166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249910", "Detail": { "ID": 249910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9552444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320466", "Detail": { "ID": 320466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1676165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230294", "Detail": { "ID": 230294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3165941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281462", "Detail": { "ID": 281462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1438783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263690", "Detail": { "ID": 263690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9005393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289074", "Detail": { "ID": 289074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.17094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228684", "Detail": { "ID": 228684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8097233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270347", "Detail": { "ID": 270347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8037317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323321", "Detail": { "ID": 323321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9447208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296493", "Detail": { "ID": 296493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8514339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229099", "Detail": { "ID": 229099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.834435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236147", "Detail": { "ID": 236147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7135057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300961", "Detail": { "ID": 300961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0263483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260599", "Detail": { "ID": 260599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0838381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316686", "Detail": { "ID": 316686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1588414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326817", "Detail": { "ID": 326817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7813417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278706", "Detail": { "ID": 278706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2308081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264695", "Detail": { "ID": 264695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1449107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249077", "Detail": { "ID": 249077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6828879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294018", "Detail": { "ID": 294018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8790675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287798", "Detail": { "ID": 287798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8867623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233546", "Detail": { "ID": 233546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1356168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243425", "Detail": { "ID": 243425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2971942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253264", "Detail": { "ID": 253264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9888246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323098", "Detail": { "ID": 323098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7219389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301438", "Detail": { "ID": 301438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2622304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273464", "Detail": { "ID": 273464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.621263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263265", "Detail": { "ID": 263265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8818714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282421", "Detail": { "ID": 282421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4121399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298851", "Detail": { "ID": 298851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.37487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230575", "Detail": { "ID": 230575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3363141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286476", "Detail": { "ID": 286476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5874836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219942", "Detail": { "ID": 219942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.321324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238749", "Detail": { "ID": 238749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4673807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225874", "Detail": { "ID": 225874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9941496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322112", "Detail": { "ID": 322112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4718261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290269", "Detail": { "ID": 290269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7395511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228874", "Detail": { "ID": 228874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8179663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304677", "Detail": { "ID": 304677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0486667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258371", "Detail": { "ID": 258371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3043443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274435", "Detail": { "ID": 274435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1064049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279485", "Detail": { "ID": 279485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5097373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267041", "Detail": { "ID": 267041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7729185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253637", "Detail": { "ID": 253637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0050328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221482", "Detail": { "ID": 221482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.934659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220558", "Detail": { "ID": 220558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6465349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240352", "Detail": { "ID": 240352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3560574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266583", "Detail": { "ID": 266583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7474009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324151", "Detail": { "ID": 324151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9943836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260179", "Detail": { "ID": 260179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6471797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247058", "Detail": { "ID": 247058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1652581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275254", "Detail": { "ID": 275254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3621513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303754", "Detail": { "ID": 303754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8342692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222043", "Detail": { "ID": 222043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9649036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242260", "Detail": { "ID": 242260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0052712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224324", "Detail": { "ID": 224324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6997436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308281", "Detail": { "ID": 308281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0488492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272756", "Detail": { "ID": 272756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3490274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244144", "Detail": { "ID": 244144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3356499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314314", "Detail": { "ID": 314314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.634353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251212", "Detail": { "ID": 251212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.453666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276496", "Detail": { "ID": 276496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6686218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256275", "Detail": { "ID": 256275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7755534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282462", "Detail": { "ID": 282462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4199292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255057", "Detail": { "ID": 255057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2953534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277760", "Detail": { "ID": 277760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.967269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325134", "Detail": { "ID": 325134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2576107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232353", "Detail": { "ID": 232353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8511788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312264", "Detail": { "ID": 312264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1201083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231483", "Detail": { "ID": 231483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6025576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267867", "Detail": { "ID": 267867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0386741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314751", "Detail": { "ID": 314751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6539179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296741", "Detail": { "ID": 296741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.87193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319422", "Detail": { "ID": 319422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9252146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306029", "Detail": { "ID": 306029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3559187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309030", "Detail": { "ID": 309030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0889856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268562", "Detail": { "ID": 268562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2726057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293190", "Detail": { "ID": 293190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5754646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261574", "Detail": { "ID": 261574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3633453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264500", "Detail": { "ID": 264500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.136204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307775", "Detail": { "ID": 307775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8443817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282671", "Detail": { "ID": 282671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4291608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280505", "Detail": { "ID": 280505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7701423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245420", "Detail": { "ID": 245420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8340795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304884", "Detail": { "ID": 304884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0628668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303254", "Detail": { "ID": 303254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.80692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297020", "Detail": { "ID": 297020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8842694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224849", "Detail": { "ID": 224849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7227388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296853", "Detail": { "ID": 296853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8768835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321350", "Detail": { "ID": 321350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4243957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315611", "Detail": { "ID": 315611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.919458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238148", "Detail": { "ID": 238148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2469857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294178", "Detail": { "ID": 294178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8863076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233580", "Detail": { "ID": 233580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1371203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312516", "Detail": { "ID": 312516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1312776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287633", "Detail": { "ID": 287633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8796703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226553", "Detail": { "ID": 226553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.236416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265156", "Detail": { "ID": 265156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1709054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284497", "Detail": { "ID": 284497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0351455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259106", "Detail": { "ID": 259106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3419742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318524", "Detail": { "ID": 318524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6618814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255579", "Detail": { "ID": 255579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5374221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295154", "Detail": { "ID": 295154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1948295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236847", "Detail": { "ID": 236847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9428459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256848", "Detail": { "ID": 256848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8124813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239558", "Detail": { "ID": 239558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7489247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290513", "Detail": { "ID": 290513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7503292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309970", "Detail": { "ID": 309970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3588184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247662", "Detail": { "ID": 247662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4230638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299230", "Detail": { "ID": 299230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6884844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234728", "Detail": { "ID": 234728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3971797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275904", "Detail": { "ID": 275904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.39598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274041", "Detail": { "ID": 274041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6518085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316477", "Detail": { "ID": 316477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1496015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325849", "Detail": { "ID": 325849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5241046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241700", "Detail": { "ID": 241700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7760779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287037", "Detail": { "ID": 287037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6115202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248471", "Detail": { "ID": 248471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6474371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288293", "Detail": { "ID": 288293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1285934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223006", "Detail": { "ID": 223006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2246841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240575", "Detail": { "ID": 240575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3731612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284675", "Detail": { "ID": 284675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0427481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232952", "Detail": { "ID": 232952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8837297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246211", "Detail": { "ID": 246211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1189077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310160", "Detail": { "ID": 310160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2106, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 71, "VoteAgainst": 14, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783.2", "ID": 7919 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3670948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269266", "Detail": { "ID": 269266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5370954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318384", "Detail": { "ID": 318384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6552761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249909", "Detail": { "ID": 249909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9552045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320467", "Detail": { "ID": 320467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1676569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230323", "Detail": { "ID": 230323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3178702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281403", "Detail": { "ID": 281403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1333041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263691", "Detail": { "ID": 263691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9005985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289858", "Detail": { "ID": 289858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4620682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228685", "Detail": { "ID": 228685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8097637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270360", "Detail": { "ID": 270360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8042929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323320", "Detail": { "ID": 323320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9446799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296485", "Detail": { "ID": 296485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8511074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM229100", "Detail": { "ID": 229100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8344757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236146", "Detail": { "ID": 236146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7134653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300962", "Detail": { "ID": 300962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0263884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM260598", "Detail": { "ID": 260598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0837975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316632", "Detail": { "ID": 316632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1565284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326816", "Detail": { "ID": 326816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7813008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278707", "Detail": { "ID": 278707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2308489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264694", "Detail": { "ID": 264694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1448699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249076", "Detail": { "ID": 249076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6828468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294017", "Detail": { "ID": 294017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8790257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287803", "Detail": { "ID": 287803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.886967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233701", "Detail": { "ID": 233701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1424078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243424", "Detail": { "ID": 243424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2971531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253263", "Detail": { "ID": 253263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9887829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323097", "Detail": { "ID": 323097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7218787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301437", "Detail": { "ID": 301437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2621897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273465", "Detail": { "ID": 273465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6213031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263266", "Detail": { "ID": 263266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8819116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285736", "Detail": { "ID": 285736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3423503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298790", "Detail": { "ID": 298790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3722809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230574", "Detail": { "ID": 230574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3362735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286463", "Detail": { "ID": 286463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5803064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219943", "Detail": { "ID": 219943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3213651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238762", "Detail": { "ID": 238762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4679263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225873", "Detail": { "ID": 225873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.994109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322113", "Detail": { "ID": 322113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4718662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290268", "Detail": { "ID": 290268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7395104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228875", "Detail": { "ID": 228875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8180075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304678", "Detail": { "ID": 304678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0487069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258372", "Detail": { "ID": 258372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3043851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274422", "Detail": { "ID": 274422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1058467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279855", "Detail": { "ID": 279855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5257094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267042", "Detail": { "ID": 267042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7729591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253638", "Detail": { "ID": 253638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0050792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221483", "Detail": { "ID": 221483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9347011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220557", "Detail": { "ID": 220557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6464943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240353", "Detail": { "ID": 240353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3560987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266363", "Detail": { "ID": 266363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7376357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324152", "Detail": { "ID": 324152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9944244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260178", "Detail": { "ID": 260178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6471392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247046", "Detail": { "ID": 247046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1647449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275253", "Detail": { "ID": 275253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3621098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303753", "Detail": { "ID": 303753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8342282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222042", "Detail": { "ID": 222042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9648633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242259", "Detail": { "ID": 242259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0052282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224323", "Detail": { "ID": 224323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6997022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308219", "Detail": { "ID": 308219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0461776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272757", "Detail": { "ID": 272757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3490858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244145", "Detail": { "ID": 244145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3356916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314315", "Detail": { "ID": 314315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6343942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251224", "Detail": { "ID": 251224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4542175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276509", "Detail": { "ID": 276509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.669183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256288", "Detail": { "ID": 256288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7761071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282449", "Detail": { "ID": 282449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4193683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255044", "Detail": { "ID": 255044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2947963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277759", "Detail": { "ID": 277759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9672291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325133", "Detail": { "ID": 325133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2575693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232354", "Detail": { "ID": 232354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8512199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312206", "Detail": { "ID": 312206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.115053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231482", "Detail": { "ID": 231482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6025171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267930", "Detail": { "ID": 267930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.048635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314811", "Detail": { "ID": 314811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6565225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM297107", "Detail": { "ID": 297107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8880168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319362", "Detail": { "ID": 319362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.922629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306028", "Detail": { "ID": 306028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3558782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309021", "Detail": { "ID": 309021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0882444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268496", "Detail": { "ID": 268496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2696851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293133", "Detail": { "ID": 293133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5730052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261573", "Detail": { "ID": 261573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3633054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264499", "Detail": { "ID": 264499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1361454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307938", "Detail": { "ID": 307938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8574118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM282672", "Detail": { "ID": 282672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4292006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280504", "Detail": { "ID": 280504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7701019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245419", "Detail": { "ID": 245419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8340391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304942", "Detail": { "ID": 304942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0654069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303255", "Detail": { "ID": 303255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8069609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297019", "Detail": { "ID": 297019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8842281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224850", "Detail": { "ID": 224850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7227801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296854", "Detail": { "ID": 296854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8769233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321349", "Detail": { "ID": 321349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4243552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315610", "Detail": { "ID": 315610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9194165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238149", "Detail": { "ID": 238149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2470262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294186", "Detail": { "ID": 294186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8866547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233579", "Detail": { "ID": 233579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1370782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312515", "Detail": { "ID": 312515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1312366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287634", "Detail": { "ID": 287634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.87971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226554", "Detail": { "ID": 226554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2364578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265155", "Detail": { "ID": 265155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1708626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284496", "Detail": { "ID": 284496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0351058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259107", "Detail": { "ID": 259107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3420144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318584", "Detail": { "ID": 318584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.664465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255578", "Detail": { "ID": 255578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5373815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295155", "Detail": { "ID": 295155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1948809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236848", "Detail": { "ID": 236848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9429039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256849", "Detail": { "ID": 256849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8125224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239559", "Detail": { "ID": 239559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7489644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290512", "Detail": { "ID": 290512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.750289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM309971", "Detail": { "ID": 309971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3588592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247663", "Detail": { "ID": 247663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4231041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299238", "Detail": { "ID": 299238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6888333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234727", "Detail": { "ID": 234727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3971387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275905", "Detail": { "ID": 275905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3960203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM273983", "Detail": { "ID": 273983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6491747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316478", "Detail": { "ID": 316478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1496428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325850", "Detail": { "ID": 325850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5241457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241701", "Detail": { "ID": 241701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7761189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287038", "Detail": { "ID": 287038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6115632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248472", "Detail": { "ID": 248472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6474952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288294", "Detail": { "ID": 288294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.128635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223007", "Detail": { "ID": 223007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2247242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240574", "Detail": { "ID": 240574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3731193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284688", "Detail": { "ID": 284688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0432931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232777", "Detail": { "ID": 232777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8757943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246210", "Detail": { "ID": 246210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1188659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310222", "Detail": { "ID": 310222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2107, "AgendaID": 2326, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 19, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Named Persons", "Reference": "S4M-07783", "ID": 7888 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-25T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5591917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259176", "Detail": { "ID": 259176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3449793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319563", "Detail": { "ID": 319563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9313357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249467", "Detail": { "ID": 249467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.927962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320882", "Detail": { "ID": 320882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1857434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228357", "Detail": { "ID": 228357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7949259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281039", "Detail": { "ID": 281039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8033991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262827", "Detail": { "ID": 262827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6246642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288963", "Detail": { "ID": 288963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1661142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230503", "Detail": { "ID": 230503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3329784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269695", "Detail": { "ID": 269695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5590342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322561", "Detail": { "ID": 322561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6940135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295365", "Detail": { "ID": 295365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5090558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243039", "Detail": { "ID": 243039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0463019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227094", "Detail": { "ID": 227094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2672508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303083", "Detail": { "ID": 303083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5578633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244176", "Detail": { "ID": 244176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3420364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316331", "Detail": { "ID": 316331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1432056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327057", "Detail": { "ID": 327057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.791749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277166", "Detail": { "ID": 277166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7039243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264008", "Detail": { "ID": 264008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9202543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248618", "Detail": { "ID": 248618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6625714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294873", "Detail": { "ID": 294873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1823984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285332", "Detail": { "ID": 285332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3184403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231270", "Detail": { "ID": 231270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5877215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243679", "Detail": { "ID": 243679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3152255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254444", "Detail": { "ID": 254444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2563724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323510", "Detail": { "ID": 323510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9594911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290869", "Detail": { "ID": 290869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7756294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273029", "Detail": { "ID": 273029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3664975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262561", "Detail": { "ID": 262561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6072154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281853", "Detail": { "ID": 281853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1604246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298274", "Detail": { "ID": 298274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.338707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231164", "Detail": { "ID": 231164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3684114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284956", "Detail": { "ID": 284956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0549315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219546", "Detail": { "ID": 219546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3040201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238252", "Detail": { "ID": 238252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4383895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225120", "Detail": { "ID": 225120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7453354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321899", "Detail": { "ID": 321899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4561443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292767", "Detail": { "ID": 292767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5572769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227578", "Detail": { "ID": 227578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5561563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313310", "Detail": { "ID": 313310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.389794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257815", "Detail": { "ID": 257815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0787884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271088", "Detail": { "ID": 271088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8419802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277991", "Detail": { "ID": 277991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9775336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288312", "Detail": { "ID": 288312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1293945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250632", "Detail": { "ID": 250632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2068429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221096", "Detail": { "ID": 221096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6748947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220098", "Detail": { "ID": 220098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3342447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252814", "Detail": { "ID": 252814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7543941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253760", "Detail": { "ID": 253760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0197586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324741", "Detail": { "ID": 324741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2358886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259409", "Detail": { "ID": 259409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6078671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239491", "Detail": { "ID": 239491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7460959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273634", "Detail": { "ID": 273634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6288143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303997", "Detail": { "ID": 303997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8449741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221598", "Detail": { "ID": 221598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9396385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241830", "Detail": { "ID": 241830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7818734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223381", "Detail": { "ID": 223381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4554283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307857", "Detail": { "ID": 307857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.853924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272367", "Detail": { "ID": 272367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3322942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245050", "Detail": { "ID": 245050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5898661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315216", "Detail": { "ID": 315216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8989391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247470", "Detail": { "ID": 247470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4051819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275152", "Detail": { "ID": 275152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1438415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255472", "Detail": { "ID": 255472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5327915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276937", "Detail": { "ID": 276937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6875023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253492", "Detail": { "ID": 253492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9987565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276372", "Detail": { "ID": 276372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6627754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325390", "Detail": { "ID": 325390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4966241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233304", "Detail": { "ID": 233304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1183086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311701", "Detail": { "ID": 311701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8905518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229633", "Detail": { "ID": 229633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0900935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267484", "Detail": { "ID": 267484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0218257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313459", "Detail": { "ID": 313459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3962734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294954", "Detail": { "ID": 294954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1859044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319149", "Detail": { "ID": 319149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6945416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306270", "Detail": { "ID": 306270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5448371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310770", "Detail": { "ID": 310770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5853125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268120", "Detail": { "ID": 268120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0570325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286455", "Detail": { "ID": 286455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5799534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258504", "Detail": { "ID": 258504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3100951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263577", "Detail": { "ID": 263577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.895392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308717", "Detail": { "ID": 308717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.067922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280128", "Detail": { "ID": 280128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.542643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279506", "Detail": { "ID": 279506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5106329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260471", "Detail": { "ID": 260471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0783069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299390", "Detail": { "ID": 299390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6953652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306750", "Detail": { "ID": 306750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5658023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300585", "Detail": { "ID": 300585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0049436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224000", "Detail": { "ID": 224000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4877076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305597", "Detail": { "ID": 305597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3312366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320122", "Detail": { "ID": 320122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9626339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315866", "Detail": { "ID": 315866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.930439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237106", "Detail": { "ID": 237106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.966112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289709", "Detail": { "ID": 289709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4558092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234272", "Detail": { "ID": 234272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3701001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313126", "Detail": { "ID": 313126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1647656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289352", "Detail": { "ID": 289352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4335534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225560", "Detail": { "ID": 225560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9802603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265712", "Detail": { "ID": 265712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4511003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283013", "Detail": { "ID": 283013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4440281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252082", "Detail": { "ID": 252082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5017826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317343", "Detail": { "ID": 317343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4180314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254219", "Detail": { "ID": 254219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2460746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296254", "Detail": { "ID": 296254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8407159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235526", "Detail": { "ID": 235526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6816229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258053", "Detail": { "ID": 258053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0893856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228593", "Detail": { "ID": 228593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8057972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291044", "Detail": { "ID": 291044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7830739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311498", "Detail": { "ID": 311498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8814374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246815", "Detail": { "ID": 246815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1545642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297693", "Detail": { "ID": 297693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1206683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234034", "Detail": { "ID": 234034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1572757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274889", "Detail": { "ID": 274889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1263901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269960", "Detail": { "ID": 269960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5754899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317682", "Detail": { "ID": 317682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4328777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326440", "Detail": { "ID": 326440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7647688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241298", "Detail": { "ID": 241298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.751899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290409", "Detail": { "ID": 290409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7458491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248091", "Detail": { "ID": 248091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4416059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288159", "Detail": { "ID": 288159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9094494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222650", "Detail": { "ID": 222650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.198037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239673", "Detail": { "ID": 239673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7540407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283802", "Detail": { "ID": 283802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7240805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231764", "Detail": { "ID": 231764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6145171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237313", "Detail": { "ID": 237313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1988187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308980", "Detail": { "ID": 308980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2102, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 3, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.3", "ID": 7851 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0863455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259177", "Detail": { "ID": 259177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3450202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319564", "Detail": { "ID": 319564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9313769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249468", "Detail": { "ID": 249468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9280129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320881", "Detail": { "ID": 320881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.185703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228356", "Detail": { "ID": 228356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7948845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281040", "Detail": { "ID": 281040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8034405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262826", "Detail": { "ID": 262826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6246232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288987", "Detail": { "ID": 288987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.167196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230502", "Detail": { "ID": 230502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3329375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269694", "Detail": { "ID": 269694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5589907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322560", "Detail": { "ID": 322560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6939736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295364", "Detail": { "ID": 295364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5090143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243038", "Detail": { "ID": 243038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0462602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227095", "Detail": { "ID": 227095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2672922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302452", "Detail": { "ID": 302452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5252023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244177", "Detail": { "ID": 244177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3420964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316332", "Detail": { "ID": 316332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1432466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327058", "Detail": { "ID": 327058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.79179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277165", "Detail": { "ID": 277165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7038835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264009", "Detail": { "ID": 264009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9202955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248619", "Detail": { "ID": 248619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6626124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294874", "Detail": { "ID": 294874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1824406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285331", "Detail": { "ID": 285331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3183986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231269", "Detail": { "ID": 231269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5876808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243680", "Detail": { "ID": 243680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3152655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254482", "Detail": { "ID": 254482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2580409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323511", "Detail": { "ID": 323511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9595327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290870", "Detail": { "ID": 290870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7756698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273028", "Detail": { "ID": 273028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3664562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262560", "Detail": { "ID": 262560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6071564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281852", "Detail": { "ID": 281852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1603837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298275", "Detail": { "ID": 298275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3387485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231165", "Detail": { "ID": 231165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3684559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284932", "Detail": { "ID": 284932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0539039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219512", "Detail": { "ID": 219512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3025358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238251", "Detail": { "ID": 238251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4383484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225121", "Detail": { "ID": 225121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7453758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321900", "Detail": { "ID": 321900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4561855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292768", "Detail": { "ID": 292768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5573179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227237", "Detail": { "ID": 227237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5367665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313273", "Detail": { "ID": 313273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3881996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257814", "Detail": { "ID": 257814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0787484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271065", "Detail": { "ID": 271065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8410087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277990", "Detail": { "ID": 277990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9774711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287348", "Detail": { "ID": 287348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8603517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250631", "Detail": { "ID": 250631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2067991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221095", "Detail": { "ID": 221095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6748541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220132", "Detail": { "ID": 220132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3357071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252472", "Detail": { "ID": 252472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7306148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253759", "Detail": { "ID": 253759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0197184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324740", "Detail": { "ID": 324740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2358482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259410", "Detail": { "ID": 259410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6079088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239492", "Detail": { "ID": 239492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7461368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273635", "Detail": { "ID": 273635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6288558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304034", "Detail": { "ID": 304034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8465423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221599", "Detail": { "ID": 221599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9396792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241831", "Detail": { "ID": 241831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7819149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223382", "Detail": { "ID": 223382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4554699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307858", "Detail": { "ID": 307858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8539662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272366", "Detail": { "ID": 272366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3322297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245049", "Detail": { "ID": 245049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5898249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315215", "Detail": { "ID": 315215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8988741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247469", "Detail": { "ID": 247469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4051411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275486", "Detail": { "ID": 275486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3773384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255471", "Detail": { "ID": 255471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5327507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276913", "Detail": { "ID": 276913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6864843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253493", "Detail": { "ID": 253493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9987982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276373", "Detail": { "ID": 276373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6628169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325391", "Detail": { "ID": 325391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4966663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233275", "Detail": { "ID": 233275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1169949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311702", "Detail": { "ID": 311702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8905923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229667", "Detail": { "ID": 229667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0915234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267485", "Detail": { "ID": 267485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0218662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313458", "Detail": { "ID": 313458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.396232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294953", "Detail": { "ID": 294953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1858622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319150", "Detail": { "ID": 319150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6945819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306271", "Detail": { "ID": 306271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5448983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310769", "Detail": { "ID": 310769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5852694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268119", "Detail": { "ID": 268119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0569907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292938", "Detail": { "ID": 292938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5646788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258505", "Detail": { "ID": 258505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3101367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263578", "Detail": { "ID": 263578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8954333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308718", "Detail": { "ID": 308718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.067963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280127", "Detail": { "ID": 280127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5426018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279507", "Detail": { "ID": 279507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5106738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260472", "Detail": { "ID": 260472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0783481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299389", "Detail": { "ID": 299389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6953233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306749", "Detail": { "ID": 306749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5657616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300586", "Detail": { "ID": 300586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0049874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223999", "Detail": { "ID": 223999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4876672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305596", "Detail": { "ID": 305596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3311754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320121", "Detail": { "ID": 320121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9625733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315867", "Detail": { "ID": 315867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9305104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237105", "Detail": { "ID": 237105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9660524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289710", "Detail": { "ID": 289710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4558489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234310", "Detail": { "ID": 234310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3717581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313127", "Detail": { "ID": 313127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1648249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289351", "Detail": { "ID": 289351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4335127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225559", "Detail": { "ID": 225559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9802176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265750", "Detail": { "ID": 265750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.452872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283014", "Detail": { "ID": 283014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4440692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252081", "Detail": { "ID": 252081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5017418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317342", "Detail": { "ID": 317342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4179905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254220", "Detail": { "ID": 254220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2461165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296253", "Detail": { "ID": 296253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8406747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235491", "Detail": { "ID": 235491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6801147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257705", "Detail": { "ID": 257705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0680172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228592", "Detail": { "ID": 228592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8057327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291081", "Detail": { "ID": 291081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7846449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311497", "Detail": { "ID": 311497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8813961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246814", "Detail": { "ID": 246814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1545244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297694", "Detail": { "ID": 297694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1207097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234035", "Detail": { "ID": 234035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1573169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274888", "Detail": { "ID": 274888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1263303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269961", "Detail": { "ID": 269961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5755435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317681", "Detail": { "ID": 317681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4328376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326439", "Detail": { "ID": 326439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7647271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241297", "Detail": { "ID": 241297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7518584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290408", "Detail": { "ID": 290408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7458086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248090", "Detail": { "ID": 248090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4415655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288158", "Detail": { "ID": 288158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9094087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222649", "Detail": { "ID": 222649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1979964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239674", "Detail": { "ID": 239674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7540825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283979", "Detail": { "ID": 283979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7317403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231765", "Detail": { "ID": 231765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6145575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237348", "Detail": { "ID": 237348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2003215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308979", "Detail": { "ID": 308979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2101, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.2", "ID": 7850 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0863043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259147", "Detail": { "ID": 259147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3437398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319566", "Detail": { "ID": 319566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9314796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249469", "Detail": { "ID": 249469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9280566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320879", "Detail": { "ID": 320879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.18562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228362", "Detail": { "ID": 228362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7951334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281058", "Detail": { "ID": 281058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8042177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262825", "Detail": { "ID": 262825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6245819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288961", "Detail": { "ID": 288961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1659214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230501", "Detail": { "ID": 230501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3328964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269724", "Detail": { "ID": 269724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5602566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322559", "Detail": { "ID": 322559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6939331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295363", "Detail": { "ID": 295363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5089734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243037", "Detail": { "ID": 243037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0462185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235094", "Detail": { "ID": 235094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4191139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302450", "Detail": { "ID": 302450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5251014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244178", "Detail": { "ID": 244178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3421389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316333", "Detail": { "ID": 316333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1432876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327060", "Detail": { "ID": 327060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.791873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277164", "Detail": { "ID": 277164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7038424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264010", "Detail": { "ID": 264010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9203361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248654", "Detail": { "ID": 248654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6641172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294876", "Detail": { "ID": 294876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1825233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285330", "Detail": { "ID": 285330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3183574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231268", "Detail": { "ID": 231268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5876391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243681", "Detail": { "ID": 243681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3153052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254484", "Detail": { "ID": 254484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2581263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323513", "Detail": { "ID": 323513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9596141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290905", "Detail": { "ID": 290905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7771379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273027", "Detail": { "ID": 273027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3664156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262370", "Detail": { "ID": 262370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5985397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281834", "Detail": { "ID": 281834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1596055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298293", "Detail": { "ID": 298293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3395063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231166", "Detail": { "ID": 231166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3684966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284966", "Detail": { "ID": 284966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.055367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219510", "Detail": { "ID": 219510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3024477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238278", "Detail": { "ID": 238278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4394969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225122", "Detail": { "ID": 225122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7454159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321901", "Detail": { "ID": 321901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4562267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292769", "Detail": { "ID": 292769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5573583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227235", "Detail": { "ID": 227235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5366836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313271", "Detail": { "ID": 313271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3881159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257813", "Detail": { "ID": 257813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0787075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271099", "Detail": { "ID": 271099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8424451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277972", "Detail": { "ID": 277972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9767033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287346", "Detail": { "ID": 287346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8602336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250630", "Detail": { "ID": 250630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2067332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221094", "Detail": { "ID": 221094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6748125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220134", "Detail": { "ID": 220134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3357907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252470", "Detail": { "ID": 252470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7305326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253740", "Detail": { "ID": 253740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0189149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324738", "Detail": { "ID": 324738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2357661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259601", "Detail": { "ID": 259601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6164721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239464", "Detail": { "ID": 239464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7379251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273636", "Detail": { "ID": 273636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6288968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304036", "Detail": { "ID": 304036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8466244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221600", "Detail": { "ID": 221600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9397388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241832", "Detail": { "ID": 241832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7819559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223407", "Detail": { "ID": 223407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4565347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307859", "Detail": { "ID": 307859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8540073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272365", "Detail": { "ID": 272365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3321892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245048", "Detail": { "ID": 245048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.589783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315213", "Detail": { "ID": 315213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8987903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247497", "Detail": { "ID": 247497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4063774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275141", "Detail": { "ID": 275141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1433479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255501", "Detail": { "ID": 255501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.534038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276948", "Detail": { "ID": 276948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6880973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253464", "Detail": { "ID": 253464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9975587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276719", "Detail": { "ID": 276719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6781921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325393", "Detail": { "ID": 325393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4967481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233274", "Detail": { "ID": 233274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1169542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311703", "Detail": { "ID": 311703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8906329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229669", "Detail": { "ID": 229669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0916045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267503", "Detail": { "ID": 267503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0226574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313457", "Detail": { "ID": 313457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3961913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294470", "Detail": { "ID": 294470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1396912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319151", "Detail": { "ID": 319151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6946225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306273", "Detail": { "ID": 306273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5449807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310768", "Detail": { "ID": 310768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5852102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268101", "Detail": { "ID": 268101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.056194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292956", "Detail": { "ID": 292956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5654488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258506", "Detail": { "ID": 258506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3101788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263767", "Detail": { "ID": 263767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9038583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308719", "Detail": { "ID": 308719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0680037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279782", "Detail": { "ID": 279782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5225921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279508", "Detail": { "ID": 279508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5107143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260473", "Detail": { "ID": 260473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0783898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299388", "Detail": { "ID": 299388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6952825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306748", "Detail": { "ID": 306748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5657205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300587", "Detail": { "ID": 300587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.005048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223998", "Detail": { "ID": 223998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4876264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305594", "Detail": { "ID": 305594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3310926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320120", "Detail": { "ID": 320120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9625319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315869", "Detail": { "ID": 315869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9306005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237104", "Detail": { "ID": 237104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9660125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289711", "Detail": { "ID": 289711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4558881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234312", "Detail": { "ID": 234312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3718422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313129", "Detail": { "ID": 313129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1649111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289350", "Detail": { "ID": 289350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4334719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225380", "Detail": { "ID": 225380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9722277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265752", "Detail": { "ID": 265752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4529553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283205", "Detail": { "ID": 283205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6903862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252046", "Detail": { "ID": 252046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5002507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317341", "Detail": { "ID": 317341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4179492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254221", "Detail": { "ID": 254221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2461588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296252", "Detail": { "ID": 296252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8406316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235489", "Detail": { "ID": 235489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6800332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257703", "Detail": { "ID": 257703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0679345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228591", "Detail": { "ID": 228591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8056916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291083", "Detail": { "ID": 291083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7847274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311495", "Detail": { "ID": 311495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8813132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246813", "Detail": { "ID": 246813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1544839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297695", "Detail": { "ID": 297695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1207498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234036", "Detail": { "ID": 234036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1573578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274699", "Detail": { "ID": 274699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1178917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269979", "Detail": { "ID": 269979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5763153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317679", "Detail": { "ID": 317679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4327578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326437", "Detail": { "ID": 326437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7646431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241296", "Detail": { "ID": 241296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7518175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290406", "Detail": { "ID": 290406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7457258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248055", "Detail": { "ID": 248055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4398352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287506", "Detail": { "ID": 287506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8739305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222624", "Detail": { "ID": 222624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1969356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239675", "Detail": { "ID": 239675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.754123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283791", "Detail": { "ID": 283791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7236113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231759", "Detail": { "ID": 231759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6142949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237349", "Detail": { "ID": 237349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2003633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308978", "Detail": { "ID": 308978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2100, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734.1", "ID": 7849 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0862642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259150", "Detail": { "ID": 259150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3438636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319565", "Detail": { "ID": 319565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9314187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249470", "Detail": { "ID": 249470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9280986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320880", "Detail": { "ID": 320880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1856624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228348", "Detail": { "ID": 228348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7945171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281048", "Detail": { "ID": 281048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8037909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262792", "Detail": { "ID": 262792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.617046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288960", "Detail": { "ID": 288960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1658784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230500", "Detail": { "ID": 230500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3328547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269721", "Detail": { "ID": 269721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5601327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322547", "Detail": { "ID": 322547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6934245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295329", "Detail": { "ID": 295329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5073955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242970", "Detail": { "ID": 242970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0433482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235095", "Detail": { "ID": 235095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4191556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302449", "Detail": { "ID": 302449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5250607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244211", "Detail": { "ID": 244211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5447542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316340", "Detail": { "ID": 316340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1435953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327059", "Detail": { "ID": 327059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7918315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277131", "Detail": { "ID": 277131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7024307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264043", "Detail": { "ID": 264043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9217497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248655", "Detail": { "ID": 248655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6641578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294875", "Detail": { "ID": 294875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1824814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285296", "Detail": { "ID": 285296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3168815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230773", "Detail": { "ID": 230773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3448973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243748", "Detail": { "ID": 243748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3181079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254485", "Detail": { "ID": 254485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2581672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323512", "Detail": { "ID": 323512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9595735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290906", "Detail": { "ID": 290906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7771776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272994", "Detail": { "ID": 272994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3646542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262369", "Detail": { "ID": 262369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5984988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281844", "Detail": { "ID": 281844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1600339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298283", "Detail": { "ID": 298283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.339077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231167", "Detail": { "ID": 231167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3685494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284967", "Detail": { "ID": 284967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0554073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219509", "Detail": { "ID": 219509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3023556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238277", "Detail": { "ID": 238277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4394556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225123", "Detail": { "ID": 225123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7454563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321913", "Detail": { "ID": 321913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4567414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292770", "Detail": { "ID": 292770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.557399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227234", "Detail": { "ID": 227234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5366413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313270", "Detail": { "ID": 313270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3880746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257812", "Detail": { "ID": 257812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0786662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271100", "Detail": { "ID": 271100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8424854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277982", "Detail": { "ID": 277982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9771368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287345", "Detail": { "ID": 287345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8601919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250629", "Detail": { "ID": 250629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1977837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221093", "Detail": { "ID": 221093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6747718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220135", "Detail": { "ID": 220135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3358326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252469", "Detail": { "ID": 252469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7304921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253751", "Detail": { "ID": 253751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0193751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324739", "Detail": { "ID": 324739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2358079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259602", "Detail": { "ID": 259602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6165135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239465", "Detail": { "ID": 239465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.737966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273669", "Detail": { "ID": 273669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6303015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304037", "Detail": { "ID": 304037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8466665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221601", "Detail": { "ID": 221601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9397818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241833", "Detail": { "ID": 241833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7819974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223408", "Detail": { "ID": 223408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4565771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307866", "Detail": { "ID": 307866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8542971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272364", "Detail": { "ID": 272364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3321483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244981", "Detail": { "ID": 244981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5868975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315214", "Detail": { "ID": 315214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8988324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247496", "Detail": { "ID": 247496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4063351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275140", "Detail": { "ID": 275140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1433054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255498", "Detail": { "ID": 255498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5339147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276949", "Detail": { "ID": 276949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6881383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253466", "Detail": { "ID": 253466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9976422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276720", "Detail": { "ID": 276720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6782323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325392", "Detail": { "ID": 325392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4967072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233273", "Detail": { "ID": 233273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1169102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311710", "Detail": { "ID": 311710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8909357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229670", "Detail": { "ID": 229670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0916449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267493", "Detail": { "ID": 267493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0222279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313450", "Detail": { "ID": 313450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3959006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294945", "Detail": { "ID": 294945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1855135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319163", "Detail": { "ID": 319163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6951346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306272", "Detail": { "ID": 306272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5449399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310772", "Detail": { "ID": 310772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5853941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268111", "Detail": { "ID": 268111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0566293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292946", "Detail": { "ID": 292946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5650232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258507", "Detail": { "ID": 258507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3102201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263768", "Detail": { "ID": 263768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9039011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308715", "Detail": { "ID": 308715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0678372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279781", "Detail": { "ID": 279781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5225503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279542", "Detail": { "ID": 279542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5121885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261006", "Detail": { "ID": 261006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1076178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299380", "Detail": { "ID": 299380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.694939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306747", "Detail": { "ID": 306747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5656783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300588", "Detail": { "ID": 300588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0050911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223997", "Detail": { "ID": 223997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4875858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305595", "Detail": { "ID": 305595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3311349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320108", "Detail": { "ID": 320108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9620156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315868", "Detail": { "ID": 315868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9305584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236760", "Detail": { "ID": 236760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9388738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289745", "Detail": { "ID": 289745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4573129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234313", "Detail": { "ID": 234313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3718839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313128", "Detail": { "ID": 313128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1648687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289349", "Detail": { "ID": 289349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4334305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225379", "Detail": { "ID": 225379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9721859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265753", "Detail": { "ID": 265753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4529963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283206", "Detail": { "ID": 283206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6904281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252045", "Detail": { "ID": 252045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5002064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317329", "Detail": { "ID": 317329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.417435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254222", "Detail": { "ID": 254222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2462016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296251", "Detail": { "ID": 296251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8405895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235488", "Detail": { "ID": 235488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6799927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257702", "Detail": { "ID": 257702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0678928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228590", "Detail": { "ID": 228590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8056498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291550", "Detail": { "ID": 291550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.124177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311496", "Detail": { "ID": 311496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8813548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246812", "Detail": { "ID": 246812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1544437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298038", "Detail": { "ID": 298038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1355983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234068", "Detail": { "ID": 234068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1652502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274698", "Detail": { "ID": 274698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.11785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269969", "Detail": { "ID": 269969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5758778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317680", "Detail": { "ID": 317680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.432798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326438", "Detail": { "ID": 326438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7646848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241295", "Detail": { "ID": 241295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7517765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290407", "Detail": { "ID": 290407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7457677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248054", "Detail": { "ID": 248054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4397938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287505", "Detail": { "ID": 287505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8738697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222623", "Detail": { "ID": 222623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1968943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239676", "Detail": { "ID": 239676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7541638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283790", "Detail": { "ID": 283790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7235703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231773", "Detail": { "ID": 231773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6148989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237350", "Detail": { "ID": 237350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2004045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308971", "Detail": { "ID": 308971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2099, "AgendaID": 2528, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland's Economy", "Reference": "S4M-07734", "ID": 7835 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0859584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259136", "Detail": { "ID": 259136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3432723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319592", "Detail": { "ID": 319592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9329238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249496", "Detail": { "ID": 249496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9293729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320869", "Detail": { "ID": 320869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1851958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228335", "Detail": { "ID": 228335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7885229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280877", "Detail": { "ID": 280877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7861886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262795", "Detail": { "ID": 262795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6171678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288945", "Detail": { "ID": 288945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1651114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229862", "Detail": { "ID": 229862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1006135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269735", "Detail": { "ID": 269735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5607202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322542", "Detail": { "ID": 322542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6932042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295332", "Detail": { "ID": 295332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5075187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243009", "Detail": { "ID": 243009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0450226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235106", "Detail": { "ID": 235106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4196272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302428", "Detail": { "ID": 302428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5240189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244208", "Detail": { "ID": 244208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5446064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316329", "Detail": { "ID": 316329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1431232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327078", "Detail": { "ID": 327078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7979047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277134", "Detail": { "ID": 277134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.702554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264040", "Detail": { "ID": 264040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9216268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248666", "Detail": { "ID": 248666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6646291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294903", "Detail": { "ID": 294903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1836986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285299", "Detail": { "ID": 285299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3170074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230775", "Detail": { "ID": 230775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3450014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243709", "Detail": { "ID": 243709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3164842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254818", "Detail": { "ID": 254818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2850613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323685", "Detail": { "ID": 323685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.967482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290917", "Detail": { "ID": 290917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7776399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272997", "Detail": { "ID": 272997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3647785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262358", "Detail": { "ID": 262358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5980243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281862", "Detail": { "ID": 281862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1608103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298265", "Detail": { "ID": 298265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3383131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231188", "Detail": { "ID": 231188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3696309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284982", "Detail": { "ID": 284982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.056132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219498", "Detail": { "ID": 219498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3018807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238290", "Detail": { "ID": 238290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4400121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225151", "Detail": { "ID": 225151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7466426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321918", "Detail": { "ID": 321918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4569473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292756", "Detail": { "ID": 292756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5568031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227223", "Detail": { "ID": 227223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5361672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313316", "Detail": { "ID": 313316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3900603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257786", "Detail": { "ID": 257786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0775461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271115", "Detail": { "ID": 271115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8431165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278000", "Detail": { "ID": 278000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9826652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287324", "Detail": { "ID": 287324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8592784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250603", "Detail": { "ID": 250603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1966907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221066", "Detail": { "ID": 221066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6736186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220146", "Detail": { "ID": 220146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3363148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252449", "Detail": { "ID": 252449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7296308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253769", "Detail": { "ID": 253769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0201391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324720", "Detail": { "ID": 324720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2350104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259613", "Detail": { "ID": 259613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6169912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239453", "Detail": { "ID": 239453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.737457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273666", "Detail": { "ID": 273666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6301793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303991", "Detail": { "ID": 303991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8446819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221628", "Detail": { "ID": 221628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9409282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241859", "Detail": { "ID": 241859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7831163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223419", "Detail": { "ID": 223419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4570503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307848", "Detail": { "ID": 307848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8535315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272338", "Detail": { "ID": 272338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3310477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245020", "Detail": { "ID": 245020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5885657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315188", "Detail": { "ID": 315188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6781145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247508", "Detail": { "ID": 247508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4068474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275125", "Detail": { "ID": 275125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.142666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255512", "Detail": { "ID": 255512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5345088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276964", "Detail": { "ID": 276964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6889341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253453", "Detail": { "ID": 253453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9970839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276731", "Detail": { "ID": 276731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6786974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325411", "Detail": { "ID": 325411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.497532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233252", "Detail": { "ID": 233252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1160078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311693", "Detail": { "ID": 311693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8901949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229681", "Detail": { "ID": 229681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0921068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267475", "Detail": { "ID": 267475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.021437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313468", "Detail": { "ID": 313468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3966653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294963", "Detail": { "ID": 294963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1862741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319147", "Detail": { "ID": 319147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6944597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306299", "Detail": { "ID": 306299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5460814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310758", "Detail": { "ID": 310758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5847947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268129", "Detail": { "ID": 268129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0574335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286446", "Detail": { "ID": 286446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5795526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258533", "Detail": { "ID": 258533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3113539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263779", "Detail": { "ID": 263779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9043773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308730", "Detail": { "ID": 308730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0684857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279770", "Detail": { "ID": 279770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5220701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279539", "Detail": { "ID": 279539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5120468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260500", "Detail": { "ID": 260500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0795706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299553", "Detail": { "ID": 299553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7024089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306762", "Detail": { "ID": 306762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5663163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300573", "Detail": { "ID": 300573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0044149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223970", "Detail": { "ID": 223970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4864204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305569", "Detail": { "ID": 305569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3300267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320103", "Detail": { "ID": 320103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9618096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315894", "Detail": { "ID": 315894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9318101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236763", "Detail": { "ID": 236763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9390147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289742", "Detail": { "ID": 289742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4571921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234487", "Detail": { "ID": 234487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3863683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313154", "Detail": { "ID": 313154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1659843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289363", "Detail": { "ID": 289363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4340255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225368", "Detail": { "ID": 225368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9717131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265774", "Detail": { "ID": 265774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4539108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283217", "Detail": { "ID": 283217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6909151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252034", "Detail": { "ID": 252034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4997344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317345", "Detail": { "ID": 317345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4181136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254248", "Detail": { "ID": 254248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2473561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296265", "Detail": { "ID": 296265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8411972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235477", "Detail": { "ID": 235477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6795291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257681", "Detail": { "ID": 257681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0669922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228563", "Detail": { "ID": 228563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8045013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291571", "Detail": { "ID": 291571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1330981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311157", "Detail": { "ID": 311157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6081523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246786", "Detail": { "ID": 246786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.153358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298035", "Detail": { "ID": 298035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1354751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234066", "Detail": { "ID": 234066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1651681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274687", "Detail": { "ID": 274687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1173764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269641", "Detail": { "ID": 269641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5566807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317498", "Detail": { "ID": 317498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4249979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326419", "Detail": { "ID": 326419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7577645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241269", "Detail": { "ID": 241269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7506649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290379", "Detail": { "ID": 290379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7444073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248043", "Detail": { "ID": 248043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4392978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287494", "Detail": { "ID": 287494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8733728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222612", "Detail": { "ID": 222612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1964281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239855", "Detail": { "ID": 239855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7619282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283775", "Detail": { "ID": 283775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7229366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231786", "Detail": { "ID": 231786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6154718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237361", "Detail": { "ID": 237361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2008761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308989", "Detail": { "ID": 308989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2097, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 65, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721.1", "ID": 7834 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.086734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259135", "Detail": { "ID": 259135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3432316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319591", "Detail": { "ID": 319591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9328823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249495", "Detail": { "ID": 249495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9293321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320870", "Detail": { "ID": 320870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1852366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228349", "Detail": { "ID": 228349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.794559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281047", "Detail": { "ID": 281047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8037494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262796", "Detail": { "ID": 262796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6172084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288946", "Detail": { "ID": 288946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1651526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230515", "Detail": { "ID": 230515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.333497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269736", "Detail": { "ID": 269736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5607612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322549", "Detail": { "ID": 322549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6935074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295333", "Detail": { "ID": 295333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5075596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243010", "Detail": { "ID": 243010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0450639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235105", "Detail": { "ID": 235105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4195859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302464", "Detail": { "ID": 302464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5257119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244207", "Detail": { "ID": 244207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.544564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316339", "Detail": { "ID": 316339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1435543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327077", "Detail": { "ID": 327077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7978424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277135", "Detail": { "ID": 277135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7025949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264039", "Detail": { "ID": 264039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9215855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248665", "Detail": { "ID": 248665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6645879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294902", "Detail": { "ID": 294902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1836575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285300", "Detail": { "ID": 285300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3170492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230776", "Detail": { "ID": 230776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3450424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243708", "Detail": { "ID": 243708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3164243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254470", "Detail": { "ID": 254470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2575047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323684", "Detail": { "ID": 323684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9674203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290916", "Detail": { "ID": 290916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7775998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272998", "Detail": { "ID": 272998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3648201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262359", "Detail": { "ID": 262359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5980724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281845", "Detail": { "ID": 281845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1600762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298282", "Detail": { "ID": 298282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3390357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231152", "Detail": { "ID": 231152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3678269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284981", "Detail": { "ID": 284981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0560701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219499", "Detail": { "ID": 219499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3019217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238291", "Detail": { "ID": 238291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4400531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225150", "Detail": { "ID": 225150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7466025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321911", "Detail": { "ID": 321911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4566598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292755", "Detail": { "ID": 292755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.556763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227224", "Detail": { "ID": 227224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5362086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313285", "Detail": { "ID": 313285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3887169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257787", "Detail": { "ID": 257787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0775863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271114", "Detail": { "ID": 271114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8430757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277983", "Detail": { "ID": 277983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9771783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287360", "Detail": { "ID": 287360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8608751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250604", "Detail": { "ID": 250604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1967316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221067", "Detail": { "ID": 221067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6736598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220145", "Detail": { "ID": 220145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3362731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252788", "Detail": { "ID": 252788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7533063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253752", "Detail": { "ID": 253752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0194157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324721", "Detail": { "ID": 324721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2350506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259612", "Detail": { "ID": 259612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6169499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239452", "Detail": { "ID": 239452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7374152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273665", "Detail": { "ID": 273665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6301385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304022", "Detail": { "ID": 304022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.846036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221627", "Detail": { "ID": 221627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9408873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241858", "Detail": { "ID": 241858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7830745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223418", "Detail": { "ID": 223418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.457009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307865", "Detail": { "ID": 307865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8542561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272339", "Detail": { "ID": 272339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3310885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245021", "Detail": { "ID": 245021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5886077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315189", "Detail": { "ID": 315189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6781563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247509", "Detail": { "ID": 247509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4068886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275126", "Detail": { "ID": 275126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.142708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255513", "Detail": { "ID": 255513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5345503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276963", "Detail": { "ID": 276963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6888913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253452", "Detail": { "ID": 253452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9970413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276730", "Detail": { "ID": 276730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6786571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325410", "Detail": { "ID": 325410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4974903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233287", "Detail": { "ID": 233287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1175058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311709", "Detail": { "ID": 311709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8908946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229680", "Detail": { "ID": 229680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0920664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267492", "Detail": { "ID": 267492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0221864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313451", "Detail": { "ID": 313451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3959438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294946", "Detail": { "ID": 294946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1855551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319161", "Detail": { "ID": 319161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6950525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306298", "Detail": { "ID": 306298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.54604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310756", "Detail": { "ID": 310756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5846936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268112", "Detail": { "ID": 268112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0566723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292945", "Detail": { "ID": 292945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5649821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258532", "Detail": { "ID": 258532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3113129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263778", "Detail": { "ID": 263778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9043343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308732", "Detail": { "ID": 308732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0685688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279771", "Detail": { "ID": 279771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5221249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279538", "Detail": { "ID": 279538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5120054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260499", "Detail": { "ID": 260499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.079529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299381", "Detail": { "ID": 299381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6949971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306763", "Detail": { "ID": 306763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5663579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300572", "Detail": { "ID": 300572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0043741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223971", "Detail": { "ID": 223971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4864613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305570", "Detail": { "ID": 305570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3300678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320110", "Detail": { "ID": 320110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9620983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315893", "Detail": { "ID": 315893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9317671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236764", "Detail": { "ID": 236764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9390555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289741", "Detail": { "ID": 289741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4571521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234298", "Detail": { "ID": 234298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3712449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313153", "Detail": { "ID": 313153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.165943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289364", "Detail": { "ID": 289364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4340661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225369", "Detail": { "ID": 225369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9717543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265738", "Detail": { "ID": 265738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4523533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283216", "Detail": { "ID": 283216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6908723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252035", "Detail": { "ID": 252035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4997769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317331", "Detail": { "ID": 317331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4175182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254247", "Detail": { "ID": 254247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2472903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296266", "Detail": { "ID": 296266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8412392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235478", "Detail": { "ID": 235478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6795697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257717", "Detail": { "ID": 257717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0745413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228564", "Detail": { "ID": 228564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8045423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291069", "Detail": { "ID": 291069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7841362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311158", "Detail": { "ID": 311158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6082172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246787", "Detail": { "ID": 246787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1533987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298034", "Detail": { "ID": 298034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1354343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234065", "Detail": { "ID": 234065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1651269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274688", "Detail": { "ID": 274688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269968", "Detail": { "ID": 269968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5758369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317499", "Detail": { "ID": 317499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4250395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326420", "Detail": { "ID": 326420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7578285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241270", "Detail": { "ID": 241270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7507058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290380", "Detail": { "ID": 290380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7444494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248044", "Detail": { "ID": 248044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4393392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287495", "Detail": { "ID": 287495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8734548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222613", "Detail": { "ID": 222613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1964696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239854", "Detail": { "ID": 239854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7617879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283776", "Detail": { "ID": 283776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7229773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231772", "Detail": { "ID": 231772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6148405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237360", "Detail": { "ID": 237360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2008354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308972", "Detail": { "ID": 308972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2098, "AgendaID": 2520, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Future", "Reference": "S4M-07721", "ID": 7821 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-18T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0859996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259535", "Detail": { "ID": 259535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6132892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318074", "Detail": { "ID": 318074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4558147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250120", "Detail": { "ID": 250120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9642156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320756", "Detail": { "ID": 320756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1802245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229457", "Detail": { "ID": 229457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0826046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281531", "Detail": { "ID": 281531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1468112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263307", "Detail": { "ID": 263307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8836867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290727", "Detail": { "ID": 290727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7696377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227917", "Detail": { "ID": 227917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5712391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270646", "Detail": { "ID": 270646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.816747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323049", "Detail": { "ID": 323049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7198227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297379", "Detail": { "ID": 297379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0974273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242603", "Detail": { "ID": 242603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0274494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236968", "Detail": { "ID": 236968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9480872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301590", "Detail": { "ID": 301590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2690461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261943", "Detail": { "ID": 261943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3848841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316736", "Detail": { "ID": 316736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1610056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326670", "Detail": { "ID": 326670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.775068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278136", "Detail": { "ID": 278136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9885841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264945", "Detail": { "ID": 264945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1614685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249305", "Detail": { "ID": 249305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9208384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293563", "Detail": { "ID": 293563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8507444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285527", "Detail": { "ID": 285527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3331545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232074", "Detail": { "ID": 232074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6333952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243272", "Detail": { "ID": 243272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2902192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253908", "Detail": { "ID": 253908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0260127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321393", "Detail": { "ID": 321393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4339129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292005", "Detail": { "ID": 292005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1517623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273214", "Detail": { "ID": 273214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.605594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262920", "Detail": { "ID": 262920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6289054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282351", "Detail": { "ID": 282351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.409098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298918", "Detail": { "ID": 298918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3779574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230608", "Detail": { "ID": 230608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3377241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287228", "Detail": { "ID": 287228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8551464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219714", "Detail": { "ID": 219714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3113524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239088", "Detail": { "ID": 239088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4822494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226238", "Detail": { "ID": 226238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2164805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322246", "Detail": { "ID": 322246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6744907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292195", "Detail": { "ID": 292195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1659342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228201", "Detail": { "ID": 228201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7825172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304440", "Detail": { "ID": 304440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.038331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258006", "Detail": { "ID": 258006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0872682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271638", "Detail": { "ID": 271638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0848009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279416", "Detail": { "ID": 279416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5067873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266709", "Detail": { "ID": 266709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7531644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250817", "Detail": { "ID": 250817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2147676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221281", "Detail": { "ID": 221281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9225985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226349", "Detail": { "ID": 226349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2275071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240020", "Detail": { "ID": 240020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7693017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266659", "Detail": { "ID": 266659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7506731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324308", "Detail": { "ID": 324308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2111492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260837", "Detail": { "ID": 260837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1000517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246134", "Detail": { "ID": 246134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8736763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276129", "Detail": { "ID": 276129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4117191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303586", "Detail": { "ID": 303586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8217072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222251", "Detail": { "ID": 222251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1748591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242461", "Detail": { "ID": 242461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0142726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224700", "Detail": { "ID": 224700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7161742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308348", "Detail": { "ID": 308348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0520846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272554", "Detail": { "ID": 272554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3404013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244453", "Detail": { "ID": 244453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5553976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314628", "Detail": { "ID": 314628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6482994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252477", "Detail": { "ID": 252477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.730841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275569", "Detail": { "ID": 275569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3811744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257032", "Detail": { "ID": 257032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8203945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283077", "Detail": { "ID": 283077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4513411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254121", "Detail": { "ID": 254121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0354233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278724", "Detail": { "ID": 278724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2315583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324977", "Detail": { "ID": 324977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2459176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232001", "Detail": { "ID": 232001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6249399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312320", "Detail": { "ID": 312320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1227464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232623", "Detail": { "ID": 232623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8691705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267802", "Detail": { "ID": 267802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0356314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314529", "Detail": { "ID": 314529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6439538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296684", "Detail": { "ID": 296684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8695382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319495", "Detail": { "ID": 319495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9284212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305881", "Detail": { "ID": 305881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3493595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309904", "Detail": { "ID": 309904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3559649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268638", "Detail": { "ID": 268638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2762341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293710", "Detail": { "ID": 293710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8656118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271389", "Detail": { "ID": 271389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0737107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269347", "Detail": { "ID": 269347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5436212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307374", "Detail": { "ID": 307374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8266868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280632", "Detail": { "ID": 280632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7755368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281218", "Detail": { "ID": 281218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1253396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245275", "Detail": { "ID": 245275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8278427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304828", "Detail": { "ID": 304828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0604791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302266", "Detail": { "ID": 302266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5169819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300169", "Detail": { "ID": 300169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7392696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224493", "Detail": { "ID": 224493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7072125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297461", "Detail": { "ID": 297461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1011743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321231", "Detail": { "ID": 321231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4192593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315453", "Detail": { "ID": 315453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9126638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237595", "Detail": { "ID": 237595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2175775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292534", "Detail": { "ID": 292534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5381299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233907", "Detail": { "ID": 233907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1515023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312045", "Detail": { "ID": 312045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9113418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286787", "Detail": { "ID": 286787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6006537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225709", "Detail": { "ID": 225709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9870267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265490", "Detail": { "ID": 265490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4414335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283831", "Detail": { "ID": 283831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7253406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258735", "Detail": { "ID": 258735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3256366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318452", "Detail": { "ID": 318452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6581943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256088", "Detail": { "ID": 256088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5701073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293990", "Detail": { "ID": 293990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8778723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236005", "Detail": { "ID": 236005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.702277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256361", "Detail": { "ID": 256361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7792193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229393", "Detail": { "ID": 229393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0798135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289416", "Detail": { "ID": 289416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4363008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310440", "Detail": { "ID": 310440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5707073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247151", "Detail": { "ID": 247151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1692796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298662", "Detail": { "ID": 298662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3558371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235759", "Detail": { "ID": 235759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6917752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275402", "Detail": { "ID": 275402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3736977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274110", "Detail": { "ID": 274110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.654879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316787", "Detail": { "ID": 316787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1634601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326006", "Detail": { "ID": 326006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5311791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241490", "Detail": { "ID": 241490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7669946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287968", "Detail": { "ID": 287968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8943236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248257", "Detail": { "ID": 248257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6380892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290802", "Detail": { "ID": 290802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7727996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222800", "Detail": { "ID": 222800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2052423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240785", "Detail": { "ID": 240785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3821916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284063", "Detail": { "ID": 284063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.741359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251633", "Detail": { "ID": 251633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4723995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246729", "Detail": { "ID": 246729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.150936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309786", "Detail": { "ID": 309786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2094, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 106, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.2", "ID": 7822 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3448866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259534", "Detail": { "ID": 259534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6132478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318073", "Detail": { "ID": 318073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.455772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250119", "Detail": { "ID": 250119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9641732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320757", "Detail": { "ID": 320757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1802664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229459", "Detail": { "ID": 229459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0826876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281480", "Detail": { "ID": 281480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1446509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263308", "Detail": { "ID": 263308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.883823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290729", "Detail": { "ID": 290729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7697182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227918", "Detail": { "ID": 227918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5712807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270647", "Detail": { "ID": 270647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8167888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323253", "Detail": { "ID": 323253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9417513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297380", "Detail": { "ID": 297380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0974681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242604", "Detail": { "ID": 242604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0274907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236615", "Detail": { "ID": 236615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9326448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301591", "Detail": { "ID": 301591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2690869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261942", "Detail": { "ID": 261942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.384843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316692", "Detail": { "ID": 316692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1591089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326669", "Detail": { "ID": 326669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7749991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278137", "Detail": { "ID": 278137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9886259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264944", "Detail": { "ID": 264944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1614276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249266", "Detail": { "ID": 249266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9191655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293562", "Detail": { "ID": 293562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8507033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285528", "Detail": { "ID": 285528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3331953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232075", "Detail": { "ID": 232075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6334362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243271", "Detail": { "ID": 243271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2901784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253907", "Detail": { "ID": 253907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0259713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321392", "Detail": { "ID": 321392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4338715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292006", "Detail": { "ID": 292006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1518033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273215", "Detail": { "ID": 273215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6056354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262922", "Detail": { "ID": 262922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6289875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282403", "Detail": { "ID": 282403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4113655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298861", "Detail": { "ID": 298861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3752906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230607", "Detail": { "ID": 230607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3376832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287227", "Detail": { "ID": 287227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8551056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219752", "Detail": { "ID": 219752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3130072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239049", "Detail": { "ID": 239049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4805685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226237", "Detail": { "ID": 226237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2164394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322191", "Detail": { "ID": 322191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4754893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292194", "Detail": { "ID": 292194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1658937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228229", "Detail": { "ID": 228229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7838266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304441", "Detail": { "ID": 304441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0383727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258007", "Detail": { "ID": 258007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0873094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271637", "Detail": { "ID": 271637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0847606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279467", "Detail": { "ID": 279467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5089786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266710", "Detail": { "ID": 266710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7532058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250818", "Detail": { "ID": 250818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2148074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221282", "Detail": { "ID": 221282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9226397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220901", "Detail": { "ID": 220901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6618509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240021", "Detail": { "ID": 240021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7693427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266621", "Detail": { "ID": 266621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.749044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324309", "Detail": { "ID": 324309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.211191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260835", "Detail": { "ID": 260835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0999694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246471", "Detail": { "ID": 246471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1301519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276128", "Detail": { "ID": 276128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4116762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303585", "Detail": { "ID": 303585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8216649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222250", "Detail": { "ID": 222250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1747982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242460", "Detail": { "ID": 242460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0142121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224644", "Detail": { "ID": 224644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7137076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308291", "Detail": { "ID": 308291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0493017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272555", "Detail": { "ID": 272555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3404426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244454", "Detail": { "ID": 244454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5554393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314629", "Detail": { "ID": 314629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6483403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251975", "Detail": { "ID": 251975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4971691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275570", "Detail": { "ID": 275570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3812159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257033", "Detail": { "ID": 257033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8204351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283076", "Detail": { "ID": 283076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4513002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254152", "Detail": { "ID": 254152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0367519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278722", "Detail": { "ID": 278722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2314784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324976", "Detail": { "ID": 324976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2458587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232002", "Detail": { "ID": 232002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6249816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312274", "Detail": { "ID": 312274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1205506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232584", "Detail": { "ID": 232584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8672042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267836", "Detail": { "ID": 267836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0370921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314579", "Detail": { "ID": 314579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.646184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296731", "Detail": { "ID": 296731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8715083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319440", "Detail": { "ID": 319440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9260579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305880", "Detail": { "ID": 305880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3493169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309905", "Detail": { "ID": 309905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3560068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268600", "Detail": { "ID": 268600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2746044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293201", "Detail": { "ID": 293201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8344959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271388", "Detail": { "ID": 271388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0736693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269345", "Detail": { "ID": 269345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5435385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307373", "Detail": { "ID": 307373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8266439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280634", "Detail": { "ID": 280634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7756422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281217", "Detail": { "ID": 281217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.125299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245274", "Detail": { "ID": 245274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8277995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304874", "Detail": { "ID": 304874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.062439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302267", "Detail": { "ID": 302267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5170236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300168", "Detail": { "ID": 300168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7392275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224494", "Detail": { "ID": 224494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7072538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297462", "Detail": { "ID": 297462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1012275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321282", "Detail": { "ID": 321282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.42147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315452", "Detail": { "ID": 315452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9126221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237596", "Detail": { "ID": 237596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2176185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292533", "Detail": { "ID": 292533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5380888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233906", "Detail": { "ID": 233906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1514616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312044", "Detail": { "ID": 312044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9113009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286788", "Detail": { "ID": 286788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6006951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226077", "Detail": { "ID": 226077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0090661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265489", "Detail": { "ID": 265489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4413718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283832", "Detail": { "ID": 283832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7253821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258762", "Detail": { "ID": 258762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3268482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318506", "Detail": { "ID": 318506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6611205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256087", "Detail": { "ID": 256087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5700662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293991", "Detail": { "ID": 293991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.877914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236351", "Detail": { "ID": 236351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9128723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256362", "Detail": { "ID": 256362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7792601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229394", "Detail": { "ID": 229394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0798541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289415", "Detail": { "ID": 289415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4362599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310441", "Detail": { "ID": 310441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5707821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247152", "Detail": { "ID": 247152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1693228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298661", "Detail": { "ID": 298661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.355796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235758", "Detail": { "ID": 235758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.691735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275404", "Detail": { "ID": 275404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3737813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274059", "Detail": { "ID": 274059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6526045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316788", "Detail": { "ID": 316788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1635196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326007", "Detail": { "ID": 326007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5312203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241491", "Detail": { "ID": 241491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7670658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287969", "Detail": { "ID": 287969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8943841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248285", "Detail": { "ID": 248285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6393161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290801", "Detail": { "ID": 290801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7727376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222845", "Detail": { "ID": 222845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2071638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240784", "Detail": { "ID": 240784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3821507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284064", "Detail": { "ID": 284064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7414192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251631", "Detail": { "ID": 251631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4723172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246701", "Detail": { "ID": 246701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1497419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310150", "Detail": { "ID": 310150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2095, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 6, "VoteAgainst": 106, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712.1", "ID": 7820 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3666469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259533", "Detail": { "ID": 259533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6132067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318072", "Detail": { "ID": 318072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4557126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250118", "Detail": { "ID": 250118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9641145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320758", "Detail": { "ID": 320758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1804298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229508", "Detail": { "ID": 229508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0847784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281481", "Detail": { "ID": 281481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1446928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263309", "Detail": { "ID": 263309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8838726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290730", "Detail": { "ID": 290730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7697592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227919", "Detail": { "ID": 227919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5713223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270648", "Detail": { "ID": 270648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8168304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323252", "Detail": { "ID": 323252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.94171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297381", "Detail": { "ID": 297381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0975123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242605", "Detail": { "ID": 242605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0275306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236614", "Detail": { "ID": 236614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9326027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301592", "Detail": { "ID": 301592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2691277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261941", "Detail": { "ID": 261941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316693", "Detail": { "ID": 316693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.15915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326668", "Detail": { "ID": 326668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7749586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278138", "Detail": { "ID": 278138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9886742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264943", "Detail": { "ID": 264943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1613872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249265", "Detail": { "ID": 249265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9191245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293561", "Detail": { "ID": 293561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8506618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285529", "Detail": { "ID": 285529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3332369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232076", "Detail": { "ID": 232076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6334773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243270", "Detail": { "ID": 243270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2901378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253906", "Detail": { "ID": 253906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0259122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321391", "Detail": { "ID": 321391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4338306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292010", "Detail": { "ID": 292010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1519897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273216", "Detail": { "ID": 273216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.605677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262923", "Detail": { "ID": 262923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6290467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282402", "Detail": { "ID": 282402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.411305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298862", "Detail": { "ID": 298862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3753307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230606", "Detail": { "ID": 230606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3376418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287226", "Detail": { "ID": 287226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8550644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219753", "Detail": { "ID": 219753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3130511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239050", "Detail": { "ID": 239050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4806095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226236", "Detail": { "ID": 226236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2163973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322192", "Detail": { "ID": 322192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4755308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292193", "Detail": { "ID": 292193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1658522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228230", "Detail": { "ID": 228230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7838685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304442", "Detail": { "ID": 304442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0384138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258207", "Detail": { "ID": 258207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.2970996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271636", "Detail": { "ID": 271636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0847199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279466", "Detail": { "ID": 279466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5089359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266711", "Detail": { "ID": 266711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7532466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250858", "Detail": { "ID": 250858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2165351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221283", "Detail": { "ID": 221283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9252693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220900", "Detail": { "ID": 220900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.66181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240022", "Detail": { "ID": 240022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7693836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266620", "Detail": { "ID": 266620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7490031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324310", "Detail": { "ID": 324310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2112318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260834", "Detail": { "ID": 260834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0999284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246470", "Detail": { "ID": 246470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1301104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276127", "Detail": { "ID": 276127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4116148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303584", "Detail": { "ID": 303584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8216055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222249", "Detail": { "ID": 222249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1747569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242459", "Detail": { "ID": 242459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.01417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224643", "Detail": { "ID": 224643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.713666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308292", "Detail": { "ID": 308292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0493425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272596", "Detail": { "ID": 272596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3421987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244455", "Detail": { "ID": 244455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5554802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314630", "Detail": { "ID": 314630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6483813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251976", "Detail": { "ID": 251976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4972101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275571", "Detail": { "ID": 275571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3812571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257034", "Detail": { "ID": 257034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8204754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283075", "Detail": { "ID": 283075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.451259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254151", "Detail": { "ID": 254151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0367103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278721", "Detail": { "ID": 278721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2314371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324975", "Detail": { "ID": 324975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2458179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232003", "Detail": { "ID": 232003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6250401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312275", "Detail": { "ID": 312275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1205917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232583", "Detail": { "ID": 232583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8671633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267837", "Detail": { "ID": 267837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0371336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314578", "Detail": { "ID": 314578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.646124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296730", "Detail": { "ID": 296730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8714684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319441", "Detail": { "ID": 319441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9260991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305879", "Detail": { "ID": 305879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3492764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309906", "Detail": { "ID": 309906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.356048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268599", "Detail": { "ID": 268599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2745609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293202", "Detail": { "ID": 293202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8345545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262203", "Detail": { "ID": 262203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5913162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269344", "Detail": { "ID": 269344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5434972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307372", "Detail": { "ID": 307372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8265956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280635", "Detail": { "ID": 280635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7756857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281216", "Detail": { "ID": 281216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1252581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245273", "Detail": { "ID": 245273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8277331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304873", "Detail": { "ID": 304873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0623983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302268", "Detail": { "ID": 302268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5170643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300167", "Detail": { "ID": 300167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7391867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224495", "Detail": { "ID": 224495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7072962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297463", "Detail": { "ID": 297463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1012705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321281", "Detail": { "ID": 321281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4214285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315451", "Detail": { "ID": 315451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9125802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237597", "Detail": { "ID": 237597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2176593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292532", "Detail": { "ID": 292532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5380475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233905", "Detail": { "ID": 233905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1514201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312043", "Detail": { "ID": 312043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9112596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286789", "Detail": { "ID": 286789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6007352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226078", "Detail": { "ID": 226078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0091067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265488", "Detail": { "ID": 265488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4413311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283836", "Detail": { "ID": 283836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7255466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258763", "Detail": { "ID": 258763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3268895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318505", "Detail": { "ID": 318505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6610486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256047", "Detail": { "ID": 256047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5682593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293992", "Detail": { "ID": 293992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8779606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236352", "Detail": { "ID": 236352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9129139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256363", "Detail": { "ID": 256363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7793017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229395", "Detail": { "ID": 229395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.079895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289414", "Detail": { "ID": 289414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4362189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310442", "Detail": { "ID": 310442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5708294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247153", "Detail": { "ID": 247153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1693649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298660", "Detail": { "ID": 298660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3557546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235757", "Detail": { "ID": 235757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6916949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275405", "Detail": { "ID": 275405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3738223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274060", "Detail": { "ID": 274060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6526462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316789", "Detail": { "ID": 316789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1635612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326008", "Detail": { "ID": 326008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5312796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241492", "Detail": { "ID": 241492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7671119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287970", "Detail": { "ID": 287970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8944264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248286", "Detail": { "ID": 248286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6393573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290797", "Detail": { "ID": 290797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7725779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222846", "Detail": { "ID": 222846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2072045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240783", "Detail": { "ID": 240783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3821101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284065", "Detail": { "ID": 284065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.741464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251581", "Detail": { "ID": 251581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4701445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246700", "Detail": { "ID": 246700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1497017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310149", "Detail": { "ID": 310149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2096, "AgendaID": 2567, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 6, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Open Cast Mining in Scotland, Coaling and Restoring", "Reference": "S4M-07712", "ID": 7811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-17T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3666051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259264", "Detail": { "ID": 259264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6013871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318687", "Detail": { "ID": 318687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6691015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250255", "Detail": { "ID": 250255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1813107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321110", "Detail": { "ID": 321110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2026858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228437", "Detail": { "ID": 228437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7989841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281545", "Detail": { "ID": 281545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1474011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263063", "Detail": { "ID": 263063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6351644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288111", "Detail": { "ID": 288111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9005615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227480", "Detail": { "ID": 227480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5519613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269297", "Detail": { "ID": 269297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5414183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323040", "Detail": { "ID": 323040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7194311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295908", "Detail": { "ID": 295908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5409745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243096", "Detail": { "ID": 243096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0487292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227038", "Detail": { "ID": 227038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2648192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301059", "Detail": { "ID": 301059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0310549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238390", "Detail": { "ID": 238390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4444788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316745", "Detail": { "ID": 316745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1613977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326952", "Detail": { "ID": 326952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7871928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277559", "Detail": { "ID": 277559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9585318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263927", "Detail": { "ID": 263927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9167786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250949", "Detail": { "ID": 250949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2205141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294152", "Detail": { "ID": 294152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8849445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285414", "Detail": { "ID": 285414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.322003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231350", "Detail": { "ID": 231350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5911557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243622", "Detail": { "ID": 243622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3128354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254352", "Detail": { "ID": 254352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2518826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323403", "Detail": { "ID": 323403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9546282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300656", "Detail": { "ID": 300656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0079794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273111", "Detail": { "ID": 273111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3700634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262642", "Detail": { "ID": 262642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6106384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282337", "Detail": { "ID": 282337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4084462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298932", "Detail": { "ID": 298932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3785617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230627", "Detail": { "ID": 230627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3385494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285839", "Detail": { "ID": 285839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3467476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219627", "Detail": { "ID": 219627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3075525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238162", "Detail": { "ID": 238162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2475814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226681", "Detail": { "ID": 226681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2420099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322255", "Detail": { "ID": 322255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6748813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292271", "Detail": { "ID": 292271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5265771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227655", "Detail": { "ID": 227655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5596699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304543", "Detail": { "ID": 304543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0429364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257871", "Detail": { "ID": 257871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0811836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271193", "Detail": { "ID": 271193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.846461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279402", "Detail": { "ID": 279402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.506183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266423", "Detail": { "ID": 266423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7402972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250688", "Detail": { "ID": 250688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2093104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221155", "Detail": { "ID": 221155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6774365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226437", "Detail": { "ID": 226437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2313534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239733", "Detail": { "ID": 239733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7565795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253210", "Detail": { "ID": 253210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9861347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324847", "Detail": { "ID": 324847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2403643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260961", "Detail": { "ID": 260961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1054331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246061", "Detail": { "ID": 246061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8705115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273552", "Detail": { "ID": 273552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6253271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303656", "Detail": { "ID": 303656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8246933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223159", "Detail": { "ID": 223159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2311417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245670", "Detail": { "ID": 245670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8534354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223325", "Detail": { "ID": 223325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4530225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308362", "Detail": { "ID": 308362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0526771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272424", "Detail": { "ID": 272424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3347399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245107", "Detail": { "ID": 245107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5923357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315323", "Detail": { "ID": 315323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9066634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247075", "Detail": { "ID": 247075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1659945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275047", "Detail": { "ID": 275047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1388773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255074", "Detail": { "ID": 255074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2960923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277352", "Detail": { "ID": 277352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9445608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254049", "Detail": { "ID": 254049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0323144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278847", "Detail": { "ID": 278847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2367983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325284", "Detail": { "ID": 325284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4920553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231949", "Detail": { "ID": 231949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6227245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312334", "Detail": { "ID": 312334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1233398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233165", "Detail": { "ID": 233165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8996773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267738", "Detail": { "ID": 267738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0328753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314515", "Detail": { "ID": 314515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6433468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296670", "Detail": { "ID": 296670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8689324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319504", "Detail": { "ID": 319504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9288123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306162", "Detail": { "ID": 306162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3616572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310276", "Detail": { "ID": 310276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5635056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268702", "Detail": { "ID": 268702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2789982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293724", "Detail": { "ID": 293724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8662051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271838", "Detail": { "ID": 271838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0936062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269471", "Detail": { "ID": 269471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5489982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307316", "Detail": { "ID": 307316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8239693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280208", "Detail": { "ID": 280208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7507103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279114", "Detail": { "ID": 279114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2536309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260413", "Detail": { "ID": 260413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0758035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304814", "Detail": { "ID": 304814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0598812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302183", "Detail": { "ID": 302183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3011288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300244", "Detail": { "ID": 300244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.989605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224212", "Detail": { "ID": 224212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6888861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305705", "Detail": { "ID": 305705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3358628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321222", "Detail": { "ID": 321222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4188646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315759", "Detail": { "ID": 315759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.925749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237185", "Detail": { "ID": 237185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1930175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288858", "Detail": { "ID": 288858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1614193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234181", "Detail": { "ID": 234181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1701399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312862", "Detail": { "ID": 312862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1465945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261388", "Detail": { "ID": 261388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3551949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225616", "Detail": { "ID": 225616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9830213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265621", "Detail": { "ID": 265621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4471213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284173", "Detail": { "ID": 284173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7461552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252159", "Detail": { "ID": 252159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.505137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318442", "Detail": { "ID": 318442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6577593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256676", "Detail": { "ID": 256676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7929323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293907", "Detail": { "ID": 293907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8739531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235918", "Detail": { "ID": 235918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6985492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255933", "Detail": { "ID": 255933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5632152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229265", "Detail": { "ID": 229265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0692135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289485", "Detail": { "ID": 289485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4392732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311605", "Detail": { "ID": 311605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8861525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246872", "Detail": { "ID": 246872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1570119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297614", "Detail": { "ID": 297614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.107756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233799", "Detail": { "ID": 233799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1468001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274969", "Detail": { "ID": 274969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1354058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274124", "Detail": { "ID": 274124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6554804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317789", "Detail": { "ID": 317789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4374144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326546", "Detail": { "ID": 326546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7693254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241356", "Detail": { "ID": 241356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.754409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290468", "Detail": { "ID": 290468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7483794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248170", "Detail": { "ID": 248170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4461552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289236", "Detail": { "ID": 289236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4285427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222706", "Detail": { "ID": 222706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.200666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240919", "Detail": { "ID": 240919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3880492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283697", "Detail": { "ID": 283697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7193698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231070", "Detail": { "ID": 231070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.364326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247269", "Detail": { "ID": 247269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3962787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309772", "Detail": { "ID": 309772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2089, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 5, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-07648", "ID": 13098 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3442686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259272", "Detail": { "ID": 259272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6017235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317985", "Detail": { "ID": 317985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4520182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250246", "Detail": { "ID": 250246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1809185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320832", "Detail": { "ID": 320832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1835973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228467", "Detail": { "ID": 228467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.800333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281562", "Detail": { "ID": 281562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1481297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263095", "Detail": { "ID": 263095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.636553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288104", "Detail": { "ID": 288104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9002514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227517", "Detail": { "ID": 227517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5535513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269289", "Detail": { "ID": 269289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5410832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323023", "Detail": { "ID": 323023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7187051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297318", "Detail": { "ID": 297318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0945311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242687", "Detail": { "ID": 242687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0312964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227029", "Detail": { "ID": 227029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2644235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301558", "Detail": { "ID": 301558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2676778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262026", "Detail": { "ID": 262026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3884197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316916", "Detail": { "ID": 316916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1689607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326585", "Detail": { "ID": 326585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7710813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277590", "Detail": { "ID": 277590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.959853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265017", "Detail": { "ID": 265017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1648007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250940", "Detail": { "ID": 250940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2201325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291168", "Detail": { "ID": 291168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7886156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285444", "Detail": { "ID": 285444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3235391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231382", "Detail": { "ID": 231382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5977267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243184", "Detail": { "ID": 243184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2863157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254004", "Detail": { "ID": 254004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0303801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321151", "Detail": { "ID": 321151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2044693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300646", "Detail": { "ID": 300646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0075464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273142", "Detail": { "ID": 273142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3714058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262651", "Detail": { "ID": 262651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6110239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282320", "Detail": { "ID": 282320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4077245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298949", "Detail": { "ID": 298949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3792624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230623", "Detail": { "ID": 230623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3383576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285846", "Detail": { "ID": 285846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3470536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219637", "Detail": { "ID": 219637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3079908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238155", "Detail": { "ID": 238155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2472943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226672", "Detail": { "ID": 226672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2416224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322272", "Detail": { "ID": 322272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.675606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292302", "Detail": { "ID": 292302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5279119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227665", "Detail": { "ID": 227665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5604011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304517", "Detail": { "ID": 304517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0416035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257880", "Detail": { "ID": 257880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0815722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271201", "Detail": { "ID": 271201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0599347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279385", "Detail": { "ID": 279385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5054156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266460", "Detail": { "ID": 266460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7420662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250697", "Detail": { "ID": 250697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2097292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221164", "Detail": { "ID": 221164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.677834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226427", "Detail": { "ID": 226427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2309183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239769", "Detail": { "ID": 239769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.758129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266706", "Detail": { "ID": 266706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7530402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324396", "Detail": { "ID": 324396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2149305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260952", "Detail": { "ID": 260952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1050656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246069", "Detail": { "ID": 246069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8708699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276212", "Detail": { "ID": 276212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.649411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303619", "Detail": { "ID": 303619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8231193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223150", "Detail": { "ID": 223150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.230754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245661", "Detail": { "ID": 245661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8530499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223316", "Detail": { "ID": 223316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4526315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308379", "Detail": { "ID": 308379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.053412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272433", "Detail": { "ID": 272433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3351308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244696", "Detail": { "ID": 244696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5743602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314716", "Detail": { "ID": 314716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6524147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247067", "Detail": { "ID": 247067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1656483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275039", "Detail": { "ID": 275039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1385479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255066", "Detail": { "ID": 255066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2957462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277360", "Detail": { "ID": 277360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9448872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254057", "Detail": { "ID": 254057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0326609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278837", "Detail": { "ID": 278837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2363754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324889", "Detail": { "ID": 324889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.242144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231965", "Detail": { "ID": 231965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6234049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312351", "Detail": { "ID": 312351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1240897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233156", "Detail": { "ID": 233156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8992866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267755", "Detail": { "ID": 267755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0336014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314498", "Detail": { "ID": 314498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6426027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296654", "Detail": { "ID": 296654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8682661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319676", "Detail": { "ID": 319676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9365512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305799", "Detail": { "ID": 305799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3458484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310310", "Detail": { "ID": 310310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5649983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268685", "Detail": { "ID": 268685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2782523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293741", "Detail": { "ID": 293741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8669333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271829", "Detail": { "ID": 271829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.093239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269462", "Detail": { "ID": 269462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5486065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307285", "Detail": { "ID": 307285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.822639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280212", "Detail": { "ID": 280212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7509022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281289", "Detail": { "ID": 281289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1284267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245192", "Detail": { "ID": 245192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.824008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300012", "Detail": { "ID": 300012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7325281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301843", "Detail": { "ID": 301843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2856551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300274", "Detail": { "ID": 300274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9908996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224221", "Detail": { "ID": 224221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6895225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297544", "Detail": { "ID": 297544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1047615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321051", "Detail": { "ID": 321051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2001335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315365", "Detail": { "ID": 315365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9088424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237218", "Detail": { "ID": 237218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.194752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292595", "Detail": { "ID": 292595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5495997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233992", "Detail": { "ID": 233992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1551953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311957", "Detail": { "ID": 311957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9075453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261357", "Detail": { "ID": 261357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3538654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225625", "Detail": { "ID": 225625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.983409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265584", "Detail": { "ID": 265584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4454704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284163", "Detail": { "ID": 284163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7457212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258656", "Detail": { "ID": 258656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3169068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318270", "Detail": { "ID": 318270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6455518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256667", "Detail": { "ID": 256667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7925429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293874", "Detail": { "ID": 293874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8725429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235927", "Detail": { "ID": 235927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6989377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255969", "Detail": { "ID": 255969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5647304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229274", "Detail": { "ID": 229274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0696107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289448", "Detail": { "ID": 289448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4376783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310527", "Detail": { "ID": 310527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5747307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246881", "Detail": { "ID": 246881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1573947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298723", "Detail": { "ID": 298723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3694661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235841", "Detail": { "ID": 235841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.695267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274979", "Detail": { "ID": 274979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1358857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274141", "Detail": { "ID": 274141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6562298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316875", "Detail": { "ID": 316875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1672153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326095", "Detail": { "ID": 326095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5396699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241365", "Detail": { "ID": 241365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7547765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288673", "Detail": { "ID": 288673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1535077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248179", "Detail": { "ID": 248179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4466561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290014", "Detail": { "ID": 290014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4690725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222715", "Detail": { "ID": 222715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2010392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240910", "Detail": { "ID": 240910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3876538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283690", "Detail": { "ID": 283690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7190687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251701", "Detail": { "ID": 251701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4850148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247260", "Detail": { "ID": 247260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3959098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309755", "Detail": { "ID": 309755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2092, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 50, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.2", "ID": 7752 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3435483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259273", "Detail": { "ID": 259273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6017638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317986", "Detail": { "ID": 317986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4520597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250247", "Detail": { "ID": 250247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1809779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320831", "Detail": { "ID": 320831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1835557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228466", "Detail": { "ID": 228466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8002924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281563", "Detail": { "ID": 281563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1481696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263094", "Detail": { "ID": 263094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6365122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288103", "Detail": { "ID": 288103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9002104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227516", "Detail": { "ID": 227516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5535104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269288", "Detail": { "ID": 269288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5410395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323022", "Detail": { "ID": 323022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7186341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297317", "Detail": { "ID": 297317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0944903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242686", "Detail": { "ID": 242686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0312563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227030", "Detail": { "ID": 227030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2644649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301557", "Detail": { "ID": 301557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2676373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262027", "Detail": { "ID": 262027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3884613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316917", "Detail": { "ID": 316917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1690012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326586", "Detail": { "ID": 326586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7711227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277589", "Detail": { "ID": 277589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9598125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265018", "Detail": { "ID": 265018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1648425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250941", "Detail": { "ID": 250941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2201723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291169", "Detail": { "ID": 291169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7886564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285443", "Detail": { "ID": 285443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3234979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231381", "Detail": { "ID": 231381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5924667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243185", "Detail": { "ID": 243185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2864214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254005", "Detail": { "ID": 254005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0304208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321152", "Detail": { "ID": 321152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2045099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300647", "Detail": { "ID": 300647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0075866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273141", "Detail": { "ID": 273141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3713636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262650", "Detail": { "ID": 262650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6109837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282319", "Detail": { "ID": 282319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4076821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298950", "Detail": { "ID": 298950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3793025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230624", "Detail": { "ID": 230624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.338398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285847", "Detail": { "ID": 285847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.347095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219636", "Detail": { "ID": 219636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3079499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238154", "Detail": { "ID": 238154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2472533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226673", "Detail": { "ID": 226673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2416628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322273", "Detail": { "ID": 322273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6756663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292303", "Detail": { "ID": 292303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5279526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227664", "Detail": { "ID": 227664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.560353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304516", "Detail": { "ID": 304516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0415446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257879", "Detail": { "ID": 257879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0815304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271202", "Detail": { "ID": 271202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0599788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279384", "Detail": { "ID": 279384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5053728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266459", "Detail": { "ID": 266459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7420252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250696", "Detail": { "ID": 250696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2096568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221163", "Detail": { "ID": 221163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6777922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226428", "Detail": { "ID": 226428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2309586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239768", "Detail": { "ID": 239768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7580682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266705", "Detail": { "ID": 266705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7529986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324395", "Detail": { "ID": 324395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2148898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260953", "Detail": { "ID": 260953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1051063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246070", "Detail": { "ID": 246070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8709103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276213", "Detail": { "ID": 276213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6494531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303620", "Detail": { "ID": 303620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8231602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223151", "Detail": { "ID": 223151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2307939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245662", "Detail": { "ID": 245662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.85309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223317", "Detail": { "ID": 223317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4526729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308380", "Detail": { "ID": 308380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0534538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272432", "Detail": { "ID": 272432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3350884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244695", "Detail": { "ID": 244695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.574303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314715", "Detail": { "ID": 314715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6523738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247066", "Detail": { "ID": 247066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1656078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275038", "Detail": { "ID": 275038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1385054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255065", "Detail": { "ID": 255065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2957064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277361", "Detail": { "ID": 277361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9500193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254058", "Detail": { "ID": 254058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0327016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278838", "Detail": { "ID": 278838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2364158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324890", "Detail": { "ID": 324890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.242185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231964", "Detail": { "ID": 231964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6233643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312352", "Detail": { "ID": 312352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.124131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233157", "Detail": { "ID": 233157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8993276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267756", "Detail": { "ID": 267756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.033644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314497", "Detail": { "ID": 314497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6425609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296653", "Detail": { "ID": 296653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8682261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319677", "Detail": { "ID": 319677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9365942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305800", "Detail": { "ID": 305800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3458905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310311", "Detail": { "ID": 310311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5650402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268684", "Detail": { "ID": 268684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2782118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293742", "Detail": { "ID": 293742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8669738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271830", "Detail": { "ID": 271830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0932806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269463", "Detail": { "ID": 269463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5486482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307284", "Detail": { "ID": 307284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8225981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280211", "Detail": { "ID": 280211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7508583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281290", "Detail": { "ID": 281290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1284672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245193", "Detail": { "ID": 245193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8240491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300011", "Detail": { "ID": 300011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7324673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301842", "Detail": { "ID": 301842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2856123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300275", "Detail": { "ID": 300275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9909406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224220", "Detail": { "ID": 224220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6894811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297543", "Detail": { "ID": 297543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1047209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321050", "Detail": { "ID": 321050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2000922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315366", "Detail": { "ID": 315366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9088831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237217", "Detail": { "ID": 237217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1947114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292596", "Detail": { "ID": 292596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.54964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233993", "Detail": { "ID": 233993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1552366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311958", "Detail": { "ID": 311958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9075856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261356", "Detail": { "ID": 261356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3538246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225624", "Detail": { "ID": 225624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9833685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265585", "Detail": { "ID": 265585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4455116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284164", "Detail": { "ID": 284164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7457629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258655", "Detail": { "ID": 258655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3168647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318269", "Detail": { "ID": 318269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6455108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256668", "Detail": { "ID": 256668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7925839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293873", "Detail": { "ID": 293873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.872503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235926", "Detail": { "ID": 235926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6988962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255968", "Detail": { "ID": 255968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5646905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229273", "Detail": { "ID": 229273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0695682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289449", "Detail": { "ID": 289449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4377187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310526", "Detail": { "ID": 310526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.57469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246880", "Detail": { "ID": 246880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1573363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298724", "Detail": { "ID": 298724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3695078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235842", "Detail": { "ID": 235842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6953075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274978", "Detail": { "ID": 274978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1358438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274142", "Detail": { "ID": 274142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6562708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316874", "Detail": { "ID": 316874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1671566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326094", "Detail": { "ID": 326094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.539611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241364", "Detail": { "ID": 241364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7547355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288672", "Detail": { "ID": 288672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1534437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248178", "Detail": { "ID": 248178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.446604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290013", "Detail": { "ID": 290013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4690315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222714", "Detail": { "ID": 222714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2009991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240911", "Detail": { "ID": 240911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3876944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283689", "Detail": { "ID": 283689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7190288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251702", "Detail": { "ID": 251702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4850547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247261", "Detail": { "ID": 247261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3959502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309754", "Detail": { "ID": 309754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2091, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643.1", "ID": 7751 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3435077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259258", "Detail": { "ID": 259258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6011192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317984", "Detail": { "ID": 317984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4519594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250245", "Detail": { "ID": 250245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1808776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320833", "Detail": { "ID": 320833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1836384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228468", "Detail": { "ID": 228468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8003737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281561", "Detail": { "ID": 281561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1480897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263096", "Detail": { "ID": 263096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6365935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288117", "Detail": { "ID": 288117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9008135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227518", "Detail": { "ID": 227518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5535915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269303", "Detail": { "ID": 269303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5416993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323024", "Detail": { "ID": 323024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7187482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297319", "Detail": { "ID": 297319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0945721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242688", "Detail": { "ID": 242688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.031337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227028", "Detail": { "ID": 227028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2643814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301559", "Detail": { "ID": 301559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2677187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262025", "Detail": { "ID": 262025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3883591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316915", "Detail": { "ID": 316915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1689199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326584", "Detail": { "ID": 326584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7710398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277591", "Detail": { "ID": 277591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9598927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265016", "Detail": { "ID": 265016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1647559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250939", "Detail": { "ID": 250939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2200921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291167", "Detail": { "ID": 291167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7885749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285445", "Detail": { "ID": 285445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3235803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231383", "Detail": { "ID": 231383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5978099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243183", "Detail": { "ID": 243183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0577121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254003", "Detail": { "ID": 254003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0303399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321150", "Detail": { "ID": 321150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.204428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300645", "Detail": { "ID": 300645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0075062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273143", "Detail": { "ID": 273143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3714469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262652", "Detail": { "ID": 262652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6110641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282321", "Detail": { "ID": 282321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4077653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298948", "Detail": { "ID": 298948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3792228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230622", "Detail": { "ID": 230622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3383174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285055", "Detail": { "ID": 285055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0594851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219638", "Detail": { "ID": 219638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.308032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238170", "Detail": { "ID": 238170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2479373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226671", "Detail": { "ID": 226671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2415812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322271", "Detail": { "ID": 322271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6755654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292301", "Detail": { "ID": 292301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5278713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227666", "Detail": { "ID": 227666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5604489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304518", "Detail": { "ID": 304518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0416446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257881", "Detail": { "ID": 257881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0816134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271187", "Detail": { "ID": 271187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8461986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279386", "Detail": { "ID": 279386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5054587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266461", "Detail": { "ID": 266461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7421067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250698", "Detail": { "ID": 250698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2097721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221165", "Detail": { "ID": 221165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6778753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226426", "Detail": { "ID": 226426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2308765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239770", "Detail": { "ID": 239770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7581712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266863", "Detail": { "ID": 266863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7652695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324397", "Detail": { "ID": 324397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2149709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260951", "Detail": { "ID": 260951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1050233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246053", "Detail": { "ID": 246053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8701811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276211", "Detail": { "ID": 276211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6493694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303618", "Detail": { "ID": 303618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.823079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223149", "Detail": { "ID": 223149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2307142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245660", "Detail": { "ID": 245660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8530093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223315", "Detail": { "ID": 223315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4525902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308378", "Detail": { "ID": 308378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.053371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272434", "Detail": { "ID": 272434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3351712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244697", "Detail": { "ID": 244697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5744016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314717", "Detail": { "ID": 314717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6524561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247387", "Detail": { "ID": 247387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.401624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275053", "Detail": { "ID": 275053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1391461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255080", "Detail": { "ID": 255080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2964216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277346", "Detail": { "ID": 277346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.944294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254043", "Detail": { "ID": 254043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.032049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278836", "Detail": { "ID": 278836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2363343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324888", "Detail": { "ID": 324888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2421034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231966", "Detail": { "ID": 231966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6234454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312350", "Detail": { "ID": 312350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1240488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233155", "Detail": { "ID": 233155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8992449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267754", "Detail": { "ID": 267754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0335415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314499", "Detail": { "ID": 314499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6426435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296655", "Detail": { "ID": 296655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8683063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319675", "Detail": { "ID": 319675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9364912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305798", "Detail": { "ID": 305798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.345788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310309", "Detail": { "ID": 310309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5649573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268686", "Detail": { "ID": 268686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2783135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293740", "Detail": { "ID": 293740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8668928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271828", "Detail": { "ID": 271828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0931965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269461", "Detail": { "ID": 269461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5485657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307286", "Detail": { "ID": 307286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.82268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280213", "Detail": { "ID": 280213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7509439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281288", "Detail": { "ID": 281288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1283859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245191", "Detail": { "ID": 245191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8239666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300013", "Detail": { "ID": 300013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.732571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301844", "Detail": { "ID": 301844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2856963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300273", "Detail": { "ID": 300273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9908578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224222", "Detail": { "ID": 224222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6895641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297545", "Detail": { "ID": 297545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1048026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321052", "Detail": { "ID": 321052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2001739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315364", "Detail": { "ID": 315364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9088011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237219", "Detail": { "ID": 237219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1947929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292594", "Detail": { "ID": 292594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5495546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233991", "Detail": { "ID": 233991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1551548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311956", "Detail": { "ID": 311956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9075033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261358", "Detail": { "ID": 261358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3539235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225626", "Detail": { "ID": 225626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9834497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265583", "Detail": { "ID": 265583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4454289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284162", "Detail": { "ID": 284162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7456805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258657", "Detail": { "ID": 258657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3169477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318271", "Detail": { "ID": 318271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6455925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256666", "Detail": { "ID": 256666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7925024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293875", "Detail": { "ID": 293875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8725827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235928", "Detail": { "ID": 235928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6989796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255970", "Detail": { "ID": 255970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5647707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229275", "Detail": { "ID": 229275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0696525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289447", "Detail": { "ID": 289447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4376374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310528", "Detail": { "ID": 310528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5747714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246882", "Detail": { "ID": 246882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1574364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298722", "Detail": { "ID": 298722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3694074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235840", "Detail": { "ID": 235840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6952252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274980", "Detail": { "ID": 274980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1359266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274140", "Detail": { "ID": 274140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6561876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316876", "Detail": { "ID": 316876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1672573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326096", "Detail": { "ID": 326096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5397122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241366", "Detail": { "ID": 241366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7548379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288674", "Detail": { "ID": 288674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1535489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248180", "Detail": { "ID": 248180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4467121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290015", "Detail": { "ID": 290015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4691131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222716", "Detail": { "ID": 222716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2010808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240909", "Detail": { "ID": 240909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3876126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283703", "Detail": { "ID": 283703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7196159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251700", "Detail": { "ID": 251700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4849746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247259", "Detail": { "ID": 247259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3958676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309756", "Detail": { "ID": 309756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2093, "AgendaID": 2313, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 117, "VoteAgainst": 3, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Enterprise Networks", "Reference": "S4M-07643", "ID": 7739 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3435899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259263", "Detail": { "ID": 259263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6013445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318686", "Detail": { "ID": 318686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6690605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250193", "Detail": { "ID": 250193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1785908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321111", "Detail": { "ID": 321111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2027274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228485", "Detail": { "ID": 228485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8010955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281543", "Detail": { "ID": 281543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1473205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263064", "Detail": { "ID": 263064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6352056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288112", "Detail": { "ID": 288112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9006035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227481", "Detail": { "ID": 227481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5520197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269298", "Detail": { "ID": 269298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5414819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323042", "Detail": { "ID": 323042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7195134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295909", "Detail": { "ID": 295909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5410151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243144", "Detail": { "ID": 243144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.056042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227037", "Detail": { "ID": 227037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2647571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301060", "Detail": { "ID": 301060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0311041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238389", "Detail": { "ID": 238389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4444144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316744", "Detail": { "ID": 316744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.161338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326951", "Detail": { "ID": 326951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7871521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277560", "Detail": { "ID": 277560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9585908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263926", "Detail": { "ID": 263926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9167378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250948", "Detail": { "ID": 250948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.220474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294150", "Detail": { "ID": 294150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8848603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285415", "Detail": { "ID": 285415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3220454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231351", "Detail": { "ID": 231351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5911988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243574", "Detail": { "ID": 243574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3107461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254351", "Detail": { "ID": 254351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2518408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323402", "Detail": { "ID": 323402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9545864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300653", "Detail": { "ID": 300653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0078571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273112", "Detail": { "ID": 273112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3701046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262643", "Detail": { "ID": 262643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6106793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282339", "Detail": { "ID": 282339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4085494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298930", "Detail": { "ID": 298930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3784623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230626", "Detail": { "ID": 230626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3384807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285838", "Detail": { "ID": 285838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3467061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219628", "Detail": { "ID": 219628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3075948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238163", "Detail": { "ID": 238163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2476279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226311", "Detail": { "ID": 226311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2201189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322253", "Detail": { "ID": 322253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6747987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292270", "Detail": { "ID": 292270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5265359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227656", "Detail": { "ID": 227656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5597111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304544", "Detail": { "ID": 304544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0429779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257932", "Detail": { "ID": 257932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0841187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271192", "Detail": { "ID": 271192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8464198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279404", "Detail": { "ID": 279404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5062668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266424", "Detail": { "ID": 266424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7403443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250750", "Detail": { "ID": 250750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2119644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221186", "Detail": { "ID": 221186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6787824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226436", "Detail": { "ID": 226436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2313123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239734", "Detail": { "ID": 239734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7566195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266880", "Detail": { "ID": 266880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7660281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324848", "Detail": { "ID": 324848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.240422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260960", "Detail": { "ID": 260960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1053926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246060", "Detail": { "ID": 246060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8704714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273551", "Detail": { "ID": 273551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6252851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303655", "Detail": { "ID": 303655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8246533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223127", "Detail": { "ID": 223127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.229788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245609", "Detail": { "ID": 245609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8508027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223324", "Detail": { "ID": 223324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4529802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308360", "Detail": { "ID": 308360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.052597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272486", "Detail": { "ID": 272486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3374845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245154", "Detail": { "ID": 245154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5943588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315324", "Detail": { "ID": 315324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9067243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247076", "Detail": { "ID": 247076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1660366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275048", "Detail": { "ID": 275048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1389365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255075", "Detail": { "ID": 255075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2961332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277351", "Detail": { "ID": 277351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9444985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254048", "Detail": { "ID": 254048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0322739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278846", "Detail": { "ID": 278846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2367582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325283", "Detail": { "ID": 325283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4920145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231950", "Detail": { "ID": 231950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6227668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312332", "Detail": { "ID": 312332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1232575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233164", "Detail": { "ID": 233164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8996167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267736", "Detail": { "ID": 267736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.032795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314517", "Detail": { "ID": 314517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6434324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296672", "Detail": { "ID": 296672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8690338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319502", "Detail": { "ID": 319502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9287292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306160", "Detail": { "ID": 306160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3615552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310275", "Detail": { "ID": 310275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5634647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268704", "Detail": { "ID": 268704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2790801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293722", "Detail": { "ID": 293722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8661246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271464", "Detail": { "ID": 271464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0769552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269470", "Detail": { "ID": 269470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5489564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307317", "Detail": { "ID": 307317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8240118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280209", "Detail": { "ID": 280209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7507519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279113", "Detail": { "ID": 279113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2535884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260366", "Detail": { "ID": 260366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0737626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304816", "Detail": { "ID": 304816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0599654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302184", "Detail": { "ID": 302184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3011801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300243", "Detail": { "ID": 300243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.989564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224243", "Detail": { "ID": 224243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6904878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305707", "Detail": { "ID": 305707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3359448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321224", "Detail": { "ID": 321224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4189473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315758", "Detail": { "ID": 315758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9257084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237186", "Detail": { "ID": 237186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1930753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288857", "Detail": { "ID": 288857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1613793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234180", "Detail": { "ID": 234180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1700985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312861", "Detail": { "ID": 312861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1465521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261389", "Detail": { "ID": 261389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3552356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225617", "Detail": { "ID": 225617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.983062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265620", "Detail": { "ID": 265620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.44708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284170", "Detail": { "ID": 284170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7460328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252160", "Detail": { "ID": 252160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5051788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318444", "Detail": { "ID": 318444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6578428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256155", "Detail": { "ID": 256155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5729847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293908", "Detail": { "ID": 293908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8739938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235919", "Detail": { "ID": 235919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6985895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255934", "Detail": { "ID": 255934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5632557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229326", "Detail": { "ID": 229326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.071885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289484", "Detail": { "ID": 289484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4392327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311606", "Detail": { "ID": 311606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8861949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247084", "Detail": { "ID": 247084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1663671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297613", "Detail": { "ID": 297613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1077152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233798", "Detail": { "ID": 233798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1467573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274970", "Detail": { "ID": 274970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1354674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274122", "Detail": { "ID": 274122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6553966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317790", "Detail": { "ID": 317790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4374566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326547", "Detail": { "ID": 326547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7693678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241417", "Detail": { "ID": 241417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7570542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291129", "Detail": { "ID": 291129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7869498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248171", "Detail": { "ID": 248171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4462066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290007", "Detail": { "ID": 290007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4687641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222707", "Detail": { "ID": 222707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2007101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240858", "Detail": { "ID": 240858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3853111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283698", "Detail": { "ID": 283698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7194109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251682", "Detail": { "ID": 251682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4842055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247268", "Detail": { "ID": 247268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3962382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309774", "Detail": { "ID": 309774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2090, "AgendaID": 2482, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 105, "VoteAgainst": 7, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Amendment to the Scottish Parliament Salaries Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-07629", "ID": 13093 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-09-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3443691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259151", "Detail": { "ID": 259151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.343904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319670", "Detail": { "ID": 319670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9362838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249471", "Detail": { "ID": 249471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9281396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320859", "Detail": { "ID": 320859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1847632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228347", "Detail": { "ID": 228347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7944755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281049", "Detail": { "ID": 281049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8038313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262791", "Detail": { "ID": 262791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6170037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288959", "Detail": { "ID": 288959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1658314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230499", "Detail": { "ID": 230499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3328126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269720", "Detail": { "ID": 269720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5600913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322548", "Detail": { "ID": 322548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6934663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295328", "Detail": { "ID": 295328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5073485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242930", "Detail": { "ID": 242930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0416375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235096", "Detail": { "ID": 235096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4191966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302448", "Detail": { "ID": 302448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5250183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244212", "Detail": { "ID": 244212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.544797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327125", "Detail": { "ID": 327125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8001971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277130", "Detail": { "ID": 277130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7023902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264044", "Detail": { "ID": 264044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9217911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248656", "Detail": { "ID": 248656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6641988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295752", "Detail": { "ID": 295752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5343909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285295", "Detail": { "ID": 285295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3168404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230772", "Detail": { "ID": 230772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3448571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243789", "Detail": { "ID": 243789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3198316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254486", "Detail": { "ID": 254486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2582082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323732", "Detail": { "ID": 323732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9695202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290907", "Detail": { "ID": 290907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7772183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272993", "Detail": { "ID": 272993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.364613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262368", "Detail": { "ID": 262368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5984582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281843", "Detail": { "ID": 281843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1599935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298284", "Detail": { "ID": 298284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3391365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231168", "Detail": { "ID": 231168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3685917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284968", "Detail": { "ID": 284968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0554488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219508", "Detail": { "ID": 219508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3023142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238276", "Detail": { "ID": 238276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4394144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225124", "Detail": { "ID": 225124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7455154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321912", "Detail": { "ID": 321912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4567011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292772", "Detail": { "ID": 292772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5575016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227233", "Detail": { "ID": 227233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5365995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313269", "Detail": { "ID": 313269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3880334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257811", "Detail": { "ID": 257811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0786247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271101", "Detail": { "ID": 271101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8425258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277981", "Detail": { "ID": 277981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9770952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287344", "Detail": { "ID": 287344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8601508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250628", "Detail": { "ID": 250628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1977433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221092", "Detail": { "ID": 221092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6747305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220136", "Detail": { "ID": 220136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3358924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252468", "Detail": { "ID": 252468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7304509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253750", "Detail": { "ID": 253750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0193345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324673", "Detail": { "ID": 324673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2330437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259603", "Detail": { "ID": 259603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6165776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239466", "Detail": { "ID": 239466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7380076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273670", "Detail": { "ID": 273670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.63036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304038", "Detail": { "ID": 304038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8467065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221602", "Detail": { "ID": 221602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.939823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241834", "Detail": { "ID": 241834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7820383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223409", "Detail": { "ID": 223409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4566374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307867", "Detail": { "ID": 307867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.854338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272363", "Detail": { "ID": 272363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3321074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244939", "Detail": { "ID": 244939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5850765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315109", "Detail": { "ID": 315109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.674696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247495", "Detail": { "ID": 247495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.406276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275139", "Detail": { "ID": 275139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1432639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255497", "Detail": { "ID": 255497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5338733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276950", "Detail": { "ID": 276950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6881794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253467", "Detail": { "ID": 253467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9976829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276721", "Detail": { "ID": 276721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6782723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325458", "Detail": { "ID": 325458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5072513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233272", "Detail": { "ID": 233272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1168497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311711", "Detail": { "ID": 311711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8909761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229671", "Detail": { "ID": 229671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0917032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267494", "Detail": { "ID": 267494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0222686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313449", "Detail": { "ID": 313449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.395841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294944", "Detail": { "ID": 294944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1854717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319162", "Detail": { "ID": 319162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6950936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306377", "Detail": { "ID": 306377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5494728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310774", "Detail": { "ID": 310774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5854767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268110", "Detail": { "ID": 268110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0565878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292947", "Detail": { "ID": 292947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.565064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258508", "Detail": { "ID": 258508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3102611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263769", "Detail": { "ID": 263769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9039428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308713", "Detail": { "ID": 308713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0677519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279780", "Detail": { "ID": 279780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5224876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279543", "Detail": { "ID": 279543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5122311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261049", "Detail": { "ID": 261049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1096042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299379", "Detail": { "ID": 299379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6948984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306745", "Detail": { "ID": 306745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5655768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300590", "Detail": { "ID": 300590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0051754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223996", "Detail": { "ID": 223996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4875442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237921", "Detail": { "ID": 237921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2318263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305491", "Detail": { "ID": 305491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3266086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320109", "Detail": { "ID": 320109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9620565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315973", "Detail": { "ID": 315973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9402606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236759", "Detail": { "ID": 236759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9388334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289746", "Detail": { "ID": 289746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4573532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234468", "Detail": { "ID": 234468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3855555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313543", "Detail": { "ID": 313543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3999114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289348", "Detail": { "ID": 289348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4333886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225378", "Detail": { "ID": 225378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9721445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265754", "Detail": { "ID": 265754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4530377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283207", "Detail": { "ID": 283207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6904696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252044", "Detail": { "ID": 252044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.500145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317330", "Detail": { "ID": 317330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4174761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254223", "Detail": { "ID": 254223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2462433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296249", "Detail": { "ID": 296249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8405062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235487", "Detail": { "ID": 235487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6799525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257701", "Detail": { "ID": 257701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0678329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228589", "Detail": { "ID": 228589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8056088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291551", "Detail": { "ID": 291551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1242182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311078", "Detail": { "ID": 311078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6044675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246811", "Detail": { "ID": 246811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1544034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298039", "Detail": { "ID": 298039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1356394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234069", "Detail": { "ID": 234069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1652923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274697", "Detail": { "ID": 274697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269970", "Detail": { "ID": 269970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5759187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317420", "Detail": { "ID": 317420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4213383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326372", "Detail": { "ID": 326372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.75565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241294", "Detail": { "ID": 241294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.751735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289684", "Detail": { "ID": 289684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4547545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248053", "Detail": { "ID": 248053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4397501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287504", "Detail": { "ID": 287504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8738294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222622", "Detail": { "ID": 222622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1968527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306961", "Detail": { "ID": 306961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.581343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239677", "Detail": { "ID": 239677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7542039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283789", "Detail": { "ID": 283789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7235292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231774", "Detail": { "ID": 231774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.61494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237351", "Detail": { "ID": 237351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2004456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308970", "Detail": { "ID": 308970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2087, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Parliamentary Recess Dates", "Reference": "S4M-07156", "ID": 13078 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0859169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259495", "Detail": { "ID": 259495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6115791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318075", "Detail": { "ID": 318075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4558555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250121", "Detail": { "ID": 250121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9642567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320601", "Detail": { "ID": 320601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1734342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229456", "Detail": { "ID": 229456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0825633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281534", "Detail": { "ID": 281534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1469343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263306", "Detail": { "ID": 263306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8836453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290678", "Detail": { "ID": 290678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7675662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227916", "Detail": { "ID": 227916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5711979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270686", "Detail": { "ID": 270686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8187324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323056", "Detail": { "ID": 323056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7201306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297378", "Detail": { "ID": 297378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0973866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242602", "Detail": { "ID": 242602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0273915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236969", "Detail": { "ID": 236969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9481278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301589", "Detail": { "ID": 301589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2690059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261944", "Detail": { "ID": 261944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.384925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326671", "Detail": { "ID": 326671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7751106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278135", "Detail": { "ID": 278135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9885431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264946", "Detail": { "ID": 264946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1615099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249314", "Detail": { "ID": 249314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9212304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293564", "Detail": { "ID": 293564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8507861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285526", "Detail": { "ID": 285526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3331135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232073", "Detail": { "ID": 232073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6333543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243273", "Detail": { "ID": 243273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2902797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253909", "Detail": { "ID": 253909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0260532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321394", "Detail": { "ID": 321394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4339541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292421", "Detail": { "ID": 292421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5330707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273213", "Detail": { "ID": 273213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6055518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262875", "Detail": { "ID": 262875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6267299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282348", "Detail": { "ID": 282348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4089482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298921", "Detail": { "ID": 298921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3780972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230609", "Detail": { "ID": 230609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3377651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287198", "Detail": { "ID": 287198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8536983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219705", "Detail": { "ID": 219705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3109463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239087", "Detail": { "ID": 239087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4822075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226239", "Detail": { "ID": 226239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2165219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322239", "Detail": { "ID": 322239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.674182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292196", "Detail": { "ID": 292196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1659755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228192", "Detail": { "ID": 228192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5882796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304433", "Detail": { "ID": 304433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0380301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258005", "Detail": { "ID": 258005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0872265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271713", "Detail": { "ID": 271713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0882711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279413", "Detail": { "ID": 279413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.50666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266708", "Detail": { "ID": 266708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7531231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250816", "Detail": { "ID": 250816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2147275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221280", "Detail": { "ID": 221280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9225564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226358", "Detail": { "ID": 226358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2278841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240019", "Detail": { "ID": 240019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7692607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266656", "Detail": { "ID": 266656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7505473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324307", "Detail": { "ID": 324307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2111077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260882", "Detail": { "ID": 260882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1020323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246135", "Detail": { "ID": 246135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8737172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276130", "Detail": { "ID": 276130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4117598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303587", "Detail": { "ID": 303587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8217484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222252", "Detail": { "ID": 222252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1749026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242462", "Detail": { "ID": 242462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0143164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224701", "Detail": { "ID": 224701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7162164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308351", "Detail": { "ID": 308351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0522077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272553", "Detail": { "ID": 272553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.340359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244452", "Detail": { "ID": 244452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5553559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314627", "Detail": { "ID": 314627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6482575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252476", "Detail": { "ID": 252476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7307799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275601", "Detail": { "ID": 275601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3825451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257072", "Detail": { "ID": 257072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8220964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283046", "Detail": { "ID": 283046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4454325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254122", "Detail": { "ID": 254122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0354647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278768", "Detail": { "ID": 278768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2334222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324978", "Detail": { "ID": 324978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2459602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232000", "Detail": { "ID": 232000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6248981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312323", "Detail": { "ID": 312323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1228692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232632", "Detail": { "ID": 232632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8695453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267805", "Detail": { "ID": 267805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0357549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314526", "Detail": { "ID": 314526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.643827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296681", "Detail": { "ID": 296681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8693971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319488", "Detail": { "ID": 319488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9281138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305882", "Detail": { "ID": 305882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3494011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309932", "Detail": { "ID": 309932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3571579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268635", "Detail": { "ID": 268635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2761117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293713", "Detail": { "ID": 293713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8657335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271390", "Detail": { "ID": 271390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0737521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269392", "Detail": { "ID": 269392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5455582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307346", "Detail": { "ID": 307346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8252436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280588", "Detail": { "ID": 280588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7736655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281219", "Detail": { "ID": 281219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1253811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245276", "Detail": { "ID": 245276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8278845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304825", "Detail": { "ID": 304825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0603558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302265", "Detail": { "ID": 302265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5169407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300170", "Detail": { "ID": 300170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7393106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224492", "Detail": { "ID": 224492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.70717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237977", "Detail": { "ID": 237977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2342557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297460", "Detail": { "ID": 297460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1010214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321238", "Detail": { "ID": 321238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4195745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315454", "Detail": { "ID": 315454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9127051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237594", "Detail": { "ID": 237594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2175367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292535", "Detail": { "ID": 292535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5381703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233908", "Detail": { "ID": 233908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1515629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312046", "Detail": { "ID": 312046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9113829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286786", "Detail": { "ID": 286786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6005946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225708", "Detail": { "ID": 225708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9869861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265491", "Detail": { "ID": 265491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4414764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283939", "Detail": { "ID": 283939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7300205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258726", "Detail": { "ID": 258726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3200043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318459", "Detail": { "ID": 318459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6584868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256089", "Detail": { "ID": 256089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5701484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293989", "Detail": { "ID": 293989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8778312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235996", "Detail": { "ID": 235996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7018865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256360", "Detail": { "ID": 256360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7791776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229392", "Detail": { "ID": 229392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0797726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289417", "Detail": { "ID": 289417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4363424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310439", "Detail": { "ID": 310439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5706661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247150", "Detail": { "ID": 247150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1692183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298663", "Detail": { "ID": 298663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3558792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235760", "Detail": { "ID": 235760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6918158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275357", "Detail": { "ID": 275357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3717537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274113", "Detail": { "ID": 274113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6550025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316786", "Detail": { "ID": 316786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1634197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326005", "Detail": { "ID": 326005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5311374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241489", "Detail": { "ID": 241489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7601749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287967", "Detail": { "ID": 287967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8942824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248248", "Detail": { "ID": 248248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.637715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290082", "Detail": { "ID": 290082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4719952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222799", "Detail": { "ID": 222799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2052013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306869", "Detail": { "ID": 306869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5772171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240786", "Detail": { "ID": 240786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3822327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284094", "Detail": { "ID": 284094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7427413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251634", "Detail": { "ID": 251634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4724603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246738", "Detail": { "ID": 246738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1513006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309783", "Detail": { "ID": 309783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2088, "AgendaID": 3048, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 103, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07109", "ID": 7230 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.34474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259146", "Detail": { "ID": 259146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3436986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319671", "Detail": { "ID": 319671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9363256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249574", "Detail": { "ID": 249574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.932728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320858", "Detail": { "ID": 320858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1847221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228346", "Detail": { "ID": 228346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7944342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281052", "Detail": { "ID": 281052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.803953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262790", "Detail": { "ID": 262790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6169446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288955", "Detail": { "ID": 288955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1656222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230498", "Detail": { "ID": 230498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3327704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269725", "Detail": { "ID": 269725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5602974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322553", "Detail": { "ID": 322553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6936692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295327", "Detail": { "ID": 295327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5072827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242929", "Detail": { "ID": 242929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.041598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235097", "Detail": { "ID": 235097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4192378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302447", "Detail": { "ID": 302447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5249781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244213", "Detail": { "ID": 244213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5448393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327133", "Detail": { "ID": 327133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8005543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277129", "Detail": { "ID": 277129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7023492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264045", "Detail": { "ID": 264045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9218327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248657", "Detail": { "ID": 248657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6642408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295753", "Detail": { "ID": 295753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5344309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285294", "Detail": { "ID": 285294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3167991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230771", "Detail": { "ID": 230771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3448161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243790", "Detail": { "ID": 243790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3198721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254799", "Detail": { "ID": 254799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2842246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323740", "Detail": { "ID": 323740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9698774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290908", "Detail": { "ID": 290908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7772587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272992", "Detail": { "ID": 272992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.364572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262367", "Detail": { "ID": 262367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5984168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281840", "Detail": { "ID": 281840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1598717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298287", "Detail": { "ID": 298287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3392608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231169", "Detail": { "ID": 231169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3686331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284972", "Detail": { "ID": 284972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0556947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219507", "Detail": { "ID": 219507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3022732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238280", "Detail": { "ID": 238280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4395798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225227", "Detail": { "ID": 225227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9602657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321907", "Detail": { "ID": 321907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4564743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292773", "Detail": { "ID": 292773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5575423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227232", "Detail": { "ID": 227232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5365585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313268", "Detail": { "ID": 313268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3879923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257245", "Detail": { "ID": 257245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0478013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271105", "Detail": { "ID": 271105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8426878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277978", "Detail": { "ID": 277978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9769503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287343", "Detail": { "ID": 287343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8601101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250524", "Detail": { "ID": 250524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1932603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220990", "Detail": { "ID": 220990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6703381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220137", "Detail": { "ID": 220137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3359432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252467", "Detail": { "ID": 252467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.730408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253747", "Detail": { "ID": 253747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0192148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324665", "Detail": { "ID": 324665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2327038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259604", "Detail": { "ID": 259604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6166204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239463", "Detail": { "ID": 239463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.737884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273671", "Detail": { "ID": 273671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.630402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304039", "Detail": { "ID": 304039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8467655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221705", "Detail": { "ID": 221705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9442446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241937", "Detail": { "ID": 241937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7864593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223410", "Detail": { "ID": 223410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4566799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307870", "Detail": { "ID": 307870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8544822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272260", "Detail": { "ID": 272260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3219894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244938", "Detail": { "ID": 244938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5850358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315108", "Detail": { "ID": 315108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6746523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247498", "Detail": { "ID": 247498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4064196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275135", "Detail": { "ID": 275135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1430999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255502", "Detail": { "ID": 255502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5340794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276954", "Detail": { "ID": 276954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6884972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253463", "Detail": { "ID": 253463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9975165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276722", "Detail": { "ID": 276722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.678313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325466", "Detail": { "ID": 325466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5075978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233271", "Detail": { "ID": 233271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1168096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311714", "Detail": { "ID": 311714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8910999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229672", "Detail": { "ID": 229672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0917451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267497", "Detail": { "ID": 267497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.022391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313446", "Detail": { "ID": 313446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.395719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294941", "Detail": { "ID": 294941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1853298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319157", "Detail": { "ID": 319157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6948891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306378", "Detail": { "ID": 306378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5495133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310775", "Detail": { "ID": 310775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5855184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268107", "Detail": { "ID": 268107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0564654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292950", "Detail": { "ID": 292950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5651852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258611", "Detail": { "ID": 258611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3147312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263770", "Detail": { "ID": 263770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9039844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308712", "Detail": { "ID": 308712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0676895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM279779", "Detail": { "ID": 279779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5224479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279544", "Detail": { "ID": 279544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5122716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261050", "Detail": { "ID": 261050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1096463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299376", "Detail": { "ID": 299376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6947766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306744", "Detail": { "ID": 306744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5655354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300591", "Detail": { "ID": 300591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0052164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223893", "Detail": { "ID": 223893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4782966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237920", "Detail": { "ID": 237920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2317848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305490", "Detail": { "ID": 305490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3265685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320114", "Detail": { "ID": 320114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9622825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315974", "Detail": { "ID": 315974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9403019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236758", "Detail": { "ID": 236758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9387931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289747", "Detail": { "ID": 289747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4573932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234469", "Detail": { "ID": 234469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3855967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313544", "Detail": { "ID": 313544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3999533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289347", "Detail": { "ID": 289347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4333477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225377", "Detail": { "ID": 225377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9721041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265755", "Detail": { "ID": 265755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4530793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283208", "Detail": { "ID": 283208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6905129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252043", "Detail": { "ID": 252043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5001048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317335", "Detail": { "ID": 317335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4176813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254327", "Detail": { "ID": 254327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2507956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296248", "Detail": { "ID": 296248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8404633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235486", "Detail": { "ID": 235486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6799119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257700", "Detail": { "ID": 257700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0677913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228178", "Detail": { "ID": 228178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.587686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291552", "Detail": { "ID": 291552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1242592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311077", "Detail": { "ID": 311077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6044265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246399", "Detail": { "ID": 246399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1270425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298040", "Detail": { "ID": 298040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.13568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234070", "Detail": { "ID": 234070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1653532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274696", "Detail": { "ID": 274696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1177678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269973", "Detail": { "ID": 269973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5760668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317419", "Detail": { "ID": 317419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4212973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326364", "Detail": { "ID": 326364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7553004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241191", "Detail": { "ID": 241191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7468934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289683", "Detail": { "ID": 289683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4545719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248052", "Detail": { "ID": 248052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4397064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287503", "Detail": { "ID": 287503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8737881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222621", "Detail": { "ID": 222621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1968117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306962", "Detail": { "ID": 306962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.581384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239932", "Detail": { "ID": 239932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7655377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283785", "Detail": { "ID": 283785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.723366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231775", "Detail": { "ID": 231775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6149804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237352", "Detail": { "ID": 237352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2004865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308967", "Detail": { "ID": 308967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2086, "AgendaID": 2466, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-07108", "ID": 7229 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-26T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0857951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269278", "Detail": { "ID": 269278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5376156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318347", "Detail": { "ID": 318347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6536996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249914", "Detail": { "ID": 249914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9554115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320501", "Detail": { "ID": 320501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1691469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230290", "Detail": { "ID": 230290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3164302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281466", "Detail": { "ID": 281466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1440417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263630", "Detail": { "ID": 263630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8979342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289075", "Detail": { "ID": 289075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1709813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228680", "Detail": { "ID": 228680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8095587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270348", "Detail": { "ID": 270348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8037739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323261", "Detail": { "ID": 323261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9421281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296556", "Detail": { "ID": 296556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8541347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242495", "Detail": { "ID": 242495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0157618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236151", "Detail": { "ID": 236151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7136692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300977", "Detail": { "ID": 300977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0270243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261143", "Detail": { "ID": 261143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1136899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326780", "Detail": { "ID": 326780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7797662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278627", "Detail": { "ID": 278627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2273971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264768", "Detail": { "ID": 264768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.148042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249081", "Detail": { "ID": 249081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.683073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293674", "Detail": { "ID": 293674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8640738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287723", "Detail": { "ID": 287723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8834944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233467", "Detail": { "ID": 233467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1317902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243387", "Detail": { "ID": 243387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2955591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253296", "Detail": { "ID": 253296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9902516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321511", "Detail": { "ID": 321511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.439229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300780", "Detail": { "ID": 300780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0185491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273391", "Detail": { "ID": 273391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6181279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263261", "Detail": { "ID": 263261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.881708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282417", "Detail": { "ID": 282417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4119736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298855", "Detail": { "ID": 298855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3750486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230579", "Detail": { "ID": 230579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3364766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286475", "Detail": { "ID": 286475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5874395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219938", "Detail": { "ID": 219938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3211593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238750", "Detail": { "ID": 238750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4674217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225878", "Detail": { "ID": 225878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9943147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322175", "Detail": { "ID": 322175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4746328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290274", "Detail": { "ID": 290274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7397748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228870", "Detail": { "ID": 228870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8177823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304646", "Detail": { "ID": 304646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0473087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258367", "Detail": { "ID": 258367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3041775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274434", "Detail": { "ID": 274434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1063646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279481", "Detail": { "ID": 279481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5095746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266856", "Detail": { "ID": 266856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7594489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253633", "Detail": { "ID": 253633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0048475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221478", "Detail": { "ID": 221478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9344739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220562", "Detail": { "ID": 220562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6467211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240320", "Detail": { "ID": 240320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3546713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266579", "Detail": { "ID": 266579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7472361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324191", "Detail": { "ID": 324191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9961192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260183", "Detail": { "ID": 260183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6473435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247057", "Detail": { "ID": 247057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1652169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275642", "Detail": { "ID": 275642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3843165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303738", "Detail": { "ID": 303738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8335221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222047", "Detail": { "ID": 222047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9650909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242264", "Detail": { "ID": 242264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0054547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224328", "Detail": { "ID": 224328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6999106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308285", "Detail": { "ID": 308285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0490322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272752", "Detail": { "ID": 272752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3488662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244337", "Detail": { "ID": 244337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5503323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314353", "Detail": { "ID": 314353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6360385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251213", "Detail": { "ID": 251213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4537269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276497", "Detail": { "ID": 276497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6686631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256276", "Detail": { "ID": 256276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7755953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282461", "Detail": { "ID": 282461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.419889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255056", "Detail": { "ID": 255056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2953122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277764", "Detail": { "ID": 277764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.967449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325094", "Detail": { "ID": 325094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.255891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232348", "Detail": { "ID": 232348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8509519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312268", "Detail": { "ID": 312268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1202743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231487", "Detail": { "ID": 231487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6027236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267871", "Detail": { "ID": 267871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0388403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314747", "Detail": { "ID": 314747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6537538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296737", "Detail": { "ID": 296737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8717696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319425", "Detail": { "ID": 319425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9253605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305993", "Detail": { "ID": 305993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3543787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309034", "Detail": { "ID": 309034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0891521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268558", "Detail": { "ID": 268558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2724408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293194", "Detail": { "ID": 293194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5756312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261578", "Detail": { "ID": 261578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3635267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264504", "Detail": { "ID": 264504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1363682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307771", "Detail": { "ID": 307771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8442155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280886", "Detail": { "ID": 280886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7865777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245385", "Detail": { "ID": 245385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8325777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304880", "Detail": { "ID": 304880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0627038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303249", "Detail": { "ID": 303249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8067124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297025", "Detail": { "ID": 297025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8844737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224845", "Detail": { "ID": 224845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7225744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237997", "Detail": { "ID": 237997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2351145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296888", "Detail": { "ID": 296888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8783653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321290", "Detail": { "ID": 321290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4218191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315572", "Detail": { "ID": 315572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9177782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238076", "Detail": { "ID": 238076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2385097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293505", "Detail": { "ID": 293505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.848274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233612", "Detail": { "ID": 233612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1385164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312476", "Detail": { "ID": 312476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1295523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287629", "Detail": { "ID": 287629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8795088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226549", "Detail": { "ID": 226549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2362504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265187", "Detail": { "ID": 265187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1722671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284450", "Detail": { "ID": 284450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0331252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259102", "Detail": { "ID": 259102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3418101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318521", "Detail": { "ID": 318521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6617577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255583", "Detail": { "ID": 255583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.537607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295149", "Detail": { "ID": 295149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1945525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236843", "Detail": { "ID": 236843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9426834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256816", "Detail": { "ID": 256816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8111023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239554", "Detail": { "ID": 239554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7487617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290497", "Detail": { "ID": 290497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7496294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310009", "Detail": { "ID": 310009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3604927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247658", "Detail": { "ID": 247658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4228914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299173", "Detail": { "ID": 299173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3911616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235268", "Detail": { "ID": 235268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6631355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275900", "Detail": { "ID": 275900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.395817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274045", "Detail": { "ID": 274045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6519988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316515", "Detail": { "ID": 316515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1513434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325889", "Detail": { "ID": 325889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5258394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241696", "Detail": { "ID": 241696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7758932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287851", "Detail": { "ID": 287851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8892863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248467", "Detail": { "ID": 248467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6472726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289112", "Detail": { "ID": 289112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1725631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223002", "Detail": { "ID": 223002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2245226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306844", "Detail": { "ID": 306844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5761526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240579", "Detail": { "ID": 240579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3733473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284676", "Detail": { "ID": 284676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0427883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232956", "Detail": { "ID": 232956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8838949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246215", "Detail": { "ID": 246215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1190725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310156", "Detail": { "ID": 310156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2084, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 91, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933.2", "ID": 7081 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3669312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269282", "Detail": { "ID": 269282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5407475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318346", "Detail": { "ID": 318346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6536581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249913", "Detail": { "ID": 249913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9553716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320502", "Detail": { "ID": 320502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.16919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230291", "Detail": { "ID": 230291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3164715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281465", "Detail": { "ID": 281465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1440006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263631", "Detail": { "ID": 263631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8979763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289071", "Detail": { "ID": 289071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1707969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228681", "Detail": { "ID": 228681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8096002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270344", "Detail": { "ID": 270344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8036063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323260", "Detail": { "ID": 323260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9420833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296510", "Detail": { "ID": 296510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8521685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242496", "Detail": { "ID": 242496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0158044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236150", "Detail": { "ID": 236150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7136274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300958", "Detail": { "ID": 300958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0262254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261142", "Detail": { "ID": 261142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1136291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326779", "Detail": { "ID": 326779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7797246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278628", "Detail": { "ID": 278628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2274573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264767", "Detail": { "ID": 264767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.147999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249080", "Detail": { "ID": 249080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.68303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293673", "Detail": { "ID": 293673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8640321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287724", "Detail": { "ID": 287724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8835364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233468", "Detail": { "ID": 233468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1318325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243386", "Detail": { "ID": 243386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2955178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253267", "Detail": { "ID": 253267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9889491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321510", "Detail": { "ID": 321510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4391871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300781", "Detail": { "ID": 300781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0185899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273392", "Detail": { "ID": 273392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6181744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263262", "Detail": { "ID": 263262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8817496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282418", "Detail": { "ID": 282418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4120162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298854", "Detail": { "ID": 298854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3749903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230578", "Detail": { "ID": 230578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3364361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286479", "Detail": { "ID": 286479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5876083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219939", "Detail": { "ID": 219939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3212014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238746", "Detail": { "ID": 238746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4672598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225877", "Detail": { "ID": 225877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9942733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322176", "Detail": { "ID": 322176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.474676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290273", "Detail": { "ID": 290273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7397339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228871", "Detail": { "ID": 228871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8178241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304674", "Detail": { "ID": 304674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0485452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258368", "Detail": { "ID": 258368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3042204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274438", "Detail": { "ID": 274438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1065468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279482", "Detail": { "ID": 279482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5096157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM267038", "Detail": { "ID": 267038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7727944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253634", "Detail": { "ID": 253634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0048886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221479", "Detail": { "ID": 221479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9345147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220561", "Detail": { "ID": 220561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6466795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240349", "Detail": { "ID": 240349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3559346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266580", "Detail": { "ID": 266580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.747278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324192", "Detail": { "ID": 324192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9961817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260182", "Detail": { "ID": 260182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6473025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247061", "Detail": { "ID": 247061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1653798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275641", "Detail": { "ID": 275641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3842754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303757", "Detail": { "ID": 303757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8343916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222046", "Detail": { "ID": 222046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9650499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242263", "Detail": { "ID": 242263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0053952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224327", "Detail": { "ID": 224327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6998681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308284", "Detail": { "ID": 308284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.048972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272753", "Detail": { "ID": 272753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.348907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244338", "Detail": { "ID": 244338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5503921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314354", "Detail": { "ID": 314354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6360801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251209", "Detail": { "ID": 251209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4535418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276493", "Detail": { "ID": 276493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6684978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256272", "Detail": { "ID": 256272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7754122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282465", "Detail": { "ID": 282465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4200516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255060", "Detail": { "ID": 255060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2954979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277763", "Detail": { "ID": 277763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9673898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325093", "Detail": { "ID": 325093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2558491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232350", "Detail": { "ID": 232350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8510543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312267", "Detail": { "ID": 312267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1202328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231486", "Detail": { "ID": 231486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.602682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267870", "Detail": { "ID": 267870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0387982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314748", "Detail": { "ID": 314748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6537946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296738", "Detail": { "ID": 296738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8718107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319426", "Detail": { "ID": 319426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9254041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305992", "Detail": { "ID": 305992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3543378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309033", "Detail": { "ID": 309033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0891105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268559", "Detail": { "ID": 268559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2724827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293193", "Detail": { "ID": 293193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.57559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261577", "Detail": { "ID": 261577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3634859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264503", "Detail": { "ID": 264503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1363268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307772", "Detail": { "ID": 307772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8442569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280885", "Detail": { "ID": 280885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7865362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245384", "Detail": { "ID": 245384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.832536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304881", "Detail": { "ID": 304881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0627458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303250", "Detail": { "ID": 303250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8067541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297024", "Detail": { "ID": 297024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8844326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224846", "Detail": { "ID": 224846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7226165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237998", "Detail": { "ID": 237998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2351561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296889", "Detail": { "ID": 296889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8784061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321289", "Detail": { "ID": 321289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4217573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315571", "Detail": { "ID": 315571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9177368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238077", "Detail": { "ID": 238077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2385514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293550", "Detail": { "ID": 293550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8501869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233583", "Detail": { "ID": 233583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1372439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312475", "Detail": { "ID": 312475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.129509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287630", "Detail": { "ID": 287630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8795504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226550", "Detail": { "ID": 226550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2362931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265159", "Detail": { "ID": 265159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1710315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284451", "Detail": { "ID": 284451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0331723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259103", "Detail": { "ID": 259103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3418516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318520", "Detail": { "ID": 318520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6617161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255582", "Detail": { "ID": 255582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5375641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295150", "Detail": { "ID": 295150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1946246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236844", "Detail": { "ID": 236844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9427244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256845", "Detail": { "ID": 256845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8123581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM239555", "Detail": { "ID": 239555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.748804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290516", "Detail": { "ID": 290516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.750455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310010", "Detail": { "ID": 310010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3605335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247659", "Detail": { "ID": 247659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4229338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299219", "Detail": { "ID": 299219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6880156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235267", "Detail": { "ID": 235267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.663093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275901", "Detail": { "ID": 275901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3958581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274044", "Detail": { "ID": 274044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6519541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316516", "Detail": { "ID": 316516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1513857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325890", "Detail": { "ID": 325890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5258825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241697", "Detail": { "ID": 241697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7759341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287852", "Detail": { "ID": 287852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8893278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248468", "Detail": { "ID": 248468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6473134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289111", "Detail": { "ID": 289111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1725222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223003", "Detail": { "ID": 223003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2245641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306843", "Detail": { "ID": 306843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5761113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240578", "Detail": { "ID": 240578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3732851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284672", "Detail": { "ID": 284672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0426286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232955", "Detail": { "ID": 232955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8838529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246214", "Detail": { "ID": 246214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1190307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310157", "Detail": { "ID": 310157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2085, "AgendaID": 2156, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 94, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Progress Toward National Planning Framework 3 and the Scottish Planning Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06933", "ID": 7062 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3669728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259430", "Detail": { "ID": 259430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6087695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318726", "Detail": { "ID": 318726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6707899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250248", "Detail": { "ID": 250248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1810212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321071", "Detail": { "ID": 321071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2009969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228465", "Detail": { "ID": 228465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8002514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281564", "Detail": { "ID": 281564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1482174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263093", "Detail": { "ID": 263093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6364713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288101", "Detail": { "ID": 288101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9001284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227515", "Detail": { "ID": 227515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5534703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269286", "Detail": { "ID": 269286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5409219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323021", "Detail": { "ID": 323021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7185933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297316", "Detail": { "ID": 297316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0944494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243103", "Detail": { "ID": 243103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0490327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227031", "Detail": { "ID": 227031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2645072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301556", "Detail": { "ID": 301556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2675959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262028", "Detail": { "ID": 262028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3885036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326581", "Detail": { "ID": 326581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7708909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277588", "Detail": { "ID": 277588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9597721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265019", "Detail": { "ID": 265019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1648857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250942", "Detail": { "ID": 250942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2202133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294806", "Detail": { "ID": 294806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1791568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285442", "Detail": { "ID": 285442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3234566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231380", "Detail": { "ID": 231380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5924264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243615", "Detail": { "ID": 243615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3125331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254006", "Detail": { "ID": 254006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0304619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323443", "Detail": { "ID": 323443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9564073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300648", "Detail": { "ID": 300648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0076355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273140", "Detail": { "ID": 273140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3713025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262649", "Detail": { "ID": 262649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6109416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282318", "Detail": { "ID": 282318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4076412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298951", "Detail": { "ID": 298951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3793435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230625", "Detail": { "ID": 230625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3384398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285849", "Detail": { "ID": 285849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3471851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219635", "Detail": { "ID": 219635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3079075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238152", "Detail": { "ID": 238152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2471522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226674", "Detail": { "ID": 226674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2417046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322274", "Detail": { "ID": 322274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6757105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292304", "Detail": { "ID": 292304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5279944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227663", "Detail": { "ID": 227663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5601331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304515", "Detail": { "ID": 304515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0415049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257878", "Detail": { "ID": 257878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0814893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271204", "Detail": { "ID": 271204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0601103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279383", "Detail": { "ID": 279383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5053258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266458", "Detail": { "ID": 266458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.741985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250695", "Detail": { "ID": 250695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2095925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221162", "Detail": { "ID": 221162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6777496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226429", "Detail": { "ID": 226429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2310009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239767", "Detail": { "ID": 239767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7580274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266704", "Detail": { "ID": 266704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7529559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324808", "Detail": { "ID": 324808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2387052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260954", "Detail": { "ID": 260954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1051476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246072", "Detail": { "ID": 246072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8709928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276214", "Detail": { "ID": 276214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6495192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303621", "Detail": { "ID": 303621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8232018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223152", "Detail": { "ID": 223152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2308535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245663", "Detail": { "ID": 245663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8531313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223318", "Detail": { "ID": 223318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4527148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308381", "Detail": { "ID": 308381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0534964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272431", "Detail": { "ID": 272431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3350275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245114", "Detail": { "ID": 245114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5926474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315285", "Detail": { "ID": 315285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9050146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247064", "Detail": { "ID": 247064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1655238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275036", "Detail": { "ID": 275036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1384048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255063", "Detail": { "ID": 255063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2956245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277363", "Detail": { "ID": 277363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9501641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254060", "Detail": { "ID": 254060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0327843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278839", "Detail": { "ID": 278839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2364575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325324", "Detail": { "ID": 325324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4937869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231963", "Detail": { "ID": 231963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6233231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312353", "Detail": { "ID": 312353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1241737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233158", "Detail": { "ID": 233158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8993695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267757", "Detail": { "ID": 267757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0336861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314496", "Detail": { "ID": 314496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6425193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296652", "Detail": { "ID": 296652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8681857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319678", "Detail": { "ID": 319678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9366365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306200", "Detail": { "ID": 306200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5417549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310312", "Detail": { "ID": 310312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5650831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268683", "Detail": { "ID": 268683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2781709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293743", "Detail": { "ID": 293743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8670149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271831", "Detail": { "ID": 271831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0933224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269464", "Detail": { "ID": 269464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5486903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307283", "Detail": { "ID": 307283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8225548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281291", "Detail": { "ID": 281291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1285091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260406", "Detail": { "ID": 260406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0754969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM300010", "Detail": { "ID": 300010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7324269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301841", "Detail": { "ID": 301841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.285552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300276", "Detail": { "ID": 300276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9909822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224219", "Detail": { "ID": 224219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6894393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237961", "Detail": { "ID": 237961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2335669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305667", "Detail": { "ID": 305667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3342292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321049", "Detail": { "ID": 321049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2000512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315798", "Detail": { "ID": 315798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9274702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237216", "Detail": { "ID": 237216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1946705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292597", "Detail": { "ID": 292597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5496822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233994", "Detail": { "ID": 233994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1553608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312901", "Detail": { "ID": 312901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1547541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261355", "Detail": { "ID": 261355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3537843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225623", "Detail": { "ID": 225623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9833265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265586", "Detail": { "ID": 265586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4455533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284165", "Detail": { "ID": 284165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.745827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258654", "Detail": { "ID": 258654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3168235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318268", "Detail": { "ID": 318268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6454686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256669", "Detail": { "ID": 256669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7926253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293872", "Detail": { "ID": 293872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8724625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235925", "Detail": { "ID": 235925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6988337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255967", "Detail": { "ID": 255967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5646504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229272", "Detail": { "ID": 229272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0695262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289450", "Detail": { "ID": 289450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4377603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311566", "Detail": { "ID": 311566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8843847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246879", "Detail": { "ID": 246879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1572953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298725", "Detail": { "ID": 298725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.369549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235843", "Detail": { "ID": 235843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6953488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274977", "Detail": { "ID": 274977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1358023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274143", "Detail": { "ID": 274143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6563126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317750", "Detail": { "ID": 317750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4357643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326506", "Detail": { "ID": 326506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7676051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241363", "Detail": { "ID": 241363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7546945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291089", "Detail": { "ID": 291089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7850617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248177", "Detail": { "ID": 248177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.446552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290012", "Detail": { "ID": 290012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4689906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222713", "Detail": { "ID": 222713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.200959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306878", "Detail": { "ID": 306878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5774015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240912", "Detail": { "ID": 240912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3877363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283687", "Detail": { "ID": 283687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7189483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251703", "Detail": { "ID": 251703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4850965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247262", "Detail": { "ID": 247262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3959926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309753", "Detail": { "ID": 309753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2083, "AgendaID": 2810, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 58, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Supporting a Sporting Nation, Celebrating and Building on Scotland’s Success in Youth Sport", "Reference": "S4M-06921.3", "ID": 7059 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-11T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3434662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259268", "Detail": { "ID": 259268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6015586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318731", "Detail": { "ID": 318731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.670991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250253", "Detail": { "ID": 250253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1812284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321066", "Detail": { "ID": 321066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2007914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228420", "Detail": { "ID": 228420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7982594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281113", "Detail": { "ID": 281113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8065538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263011", "Detail": { "ID": 263011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6328132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288108", "Detail": { "ID": 288108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9004155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227434", "Detail": { "ID": 227434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5500071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269293", "Detail": { "ID": 269293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5412498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322494", "Detail": { "ID": 322494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6910508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295394", "Detail": { "ID": 295394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5102989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243098", "Detail": { "ID": 243098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0488285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235118", "Detail": { "ID": 235118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4201475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301012", "Detail": { "ID": 301012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0286187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238442", "Detail": { "ID": 238442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4467119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326996", "Detail": { "ID": 326996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7891009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277506", "Detail": { "ID": 277506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9562877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263979", "Detail": { "ID": 263979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.919012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248593", "Detail": { "ID": 248593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6529849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294811", "Detail": { "ID": 294811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1793614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285361", "Detail": { "ID": 285361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3197041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231299", "Detail": { "ID": 231299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5889626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243620", "Detail": { "ID": 243620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3127334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254400", "Detail": { "ID": 254400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2543024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323448", "Detail": { "ID": 323448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.956614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300651", "Detail": { "ID": 300651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0077561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273058", "Detail": { "ID": 273058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3677534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262586", "Detail": { "ID": 262586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6082693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281780", "Detail": { "ID": 281780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1573003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298501", "Detail": { "ID": 298501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.348846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231120", "Detail": { "ID": 231120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3664782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285842", "Detail": { "ID": 285842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3468698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219569", "Detail": { "ID": 219569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3050126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238300", "Detail": { "ID": 238300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4404454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226679", "Detail": { "ID": 226679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2419269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321966", "Detail": { "ID": 321966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.459117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292309", "Detail": { "ID": 292309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5282216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227602", "Detail": { "ID": 227602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5571925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304575", "Detail": { "ID": 304575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0443019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257873", "Detail": { "ID": 257873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0812652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271197", "Detail": { "ID": 271197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0597403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274360", "Detail": { "ID": 274360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1026846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266068", "Detail": { "ID": 266068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4729712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250690", "Detail": { "ID": 250690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2093925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221157", "Detail": { "ID": 221157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.677519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220074", "Detail": { "ID": 220074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3332168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239687", "Detail": { "ID": 239687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7546291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253219", "Detail": { "ID": 253219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9865288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324803", "Detail": { "ID": 324803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.238485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259384", "Detail": { "ID": 259384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6067995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246065", "Detail": { "ID": 246065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.870706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273605", "Detail": { "ID": 273605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6275918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303703", "Detail": { "ID": 303703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8266991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223157", "Detail": { "ID": 223157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2310561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245668", "Detail": { "ID": 245668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8533539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223431", "Detail": { "ID": 223431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4576264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307930", "Detail": { "ID": 307930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8570586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272426", "Detail": { "ID": 272426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3348224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245109", "Detail": { "ID": 245109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5924189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315280", "Detail": { "ID": 315280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9047738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247071", "Detail": { "ID": 247071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1658106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275043", "Detail": { "ID": 275043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1387124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255070", "Detail": { "ID": 255070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2959279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277356", "Detail": { "ID": 277356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9447245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254053", "Detail": { "ID": 254053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0324781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278844", "Detail": { "ID": 278844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2366752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325329", "Detail": { "ID": 325329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4939909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231917", "Detail": { "ID": 231917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6213293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311774", "Detail": { "ID": 311774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8937056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229609", "Detail": { "ID": 229609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0890893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267558", "Detail": { "ID": 267558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0250555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313386", "Detail": { "ID": 313386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.393144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294416", "Detail": { "ID": 294416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1373824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319215", "Detail": { "ID": 319215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9104063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306205", "Detail": { "ID": 306205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5420539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310333", "Detail": { "ID": 310333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5659966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268046", "Detail": { "ID": 268046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0536625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293010", "Detail": { "ID": 293010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5677566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271836", "Detail": { "ID": 271836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0935254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263552", "Detail": { "ID": 263552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8943288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307262", "Detail": { "ID": 307262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8216478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279167", "Detail": { "ID": 279167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2559234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260411", "Detail": { "ID": 260411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0757032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299317", "Detail": { "ID": 299317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6922639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301836", "Detail": { "ID": 301836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2853479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300281", "Detail": { "ID": 300281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9911871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224214", "Detail": { "ID": 224214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6889911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237912", "Detail": { "ID": 237912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2314368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305662", "Detail": { "ID": 305662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3340185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320055", "Detail": { "ID": 320055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9595779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315803", "Detail": { "ID": 315803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9276766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237135", "Detail": { "ID": 237135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9673125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288910", "Detail": { "ID": 288910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1636309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234227", "Detail": { "ID": 234227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3677509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312906", "Detail": { "ID": 312906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1549807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261350", "Detail": { "ID": 261350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3535813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225356", "Detail": { "ID": 225356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9711835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265668", "Detail": { "ID": 265668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4491335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284168", "Detail": { "ID": 284168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7459495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252107", "Detail": { "ID": 252107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5028771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317278", "Detail": { "ID": 317278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4115362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256674", "Detail": { "ID": 256674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7928483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293867", "Detail": { "ID": 293867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8722403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235860", "Detail": { "ID": 235860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.696056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255885", "Detail": { "ID": 255885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5611788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229267", "Detail": { "ID": 229267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0692975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289532", "Detail": { "ID": 289532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4481427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311561", "Detail": { "ID": 311561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8841772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246874", "Detail": { "ID": 246874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1570938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297664", "Detail": { "ID": 297664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1194449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233851", "Detail": { "ID": 233851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.149078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274972", "Detail": { "ID": 274972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1355551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270034", "Detail": { "ID": 270034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5786893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317745", "Detail": { "ID": 317745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4355425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326501", "Detail": { "ID": 326501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7674018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241358", "Detail": { "ID": 241358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7544908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291084", "Detail": { "ID": 291084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7847682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248116", "Detail": { "ID": 248116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4426861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290009", "Detail": { "ID": 290009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4688468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222600", "Detail": { "ID": 222600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1959161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306883", "Detail": { "ID": 306883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5776065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240917", "Detail": { "ID": 240917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3879661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283694", "Detail": { "ID": 283694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.719229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231087", "Detail": { "ID": 231087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3650533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237288", "Detail": { "ID": 237288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1977426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308907", "Detail": { "ID": 308907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2082, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845.1", "ID": 6981 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0832325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259269", "Detail": { "ID": 259269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6016005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318730", "Detail": { "ID": 318730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6709511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250252", "Detail": { "ID": 250252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.181185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321067", "Detail": { "ID": 321067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2008319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228421", "Detail": { "ID": 228421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.798302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281112", "Detail": { "ID": 281112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8065122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263012", "Detail": { "ID": 263012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.632872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288107", "Detail": { "ID": 288107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9003744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227435", "Detail": { "ID": 227435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5500481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269292", "Detail": { "ID": 269292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5412079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322493", "Detail": { "ID": 322493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6910085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296570", "Detail": { "ID": 296570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8547306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243099", "Detail": { "ID": 243099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0488704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227035", "Detail": { "ID": 227035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2646736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301013", "Detail": { "ID": 301013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0286611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238441", "Detail": { "ID": 238441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4466707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326995", "Detail": { "ID": 326995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7890596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277507", "Detail": { "ID": 277507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9563289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263978", "Detail": { "ID": 263978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9189707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250946", "Detail": { "ID": 250946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2203921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294810", "Detail": { "ID": 294810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1793211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285362", "Detail": { "ID": 285362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.319745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231300", "Detail": { "ID": 231300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5890043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243619", "Detail": { "ID": 243619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3126934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254399", "Detail": { "ID": 254399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2542612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323447", "Detail": { "ID": 323447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9565734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300654", "Detail": { "ID": 300654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.007898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273059", "Detail": { "ID": 273059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3677951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262645", "Detail": { "ID": 262645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6107604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281781", "Detail": { "ID": 281781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1573399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298500", "Detail": { "ID": 298500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3488051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231119", "Detail": { "ID": 231119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.36642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285843", "Detail": { "ID": 285843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3469112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219631", "Detail": { "ID": 219631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3077188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238158", "Detail": { "ID": 238158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2474171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226678", "Detail": { "ID": 226678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2418864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321967", "Detail": { "ID": 321967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4591596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292308", "Detail": { "ID": 292308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5281796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227659", "Detail": { "ID": 227659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5598615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304576", "Detail": { "ID": 304576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0443419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257874", "Detail": { "ID": 257874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0813055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271198", "Detail": { "ID": 271198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0598013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274361", "Detail": { "ID": 274361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1027263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266069", "Detail": { "ID": 266069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4730113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250691", "Detail": { "ID": 250691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2094322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221158", "Detail": { "ID": 221158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6775604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226433", "Detail": { "ID": 226433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2311876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239688", "Detail": { "ID": 239688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7546688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253220", "Detail": { "ID": 253220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9865712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324804", "Detail": { "ID": 324804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2385432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260958", "Detail": { "ID": 260958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1053098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246066", "Detail": { "ID": 246066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8707474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273604", "Detail": { "ID": 273604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6275337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303702", "Detail": { "ID": 303702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223156", "Detail": { "ID": 223156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2310162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245667", "Detail": { "ID": 245667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8533127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223322", "Detail": { "ID": 223322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4528786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307929", "Detail": { "ID": 307929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8570181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272427", "Detail": { "ID": 272427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3348632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245110", "Detail": { "ID": 245110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5924601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315281", "Detail": { "ID": 315281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9048458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247070", "Detail": { "ID": 247070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1657704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275042", "Detail": { "ID": 275042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1386715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255069", "Detail": { "ID": 255069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2958864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277357", "Detail": { "ID": 277357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9447657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254054", "Detail": { "ID": 254054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0325191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278843", "Detail": { "ID": 278843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2366179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325328", "Detail": { "ID": 325328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4939501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231918", "Detail": { "ID": 231918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6213707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311773", "Detail": { "ID": 311773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8936645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233162", "Detail": { "ID": 233162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8995335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267557", "Detail": { "ID": 267557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0250115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313387", "Detail": { "ID": 313387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3931867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294417", "Detail": { "ID": 294417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1374228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319216", "Detail": { "ID": 319216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9104482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306204", "Detail": { "ID": 306204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5419659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310332", "Detail": { "ID": 310332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5659557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268047", "Detail": { "ID": 268047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0537032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293009", "Detail": { "ID": 293009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5677164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271835", "Detail": { "ID": 271835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0934851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269468", "Detail": { "ID": 269468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5488552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307263", "Detail": { "ID": 307263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8216899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279166", "Detail": { "ID": 279166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2558808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260410", "Detail": { "ID": 260410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0756617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299318", "Detail": { "ID": 299318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6923053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301837", "Detail": { "ID": 301837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2853886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300280", "Detail": { "ID": 300280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9911466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224215", "Detail": { "ID": 224215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6890442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237957", "Detail": { "ID": 237957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2333826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305663", "Detail": { "ID": 305663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3340653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320054", "Detail": { "ID": 320054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9595362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315802", "Detail": { "ID": 315802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9276352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237136", "Detail": { "ID": 237136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9673514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293494", "Detail": { "ID": 293494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8477951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234226", "Detail": { "ID": 234226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.36771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312905", "Detail": { "ID": 312905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1549398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261351", "Detail": { "ID": 261351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3536217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225619", "Detail": { "ID": 225619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9831442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265667", "Detail": { "ID": 265667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.449093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284171", "Detail": { "ID": 284171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7460737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252162", "Detail": { "ID": 252162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5052604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317277", "Detail": { "ID": 317277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4114952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256673", "Detail": { "ID": 256673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7927883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293868", "Detail": { "ID": 293868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8722803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235921", "Detail": { "ID": 235921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.698671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255886", "Detail": { "ID": 255886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5612365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229268", "Detail": { "ID": 229268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0693388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289531", "Detail": { "ID": 289531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4481007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311562", "Detail": { "ID": 311562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8842195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246875", "Detail": { "ID": 246875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1571337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299162", "Detail": { "ID": 299162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3905875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233850", "Detail": { "ID": 233850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1490367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274973", "Detail": { "ID": 274973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1355963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270033", "Detail": { "ID": 270033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.578648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317746", "Detail": { "ID": 317746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4355834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326502", "Detail": { "ID": 326502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7674431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241359", "Detail": { "ID": 241359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7545314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291085", "Detail": { "ID": 291085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7848088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248173", "Detail": { "ID": 248173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4463134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289238", "Detail": { "ID": 289238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4286329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222709", "Detail": { "ID": 222709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2007942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306882", "Detail": { "ID": 306882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5775656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240916", "Detail": { "ID": 240916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3879241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283693", "Detail": { "ID": 283693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7191889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231086", "Detail": { "ID": 231086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3649951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247266", "Detail": { "ID": 247266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3961553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308908", "Detail": { "ID": 308908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2078, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 98, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Land Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06845", "ID": 6969 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0832743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259270", "Detail": { "ID": 259270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6016419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318729", "Detail": { "ID": 318729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.670911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250251", "Detail": { "ID": 250251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1811446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321068", "Detail": { "ID": 321068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2008731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228422", "Detail": { "ID": 228422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7983429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281111", "Detail": { "ID": 281111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8064529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263090", "Detail": { "ID": 263090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6363466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288106", "Detail": { "ID": 288106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.900333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227436", "Detail": { "ID": 227436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5500885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269291", "Detail": { "ID": 269291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5411667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322492", "Detail": { "ID": 322492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6909486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297313", "Detail": { "ID": 297313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0943243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243100", "Detail": { "ID": 243100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0489107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227034", "Detail": { "ID": 227034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2646323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301014", "Detail": { "ID": 301014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0287019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262031", "Detail": { "ID": 262031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3886257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326994", "Detail": { "ID": 326994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7890181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277585", "Detail": { "ID": 277585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9596502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265022", "Detail": { "ID": 265022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1650535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250945", "Detail": { "ID": 250945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2203524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294809", "Detail": { "ID": 294809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1792793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285439", "Detail": { "ID": 285439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3233285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231377", "Detail": { "ID": 231377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5923033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243618", "Detail": { "ID": 243618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3126536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254398", "Detail": { "ID": 254398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2542197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323446", "Detail": { "ID": 323446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9565322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300655", "Detail": { "ID": 300655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0079389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273137", "Detail": { "ID": 273137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3711788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262646", "Detail": { "ID": 262646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6108013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281782", "Detail": { "ID": 281782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1573799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298499", "Detail": { "ID": 298499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.348764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231118", "Detail": { "ID": 231118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3663794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285844", "Detail": { "ID": 285844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3469526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219632", "Detail": { "ID": 219632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3077609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238157", "Detail": { "ID": 238157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2473759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226677", "Detail": { "ID": 226677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2418445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321968", "Detail": { "ID": 321968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4591999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292307", "Detail": { "ID": 292307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.528137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227660", "Detail": { "ID": 227660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5599018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304577", "Detail": { "ID": 304577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0443824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257875", "Detail": { "ID": 257875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0813462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271199", "Detail": { "ID": 271199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0598474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274362", "Detail": { "ID": 274362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1027881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266070", "Detail": { "ID": 266070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4730783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250692", "Detail": { "ID": 250692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.209472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221159", "Detail": { "ID": 221159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.677608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226432", "Detail": { "ID": 226432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2311463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239689", "Detail": { "ID": 239689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7547086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253221", "Detail": { "ID": 253221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9866122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324805", "Detail": { "ID": 324805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2385844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260957", "Detail": { "ID": 260957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1052696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246067", "Detail": { "ID": 246067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8707881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276217", "Detail": { "ID": 276217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6496464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303701", "Detail": { "ID": 303701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8266177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223155", "Detail": { "ID": 223155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2309758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245666", "Detail": { "ID": 245666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8532715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223321", "Detail": { "ID": 223321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.452838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307928", "Detail": { "ID": 307928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8569768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272428", "Detail": { "ID": 272428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3349043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245111", "Detail": { "ID": 245111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5925011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315282", "Detail": { "ID": 315282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9048894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247069", "Detail": { "ID": 247069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1657292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275041", "Detail": { "ID": 275041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1386301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255068", "Detail": { "ID": 255068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2958277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277358", "Detail": { "ID": 277358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9448059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254055", "Detail": { "ID": 254055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0325774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278842", "Detail": { "ID": 278842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2365779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325327", "Detail": { "ID": 325327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4939099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231919", "Detail": { "ID": 231919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6214124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311772", "Detail": { "ID": 311772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8936221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233161", "Detail": { "ID": 233161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8994927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267556", "Detail": { "ID": 267556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.024946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313388", "Detail": { "ID": 313388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3932281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294418", "Detail": { "ID": 294418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1374632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319217", "Detail": { "ID": 319217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9104903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306203", "Detail": { "ID": 306203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5419137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310331", "Detail": { "ID": 310331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5659146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268048", "Detail": { "ID": 268048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0537447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293008", "Detail": { "ID": 293008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5676752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271834", "Detail": { "ID": 271834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0934447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269467", "Detail": { "ID": 269467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5488146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307264", "Detail": { "ID": 307264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8217309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281294", "Detail": { "ID": 281294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1286302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260409", "Detail": { "ID": 260409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0756211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299319", "Detail": { "ID": 299319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6923458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301838", "Detail": { "ID": 301838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.285429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300279", "Detail": { "ID": 300279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.991106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224216", "Detail": { "ID": 224216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6890972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237958", "Detail": { "ID": 237958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2334236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305664", "Detail": { "ID": 305664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3341065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320053", "Detail": { "ID": 320053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9594875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315801", "Detail": { "ID": 315801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9275943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237213", "Detail": { "ID": 237213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1945184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292600", "Detail": { "ID": 292600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5498025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234225", "Detail": { "ID": 234225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3676689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312904", "Detail": { "ID": 312904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1548984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261352", "Detail": { "ID": 261352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3536627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225620", "Detail": { "ID": 225620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9831846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265666", "Detail": { "ID": 265666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4490532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284172", "Detail": { "ID": 284172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.746114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252163", "Detail": { "ID": 252163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5053009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317276", "Detail": { "ID": 317276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4114542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256672", "Detail": { "ID": 256672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7927481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293869", "Detail": { "ID": 293869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8723385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235922", "Detail": { "ID": 235922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6987114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255887", "Detail": { "ID": 255887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5612785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229269", "Detail": { "ID": 229269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0693798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289530", "Detail": { "ID": 289530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4480285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311563", "Detail": { "ID": 311563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8842604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246876", "Detail": { "ID": 246876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1571745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298728", "Detail": { "ID": 298728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.369669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235846", "Detail": { "ID": 235846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6954698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274974", "Detail": { "ID": 274974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1356378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270032", "Detail": { "ID": 270032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5786073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317747", "Detail": { "ID": 317747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4356232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326503", "Detail": { "ID": 326503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7674833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241360", "Detail": { "ID": 241360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7545721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291086", "Detail": { "ID": 291086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7849219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248174", "Detail": { "ID": 248174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4463872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289237", "Detail": { "ID": 289237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4285911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222710", "Detail": { "ID": 222710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2008355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306881", "Detail": { "ID": 306881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5775253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240915", "Detail": { "ID": 240915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3878591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283692", "Detail": { "ID": 283692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.719149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231085", "Detail": { "ID": 231085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3649549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247265", "Detail": { "ID": 247265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3961147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308909", "Detail": { "ID": 308909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2079, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.2", "ID": 6989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0833159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259271", "Detail": { "ID": 259271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6016831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318728", "Detail": { "ID": 318728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6708703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250250", "Detail": { "ID": 250250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1811033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321069", "Detail": { "ID": 321069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2009138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228423", "Detail": { "ID": 228423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7983836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281110", "Detail": { "ID": 281110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8064125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263091", "Detail": { "ID": 263091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6363875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288105", "Detail": { "ID": 288105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9002924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227437", "Detail": { "ID": 227437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5501286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269290", "Detail": { "ID": 269290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5411249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322491", "Detail": { "ID": 322491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6909082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297314", "Detail": { "ID": 297314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0943655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243101", "Detail": { "ID": 243101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0489512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227033", "Detail": { "ID": 227033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2645909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301015", "Detail": { "ID": 301015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0287432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262030", "Detail": { "ID": 262030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3885855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326993", "Detail": { "ID": 326993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7889765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277586", "Detail": { "ID": 277586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9596906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265021", "Detail": { "ID": 265021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1650056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250944", "Detail": { "ID": 250944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2203112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294808", "Detail": { "ID": 294808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1792386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285440", "Detail": { "ID": 285440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3233716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231378", "Detail": { "ID": 231378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5923434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243617", "Detail": { "ID": 243617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3126136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254397", "Detail": { "ID": 254397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2541767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323445", "Detail": { "ID": 323445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9564908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300649", "Detail": { "ID": 300649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0076755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273138", "Detail": { "ID": 273138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3712197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262647", "Detail": { "ID": 262647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6108418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281783", "Detail": { "ID": 281783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1574198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298498", "Detail": { "ID": 298498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3487235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231117", "Detail": { "ID": 231117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.366339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285845", "Detail": { "ID": 285845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3470117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219633", "Detail": { "ID": 219633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3078031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238156", "Detail": { "ID": 238156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2473351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226676", "Detail": { "ID": 226676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2417867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321969", "Detail": { "ID": 321969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4592402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292306", "Detail": { "ID": 292306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5280766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227661", "Detail": { "ID": 227661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5600435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304578", "Detail": { "ID": 304578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0444228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257876", "Detail": { "ID": 257876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0813871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271200", "Detail": { "ID": 271200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0598918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274363", "Detail": { "ID": 274363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1028318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266071", "Detail": { "ID": 266071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4731196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250693", "Detail": { "ID": 250693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2095123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221160", "Detail": { "ID": 221160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6776493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226431", "Detail": { "ID": 226431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2311039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239690", "Detail": { "ID": 239690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7547486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253222", "Detail": { "ID": 253222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9866539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324806", "Detail": { "ID": 324806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2386242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260956", "Detail": { "ID": 260956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1052292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246068", "Detail": { "ID": 246068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8708285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276216", "Detail": { "ID": 276216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6496046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303700", "Detail": { "ID": 303700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8265776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223154", "Detail": { "ID": 223154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2309358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245665", "Detail": { "ID": 245665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8532122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223320", "Detail": { "ID": 223320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4527973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307927", "Detail": { "ID": 307927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8569359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272429", "Detail": { "ID": 272429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.334945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245112", "Detail": { "ID": 245112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5925417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315283", "Detail": { "ID": 315283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9049309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247068", "Detail": { "ID": 247068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1656889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275040", "Detail": { "ID": 275040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1385887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255067", "Detail": { "ID": 255067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.295787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277359", "Detail": { "ID": 277359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.944846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254056", "Detail": { "ID": 254056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.032619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278841", "Detail": { "ID": 278841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2365379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325326", "Detail": { "ID": 325326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4938694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231920", "Detail": { "ID": 231920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6214547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311771", "Detail": { "ID": 311771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8935602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233160", "Detail": { "ID": 233160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.899452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267555", "Detail": { "ID": 267555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0249058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313389", "Detail": { "ID": 313389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3932693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294419", "Detail": { "ID": 294419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1375041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319218", "Detail": { "ID": 319218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9105314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306202", "Detail": { "ID": 306202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5418609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310314", "Detail": { "ID": 310314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5651647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268049", "Detail": { "ID": 268049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0537859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293007", "Detail": { "ID": 293007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5676344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271833", "Detail": { "ID": 271833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0934031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269466", "Detail": { "ID": 269466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5487728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307281", "Detail": { "ID": 307281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8224528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281293", "Detail": { "ID": 281293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1285899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260408", "Detail": { "ID": 260408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0755801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299320", "Detail": { "ID": 299320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6923863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301839", "Detail": { "ID": 301839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2854695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300278", "Detail": { "ID": 300278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9910651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224217", "Detail": { "ID": 224217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6893356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237959", "Detail": { "ID": 237959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2334642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305665", "Detail": { "ID": 305665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3341468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320052", "Detail": { "ID": 320052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.959405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315800", "Detail": { "ID": 315800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9275531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237214", "Detail": { "ID": 237214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1945854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292599", "Detail": { "ID": 292599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5497626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234224", "Detail": { "ID": 234224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3676279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312903", "Detail": { "ID": 312903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1548557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261353", "Detail": { "ID": 261353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3537027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225621", "Detail": { "ID": 225621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9832253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265665", "Detail": { "ID": 265665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4490132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284166", "Detail": { "ID": 284166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7458683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252164", "Detail": { "ID": 252164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.505361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317275", "Detail": { "ID": 317275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4114131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256671", "Detail": { "ID": 256671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7927068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293870", "Detail": { "ID": 293870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8723801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235923", "Detail": { "ID": 235923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6987517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255888", "Detail": { "ID": 255888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5613186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229270", "Detail": { "ID": 229270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.069421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289529", "Detail": { "ID": 289529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4479875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311564", "Detail": { "ID": 311564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8843011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246877", "Detail": { "ID": 246877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1572144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298727", "Detail": { "ID": 298727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3696287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235845", "Detail": { "ID": 235845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.69543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274975", "Detail": { "ID": 274975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1357152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270031", "Detail": { "ID": 270031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5785663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317748", "Detail": { "ID": 317748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4356633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326504", "Detail": { "ID": 326504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7675233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241361", "Detail": { "ID": 241361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7546124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291087", "Detail": { "ID": 291087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.784965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248175", "Detail": { "ID": 248175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4464383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290011", "Detail": { "ID": 290011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4689486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222711", "Detail": { "ID": 222711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2008766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306880", "Detail": { "ID": 306880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5774847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240914", "Detail": { "ID": 240914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3878187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283691", "Detail": { "ID": 283691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7191086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231084", "Detail": { "ID": 231084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3649149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247264", "Detail": { "ID": 247264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3960742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308910", "Detail": { "ID": 308910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2080, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843.1", "ID": 6980 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0833573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259429", "Detail": { "ID": 259429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6087271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318727", "Detail": { "ID": 318727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6708301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250249", "Detail": { "ID": 250249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1810627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321070", "Detail": { "ID": 321070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2009549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228424", "Detail": { "ID": 228424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7984241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281126", "Detail": { "ID": 281126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8071004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263092", "Detail": { "ID": 263092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6364287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288102", "Detail": { "ID": 288102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9001689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227438", "Detail": { "ID": 227438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5501888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269287", "Detail": { "ID": 269287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5409953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323041", "Detail": { "ID": 323041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7194722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297315", "Detail": { "ID": 297315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0944063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243102", "Detail": { "ID": 243102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0489914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227032", "Detail": { "ID": 227032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2645489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301572", "Detail": { "ID": 301572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2682717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262029", "Detail": { "ID": 262029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3885443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326992", "Detail": { "ID": 326992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7889349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277587", "Detail": { "ID": 277587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9597304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265020", "Detail": { "ID": 265020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1649271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250943", "Detail": { "ID": 250943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2202539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294807", "Detail": { "ID": 294807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1791977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285441", "Detail": { "ID": 285441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3234132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231379", "Detail": { "ID": 231379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5923845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243616", "Detail": { "ID": 243616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3125729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254396", "Detail": { "ID": 254396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2541105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323444", "Detail": { "ID": 323444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.956449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300650", "Detail": { "ID": 300650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0077157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273139", "Detail": { "ID": 273139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3712604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262648", "Detail": { "ID": 262648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6108819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281768", "Detail": { "ID": 281768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1567998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298512", "Detail": { "ID": 298512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3493156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231116", "Detail": { "ID": 231116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3662984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285848", "Detail": { "ID": 285848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3471419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219634", "Detail": { "ID": 219634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3078638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238153", "Detail": { "ID": 238153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2472107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226675", "Detail": { "ID": 226675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2417457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322254", "Detail": { "ID": 322254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6748398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292305", "Detail": { "ID": 292305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5280357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227662", "Detail": { "ID": 227662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5600909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304496", "Detail": { "ID": 304496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0407117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257877", "Detail": { "ID": 257877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0814461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271203", "Detail": { "ID": 271203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0600634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274346", "Detail": { "ID": 274346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1020554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266072", "Detail": { "ID": 266072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4731603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250694", "Detail": { "ID": 250694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2095518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221161", "Detail": { "ID": 221161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6776899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226430", "Detail": { "ID": 226430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2310434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239691", "Detail": { "ID": 239691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7547888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253204", "Detail": { "ID": 253204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9858595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324807", "Detail": { "ID": 324807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2386644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260955", "Detail": { "ID": 260955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1051888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246071", "Detail": { "ID": 246071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8709506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276215", "Detail": { "ID": 276215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6495631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303605", "Detail": { "ID": 303605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8225114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223153", "Detail": { "ID": 223153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.230895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245664", "Detail": { "ID": 245664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8531717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223319", "Detail": { "ID": 223319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4527557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308095", "Detail": { "ID": 308095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8645023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272430", "Detail": { "ID": 272430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3349856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245113", "Detail": { "ID": 245113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5925824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315284", "Detail": { "ID": 315284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9049718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247065", "Detail": { "ID": 247065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1655664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275037", "Detail": { "ID": 275037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1384457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255064", "Detail": { "ID": 255064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2956652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277362", "Detail": { "ID": 277362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.950087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254059", "Detail": { "ID": 254059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0327429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278840", "Detail": { "ID": 278840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2364974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325325", "Detail": { "ID": 325325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4938285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231921", "Detail": { "ID": 231921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6214964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312333", "Detail": { "ID": 312333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1232986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233159", "Detail": { "ID": 233159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8994107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267572", "Detail": { "ID": 267572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0256578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314516", "Detail": { "ID": 314516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6433895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294405", "Detail": { "ID": 294405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1369121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319503", "Detail": { "ID": 319503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9287703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306201", "Detail": { "ID": 306201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5418076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310313", "Detail": { "ID": 310313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5651237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268032", "Detail": { "ID": 268032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0530578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293021", "Detail": { "ID": 293021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5682274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271832", "Detail": { "ID": 271832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.093363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269465", "Detail": { "ID": 269465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5487318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307282", "Detail": { "ID": 307282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8224938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281292", "Detail": { "ID": 281292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1285497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260407", "Detail": { "ID": 260407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0755386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299305", "Detail": { "ID": 299305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6917505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301840", "Detail": { "ID": 301840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2855106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300277", "Detail": { "ID": 300277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9910233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224218", "Detail": { "ID": 224218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6893874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237960", "Detail": { "ID": 237960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.233523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305666", "Detail": { "ID": 305666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3341876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321223", "Detail": { "ID": 321223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4189058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315799", "Detail": { "ID": 315799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.927512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237215", "Detail": { "ID": 237215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1946282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292598", "Detail": { "ID": 292598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5497225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234223", "Detail": { "ID": 234223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3675861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312902", "Detail": { "ID": 312902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1547955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261354", "Detail": { "ID": 261354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.353743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225622", "Detail": { "ID": 225622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9832655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265664", "Detail": { "ID": 265664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4489719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284167", "Detail": { "ID": 284167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.745909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252165", "Detail": { "ID": 252165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5054033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318443", "Detail": { "ID": 318443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6578008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256670", "Detail": { "ID": 256670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7926663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293871", "Detail": { "ID": 293871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8724209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235924", "Detail": { "ID": 235924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.698792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255889", "Detail": { "ID": 255889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5613586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229271", "Detail": { "ID": 229271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0694824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289434", "Detail": { "ID": 289434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4370827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311565", "Detail": { "ID": 311565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8843417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246878", "Detail": { "ID": 246878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1572541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298726", "Detail": { "ID": 298726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3695889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235844", "Detail": { "ID": 235844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6953894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274976", "Detail": { "ID": 274976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.135759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270048", "Detail": { "ID": 270048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5793049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317749", "Detail": { "ID": 317749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.435703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326505", "Detail": { "ID": 326505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7675635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241362", "Detail": { "ID": 241362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7546531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291088", "Detail": { "ID": 291088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7850072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248176", "Detail": { "ID": 248176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4464924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290010", "Detail": { "ID": 290010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4689067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222712", "Detail": { "ID": 222712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2009175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306879", "Detail": { "ID": 306879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5774441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240913", "Detail": { "ID": 240913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3877777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283688", "Detail": { "ID": 283688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7189889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231083", "Detail": { "ID": 231083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.364874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247263", "Detail": { "ID": 247263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3960338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308895", "Detail": { "ID": 308895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2081, "AgendaID": 2911, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Student Support", "Reference": "S4M-06843", "ID": 6967 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "End": "2013-06-05T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0826953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258858", "Detail": { "ID": 258858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3310149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319872", "Detail": { "ID": 319872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9450323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249562", "Detail": { "ID": 249562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9321974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320849", "Detail": { "ID": 320849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1843316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227759", "Detail": { "ID": 227759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5644005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280759", "Detail": { "ID": 280759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7812069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262513", "Detail": { "ID": 262513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6051606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288072", "Detail": { "ID": 288072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8988443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229763", "Detail": { "ID": 229763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0956319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270169", "Detail": { "ID": 270169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5845205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322720", "Detail": { "ID": 322720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7007552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294745", "Detail": { "ID": 294745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1764936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242882", "Detail": { "ID": 242882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0396317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235234", "Detail": { "ID": 235234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6615893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302328", "Detail": { "ID": 302328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5196548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244487", "Detail": { "ID": 244487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5568898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327197", "Detail": { "ID": 327197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8033697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276696", "Detail": { "ID": 276696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6772205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264321", "Detail": { "ID": 264321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1284781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248766", "Detail": { "ID": 248766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6689729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295802", "Detail": { "ID": 295802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.536503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285174", "Detail": { "ID": 285174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0696279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230652", "Detail": { "ID": 230652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3393852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243837", "Detail": { "ID": 243837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3219252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254917", "Detail": { "ID": 254917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2893399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323804", "Detail": { "ID": 323804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9726434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291333", "Detail": { "ID": 291333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1144242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265345", "Detail": { "ID": 265345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4351631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262258", "Detail": { "ID": 262258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5937455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281982", "Detail": { "ID": 281982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.166127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297990", "Detail": { "ID": 297990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1335743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231581", "Detail": { "ID": 231581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6067841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285937", "Detail": { "ID": 285937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3509674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219395", "Detail": { "ID": 219395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2968119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238569", "Detail": { "ID": 238569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4597783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225453", "Detail": { "ID": 225453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9753874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321739", "Detail": { "ID": 321739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4493309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292888", "Detail": { "ID": 292888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5625456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227121", "Detail": { "ID": 227121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2687147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312688", "Detail": { "ID": 312688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.13908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257257", "Detail": { "ID": 257257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0483172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271292", "Detail": { "ID": 271292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0640004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278427", "Detail": { "ID": 278427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2183381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286760", "Detail": { "ID": 286760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5995053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250537", "Detail": { "ID": 250537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1938536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220762", "Detail": { "ID": 220762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6559421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220248", "Detail": { "ID": 220248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6302185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252348", "Detail": { "ID": 252348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7253191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266114", "Detail": { "ID": 266114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4749487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324601", "Detail": { "ID": 324601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2299867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259713", "Detail": { "ID": 259713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6213094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239328", "Detail": { "ID": 239328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7320958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273792", "Detail": { "ID": 273792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6358533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304157", "Detail": { "ID": 304157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8521165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221777", "Detail": { "ID": 221777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9473708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241926", "Detail": { "ID": 241926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7859801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223701", "Detail": { "ID": 223701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4700786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307574", "Detail": { "ID": 307574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8353786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272272", "Detail": { "ID": 272272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3225058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244890", "Detail": { "ID": 244890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5829946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315060", "Detail": { "ID": 315060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6723496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247940", "Detail": { "ID": 247940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4349042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274793", "Detail": { "ID": 274793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1219847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255790", "Detail": { "ID": 255790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5570442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277452", "Detail": { "ID": 277452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9539783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253022", "Detail": { "ID": 253022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7634946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276833", "Detail": { "ID": 276833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6830413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325530", "Detail": { "ID": 325530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5103231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232853", "Detail": { "ID": 232853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8794283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311420", "Detail": { "ID": 311420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8780279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230401", "Detail": { "ID": 230401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3282205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267357", "Detail": { "ID": 267357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0159496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313741", "Detail": { "ID": 313741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4086766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295084", "Detail": { "ID": 295084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1915022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318988", "Detail": { "ID": 318988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6876044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306426", "Detail": { "ID": 306426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5515722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311196", "Detail": { "ID": 311196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6098336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268246", "Detail": { "ID": 268246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2551797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286326", "Detail": { "ID": 286326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5739951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258599", "Detail": { "ID": 258599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3142146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263881", "Detail": { "ID": 263881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9147869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308443", "Detail": { "ID": 308443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0561504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279974", "Detail": { "ID": 279974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5308622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261097", "Detail": { "ID": 261097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1116754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299673", "Detail": { "ID": 299673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7078419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306629", "Detail": { "ID": 306629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5602995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301166", "Detail": { "ID": 301166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0367734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223667", "Detail": { "ID": 223667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4686442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237500", "Detail": { "ID": 237500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2132858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305441", "Detail": { "ID": 305441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3241584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320438", "Detail": { "ID": 320438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1664223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316022", "Detail": { "ID": 316022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9424677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236636", "Detail": { "ID": 236636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9335516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291407", "Detail": { "ID": 291407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1179799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234588", "Detail": { "ID": 234588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3907806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313592", "Detail": { "ID": 313592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4020404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288614", "Detail": { "ID": 288614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1509967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225084", "Detail": { "ID": 225084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7438189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265874", "Detail": { "ID": 265874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4642798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283324", "Detail": { "ID": 283324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6957817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251473", "Detail": { "ID": 251473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4651873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317659", "Detail": { "ID": 317659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4319112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254315", "Detail": { "ID": 254315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2502718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295672", "Detail": { "ID": 295672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5309187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234916", "Detail": { "ID": 234916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4052763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257581", "Detail": { "ID": 257581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0626805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228106", "Detail": { "ID": 228106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5846092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291671", "Detail": { "ID": 291671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1373004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311029", "Detail": { "ID": 311029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6023807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246411", "Detail": { "ID": 246411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1275558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298160", "Detail": { "ID": 298160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1407889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234345", "Detail": { "ID": 234345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3732705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274584", "Detail": { "ID": 274584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1129357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269524", "Detail": { "ID": 269524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5513517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317371", "Detail": { "ID": 317371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4192529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326300", "Detail": { "ID": 326300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7524959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241202", "Detail": { "ID": 241202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7473969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289634", "Detail": { "ID": 289634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4524394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247790", "Detail": { "ID": 247790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4285598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287386", "Detail": { "ID": 287386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.861998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222485", "Detail": { "ID": 222485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1909821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307070", "Detail": { "ID": 307070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.585991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240159", "Detail": { "ID": 240159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7814925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283444", "Detail": { "ID": 283444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7081549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232205", "Detail": { "ID": 232205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8446428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237763", "Detail": { "ID": 237763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2250631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309264", "Detail": { "ID": 309264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2077, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 4, "VoteAgainst": 105, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.4", "ID": 6904 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3218242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258857", "Detail": { "ID": 258857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.330961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319873", "Detail": { "ID": 319873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9450748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249646", "Detail": { "ID": 249646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9437783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320848", "Detail": { "ID": 320848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1842907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227758", "Detail": { "ID": 227758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5643594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280760", "Detail": { "ID": 280760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.781247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262512", "Detail": { "ID": 262512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6051195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288073", "Detail": { "ID": 288073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8988863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229762", "Detail": { "ID": 229762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.095591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270170", "Detail": { "ID": 270170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5845613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322721", "Detail": { "ID": 322721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7008126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294744", "Detail": { "ID": 294744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1764524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242881", "Detail": { "ID": 242881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0395917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235235", "Detail": { "ID": 235235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6616311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302327", "Detail": { "ID": 302327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5196138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244488", "Detail": { "ID": 244488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5569321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327198", "Detail": { "ID": 327198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8034117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276695", "Detail": { "ID": 276695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6771798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264322", "Detail": { "ID": 264322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1285199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248767", "Detail": { "ID": 248767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6690215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295803", "Detail": { "ID": 295803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5365447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285173", "Detail": { "ID": 285173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0695851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230651", "Detail": { "ID": 230651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3393442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243838", "Detail": { "ID": 243838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3219651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254918", "Detail": { "ID": 254918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2893814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323805", "Detail": { "ID": 323805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9726856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291332", "Detail": { "ID": 291332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1143827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265344", "Detail": { "ID": 265344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.435122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262257", "Detail": { "ID": 262257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5937047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281981", "Detail": { "ID": 281981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1660854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297991", "Detail": { "ID": 297991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.133615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231582", "Detail": { "ID": 231582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6068254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285936", "Detail": { "ID": 285936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3509267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219394", "Detail": { "ID": 219394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2967689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238570", "Detail": { "ID": 238570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4598179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225452", "Detail": { "ID": 225452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9753467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321738", "Detail": { "ID": 321738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.44929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292889", "Detail": { "ID": 292889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5625893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227120", "Detail": { "ID": 227120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2686725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312687", "Detail": { "ID": 312687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1390166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257173", "Detail": { "ID": 257173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8264558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271291", "Detail": { "ID": 271291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0639588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278426", "Detail": { "ID": 278426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2182961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286759", "Detail": { "ID": 286759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5994652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250451", "Detail": { "ID": 250451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1901155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220763", "Detail": { "ID": 220763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6559827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220249", "Detail": { "ID": 220249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6302796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252347", "Detail": { "ID": 252347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7252707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266113", "Detail": { "ID": 266113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4748899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324600", "Detail": { "ID": 324600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2299461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259714", "Detail": { "ID": 259714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6213699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239327", "Detail": { "ID": 239327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7320551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273793", "Detail": { "ID": 273793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6358944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304158", "Detail": { "ID": 304158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8521672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221776", "Detail": { "ID": 221776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9473284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242009", "Detail": { "ID": 242009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7898988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223702", "Detail": { "ID": 223702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.470119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307575", "Detail": { "ID": 307575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8354382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272190", "Detail": { "ID": 272190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1154395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244889", "Detail": { "ID": 244889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5829543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315059", "Detail": { "ID": 315059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6723078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247941", "Detail": { "ID": 247941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4349452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274794", "Detail": { "ID": 274794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1220451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255791", "Detail": { "ID": 255791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5570845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277451", "Detail": { "ID": 277451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9539362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253021", "Detail": { "ID": 253021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7634533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276834", "Detail": { "ID": 276834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6830825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325531", "Detail": { "ID": 325531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5103641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232852", "Detail": { "ID": 232852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8793866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311421", "Detail": { "ID": 311421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8780709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230402", "Detail": { "ID": 230402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3282613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267358", "Detail": { "ID": 267358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0159908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313740", "Detail": { "ID": 313740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4086365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295083", "Detail": { "ID": 295083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1914602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318987", "Detail": { "ID": 318987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6875634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306427", "Detail": { "ID": 306427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5516143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311197", "Detail": { "ID": 311197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6098742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268245", "Detail": { "ID": 268245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2551373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286327", "Detail": { "ID": 286327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5740377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260694", "Detail": { "ID": 260694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0882414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263882", "Detail": { "ID": 263882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9148279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308442", "Detail": { "ID": 308442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0561098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279975", "Detail": { "ID": 279975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5309045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261098", "Detail": { "ID": 261098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1117182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299672", "Detail": { "ID": 299672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7078011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306628", "Detail": { "ID": 306628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.560258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301167", "Detail": { "ID": 301167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0368255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223668", "Detail": { "ID": 223668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4686844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237499", "Detail": { "ID": 237499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2132445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305440", "Detail": { "ID": 305440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3241174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320439", "Detail": { "ID": 320439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.166463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316023", "Detail": { "ID": 316023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9425286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236635", "Detail": { "ID": 236635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9335089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291408", "Detail": { "ID": 291408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1180213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234589", "Detail": { "ID": 234589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3908224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313593", "Detail": { "ID": 313593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4020815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288613", "Detail": { "ID": 288613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1509553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225083", "Detail": { "ID": 225083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7437784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265875", "Detail": { "ID": 265875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4643205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283323", "Detail": { "ID": 283323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6957411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251472", "Detail": { "ID": 251472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4651446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317660", "Detail": { "ID": 317660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4319514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254712", "Detail": { "ID": 254712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2804952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295671", "Detail": { "ID": 295671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5308581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234915", "Detail": { "ID": 234915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4052347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257580", "Detail": { "ID": 257580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0626389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228107", "Detail": { "ID": 228107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5846502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291672", "Detail": { "ID": 291672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1373415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311028", "Detail": { "ID": 311028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6023395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246328", "Detail": { "ID": 246328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1239951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298161", "Detail": { "ID": 298161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1408294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234346", "Detail": { "ID": 234346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3733113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274583", "Detail": { "ID": 274583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1128927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269525", "Detail": { "ID": 269525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5513935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317370", "Detail": { "ID": 317370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4192104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326299", "Detail": { "ID": 326299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7524545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241119", "Detail": { "ID": 241119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4028294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289633", "Detail": { "ID": 289633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4523991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247789", "Detail": { "ID": 247789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4285192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287387", "Detail": { "ID": 287387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8620394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222484", "Detail": { "ID": 222484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1909409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307071", "Detail": { "ID": 307071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.586032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240158", "Detail": { "ID": 240158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7814511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283445", "Detail": { "ID": 283445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7081988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232206", "Detail": { "ID": 232206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8446847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237764", "Detail": { "ID": 237764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2251028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309263", "Detail": { "ID": 309263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2076, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 49, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.3", "ID": 6903 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3217837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258860", "Detail": { "ID": 258860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3310984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319837", "Detail": { "ID": 319837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9435118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249560", "Detail": { "ID": 249560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9321144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320851", "Detail": { "ID": 320851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1844133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227761", "Detail": { "ID": 227761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5645004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280763", "Detail": { "ID": 280763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7813862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262515", "Detail": { "ID": 262515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6052415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288070", "Detail": { "ID": 288070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8987617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229765", "Detail": { "ID": 229765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0957131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270167", "Detail": { "ID": 270167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5844385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322724", "Detail": { "ID": 322724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7009343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295307", "Detail": { "ID": 295307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5063623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242917", "Detail": { "ID": 242917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0410982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235232", "Detail": { "ID": 235232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.66148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302330", "Detail": { "ID": 302330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5197374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244485", "Detail": { "ID": 244485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5568061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327146", "Detail": { "ID": 327146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8011297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276698", "Detail": { "ID": 276698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6773015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264319", "Detail": { "ID": 264319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1283947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248764", "Detail": { "ID": 248764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6688498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295766", "Detail": { "ID": 295766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5349772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285274", "Detail": { "ID": 285274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3159235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230654", "Detail": { "ID": 230654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3394868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243802", "Detail": { "ID": 243802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.320372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254915", "Detail": { "ID": 254915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2892574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323753", "Detail": { "ID": 323753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9704332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291326", "Detail": { "ID": 291326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.114133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265347", "Detail": { "ID": 265347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4352455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262260", "Detail": { "ID": 262260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5938269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281978", "Detail": { "ID": 281978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1659439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297994", "Detail": { "ID": 297994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1337346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231579", "Detail": { "ID": 231579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6067015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285939", "Detail": { "ID": 285939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3510499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219397", "Detail": { "ID": 219397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2968986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238567", "Detail": { "ID": 238567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4596962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225215", "Detail": { "ID": 225215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9596885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321735", "Detail": { "ID": 321735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4491688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292886", "Detail": { "ID": 292886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5624003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227123", "Detail": { "ID": 227123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2687973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312690", "Detail": { "ID": 312690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1391633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257259", "Detail": { "ID": 257259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0484203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271294", "Detail": { "ID": 271294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0640836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278423", "Detail": { "ID": 278423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2181522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286762", "Detail": { "ID": 286762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.599586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250539", "Detail": { "ID": 250539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1939365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221002", "Detail": { "ID": 221002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6708707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220246", "Detail": { "ID": 220246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6301352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252350", "Detail": { "ID": 252350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7254033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266110", "Detail": { "ID": 266110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4747671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324652", "Detail": { "ID": 324652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2321618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259711", "Detail": { "ID": 259711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6212253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239330", "Detail": { "ID": 239330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.732177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273790", "Detail": { "ID": 273790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6357709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304155", "Detail": { "ID": 304155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8520131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221693", "Detail": { "ID": 221693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9437208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241924", "Detail": { "ID": 241924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7858968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223699", "Detail": { "ID": 223699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4699971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307578", "Detail": { "ID": 307578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8355637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272274", "Detail": { "ID": 272274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3225968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244926", "Detail": { "ID": 244926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5845279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315095", "Detail": { "ID": 315095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6738372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247938", "Detail": { "ID": 247938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4348206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274791", "Detail": { "ID": 274791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1219025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255788", "Detail": { "ID": 255788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5569487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277454", "Detail": { "ID": 277454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9540593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253024", "Detail": { "ID": 253024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7635775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276831", "Detail": { "ID": 276831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6829391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325479", "Detail": { "ID": 325479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.50815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232855", "Detail": { "ID": 232855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8795111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311424", "Detail": { "ID": 311424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8781956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230399", "Detail": { "ID": 230399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.328137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267361", "Detail": { "ID": 267361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0161342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313737", "Detail": { "ID": 313737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4084933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295080", "Detail": { "ID": 295080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.191338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318984", "Detail": { "ID": 318984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6874404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306391", "Detail": { "ID": 306391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5500704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311194", "Detail": { "ID": 311194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6097518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268242", "Detail": { "ID": 268242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2549884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286330", "Detail": { "ID": 286330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5741617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258597", "Detail": { "ID": 258597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3141308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263879", "Detail": { "ID": 263879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9147041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308445", "Detail": { "ID": 308445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0562323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279972", "Detail": { "ID": 279972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5307603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261063", "Detail": { "ID": 261063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1102058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299669", "Detail": { "ID": 299669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7076599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306631", "Detail": { "ID": 306631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5604024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301164", "Detail": { "ID": 301164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.036671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223905", "Detail": { "ID": 223905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4788113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237502", "Detail": { "ID": 237502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2133669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305477", "Detail": { "ID": 305477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3257938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320442", "Detail": { "ID": 320442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1665858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315987", "Detail": { "ID": 315987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9408626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236638", "Detail": { "ID": 236638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9336329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289767", "Detail": { "ID": 289767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4582374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234586", "Detail": { "ID": 234586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3906983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313557", "Detail": { "ID": 313557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4005328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288616", "Detail": { "ID": 288616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1510775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225086", "Detail": { "ID": 225086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7438994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265872", "Detail": { "ID": 265872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4641956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283317", "Detail": { "ID": 283317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6954924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251475", "Detail": { "ID": 251475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4652714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317663", "Detail": { "ID": 317663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4320909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254313", "Detail": { "ID": 254313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2501869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295674", "Detail": { "ID": 295674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5310006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234918", "Detail": { "ID": 234918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4053863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257583", "Detail": { "ID": 257583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0627812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228498", "Detail": { "ID": 228498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8016759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291669", "Detail": { "ID": 291669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.137218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311064", "Detail": { "ID": 311064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6038698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246413", "Detail": { "ID": 246413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1276569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298061", "Detail": { "ID": 298061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1365806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234343", "Detail": { "ID": 234343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3731875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274586", "Detail": { "ID": 274586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1130183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269528", "Detail": { "ID": 269528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5515174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317406", "Detail": { "ID": 317406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4207446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326351", "Detail": { "ID": 326351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7547375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241204", "Detail": { "ID": 241204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.747501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289670", "Detail": { "ID": 289670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4539305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247792", "Detail": { "ID": 247792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4286413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287393", "Detail": { "ID": 287393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8622849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222487", "Detail": { "ID": 222487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1910639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307068", "Detail": { "ID": 307068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5859082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239920", "Detail": { "ID": 239920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7650229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283442", "Detail": { "ID": 283442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7080496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232203", "Detail": { "ID": 232203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8445571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237761", "Detail": { "ID": 237761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2249814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309260", "Detail": { "ID": 309260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2074, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 69, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.2", "ID": 6900 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3216605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258856", "Detail": { "ID": 258856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3308322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319874", "Detail": { "ID": 319874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9451166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249648", "Detail": { "ID": 249648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9438599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320847", "Detail": { "ID": 320847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1842482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227757", "Detail": { "ID": 227757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5643181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280761", "Detail": { "ID": 280761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.781287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262511", "Detail": { "ID": 262511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6050781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288074", "Detail": { "ID": 288074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8989275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229761", "Detail": { "ID": 229761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0955503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270171", "Detail": { "ID": 270171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5846017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322722", "Detail": { "ID": 322722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7008541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294743", "Detail": { "ID": 294743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1764107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242880", "Detail": { "ID": 242880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0395511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235236", "Detail": { "ID": 235236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6616728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302170", "Detail": { "ID": 302170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3004388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244489", "Detail": { "ID": 244489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5569733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327199", "Detail": { "ID": 327199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.803453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276694", "Detail": { "ID": 276694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6771382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264323", "Detail": { "ID": 264323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1285604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248768", "Detail": { "ID": 248768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6690636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295804", "Detail": { "ID": 295804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5365856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285172", "Detail": { "ID": 285172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0695255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230650", "Detail": { "ID": 230650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3393038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243839", "Detail": { "ID": 243839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3221046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254919", "Detail": { "ID": 254919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2894225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323806", "Detail": { "ID": 323806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.972727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291331", "Detail": { "ID": 291331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1143417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265343", "Detail": { "ID": 265343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4350805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262256", "Detail": { "ID": 262256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5936634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281980", "Detail": { "ID": 281980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1660254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297992", "Detail": { "ID": 297992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.133655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231583", "Detail": { "ID": 231583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6068658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285933", "Detail": { "ID": 285933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3508037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219393", "Detail": { "ID": 219393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2967258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238571", "Detail": { "ID": 238571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4598582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225454", "Detail": { "ID": 225454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9754284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321737", "Detail": { "ID": 321737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4492501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292890", "Detail": { "ID": 292890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5626295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227119", "Detail": { "ID": 227119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2686306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312686", "Detail": { "ID": 312686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1389748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257171", "Detail": { "ID": 257171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8263724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271288", "Detail": { "ID": 271288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0638145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278425", "Detail": { "ID": 278425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.218255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286758", "Detail": { "ID": 286758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5994246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250449", "Detail": { "ID": 250449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1900138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220761", "Detail": { "ID": 220761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6559006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220250", "Detail": { "ID": 220250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6303222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252346", "Detail": { "ID": 252346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7252118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266112", "Detail": { "ID": 266112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4748492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324599", "Detail": { "ID": 324599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2299049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259715", "Detail": { "ID": 259715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6214124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239326", "Detail": { "ID": 239326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7320114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273794", "Detail": { "ID": 273794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6359347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304159", "Detail": { "ID": 304159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8522392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221778", "Detail": { "ID": 221778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9474113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242011", "Detail": { "ID": 242011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7899818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223703", "Detail": { "ID": 223703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4701595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307576", "Detail": { "ID": 307576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.835481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272188", "Detail": { "ID": 272188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.115356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244888", "Detail": { "ID": 244888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5829134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315058", "Detail": { "ID": 315058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6722663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247942", "Detail": { "ID": 247942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4349859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274797", "Detail": { "ID": 274797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1221692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255792", "Detail": { "ID": 255792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.557159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277448", "Detail": { "ID": 277448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9537965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253020", "Detail": { "ID": 253020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7634105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276835", "Detail": { "ID": 276835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6831226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325532", "Detail": { "ID": 325532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5104054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232851", "Detail": { "ID": 232851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.879345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311422", "Detail": { "ID": 311422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8781129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230403", "Detail": { "ID": 230403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3283024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267359", "Detail": { "ID": 267359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.016052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313739", "Detail": { "ID": 313739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4085958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295082", "Detail": { "ID": 295082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1914195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318986", "Detail": { "ID": 318986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6875224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306428", "Detail": { "ID": 306428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5516551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311198", "Detail": { "ID": 311198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6099148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268244", "Detail": { "ID": 268244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2550708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286328", "Detail": { "ID": 286328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5740795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260696", "Detail": { "ID": 260696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0883232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263883", "Detail": { "ID": 263883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9148685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308441", "Detail": { "ID": 308441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0560673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279976", "Detail": { "ID": 279976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5309454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261099", "Detail": { "ID": 261099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1117602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299671", "Detail": { "ID": 299671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7077587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306627", "Detail": { "ID": 306627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5602161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301168", "Detail": { "ID": 301168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0368752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223666", "Detail": { "ID": 223666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4686036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237498", "Detail": { "ID": 237498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2132024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305439", "Detail": { "ID": 305439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3240753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320440", "Detail": { "ID": 320440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1665042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316024", "Detail": { "ID": 316024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.942571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236634", "Detail": { "ID": 236634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9334672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291409", "Detail": { "ID": 291409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1180625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234590", "Detail": { "ID": 234590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3908639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313594", "Detail": { "ID": 313594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4021226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288612", "Detail": { "ID": 288612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1509133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225082", "Detail": { "ID": 225082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.743736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265876", "Detail": { "ID": 265876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.464361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283322", "Detail": { "ID": 283322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6956994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251471", "Detail": { "ID": 251471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4651017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317661", "Detail": { "ID": 317661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4319923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254714", "Detail": { "ID": 254714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2805786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295670", "Detail": { "ID": 295670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5308178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234914", "Detail": { "ID": 234914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4051931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257579", "Detail": { "ID": 257579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0625976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228105", "Detail": { "ID": 228105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5845682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291673", "Detail": { "ID": 291673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1373823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311027", "Detail": { "ID": 311027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6022976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246326", "Detail": { "ID": 246326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1239103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298162", "Detail": { "ID": 298162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1408705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234347", "Detail": { "ID": 234347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3733526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274582", "Detail": { "ID": 274582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.112832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269526", "Detail": { "ID": 269526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5514354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317369", "Detail": { "ID": 317369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4191508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326298", "Detail": { "ID": 326298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7524131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241117", "Detail": { "ID": 241117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.402705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289632", "Detail": { "ID": 289632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4523589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247788", "Detail": { "ID": 247788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4284782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287388", "Detail": { "ID": 287388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8620808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222483", "Detail": { "ID": 222483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1908994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307072", "Detail": { "ID": 307072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5860731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240161", "Detail": { "ID": 240161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7815748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283448", "Detail": { "ID": 283448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7083272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232207", "Detail": { "ID": 232207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8447266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237765", "Detail": { "ID": 237765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2251671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309262", "Detail": { "ID": 309262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2075, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 11, "VoteAgainst": 98, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766.1", "ID": 6899 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3217429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258859", "Detail": { "ID": 258859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3310573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319871", "Detail": { "ID": 319871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9449723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249561", "Detail": { "ID": 249561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9321566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320850", "Detail": { "ID": 320850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1843726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227760", "Detail": { "ID": 227760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5644589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280764", "Detail": { "ID": 280764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7814273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262514", "Detail": { "ID": 262514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6052009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288071", "Detail": { "ID": 288071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8988031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229764", "Detail": { "ID": 229764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0956724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270168", "Detail": { "ID": 270168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5844792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322725", "Detail": { "ID": 322725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7009749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294746", "Detail": { "ID": 294746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1765343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242883", "Detail": { "ID": 242883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0396718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235233", "Detail": { "ID": 235233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6615459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302329", "Detail": { "ID": 302329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5196959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244486", "Detail": { "ID": 244486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.556848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327189", "Detail": { "ID": 327189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8030169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276697", "Detail": { "ID": 276697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6772611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264320", "Detail": { "ID": 264320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1284369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248765", "Detail": { "ID": 248765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6688905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295801", "Detail": { "ID": 295801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5364445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285175", "Detail": { "ID": 285175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0696687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230653", "Detail": { "ID": 230653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.339445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243836", "Detail": { "ID": 243836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3218841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254916", "Detail": { "ID": 254916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2892989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323796", "Detail": { "ID": 323796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9722921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291334", "Detail": { "ID": 291334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.114466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265346", "Detail": { "ID": 265346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4352039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262259", "Detail": { "ID": 262259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5937868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281977", "Detail": { "ID": 281977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1659026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297995", "Detail": { "ID": 297995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1337751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231580", "Detail": { "ID": 231580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.606743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285938", "Detail": { "ID": 285938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3510086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219396", "Detail": { "ID": 219396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2968544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238568", "Detail": { "ID": 238568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4597375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225216", "Detail": { "ID": 225216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9597405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321734", "Detail": { "ID": 321734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4491275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292887", "Detail": { "ID": 292887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5624693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227122", "Detail": { "ID": 227122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.268756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312689", "Detail": { "ID": 312689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1391224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257258", "Detail": { "ID": 257258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0483773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271293", "Detail": { "ID": 271293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0640418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278422", "Detail": { "ID": 278422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2181103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286761", "Detail": { "ID": 286761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5995449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250538", "Detail": { "ID": 250538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1938951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221001", "Detail": { "ID": 221001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6708098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220247", "Detail": { "ID": 220247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6301767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252349", "Detail": { "ID": 252349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7253622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266109", "Detail": { "ID": 266109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4747258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324609", "Detail": { "ID": 324609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2303327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259712", "Detail": { "ID": 259712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6212674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239329", "Detail": { "ID": 239329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7321365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273791", "Detail": { "ID": 273791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6358123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304156", "Detail": { "ID": 304156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8520539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221694", "Detail": { "ID": 221694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9437619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241925", "Detail": { "ID": 241925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.785938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223700", "Detail": { "ID": 223700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4700375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307579", "Detail": { "ID": 307579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8356044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272273", "Detail": { "ID": 272273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3225484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244891", "Detail": { "ID": 244891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5830348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315061", "Detail": { "ID": 315061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6723909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247939", "Detail": { "ID": 247939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4348625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274792", "Detail": { "ID": 274792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1219441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255789", "Detail": { "ID": 255789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5570019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277453", "Detail": { "ID": 277453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9540189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253023", "Detail": { "ID": 253023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7635364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276832", "Detail": { "ID": 276832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6829796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325522", "Detail": { "ID": 325522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5099772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232854", "Detail": { "ID": 232854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8794704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311425", "Detail": { "ID": 311425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8782381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230400", "Detail": { "ID": 230400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3281795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267362", "Detail": { "ID": 267362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0161764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313736", "Detail": { "ID": 313736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4084516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295079", "Detail": { "ID": 295079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1912968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318983", "Detail": { "ID": 318983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6873988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306425", "Detail": { "ID": 306425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5515115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311195", "Detail": { "ID": 311195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.609793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268241", "Detail": { "ID": 268241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2549464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286331", "Detail": { "ID": 286331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5742229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258598", "Detail": { "ID": 258598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3141732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263880", "Detail": { "ID": 263880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9147461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308444", "Detail": { "ID": 308444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0561915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279973", "Detail": { "ID": 279973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.530802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261096", "Detail": { "ID": 261096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1116336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299668", "Detail": { "ID": 299668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7076191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306630", "Detail": { "ID": 306630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5603598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301165", "Detail": { "ID": 301165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0367239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223904", "Detail": { "ID": 223904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4787694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237501", "Detail": { "ID": 237501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2133262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305442", "Detail": { "ID": 305442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3242001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320443", "Detail": { "ID": 320443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1666264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316021", "Detail": { "ID": 316021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9424263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236637", "Detail": { "ID": 236637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9335922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291406", "Detail": { "ID": 291406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1179376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234587", "Detail": { "ID": 234587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3907399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313591", "Detail": { "ID": 313591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4019983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288615", "Detail": { "ID": 288615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1510372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225085", "Detail": { "ID": 225085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7438592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265873", "Detail": { "ID": 265873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.464238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283325", "Detail": { "ID": 283325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6958438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251474", "Detail": { "ID": 251474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4652296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317664", "Detail": { "ID": 317664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4321317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254314", "Detail": { "ID": 254314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2502302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295673", "Detail": { "ID": 295673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5309607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234917", "Detail": { "ID": 234917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.405343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257582", "Detail": { "ID": 257582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0627214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228497", "Detail": { "ID": 228497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8016339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291670", "Detail": { "ID": 291670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1372589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311030", "Detail": { "ID": 311030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6024213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246412", "Detail": { "ID": 246412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1275972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298159", "Detail": { "ID": 298159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1407476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234344", "Detail": { "ID": 234344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.37323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274585", "Detail": { "ID": 274585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1129772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269529", "Detail": { "ID": 269529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5515585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317372", "Detail": { "ID": 317372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4192942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326308", "Detail": { "ID": 326308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7528476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241203", "Detail": { "ID": 241203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7474383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289635", "Detail": { "ID": 289635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4524793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247791", "Detail": { "ID": 247791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4286007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284899", "Detail": { "ID": 284899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0524871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222486", "Detail": { "ID": 222486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1910234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307069", "Detail": { "ID": 307069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5859492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239921", "Detail": { "ID": 239921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7650647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283443", "Detail": { "ID": 283443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7080909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232204", "Detail": { "ID": 232204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8445999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237762", "Detail": { "ID": 237762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2250229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309259", "Detail": { "ID": 309259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2073, "AgendaID": 2744, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 59, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Transforming Scotland's Railways", "Reference": "S4M-06766", "ID": 6885 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3216191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269277", "Detail": { "ID": 269277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5375728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318348", "Detail": { "ID": 318348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.653741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249915", "Detail": { "ID": 249915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9554697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320500", "Detail": { "ID": 320500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.169087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230289", "Detail": { "ID": 230289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.316387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281467", "Detail": { "ID": 281467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1440836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263629", "Detail": { "ID": 263629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8978925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289076", "Detail": { "ID": 289076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1710237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228679", "Detail": { "ID": 228679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8095158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270349", "Detail": { "ID": 270349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8038182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323262", "Detail": { "ID": 323262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.942171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296555", "Detail": { "ID": 296555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8540928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242494", "Detail": { "ID": 242494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0157128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236152", "Detail": { "ID": 236152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7137298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300976", "Detail": { "ID": 300976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0269831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261144", "Detail": { "ID": 261144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1137378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326781", "Detail": { "ID": 326781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.779808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278626", "Detail": { "ID": 278626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2273557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264769", "Detail": { "ID": 264769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1480833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249082", "Detail": { "ID": 249082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6831149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293675", "Detail": { "ID": 293675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8641346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287722", "Detail": { "ID": 287722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.88343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233466", "Detail": { "ID": 233466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1317481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243388", "Detail": { "ID": 243388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2956005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253297", "Detail": { "ID": 253297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9902951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321512", "Detail": { "ID": 321512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4392703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300783", "Detail": { "ID": 300783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0186899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273390", "Detail": { "ID": 273390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6180463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263260", "Detail": { "ID": 263260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8816672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282416", "Detail": { "ID": 282416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4119316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298856", "Detail": { "ID": 298856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3750908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230580", "Detail": { "ID": 230580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3365184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286474", "Detail": { "ID": 286474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5873937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219937", "Detail": { "ID": 219937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.321117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238751", "Detail": { "ID": 238751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4674627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225915", "Detail": { "ID": 225915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9959143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322174", "Detail": { "ID": 322174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4745719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290275", "Detail": { "ID": 290275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7398197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228869", "Detail": { "ID": 228869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8177412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304645", "Detail": { "ID": 304645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0472683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258366", "Detail": { "ID": 258366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3041166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274433", "Detail": { "ID": 274433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.106323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279480", "Detail": { "ID": 279480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5095327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266855", "Detail": { "ID": 266855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7594075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253632", "Detail": { "ID": 253632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.004806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221446", "Detail": { "ID": 221446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9330542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220563", "Detail": { "ID": 220563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6467626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240319", "Detail": { "ID": 240319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3546168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266578", "Detail": { "ID": 266578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7471941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324190", "Detail": { "ID": 324190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.996051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260184", "Detail": { "ID": 260184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6474034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247056", "Detail": { "ID": 247056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1651753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275643", "Detail": { "ID": 275643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3843574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303739", "Detail": { "ID": 303739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8335895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222082", "Detail": { "ID": 222082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9670099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242298", "Detail": { "ID": 242298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0069466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224329", "Detail": { "ID": 224329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6999533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308286", "Detail": { "ID": 308286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0490745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272751", "Detail": { "ID": 272751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3488255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244336", "Detail": { "ID": 244336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5502906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314352", "Detail": { "ID": 314352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6359964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251214", "Detail": { "ID": 251214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4537705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276498", "Detail": { "ID": 276498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6687046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256277", "Detail": { "ID": 256277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7756368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282460", "Detail": { "ID": 282460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4198475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255055", "Detail": { "ID": 255055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.295271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277765", "Detail": { "ID": 277765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.967498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325095", "Detail": { "ID": 325095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.255951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232347", "Detail": { "ID": 232347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8509103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312269", "Detail": { "ID": 312269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1203161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231488", "Detail": { "ID": 231488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6027665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267872", "Detail": { "ID": 267872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.038882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314746", "Detail": { "ID": 314746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6537129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296736", "Detail": { "ID": 296736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8717271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319424", "Detail": { "ID": 319424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9252974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305994", "Detail": { "ID": 305994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.35442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309139", "Detail": { "ID": 309139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0936887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268557", "Detail": { "ID": 268557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2723969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293195", "Detail": { "ID": 293195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5756727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM261579", "Detail": { "ID": 261579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3635679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264505", "Detail": { "ID": 264505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1364093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307671", "Detail": { "ID": 307671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.839877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280887", "Detail": { "ID": 280887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7866194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245386", "Detail": { "ID": 245386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8326191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304879", "Detail": { "ID": 304879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0626622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303244", "Detail": { "ID": 303244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.80648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297026", "Detail": { "ID": 297026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8845155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224812", "Detail": { "ID": 224812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7209891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237996", "Detail": { "ID": 237996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2350719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296887", "Detail": { "ID": 296887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8783238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321291", "Detail": { "ID": 321291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4218618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315573", "Detail": { "ID": 315573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9178203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238075", "Detail": { "ID": 238075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2384683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293506", "Detail": { "ID": 293506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8483156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233613", "Detail": { "ID": 233613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1385588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312477", "Detail": { "ID": 312477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1295946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287628", "Detail": { "ID": 287628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8794673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226548", "Detail": { "ID": 226548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2362073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265188", "Detail": { "ID": 265188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1723143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284453", "Detail": { "ID": 284453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0332586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259101", "Detail": { "ID": 259101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.341769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318522", "Detail": { "ID": 318522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6617993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255584", "Detail": { "ID": 255584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5376482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295144", "Detail": { "ID": 295144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1942902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236842", "Detail": { "ID": 236842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9426419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256815", "Detail": { "ID": 256815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8110612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230017", "Detail": { "ID": 230017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1127088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290498", "Detail": { "ID": 290498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7496891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310008", "Detail": { "ID": 310008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3604515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247657", "Detail": { "ID": 247657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.42283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299174", "Detail": { "ID": 299174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3912337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235269", "Detail": { "ID": 235269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6631777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275899", "Detail": { "ID": 275899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3957751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274046", "Detail": { "ID": 274046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6520411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316514", "Detail": { "ID": 316514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1512939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325888", "Detail": { "ID": 325888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5257786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241658", "Detail": { "ID": 241658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7742843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287850", "Detail": { "ID": 287850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8892456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248466", "Detail": { "ID": 248466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6472309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289109", "Detail": { "ID": 289109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1724387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223001", "Detail": { "ID": 223001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2244797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306845", "Detail": { "ID": 306845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5761939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240617", "Detail": { "ID": 240617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3750234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284677", "Detail": { "ID": 284677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0428289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232957", "Detail": { "ID": 232957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8839369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246216", "Detail": { "ID": 246216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1191341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310155", "Detail": { "ID": 310155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2072, "AgendaID": 2903, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 40, "VoteAgainst": 70, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ensuring Access to High Quality Sustainable Services for People Living with Chronic Pain", "Reference": "S4M-06746.1", "ID": 6886 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3668899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259841", "Detail": { "ID": 259841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6323267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318350", "Detail": { "ID": 318350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6538222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249953", "Detail": { "ID": 249953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9570658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320498", "Detail": { "ID": 320498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1690054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230259", "Detail": { "ID": 230259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3150857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281437", "Detail": { "ID": 281437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1427658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263627", "Detail": { "ID": 263627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8978087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289868", "Detail": { "ID": 289868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.462496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228677", "Detail": { "ID": 228677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8094147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270494", "Detail": { "ID": 270494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8102051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323289", "Detail": { "ID": 323289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.94333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296553", "Detail": { "ID": 296553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8540105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242492", "Detail": { "ID": 242492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0156099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236493", "Detail": { "ID": 236493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9272539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300974", "Detail": { "ID": 300974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0269006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261146", "Detail": { "ID": 261146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1138199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326783", "Detail": { "ID": 326783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7798898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278624", "Detail": { "ID": 278624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2272721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264771", "Detail": { "ID": 264771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1481644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249114", "Detail": { "ID": 249114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6844964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293677", "Detail": { "ID": 293677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8642165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287720", "Detail": { "ID": 287720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8833485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233464", "Detail": { "ID": 233464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1316643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243390", "Detail": { "ID": 243390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2956807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253299", "Detail": { "ID": 253299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9903773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321514", "Detail": { "ID": 321514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.439351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300718", "Detail": { "ID": 300718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0158754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273388", "Detail": { "ID": 273388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6179466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263228", "Detail": { "ID": 263228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.880292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285702", "Detail": { "ID": 285702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3409079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298824", "Detail": { "ID": 298824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3737259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230582", "Detail": { "ID": 230582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3365992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286299", "Detail": { "ID": 286299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5728292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219903", "Detail": { "ID": 219903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3196511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238896", "Detail": { "ID": 238896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4736635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225917", "Detail": { "ID": 225917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9959954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322148", "Detail": { "ID": 322148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4733893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290277", "Detail": { "ID": 290277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7399016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228839", "Detail": { "ID": 228839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8164372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304643", "Detail": { "ID": 304643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0471863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258328", "Detail": { "ID": 258328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3023902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272029", "Detail": { "ID": 272029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1082624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279821", "Detail": { "ID": 279821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5242477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266853", "Detail": { "ID": 266853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7593245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253597", "Detail": { "ID": 253597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0032989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221444", "Detail": { "ID": 221444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9329705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220597", "Detail": { "ID": 220597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6482193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240317", "Detail": { "ID": 240317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3544226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266562", "Detail": { "ID": 266562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7465119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324188", "Detail": { "ID": 324188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9959682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260216", "Detail": { "ID": 260216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0669387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246926", "Detail": { "ID": 246926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1596245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275645", "Detail": { "ID": 275645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3844376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303741", "Detail": { "ID": 303741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8336784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222084", "Detail": { "ID": 222084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.967091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242300", "Detail": { "ID": 242300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0070283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224366", "Detail": { "ID": 224366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7017187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308253", "Detail": { "ID": 308253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0476359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272717", "Detail": { "ID": 272717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3473754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244334", "Detail": { "ID": 244334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5502057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314350", "Detail": { "ID": 314350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6359141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251359", "Detail": { "ID": 251359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4601519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276518", "Detail": { "ID": 276518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6695778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256573", "Detail": { "ID": 256573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7885178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282440", "Detail": { "ID": 282440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4189752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254613", "Detail": { "ID": 254613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2637829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278260", "Detail": { "ID": 278260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2045374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325097", "Detail": { "ID": 325097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2560333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232345", "Detail": { "ID": 232345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8508278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312237", "Detail": { "ID": 312237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1164588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231519", "Detail": { "ID": 231519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6041102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267888", "Detail": { "ID": 267888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.046809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314778", "Detail": { "ID": 314778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6551033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296767", "Detail": { "ID": 296767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8730687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319397", "Detail": { "ID": 319397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9241377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305996", "Detail": { "ID": 305996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3545022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309141", "Detail": { "ID": 309141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0937699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268541", "Detail": { "ID": 268541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2716074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293164", "Detail": { "ID": 293164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5743333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262082", "Detail": { "ID": 262082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3908064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268882", "Detail": { "ID": 268882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2871752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307669", "Detail": { "ID": 307669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.839794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280889", "Detail": { "ID": 280889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7867005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245388", "Detail": { "ID": 245388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8327014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304911", "Detail": { "ID": 304911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0640616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303242", "Detail": { "ID": 303242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8063962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297028", "Detail": { "ID": 297028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8846187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224810", "Detail": { "ID": 224810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7208899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237994", "Detail": { "ID": 237994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2349889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296885", "Detail": { "ID": 296885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8782257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321317", "Detail": { "ID": 321317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4229781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315575", "Detail": { "ID": 315575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9179024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238073", "Detail": { "ID": 238073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2383858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293508", "Detail": { "ID": 293508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.848396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233615", "Detail": { "ID": 233615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1386414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312479", "Detail": { "ID": 312479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1296769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287626", "Detail": { "ID": 287626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8793841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226511", "Detail": { "ID": 226511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2345714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265190", "Detail": { "ID": 265190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.172398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284234", "Detail": { "ID": 284234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0172525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259070", "Detail": { "ID": 259070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3404334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318549", "Detail": { "ID": 318549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6629707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255619", "Detail": { "ID": 255619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5391469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295142", "Detail": { "ID": 295142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1941905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236811", "Detail": { "ID": 236811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9411407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256813", "Detail": { "ID": 256813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8109792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230015", "Detail": { "ID": 230015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1126073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290500", "Detail": { "ID": 290500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7497717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310006", "Detail": { "ID": 310006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3603697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247622", "Detail": { "ID": 247622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4213386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299176", "Detail": { "ID": 299176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3913375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235271", "Detail": { "ID": 235271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6632598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275866", "Detail": { "ID": 275866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3943491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274016", "Detail": { "ID": 274016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6507271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316512", "Detail": { "ID": 316512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1511752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325886", "Detail": { "ID": 325886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5256888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241656", "Detail": { "ID": 241656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7742033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287072", "Detail": { "ID": 287072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6130181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248435", "Detail": { "ID": 248435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.645849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289174", "Detail": { "ID": 289174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1806531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222967", "Detail": { "ID": 222967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2230154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306847", "Detail": { "ID": 306847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5762752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240619", "Detail": { "ID": 240619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3751061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284697", "Detail": { "ID": 284697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0436791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232988", "Detail": { "ID": 232988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8852782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246246", "Detail": { "ID": 246246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1204122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310188", "Detail": { "ID": 310188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2070, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658.2", "ID": 6813 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3684487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM269276", "Detail": { "ID": 269276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5375125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318349", "Detail": { "ID": 318349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.653782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249952", "Detail": { "ID": 249952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9570256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320499", "Detail": { "ID": 320499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1690459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230260", "Detail": { "ID": 230260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3151268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281469", "Detail": { "ID": 281469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1441831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263628", "Detail": { "ID": 263628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8978509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289077", "Detail": { "ID": 289077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1710646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228678", "Detail": { "ID": 228678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8094546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270350", "Detail": { "ID": 270350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8038592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323258", "Detail": { "ID": 323258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.941956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296554", "Detail": { "ID": 296554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8540514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242493", "Detail": { "ID": 242493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0156512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236153", "Detail": { "ID": 236153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7137726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300975", "Detail": { "ID": 300975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0269414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261145", "Detail": { "ID": 261145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1137791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326782", "Detail": { "ID": 326782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7798493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278625", "Detail": { "ID": 278625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2273129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264770", "Detail": { "ID": 264770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1481241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249074", "Detail": { "ID": 249074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6827639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293676", "Detail": { "ID": 293676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8641761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287721", "Detail": { "ID": 287721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8833892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233465", "Detail": { "ID": 233465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1317062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243389", "Detail": { "ID": 243389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2956405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253298", "Detail": { "ID": 253298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9903363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321513", "Detail": { "ID": 321513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4393106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM301436", "Detail": { "ID": 301436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2621486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273389", "Detail": { "ID": 273389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6179868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263268", "Detail": { "ID": 263268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8820134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282414", "Detail": { "ID": 282414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4118461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298858", "Detail": { "ID": 298858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.375171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230581", "Detail": { "ID": 230581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.336559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286473", "Detail": { "ID": 286473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5873331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219905", "Detail": { "ID": 219905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3197347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238752", "Detail": { "ID": 238752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4675026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225916", "Detail": { "ID": 225916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9959548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322178", "Detail": { "ID": 322178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4747577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290276", "Detail": { "ID": 290276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7398612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228877", "Detail": { "ID": 228877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8180896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304644", "Detail": { "ID": 304644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0472266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258329", "Detail": { "ID": 258329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3024309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM274432", "Detail": { "ID": 274432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1062817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279478", "Detail": { "ID": 279478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5094501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266854", "Detail": { "ID": 266854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7593661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253598", "Detail": { "ID": 253598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0033398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221445", "Detail": { "ID": 221445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9330122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220595", "Detail": { "ID": 220595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6481378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240318", "Detail": { "ID": 240318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3544632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266563", "Detail": { "ID": 266563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7465549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324189", "Detail": { "ID": 324189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9960095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260176", "Detail": { "ID": 260176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6470572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM247055", "Detail": { "ID": 247055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1651336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275644", "Detail": { "ID": 275644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3843979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303740", "Detail": { "ID": 303740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.833635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222083", "Detail": { "ID": 222083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9670506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242299", "Detail": { "ID": 242299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0069876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224330", "Detail": { "ID": 224330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6999946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308288", "Detail": { "ID": 308288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.049157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272718", "Detail": { "ID": 272718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3474161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244335", "Detail": { "ID": 244335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5502477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314351", "Detail": { "ID": 314351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6359546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251215", "Detail": { "ID": 251215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4538132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276499", "Detail": { "ID": 276499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.668768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256278", "Detail": { "ID": 256278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7756774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282459", "Detail": { "ID": 282459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4198059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM255054", "Detail": { "ID": 255054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2952296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277757", "Detail": { "ID": 277757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9671488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325096", "Detail": { "ID": 325096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2559929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232346", "Detail": { "ID": 232346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8508684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312271", "Detail": { "ID": 312271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1203982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231480", "Detail": { "ID": 231480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6024334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267874", "Detail": { "ID": 267874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0389634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314744", "Detail": { "ID": 314744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6536296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296734", "Detail": { "ID": 296734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8716277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319428", "Detail": { "ID": 319428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9254871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305995", "Detail": { "ID": 305995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3544603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309140", "Detail": { "ID": 309140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0937291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268555", "Detail": { "ID": 268555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2722027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293197", "Detail": { "ID": 293197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8341305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262081", "Detail": { "ID": 262081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3907656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264497", "Detail": { "ID": 264497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1360646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307670", "Detail": { "ID": 307670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8398348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280888", "Detail": { "ID": 280888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7866596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245387", "Detail": { "ID": 245387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8326601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304877", "Detail": { "ID": 304877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0625611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303243", "Detail": { "ID": 303243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8064373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297027", "Detail": { "ID": 297027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8845764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224811", "Detail": { "ID": 224811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7209297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237995", "Detail": { "ID": 237995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2350296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296886", "Detail": { "ID": 296886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8782651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321287", "Detail": { "ID": 321287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4216749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315574", "Detail": { "ID": 315574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9178615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238074", "Detail": { "ID": 238074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2384272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293507", "Detail": { "ID": 293507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8483556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233614", "Detail": { "ID": 233614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1386002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312478", "Detail": { "ID": 312478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1296354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287627", "Detail": { "ID": 287627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.879426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226547", "Detail": { "ID": 226547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2361404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265189", "Detail": { "ID": 265189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1723562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284495", "Detail": { "ID": 284495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.035065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259109", "Detail": { "ID": 259109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3421154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318518", "Detail": { "ID": 318518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6616343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255618", "Detail": { "ID": 255618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5391063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295143", "Detail": { "ID": 295143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1942403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236850", "Detail": { "ID": 236850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9429862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256814", "Detail": { "ID": 256814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8110202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230016", "Detail": { "ID": 230016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1126481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290499", "Detail": { "ID": 290499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7497314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310007", "Detail": { "ID": 310007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3604099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247623", "Detail": { "ID": 247623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4213784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299175", "Detail": { "ID": 299175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3912866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235270", "Detail": { "ID": 235270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6632188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275907", "Detail": { "ID": 275907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3961197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274048", "Detail": { "ID": 274048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6521227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316513", "Detail": { "ID": 316513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1512158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325887", "Detail": { "ID": 325887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5257366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241657", "Detail": { "ID": 241657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7742433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287073", "Detail": { "ID": 287073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6130594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248474", "Detail": { "ID": 248474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6475779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288295", "Detail": { "ID": 288295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1286758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM223000", "Detail": { "ID": 223000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2244197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306846", "Detail": { "ID": 306846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5762349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240618", "Detail": { "ID": 240618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3750645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284678", "Detail": { "ID": 284678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0428877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232987", "Detail": { "ID": 232987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8852371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246208", "Detail": { "ID": 246208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1187832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310153", "Detail": { "ID": 310153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2071, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Ferry Services", "Reference": "S4M-06658", "ID": 6783 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3668015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259836", "Detail": { "ID": 259836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6321213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318352", "Detail": { "ID": 318352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6539034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249955", "Detail": { "ID": 249955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9571449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320496", "Detail": { "ID": 320496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1689238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230257", "Detail": { "ID": 230257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.315004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281439", "Detail": { "ID": 281439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1428496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263625", "Detail": { "ID": 263625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8977081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289947", "Detail": { "ID": 289947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4661816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228005", "Detail": { "ID": 228005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5802407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270499", "Detail": { "ID": 270499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.810414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323291", "Detail": { "ID": 323291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9434319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296551", "Detail": { "ID": 296551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8539291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242490", "Detail": { "ID": 242490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0155267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236496", "Detail": { "ID": 236496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9273787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300471", "Detail": { "ID": 300471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9996145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261148", "Detail": { "ID": 261148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1139026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326785", "Detail": { "ID": 326785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.779972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278622", "Detail": { "ID": 278622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2271897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264773", "Detail": { "ID": 264773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1482459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249117", "Detail": { "ID": 249117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6846198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293679", "Detail": { "ID": 293679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8642978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287718", "Detail": { "ID": 287718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8832668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233462", "Detail": { "ID": 233462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1315808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243392", "Detail": { "ID": 243392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.295763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253324", "Detail": { "ID": 253324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9914624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321516", "Detail": { "ID": 321516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4394504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300719", "Detail": { "ID": 300719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0159194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273386", "Detail": { "ID": 273386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6178657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263224", "Detail": { "ID": 263224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8801275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285700", "Detail": { "ID": 285700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3408269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298827", "Detail": { "ID": 298827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3738485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230584", "Detail": { "ID": 230584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3367012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287123", "Detail": { "ID": 287123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6201649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219901", "Detail": { "ID": 219901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3195496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238902", "Detail": { "ID": 238902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4739147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225919", "Detail": { "ID": 225919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9960776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322146", "Detail": { "ID": 322146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4732868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290272", "Detail": { "ID": 290272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7396921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228837", "Detail": { "ID": 228837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8163548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304714", "Detail": { "ID": 304714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0502426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258326", "Detail": { "ID": 258326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3023071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272024", "Detail": { "ID": 272024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1080583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279819", "Detail": { "ID": 279819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5241649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266828", "Detail": { "ID": 266828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7582317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253595", "Detail": { "ID": 253595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0032163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221442", "Detail": { "ID": 221442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9328857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220599", "Detail": { "ID": 220599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6483011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240137", "Detail": { "ID": 240137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7805439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266560", "Detail": { "ID": 266560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7464127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324186", "Detail": { "ID": 324186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9958869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260219", "Detail": { "ID": 260219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0670934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246615", "Detail": { "ID": 246615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1458859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275647", "Detail": { "ID": 275647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3845184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303782", "Detail": { "ID": 303782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8354835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222086", "Detail": { "ID": 222086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9671725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242302", "Detail": { "ID": 242302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0071332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224369", "Detail": { "ID": 224369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7018431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308257", "Detail": { "ID": 308257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.047819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272715", "Detail": { "ID": 272715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3472938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244332", "Detail": { "ID": 244332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5501226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314348", "Detail": { "ID": 314348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6358311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251365", "Detail": { "ID": 251365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4604242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275987", "Detail": { "ID": 275987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4055856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256578", "Detail": { "ID": 256578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7887419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282816", "Detail": { "ID": 282816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4352972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254608", "Detail": { "ID": 254608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2635478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278264", "Detail": { "ID": 278264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2047219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325099", "Detail": { "ID": 325099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2561154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232344", "Detail": { "ID": 232344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8507855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312241", "Detail": { "ID": 312241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.116646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231522", "Detail": { "ID": 231522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.604233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267890", "Detail": { "ID": 267890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0468921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314774", "Detail": { "ID": 314774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.65493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296765", "Detail": { "ID": 296765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8729892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319395", "Detail": { "ID": 319395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9240554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305998", "Detail": { "ID": 305998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3546131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309032", "Detail": { "ID": 309032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0890682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268539", "Detail": { "ID": 268539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2715262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293166", "Detail": { "ID": 293166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5744149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262084", "Detail": { "ID": 262084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3908875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268886", "Detail": { "ID": 268886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2873386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307773", "Detail": { "ID": 307773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8442986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280891", "Detail": { "ID": 280891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7867813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245390", "Detail": { "ID": 245390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8327849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304908", "Detail": { "ID": 304908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0639155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303251", "Detail": { "ID": 303251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8067966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297023", "Detail": { "ID": 297023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.884391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224808", "Detail": { "ID": 224808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7208093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237992", "Detail": { "ID": 237992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2349058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296883", "Detail": { "ID": 296883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8781464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321319", "Detail": { "ID": 321319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4230605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315577", "Detail": { "ID": 315577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9180028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238071", "Detail": { "ID": 238071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2383038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293510", "Detail": { "ID": 293510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8484781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233637", "Detail": { "ID": 233637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1396031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312481", "Detail": { "ID": 312481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1297594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286869", "Detail": { "ID": 286869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6043204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226508", "Detail": { "ID": 226508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2344484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265215", "Detail": { "ID": 265215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4290966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284235", "Detail": { "ID": 284235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0172941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259068", "Detail": { "ID": 259068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3403507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318551", "Detail": { "ID": 318551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6630526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255621", "Detail": { "ID": 255621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5392297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295151", "Detail": { "ID": 295151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1946769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236808", "Detail": { "ID": 236808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9410164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256480", "Detail": { "ID": 256480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7842987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230013", "Detail": { "ID": 230013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1125256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290541", "Detail": { "ID": 290541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7613488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310004", "Detail": { "ID": 310004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3602885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247620", "Detail": { "ID": 247620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4212584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299178", "Detail": { "ID": 299178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3914353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235273", "Detail": { "ID": 235273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6633435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275862", "Detail": { "ID": 275862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3941607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274018", "Detail": { "ID": 274018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.650809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316510", "Detail": { "ID": 316510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1510927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325884", "Detail": { "ID": 325884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.525607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241654", "Detail": { "ID": 241654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7741042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287070", "Detail": { "ID": 287070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6129346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248433", "Detail": { "ID": 248433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6457661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289173", "Detail": { "ID": 289173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1806117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222964", "Detail": { "ID": 222964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2228934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306842", "Detail": { "ID": 306842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5760694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240621", "Detail": { "ID": 240621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3752146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284323", "Detail": { "ID": 284323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0213982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232990", "Detail": { "ID": 232990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8853611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246248", "Detail": { "ID": 246248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.120502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310184", "Detail": { "ID": 310184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2068, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 46, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657.1", "ID": 6812 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3681619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259837", "Detail": { "ID": 259837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6321629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318351", "Detail": { "ID": 318351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6538628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249954", "Detail": { "ID": 249954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9571054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320497", "Detail": { "ID": 320497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1689648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230258", "Detail": { "ID": 230258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.315045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281438", "Detail": { "ID": 281438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.142808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263626", "Detail": { "ID": 263626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8977496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289946", "Detail": { "ID": 289946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4661399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228006", "Detail": { "ID": 228006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5803112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270498", "Detail": { "ID": 270498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8103719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323290", "Detail": { "ID": 323290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9433717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296552", "Detail": { "ID": 296552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.85397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242491", "Detail": { "ID": 242491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0155678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236495", "Detail": { "ID": 236495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9273376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300980", "Detail": { "ID": 300980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0271688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261147", "Detail": { "ID": 261147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1138606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326784", "Detail": { "ID": 326784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.779931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278623", "Detail": { "ID": 278623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2272311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264772", "Detail": { "ID": 264772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1482057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249116", "Detail": { "ID": 249116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.684579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293678", "Detail": { "ID": 293678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8642568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287719", "Detail": { "ID": 287719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8833081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233463", "Detail": { "ID": 233463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1316223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243391", "Detail": { "ID": 243391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2957219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253292", "Detail": { "ID": 253292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9900266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321515", "Detail": { "ID": 321515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4393918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300720", "Detail": { "ID": 300720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0159609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273387", "Detail": { "ID": 273387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6179065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263225", "Detail": { "ID": 263225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8801692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM285701", "Detail": { "ID": 285701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3408678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298826", "Detail": { "ID": 298826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3738077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230583", "Detail": { "ID": 230583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3366597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287124", "Detail": { "ID": 287124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6202253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219902", "Detail": { "ID": 219902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3195909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238901", "Detail": { "ID": 238901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4738668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225918", "Detail": { "ID": 225918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9960362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322147", "Detail": { "ID": 322147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.473348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM290278", "Detail": { "ID": 290278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.739943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228838", "Detail": { "ID": 228838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8163965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304649", "Detail": { "ID": 304649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0474499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258327", "Detail": { "ID": 258327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3023487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272025", "Detail": { "ID": 272025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1080997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279820", "Detail": { "ID": 279820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5242067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266860", "Detail": { "ID": 266860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7651397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253596", "Detail": { "ID": 253596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0032574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221443", "Detail": { "ID": 221443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9329271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220598", "Detail": { "ID": 220598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6482605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240324", "Detail": { "ID": 240324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3548682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266561", "Detail": { "ID": 266561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7464538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324187", "Detail": { "ID": 324187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9959279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260218", "Detail": { "ID": 260218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0670476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246616", "Detail": { "ID": 246616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1459259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275646", "Detail": { "ID": 275646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3844782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303735", "Detail": { "ID": 303735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8280677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222085", "Detail": { "ID": 222085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.967132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242301", "Detail": { "ID": 242301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0070899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224368", "Detail": { "ID": 224368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7018011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308256", "Detail": { "ID": 308256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.047759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272716", "Detail": { "ID": 272716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3473345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244333", "Detail": { "ID": 244333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5501644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314349", "Detail": { "ID": 314349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6358728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251364", "Detail": { "ID": 251364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4603807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275986", "Detail": { "ID": 275986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4055441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256577", "Detail": { "ID": 256577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7887013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282817", "Detail": { "ID": 282817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4353376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254609", "Detail": { "ID": 254609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2635896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278263", "Detail": { "ID": 278263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2046811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325098", "Detail": { "ID": 325098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2560746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232349", "Detail": { "ID": 232349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8509942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312240", "Detail": { "ID": 312240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1166033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231521", "Detail": { "ID": 231521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6041925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267889", "Detail": { "ID": 267889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0468499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314775", "Detail": { "ID": 314775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6549786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296766", "Detail": { "ID": 296766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8730291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319396", "Detail": { "ID": 319396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9240973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305997", "Detail": { "ID": 305997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.35457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309142", "Detail": { "ID": 309142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0938111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268540", "Detail": { "ID": 268540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.271567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293165", "Detail": { "ID": 293165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5743744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262083", "Detail": { "ID": 262083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3908472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268885", "Detail": { "ID": 268885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2872981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307668", "Detail": { "ID": 307668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8397526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280890", "Detail": { "ID": 280890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.786741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245389", "Detail": { "ID": 245389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8327427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304909", "Detail": { "ID": 304909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.063957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303241", "Detail": { "ID": 303241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8063551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM297029", "Detail": { "ID": 297029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8846599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224809", "Detail": { "ID": 224809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7208498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237993", "Detail": { "ID": 237993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2349482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296884", "Detail": { "ID": 296884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8781862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321318", "Detail": { "ID": 321318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4230197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315576", "Detail": { "ID": 315576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9179611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238072", "Detail": { "ID": 238072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2383453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293509", "Detail": { "ID": 293509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.848437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233608", "Detail": { "ID": 233608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.138326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312480", "Detail": { "ID": 312480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1297181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM287625", "Detail": { "ID": 287625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.879324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226509", "Detail": { "ID": 226509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2344892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265183", "Detail": { "ID": 265183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1720721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284236", "Detail": { "ID": 284236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0173357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259069", "Detail": { "ID": 259069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3403932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318550", "Detail": { "ID": 318550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6630122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255620", "Detail": { "ID": 255620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5391887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295141", "Detail": { "ID": 295141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1941364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236809", "Detail": { "ID": 236809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9410574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256820", "Detail": { "ID": 256820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8112681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230014", "Detail": { "ID": 230014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1125663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290493", "Detail": { "ID": 290493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7494634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310005", "Detail": { "ID": 310005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3603295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247621", "Detail": { "ID": 247621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4212986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299177", "Detail": { "ID": 299177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.391387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235272", "Detail": { "ID": 235272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6633022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275863", "Detail": { "ID": 275863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.394202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274017", "Detail": { "ID": 274017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6507685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316511", "Detail": { "ID": 316511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1511343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325885", "Detail": { "ID": 325885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5256482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241655", "Detail": { "ID": 241655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7741626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287071", "Detail": { "ID": 287071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6129767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248434", "Detail": { "ID": 248434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6458074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289172", "Detail": { "ID": 289172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1805701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222965", "Detail": { "ID": 222965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2229341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306848", "Detail": { "ID": 306848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5763158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240620", "Detail": { "ID": 240620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3751718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284322", "Detail": { "ID": 284322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0213578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232989", "Detail": { "ID": 232989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8853201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246247", "Detail": { "ID": 246247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1204602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM310185", "Detail": { "ID": 310185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2069, "AgendaID": 3047, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Immediate Action at the Haudagain Roundabout", "Reference": "S4M-06657", "ID": 6782 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3683021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259250", "Detail": { "ID": 259250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6007674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318723", "Detail": { "ID": 318723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6706581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250224", "Detail": { "ID": 250224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1799689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM321074", "Detail": { "ID": 321074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2011404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228435", "Detail": { "ID": 228435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7989019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281122", "Detail": { "ID": 281122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8069186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263052", "Detail": { "ID": 263052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6346844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288125", "Detail": { "ID": 288125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9079361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227455", "Detail": { "ID": 227455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5508972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269311", "Detail": { "ID": 269311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5420572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322478", "Detail": { "ID": 322478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6903535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295897", "Detail": { "ID": 295897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5405065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243106", "Detail": { "ID": 243106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0491554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227062", "Detail": { "ID": 227062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2658597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301033", "Detail": { "ID": 301033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0296918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238401", "Detail": { "ID": 238401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4449583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4984E13P25VM316375", "Detail": { "ID": 316375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4984, "ParliamentaryName": "Buchanan, Cameron", "DisplayName": "Cameron Buchanan", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1451634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326989", "Detail": { "ID": 326989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7887932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277548", "Detail": { "ID": 277548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9580622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263938", "Detail": { "ID": 263938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9172549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250964", "Detail": { "ID": 250964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2211375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294803", "Detail": { "ID": 294803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1790311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285403", "Detail": { "ID": 285403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3215228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231339", "Detail": { "ID": 231339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5906577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243612", "Detail": { "ID": 243612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3124108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254378", "Detail": { "ID": 254378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2531092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323440", "Detail": { "ID": 323440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9562463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300644", "Detail": { "ID": 300644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.007466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273100", "Detail": { "ID": 273100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3695867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262653", "Detail": { "ID": 262653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6111046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281772", "Detail": { "ID": 281772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1569595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298508", "Detail": { "ID": 298508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.349153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285047", "Detail": { "ID": 285047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.059154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219611", "Detail": { "ID": 219611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.306844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238203", "Detail": { "ID": 238203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4360423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226691", "Detail": { "ID": 226691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2424396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321982", "Detail": { "ID": 321982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4598069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292652", "Detail": { "ID": 292652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5520131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227639", "Detail": { "ID": 227639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5588875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304597", "Detail": { "ID": 304597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0452269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257902", "Detail": { "ID": 257902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0825208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271179", "Detail": { "ID": 271179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.845853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274350", "Detail": { "ID": 274350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.102223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266089", "Detail": { "ID": 266089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4738713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250719", "Detail": { "ID": 250719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2106594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221145", "Detail": { "ID": 221145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6770032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226453", "Detail": { "ID": 226453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2320636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239708", "Detail": { "ID": 239708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7555165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253208", "Detail": { "ID": 253208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9860487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324811", "Detail": { "ID": 324811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2388248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260949", "Detail": { "ID": 260949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1049221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246045", "Detail": { "ID": 246045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8698336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273563", "Detail": { "ID": 273563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6257995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5556E30P111VM301974", "Detail": { "ID": 301974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5556, "ParliamentaryName": "Hilton, Cara", "DisplayName": "Cara Hilton", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2915415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303682", "Detail": { "ID": 303682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8258211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223169", "Detail": { "ID": 223169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2315868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245680", "Detail": { "ID": 245680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8538607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223349", "Detail": { "ID": 223349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4540563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308090", "Detail": { "ID": 308090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8642788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272456", "Detail": { "ID": 272456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3361131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245117", "Detail": { "ID": 245117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5927712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315288", "Detail": { "ID": 315288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.90514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247395", "Detail": { "ID": 247395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4019742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275061", "Detail": { "ID": 275061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1395016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255088", "Detail": { "ID": 255088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2968207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277338", "Detail": { "ID": 277338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9439423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254035", "Detail": { "ID": 254035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0317181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278835", "Detail": { "ID": 278835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.236294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325321", "Detail": { "ID": 325321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4936615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231937", "Detail": { "ID": 231937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6222011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311782", "Detail": { "ID": 311782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.894058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233181", "Detail": { "ID": 233181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9003592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267568", "Detail": { "ID": 267568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0254916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313070", "Detail": { "ID": 313070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1623373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294409", "Detail": { "ID": 294409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1370932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319231", "Detail": { "ID": 319231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9111396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306197", "Detail": { "ID": 306197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5415683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310344", "Detail": { "ID": 310344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5664682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268036", "Detail": { "ID": 268036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0532228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293017", "Detail": { "ID": 293017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5680621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271494", "Detail": { "ID": 271494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0782382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269460", "Detail": { "ID": 269460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5485246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307251", "Detail": { "ID": 307251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8211749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E230P376VM280214", "Detail": { "ID": 280214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7509854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279125", "Detail": { "ID": 279125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2541137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260403", "Detail": { "ID": 260403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0753729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299310", "Detail": { "ID": 299310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6919556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301802", "Detail": { "ID": 301802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2838714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300315", "Detail": { "ID": 300315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9928632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224202", "Detail": { "ID": 224202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4969681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305670", "Detail": { "ID": 305670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.334352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320039", "Detail": { "ID": 320039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9587699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315795", "Detail": { "ID": 315795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9273464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237175", "Detail": { "ID": 237175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9689904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288869", "Detail": { "ID": 288869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1618872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234206", "Detail": { "ID": 234206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3667357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312898", "Detail": { "ID": 312898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1546295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261315", "Detail": { "ID": 261315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3520864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225592", "Detail": { "ID": 225592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9819911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265647", "Detail": { "ID": 265647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4482365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284161", "Detail": { "ID": 284161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7456396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258659", "Detail": { "ID": 258659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3170316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317262", "Detail": { "ID": 317262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4108503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256186", "Detail": { "ID": 256186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5742951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293372", "Detail": { "ID": 293372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8421837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235902", "Detail": { "ID": 235902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6978493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255907", "Detail": { "ID": 255907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5620997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228640", "Detail": { "ID": 228640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8078275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289511", "Detail": { "ID": 289511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4404045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311569", "Detail": { "ID": 311569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.884528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246862", "Detail": { "ID": 246862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1565879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297625", "Detail": { "ID": 297625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1082291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233810", "Detail": { "ID": 233810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1473018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274981", "Detail": { "ID": 274981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1359682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270044", "Detail": { "ID": 270044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5791223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317753", "Detail": { "ID": 317753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4358882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326509", "Detail": { "ID": 326509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7677492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241346", "Detail": { "ID": 241346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.753977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291092", "Detail": { "ID": 291092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7851845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248154", "Detail": { "ID": 248154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4452835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290016", "Detail": { "ID": 290016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4691541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222682", "Detail": { "ID": 222682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1994018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240929", "Detail": { "ID": 240929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3884849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283711", "Detail": { "ID": 283711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7199703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231072", "Detail": { "ID": 231072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3644092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247284", "Detail": { "ID": 247284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3969729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308900", "Detail": { "ID": 308900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2127, "AgendaID": 2389, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 74, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution", "Reference": "S4M-06623", "ID": 6746 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-11-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0829225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259138", "Detail": { "ID": 259138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3433528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319593", "Detail": { "ID": 319593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9329648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249497", "Detail": { "ID": 249497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9294134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320868", "Detail": { "ID": 320868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.185153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227874", "Detail": { "ID": 227874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5693742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280875", "Detail": { "ID": 280875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7861071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262793", "Detail": { "ID": 262793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6170867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288943", "Detail": { "ID": 288943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1650279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229861", "Detail": { "ID": 229861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.100572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269733", "Detail": { "ID": 269733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5606391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322576", "Detail": { "ID": 322576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6946458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295330", "Detail": { "ID": 295330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5074364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243008", "Detail": { "ID": 243008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0449634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235107", "Detail": { "ID": 235107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4196681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302426", "Detail": { "ID": 302426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.523937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244210", "Detail": { "ID": 244210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.544712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327079", "Detail": { "ID": 327079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7979473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277132", "Detail": { "ID": 277132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7024715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264042", "Detail": { "ID": 264042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9217091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248667", "Detail": { "ID": 248667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6646696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294904", "Detail": { "ID": 294904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1837398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285297", "Detail": { "ID": 285297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3169236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230774", "Detail": { "ID": 230774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3449586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243710", "Detail": { "ID": 243710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3165265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254820", "Detail": { "ID": 254820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2851436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323686", "Detail": { "ID": 323686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9675247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290918", "Detail": { "ID": 290918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7776799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272995", "Detail": { "ID": 272995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3646961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262357", "Detail": { "ID": 262357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.597984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281864", "Detail": { "ID": 281864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1608933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298263", "Detail": { "ID": 298263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3382298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231189", "Detail": { "ID": 231189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3696715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284984", "Detail": { "ID": 284984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0562141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219497", "Detail": { "ID": 219497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3018394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238288", "Detail": { "ID": 238288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4399297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225152", "Detail": { "ID": 225152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7466832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321884", "Detail": { "ID": 321884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4554779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292757", "Detail": { "ID": 292757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5568437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227222", "Detail": { "ID": 227222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5361249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313248", "Detail": { "ID": 313248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3844767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257785", "Detail": { "ID": 257785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.077505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271117", "Detail": { "ID": 271117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8431977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278002", "Detail": { "ID": 278002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9827771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287321", "Detail": { "ID": 287321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8591487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250602", "Detail": { "ID": 250602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1966488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221065", "Detail": { "ID": 221065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.673576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220147", "Detail": { "ID": 220147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3363736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252447", "Detail": { "ID": 252447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7295486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253771", "Detail": { "ID": 253771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0202186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324719", "Detail": { "ID": 324719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2349703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259614", "Detail": { "ID": 259614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6170506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239455", "Detail": { "ID": 239455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7375381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273668", "Detail": { "ID": 273668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6302602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304059", "Detail": { "ID": 304059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8476029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221629", "Detail": { "ID": 221629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9409688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241860", "Detail": { "ID": 241860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7831572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223420", "Detail": { "ID": 223420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4571094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307846", "Detail": { "ID": 307846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8534473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272337", "Detail": { "ID": 272337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3310059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245019", "Detail": { "ID": 245019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5885247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315187", "Detail": { "ID": 315187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6780734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247506", "Detail": { "ID": 247506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4067444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275123", "Detail": { "ID": 275123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1425831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255510", "Detail": { "ID": 255510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5344262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276966", "Detail": { "ID": 276966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.689016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253455", "Detail": { "ID": 253455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.997168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276732", "Detail": { "ID": 276732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6787379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325412", "Detail": { "ID": 325412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4975724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233251", "Detail": { "ID": 233251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1159644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311691", "Detail": { "ID": 311691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.890111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229682", "Detail": { "ID": 229682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0921651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267473", "Detail": { "ID": 267473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0213552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313470", "Detail": { "ID": 313470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3967478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294965", "Detail": { "ID": 294965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1863753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319133", "Detail": { "ID": 319133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6938651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306300", "Detail": { "ID": 306300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5461221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310760", "Detail": { "ID": 310760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5848788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268131", "Detail": { "ID": 268131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0575174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286444", "Detail": { "ID": 286444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5794698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258534", "Detail": { "ID": 258534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.311395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263780", "Detail": { "ID": 263780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9044187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308728", "Detail": { "ID": 308728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0684027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279541", "Detail": { "ID": 279541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5121281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260501", "Detail": { "ID": 260501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0796117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299555", "Detail": { "ID": 299555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7024937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306760", "Detail": { "ID": 306760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5662344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300575", "Detail": { "ID": 300575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0044957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223969", "Detail": { "ID": 223969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4863757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237915", "Detail": { "ID": 237915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2315616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305568", "Detail": { "ID": 305568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3299853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320293", "Detail": { "ID": 320293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1535167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315895", "Detail": { "ID": 315895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9318522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236761", "Detail": { "ID": 236761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9389316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289744", "Detail": { "ID": 289744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4572724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234489", "Detail": { "ID": 234489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3864737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313155", "Detail": { "ID": 313155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1660255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289362", "Detail": { "ID": 289362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4339848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225367", "Detail": { "ID": 225367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9716722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265777", "Detail": { "ID": 265777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.454035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283218", "Detail": { "ID": 283218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6909566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252033", "Detail": { "ID": 252033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4996738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317359", "Detail": { "ID": 317359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4187176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254249", "Detail": { "ID": 254249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2473991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296264", "Detail": { "ID": 296264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8411548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235476", "Detail": { "ID": 235476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6794878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257679", "Detail": { "ID": 257679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0668899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228562", "Detail": { "ID": 228562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8044595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291573", "Detail": { "ID": 291573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1331795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311156", "Detail": { "ID": 311156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6081114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246785", "Detail": { "ID": 246785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.153317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298037", "Detail": { "ID": 298037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1355573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234067", "Detail": { "ID": 234067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1652089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274686", "Detail": { "ID": 274686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269639", "Detail": { "ID": 269639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5565666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317497", "Detail": { "ID": 317497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4249569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326418", "Detail": { "ID": 326418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7577228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241268", "Detail": { "ID": 241268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7506216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290378", "Detail": { "ID": 290378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.744355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248042", "Detail": { "ID": 248042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4392568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287493", "Detail": { "ID": 287493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8733266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222611", "Detail": { "ID": 222611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.196387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306953", "Detail": { "ID": 306953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5809899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239856", "Detail": { "ID": 239856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7619759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283773", "Detail": { "ID": 283773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7228546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231787", "Detail": { "ID": 231787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6155169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237362", "Detail": { "ID": 237362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2009174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308991", "Detail": { "ID": 308991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2067, "AgendaID": 2065, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 71, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Electricity Market Reform", "Reference": "S4M-06582.1", "ID": 6724 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0868153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259201", "Detail": { "ID": 259201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5985518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319536", "Detail": { "ID": 319536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.930189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250270", "Detail": { "ID": 250270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1819668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4965E144P365VM320895", "Detail": { "ID": 320895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4965, "ParliamentaryName": "Allard, Christian", "DisplayName": "Christian Allard", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1862986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228402", "Detail": { "ID": 228402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7974616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281099", "Detail": { "ID": 281099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8059471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263046", "Detail": { "ID": 263046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6344355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288995", "Detail": { "ID": 288995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1675264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230538", "Detail": { "ID": 230538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3346832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269670", "Detail": { "ID": 269670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5579374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322505", "Detail": { "ID": 322505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6915185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295891", "Detail": { "ID": 295891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5402659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243063", "Detail": { "ID": 243063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0473197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227076", "Detail": { "ID": 227076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2664644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303081", "Detail": { "ID": 303081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5577824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238407", "Detail": { "ID": 238407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4452043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327032", "Detail": { "ID": 327032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7906541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277542", "Detail": { "ID": 277542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9578193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263944", "Detail": { "ID": 263944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9175189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250986", "Detail": { "ID": 250986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2220607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294848", "Detail": { "ID": 294848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1809698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285397", "Detail": { "ID": 285397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3212736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231333", "Detail": { "ID": 231333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.590414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243655", "Detail": { "ID": 243655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3142206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254447", "Detail": { "ID": 254447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2564978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323484", "Detail": { "ID": 323484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9583443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300694", "Detail": { "ID": 300694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0095888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273094", "Detail": { "ID": 273094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3693229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262606", "Detail": { "ID": 262606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6091211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281794", "Detail": { "ID": 281794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1578803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298487", "Detail": { "ID": 298487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3482519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231141", "Detail": { "ID": 231141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3673546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284923", "Detail": { "ID": 284923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.053506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219589", "Detail": { "ID": 219589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3058899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238227", "Detail": { "ID": 238227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4372889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226697", "Detail": { "ID": 226697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2426854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321955", "Detail": { "ID": 321955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4586393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292658", "Detail": { "ID": 292658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5522808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227617", "Detail": { "ID": 227617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.557823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313308", "Detail": { "ID": 313308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3897098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257856", "Detail": { "ID": 257856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0805547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271055", "Detail": { "ID": 271055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8405805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274374", "Detail": { "ID": 274374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1033109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287383", "Detail": { "ID": 287383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.861857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250673", "Detail": { "ID": 250673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2085971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221139", "Detail": { "ID": 221139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6767385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226475", "Detail": { "ID": 226475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2330175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252811", "Detail": { "ID": 252811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7542726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253233", "Detail": { "ID": 253233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9872194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324767", "Detail": { "ID": 324767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2369816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261615", "Detail": { "ID": 261615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3651029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239516", "Detail": { "ID": 239516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7471435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273569", "Detail": { "ID": 273569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6260442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303999", "Detail": { "ID": 303999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8450573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223175", "Detail": { "ID": 223175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2318585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245686", "Detail": { "ID": 245686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8541017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223363", "Detail": { "ID": 223363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4546492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307916", "Detail": { "ID": 307916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8564626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272408", "Detail": { "ID": 272408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3340457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245074", "Detail": { "ID": 245074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5908892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315243", "Detail": { "ID": 315243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9001046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247445", "Detail": { "ID": 247445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4041253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275495", "Detail": { "ID": 275495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3777309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255447", "Detail": { "ID": 255447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5317337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276904", "Detail": { "ID": 276904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6860979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253517", "Detail": { "ID": 253517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.999845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279190", "Detail": { "ID": 279190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2569041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325364", "Detail": { "ID": 325364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4955082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233301", "Detail": { "ID": 233301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1181562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311760", "Detail": { "ID": 311760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8930797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233203", "Detail": { "ID": 233203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.113776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267544", "Detail": { "ID": 267544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0244268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313400", "Detail": { "ID": 313400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3937427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294430", "Detail": { "ID": 294430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1379798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319204", "Detail": { "ID": 319204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9097419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306243", "Detail": { "ID": 306243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.543693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310358", "Detail": { "ID": 310358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5670862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268060", "Detail": { "ID": 268060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0542784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292996", "Detail": { "ID": 292996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.567164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271854", "Detail": { "ID": 271854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0942953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269818", "Detail": { "ID": 269818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5642486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307237", "Detail": { "ID": 307237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8205494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279131", "Detail": { "ID": 279131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2543601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260447", "Detail": { "ID": 260447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0772728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299331", "Detail": { "ID": 299331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6928623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301795", "Detail": { "ID": 301795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2835665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300322", "Detail": { "ID": 300322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9931929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224196", "Detail": { "ID": 224196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4967201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237941", "Detail": { "ID": 237941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2326935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305624", "Detail": { "ID": 305624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.33238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320066", "Detail": { "ID": 320066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9601903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315839", "Detail": { "ID": 315839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.929284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237169", "Detail": { "ID": 237169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9687313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288875", "Detail": { "ID": 288875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1621288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234275", "Detail": { "ID": 234275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3702492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313099", "Detail": { "ID": 313099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1636068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261309", "Detail": { "ID": 261309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3518253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225578", "Detail": { "ID": 225578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9813757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265715", "Detail": { "ID": 265715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4512256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284211", "Detail": { "ID": 284211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0162547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252123", "Detail": { "ID": 252123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5035829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317288", "Detail": { "ID": 317288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4119691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256691", "Detail": { "ID": 256691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7935689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293366", "Detail": { "ID": 293366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8419195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235880", "Detail": { "ID": 235880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6969128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258050", "Detail": { "ID": 258050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0892087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228634", "Detail": { "ID": 228634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8075617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291046", "Detail": { "ID": 291046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7831563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311524", "Detail": { "ID": 311524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8825771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246856", "Detail": { "ID": 246856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1563273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297631", "Detail": { "ID": 297631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1084921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233816", "Detail": { "ID": 233816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1475727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274933", "Detail": { "ID": 274933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1283048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270020", "Detail": { "ID": 270020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5780914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317709", "Detail": { "ID": 317709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4340289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326466", "Detail": { "ID": 326466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7659145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241340", "Detail": { "ID": 241340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7537134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290434", "Detail": { "ID": 290434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7469317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248132", "Detail": { "ID": 248132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4440792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289198", "Detail": { "ID": 289198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4263691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222668", "Detail": { "ID": 222668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1988114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306889", "Detail": { "ID": 306889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5779425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240935", "Detail": { "ID": 240935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3887317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283988", "Detail": { "ID": 283988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7321348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231719", "Detail": { "ID": 231719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6126241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247306", "Detail": { "ID": 247306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3979095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308921", "Detail": { "ID": 308921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2066, "AgendaID": 2054, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 97, "VoteAgainst": 12, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06545", "ID": 6672 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY3", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0838292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259835", "Detail": { "ID": 259835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6320782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318353", "Detail": { "ID": 318353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6539447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249956", "Detail": { "ID": 249956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9571858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230256", "Detail": { "ID": 230256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3149611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281725", "Detail": { "ID": 281725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1549808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263624", "Detail": { "ID": 263624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8976672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289948", "Detail": { "ID": 289948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4662234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228004", "Detail": { "ID": 228004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5801996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270500", "Detail": { "ID": 270500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8104564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322867", "Detail": { "ID": 322867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7069685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296550", "Detail": { "ID": 296550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8538867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242509", "Detail": { "ID": 242509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0234055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236497", "Detail": { "ID": 236497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.927421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300470", "Detail": { "ID": 300470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.999572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261149", "Detail": { "ID": 261149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1139446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326787", "Detail": { "ID": 326787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.780055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278621", "Detail": { "ID": 278621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2271471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264774", "Detail": { "ID": 264774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1482873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249118", "Detail": { "ID": 249118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6846619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293660", "Detail": { "ID": 293660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8634851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287717", "Detail": { "ID": 287717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8832264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233461", "Detail": { "ID": 233461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.131539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243372", "Detail": { "ID": 243372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2948808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253325", "Detail": { "ID": 253325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.991523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321518", "Detail": { "ID": 321518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4395358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300721", "Detail": { "ID": 300721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0160032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273385", "Detail": { "ID": 273385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6178248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263223", "Detail": { "ID": 263223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8800856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282157", "Detail": { "ID": 282157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1784638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299266", "Detail": { "ID": 299266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6900674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230585", "Detail": { "ID": 230585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3367437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287122", "Detail": { "ID": 287122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6201233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219900", "Detail": { "ID": 219900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.319508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238903", "Detail": { "ID": 238903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4739568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225920", "Detail": { "ID": 225920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9961194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322428", "Detail": { "ID": 322428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6882067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291804", "Detail": { "ID": 291804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1430336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228836", "Detail": { "ID": 228836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8163134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304713", "Detail": { "ID": 304713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0502025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258325", "Detail": { "ID": 258325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3022648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272023", "Detail": { "ID": 272023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1080168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278913", "Detail": { "ID": 278913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2396561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266827", "Detail": { "ID": 266827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7581915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253594", "Detail": { "ID": 253594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0031748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221441", "Detail": { "ID": 221441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9328444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220600", "Detail": { "ID": 220600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.648361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240136", "Detail": { "ID": 240136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7805025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266888", "Detail": { "ID": 266888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7663579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324184", "Detail": { "ID": 324184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.995804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260220", "Detail": { "ID": 260220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0671352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246614", "Detail": { "ID": 246614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1458455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275648", "Detail": { "ID": 275648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.38456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303783", "Detail": { "ID": 303783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8355253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222087", "Detail": { "ID": 222087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.967238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242303", "Detail": { "ID": 242303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0071754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224370", "Detail": { "ID": 224370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7018858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308697", "Detail": { "ID": 308697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0670521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272714", "Detail": { "ID": 272714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3472515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244351", "Detail": { "ID": 244351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5509563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314347", "Detail": { "ID": 314347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6357899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251366", "Detail": { "ID": 251366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4604661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275988", "Detail": { "ID": 275988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4056277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256579", "Detail": { "ID": 256579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7887832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282815", "Detail": { "ID": 282815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4352562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254607", "Detail": { "ID": 254607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2635069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278265", "Detail": { "ID": 278265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2047636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325101", "Detail": { "ID": 325101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2561986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232343", "Detail": { "ID": 232343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8507443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313023", "Detail": { "ID": 313023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1603002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231523", "Detail": { "ID": 231523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6042928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267728", "Detail": { "ID": 267728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0324444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314178", "Detail": { "ID": 314178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.433113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296028", "Detail": { "ID": 296028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5460515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319989", "Detail": { "ID": 319989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9564561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305978", "Detail": { "ID": 305978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3537367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309808", "Detail": { "ID": 309808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3458279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268712", "Detail": { "ID": 268712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2794321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294365", "Detail": { "ID": 294365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1352121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262085", "Detail": { "ID": 262085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3909289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268887", "Detail": { "ID": 268887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2873797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307471", "Detail": { "ID": 307471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8309506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282634", "Detail": { "ID": 282634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.42759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280892", "Detail": { "ID": 280892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.786823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245371", "Detail": { "ID": 245371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8319826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299847", "Detail": { "ID": 299847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7252173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302787", "Detail": { "ID": 302787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5451638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300088", "Detail": { "ID": 300088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7358078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224807", "Detail": { "ID": 224807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7207679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237991", "Detail": { "ID": 237991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2348473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296902", "Detail": { "ID": 296902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8789499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320739", "Detail": { "ID": 320739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1793823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315578", "Detail": { "ID": 315578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9180451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238070", "Detail": { "ID": 238070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2382624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293511", "Detail": { "ID": 293511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8485196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233638", "Detail": { "ID": 233638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1396455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312483", "Detail": { "ID": 312483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1298434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286867", "Detail": { "ID": 286867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6042396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226507", "Detail": { "ID": 226507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2344063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265216", "Detail": { "ID": 265216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4291393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284237", "Detail": { "ID": 284237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0173782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259067", "Detail": { "ID": 259067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3403024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317958", "Detail": { "ID": 317958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4508467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255622", "Detail": { "ID": 255622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5392709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294531", "Detail": { "ID": 294531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1424341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236807", "Detail": { "ID": 236807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9409754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256479", "Detail": { "ID": 256479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7842564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230012", "Detail": { "ID": 230012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1124845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290542", "Detail": { "ID": 290542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7614229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310024", "Detail": { "ID": 310024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3611551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247619", "Detail": { "ID": 247619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4212166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299179", "Detail": { "ID": 299179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3914901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235274", "Detail": { "ID": 235274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6633858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275861", "Detail": { "ID": 275861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3941189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274305", "Detail": { "ID": 274305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0948463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316509", "Detail": { "ID": 316509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1510496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325882", "Detail": { "ID": 325882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5255245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241653", "Detail": { "ID": 241653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7740634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287865", "Detail": { "ID": 287865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8898759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248432", "Detail": { "ID": 248432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6457246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289171", "Detail": { "ID": 289171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1805287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222963", "Detail": { "ID": 222963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2228529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306850", "Detail": { "ID": 306850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.576416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240622", "Detail": { "ID": 240622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3752561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284324", "Detail": { "ID": 284324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0214394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232991", "Detail": { "ID": 232991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8854033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246249", "Detail": { "ID": 246249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1205632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309438", "Detail": { "ID": 309438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2065, "AgendaID": 2434, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 44, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Young People, Supporting Scotland’s Economy Today and Tomorrow", "Reference": "S4M-06492.2", "ID": 6641 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3293503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259122", "Detail": { "ID": 259122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3426704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319606", "Detail": { "ID": 319606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.933522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249514", "Detail": { "ID": 249514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9301518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227862", "Detail": { "ID": 227862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.568865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280863", "Detail": { "ID": 280863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7856018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263008", "Detail": { "ID": 263008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6326892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288933", "Detail": { "ID": 288933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1646025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227431", "Detail": { "ID": 227431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5498858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269749", "Detail": { "ID": 269749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5613258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322496", "Detail": { "ID": 322496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6911317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295391", "Detail": { "ID": 295391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5101763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242995", "Detail": { "ID": 242995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0444128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235122", "Detail": { "ID": 235122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4203323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301009", "Detail": { "ID": 301009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0284069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238445", "Detail": { "ID": 238445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4468533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327101", "Detail": { "ID": 327101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7989016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277503", "Detail": { "ID": 277503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9561448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263982", "Detail": { "ID": 263982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9191338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248597", "Detail": { "ID": 248597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6531493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294917", "Detail": { "ID": 294917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1842984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285358", "Detail": { "ID": 285358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3195807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231296", "Detail": { "ID": 231296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5888401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243723", "Detail": { "ID": 243723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3170661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254403", "Detail": { "ID": 254403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2544268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323708", "Detail": { "ID": 323708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9684808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290849", "Detail": { "ID": 290849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7747888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273055", "Detail": { "ID": 273055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3676288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262582", "Detail": { "ID": 262582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6080864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281876", "Detail": { "ID": 281876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1614016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298250", "Detail": { "ID": 298250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3376549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231123", "Detail": { "ID": 231123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3666028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285000", "Detail": { "ID": 285000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0569113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219565", "Detail": { "ID": 219565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3048475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238458", "Detail": { "ID": 238458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4474778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225168", "Detail": { "ID": 225168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.747412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321964", "Detail": { "ID": 321964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4590126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292312", "Detail": { "ID": 292312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5283454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227598", "Detail": { "ID": 227598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5570117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304572", "Detail": { "ID": 304572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0441794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257768", "Detail": { "ID": 257768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.076787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271133", "Detail": { "ID": 271133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8438995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278013", "Detail": { "ID": 278013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9832531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266065", "Detail": { "ID": 266065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4728491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250585", "Detail": { "ID": 250585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1959102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221049", "Detail": { "ID": 221049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6728788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220078", "Detail": { "ID": 220078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.333382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239684", "Detail": { "ID": 239684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7545083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253782", "Detail": { "ID": 253782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0206772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324697", "Detail": { "ID": 324697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2340464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259388", "Detail": { "ID": 259388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6069647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239439", "Detail": { "ID": 239439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7368558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273608", "Detail": { "ID": 273608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6277151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303706", "Detail": { "ID": 303706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8268407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221646", "Detail": { "ID": 221646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9417099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241876", "Detail": { "ID": 241876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7838279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223435", "Detail": { "ID": 223435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4578522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307833", "Detail": { "ID": 307833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8528624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272321", "Detail": { "ID": 272321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.330282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245006", "Detail": { "ID": 245006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.587972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315174", "Detail": { "ID": 315174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6775196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247522", "Detail": { "ID": 247522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4074384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275107", "Detail": { "ID": 275107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1418728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255526", "Detail": { "ID": 255526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5351032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276982", "Detail": { "ID": 276982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6896904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253439", "Detail": { "ID": 253439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9964707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276351", "Detail": { "ID": 276351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6557861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325434", "Detail": { "ID": 325434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5062178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231914", "Detail": { "ID": 231914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6212025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311678", "Detail": { "ID": 311678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8895524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229613", "Detail": { "ID": 229613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0892509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267462", "Detail": { "ID": 267462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0208835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313483", "Detail": { "ID": 313483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.397325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294977", "Detail": { "ID": 294977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1868846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319213", "Detail": { "ID": 319213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9103215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306313", "Detail": { "ID": 306313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5466745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310336", "Detail": { "ID": 310336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5661203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268142", "Detail": { "ID": 268142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0580047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286432", "Detail": { "ID": 286432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5789131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258550", "Detail": { "ID": 258550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3120779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263556", "Detail": { "ID": 263556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8944917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307259", "Detail": { "ID": 307259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8215063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280149", "Detail": { "ID": 280149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.543538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279170", "Detail": { "ID": 279170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2560462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260981", "Detail": { "ID": 260981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1062955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299568", "Detail": { "ID": 299568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.70305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301833", "Detail": { "ID": 301833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2852243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300284", "Detail": { "ID": 300284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9913348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223952", "Detail": { "ID": 223952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4856524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237908", "Detail": { "ID": 237908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2312714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305555", "Detail": { "ID": 305555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3294358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320057", "Detail": { "ID": 320057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.95981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315908", "Detail": { "ID": 315908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9324113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237132", "Detail": { "ID": 237132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9671934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288913", "Detail": { "ID": 288913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1637521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234230", "Detail": { "ID": 234230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3678753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313168", "Detail": { "ID": 313168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1665792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261347", "Detail": { "ID": 261347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3534583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225352", "Detail": { "ID": 225352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9709707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265671", "Detail": { "ID": 265671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4492541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282993", "Detail": { "ID": 282993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4431731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252103", "Detail": { "ID": 252103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5027101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317524", "Detail": { "ID": 317524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4261672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254267", "Detail": { "ID": 254267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.248173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293864", "Detail": { "ID": 293864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8721202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235856", "Detail": { "ID": 235856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.695896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255882", "Detail": { "ID": 255882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5610569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228546", "Detail": { "ID": 228546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8037576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289535", "Detail": { "ID": 289535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4482637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311143", "Detail": { "ID": 311143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6073267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246461", "Detail": { "ID": 246461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1297189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297668", "Detail": { "ID": 297668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.119607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234008", "Detail": { "ID": 234008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1561619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274910", "Detail": { "ID": 274910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1272898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269628", "Detail": { "ID": 269628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5560954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317484", "Detail": { "ID": 317484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4244078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326396", "Detail": { "ID": 326396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7566897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241252", "Detail": { "ID": 241252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7496661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290365", "Detail": { "ID": 290365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7437273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248112", "Detail": { "ID": 248112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.442518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288179", "Detail": { "ID": 288179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9103514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222596", "Detail": { "ID": 222596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1957511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306886", "Detail": { "ID": 306886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5777284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239872", "Detail": { "ID": 239872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7629434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283757", "Detail": { "ID": 283757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7221616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231798", "Detail": { "ID": 231798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6159874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237292", "Detail": { "ID": 237292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1979254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309004", "Detail": { "ID": 309004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2064, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475.1", "ID": 6616 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0873688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259123", "Detail": { "ID": 259123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3427106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318733", "Detail": { "ID": 318733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6710928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249512", "Detail": { "ID": 249512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9300688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228418", "Detail": { "ID": 228418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7981518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281116", "Detail": { "ID": 281116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8066749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263009", "Detail": { "ID": 263009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.63273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288932", "Detail": { "ID": 288932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1645618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227432", "Detail": { "ID": 227432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5499256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269748", "Detail": { "ID": 269748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5612854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322498", "Detail": { "ID": 322498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6912126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295392", "Detail": { "ID": 295392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5102166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242996", "Detail": { "ID": 242996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.044453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235121", "Detail": { "ID": 235121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4202913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301010", "Detail": { "ID": 301010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0284474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238444", "Detail": { "ID": 238444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4468127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327011", "Detail": { "ID": 327011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7897485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277504", "Detail": { "ID": 277504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9561857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263981", "Detail": { "ID": 263981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9190933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248596", "Detail": { "ID": 248596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6531082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294813", "Detail": { "ID": 294813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1794629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285359", "Detail": { "ID": 285359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3196213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231297", "Detail": { "ID": 231297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5888815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243722", "Detail": { "ID": 243722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3170263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254402", "Detail": { "ID": 254402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2543859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323464", "Detail": { "ID": 323464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9573205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290848", "Detail": { "ID": 290848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7747484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273056", "Detail": { "ID": 273056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3676707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262583", "Detail": { "ID": 262583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6081475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281778", "Detail": { "ID": 281778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1572209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298503", "Detail": { "ID": 298503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3489269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231122", "Detail": { "ID": 231122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.366561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285001", "Detail": { "ID": 285001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0569518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219566", "Detail": { "ID": 219566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3048888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238457", "Detail": { "ID": 238457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4474368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225167", "Detail": { "ID": 225167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7473483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321962", "Detail": { "ID": 321962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4589299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292311", "Detail": { "ID": 292311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5283042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227599", "Detail": { "ID": 227599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.557052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304573", "Detail": { "ID": 304573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0442203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257771", "Detail": { "ID": 257771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0769102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271134", "Detail": { "ID": 271134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8439399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274356", "Detail": { "ID": 274356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1025159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266066", "Detail": { "ID": 266066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4728895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250587", "Detail": { "ID": 250587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1959918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221050", "Detail": { "ID": 221050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6729195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220077", "Detail": { "ID": 220077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3333411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239685", "Detail": { "ID": 239685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7545482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253215", "Detail": { "ID": 253215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9863418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324787", "Detail": { "ID": 324787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2378235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259387", "Detail": { "ID": 259387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6069239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239440", "Detail": { "ID": 239440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7368967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273607", "Detail": { "ID": 273607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6276751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303705", "Detail": { "ID": 303705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8268001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221645", "Detail": { "ID": 221645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9416689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241875", "Detail": { "ID": 241875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7837869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223434", "Detail": { "ID": 223434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4577519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307932", "Detail": { "ID": 307932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8571397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272455", "Detail": { "ID": 272455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3360713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245007", "Detail": { "ID": 245007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5880125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315278", "Detail": { "ID": 315278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9046844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247521", "Detail": { "ID": 247521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4073983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275106", "Detail": { "ID": 275106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1418316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255525", "Detail": { "ID": 255525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5350628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276983", "Detail": { "ID": 276983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6960041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253440", "Detail": { "ID": 253440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9965108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276350", "Detail": { "ID": 276350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6557454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325344", "Detail": { "ID": 325344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4946502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231915", "Detail": { "ID": 231915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6212452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311777", "Detail": { "ID": 311777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8938299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229612", "Detail": { "ID": 229612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0892106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267562", "Detail": { "ID": 267562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0252226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313075", "Detail": { "ID": 313075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1625665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294414", "Detail": { "ID": 294414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1373009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319211", "Detail": { "ID": 319211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.910211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306207", "Detail": { "ID": 306207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5421411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310335", "Detail": { "ID": 310335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5660792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268042", "Detail": { "ID": 268042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0534975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293012", "Detail": { "ID": 293012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5678372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271495", "Detail": { "ID": 271495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0782972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263555", "Detail": { "ID": 263555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.894451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307260", "Detail": { "ID": 307260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8215473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280150", "Detail": { "ID": 280150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.543578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279169", "Detail": { "ID": 279169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2560052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260980", "Detail": { "ID": 260980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.106254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299315", "Detail": { "ID": 299315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6921601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301834", "Detail": { "ID": 301834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.285265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300283", "Detail": { "ID": 300283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.991276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223953", "Detail": { "ID": 223953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4856947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237909", "Detail": { "ID": 237909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2313137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305660", "Detail": { "ID": 305660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3339176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320059", "Detail": { "ID": 320059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9599007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315805", "Detail": { "ID": 315805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9278207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237133", "Detail": { "ID": 237133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9672326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288912", "Detail": { "ID": 288912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1637123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234229", "Detail": { "ID": 234229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3678349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312908", "Detail": { "ID": 312908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1550627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261348", "Detail": { "ID": 261348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3535003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225353", "Detail": { "ID": 225353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9710508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265670", "Detail": { "ID": 265670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4492141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282992", "Detail": { "ID": 282992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4431328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252104", "Detail": { "ID": 252104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5027512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317281", "Detail": { "ID": 317281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4116581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254264", "Detail": { "ID": 254264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2480477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293865", "Detail": { "ID": 293865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8721595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235857", "Detail": { "ID": 235857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6959359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255883", "Detail": { "ID": 255883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5610979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228547", "Detail": { "ID": 228547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8037993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289534", "Detail": { "ID": 289534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4482239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311559", "Detail": { "ID": 311559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8840946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246462", "Detail": { "ID": 246462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1297595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297667", "Detail": { "ID": 297667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1195669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233853", "Detail": { "ID": 233853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1491608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274911", "Detail": { "ID": 274911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1273505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270038", "Detail": { "ID": 270038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5788725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317743", "Detail": { "ID": 317743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4354608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326486", "Detail": { "ID": 326486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7667681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241253", "Detail": { "ID": 241253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7497376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290469", "Detail": { "ID": 290469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7484258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248113", "Detail": { "ID": 248113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4425591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288180", "Detail": { "ID": 288180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9103929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222597", "Detail": { "ID": 222597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1957932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306885", "Detail": { "ID": 306885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5776879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239871", "Detail": { "ID": 239871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7628875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283756", "Detail": { "ID": 283756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7221205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231089", "Detail": { "ID": 231089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3651371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237291", "Detail": { "ID": 237291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1978848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308905", "Detail": { "ID": 308905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2061, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Childcare", "Reference": "S4M-06475", "ID": 6599 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0831279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259124", "Detail": { "ID": 259124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3427521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318732", "Detail": { "ID": 318732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6710504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250254", "Detail": { "ID": 250254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1812696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228419", "Detail": { "ID": 228419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7981934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281117", "Detail": { "ID": 281117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8067154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263010", "Detail": { "ID": 263010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6327726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288931", "Detail": { "ID": 288931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1645196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227433", "Detail": { "ID": 227433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5499669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269747", "Detail": { "ID": 269747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5612436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322499", "Detail": { "ID": 322499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.691254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295393", "Detail": { "ID": 295393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5102573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243097", "Detail": { "ID": 243097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.04877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235120", "Detail": { "ID": 235120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4202492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301011", "Detail": { "ID": 301011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0285646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238443", "Detail": { "ID": 238443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.446771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327012", "Detail": { "ID": 327012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7897897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277505", "Detail": { "ID": 277505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9562461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263980", "Detail": { "ID": 263980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9190528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248595", "Detail": { "ID": 248595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6530673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294812", "Detail": { "ID": 294812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1794029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285360", "Detail": { "ID": 285360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3196627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231298", "Detail": { "ID": 231298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5889221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243621", "Detail": { "ID": 243621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3127941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254401", "Detail": { "ID": 254401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2543444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323465", "Detail": { "ID": 323465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9573627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290847", "Detail": { "ID": 290847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7747085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273057", "Detail": { "ID": 273057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3677125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262584", "Detail": { "ID": 262584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6081896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281777", "Detail": { "ID": 281777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1571813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298504", "Detail": { "ID": 298504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3489864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231121", "Detail": { "ID": 231121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3665205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285002", "Detail": { "ID": 285002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.056993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219567", "Detail": { "ID": 219567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3049303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238303", "Detail": { "ID": 238303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4405709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226680", "Detail": { "ID": 226680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2419687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321961", "Detail": { "ID": 321961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4588886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292310", "Detail": { "ID": 292310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5282631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227600", "Detail": { "ID": 227600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5571102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304574", "Detail": { "ID": 304574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.044262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257872", "Detail": { "ID": 257872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.081225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271135", "Detail": { "ID": 271135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8439804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274355", "Detail": { "ID": 274355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1024746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266067", "Detail": { "ID": 266067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4729309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250689", "Detail": { "ID": 250689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2093525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221156", "Detail": { "ID": 221156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6774785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220076", "Detail": { "ID": 220076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3332997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239686", "Detail": { "ID": 239686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7545889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253214", "Detail": { "ID": 253214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9863008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324786", "Detail": { "ID": 324786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2377832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259386", "Detail": { "ID": 259386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6068832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239441", "Detail": { "ID": 239441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7369381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273606", "Detail": { "ID": 273606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6276338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303704", "Detail": { "ID": 303704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8267586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223158", "Detail": { "ID": 223158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2310966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245669", "Detail": { "ID": 245669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8533954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223433", "Detail": { "ID": 223433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4577113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307933", "Detail": { "ID": 307933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8571812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272425", "Detail": { "ID": 272425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3347816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245108", "Detail": { "ID": 245108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5923772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315279", "Detail": { "ID": 315279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9047304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247520", "Detail": { "ID": 247520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4073578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275105", "Detail": { "ID": 275105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1417902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255524", "Detail": { "ID": 255524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5350226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276984", "Detail": { "ID": 276984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6960609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253441", "Detail": { "ID": 253441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9965521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276349", "Detail": { "ID": 276349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6557046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325345", "Detail": { "ID": 325345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4946912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231916", "Detail": { "ID": 231916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6212875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311778", "Detail": { "ID": 311778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8938725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229611", "Detail": { "ID": 229611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0891703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267563", "Detail": { "ID": 267563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.025264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313074", "Detail": { "ID": 313074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1625237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294413", "Detail": { "ID": 294413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1372594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319210", "Detail": { "ID": 319210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9101261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306206", "Detail": { "ID": 306206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5420991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310334", "Detail": { "ID": 310334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5660382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268041", "Detail": { "ID": 268041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0534565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293013", "Detail": { "ID": 293013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5678791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271837", "Detail": { "ID": 271837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0935661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263554", "Detail": { "ID": 263554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8944107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307261", "Detail": { "ID": 307261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8215882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280151", "Detail": { "ID": 280151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5436188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279168", "Detail": { "ID": 279168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2559648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260412", "Detail": { "ID": 260412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0757447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299314", "Detail": { "ID": 299314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.69212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301835", "Detail": { "ID": 301835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2853066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300282", "Detail": { "ID": 300282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9912347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224213", "Detail": { "ID": 224213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6889384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237910", "Detail": { "ID": 237910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2313553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305661", "Detail": { "ID": 305661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.333977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320060", "Detail": { "ID": 320060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9599427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315804", "Detail": { "ID": 315804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9277772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237134", "Detail": { "ID": 237134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9672729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288911", "Detail": { "ID": 288911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1636722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234228", "Detail": { "ID": 234228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3677939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312907", "Detail": { "ID": 312907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1550219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261349", "Detail": { "ID": 261349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.353541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225354", "Detail": { "ID": 225354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9710987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265669", "Detail": { "ID": 265669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4491742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282991", "Detail": { "ID": 282991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4430917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252105", "Detail": { "ID": 252105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5027946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317282", "Detail": { "ID": 317282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4117001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256675", "Detail": { "ID": 256675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.792891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293866", "Detail": { "ID": 293866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8722002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235858", "Detail": { "ID": 235858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6959765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255884", "Detail": { "ID": 255884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5611391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229266", "Detail": { "ID": 229266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.069256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289533", "Detail": { "ID": 289533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4481836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311560", "Detail": { "ID": 311560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8841362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246873", "Detail": { "ID": 246873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1570532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297666", "Detail": { "ID": 297666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1195265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233852", "Detail": { "ID": 233852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1491197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274912", "Detail": { "ID": 274912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1273929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270039", "Detail": { "ID": 270039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5789146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317744", "Detail": { "ID": 317744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.435502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326485", "Detail": { "ID": 326485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7667093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241357", "Detail": { "ID": 241357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7544498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290470", "Detail": { "ID": 290470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7484668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248114", "Detail": { "ID": 248114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4426003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288181", "Detail": { "ID": 288181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.910434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222598", "Detail": { "ID": 222598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1958342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306884", "Detail": { "ID": 306884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5776475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240918", "Detail": { "ID": 240918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3880082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283755", "Detail": { "ID": 283755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7220799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231088", "Detail": { "ID": 231088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3650965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237290", "Detail": { "ID": 237290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1978446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308904", "Detail": { "ID": 308904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2062, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 77, "VoteAgainst": 40, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474.1", "ID": 6617 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0830876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259121", "Detail": { "ID": 259121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3426299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319607", "Detail": { "ID": 319607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9335632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249515", "Detail": { "ID": 249515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9301927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227861", "Detail": { "ID": 227861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5688242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280862", "Detail": { "ID": 280862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7855618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263007", "Detail": { "ID": 263007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6326488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288934", "Detail": { "ID": 288934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.164643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227430", "Detail": { "ID": 227430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5498456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269750", "Detail": { "ID": 269750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5613664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322586", "Detail": { "ID": 322586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.695082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295390", "Detail": { "ID": 295390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5101352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242994", "Detail": { "ID": 242994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0443722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235123", "Detail": { "ID": 235123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.420373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301008", "Detail": { "ID": 301008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.028366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238446", "Detail": { "ID": 238446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4468951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327100", "Detail": { "ID": 327100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7988596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277502", "Detail": { "ID": 277502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9561047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263983", "Detail": { "ID": 263983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9191934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248598", "Detail": { "ID": 248598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.653191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294918", "Detail": { "ID": 294918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1843402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285357", "Detail": { "ID": 285357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3195395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231295", "Detail": { "ID": 231295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5887798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243724", "Detail": { "ID": 243724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3171064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254404", "Detail": { "ID": 254404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2544685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323707", "Detail": { "ID": 323707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9684375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290850", "Detail": { "ID": 290850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7748292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273054", "Detail": { "ID": 273054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3675684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262581", "Detail": { "ID": 262581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6080458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281877", "Detail": { "ID": 281877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1614429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298249", "Detail": { "ID": 298249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3376143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231124", "Detail": { "ID": 231124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3666438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284999", "Detail": { "ID": 284999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0568708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219564", "Detail": { "ID": 219564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3048055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238459", "Detail": { "ID": 238459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4475204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225169", "Detail": { "ID": 225169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7474536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321874", "Detail": { "ID": 321874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4550459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292313", "Detail": { "ID": 292313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5283874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227597", "Detail": { "ID": 227597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5569708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304571", "Detail": { "ID": 304571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0441212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257767", "Detail": { "ID": 257767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.076745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271132", "Detail": { "ID": 271132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8438592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278014", "Detail": { "ID": 278014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9832959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266064", "Detail": { "ID": 266064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4728088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250584", "Detail": { "ID": 250584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1958697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221048", "Detail": { "ID": 221048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6728385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220079", "Detail": { "ID": 220079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3334237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239683", "Detail": { "ID": 239683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7544677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253783", "Detail": { "ID": 253783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0207177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324698", "Detail": { "ID": 324698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2340871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259389", "Detail": { "ID": 259389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.607006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239438", "Detail": { "ID": 239438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7368149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273609", "Detail": { "ID": 273609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6277563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303707", "Detail": { "ID": 303707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8268827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221647", "Detail": { "ID": 221647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9417517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241877", "Detail": { "ID": 241877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7838686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223436", "Detail": { "ID": 223436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4579021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307832", "Detail": { "ID": 307832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8528213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272320", "Detail": { "ID": 272320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.330241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245005", "Detail": { "ID": 245005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5879309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315173", "Detail": { "ID": 315173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6774792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247523", "Detail": { "ID": 247523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4074799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275108", "Detail": { "ID": 275108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1419155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255527", "Detail": { "ID": 255527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5351444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276981", "Detail": { "ID": 276981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6896497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253438", "Detail": { "ID": 253438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.99643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276352", "Detail": { "ID": 276352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6558464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325433", "Detail": { "ID": 325433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5061767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231913", "Detail": { "ID": 231913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6211431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311677", "Detail": { "ID": 311677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8895104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229614", "Detail": { "ID": 229614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.089292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267461", "Detail": { "ID": 267461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0208432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313484", "Detail": { "ID": 313484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3973673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294978", "Detail": { "ID": 294978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1869262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319123", "Detail": { "ID": 319123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6934373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306314", "Detail": { "ID": 306314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5467156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310339", "Detail": { "ID": 310339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5662635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268143", "Detail": { "ID": 268143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0580464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286431", "Detail": { "ID": 286431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5788719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258551", "Detail": { "ID": 258551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3121197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263557", "Detail": { "ID": 263557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8945327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307256", "Detail": { "ID": 307256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8213829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280148", "Detail": { "ID": 280148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5434966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279171", "Detail": { "ID": 279171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2560876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260982", "Detail": { "ID": 260982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1063372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299569", "Detail": { "ID": 299569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7030925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301832", "Detail": { "ID": 301832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2851817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300285", "Detail": { "ID": 300285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9913771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223951", "Detail": { "ID": 223951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4855938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237907", "Detail": { "ID": 237907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2312298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305554", "Detail": { "ID": 305554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3293953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320303", "Detail": { "ID": 320303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1541796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315909", "Detail": { "ID": 315909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.932453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237131", "Detail": { "ID": 237131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9671539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288914", "Detail": { "ID": 288914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.163793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234231", "Detail": { "ID": 234231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3679376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313169", "Detail": { "ID": 313169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1666205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261346", "Detail": { "ID": 261346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3533996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225351", "Detail": { "ID": 225351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9708213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265672", "Detail": { "ID": 265672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4492951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282994", "Detail": { "ID": 282994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.443214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252102", "Detail": { "ID": 252102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5026629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317523", "Detail": { "ID": 317523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4261254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254268", "Detail": { "ID": 254268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.248215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293863", "Detail": { "ID": 293863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8720799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235855", "Detail": { "ID": 235855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6958558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255418", "Detail": { "ID": 255418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5305003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228545", "Detail": { "ID": 228545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8037168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289536", "Detail": { "ID": 289536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4483046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311142", "Detail": { "ID": 311142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6072856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246460", "Detail": { "ID": 246460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1296783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297669", "Detail": { "ID": 297669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1196475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234009", "Detail": { "ID": 234009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1562037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274909", "Detail": { "ID": 274909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1272489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269627", "Detail": { "ID": 269627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5560545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317483", "Detail": { "ID": 317483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4243665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326397", "Detail": { "ID": 326397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7567312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241251", "Detail": { "ID": 241251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.749625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290364", "Detail": { "ID": 290364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.743686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248111", "Detail": { "ID": 248111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4424756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288178", "Detail": { "ID": 288178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9103104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222595", "Detail": { "ID": 222595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1956924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306887", "Detail": { "ID": 306887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5777692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239873", "Detail": { "ID": 239873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7629873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283758", "Detail": { "ID": 283758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7222022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231799", "Detail": { "ID": 231799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6160296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237293", "Detail": { "ID": 237293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1979668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309005", "Detail": { "ID": 309005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2063, "AgendaID": 2402, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 84, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service", "Reference": "S4M-06474", "ID": 6598 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-08T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0874311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259809", "Detail": { "ID": 259809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6309159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318336", "Detail": { "ID": 318336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6532208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249958", "Detail": { "ID": 249958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9572838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230254", "Detail": { "ID": 230254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3148581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281722", "Detail": { "ID": 281722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1548601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263423", "Detail": { "ID": 263423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8887781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289958", "Detail": { "ID": 289958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4666555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228002", "Detail": { "ID": 228002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5801176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270526", "Detail": { "ID": 270526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8115842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322864", "Detail": { "ID": 322864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7068469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296547", "Detail": { "ID": 296547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8537455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242506", "Detail": { "ID": 242506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0232774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236499", "Detail": { "ID": 236499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9275046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300438", "Detail": { "ID": 300438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261208", "Detail": { "ID": 261208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3474876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326774", "Detail": { "ID": 326774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7794985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278250", "Detail": { "ID": 278250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2040995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264829", "Detail": { "ID": 264829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1507579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249120", "Detail": { "ID": 249120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6847442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293663", "Detail": { "ID": 293663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8636073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285640", "Detail": { "ID": 285640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3379429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233402", "Detail": { "ID": 233402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1226522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243376", "Detail": { "ID": 243376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2950468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253356", "Detail": { "ID": 253356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9928738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321505", "Detail": { "ID": 321505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4389625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300723", "Detail": { "ID": 300723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0160856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273329", "Detail": { "ID": 273329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6153757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263221", "Detail": { "ID": 263221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8799834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282160", "Detail": { "ID": 282160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1785871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299263", "Detail": { "ID": 299263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6899342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230587", "Detail": { "ID": 230587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3368255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287112", "Detail": { "ID": 287112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6196823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219898", "Detail": { "ID": 219898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3194246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238929", "Detail": { "ID": 238929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4754114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225922", "Detail": { "ID": 225922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9962007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322431", "Detail": { "ID": 322431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6883328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291806", "Detail": { "ID": 291806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1431555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228834", "Detail": { "ID": 228834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8162295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304745", "Detail": { "ID": 304745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0515552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258323", "Detail": { "ID": 258323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3021562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271997", "Detail": { "ID": 271997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1068915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278915", "Detail": { "ID": 278915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2397387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266795", "Detail": { "ID": 266795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7568409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253592", "Detail": { "ID": 253592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.003089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221439", "Detail": { "ID": 221439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9327269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220602", "Detail": { "ID": 220602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6484454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240105", "Detail": { "ID": 240105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7791143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266890", "Detail": { "ID": 266890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7664599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324197", "Detail": { "ID": 324197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.99639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260222", "Detail": { "ID": 260222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0672178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246591", "Detail": { "ID": 246591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1448712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275707", "Detail": { "ID": 275707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3871164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303815", "Detail": { "ID": 303815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8369621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222089", "Detail": { "ID": 222089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9673215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242305", "Detail": { "ID": 242305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0072598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224372", "Detail": { "ID": 224372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7019688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308694", "Detail": { "ID": 308694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0669293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272712", "Detail": { "ID": 272712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3471504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244348", "Detail": { "ID": 244348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5508099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314364", "Detail": { "ID": 314364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6365105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251392", "Detail": { "ID": 251392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4615987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275998", "Detail": { "ID": 275998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4060681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256605", "Detail": { "ID": 256605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7898784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282805", "Detail": { "ID": 282805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.434836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254584", "Detail": { "ID": 254584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2625002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278267", "Detail": { "ID": 278267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2048452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325088", "Detail": { "ID": 325088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.255644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232341", "Detail": { "ID": 232341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8506605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313020", "Detail": { "ID": 313020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1601506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231525", "Detail": { "ID": 231525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6043764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267726", "Detail": { "ID": 267726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0323619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314181", "Detail": { "ID": 314181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4332349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296031", "Detail": { "ID": 296031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5461937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319992", "Detail": { "ID": 319992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9566037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305982", "Detail": { "ID": 305982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3539011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309810", "Detail": { "ID": 309810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3459324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268714", "Detail": { "ID": 268714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2795144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294362", "Detail": { "ID": 294362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1350694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262087", "Detail": { "ID": 262087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3910111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268889", "Detail": { "ID": 268889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.287462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307469", "Detail": { "ID": 307469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8308674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282632", "Detail": { "ID": 282632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4275069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280950", "Detail": { "ID": 280950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7893117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245374", "Detail": { "ID": 245374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8321072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299850", "Detail": { "ID": 299850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7253841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302785", "Detail": { "ID": 302785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5450612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300090", "Detail": { "ID": 300090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7358908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224805", "Detail": { "ID": 224805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7206856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237989", "Detail": { "ID": 237989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2347646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296899", "Detail": { "ID": 296899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8788282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320736", "Detail": { "ID": 320736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1792402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315561", "Detail": { "ID": 315561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9173071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238014", "Detail": { "ID": 238014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2358528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293408", "Detail": { "ID": 293408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.843782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233669", "Detail": { "ID": 233669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1410023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312465", "Detail": { "ID": 312465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1290755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286865", "Detail": { "ID": 286865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6041584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226505", "Detail": { "ID": 226505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2343234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265248", "Detail": { "ID": 265248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4307317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284239", "Detail": { "ID": 284239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.01746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259065", "Detail": { "ID": 259065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3402128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317955", "Detail": { "ID": 317955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4507222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255624", "Detail": { "ID": 255624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5393531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294529", "Detail": { "ID": 294529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1423507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236805", "Detail": { "ID": 236805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9408778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256447", "Detail": { "ID": 256447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7828972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230010", "Detail": { "ID": 230010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1124016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290574", "Detail": { "ID": 290574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7628396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310020", "Detail": { "ID": 310020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.360966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247617", "Detail": { "ID": 247617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4211345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299182", "Detail": { "ID": 299182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3916808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235333", "Detail": { "ID": 235333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6659658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275859", "Detail": { "ID": 275859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3940344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274303", "Detail": { "ID": 274303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0947631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316526", "Detail": { "ID": 316526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1519563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325895", "Detail": { "ID": 325895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5260893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241651", "Detail": { "ID": 241651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7739819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287862", "Detail": { "ID": 287862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8897534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248430", "Detail": { "ID": 248430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6456385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289169", "Detail": { "ID": 289169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1804261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222961", "Detail": { "ID": 222961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2227711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306852", "Detail": { "ID": 306852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5764984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240624", "Detail": { "ID": 240624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3753377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284334", "Detail": { "ID": 284334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0218723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232993", "Detail": { "ID": 232993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8855043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246251", "Detail": { "ID": 246251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1206473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309441", "Detail": { "ID": 309441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2059, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 36, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.2", "ID": 6575 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3294745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259834", "Detail": { "ID": 259834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6320165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318335", "Detail": { "ID": 318335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6531804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249957", "Detail": { "ID": 249957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9572262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230255", "Detail": { "ID": 230255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3148988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281724", "Detail": { "ID": 281724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1549404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263623", "Detail": { "ID": 263623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8976252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289949", "Detail": { "ID": 289949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4662646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228003", "Detail": { "ID": 228003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5801583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270501", "Detail": { "ID": 270501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8104976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322866", "Detail": { "ID": 322866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7069275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM296549", "Detail": { "ID": 296549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8538272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242507", "Detail": { "ID": 242507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0233199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236498", "Detail": { "ID": 236498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9274625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300439", "Detail": { "ID": 300439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9982418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261150", "Detail": { "ID": 261150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1139857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326775", "Detail": { "ID": 326775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7795397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278620", "Detail": { "ID": 278620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2271051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264775", "Detail": { "ID": 264775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.148328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249119", "Detail": { "ID": 249119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6847027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293662", "Detail": { "ID": 293662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8635666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM287716", "Detail": { "ID": 287716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8831848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233460", "Detail": { "ID": 233460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1314957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243375", "Detail": { "ID": 243375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.295006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253355", "Detail": { "ID": 253355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9928152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321506", "Detail": { "ID": 321506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4390216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300722", "Detail": { "ID": 300722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0160447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273384", "Detail": { "ID": 273384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6177833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263222", "Detail": { "ID": 263222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8800239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282158", "Detail": { "ID": 282158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1785052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299265", "Detail": { "ID": 299265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6900243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230586", "Detail": { "ID": 230586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3367849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287121", "Detail": { "ID": 287121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6200802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219899", "Detail": { "ID": 219899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3194655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238904", "Detail": { "ID": 238904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4739974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225921", "Detail": { "ID": 225921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9961601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322429", "Detail": { "ID": 322429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6882499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291805", "Detail": { "ID": 291805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1430747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228835", "Detail": { "ID": 228835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8162714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304746", "Detail": { "ID": 304746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0515955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258324", "Detail": { "ID": 258324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3022209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM272022", "Detail": { "ID": 272022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1079733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278914", "Detail": { "ID": 278914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2396972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266796", "Detail": { "ID": 266796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7568811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253593", "Detail": { "ID": 253593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0031324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221440", "Detail": { "ID": 221440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9328006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220601", "Detail": { "ID": 220601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6484042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240106", "Detail": { "ID": 240106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7791593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266889", "Detail": { "ID": 266889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7664176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324196", "Detail": { "ID": 324196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9963481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260221", "Detail": { "ID": 260221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0671769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246613", "Detail": { "ID": 246613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1458041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275649", "Detail": { "ID": 275649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3846005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303814", "Detail": { "ID": 303814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.836921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222088", "Detail": { "ID": 222088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.96728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242304", "Detail": { "ID": 242304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0072176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224371", "Detail": { "ID": 224371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7019277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308696", "Detail": { "ID": 308696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0670106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272713", "Detail": { "ID": 272713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3471908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244349", "Detail": { "ID": 244349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5508702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314365", "Detail": { "ID": 314365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6365526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251367", "Detail": { "ID": 251367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4605073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275989", "Detail": { "ID": 275989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4056689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256580", "Detail": { "ID": 256580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7888247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282814", "Detail": { "ID": 282814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4352143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254606", "Detail": { "ID": 254606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.263465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278266", "Detail": { "ID": 278266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2048047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325089", "Detail": { "ID": 325089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2556845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232342", "Detail": { "ID": 232342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8507018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313022", "Detail": { "ID": 313022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1602576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231524", "Detail": { "ID": 231524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.604335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267727", "Detail": { "ID": 267727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0324032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314179", "Detail": { "ID": 314179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4331539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296029", "Detail": { "ID": 296029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5460921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319990", "Detail": { "ID": 319990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9564978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305981", "Detail": { "ID": 305981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3538594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309809", "Detail": { "ID": 309809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.345889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268713", "Detail": { "ID": 268713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2794735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294364", "Detail": { "ID": 294364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1351511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262086", "Detail": { "ID": 262086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3909706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268888", "Detail": { "ID": 268888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2874214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307470", "Detail": { "ID": 307470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8309086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282633", "Detail": { "ID": 282633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4275481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280893", "Detail": { "ID": 280893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.786864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245373", "Detail": { "ID": 245373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8320656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299848", "Detail": { "ID": 299848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7252586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302786", "Detail": { "ID": 302786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5451211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300089", "Detail": { "ID": 300089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.73585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224806", "Detail": { "ID": 224806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7207262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237990", "Detail": { "ID": 237990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2348053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296900", "Detail": { "ID": 296900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8788685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320738", "Detail": { "ID": 320738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1793396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315560", "Detail": { "ID": 315560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9172657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238069", "Detail": { "ID": 238069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2382198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293512", "Detail": { "ID": 293512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8485598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233668", "Detail": { "ID": 233668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1409595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312464", "Detail": { "ID": 312464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1290319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286866", "Detail": { "ID": 286866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6041987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226506", "Detail": { "ID": 226506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.234365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265247", "Detail": { "ID": 265247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4306891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284238", "Detail": { "ID": 284238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0174189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259066", "Detail": { "ID": 259066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3402597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317957", "Detail": { "ID": 317957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4508044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255623", "Detail": { "ID": 255623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5393119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294530", "Detail": { "ID": 294530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1423923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236806", "Detail": { "ID": 236806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9409317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256448", "Detail": { "ID": 256448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7829381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230011", "Detail": { "ID": 230011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1124424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290573", "Detail": { "ID": 290573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7627792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310021", "Detail": { "ID": 310021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3610068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247618", "Detail": { "ID": 247618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4211751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299180", "Detail": { "ID": 299180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3915395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235275", "Detail": { "ID": 235275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6634272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275860", "Detail": { "ID": 275860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.394075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274304", "Detail": { "ID": 274304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0948046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316527", "Detail": { "ID": 316527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1519971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325894", "Detail": { "ID": 325894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5260484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241652", "Detail": { "ID": 241652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7740225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287863", "Detail": { "ID": 287863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8897943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248431", "Detail": { "ID": 248431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.645682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289170", "Detail": { "ID": 289170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1804676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222962", "Detail": { "ID": 222962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2228116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306851", "Detail": { "ID": 306851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5764578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240623", "Detail": { "ID": 240623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3752972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284325", "Detail": { "ID": 284325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.021481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232992", "Detail": { "ID": 232992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.885445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246250", "Detail": { "ID": 246250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1206064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309439", "Detail": { "ID": 309439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2060, "AgendaID": 2767, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 99, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Redesigning the Community Justice System", "Reference": "S4M-06433.1", "ID": 6573 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-02T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3293929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259119", "Detail": { "ID": 259119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3425464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319609", "Detail": { "ID": 319609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9336452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249517", "Detail": { "ID": 249517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9302744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227859", "Detail": { "ID": 227859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5687405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280860", "Detail": { "ID": 280860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7854614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263005", "Detail": { "ID": 263005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.632565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288936", "Detail": { "ID": 288936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1647247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227428", "Detail": { "ID": 227428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5497632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269752", "Detail": { "ID": 269752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5614475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322584", "Detail": { "ID": 322584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6950007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295388", "Detail": { "ID": 295388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5100346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242992", "Detail": { "ID": 242992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.04429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235125", "Detail": { "ID": 235125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4204557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301006", "Detail": { "ID": 301006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0282837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238448", "Detail": { "ID": 238448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4469765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327098", "Detail": { "ID": 327098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.798753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277500", "Detail": { "ID": 277500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9560224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263985", "Detail": { "ID": 263985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9192763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248600", "Detail": { "ID": 248600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6532912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294920", "Detail": { "ID": 294920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1844221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285355", "Detail": { "ID": 285355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3194563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231293", "Detail": { "ID": 231293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5886988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243726", "Detail": { "ID": 243726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3171861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254406", "Detail": { "ID": 254406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2545519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323705", "Detail": { "ID": 323705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9683347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290852", "Detail": { "ID": 290852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7749092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273052", "Detail": { "ID": 273052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3674859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262579", "Detail": { "ID": 262579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6079651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281879", "Detail": { "ID": 281879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1615241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298247", "Detail": { "ID": 298247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3375311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231126", "Detail": { "ID": 231126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3667254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284997", "Detail": { "ID": 284997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.05679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219562", "Detail": { "ID": 219562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3047221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238461", "Detail": { "ID": 238461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4476292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225171", "Detail": { "ID": 225171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7475353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321876", "Detail": { "ID": 321876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4551272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292804", "Detail": { "ID": 292804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5588509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227595", "Detail": { "ID": 227595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5568901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304569", "Detail": { "ID": 304569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0440404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257765", "Detail": { "ID": 257765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0766459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271130", "Detail": { "ID": 271130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8437766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278016", "Detail": { "ID": 278016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9833798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266062", "Detail": { "ID": 266062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4727267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250582", "Detail": { "ID": 250582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1957872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221046", "Detail": { "ID": 221046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6727564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220081", "Detail": { "ID": 220081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3335066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM235080", "Detail": { "ID": 235080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4185154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253785", "Detail": { "ID": 253785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0207979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324700", "Detail": { "ID": 324700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2341683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259391", "Detail": { "ID": 259391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6070887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239436", "Detail": { "ID": 239436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7367317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273611", "Detail": { "ID": 273611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6278375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303709", "Detail": { "ID": 303709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221649", "Detail": { "ID": 221649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9418355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241879", "Detail": { "ID": 241879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7839707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223438", "Detail": { "ID": 223438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4579855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307830", "Detail": { "ID": 307830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.852738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272318", "Detail": { "ID": 272318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3301573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245003", "Detail": { "ID": 245003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5878459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315171", "Detail": { "ID": 315171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6773776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247525", "Detail": { "ID": 247525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4075613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275110", "Detail": { "ID": 275110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1420233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255529", "Detail": { "ID": 255529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5352455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276979", "Detail": { "ID": 276979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6895681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253436", "Detail": { "ID": 253436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9963468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276354", "Detail": { "ID": 276354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6619948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325431", "Detail": { "ID": 325431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5060935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231911", "Detail": { "ID": 231911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6210603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311675", "Detail": { "ID": 311675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8894249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229616", "Detail": { "ID": 229616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0893905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267459", "Detail": { "ID": 267459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0207592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313486", "Detail": { "ID": 313486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3974497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294980", "Detail": { "ID": 294980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1870079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319125", "Detail": { "ID": 319125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6935185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306316", "Detail": { "ID": 306316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5468172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310806", "Detail": { "ID": 310806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5868456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268145", "Detail": { "ID": 268145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0581292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286429", "Detail": { "ID": 286429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5787867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258553", "Detail": { "ID": 258553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3122209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263559", "Detail": { "ID": 263559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8946148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308526", "Detail": { "ID": 308526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0597092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280146", "Detail": { "ID": 280146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5434135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279173", "Detail": { "ID": 279173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2561699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260984", "Detail": { "ID": 260984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1064382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299571", "Detail": { "ID": 299571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7031751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306712", "Detail": { "ID": 306712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5641583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300622", "Detail": { "ID": 300622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0065316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223949", "Detail": { "ID": 223949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4855119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237905", "Detail": { "ID": 237905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2311273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305552", "Detail": { "ID": 305552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3292864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320301", "Detail": { "ID": 320301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1540952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315911", "Detail": { "ID": 315911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9375478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237129", "Detail": { "ID": 237129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9670724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288916", "Detail": { "ID": 288916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1638741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234233", "Detail": { "ID": 234233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.368023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313171", "Detail": { "ID": 313171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1667275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289316", "Detail": { "ID": 289316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4320234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225349", "Detail": { "ID": 225349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9707391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265674", "Detail": { "ID": 265674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4493959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282996", "Detail": { "ID": 282996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4432961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252100", "Detail": { "ID": 252100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5025775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317521", "Detail": { "ID": 317521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4260228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254270", "Detail": { "ID": 254270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2483183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296217", "Detail": { "ID": 296217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8391106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235543", "Detail": { "ID": 235543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6823393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255416", "Detail": { "ID": 255416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.530399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228543", "Detail": { "ID": 228543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8036339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289538", "Detail": { "ID": 289538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4483848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311140", "Detail": { "ID": 311140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6072037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246458", "Detail": { "ID": 246458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.129595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297671", "Detail": { "ID": 297671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1197481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234011", "Detail": { "ID": 234011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1562863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274907", "Detail": { "ID": 274907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1271652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269625", "Detail": { "ID": 269625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5559713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317481", "Detail": { "ID": 317481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4242845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326399", "Detail": { "ID": 326399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7568319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241249", "Detail": { "ID": 241249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7495404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290362", "Detail": { "ID": 290362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7436034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248109", "Detail": { "ID": 248109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4423693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288176", "Detail": { "ID": 288176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9102264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222593", "Detail": { "ID": 222593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1956096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306993", "Detail": { "ID": 306993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5827073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239875", "Detail": { "ID": 239875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7630703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283760", "Detail": { "ID": 283760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7223026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231801", "Detail": { "ID": 231801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6161108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237295", "Detail": { "ID": 237295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1980482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309007", "Detail": { "ID": 309007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2057, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 44, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407.4", "ID": 6555 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0875159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259120", "Detail": { "ID": 259120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3425884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319608", "Detail": { "ID": 319608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9336049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249516", "Detail": { "ID": 249516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9302338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227860", "Detail": { "ID": 227860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5687828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280861", "Detail": { "ID": 280861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.78552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263006", "Detail": { "ID": 263006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6326062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288935", "Detail": { "ID": 288935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1646837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227429", "Detail": { "ID": 227429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5498042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269751", "Detail": { "ID": 269751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5614073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322585", "Detail": { "ID": 322585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6950411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295389", "Detail": { "ID": 295389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5100758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242993", "Detail": { "ID": 242993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0443311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235124", "Detail": { "ID": 235124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4204142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301007", "Detail": { "ID": 301007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0283251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238447", "Detail": { "ID": 238447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4469358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327099", "Detail": { "ID": 327099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7988159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277501", "Detail": { "ID": 277501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9560631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263984", "Detail": { "ID": 263984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9192356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248599", "Detail": { "ID": 248599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6532321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294919", "Detail": { "ID": 294919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1843809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285356", "Detail": { "ID": 285356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3194975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231294", "Detail": { "ID": 231294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5887392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243725", "Detail": { "ID": 243725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3171464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254405", "Detail": { "ID": 254405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2545103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323706", "Detail": { "ID": 323706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9683756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290851", "Detail": { "ID": 290851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7748693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273053", "Detail": { "ID": 273053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3675268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262580", "Detail": { "ID": 262580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6080055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281878", "Detail": { "ID": 281878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1614835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298248", "Detail": { "ID": 298248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3375727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231125", "Detail": { "ID": 231125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3666844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284998", "Detail": { "ID": 284998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0568301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219563", "Detail": { "ID": 219563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3047634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238460", "Detail": { "ID": 238460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4475615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225170", "Detail": { "ID": 225170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7474943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321875", "Detail": { "ID": 321875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4550865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292803", "Detail": { "ID": 292803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5588086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227596", "Detail": { "ID": 227596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.55693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304570", "Detail": { "ID": 304570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0440804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257766", "Detail": { "ID": 257766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0766862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271131", "Detail": { "ID": 271131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8438176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278015", "Detail": { "ID": 278015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9833375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266063", "Detail": { "ID": 266063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4727677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250583", "Detail": { "ID": 250583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.195828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221047", "Detail": { "ID": 221047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6727974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220080", "Detail": { "ID": 220080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3334647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM235081", "Detail": { "ID": 235081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4185568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253784", "Detail": { "ID": 253784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0207578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324699", "Detail": { "ID": 324699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2341278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259390", "Detail": { "ID": 259390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6070469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239437", "Detail": { "ID": 239437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7367732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273610", "Detail": { "ID": 273610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6277968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303708", "Detail": { "ID": 303708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8269234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221648", "Detail": { "ID": 221648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9417946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241878", "Detail": { "ID": 241878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.783909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223437", "Detail": { "ID": 223437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4579441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307831", "Detail": { "ID": 307831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8527791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272319", "Detail": { "ID": 272319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3301989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245004", "Detail": { "ID": 245004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5878888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315172", "Detail": { "ID": 315172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.677437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247524", "Detail": { "ID": 247524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4075208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275109", "Detail": { "ID": 275109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1419573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255528", "Detail": { "ID": 255528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5352039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276980", "Detail": { "ID": 276980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6896089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253437", "Detail": { "ID": 253437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9963879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276353", "Detail": { "ID": 276353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6619338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325432", "Detail": { "ID": 325432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.506135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231912", "Detail": { "ID": 231912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6211015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311676", "Detail": { "ID": 311676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8894686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229615", "Detail": { "ID": 229615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0893323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267460", "Detail": { "ID": 267460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0208007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313485", "Detail": { "ID": 313485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3974089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294979", "Detail": { "ID": 294979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1869672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319124", "Detail": { "ID": 319124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6934779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306315", "Detail": { "ID": 306315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5467753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310805", "Detail": { "ID": 310805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5868047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268144", "Detail": { "ID": 268144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0580878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286430", "Detail": { "ID": 286430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.57883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258552", "Detail": { "ID": 258552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3121614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263558", "Detail": { "ID": 263558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.894574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308527", "Detail": { "ID": 308527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0597497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280147", "Detail": { "ID": 280147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5434553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279172", "Detail": { "ID": 279172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2561292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260983", "Detail": { "ID": 260983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1063786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299570", "Detail": { "ID": 299570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.703134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306713", "Detail": { "ID": 306713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5641991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300621", "Detail": { "ID": 300621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0064915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223950", "Detail": { "ID": 223950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4855522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237906", "Detail": { "ID": 237906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2311864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305553", "Detail": { "ID": 305553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3293527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320302", "Detail": { "ID": 320302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1541369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315910", "Detail": { "ID": 315910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9374911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237130", "Detail": { "ID": 237130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.967113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288915", "Detail": { "ID": 288915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1638334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234232", "Detail": { "ID": 234232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3679815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313170", "Detail": { "ID": 313170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1666836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289317", "Detail": { "ID": 289317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4320645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225350", "Detail": { "ID": 225350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.97078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265673", "Detail": { "ID": 265673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4493549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282995", "Detail": { "ID": 282995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4432547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252101", "Detail": { "ID": 252101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5026202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317522", "Detail": { "ID": 317522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4260628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254269", "Detail": { "ID": 254269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2482563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296218", "Detail": { "ID": 296218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.839152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235544", "Detail": { "ID": 235544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6823798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255417", "Detail": { "ID": 255417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5304396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228544", "Detail": { "ID": 228544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8036745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289537", "Detail": { "ID": 289537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4483452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311141", "Detail": { "ID": 311141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6072446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246459", "Detail": { "ID": 246459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1296367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297670", "Detail": { "ID": 297670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1196874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234010", "Detail": { "ID": 234010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1562452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274908", "Detail": { "ID": 274908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1272064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269626", "Detail": { "ID": 269626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5560128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317482", "Detail": { "ID": 317482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4243249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326398", "Detail": { "ID": 326398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7567727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241250", "Detail": { "ID": 241250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7495831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290363", "Detail": { "ID": 290363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7436445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248110", "Detail": { "ID": 248110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.442431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288177", "Detail": { "ID": 288177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9102682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222594", "Detail": { "ID": 222594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1956506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306992", "Detail": { "ID": 306992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5826661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239874", "Detail": { "ID": 239874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7630288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283759", "Detail": { "ID": 283759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7222424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231800", "Detail": { "ID": 231800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6160704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237294", "Detail": { "ID": 237294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1980076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309006", "Detail": { "ID": 309006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2058, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 96, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland Needs a Balanced Energy Policy", "Reference": "S4M-06407", "ID": 6531 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0874736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259118", "Detail": { "ID": 259118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3424877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319610", "Detail": { "ID": 319610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9337052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249518", "Detail": { "ID": 249518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9303158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227858", "Detail": { "ID": 227858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5686799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280859", "Detail": { "ID": 280859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7854215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263004", "Detail": { "ID": 263004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6325229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288937", "Detail": { "ID": 288937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1647654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227427", "Detail": { "ID": 227427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5497211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269753", "Detail": { "ID": 269753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5614877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322583", "Detail": { "ID": 322583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6949605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295387", "Detail": { "ID": 295387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5099942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242991", "Detail": { "ID": 242991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0442486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235126", "Detail": { "ID": 235126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4204971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301005", "Detail": { "ID": 301005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0282429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238449", "Detail": { "ID": 238449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4470171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327097", "Detail": { "ID": 327097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7987117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277499", "Detail": { "ID": 277499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9559822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263986", "Detail": { "ID": 263986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9193171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248601", "Detail": { "ID": 248601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6533342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294921", "Detail": { "ID": 294921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.184483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285354", "Detail": { "ID": 285354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3194136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231292", "Detail": { "ID": 231292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5886585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243727", "Detail": { "ID": 243727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3172259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254407", "Detail": { "ID": 254407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2545933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323704", "Detail": { "ID": 323704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9682928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290853", "Detail": { "ID": 290853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7749496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273051", "Detail": { "ID": 273051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3674448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262578", "Detail": { "ID": 262578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6079247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281880", "Detail": { "ID": 281880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1615655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298246", "Detail": { "ID": 298246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3374904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231127", "Detail": { "ID": 231127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3667663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284992", "Detail": { "ID": 284992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0565826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219561", "Detail": { "ID": 219561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3046803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238462", "Detail": { "ID": 238462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.447676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225172", "Detail": { "ID": 225172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7475753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321877", "Detail": { "ID": 321877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4551893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292805", "Detail": { "ID": 292805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5588917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227594", "Detail": { "ID": 227594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5568498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304568", "Detail": { "ID": 304568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0439993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257764", "Detail": { "ID": 257764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0766053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271125", "Detail": { "ID": 271125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8435498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278017", "Detail": { "ID": 278017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9834208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266061", "Detail": { "ID": 266061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4726857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250581", "Detail": { "ID": 250581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1957464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221045", "Detail": { "ID": 221045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.672715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220082", "Detail": { "ID": 220082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3335476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM235079", "Detail": { "ID": 235079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.418474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253786", "Detail": { "ID": 253786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0208383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324701", "Detail": { "ID": 324701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2342087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259392", "Detail": { "ID": 259392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6071297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239435", "Detail": { "ID": 239435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7366879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273612", "Detail": { "ID": 273612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6278777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303710", "Detail": { "ID": 303710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8270049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221650", "Detail": { "ID": 221650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9418766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241880", "Detail": { "ID": 241880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.784013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223439", "Detail": { "ID": 223439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4580268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307829", "Detail": { "ID": 307829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8526964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272317", "Detail": { "ID": 272317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3301152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245002", "Detail": { "ID": 245002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5877855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315170", "Detail": { "ID": 315170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6773361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247526", "Detail": { "ID": 247526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4076018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275115", "Detail": { "ID": 275115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1422339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255530", "Detail": { "ID": 255530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5352864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276974", "Detail": { "ID": 276974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6893608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253435", "Detail": { "ID": 253435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9963059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276355", "Detail": { "ID": 276355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6620394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325430", "Detail": { "ID": 325430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5060523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231910", "Detail": { "ID": 231910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6210178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311674", "Detail": { "ID": 311674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.889364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229617", "Detail": { "ID": 229617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.089432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267458", "Detail": { "ID": 267458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.020717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313487", "Detail": { "ID": 313487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3974913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294981", "Detail": { "ID": 294981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1870488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319126", "Detail": { "ID": 319126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6935592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306317", "Detail": { "ID": 306317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5468583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310807", "Detail": { "ID": 310807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5868869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268146", "Detail": { "ID": 268146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0581706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286428", "Detail": { "ID": 286428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5787264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258554", "Detail": { "ID": 258554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3122636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263560", "Detail": { "ID": 263560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8946558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308525", "Detail": { "ID": 308525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0596687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280145", "Detail": { "ID": 280145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5433547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279174", "Detail": { "ID": 279174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.256211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260985", "Detail": { "ID": 260985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1064811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299572", "Detail": { "ID": 299572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7032164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306711", "Detail": { "ID": 306711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5641169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300623", "Detail": { "ID": 300623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0065717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223948", "Detail": { "ID": 223948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4854703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237904", "Detail": { "ID": 237904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2310846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305551", "Detail": { "ID": 305551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.329244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320300", "Detail": { "ID": 320300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1540528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315912", "Detail": { "ID": 315912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9375921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237128", "Detail": { "ID": 237128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.967031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288917", "Detail": { "ID": 288917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1639144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234234", "Detail": { "ID": 234234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3680646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313172", "Detail": { "ID": 313172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1667692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289315", "Detail": { "ID": 289315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4319823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225348", "Detail": { "ID": 225348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9706983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265675", "Detail": { "ID": 265675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4494362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282997", "Detail": { "ID": 282997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4433547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252099", "Detail": { "ID": 252099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.502532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317520", "Detail": { "ID": 317520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4259823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254271", "Detail": { "ID": 254271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2483618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296216", "Detail": { "ID": 296216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8390669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235542", "Detail": { "ID": 235542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6822981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255415", "Detail": { "ID": 255415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.530358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228542", "Detail": { "ID": 228542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8035929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289539", "Detail": { "ID": 289539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4484263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311139", "Detail": { "ID": 311139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6071629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246457", "Detail": { "ID": 246457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1295539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297672", "Detail": { "ID": 297672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1197905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234012", "Detail": { "ID": 234012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1563278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274906", "Detail": { "ID": 274906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1271232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269624", "Detail": { "ID": 269624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5559299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317480", "Detail": { "ID": 317480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4242431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326400", "Detail": { "ID": 326400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7568752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241248", "Detail": { "ID": 241248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.749497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290361", "Detail": { "ID": 290361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7435628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248108", "Detail": { "ID": 248108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4423279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288175", "Detail": { "ID": 288175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9101846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222592", "Detail": { "ID": 222592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1955691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306994", "Detail": { "ID": 306994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5827481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239876", "Detail": { "ID": 239876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7631371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283765", "Detail": { "ID": 283765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7225088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231802", "Detail": { "ID": 231802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6161508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237296", "Detail": { "ID": 237296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1980888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309008", "Detail": { "ID": 309008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2056, "AgendaID": 2515, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 33, "VoteAgainst": 76, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Funding of the Voluntary Sector", "Reference": "S4M-06405.1", "ID": 6551 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "End": "2013-05-01T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0875575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252733", "Detail": { "ID": 252733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7512045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258963", "Detail": { "ID": 258963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3357859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319611", "Detail": { "ID": 319611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9337472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249519", "Detail": { "ID": 249519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.930356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227857", "Detail": { "ID": 227857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5686393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280858", "Detail": { "ID": 280858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7853811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263003", "Detail": { "ID": 263003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6324821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288938", "Detail": { "ID": 288938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1648055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229814", "Detail": { "ID": 229814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0985587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269754", "Detail": { "ID": 269754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5615275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322582", "Detail": { "ID": 322582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.69492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295386", "Detail": { "ID": 295386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5099537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242990", "Detail": { "ID": 242990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0442073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235127", "Detail": { "ID": 235127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4205374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302379", "Detail": { "ID": 302379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5218571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238450", "Detail": { "ID": 238450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4470583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327096", "Detail": { "ID": 327096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7986709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277498", "Detail": { "ID": 277498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9559417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263987", "Detail": { "ID": 263987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9193579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248603", "Detail": { "ID": 248603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6534167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294922", "Detail": { "ID": 294922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1845247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285353", "Detail": { "ID": 285353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3193532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231291", "Detail": { "ID": 231291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5886173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243728", "Detail": { "ID": 243728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3172657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254867", "Detail": { "ID": 254867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2872193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323703", "Detail": { "ID": 323703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9682509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290855", "Detail": { "ID": 290855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7750301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273050", "Detail": { "ID": 273050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3674033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262576", "Detail": { "ID": 262576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6078442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281881", "Detail": { "ID": 281881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1616059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298245", "Detail": { "ID": 298245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3374487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231224", "Detail": { "ID": 231224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.58575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284991", "Detail": { "ID": 284991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0565219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219461", "Detail": { "ID": 219461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3002399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238463", "Detail": { "ID": 238463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4477186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225173", "Detail": { "ID": 225173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7476153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321878", "Detail": { "ID": 321878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4552314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292806", "Detail": { "ID": 292806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5589318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227592", "Detail": { "ID": 227592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.556769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304592", "Detail": { "ID": 304592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0450061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257763", "Detail": { "ID": 257763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0765643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271124", "Detail": { "ID": 271124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8435093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278018", "Detail": { "ID": 278018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9834626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287274", "Detail": { "ID": 287274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8571173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250580", "Detail": { "ID": 250580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1957055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221044", "Detail": { "ID": 221044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6726728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220084", "Detail": { "ID": 220084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3336478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252399", "Detail": { "ID": 252399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7274856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253787", "Detail": { "ID": 253787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.020878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324702", "Detail": { "ID": 324702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.234249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259394", "Detail": { "ID": 259394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6072302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239434", "Detail": { "ID": 239434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.736628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273613", "Detail": { "ID": 273613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6279201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304106", "Detail": { "ID": 304106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8499356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221651", "Detail": { "ID": 221651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9419168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241881", "Detail": { "ID": 241881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7840538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223440", "Detail": { "ID": 223440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4580683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307828", "Detail": { "ID": 307828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8526546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272316", "Detail": { "ID": 272316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3300694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245001", "Detail": { "ID": 245001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5877442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315169", "Detail": { "ID": 315169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6772958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247527", "Detail": { "ID": 247527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.407642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275116", "Detail": { "ID": 275116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.142276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255531", "Detail": { "ID": 255531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5353272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276973", "Detail": { "ID": 276973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6893007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253434", "Detail": { "ID": 253434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9962652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276357", "Detail": { "ID": 276357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6621241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325429", "Detail": { "ID": 325429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5060097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232903", "Detail": { "ID": 232903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8816081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311673", "Detail": { "ID": 311673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8893222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229619", "Detail": { "ID": 229619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0895128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267457", "Detail": { "ID": 267457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0206549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313488", "Detail": { "ID": 313488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3975322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294982", "Detail": { "ID": 294982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1870895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319127", "Detail": { "ID": 319127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6936005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306318", "Detail": { "ID": 306318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.546899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310808", "Detail": { "ID": 310808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5869287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268147", "Detail": { "ID": 268147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0582316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286427", "Detail": { "ID": 286427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5786848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258555", "Detail": { "ID": 258555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3123045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263562", "Detail": { "ID": 263562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.894757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308524", "Detail": { "ID": 308524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0596281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280143", "Detail": { "ID": 280143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5432729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279175", "Detail": { "ID": 279175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2562517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260986", "Detail": { "ID": 260986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1065224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299573", "Detail": { "ID": 299573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7032578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306710", "Detail": { "ID": 306710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5640756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300624", "Detail": { "ID": 300624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0066128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223947", "Detail": { "ID": 223947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4854295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237903", "Detail": { "ID": 237903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2310439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305550", "Detail": { "ID": 305550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3291918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320299", "Detail": { "ID": 320299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.154011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315913", "Detail": { "ID": 315913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9376356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237127", "Detail": { "ID": 237127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9669721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288918", "Detail": { "ID": 288918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1639547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234538", "Detail": { "ID": 234538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3886058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313173", "Detail": { "ID": 313173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.16681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289314", "Detail": { "ID": 289314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4319413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225347", "Detail": { "ID": 225347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9706577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265824", "Detail": { "ID": 265824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4560874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282999", "Detail": { "ID": 282999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4434371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252097", "Detail": { "ID": 252097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5024257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317519", "Detail": { "ID": 317519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.425941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254272", "Detail": { "ID": 254272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2484038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296215", "Detail": { "ID": 296215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8389952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235540", "Detail": { "ID": 235540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6822163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257632", "Detail": { "ID": 257632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0648766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228541", "Detail": { "ID": 228541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.803552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291620", "Detail": { "ID": 291620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1351659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311138", "Detail": { "ID": 311138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6071215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246456", "Detail": { "ID": 246456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1295118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297673", "Detail": { "ID": 297673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1198307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234013", "Detail": { "ID": 234013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1563694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274904", "Detail": { "ID": 274904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1270402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269623", "Detail": { "ID": 269623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5558886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317479", "Detail": { "ID": 317479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4242003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326401", "Detail": { "ID": 326401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7569164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241247", "Detail": { "ID": 241247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7494446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290360", "Detail": { "ID": 290360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7435214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248106", "Detail": { "ID": 248106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.442245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288173", "Detail": { "ID": 288173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9100963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222591", "Detail": { "ID": 222591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1955283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306995", "Detail": { "ID": 306995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5827883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239877", "Detail": { "ID": 239877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7631795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283766", "Detail": { "ID": 283766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7225496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231803", "Detail": { "ID": 231803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6161913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237298", "Detail": { "ID": 237298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1981699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309009", "Detail": { "ID": 309009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2055, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 49, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306.2", "ID": 6457 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0875989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252719", "Detail": { "ID": 252719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7506207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258923", "Detail": { "ID": 258923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3340735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319612", "Detail": { "ID": 319612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9337881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249520", "Detail": { "ID": 249520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9303967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227837", "Detail": { "ID": 227837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5677926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280857", "Detail": { "ID": 280857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7853409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263002", "Detail": { "ID": 263002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6324403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288154", "Detail": { "ID": 288154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.909243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229813", "Detail": { "ID": 229813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0985161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269793", "Detail": { "ID": 269793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5631827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322581", "Detail": { "ID": 322581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6948794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295385", "Detail": { "ID": 295385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5099136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242989", "Detail": { "ID": 242989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0441664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235169", "Detail": { "ID": 235169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4223518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302378", "Detail": { "ID": 302378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5218172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238451", "Detail": { "ID": 238451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4470988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327095", "Detail": { "ID": 327095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7986295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277497", "Detail": { "ID": 277497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9559006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263988", "Detail": { "ID": 263988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.919399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248705", "Detail": { "ID": 248705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6662751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294923", "Detail": { "ID": 294923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1845657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285352", "Detail": { "ID": 285352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3193113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231290", "Detail": { "ID": 231290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5885768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243729", "Detail": { "ID": 243729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3173051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254868", "Detail": { "ID": 254868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2872619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323702", "Detail": { "ID": 323702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9682101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291263", "Detail": { "ID": 291263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.11133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273049", "Detail": { "ID": 273049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3673622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262320", "Detail": { "ID": 262320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5963857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281882", "Detail": { "ID": 281882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1616459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298244", "Detail": { "ID": 298244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3374081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231225", "Detail": { "ID": 231225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5857916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285005", "Detail": { "ID": 285005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0571353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219460", "Detail": { "ID": 219460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3001989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238503", "Detail": { "ID": 238503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.456916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225174", "Detail": { "ID": 225174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7476553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321879", "Detail": { "ID": 321879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4552722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292807", "Detail": { "ID": 292807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5589729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227185", "Detail": { "ID": 227185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2714788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312738", "Detail": { "ID": 312738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1412074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257762", "Detail": { "ID": 257762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0765237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271237", "Detail": { "ID": 271237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0616145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278019", "Detail": { "ID": 278019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9835035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287273", "Detail": { "ID": 287273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8570768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250579", "Detail": { "ID": 250579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1956623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221043", "Detail": { "ID": 221043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6726138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220184", "Detail": { "ID": 220184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3379685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252398", "Detail": { "ID": 252398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7274438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253788", "Detail": { "ID": 253788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0209368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324703", "Detail": { "ID": 324703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2342886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259652", "Detail": { "ID": 259652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6186893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239393", "Detail": { "ID": 239393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7348765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273614", "Detail": { "ID": 273614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6279604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304107", "Detail": { "ID": 304107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8499754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221652", "Detail": { "ID": 221652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9419571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241882", "Detail": { "ID": 241882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7840937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223482", "Detail": { "ID": 223482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4603158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307827", "Detail": { "ID": 307827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8526136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272315", "Detail": { "ID": 272315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3300081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245000", "Detail": { "ID": 245000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5877028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315168", "Detail": { "ID": 315168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6772547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247875", "Detail": { "ID": 247875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4321577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274849", "Detail": { "ID": 274849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1244195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255571", "Detail": { "ID": 255571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5370679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277396", "Detail": { "ID": 277396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9515888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253086", "Detail": { "ID": 253086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7662675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276769", "Detail": { "ID": 276769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6803329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325428", "Detail": { "ID": 325428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5059653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232902", "Detail": { "ID": 232902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8815677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311672", "Detail": { "ID": 311672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8892807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230338", "Detail": { "ID": 230338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3186665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267456", "Detail": { "ID": 267456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0206143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313489", "Detail": { "ID": 313489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3975728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294983", "Detail": { "ID": 294983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.18713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319128", "Detail": { "ID": 319128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6936408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306319", "Detail": { "ID": 306319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5469392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310809", "Detail": { "ID": 310809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.58697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268148", "Detail": { "ID": 268148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0582733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286426", "Detail": { "ID": 286426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5786439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258556", "Detail": { "ID": 258556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3123454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263817", "Detail": { "ID": 263817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9059978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308523", "Detail": { "ID": 308523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0595869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279733", "Detail": { "ID": 279733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5202854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279176", "Detail": { "ID": 279176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2562927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260987", "Detail": { "ID": 260987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1065637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299574", "Detail": { "ID": 299574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7033167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306709", "Detail": { "ID": 306709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5640348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300625", "Detail": { "ID": 300625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0066534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223946", "Detail": { "ID": 223946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4853889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237868", "Detail": { "ID": 237868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2295374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305549", "Detail": { "ID": 305549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3291122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320298", "Detail": { "ID": 320298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.15397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315914", "Detail": { "ID": 315914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9377076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237126", "Detail": { "ID": 237126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9669323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288919", "Detail": { "ID": 288919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1639945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234539", "Detail": { "ID": 234539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3886468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313174", "Detail": { "ID": 313174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.166851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289313", "Detail": { "ID": 289313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4318997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225305", "Detail": { "ID": 225305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9636507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265825", "Detail": { "ID": 265825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4561298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283255", "Detail": { "ID": 283255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.692554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251534", "Detail": { "ID": 251534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4678393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317518", "Detail": { "ID": 317518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4258986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254273", "Detail": { "ID": 254273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2484449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296214", "Detail": { "ID": 296214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8389533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235438", "Detail": { "ID": 235438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6777721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257631", "Detail": { "ID": 257631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0648345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228540", "Detail": { "ID": 228540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8035109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291621", "Detail": { "ID": 291621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1352058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311137", "Detail": { "ID": 311137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6070798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246455", "Detail": { "ID": 246455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1294522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297674", "Detail": { "ID": 297674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1198707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234014", "Detail": { "ID": 234014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1564102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274648", "Detail": { "ID": 274648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1156954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269622", "Detail": { "ID": 269622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5558471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317478", "Detail": { "ID": 317478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4241356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326402", "Detail": { "ID": 326402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7569573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241246", "Detail": { "ID": 241246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7493104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290359", "Detail": { "ID": 290359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7434803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248004", "Detail": { "ID": 248004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.437631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287456", "Detail": { "ID": 287456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8649656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222549", "Detail": { "ID": 222549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1937208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306996", "Detail": { "ID": 306996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5828288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239878", "Detail": { "ID": 239878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7632208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283500", "Detail": { "ID": 283500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7105901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231823", "Detail": { "ID": 231823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6170584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237701", "Detail": { "ID": 237701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2221319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309010", "Detail": { "ID": 309010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2054, "AgendaID": 2527, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 50, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Access to Justice", "Reference": "S4M-06306", "ID": 6438 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0876396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253125", "Detail": { "ID": 253125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7678599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259770", "Detail": { "ID": 259770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6290756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318340", "Detail": { "ID": 318340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6533847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250093", "Detail": { "ID": 250093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9630564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230236", "Detail": { "ID": 230236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3140936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281706", "Detail": { "ID": 281706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.154179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263419", "Detail": { "ID": 263419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8885959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289998", "Detail": { "ID": 289998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4683706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227998", "Detail": { "ID": 227998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5799339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270565", "Detail": { "ID": 270565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8132546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322877", "Detail": { "ID": 322877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7073912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297270", "Detail": { "ID": 297270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0924676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242502", "Detail": { "ID": 242502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0160521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236590", "Detail": { "ID": 236590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9315765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300434", "Detail": { "ID": 300434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9980163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261212", "Detail": { "ID": 261212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3476505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326770", "Detail": { "ID": 326770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.779334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278246", "Detail": { "ID": 278246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.20393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264833", "Detail": { "ID": 264833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1509403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249157", "Detail": { "ID": 249157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6863521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293667", "Detail": { "ID": 293667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8637879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285636", "Detail": { "ID": 285636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.337782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233398", "Detail": { "ID": 233398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1224906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243380", "Detail": { "ID": 243380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2952096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253360", "Detail": { "ID": 253360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9930395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321501", "Detail": { "ID": 321501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4387986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300745", "Detail": { "ID": 300745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0170527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273325", "Detail": { "ID": 273325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.610383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263183", "Detail": { "ID": 263183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6405251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282176", "Detail": { "ID": 282176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.179294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299247", "Detail": { "ID": 299247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6892326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230591", "Detail": { "ID": 230591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.336987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286608", "Detail": { "ID": 286608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5930949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219862", "Detail": { "ID": 219862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3178821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238968", "Detail": { "ID": 238968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4770834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226210", "Detail": { "ID": 226210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2147186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322418", "Detail": { "ID": 322418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6875151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291810", "Detail": { "ID": 291810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.143438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228797", "Detail": { "ID": 228797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8145724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304741", "Detail": { "ID": 304741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0513941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258033", "Detail": { "ID": 258033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0884304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271802", "Detail": { "ID": 271802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0920754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278932", "Detail": { "ID": 278932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2404836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266791", "Detail": { "ID": 266791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7566636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250838", "Detail": { "ID": 250838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2156559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221303", "Detail": { "ID": 221303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9261862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220792", "Detail": { "ID": 220792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6572225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240101", "Detail": { "ID": 240101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7727914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266908", "Detail": { "ID": 266908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7672211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324201", "Detail": { "ID": 324201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9965529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260260", "Detail": { "ID": 260260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0688582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246552", "Detail": { "ID": 246552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1336009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275711", "Detail": { "ID": 275711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3872783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303819", "Detail": { "ID": 303819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8371641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222225", "Detail": { "ID": 222225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1737093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242439", "Detail": { "ID": 242439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0133184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224464", "Detail": { "ID": 224464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7059542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308679", "Detail": { "ID": 308679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0662733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272576", "Detail": { "ID": 272576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3413427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244344", "Detail": { "ID": 244344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5506447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314360", "Detail": { "ID": 314360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6363477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251894", "Detail": { "ID": 251894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4937179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276038", "Detail": { "ID": 276038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4078009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256644", "Detail": { "ID": 256644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7915491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282764", "Detail": { "ID": 282764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.433102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254545", "Detail": { "ID": 254545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2607703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278305", "Detail": { "ID": 278305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2065054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325084", "Detail": { "ID": 325084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2554795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232337", "Detail": { "ID": 232337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8504731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313005", "Detail": { "ID": 313005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1593263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231563", "Detail": { "ID": 231563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6060042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267709", "Detail": { "ID": 267709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0316347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314196", "Detail": { "ID": 314196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4338901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296047", "Detail": { "ID": 296047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5469763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319823", "Detail": { "ID": 319823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9429151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305986", "Detail": { "ID": 305986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3540884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309814", "Detail": { "ID": 309814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3460969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268731", "Detail": { "ID": 268731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2802582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294346", "Detail": { "ID": 294346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1343961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271362", "Detail": { "ID": 271362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.072505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268926", "Detail": { "ID": 268926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2960534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307465", "Detail": { "ID": 307465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8306806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282594", "Detail": { "ID": 282594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.425729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280954", "Detail": { "ID": 280954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7894737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245378", "Detail": { "ID": 245378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8322707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299866", "Detail": { "ID": 299866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.726312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302781", "Detail": { "ID": 302781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5448991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300094", "Detail": { "ID": 300094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7360525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224515", "Detail": { "ID": 224515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7081647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237985", "Detail": { "ID": 237985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2346019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296895", "Detail": { "ID": 296895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8786486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320749", "Detail": { "ID": 320749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1798719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315565", "Detail": { "ID": 315565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9174877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238010", "Detail": { "ID": 238010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2356702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293412", "Detail": { "ID": 293412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8439441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233673", "Detail": { "ID": 233673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1411888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312469", "Detail": { "ID": 312469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1292384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286861", "Detail": { "ID": 286861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6039773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226102", "Detail": { "ID": 226102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0101224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265252", "Detail": { "ID": 265252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4311324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284261", "Detail": { "ID": 284261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0184956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259028", "Detail": { "ID": 259028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3385753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317968", "Detail": { "ID": 317968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4512809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256067", "Detail": { "ID": 256067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5692091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294525", "Detail": { "ID": 294525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1421691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236459", "Detail": { "ID": 236459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9257811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256443", "Detail": { "ID": 256443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.782716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229877", "Detail": { "ID": 229877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1012562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290578", "Detail": { "ID": 290578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7630024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310016", "Detail": { "ID": 310016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3608022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247173", "Detail": { "ID": 247173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1702315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298770", "Detail": { "ID": 298770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3714409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235337", "Detail": { "ID": 235337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6661305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275822", "Detail": { "ID": 275822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3924321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274286", "Detail": { "ID": 274286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0940229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316522", "Detail": { "ID": 316522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1517911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325899", "Detail": { "ID": 325899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5262541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241518", "Detail": { "ID": 241518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7682806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287858", "Detail": { "ID": 287858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8895721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248394", "Detail": { "ID": 248394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6440771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289147", "Detail": { "ID": 289147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1794585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222869", "Detail": { "ID": 222869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2081811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306856", "Detail": { "ID": 306856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5766624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240757", "Detail": { "ID": 240757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3809923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284375", "Detail": { "ID": 284375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0236326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233011", "Detail": { "ID": 233011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8862702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246288", "Detail": { "ID": 246288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1222254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309456", "Detail": { "ID": 309456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2053, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 38, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.3", "ID": 6372 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3301058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253126", "Detail": { "ID": 253126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7679008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259806", "Detail": { "ID": 259806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6306269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318339", "Detail": { "ID": 318339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.653344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249961", "Detail": { "ID": 249961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9574055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230237", "Detail": { "ID": 230237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3141346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281707", "Detail": { "ID": 281707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1542191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263420", "Detail": { "ID": 263420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8886548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289961", "Detail": { "ID": 289961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4667782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227999", "Detail": { "ID": 227999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5799739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270529", "Detail": { "ID": 270529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8117072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322878", "Detail": { "ID": 322878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7074309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297271", "Detail": { "ID": 297271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0925084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242503", "Detail": { "ID": 242503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.016093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236582", "Detail": { "ID": 236582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9312262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300435", "Detail": { "ID": 300435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9980757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261211", "Detail": { "ID": 261211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3476101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326771", "Detail": { "ID": 326771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7793758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278247", "Detail": { "ID": 278247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2039704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264832", "Detail": { "ID": 264832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1508985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249123", "Detail": { "ID": 249123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6848859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293666", "Detail": { "ID": 293666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8637477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285637", "Detail": { "ID": 285637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3378219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233399", "Detail": { "ID": 233399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.122531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243379", "Detail": { "ID": 243379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2951691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253359", "Detail": { "ID": 253359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9929985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321502", "Detail": { "ID": 321502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4388395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300726", "Detail": { "ID": 300726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0162072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273326", "Detail": { "ID": 273326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.610443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263218", "Detail": { "ID": 263218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8798628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282175", "Detail": { "ID": 282175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.179252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299248", "Detail": { "ID": 299248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6892731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230590", "Detail": { "ID": 230590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3369469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287109", "Detail": { "ID": 287109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6195603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219863", "Detail": { "ID": 219863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3179225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238932", "Detail": { "ID": 238932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.475537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226209", "Detail": { "ID": 226209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2146778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322417", "Detail": { "ID": 322417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.687473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291809", "Detail": { "ID": 291809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.14328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228798", "Detail": { "ID": 228798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.81466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304742", "Detail": { "ID": 304742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0514346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258320", "Detail": { "ID": 258320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3020317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271994", "Detail": { "ID": 271994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1067689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278931", "Detail": { "ID": 278931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2404427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266792", "Detail": { "ID": 266792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7567208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253589", "Detail": { "ID": 253589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0029467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221304", "Detail": { "ID": 221304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9262271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220791", "Detail": { "ID": 220791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6571807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240102", "Detail": { "ID": 240102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7728342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266907", "Detail": { "ID": 266907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7671805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324200", "Detail": { "ID": 324200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9965118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260225", "Detail": { "ID": 260225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0673398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246588", "Detail": { "ID": 246588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1447496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275710", "Detail": { "ID": 275710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3872383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303818", "Detail": { "ID": 303818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.837085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222224", "Detail": { "ID": 222224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1736673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242308", "Detail": { "ID": 242308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0073832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224456", "Detail": { "ID": 224456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7056056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308680", "Detail": { "ID": 308680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0663333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272709", "Detail": { "ID": 272709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3470291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244345", "Detail": { "ID": 244345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5506856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314361", "Detail": { "ID": 314361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6363891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251858", "Detail": { "ID": 251858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.492168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276001", "Detail": { "ID": 276001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4062087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256608", "Detail": { "ID": 256608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7899997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282802", "Detail": { "ID": 282802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4346965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254581", "Detail": { "ID": 254581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2623736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278270", "Detail": { "ID": 278270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2049666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325085", "Detail": { "ID": 325085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2555218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232338", "Detail": { "ID": 232338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8505153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313006", "Detail": { "ID": 313006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1593674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231562", "Detail": { "ID": 231562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6059633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267710", "Detail": { "ID": 267710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0316746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314195", "Detail": { "ID": 314195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4338494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296046", "Detail": { "ID": 296046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5468972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319822", "Detail": { "ID": 319822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9428738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305985", "Detail": { "ID": 305985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3540225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309813", "Detail": { "ID": 309813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3460564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268730", "Detail": { "ID": 268730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2802173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294347", "Detail": { "ID": 294347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1344363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262090", "Detail": { "ID": 262090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3911319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268892", "Detail": { "ID": 268892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2876056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307466", "Detail": { "ID": 307466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8307207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282629", "Detail": { "ID": 282629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4273644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280953", "Detail": { "ID": 280953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7894332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245377", "Detail": { "ID": 245377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8322301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299865", "Detail": { "ID": 299865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7262719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302782", "Detail": { "ID": 302782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5449402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300093", "Detail": { "ID": 300093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7360123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224516", "Detail": { "ID": 224516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7082057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237986", "Detail": { "ID": 237986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2346427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296896", "Detail": { "ID": 296896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8786888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320750", "Detail": { "ID": 320750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1799152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315564", "Detail": { "ID": 315564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9174282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238011", "Detail": { "ID": 238011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2357111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293411", "Detail": { "ID": 293411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8439036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233672", "Detail": { "ID": 233672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1411456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312468", "Detail": { "ID": 312468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1291973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286862", "Detail": { "ID": 286862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6040171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226110", "Detail": { "ID": 226110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0104664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265251", "Detail": { "ID": 265251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4310623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284242", "Detail": { "ID": 284242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0176026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259062", "Detail": { "ID": 259062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3400271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317969", "Detail": { "ID": 317969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4513217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255627", "Detail": { "ID": 255627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5394932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294526", "Detail": { "ID": 294526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1422098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236460", "Detail": { "ID": 236460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9258221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256444", "Detail": { "ID": 256444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7827559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229878", "Detail": { "ID": 229878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1013167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290577", "Detail": { "ID": 290577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7629623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310017", "Detail": { "ID": 310017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3608436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247614", "Detail": { "ID": 247614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4209704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298769", "Detail": { "ID": 298769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3714016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235336", "Detail": { "ID": 235336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6660891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275856", "Detail": { "ID": 275856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3939115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274287", "Detail": { "ID": 274287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0940834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316523", "Detail": { "ID": 316523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1518321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325898", "Detail": { "ID": 325898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.526213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241648", "Detail": { "ID": 241648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7738617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287859", "Detail": { "ID": 287859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8896122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248427", "Detail": { "ID": 248427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6454951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289166", "Detail": { "ID": 289166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1803038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222877", "Detail": { "ID": 222877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2085267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306855", "Detail": { "ID": 306855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5766216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240756", "Detail": { "ID": 240756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3809523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284337", "Detail": { "ID": 284337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0219961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233010", "Detail": { "ID": 233010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8862294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246287", "Detail": { "ID": 246287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1221842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309455", "Detail": { "ID": 309455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2050, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 94, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.2", "ID": 6371 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.330065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253127", "Detail": { "ID": 253127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7679415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259807", "Detail": { "ID": 259807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.630667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318338", "Detail": { "ID": 318338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6533032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249960", "Detail": { "ID": 249960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9573658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230238", "Detail": { "ID": 230238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3141754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281709", "Detail": { "ID": 281709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1542983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263421", "Detail": { "ID": 263421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8886962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289960", "Detail": { "ID": 289960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4667376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228000", "Detail": { "ID": 228000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5800137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270528", "Detail": { "ID": 270528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8116664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322876", "Detail": { "ID": 322876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7073517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297272", "Detail": { "ID": 297272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0925489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242504", "Detail": { "ID": 242504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0231663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236501", "Detail": { "ID": 236501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9276068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300436", "Detail": { "ID": 300436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9981177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261210", "Detail": { "ID": 261210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3475696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326772", "Detail": { "ID": 326772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7794168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278248", "Detail": { "ID": 278248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2040109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264831", "Detail": { "ID": 264831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.150839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249122", "Detail": { "ID": 249122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6848264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293665", "Detail": { "ID": 293665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8637077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285638", "Detail": { "ID": 285638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3378619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233400", "Detail": { "ID": 233400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1225717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243378", "Detail": { "ID": 243378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2951288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253358", "Detail": { "ID": 253358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9929578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321503", "Detail": { "ID": 321503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4388811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300725", "Detail": { "ID": 300725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0161669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273327", "Detail": { "ID": 273327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6104846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263219", "Detail": { "ID": 263219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8799026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282173", "Detail": { "ID": 282173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1791517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299250", "Detail": { "ID": 299250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6893544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230589", "Detail": { "ID": 230589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.336907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287110", "Detail": { "ID": 287110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6196008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219896", "Detail": { "ID": 219896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.319343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238931", "Detail": { "ID": 238931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4754963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225924", "Detail": { "ID": 225924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9963021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322419", "Detail": { "ID": 322419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.687556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291808", "Detail": { "ID": 291808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1432396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228832", "Detail": { "ID": 228832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8161472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304743", "Detail": { "ID": 304743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0514745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258321", "Detail": { "ID": 258321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3020728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271995", "Detail": { "ID": 271995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1068097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278929", "Detail": { "ID": 278929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2403578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266793", "Detail": { "ID": 266793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7567612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253590", "Detail": { "ID": 253590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0029872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221437", "Detail": { "ID": 221437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9326449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220604", "Detail": { "ID": 220604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6485274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240103", "Detail": { "ID": 240103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7728753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266905", "Detail": { "ID": 266905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7670976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324199", "Detail": { "ID": 324199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.996471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260224", "Detail": { "ID": 260224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0672994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246589", "Detail": { "ID": 246589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1447902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275709", "Detail": { "ID": 275709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3871978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303817", "Detail": { "ID": 303817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8370434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222091", "Detail": { "ID": 222091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9674021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242307", "Detail": { "ID": 242307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0073422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224374", "Detail": { "ID": 224374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7020709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308682", "Detail": { "ID": 308682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0664165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272710", "Detail": { "ID": 272710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3470696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244346", "Detail": { "ID": 244346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5507265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314362", "Detail": { "ID": 314362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6364294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251394", "Detail": { "ID": 251394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4616808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276000", "Detail": { "ID": 276000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4061493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256607", "Detail": { "ID": 256607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7899595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282803", "Detail": { "ID": 282803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4347543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254582", "Detail": { "ID": 254582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2624143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278269", "Detail": { "ID": 278269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2049261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325086", "Detail": { "ID": 325086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2555625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232339", "Detail": { "ID": 232339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8505753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313008", "Detail": { "ID": 313008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1595039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231527", "Detail": { "ID": 231527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6044573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267712", "Detail": { "ID": 267712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0317738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314193", "Detail": { "ID": 314193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4337472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296044", "Detail": { "ID": 296044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5468158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319824", "Detail": { "ID": 319824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9429559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305984", "Detail": { "ID": 305984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3539824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309812", "Detail": { "ID": 309812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3460157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268728", "Detail": { "ID": 268728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2801107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294349", "Detail": { "ID": 294349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1345186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262089", "Detail": { "ID": 262089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3910914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268891", "Detail": { "ID": 268891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2875642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307467", "Detail": { "ID": 307467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8307835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282630", "Detail": { "ID": 282630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4274236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280952", "Detail": { "ID": 280952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7893928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245376", "Detail": { "ID": 245376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.832189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299863", "Detail": { "ID": 299863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7261902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302783", "Detail": { "ID": 302783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5449803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300092", "Detail": { "ID": 300092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.735972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224803", "Detail": { "ID": 224803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7206042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237987", "Detail": { "ID": 237987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2346828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296897", "Detail": { "ID": 296897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8787285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320748", "Detail": { "ID": 320748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1797496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315563", "Detail": { "ID": 315563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9173882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238012", "Detail": { "ID": 238012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2357513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293410", "Detail": { "ID": 293410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8438633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233671", "Detail": { "ID": 233671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1410845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312467", "Detail": { "ID": 312467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1291568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286863", "Detail": { "ID": 286863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6040569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226503", "Detail": { "ID": 226503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2342223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265250", "Detail": { "ID": 265250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.431008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284241", "Detail": { "ID": 284241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0175426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259063", "Detail": { "ID": 259063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3400681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317967", "Detail": { "ID": 317967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4512399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255626", "Detail": { "ID": 255626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5394529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294527", "Detail": { "ID": 294527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1422509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236803", "Detail": { "ID": 236803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.940718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256445", "Detail": { "ID": 256445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7827965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230008", "Detail": { "ID": 230008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1123193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290576", "Detail": { "ID": 290576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7629219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310018", "Detail": { "ID": 310018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3608841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247615", "Detail": { "ID": 247615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4210483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298768", "Detail": { "ID": 298768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3713617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235335", "Detail": { "ID": 235335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6660482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275857", "Detail": { "ID": 275857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3939526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274289", "Detail": { "ID": 274289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0941673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316524", "Detail": { "ID": 316524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1518731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325897", "Detail": { "ID": 325897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5261717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241649", "Detail": { "ID": 241649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7739017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287860", "Detail": { "ID": 287860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8896714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248428", "Detail": { "ID": 248428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6455368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289167", "Detail": { "ID": 289167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1803444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222959", "Detail": { "ID": 222959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.22269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306854", "Detail": { "ID": 306854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.57658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240626", "Detail": { "ID": 240626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3754179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284336", "Detail": { "ID": 284336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0219547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233009", "Detail": { "ID": 233009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8861882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246253", "Detail": { "ID": 246253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.120728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309453", "Detail": { "ID": 309453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2051, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 95, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225.1", "ID": 6367 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3299839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253128", "Detail": { "ID": 253128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7679821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259808", "Detail": { "ID": 259808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6307076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318337", "Detail": { "ID": 318337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6532625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249959", "Detail": { "ID": 249959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9573257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230245", "Detail": { "ID": 230245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3144848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281723", "Detail": { "ID": 281723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1548997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263422", "Detail": { "ID": 263422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8887375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM289959", "Detail": { "ID": 289959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4666967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM228001", "Detail": { "ID": 228001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.580075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270527", "Detail": { "ID": 270527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8116257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322865", "Detail": { "ID": 322865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7068871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297273", "Detail": { "ID": 297273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0925891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242505", "Detail": { "ID": 242505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0232325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236500", "Detail": { "ID": 236500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9275646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300437", "Detail": { "ID": 300437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9981581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261209", "Detail": { "ID": 261209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3475289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326773", "Detail": { "ID": 326773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.779458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278249", "Detail": { "ID": 278249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2040517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264830", "Detail": { "ID": 264830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1507984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249121", "Detail": { "ID": 249121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.684785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293664", "Detail": { "ID": 293664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8636661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285639", "Detail": { "ID": 285639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3379027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233401", "Detail": { "ID": 233401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1226119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243377", "Detail": { "ID": 243377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2950874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253357", "Detail": { "ID": 253357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9929166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321504", "Detail": { "ID": 321504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4389218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300724", "Detail": { "ID": 300724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0161262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273328", "Detail": { "ID": 273328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.615306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263220", "Detail": { "ID": 263220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.879943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282159", "Detail": { "ID": 282159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.178546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299264", "Detail": { "ID": 299264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6899829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230588", "Detail": { "ID": 230588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.336866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287111", "Detail": { "ID": 287111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6196414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219897", "Detail": { "ID": 219897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3193839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238930", "Detail": { "ID": 238930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4754542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225923", "Detail": { "ID": 225923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9962429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322430", "Detail": { "ID": 322430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6882911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291807", "Detail": { "ID": 291807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1431993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228833", "Detail": { "ID": 228833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8161884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304744", "Detail": { "ID": 304744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0515147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258322", "Detail": { "ID": 258322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3021142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271996", "Detail": { "ID": 271996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1068502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278920", "Detail": { "ID": 278920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2399654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266794", "Detail": { "ID": 266794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7568008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM253591", "Detail": { "ID": 253591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0030281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221438", "Detail": { "ID": 221438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9326856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220603", "Detail": { "ID": 220603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6484859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240104", "Detail": { "ID": 240104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7790535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266896", "Detail": { "ID": 266896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7667053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324198", "Detail": { "ID": 324198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9964307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260223", "Detail": { "ID": 260223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0672585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246590", "Detail": { "ID": 246590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1448305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275708", "Detail": { "ID": 275708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3871577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303816", "Detail": { "ID": 303816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8370025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222090", "Detail": { "ID": 222090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9673621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242306", "Detail": { "ID": 242306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.007301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224373", "Detail": { "ID": 224373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7020106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308695", "Detail": { "ID": 308695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0669695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272711", "Detail": { "ID": 272711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.34711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244347", "Detail": { "ID": 244347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5507674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314363", "Detail": { "ID": 314363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6364699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251393", "Detail": { "ID": 251393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4616398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275999", "Detail": { "ID": 275999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4061087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256606", "Detail": { "ID": 256606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7899193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282804", "Detail": { "ID": 282804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4347955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254583", "Detail": { "ID": 254583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2624553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278268", "Detail": { "ID": 278268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2048856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325087", "Detail": { "ID": 325087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2556034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232340", "Detail": { "ID": 232340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8506187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313021", "Detail": { "ID": 313021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1602153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231526", "Detail": { "ID": 231526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6044171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267721", "Detail": { "ID": 267721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0321368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314180", "Detail": { "ID": 314180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4331944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296030", "Detail": { "ID": 296030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5461511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319991", "Detail": { "ID": 319991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9565602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305983", "Detail": { "ID": 305983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3539418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309811", "Detail": { "ID": 309811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3459734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268719", "Detail": { "ID": 268719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2797395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294363", "Detail": { "ID": 294363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1351102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM262088", "Detail": { "ID": 262088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.391051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268890", "Detail": { "ID": 268890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2875222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307468", "Detail": { "ID": 307468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8308258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282631", "Detail": { "ID": 282631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4274654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280951", "Detail": { "ID": 280951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7893521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245375", "Detail": { "ID": 245375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8321482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299849", "Detail": { "ID": 299849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7253378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302784", "Detail": { "ID": 302784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5450205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300091", "Detail": { "ID": 300091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7359318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224804", "Detail": { "ID": 224804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7206451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237988", "Detail": { "ID": 237988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2347234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296898", "Detail": { "ID": 296898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8787866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320737", "Detail": { "ID": 320737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1792805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315562", "Detail": { "ID": 315562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9173475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238013", "Detail": { "ID": 238013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2358108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293409", "Detail": { "ID": 293409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8438223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233670", "Detail": { "ID": 233670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1410433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312466", "Detail": { "ID": 312466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1291163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286864", "Detail": { "ID": 286864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6041167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226504", "Detail": { "ID": 226504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2342637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265249", "Detail": { "ID": 265249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4307736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284240", "Detail": { "ID": 284240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0175016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259064", "Detail": { "ID": 259064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.340109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317956", "Detail": { "ID": 317956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4507631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255625", "Detail": { "ID": 255625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5394115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294528", "Detail": { "ID": 294528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1422914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236804", "Detail": { "ID": 236804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9407599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256446", "Detail": { "ID": 256446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7828556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM230009", "Detail": { "ID": 230009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1123606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290575", "Detail": { "ID": 290575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7628817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310019", "Detail": { "ID": 310019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3609245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247616", "Detail": { "ID": 247616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4210927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298767", "Detail": { "ID": 298767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3713202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235334", "Detail": { "ID": 235334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6660069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275858", "Detail": { "ID": 275858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.393993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274298", "Detail": { "ID": 274298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0945584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316525", "Detail": { "ID": 316525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1519144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325896", "Detail": { "ID": 325896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5261306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241650", "Detail": { "ID": 241650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7739413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287861", "Detail": { "ID": 287861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.889713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248429", "Detail": { "ID": 248429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6455782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289168", "Detail": { "ID": 289168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1803848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222960", "Detail": { "ID": 222960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2227307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306853", "Detail": { "ID": 306853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5765392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240625", "Detail": { "ID": 240625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3753777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284335", "Detail": { "ID": 284335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0219136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233002", "Detail": { "ID": 233002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8858743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246252", "Detail": { "ID": 246252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1206878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309440", "Detail": { "ID": 309440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2052, "AgendaID": 2667, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 48, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Universal Services", "Reference": "S4M-06225", "ID": 6360 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "End": "2013-04-16T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3294335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252748", "Detail": { "ID": 252748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7516263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259137", "Detail": { "ID": 259137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3433124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319594", "Detail": { "ID": 319594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9330058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249498", "Detail": { "ID": 249498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9294546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227873", "Detail": { "ID": 227873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5693335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280876", "Detail": { "ID": 280876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7861475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262794", "Detail": { "ID": 262794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.617127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288944", "Detail": { "ID": 288944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1650695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229860", "Detail": { "ID": 229860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1005313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269734", "Detail": { "ID": 269734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5606797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322577", "Detail": { "ID": 322577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6946865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295331", "Detail": { "ID": 295331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5074772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243007", "Detail": { "ID": 243007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0449233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235108", "Detail": { "ID": 235108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4197096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302425", "Detail": { "ID": 302425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5238904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244209", "Detail": { "ID": 244209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5446685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327080", "Detail": { "ID": 327080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7979895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277133", "Detail": { "ID": 277133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7025124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264041", "Detail": { "ID": 264041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9216684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248668", "Detail": { "ID": 248668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6647103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294905", "Detail": { "ID": 294905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1837817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285298", "Detail": { "ID": 285298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3169655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230751", "Detail": { "ID": 230751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3439645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243711", "Detail": { "ID": 243711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3165673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254821", "Detail": { "ID": 254821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2851847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323687", "Detail": { "ID": 323687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9675662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290919", "Detail": { "ID": 290919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7777201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM272996", "Detail": { "ID": 272996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3647371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262356", "Detail": { "ID": 262356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5979432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281863", "Detail": { "ID": 281863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1608522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298264", "Detail": { "ID": 298264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3382721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231190", "Detail": { "ID": 231190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3697125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284983", "Detail": { "ID": 284983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0561731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219496", "Detail": { "ID": 219496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3017972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238289", "Detail": { "ID": 238289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4399713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225153", "Detail": { "ID": 225153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7467232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321883", "Detail": { "ID": 321883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4554373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292758", "Detail": { "ID": 292758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5568848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227221", "Detail": { "ID": 227221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5360826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313247", "Detail": { "ID": 313247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3843496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257784", "Detail": { "ID": 257784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0774648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271116", "Detail": { "ID": 271116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8431572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278001", "Detail": { "ID": 278001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9827068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287320", "Detail": { "ID": 287320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8591067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250601", "Detail": { "ID": 250601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1966079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221064", "Detail": { "ID": 221064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6735158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220148", "Detail": { "ID": 220148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3364162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252446", "Detail": { "ID": 252446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7295074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253770", "Detail": { "ID": 253770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0201791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324718", "Detail": { "ID": 324718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2349303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259615", "Detail": { "ID": 259615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6170939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239454", "Detail": { "ID": 239454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7374976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273667", "Detail": { "ID": 273667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6302197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304060", "Detail": { "ID": 304060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8476442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221630", "Detail": { "ID": 221630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9410089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241861", "Detail": { "ID": 241861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7831983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223421", "Detail": { "ID": 223421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4571527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307847", "Detail": { "ID": 307847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8534902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272336", "Detail": { "ID": 272336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.330965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245018", "Detail": { "ID": 245018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5884839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315186", "Detail": { "ID": 315186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6780322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247507", "Detail": { "ID": 247507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4068046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275124", "Detail": { "ID": 275124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1426243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255511", "Detail": { "ID": 255511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5344678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276965", "Detail": { "ID": 276965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.688975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253454", "Detail": { "ID": 253454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9971265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276733", "Detail": { "ID": 276733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6787782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325413", "Detail": { "ID": 325413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4976132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233250", "Detail": { "ID": 233250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1159047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311692", "Detail": { "ID": 311692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8901534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229683", "Detail": { "ID": 229683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0922061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267474", "Detail": { "ID": 267474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0213964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313469", "Detail": { "ID": 313469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3967066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294964", "Detail": { "ID": 294964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.186333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319132", "Detail": { "ID": 319132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6938242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306301", "Detail": { "ID": 306301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5461629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310761", "Detail": { "ID": 310761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5849208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268130", "Detail": { "ID": 268130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0574749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286445", "Detail": { "ID": 286445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5795109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258535", "Detail": { "ID": 258535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3114359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263781", "Detail": { "ID": 263781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9044596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308727", "Detail": { "ID": 308727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0683619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279769", "Detail": { "ID": 279769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5219022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279540", "Detail": { "ID": 279540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5120873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260502", "Detail": { "ID": 260502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0796532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299554", "Detail": { "ID": 299554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7024518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306759", "Detail": { "ID": 306759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5661938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300576", "Detail": { "ID": 300576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0045554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223968", "Detail": { "ID": 223968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4863339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237914", "Detail": { "ID": 237914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2315206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305567", "Detail": { "ID": 305567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3299447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320294", "Detail": { "ID": 320294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1536681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315896", "Detail": { "ID": 315896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9318943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236762", "Detail": { "ID": 236762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9389734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289743", "Detail": { "ID": 289743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4572327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234490", "Detail": { "ID": 234490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3865166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313156", "Detail": { "ID": 313156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1660676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289361", "Detail": { "ID": 289361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4339435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225366", "Detail": { "ID": 225366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9716314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265778", "Detail": { "ID": 265778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4540762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283219", "Detail": { "ID": 283219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6909984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252032", "Detail": { "ID": 252032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.499633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317360", "Detail": { "ID": 317360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4187796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254250", "Detail": { "ID": 254250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2474415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296263", "Detail": { "ID": 296263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8411136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235475", "Detail": { "ID": 235475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6794476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257678", "Detail": { "ID": 257678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0668497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228561", "Detail": { "ID": 228561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8044184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291574", "Detail": { "ID": 291574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.13322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311155", "Detail": { "ID": 311155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6080708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246784", "Detail": { "ID": 246784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1532767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298036", "Detail": { "ID": 298036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1355161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234090", "Detail": { "ID": 234090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1661978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274685", "Detail": { "ID": 274685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1172932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269640", "Detail": { "ID": 269640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5566384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317496", "Detail": { "ID": 317496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4249166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326417", "Detail": { "ID": 326417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7576771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241267", "Detail": { "ID": 241267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7505628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290377", "Detail": { "ID": 290377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7443096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248041", "Detail": { "ID": 248041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.439214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287492", "Detail": { "ID": 287492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8732546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222610", "Detail": { "ID": 222610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1963458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306954", "Detail": { "ID": 306954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5810341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239857", "Detail": { "ID": 239857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7620192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283774", "Detail": { "ID": 283774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7228955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231788", "Detail": { "ID": 231788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6155585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237363", "Detail": { "ID": 237363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2009583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308990", "Detail": { "ID": 308990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2049, "AgendaID": 2630, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-06059", "ID": 6199 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-27T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0867747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253119", "Detail": { "ID": 253119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7676099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259476", "Detail": { "ID": 259476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6107458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319541", "Detail": { "ID": 319541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9303938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250124", "Detail": { "ID": 250124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9643799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229453", "Detail": { "ID": 229453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0824385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281532", "Detail": { "ID": 281532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1468519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263303", "Detail": { "ID": 263303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.883521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290688", "Detail": { "ID": 290688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.767991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230561", "Detail": { "ID": 230561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3357082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270705", "Detail": { "ID": 270705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8195336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323054", "Detail": { "ID": 323054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7200282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297375", "Detail": { "ID": 297375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0972429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243057", "Detail": { "ID": 243057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.047075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236972", "Detail": { "ID": 236972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9482493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303105", "Detail": { "ID": 303105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5588013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261947", "Detail": { "ID": 261947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3850479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327044", "Detail": { "ID": 327044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7911745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278132", "Detail": { "ID": 278132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9884184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264949", "Detail": { "ID": 264949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1616315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249317", "Detail": { "ID": 249317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9213752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294854", "Detail": { "ID": 294854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1812176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285523", "Detail": { "ID": 285523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.33297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232070", "Detail": { "ID": 232070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6332299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243661", "Detail": { "ID": 243661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3144617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254423", "Detail": { "ID": 254423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2553214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323496", "Detail": { "ID": 323496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9588881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292424", "Detail": { "ID": 292424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5331933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273210", "Detail": { "ID": 273210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6054254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262872", "Detail": { "ID": 262872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6266062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282350", "Detail": { "ID": 282350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4090561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298919", "Detail": { "ID": 298919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3779977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231130", "Detail": { "ID": 231130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3668889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287180", "Detail": { "ID": 287180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6226079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219702", "Detail": { "ID": 219702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3108224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239105", "Detail": { "ID": 239105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4954992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226242", "Detail": { "ID": 226242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2166744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322241", "Detail": { "ID": 322241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6742847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292727", "Detail": { "ID": 292727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5552199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228189", "Detail": { "ID": 228189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5881556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313333", "Detail": { "ID": 313333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3907963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258002", "Detail": { "ID": 258002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0871035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271686", "Detail": { "ID": 271686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0868279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279415", "Detail": { "ID": 279415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5067455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288332", "Detail": { "ID": 288332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1302582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250813", "Detail": { "ID": 250813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2145869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221277", "Detail": { "ID": 221277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9224111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226361", "Detail": { "ID": 226361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2280305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252836", "Detail": { "ID": 252836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7553277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266658", "Detail": { "ID": 266658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7506315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324755", "Detail": { "ID": 324755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2364775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260885", "Detail": { "ID": 260885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1021752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246119", "Detail": { "ID": 246119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8730411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276133", "Detail": { "ID": 276133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4118829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303974", "Detail": { "ID": 303974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8439666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222255", "Detail": { "ID": 222255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1750269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245545", "Detail": { "ID": 245545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8398206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224704", "Detail": { "ID": 224704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7163414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308349", "Detail": { "ID": 308349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0521259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272550", "Detail": { "ID": 272550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3402158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245068", "Detail": { "ID": 245068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5906229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315238", "Detail": { "ID": 315238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8998962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252494", "Detail": { "ID": 252494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7315606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275619", "Detail": { "ID": 275619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3833295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257090", "Detail": { "ID": 257090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.822878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282873", "Detail": { "ID": 282873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4380058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254106", "Detail": { "ID": 254106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0347592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278771", "Detail": { "ID": 278771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2335667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325376", "Detail": { "ID": 325376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4960291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233323", "Detail": { "ID": 233323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1192672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312321", "Detail": { "ID": 312321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1227877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233090", "Detail": { "ID": 233090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8963761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267803", "Detail": { "ID": 267803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0356726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314528", "Detail": { "ID": 314528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6439117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296683", "Detail": { "ID": 296683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8694979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319490", "Detail": { "ID": 319490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9282152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306249", "Detail": { "ID": 306249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5439581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310729", "Detail": { "ID": 310729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5835341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268637", "Detail": { "ID": 268637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2761922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293711", "Detail": { "ID": 293711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8656527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271393", "Detail": { "ID": 271393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0738759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269395", "Detail": { "ID": 269395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5457019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308759", "Detail": { "ID": 308759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0697665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280585", "Detail": { "ID": 280585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.773543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281222", "Detail": { "ID": 281222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1255293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260453", "Detail": { "ID": 260453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0775207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304827", "Detail": { "ID": 304827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0604378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306791", "Detail": { "ID": 306791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5738448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300544", "Detail": { "ID": 300544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.002937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224489", "Detail": { "ID": 224489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7070268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237974", "Detail": { "ID": 237974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2341315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305618", "Detail": { "ID": 305618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.332132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321236", "Detail": { "ID": 321236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4194886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315844", "Detail": { "ID": 315844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9294899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237591", "Detail": { "ID": 237591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2174123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292538", "Detail": { "ID": 292538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5383156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234249", "Detail": { "ID": 234249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3688574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313104", "Detail": { "ID": 313104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1638133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289392", "Detail": { "ID": 289392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4352733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225705", "Detail": { "ID": 225705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9868616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265691", "Detail": { "ID": 265691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4501079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283942", "Detail": { "ID": 283942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7301458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258723", "Detail": { "ID": 258723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3198622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318457", "Detail": { "ID": 318457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6584036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256092", "Detail": { "ID": 256092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5702919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296294", "Detail": { "ID": 296294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8428154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235993", "Detail": { "ID": 235993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.701764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258074", "Detail": { "ID": 258074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0905142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229389", "Detail": { "ID": 229389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0796493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291023", "Detail": { "ID": 291023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7821653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311519", "Detail": { "ID": 311519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.882351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247147", "Detail": { "ID": 247147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1690946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298666", "Detail": { "ID": 298666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3560093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235763", "Detail": { "ID": 235763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6919383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275354", "Detail": { "ID": 275354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3716262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274111", "Detail": { "ID": 274111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6549205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317704", "Detail": { "ID": 317704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4338078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326454", "Detail": { "ID": 326454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7654037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241486", "Detail": { "ID": 241486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7600513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290428", "Detail": { "ID": 290428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7466663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248245", "Detail": { "ID": 248245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6375714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290079", "Detail": { "ID": 290079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.471871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222796", "Detail": { "ID": 222796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2050806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306935", "Detail": { "ID": 306935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5802315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240789", "Detail": { "ID": 240789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3823551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284112", "Detail": { "ID": 284112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7435255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251637", "Detail": { "ID": 251637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4725871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246741", "Detail": { "ID": 246741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1514427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309785", "Detail": { "ID": 309785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2046, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.3", "ID": 6164 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3448433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253118", "Detail": { "ID": 253118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.767549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259475", "Detail": { "ID": 259475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6107046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319543", "Detail": { "ID": 319543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9304765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250125", "Detail": { "ID": 250125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9644203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229452", "Detail": { "ID": 229452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.082379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281528", "Detail": { "ID": 281528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1466882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263001", "Detail": { "ID": 263001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6323975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290689", "Detail": { "ID": 290689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7680307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230560", "Detail": { "ID": 230560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3356466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270706", "Detail": { "ID": 270706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8195929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323058", "Detail": { "ID": 323058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.720213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295384", "Detail": { "ID": 295384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5098722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243056", "Detail": { "ID": 243056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.047034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236973", "Detail": { "ID": 236973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9482901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303104", "Detail": { "ID": 303104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5587604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238452", "Detail": { "ID": 238452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4471404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327042", "Detail": { "ID": 327042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7910923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277496", "Detail": { "ID": 277496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.95586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263989", "Detail": { "ID": 263989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9194398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249318", "Detail": { "ID": 249318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9214176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294855", "Detail": { "ID": 294855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1812592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285351", "Detail": { "ID": 285351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3192706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231289", "Detail": { "ID": 231289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5885364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243662", "Detail": { "ID": 243662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3145017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254424", "Detail": { "ID": 254424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.255363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323494", "Detail": { "ID": 323494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9587847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292425", "Detail": { "ID": 292425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5332343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273048", "Detail": { "ID": 273048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3673213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262871", "Detail": { "ID": 262871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6265652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282355", "Detail": { "ID": 282355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4092653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298914", "Detail": { "ID": 298914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3777964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231131", "Detail": { "ID": 231131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3669481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287179", "Detail": { "ID": 287179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6225668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219701", "Detail": { "ID": 219701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3107802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239106", "Detail": { "ID": 239106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4955411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226243", "Detail": { "ID": 226243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.216716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322237", "Detail": { "ID": 322237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6740996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292728", "Detail": { "ID": 292728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5552604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228188", "Detail": { "ID": 228188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5881146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313332", "Detail": { "ID": 313332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3907353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258001", "Detail": { "ID": 258001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0870624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271685", "Detail": { "ID": 271685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0867871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279419", "Detail": { "ID": 279419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5069124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288331", "Detail": { "ID": 288331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1302177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250812", "Detail": { "ID": 250812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2145472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221276", "Detail": { "ID": 221276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9223697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226362", "Detail": { "ID": 226362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2280717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252835", "Detail": { "ID": 252835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7552816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266663", "Detail": { "ID": 266663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7509297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324757", "Detail": { "ID": 324757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2365589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260886", "Detail": { "ID": 260886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1022168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246118", "Detail": { "ID": 246118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.872977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273615", "Detail": { "ID": 273615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6280014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303975", "Detail": { "ID": 303975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8440081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222256", "Detail": { "ID": 222256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1750695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245546", "Detail": { "ID": 245546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8398599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224705", "Detail": { "ID": 224705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7163823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308344", "Detail": { "ID": 308344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0519198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272549", "Detail": { "ID": 272549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3401751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245067", "Detail": { "ID": 245067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5905811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315236", "Detail": { "ID": 315236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8997937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252495", "Detail": { "ID": 252495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7316014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275620", "Detail": { "ID": 275620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3833727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257091", "Detail": { "ID": 257091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.822919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282872", "Detail": { "ID": 282872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4379652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254105", "Detail": { "ID": 254105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0347184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278772", "Detail": { "ID": 278772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2336081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325374", "Detail": { "ID": 325374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4959472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233322", "Detail": { "ID": 233322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1192262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312316", "Detail": { "ID": 312316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1225816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233091", "Detail": { "ID": 233091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8964192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267798", "Detail": { "ID": 267798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0354455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314533", "Detail": { "ID": 314533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6441197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296688", "Detail": { "ID": 296688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8697002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319485", "Detail": { "ID": 319485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9279911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306250", "Detail": { "ID": 306250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.544001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310730", "Detail": { "ID": 310730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5835752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268642", "Detail": { "ID": 268642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2763998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293245", "Detail": { "ID": 293245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8366681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271394", "Detail": { "ID": 271394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0739174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269396", "Detail": { "ID": 269396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5457432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308758", "Detail": { "ID": 308758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0697249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280584", "Detail": { "ID": 280584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7735022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279177", "Detail": { "ID": 279177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2563512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260454", "Detail": { "ID": 260454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0775625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304832", "Detail": { "ID": 304832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0606427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306790", "Detail": { "ID": 306790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.573803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300545", "Detail": { "ID": 300545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0029782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224488", "Detail": { "ID": 224488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7069855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237973", "Detail": { "ID": 237973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2340899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305617", "Detail": { "ID": 305617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3320728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321240", "Detail": { "ID": 321240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4196584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315846", "Detail": { "ID": 315846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9295718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237125", "Detail": { "ID": 237125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9668924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288920", "Detail": { "ID": 288920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1640548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234250", "Detail": { "ID": 234250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3688989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313106", "Detail": { "ID": 313106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1639151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289391", "Detail": { "ID": 289391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4352321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225704", "Detail": { "ID": 225704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.986821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265692", "Detail": { "ID": 265692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4501489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283943", "Detail": { "ID": 283943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7301866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258722", "Detail": { "ID": 258722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3198204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318462", "Detail": { "ID": 318462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6586293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256093", "Detail": { "ID": 256093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.570333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296293", "Detail": { "ID": 296293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8427716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235992", "Detail": { "ID": 235992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7017227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258073", "Detail": { "ID": 258073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0904412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229388", "Detail": { "ID": 229388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0796071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291024", "Detail": { "ID": 291024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7822068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311518", "Detail": { "ID": 311518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.882309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247146", "Detail": { "ID": 247146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1690536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297675", "Detail": { "ID": 297675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1199109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234015", "Detail": { "ID": 234015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1564721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275353", "Detail": { "ID": 275353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3715396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274107", "Detail": { "ID": 274107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6547517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317702", "Detail": { "ID": 317702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4337264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326456", "Detail": { "ID": 326456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7654857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241485", "Detail": { "ID": 241485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7600102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290427", "Detail": { "ID": 290427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7466255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248244", "Detail": { "ID": 248244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6375308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290078", "Detail": { "ID": 290078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4718302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222795", "Detail": { "ID": 222795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2050393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306936", "Detail": { "ID": 306936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5802726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240790", "Detail": { "ID": 240790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3824147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284113", "Detail": { "ID": 284113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7435668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251638", "Detail": { "ID": 251638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4726289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246742", "Detail": { "ID": 246742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1514828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309790", "Detail": { "ID": 309790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2045, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.2", "ID": 6163 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3450498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253120", "Detail": { "ID": 253120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7676527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259477", "Detail": { "ID": 259477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6107865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318090", "Detail": { "ID": 318090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4564883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250123", "Detail": { "ID": 250123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9643386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229454", "Detail": { "ID": 229454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0824803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281533", "Detail": { "ID": 281533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1468932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263304", "Detail": { "ID": 263304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8835625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290687", "Detail": { "ID": 290687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7679506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230562", "Detail": { "ID": 230562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3357512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270704", "Detail": { "ID": 270704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8194927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323055", "Detail": { "ID": 323055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7200874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297376", "Detail": { "ID": 297376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0972835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243058", "Detail": { "ID": 243058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.047116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236971", "Detail": { "ID": 236971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9482088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303106", "Detail": { "ID": 303106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5588431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261946", "Detail": { "ID": 261946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3850076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326680", "Detail": { "ID": 326680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7754987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278133", "Detail": { "ID": 278133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9884612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264948", "Detail": { "ID": 264948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1615912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249316", "Detail": { "ID": 249316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9213319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294853", "Detail": { "ID": 294853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1811766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285524", "Detail": { "ID": 285524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3330297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232071", "Detail": { "ID": 232071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6332716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243660", "Detail": { "ID": 243660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.314421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254422", "Detail": { "ID": 254422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2552799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321409", "Detail": { "ID": 321409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4346133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292423", "Detail": { "ID": 292423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5331531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273211", "Detail": { "ID": 273211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6054673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262873", "Detail": { "ID": 262873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6266476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282349", "Detail": { "ID": 282349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4090122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298920", "Detail": { "ID": 298920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3780381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231129", "Detail": { "ID": 231129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3668483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287181", "Detail": { "ID": 287181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.622649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219703", "Detail": { "ID": 219703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3108625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239104", "Detail": { "ID": 239104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4954582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226241", "Detail": { "ID": 226241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2166318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322240", "Detail": { "ID": 322240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6742419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292726", "Detail": { "ID": 292726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5551801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228190", "Detail": { "ID": 228190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5881974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313334", "Detail": { "ID": 313334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3908385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258003", "Detail": { "ID": 258003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0871443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271687", "Detail": { "ID": 271687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.087107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279414", "Detail": { "ID": 279414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5067039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288333", "Detail": { "ID": 288333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1302995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250814", "Detail": { "ID": 250814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.214627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221278", "Detail": { "ID": 221278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9224536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226360", "Detail": { "ID": 226360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2279886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252837", "Detail": { "ID": 252837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7553697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266657", "Detail": { "ID": 266657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7505895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324292", "Detail": { "ID": 324292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2103061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260884", "Detail": { "ID": 260884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1021145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246120", "Detail": { "ID": 246120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8730826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276132", "Detail": { "ID": 276132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4118412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303973", "Detail": { "ID": 303973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8439248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222254", "Detail": { "ID": 222254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1749858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245544", "Detail": { "ID": 245544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8397795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224703", "Detail": { "ID": 224703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7162995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308350", "Detail": { "ID": 308350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0521667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272551", "Detail": { "ID": 272551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3402756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245069", "Detail": { "ID": 245069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5906826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314612", "Detail": { "ID": 314612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6476125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252493", "Detail": { "ID": 252493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7315199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275618", "Detail": { "ID": 275618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3832692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257089", "Detail": { "ID": 257089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8228366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282874", "Detail": { "ID": 282874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4380463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254107", "Detail": { "ID": 254107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0348006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278770", "Detail": { "ID": 278770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2335263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324993", "Detail": { "ID": 324993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2465941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233324", "Detail": { "ID": 233324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1193077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312322", "Detail": { "ID": 312322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1228283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233089", "Detail": { "ID": 233089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8963155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267804", "Detail": { "ID": 267804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0357139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314527", "Detail": { "ID": 314527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6438699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296682", "Detail": { "ID": 296682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8694565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319489", "Detail": { "ID": 319489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9281546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306248", "Detail": { "ID": 306248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5438981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310728", "Detail": { "ID": 310728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5834927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268636", "Detail": { "ID": 268636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2761524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293712", "Detail": { "ID": 293712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8656931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271392", "Detail": { "ID": 271392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.073835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269394", "Detail": { "ID": 269394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5456596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308760", "Detail": { "ID": 308760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0698086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280586", "Detail": { "ID": 280586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7735838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281221", "Detail": { "ID": 281221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1254856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260452", "Detail": { "ID": 260452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0774788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304826", "Detail": { "ID": 304826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0603971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306792", "Detail": { "ID": 306792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5738862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300543", "Detail": { "ID": 300543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0028916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224490", "Detail": { "ID": 224490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7070681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237975", "Detail": { "ID": 237975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2341723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305619", "Detail": { "ID": 305619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3321742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321237", "Detail": { "ID": 321237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4195325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315469", "Detail": { "ID": 315469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9133661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237592", "Detail": { "ID": 237592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.217455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292537", "Detail": { "ID": 292537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.538274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234248", "Detail": { "ID": 234248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3688149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312061", "Detail": { "ID": 312061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9120405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290163", "Detail": { "ID": 290163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4817726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225706", "Detail": { "ID": 225706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9869031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265690", "Detail": { "ID": 265690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4500677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283941", "Detail": { "ID": 283941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7301033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258724", "Detail": { "ID": 258724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3199033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318458", "Detail": { "ID": 318458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6584456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256091", "Detail": { "ID": 256091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5702506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296295", "Detail": { "ID": 296295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8428564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235994", "Detail": { "ID": 235994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7018051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258075", "Detail": { "ID": 258075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0905655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229390", "Detail": { "ID": 229390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0796902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291022", "Detail": { "ID": 291022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7821238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310424", "Detail": { "ID": 310424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5699313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247148", "Detail": { "ID": 247148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1691355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298665", "Detail": { "ID": 298665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3559668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235762", "Detail": { "ID": 235762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6918977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275355", "Detail": { "ID": 275355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3716701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274112", "Detail": { "ID": 274112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6549615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316771", "Detail": { "ID": 316771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1627856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325991", "Detail": { "ID": 325991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5305366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241487", "Detail": { "ID": 241487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7600927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290429", "Detail": { "ID": 290429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7467072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248246", "Detail": { "ID": 248246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6376129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290080", "Detail": { "ID": 290080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.471912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222797", "Detail": { "ID": 222797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2051201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306934", "Detail": { "ID": 306934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5801905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240788", "Detail": { "ID": 240788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3823145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284111", "Detail": { "ID": 284111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7434828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251636", "Detail": { "ID": 251636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4725456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246740", "Detail": { "ID": 246740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1514018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309784", "Detail": { "ID": 309784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2047, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 45, "VoteAgainst": 68, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016.1", "ID": 6162 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3448014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253121", "Detail": { "ID": 253121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7676948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259478", "Detail": { "ID": 259478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.610829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318092", "Detail": { "ID": 318092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4565699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250122", "Detail": { "ID": 250122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9642977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229455", "Detail": { "ID": 229455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.082522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281535", "Detail": { "ID": 281535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1469942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263305", "Detail": { "ID": 263305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8836036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290686", "Detail": { "ID": 290686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7679103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230563", "Detail": { "ID": 230563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3357938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270703", "Detail": { "ID": 270703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8194521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323057", "Detail": { "ID": 323057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7201716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297377", "Detail": { "ID": 297377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0973442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242594", "Detail": { "ID": 242594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.027071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236970", "Detail": { "ID": 236970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9481683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303108", "Detail": { "ID": 303108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5589435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261945", "Detail": { "ID": 261945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3849667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326679", "Detail": { "ID": 326679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7754373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278134", "Detail": { "ID": 278134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9885022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264947", "Detail": { "ID": 264947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1615507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249315", "Detail": { "ID": 249315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9212717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293573", "Detail": { "ID": 293573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.851176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285525", "Detail": { "ID": 285525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3330724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM232072", "Detail": { "ID": 232072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6333126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243286", "Detail": { "ID": 243286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2908333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254420", "Detail": { "ID": 254420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2551964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321407", "Detail": { "ID": 321407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4345124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292422", "Detail": { "ID": 292422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.533112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273212", "Detail": { "ID": 273212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6055094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262874", "Detail": { "ID": 262874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.626689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282347", "Detail": { "ID": 282347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4089061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298922", "Detail": { "ID": 298922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3781392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231128", "Detail": { "ID": 231128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3668078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287182", "Detail": { "ID": 287182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6226906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219704", "Detail": { "ID": 219704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3109046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239103", "Detail": { "ID": 239103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4954163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226240", "Detail": { "ID": 226240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.216564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322238", "Detail": { "ID": 322238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6741406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292197", "Detail": { "ID": 292197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5232525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228191", "Detail": { "ID": 228191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5882386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304432", "Detail": { "ID": 304432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0379894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258004", "Detail": { "ID": 258004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0871855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271688", "Detail": { "ID": 271688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0871911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279412", "Detail": { "ID": 279412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5065974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288335", "Detail": { "ID": 288335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1303828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250815", "Detail": { "ID": 250815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2146855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221279", "Detail": { "ID": 221279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9225134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226359", "Detail": { "ID": 226359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2279453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252839", "Detail": { "ID": 252839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7554508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266655", "Detail": { "ID": 266655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7505057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324294", "Detail": { "ID": 324294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.210389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260883", "Detail": { "ID": 260883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1020736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246121", "Detail": { "ID": 246121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8731238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276131", "Detail": { "ID": 276131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4118009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303589", "Detail": { "ID": 303589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.821838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222253", "Detail": { "ID": 222253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1749444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242463", "Detail": { "ID": 242463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0143583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224702", "Detail": { "ID": 224702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7162581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308352", "Detail": { "ID": 308352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0522489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272552", "Detail": { "ID": 272552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3403177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244439", "Detail": { "ID": 244439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5547959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314610", "Detail": { "ID": 314610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6475092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252492", "Detail": { "ID": 252492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7314782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275617", "Detail": { "ID": 275617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.383228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257088", "Detail": { "ID": 257088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8227958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282875", "Detail": { "ID": 282875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.438087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254108", "Detail": { "ID": 254108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0348596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278769", "Detail": { "ID": 278769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2334841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324991", "Detail": { "ID": 324991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2465121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233325", "Detail": { "ID": 233325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.119348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312324", "Detail": { "ID": 312324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1229099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232633", "Detail": { "ID": 232633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.869587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267806", "Detail": { "ID": 267806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0357974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314525", "Detail": { "ID": 314525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6437662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296680", "Detail": { "ID": 296680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.869356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319487", "Detail": { "ID": 319487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.928073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305891", "Detail": { "ID": 305891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3497895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309933", "Detail": { "ID": 309933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3571999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268634", "Detail": { "ID": 268634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.27607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293714", "Detail": { "ID": 293714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8657737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271391", "Detail": { "ID": 271391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0737935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269393", "Detail": { "ID": 269393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5455998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307345", "Detail": { "ID": 307345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8252028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280587", "Detail": { "ID": 280587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7736243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281220", "Detail": { "ID": 281220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1254232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245284", "Detail": { "ID": 245284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8282196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304824", "Detail": { "ID": 304824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0603127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302264", "Detail": { "ID": 302264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5168993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300171", "Detail": { "ID": 300171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7393522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224491", "Detail": { "ID": 224491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7071095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237976", "Detail": { "ID": 237976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2342132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297451", "Detail": { "ID": 297451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1005239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321239", "Detail": { "ID": 321239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4196169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315471", "Detail": { "ID": 315471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9134478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237593", "Detail": { "ID": 237593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2174962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292536", "Detail": { "ID": 292536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.53823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234246", "Detail": { "ID": 234246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3686809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312063", "Detail": { "ID": 312063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9121235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290165", "Detail": { "ID": 290165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4818604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225707", "Detail": { "ID": 225707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9869439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265688", "Detail": { "ID": 265688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4499864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283940", "Detail": { "ID": 283940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7300621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258725", "Detail": { "ID": 258725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3199442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318460", "Detail": { "ID": 318460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6585281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256090", "Detail": { "ID": 256090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5702076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293988", "Detail": { "ID": 293988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8777888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235995", "Detail": { "ID": 235995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7018459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258077", "Detail": { "ID": 258077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0906696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229391", "Detail": { "ID": 229391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0797317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291020", "Detail": { "ID": 291020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7820408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310422", "Detail": { "ID": 310422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5698291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247149", "Detail": { "ID": 247149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1691769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298664", "Detail": { "ID": 298664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3559202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235761", "Detail": { "ID": 235761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6918573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275356", "Detail": { "ID": 275356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3717114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274114", "Detail": { "ID": 274114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6550443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316769", "Detail": { "ID": 316769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1626976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325993", "Detail": { "ID": 325993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5306244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241488", "Detail": { "ID": 241488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7601337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287952", "Detail": { "ID": 287952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8936428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248247", "Detail": { "ID": 248247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6376541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290081", "Detail": { "ID": 290081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4719531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222798", "Detail": { "ID": 222798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2051607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306870", "Detail": { "ID": 306870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5772588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240787", "Detail": { "ID": 240787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3822738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284110", "Detail": { "ID": 284110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7434207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251635", "Detail": { "ID": 251635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4725033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246739", "Detail": { "ID": 246739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1513598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309782", "Detail": { "ID": 309782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2048, "AgendaID": 2494, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 45, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Financial Strength", "Reference": "S4M-06016", "ID": 6154 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-21T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3446985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252703", "Detail": { "ID": 252703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7499383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258917", "Detail": { "ID": 258917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3337871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319647", "Detail": { "ID": 319647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9352964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249563", "Detail": { "ID": 249563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9322569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227821", "Detail": { "ID": 227821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5670887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280822", "Detail": { "ID": 280822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7838705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262724", "Detail": { "ID": 262724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.614127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288092", "Detail": { "ID": 288092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8997201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229810", "Detail": { "ID": 229810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0982646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269799", "Detail": { "ID": 269799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5634269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322628", "Detail": { "ID": 322628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6968965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295262", "Detail": { "ID": 295262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5044428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242953", "Detail": { "ID": 242953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0426129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235172", "Detail": { "ID": 235172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4224748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302375", "Detail": { "ID": 302375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5216763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244279", "Detail": { "ID": 244279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5478074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327172", "Detail": { "ID": 327172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8022746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277063", "Detail": { "ID": 277063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6995066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264266", "Detail": { "ID": 264266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1258891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248708", "Detail": { "ID": 248708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6664159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295728", "Detail": { "ID": 295728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5333754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285228", "Detail": { "ID": 285228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3139139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230705", "Detail": { "ID": 230705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3417774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243766", "Detail": { "ID": 243766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3188691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254871", "Detail": { "ID": 254871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2873843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323779", "Detail": { "ID": 323779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9715484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291266", "Detail": { "ID": 291266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1114528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265400", "Detail": { "ID": 265400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4375453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262317", "Detail": { "ID": 262317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5962652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281918", "Detail": { "ID": 281918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1633917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298208", "Detail": { "ID": 298208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3358334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231228", "Detail": { "ID": 231228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5859134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285876", "Detail": { "ID": 285876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3483331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219457", "Detail": { "ID": 219457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3000759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238509", "Detail": { "ID": 238509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4571805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225217", "Detail": { "ID": 225217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9597921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321832", "Detail": { "ID": 321832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.453251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292810", "Detail": { "ID": 292810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5590924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227182", "Detail": { "ID": 227182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2713516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312735", "Detail": { "ID": 312735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1410872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257769", "Detail": { "ID": 257769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0768283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271231", "Detail": { "ID": 271231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0613407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278055", "Detail": { "ID": 278055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9850489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287270", "Detail": { "ID": 287270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8569557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250536", "Detail": { "ID": 250536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.19381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221000", "Detail": { "ID": 221000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.670768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220187", "Detail": { "ID": 220187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3380906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252395", "Detail": { "ID": 252395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7273221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253822", "Detail": { "ID": 253822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0223819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324626", "Detail": { "ID": 324626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2310472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259655", "Detail": { "ID": 259655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6188113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239387", "Detail": { "ID": 239387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7346119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273737", "Detail": { "ID": 273737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6335022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304110", "Detail": { "ID": 304110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8500966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221695", "Detail": { "ID": 221695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.943803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241927", "Detail": { "ID": 241927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7860209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223485", "Detail": { "ID": 223485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4604648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307791", "Detail": { "ID": 307791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8450649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272322", "Detail": { "ID": 272322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3303233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244963", "Detail": { "ID": 244963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5861131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315133", "Detail": { "ID": 315133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6757356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247881", "Detail": { "ID": 247881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4323995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275009", "Detail": { "ID": 275009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.137236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255731", "Detail": { "ID": 255731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5544827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277390", "Detail": { "ID": 277390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9513269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253080", "Detail": { "ID": 253080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7659994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276772", "Detail": { "ID": 276772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6804526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325505", "Detail": { "ID": 325505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5092681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232899", "Detail": { "ID": 232899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8814449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311483", "Detail": { "ID": 311483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8807936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230341", "Detail": { "ID": 230341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3187931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267421", "Detail": { "ID": 267421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0190922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313526", "Detail": { "ID": 313526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3991823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295019", "Detail": { "ID": 295019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1887268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319082", "Detail": { "ID": 319082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6916703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306353", "Detail": { "ID": 306353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5484476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310812", "Detail": { "ID": 310812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.587091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268183", "Detail": { "ID": 268183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0597946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286390", "Detail": { "ID": 286390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5770993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258549", "Detail": { "ID": 258549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.312037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263820", "Detail": { "ID": 263820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9117721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308520", "Detail": { "ID": 308520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0594662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279730", "Detail": { "ID": 279730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5201658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279609", "Detail": { "ID": 279609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5150229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261025", "Detail": { "ID": 261025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1085484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299610", "Detail": { "ID": 299610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7051442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306706", "Detail": { "ID": 306706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5639106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300628", "Detail": { "ID": 300628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0067736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223903", "Detail": { "ID": 223903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4787283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237865", "Detail": { "ID": 237865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2294153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305515", "Detail": { "ID": 305515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3276621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320344", "Detail": { "ID": 320344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1559766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315949", "Detail": { "ID": 315949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9392283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236691", "Detail": { "ID": 236691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9359186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289813", "Detail": { "ID": 289813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.460171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234542", "Detail": { "ID": 234542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3887923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313208", "Detail": { "ID": 313208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3823347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289310", "Detail": { "ID": 289310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4317575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225302", "Detail": { "ID": 225302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9635271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265828", "Detail": { "ID": 265828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.456253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283258", "Detail": { "ID": 283258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6927008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251531", "Detail": { "ID": 251531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4677136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317565", "Detail": { "ID": 317565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4279056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254266", "Detail": { "ID": 254266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2481318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296211", "Detail": { "ID": 296211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8388157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235435", "Detail": { "ID": 235435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6776492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257628", "Detail": { "ID": 257628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0647127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228496", "Detail": { "ID": 228496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8015907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291624", "Detail": { "ID": 291624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1353246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311103", "Detail": { "ID": 311103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6055308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246410", "Detail": { "ID": 246410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1275139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298106", "Detail": { "ID": 298106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1384895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234138", "Detail": { "ID": 234138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1682778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274645", "Detail": { "ID": 274645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1155504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269587", "Detail": { "ID": 269587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5542815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317444", "Detail": { "ID": 317444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4223608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326325", "Detail": { "ID": 326325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7535894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241201", "Detail": { "ID": 241201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7473543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290324", "Detail": { "ID": 290324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.741925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248001", "Detail": { "ID": 248001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4374896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287453", "Detail": { "ID": 287453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8648447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222546", "Detail": { "ID": 222546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1935995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306999", "Detail": { "ID": 306999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5829502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239922", "Detail": { "ID": 239922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7651051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283506", "Detail": { "ID": 283506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7108364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231839", "Detail": { "ID": 231839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6177607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237704", "Detail": { "ID": 237704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2222526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309202", "Detail": { "ID": 309202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2042, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 12, "VoteAgainst": 67, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.2", "ID": 6153 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3172831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252704", "Detail": { "ID": 252704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7499965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258918", "Detail": { "ID": 258918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3338275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319645", "Detail": { "ID": 319645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9352145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249522", "Detail": { "ID": 249522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227822", "Detail": { "ID": 227822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5671302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280823", "Detail": { "ID": 280823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7839113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262725", "Detail": { "ID": 262725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6141672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288091", "Detail": { "ID": 288091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8996785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229811", "Detail": { "ID": 229811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0983852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269798", "Detail": { "ID": 269798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5633863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322629", "Detail": { "ID": 322629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6969367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295263", "Detail": { "ID": 295263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5044835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242954", "Detail": { "ID": 242954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0426715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235171", "Detail": { "ID": 235171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4224339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302376", "Detail": { "ID": 302376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.521735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244278", "Detail": { "ID": 244278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5477661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327174", "Detail": { "ID": 327174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8023575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277064", "Detail": { "ID": 277064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6995472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264265", "Detail": { "ID": 264265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1258484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248707", "Detail": { "ID": 248707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.666374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295726", "Detail": { "ID": 295726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5332929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285229", "Detail": { "ID": 285229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3139553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230706", "Detail": { "ID": 230706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3418228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243764", "Detail": { "ID": 243764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3187894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254870", "Detail": { "ID": 254870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.287344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323781", "Detail": { "ID": 323781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9716308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291265", "Detail": { "ID": 291265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1114122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265401", "Detail": { "ID": 265401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4375862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262318", "Detail": { "ID": 262318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5963056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281917", "Detail": { "ID": 281917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1633507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298209", "Detail": { "ID": 298209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3358754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231227", "Detail": { "ID": 231227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5858731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285877", "Detail": { "ID": 285877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3483732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219458", "Detail": { "ID": 219458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3001171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238508", "Detail": { "ID": 238508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4571384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225176", "Detail": { "ID": 225176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7477349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321831", "Detail": { "ID": 321831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4532107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292809", "Detail": { "ID": 292809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5590529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227183", "Detail": { "ID": 227183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2713955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312736", "Detail": { "ID": 312736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.141127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257760", "Detail": { "ID": 257760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0764426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271232", "Detail": { "ID": 271232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0613813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278054", "Detail": { "ID": 278054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9850079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287271", "Detail": { "ID": 287271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.856996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250577", "Detail": { "ID": 250577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1955605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221041", "Detail": { "ID": 221041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6725326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220186", "Detail": { "ID": 220186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3380502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252396", "Detail": { "ID": 252396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7273625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253821", "Detail": { "ID": 253821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0223415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324624", "Detail": { "ID": 324624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.230966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259654", "Detail": { "ID": 259654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6187701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239388", "Detail": { "ID": 239388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.734652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273736", "Detail": { "ID": 273736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6334609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304109", "Detail": { "ID": 304109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.850056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221654", "Detail": { "ID": 221654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9420591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241884", "Detail": { "ID": 241884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7841752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223484", "Detail": { "ID": 223484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4604225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307792", "Detail": { "ID": 307792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8451263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272313", "Detail": { "ID": 272313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3245355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244965", "Detail": { "ID": 244965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5861979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315135", "Detail": { "ID": 315135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6758331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247880", "Detail": { "ID": 247880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4323599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275008", "Detail": { "ID": 275008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1371946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255730", "Detail": { "ID": 255730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5544433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277391", "Detail": { "ID": 277391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9513676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253081", "Detail": { "ID": 253081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7660406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276771", "Detail": { "ID": 276771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6804131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325507", "Detail": { "ID": 325507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5093493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232900", "Detail": { "ID": 232900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8814859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311484", "Detail": { "ID": 311484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8808349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230340", "Detail": { "ID": 230340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3187509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267422", "Detail": { "ID": 267422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0191326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313525", "Detail": { "ID": 313525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3991391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295018", "Detail": { "ID": 295018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1886679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319081", "Detail": { "ID": 319081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6916298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306351", "Detail": { "ID": 306351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5483657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310811", "Detail": { "ID": 310811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5870506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268182", "Detail": { "ID": 268182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0597537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286391", "Detail": { "ID": 286391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5771399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258558", "Detail": { "ID": 258558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3124274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263819", "Detail": { "ID": 263819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9060796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308521", "Detail": { "ID": 308521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0595063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279731", "Detail": { "ID": 279731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.520206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279608", "Detail": { "ID": 279608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5149831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261023", "Detail": { "ID": 261023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1084632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299609", "Detail": { "ID": 299609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.705103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306707", "Detail": { "ID": 306707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5639513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300627", "Detail": { "ID": 300627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0067338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223944", "Detail": { "ID": 223944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4853069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237866", "Detail": { "ID": 237866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2294564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305517", "Detail": { "ID": 305517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3277446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320345", "Detail": { "ID": 320345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1560191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315947", "Detail": { "ID": 315947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9391455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236692", "Detail": { "ID": 236692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.935959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289812", "Detail": { "ID": 289812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4601312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234541", "Detail": { "ID": 234541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3887291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313206", "Detail": { "ID": 313206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3822255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289311", "Detail": { "ID": 289311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4317983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225303", "Detail": { "ID": 225303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9635678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265827", "Detail": { "ID": 265827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4562119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283257", "Detail": { "ID": 283257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.692636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251532", "Detail": { "ID": 251532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4677546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317566", "Detail": { "ID": 317566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4279645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254275", "Detail": { "ID": 254275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2485283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296212", "Detail": { "ID": 296212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8388674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235436", "Detail": { "ID": 235436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6776906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257629", "Detail": { "ID": 257629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0647532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228538", "Detail": { "ID": 228538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8034053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291623", "Detail": { "ID": 291623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1352843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311105", "Detail": { "ID": 311105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6056325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246453", "Detail": { "ID": 246453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.12937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298105", "Detail": { "ID": 298105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.138449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234137", "Detail": { "ID": 234137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1682371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274646", "Detail": { "ID": 274646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1155918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269588", "Detail": { "ID": 269588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5543314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317446", "Detail": { "ID": 317446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4224433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326323", "Detail": { "ID": 326323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.753507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241244", "Detail": { "ID": 241244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7492284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290326", "Detail": { "ID": 290326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7420108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248002", "Detail": { "ID": 248002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4375308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287454", "Detail": { "ID": 287454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8648851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222547", "Detail": { "ID": 222547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1936401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306998", "Detail": { "ID": 306998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5829099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239880", "Detail": { "ID": 239880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.763303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283505", "Detail": { "ID": 283505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7107957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231838", "Detail": { "ID": 231838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6177187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237703", "Detail": { "ID": 237703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2222125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309201", "Detail": { "ID": 309201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2043, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 1, "VoteAgainst": 75, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988.1", "ID": 6147 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0966979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252705", "Detail": { "ID": 252705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.750038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258919", "Detail": { "ID": 258919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.333903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319613", "Detail": { "ID": 319613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9338293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249521", "Detail": { "ID": 249521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9304567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227823", "Detail": { "ID": 227823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5671714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280824", "Detail": { "ID": 280824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7839512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262726", "Detail": { "ID": 262726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6142269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288090", "Detail": { "ID": 288090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8996371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229812", "Detail": { "ID": 229812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0984704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269797", "Detail": { "ID": 269797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5633453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322630", "Detail": { "ID": 322630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6969767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295933", "Detail": { "ID": 295933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5420414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242971", "Detail": { "ID": 242971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0433894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235170", "Detail": { "ID": 235170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4223926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302377", "Detail": { "ID": 302377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5217767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244277", "Detail": { "ID": 244277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.547725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327094", "Detail": { "ID": 327094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7985883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277065", "Detail": { "ID": 277065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6995877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264264", "Detail": { "ID": 264264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1258076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248706", "Detail": { "ID": 248706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.666315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294925", "Detail": { "ID": 294925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1846491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285230", "Detail": { "ID": 285230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.313997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230707", "Detail": { "ID": 230707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3418637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243747", "Detail": { "ID": 243747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3180678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254869", "Detail": { "ID": 254869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2873024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323701", "Detail": { "ID": 323701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9681694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291264", "Detail": { "ID": 291264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1113711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265402", "Detail": { "ID": 265402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4376268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262319", "Detail": { "ID": 262319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5963455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281916", "Detail": { "ID": 281916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1633095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298210", "Detail": { "ID": 298210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3359173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231226", "Detail": { "ID": 231226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5858324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285878", "Detail": { "ID": 285878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3484334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219459", "Detail": { "ID": 219459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.300158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238507", "Detail": { "ID": 238507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4570793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225175", "Detail": { "ID": 225175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7476951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321830", "Detail": { "ID": 321830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4531705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292808", "Detail": { "ID": 292808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5590129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227184", "Detail": { "ID": 227184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.271437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312737", "Detail": { "ID": 312737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.141167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257761", "Detail": { "ID": 257761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0764829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271233", "Detail": { "ID": 271233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.061422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278053", "Detail": { "ID": 278053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9849669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287272", "Detail": { "ID": 287272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.857036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250578", "Detail": { "ID": 250578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1956012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221042", "Detail": { "ID": 221042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6725735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220185", "Detail": { "ID": 220185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3380093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252397", "Detail": { "ID": 252397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7274034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253820", "Detail": { "ID": 253820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0222826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324704", "Detail": { "ID": 324704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2343281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259653", "Detail": { "ID": 259653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6187296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239389", "Detail": { "ID": 239389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7346929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273735", "Detail": { "ID": 273735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6334207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304108", "Detail": { "ID": 304108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8500155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221653", "Detail": { "ID": 221653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9419984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241883", "Detail": { "ID": 241883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7841341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223483", "Detail": { "ID": 223483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4603798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307793", "Detail": { "ID": 307793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8451686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272314", "Detail": { "ID": 272314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3246685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244982", "Detail": { "ID": 244982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5869402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315167", "Detail": { "ID": 315167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6772132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247879", "Detail": { "ID": 247879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4323197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274853", "Detail": { "ID": 274853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1245834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255729", "Detail": { "ID": 255729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5544037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277392", "Detail": { "ID": 277392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9514079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253082", "Detail": { "ID": 253082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7660826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276770", "Detail": { "ID": 276770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6803732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325427", "Detail": { "ID": 325427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5058794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232901", "Detail": { "ID": 232901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8815262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311485", "Detail": { "ID": 311485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8808758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230339", "Detail": { "ID": 230339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3187097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267423", "Detail": { "ID": 267423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0191731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313524", "Detail": { "ID": 313524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3990796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295017", "Detail": { "ID": 295017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1886264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319080", "Detail": { "ID": 319080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6915892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306320", "Detail": { "ID": 306320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5469807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310810", "Detail": { "ID": 310810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5870101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268181", "Detail": { "ID": 268181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0597125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286392", "Detail": { "ID": 286392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5771807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258557", "Detail": { "ID": 258557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3123865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263818", "Detail": { "ID": 263818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9060391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308522", "Detail": { "ID": 308522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0595466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279732", "Detail": { "ID": 279732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5202455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279607", "Detail": { "ID": 279607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5149424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261005", "Detail": { "ID": 261005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1075739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299608", "Detail": { "ID": 299608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7050619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306708", "Detail": { "ID": 306708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5639931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300626", "Detail": { "ID": 300626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0066931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223945", "Detail": { "ID": 223945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4853477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237867", "Detail": { "ID": 237867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2294969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305548", "Detail": { "ID": 305548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3290711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320346", "Detail": { "ID": 320346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1560596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315915", "Detail": { "ID": 315915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9377506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236693", "Detail": { "ID": 236693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9359999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289811", "Detail": { "ID": 289811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.460091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234540", "Detail": { "ID": 234540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3886881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313175", "Detail": { "ID": 313175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1668924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289312", "Detail": { "ID": 289312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.431839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225304", "Detail": { "ID": 225304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9636092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265826", "Detail": { "ID": 265826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4561706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283256", "Detail": { "ID": 283256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6925952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251533", "Detail": { "ID": 251533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.467797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317567", "Detail": { "ID": 317567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4280059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254274", "Detail": { "ID": 254274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2484869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296213", "Detail": { "ID": 296213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8389116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235437", "Detail": { "ID": 235437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6777313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257630", "Detail": { "ID": 257630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0647938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228539", "Detail": { "ID": 228539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8034691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291622", "Detail": { "ID": 291622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.135245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311136", "Detail": { "ID": 311136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6070277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246454", "Detail": { "ID": 246454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1294108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297588", "Detail": { "ID": 297588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1066493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234136", "Detail": { "ID": 234136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1681966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274647", "Detail": { "ID": 274647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1156527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269589", "Detail": { "ID": 269589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5543817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317477", "Detail": { "ID": 317477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4240943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326403", "Detail": { "ID": 326403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7569979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241245", "Detail": { "ID": 241245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7492692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290342", "Detail": { "ID": 290342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7427362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248003", "Detail": { "ID": 248003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4375894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287455", "Detail": { "ID": 287455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.864925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222548", "Detail": { "ID": 222548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1936803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306997", "Detail": { "ID": 306997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.582869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239879", "Detail": { "ID": 239879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7632624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283504", "Detail": { "ID": 283504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7107551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231837", "Detail": { "ID": 231837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6176592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237702", "Detail": { "ID": 237702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2221722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309200", "Detail": { "ID": 309200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2044, "AgendaID": 2620, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 16, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Trident", "Reference": "S4M-05988", "ID": 6129 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0966564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253102", "Detail": { "ID": 253102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7668679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259265", "Detail": { "ID": 259265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.601428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318735", "Detail": { "ID": 318735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6711744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250257", "Detail": { "ID": 250257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1813936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228429", "Detail": { "ID": 228429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7986337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281131", "Detail": { "ID": 281131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8073032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263061", "Detail": { "ID": 263061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6350821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288110", "Detail": { "ID": 288110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9005206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227478", "Detail": { "ID": 227478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.551879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269296", "Detail": { "ID": 269296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5413766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322470", "Detail": { "ID": 322470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.690006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295906", "Detail": { "ID": 295906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5408943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243094", "Detail": { "ID": 243094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0486482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227040", "Detail": { "ID": 227040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.264904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301057", "Detail": { "ID": 301057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0309491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238392", "Detail": { "ID": 238392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.444564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327009", "Detail": { "ID": 327009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7896657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277557", "Detail": { "ID": 277557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9584514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263929", "Detail": { "ID": 263929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9168608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250951", "Detail": { "ID": 250951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2205951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294815", "Detail": { "ID": 294815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1795471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285412", "Detail": { "ID": 285412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3219203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231348", "Detail": { "ID": 231348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5910542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243624", "Detail": { "ID": 243624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3129162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254354", "Detail": { "ID": 254354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2519656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323462", "Detail": { "ID": 323462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9572185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300658", "Detail": { "ID": 300658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.008062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273109", "Detail": { "ID": 273109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3699803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262640", "Detail": { "ID": 262640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6105562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281763", "Detail": { "ID": 281763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1565777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298517", "Detail": { "ID": 298517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3495418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230629", "Detail": { "ID": 230629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3386327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285840", "Detail": { "ID": 285840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3467885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219625", "Detail": { "ID": 219625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3074697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238161", "Detail": { "ID": 238161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.247541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226683", "Detail": { "ID": 226683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2420915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321990", "Detail": { "ID": 321990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4601661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292269", "Detail": { "ID": 292269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5264935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227653", "Detail": { "ID": 227653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5595824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304541", "Detail": { "ID": 304541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0428422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257869", "Detail": { "ID": 257869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0811023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271194", "Detail": { "ID": 271194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8465017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274341", "Detail": { "ID": 274341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0964295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266421", "Detail": { "ID": 266421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7402025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250686", "Detail": { "ID": 250686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2092277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221153", "Detail": { "ID": 221153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6773544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226439", "Detail": { "ID": 226439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2314369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239731", "Detail": { "ID": 239731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7564986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253199", "Detail": { "ID": 253199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9856074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324789", "Detail": { "ID": 324789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2379045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260963", "Detail": { "ID": 260963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1055341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246062", "Detail": { "ID": 246062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8705523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273554", "Detail": { "ID": 273554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.625409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303658", "Detail": { "ID": 303658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8247741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223161", "Detail": { "ID": 223161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2312222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245672", "Detail": { "ID": 245672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8535161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223327", "Detail": { "ID": 223327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4531048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308100", "Detail": { "ID": 308100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8647121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272422", "Detail": { "ID": 272422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3346576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245105", "Detail": { "ID": 245105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5922506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315276", "Detail": { "ID": 315276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9015336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247074", "Detail": { "ID": 247074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1659334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275046", "Detail": { "ID": 275046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1388364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255073", "Detail": { "ID": 255073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2960515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277353", "Detail": { "ID": 277353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9446026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254050", "Detail": { "ID": 254050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.032356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278849", "Detail": { "ID": 278849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2368792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325342", "Detail": { "ID": 325342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4945687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231947", "Detail": { "ID": 231947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6226402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311791", "Detail": { "ID": 311791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8944304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233167", "Detail": { "ID": 233167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8997609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267577", "Detail": { "ID": 267577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0258648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313061", "Detail": { "ID": 313061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1619402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294400", "Detail": { "ID": 294400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1367068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319239", "Detail": { "ID": 319239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9114692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306209", "Detail": { "ID": 306209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5422239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310274", "Detail": { "ID": 310274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5634233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268027", "Detail": { "ID": 268027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.052824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293026", "Detail": { "ID": 293026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5684328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271840", "Detail": { "ID": 271840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0937082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269473", "Detail": { "ID": 269473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5490808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307318", "Detail": { "ID": 307318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8240536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280206", "Detail": { "ID": 280206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7506271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279116", "Detail": { "ID": 279116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2537131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260415", "Detail": { "ID": 260415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0758875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299300", "Detail": { "ID": 299300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6915272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302185", "Detail": { "ID": 302185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.301233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300242", "Detail": { "ID": 300242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9895224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224210", "Detail": { "ID": 224210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6887823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237955", "Detail": { "ID": 237955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2333002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305658", "Detail": { "ID": 305658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3338368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320031", "Detail": { "ID": 320031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9584196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315807", "Detail": { "ID": 315807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.927904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237183", "Detail": { "ID": 237183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9693326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288860", "Detail": { "ID": 288860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1615002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234183", "Detail": { "ID": 234183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1702227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312910", "Detail": { "ID": 312910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1551453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290206", "Detail": { "ID": 290206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7368183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225614", "Detail": { "ID": 225614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9829391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265623", "Detail": { "ID": 265623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4472048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284175", "Detail": { "ID": 284175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7462375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252157", "Detail": { "ID": 252157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.505055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317254", "Detail": { "ID": 317254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.410501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256678", "Detail": { "ID": 256678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7930138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293909", "Detail": { "ID": 293909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8740347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235916", "Detail": { "ID": 235916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6984674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255931", "Detail": { "ID": 255931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5631348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229263", "Detail": { "ID": 229263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0691313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289487", "Detail": { "ID": 289487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4393736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311557", "Detail": { "ID": 311557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8840092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246870", "Detail": { "ID": 246870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1569298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297616", "Detail": { "ID": 297616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1078549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233801", "Detail": { "ID": 233801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1469206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274967", "Detail": { "ID": 274967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1297824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270053", "Detail": { "ID": 270053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5795126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317741", "Detail": { "ID": 317741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4353786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326488", "Detail": { "ID": 326488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7668506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241354", "Detail": { "ID": 241354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7543058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290466", "Detail": { "ID": 290466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7482977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248168", "Detail": { "ID": 248168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4460502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289234", "Detail": { "ID": 289234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4284411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222704", "Detail": { "ID": 222704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2005489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306871", "Detail": { "ID": 306871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5772999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240921", "Detail": { "ID": 240921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3881316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283696", "Detail": { "ID": 283696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7193286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231078", "Detail": { "ID": 231078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3646708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247271", "Detail": { "ID": 247271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3964075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308890", "Detail": { "ID": 308890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2040, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 10, "VoteAgainst": 72, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.2", "ID": 6127 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.08249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253103", "Detail": { "ID": 253103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.766909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259266", "Detail": { "ID": 259266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6014758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318734", "Detail": { "ID": 318734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6711336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250256", "Detail": { "ID": 250256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1813517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228430", "Detail": { "ID": 228430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7986745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281133", "Detail": { "ID": 281133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8073834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263062", "Detail": { "ID": 263062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.635123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288109", "Detail": { "ID": 288109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9004784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227479", "Detail": { "ID": 227479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5519209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269295", "Detail": { "ID": 269295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5413349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322468", "Detail": { "ID": 322468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6899244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295907", "Detail": { "ID": 295907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5409345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243095", "Detail": { "ID": 243095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0486889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227039", "Detail": { "ID": 227039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.264863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301058", "Detail": { "ID": 301058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0310045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238391", "Detail": { "ID": 238391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.444522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327010", "Detail": { "ID": 327010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7897079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277558", "Detail": { "ID": 277558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9584913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263928", "Detail": { "ID": 263928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.91682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250950", "Detail": { "ID": 250950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2205545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294814", "Detail": { "ID": 294814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1795058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285413", "Detail": { "ID": 285413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3219618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231349", "Detail": { "ID": 231349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5910945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243623", "Detail": { "ID": 243623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3128758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254353", "Detail": { "ID": 254353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2519247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323463", "Detail": { "ID": 323463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9572787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300657", "Detail": { "ID": 300657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0080203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273110", "Detail": { "ID": 273110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3700223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262641", "Detail": { "ID": 262641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6105981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281761", "Detail": { "ID": 281761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1564982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298519", "Detail": { "ID": 298519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3496236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230628", "Detail": { "ID": 230628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3385914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285841", "Detail": { "ID": 285841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3468293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219626", "Detail": { "ID": 219626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3075114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238160", "Detail": { "ID": 238160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2475001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226682", "Detail": { "ID": 226682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2420506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321992", "Detail": { "ID": 321992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4602473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292272", "Detail": { "ID": 292272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.526618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227654", "Detail": { "ID": 227654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5596284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304542", "Detail": { "ID": 304542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0428937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257870", "Detail": { "ID": 257870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0811427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271195", "Detail": { "ID": 271195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8465417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274339", "Detail": { "ID": 274339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0963238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266422", "Detail": { "ID": 266422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7402544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250687", "Detail": { "ID": 250687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2092698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221154", "Detail": { "ID": 221154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6773957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226438", "Detail": { "ID": 226438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2313955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239732", "Detail": { "ID": 239732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7565386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253197", "Detail": { "ID": 253197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9854981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324788", "Detail": { "ID": 324788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.237864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260962", "Detail": { "ID": 260962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1054923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246063", "Detail": { "ID": 246063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8705927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273553", "Detail": { "ID": 273553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6253682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303657", "Detail": { "ID": 303657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8247338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223160", "Detail": { "ID": 223160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2311817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245671", "Detail": { "ID": 245671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8534756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223326", "Detail": { "ID": 223326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4530636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308102", "Detail": { "ID": 308102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8647942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272423", "Detail": { "ID": 272423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3346989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245106", "Detail": { "ID": 245106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5922936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315277", "Detail": { "ID": 315277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9046235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247073", "Detail": { "ID": 247073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1658924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275045", "Detail": { "ID": 275045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1387949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255072", "Detail": { "ID": 255072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2960098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277354", "Detail": { "ID": 277354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9446429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254051", "Detail": { "ID": 254051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.032397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278848", "Detail": { "ID": 278848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.236839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325343", "Detail": { "ID": 325343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4946099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231948", "Detail": { "ID": 231948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.622683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311793", "Detail": { "ID": 311793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8945304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233166", "Detail": { "ID": 233166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8997199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267579", "Detail": { "ID": 267579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0259753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313059", "Detail": { "ID": 313059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1618579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294398", "Detail": { "ID": 294398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1366238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319241", "Detail": { "ID": 319241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9115734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306208", "Detail": { "ID": 306208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5421828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310285", "Detail": { "ID": 310285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.563908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268025", "Detail": { "ID": 268025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0527412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293028", "Detail": { "ID": 293028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5685327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271839", "Detail": { "ID": 271839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0936663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269472", "Detail": { "ID": 269472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5490396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307307", "Detail": { "ID": 307307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8235829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280207", "Detail": { "ID": 280207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7506686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279115", "Detail": { "ID": 279115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2536719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260414", "Detail": { "ID": 260414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0758456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299298", "Detail": { "ID": 299298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6914457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302179", "Detail": { "ID": 302179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.300925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300245", "Detail": { "ID": 300245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9896461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224211", "Detail": { "ID": 224211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6888344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237956", "Detail": { "ID": 237956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2333415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305659", "Detail": { "ID": 305659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3338776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320029", "Detail": { "ID": 320029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9583381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315806", "Detail": { "ID": 315806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9278621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237184", "Detail": { "ID": 237184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1929466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288859", "Detail": { "ID": 288859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1614597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234182", "Detail": { "ID": 234182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.170181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312909", "Detail": { "ID": 312909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1551045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261387", "Detail": { "ID": 261387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3551549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225615", "Detail": { "ID": 225615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.982981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265622", "Detail": { "ID": 265622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4471627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284174", "Detail": { "ID": 284174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7461963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252158", "Detail": { "ID": 252158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.505096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317252", "Detail": { "ID": 317252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4104159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256677", "Detail": { "ID": 256677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7929729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293903", "Detail": { "ID": 293903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8737832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235917", "Detail": { "ID": 235917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6985085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255932", "Detail": { "ID": 255932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5631751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229264", "Detail": { "ID": 229264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0691724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289486", "Detail": { "ID": 289486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4393138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311558", "Detail": { "ID": 311558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8840528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246871", "Detail": { "ID": 246871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1569713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297615", "Detail": { "ID": 297615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1077969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233800", "Detail": { "ID": 233800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1468425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274968", "Detail": { "ID": 274968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1298241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270055", "Detail": { "ID": 270055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5795941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317742", "Detail": { "ID": 317742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4354207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326487", "Detail": { "ID": 326487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7668102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241355", "Detail": { "ID": 241355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7543663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290467", "Detail": { "ID": 290467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7483389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248169", "Detail": { "ID": 248169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.446105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289235", "Detail": { "ID": 289235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4284826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222705", "Detail": { "ID": 222705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2005901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306874", "Detail": { "ID": 306874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5773407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240920", "Detail": { "ID": 240920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3880901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283695", "Detail": { "ID": 283695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7192692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231077", "Detail": { "ID": 231077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3646304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247270", "Detail": { "ID": 247270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3963612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308888", "Detail": { "ID": 308888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2041, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981.1", "ID": 6124 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0824076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253101", "Detail": { "ID": 253101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7668269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259262", "Detail": { "ID": 259262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6012846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318736", "Detail": { "ID": 318736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6712149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250258", "Detail": { "ID": 250258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1814529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228428", "Detail": { "ID": 228428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7985909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281130", "Detail": { "ID": 281130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.807263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263060", "Detail": { "ID": 263060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6350412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288113", "Detail": { "ID": 288113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9006454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227477", "Detail": { "ID": 227477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5518381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269299", "Detail": { "ID": 269299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5415315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322469", "Detail": { "ID": 322469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6899656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295905", "Detail": { "ID": 295905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5408544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243093", "Detail": { "ID": 243093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.048607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227041", "Detail": { "ID": 227041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2649456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301056", "Detail": { "ID": 301056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.030896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238393", "Detail": { "ID": 238393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4446054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327008", "Detail": { "ID": 327008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7896243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277556", "Detail": { "ID": 277556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9584109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263930", "Detail": { "ID": 263930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9169212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250952", "Detail": { "ID": 250952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2206355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294816", "Detail": { "ID": 294816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1795877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285411", "Detail": { "ID": 285411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3218786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231347", "Detail": { "ID": 231347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.591014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243625", "Detail": { "ID": 243625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.312956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254355", "Detail": { "ID": 254355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2520305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323461", "Detail": { "ID": 323461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9571766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300659", "Detail": { "ID": 300659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0081019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273108", "Detail": { "ID": 273108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.369921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262639", "Detail": { "ID": 262639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6105161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281764", "Detail": { "ID": 281764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1566371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298516", "Detail": { "ID": 298516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3495008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230630", "Detail": { "ID": 230630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3386729+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285837", "Detail": { "ID": 285837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3466651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219624", "Detail": { "ID": 219624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3074267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238164", "Detail": { "ID": 238164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2476867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226684", "Detail": { "ID": 226684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.242132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321991", "Detail": { "ID": 321991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4602066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292684", "Detail": { "ID": 292684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5533813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227652", "Detail": { "ID": 227652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5594417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304540", "Detail": { "ID": 304540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0426915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257868", "Detail": { "ID": 257868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0810615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271191", "Detail": { "ID": 271191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8463616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274342", "Detail": { "ID": 274342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1018555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266420", "Detail": { "ID": 266420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7401585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250685", "Detail": { "ID": 250685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2091631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221152", "Detail": { "ID": 221152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.677313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226440", "Detail": { "ID": 226440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2314784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239730", "Detail": { "ID": 239730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7564589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253200", "Detail": { "ID": 253200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9856595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324790", "Detail": { "ID": 324790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.237944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260964", "Detail": { "ID": 260964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1055752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246059", "Detail": { "ID": 246059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8704299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273555", "Detail": { "ID": 273555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6254495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303659", "Detail": { "ID": 303659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8248149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223162", "Detail": { "ID": 223162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2312625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245673", "Detail": { "ID": 245673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8535568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223328", "Detail": { "ID": 223328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4531463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308099", "Detail": { "ID": 308099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.86467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272421", "Detail": { "ID": 272421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3346158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245104", "Detail": { "ID": 245104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5921813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315275", "Detail": { "ID": 315275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9014927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247077", "Detail": { "ID": 247077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1660776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275049", "Detail": { "ID": 275049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1389797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255076", "Detail": { "ID": 255076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2961737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277350", "Detail": { "ID": 277350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9444571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254047", "Detail": { "ID": 254047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0322331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278850", "Detail": { "ID": 278850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.236935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325341", "Detail": { "ID": 325341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.494526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231946", "Detail": { "ID": 231946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6225796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311790", "Detail": { "ID": 311790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8943894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233168", "Detail": { "ID": 233168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8998019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267576", "Detail": { "ID": 267576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0258236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313062", "Detail": { "ID": 313062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.161981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294401", "Detail": { "ID": 294401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1367477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319240", "Detail": { "ID": 319240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.91151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306210", "Detail": { "ID": 306210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5422652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310384", "Detail": { "ID": 310384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5682017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268028", "Detail": { "ID": 268028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0528897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293025", "Detail": { "ID": 293025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5683926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271841", "Detail": { "ID": 271841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0937485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269474", "Detail": { "ID": 269474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5491221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308801", "Detail": { "ID": 308801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0718474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280205", "Detail": { "ID": 280205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7505851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279117", "Detail": { "ID": 279117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2537539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260416", "Detail": { "ID": 260416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0759287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299301", "Detail": { "ID": 299301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6915677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306832", "Detail": { "ID": 306832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5756327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300502", "Detail": { "ID": 300502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.000947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224209", "Detail": { "ID": 224209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.688728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237954", "Detail": { "ID": 237954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2332587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305657", "Detail": { "ID": 305657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3337959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320030", "Detail": { "ID": 320030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9583788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315808", "Detail": { "ID": 315808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9279448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237182", "Detail": { "ID": 237182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9692925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288861", "Detail": { "ID": 288861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1615404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234184", "Detail": { "ID": 234184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1702636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312911", "Detail": { "ID": 312911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1551866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290205", "Detail": { "ID": 290205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7367146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225613", "Detail": { "ID": 225613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9828967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265624", "Detail": { "ID": 265624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4472457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284176", "Detail": { "ID": 284176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7462969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252156", "Detail": { "ID": 252156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5050139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317253", "Detail": { "ID": 317253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.41046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256679", "Detail": { "ID": 256679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7930542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296951", "Detail": { "ID": 296951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.880998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235915", "Detail": { "ID": 235915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.698426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255930", "Detail": { "ID": 255930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5630945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229262", "Detail": { "ID": 229262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0690887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289488", "Detail": { "ID": 289488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4394159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311556", "Detail": { "ID": 311556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8839491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246869", "Detail": { "ID": 246869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1568716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297617", "Detail": { "ID": 297617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1078974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233802", "Detail": { "ID": 233802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1469646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274966", "Detail": { "ID": 274966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.129741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270052", "Detail": { "ID": 270052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5794712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317740", "Detail": { "ID": 317740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4353376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326489", "Detail": { "ID": 326489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.766891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241353", "Detail": { "ID": 241353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7542647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290465", "Detail": { "ID": 290465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7482556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248167", "Detail": { "ID": 248167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4460003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289233", "Detail": { "ID": 289233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4283995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222703", "Detail": { "ID": 222703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2005066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306915", "Detail": { "ID": 306915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5793549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240922", "Detail": { "ID": 240922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3881737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283699", "Detail": { "ID": 283699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7194512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231079", "Detail": { "ID": 231079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3647119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247272", "Detail": { "ID": 247272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3964559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308891", "Detail": { "ID": 308891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2039, "AgendaID": 2424, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 73, "VoteAgainst": 10, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "10 Years on from the Invasion of Iraq", "Reference": "S4M-05981", "ID": 6120 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0825308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253098", "Detail": { "ID": 253098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7667009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259259", "Detail": { "ID": 259259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6011603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318739", "Detail": { "ID": 318739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6713354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250261", "Detail": { "ID": 250261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1815787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228425", "Detail": { "ID": 228425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7984655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281127", "Detail": { "ID": 281127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8071411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263057", "Detail": { "ID": 263057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6349167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288116", "Detail": { "ID": 288116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.900771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230514", "Detail": { "ID": 230514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3334558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269302", "Detail": { "ID": 269302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5416578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322472", "Detail": { "ID": 322472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6901076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295902", "Detail": { "ID": 295902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5407328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243090", "Detail": { "ID": 243090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0484838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235194", "Detail": { "ID": 235194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4234238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302463", "Detail": { "ID": 302463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5256694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238396", "Detail": { "ID": 238396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4447301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327005", "Detail": { "ID": 327005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7894987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277553", "Detail": { "ID": 277553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9582885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263933", "Detail": { "ID": 263933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9170457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250955", "Detail": { "ID": 250955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2207749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294819", "Detail": { "ID": 294819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1797132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285408", "Detail": { "ID": 285408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3217532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231344", "Detail": { "ID": 231344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5908911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243628", "Detail": { "ID": 243628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3130767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254471", "Detail": { "ID": 254471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2575664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323458", "Detail": { "ID": 323458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.957052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300662", "Detail": { "ID": 300662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0082243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273105", "Detail": { "ID": 273105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3697971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262636", "Detail": { "ID": 262636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6103744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281767", "Detail": { "ID": 281767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.15676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298513", "Detail": { "ID": 298513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3493567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231153", "Detail": { "ID": 231153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3678879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285834", "Detail": { "ID": 285834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3465404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219433", "Detail": { "ID": 219433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2987652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238167", "Detail": { "ID": 238167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2478124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226687", "Detail": { "ID": 226687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2422556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321988", "Detail": { "ID": 321988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4600829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292687", "Detail": { "ID": 292687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5535258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227159", "Detail": { "ID": 227159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2703631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313284", "Detail": { "ID": 313284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.388676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257865", "Detail": { "ID": 257865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0809187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271188", "Detail": { "ID": 271188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8462394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274345", "Detail": { "ID": 274345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1020136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287359", "Detail": { "ID": 287359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8608343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250682", "Detail": { "ID": 250682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2090413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221149", "Detail": { "ID": 221149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6771676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220210", "Detail": { "ID": 220210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3390938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252787", "Detail": { "ID": 252787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7532651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253203", "Detail": { "ID": 253203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9858167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324793", "Detail": { "ID": 324793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2380831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260967", "Detail": { "ID": 260967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1056983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246056", "Detail": { "ID": 246056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8703071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273558", "Detail": { "ID": 273558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.625573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304023", "Detail": { "ID": 304023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8460769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223165", "Detail": { "ID": 223165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2314255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245676", "Detail": { "ID": 245676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8536982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223508", "Detail": { "ID": 223508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4614574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308096", "Detail": { "ID": 308096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8645454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272418", "Detail": { "ID": 272418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3344735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245101", "Detail": { "ID": 245101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5920374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315272", "Detail": { "ID": 315272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9013681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247385", "Detail": { "ID": 247385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.40154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275052", "Detail": { "ID": 275052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1391046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255079", "Detail": { "ID": 255079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2962972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277347", "Detail": { "ID": 277347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9443357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254044", "Detail": { "ID": 254044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0321081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278853", "Detail": { "ID": 278853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2370591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325338", "Detail": { "ID": 325338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4943828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233286", "Detail": { "ID": 233286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1174651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311787", "Detail": { "ID": 311787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8942647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230363", "Detail": { "ID": 230363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3197574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267573", "Detail": { "ID": 267573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0256995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313065", "Detail": { "ID": 313065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1621295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294404", "Detail": { "ID": 294404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1368709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319237", "Detail": { "ID": 319237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9113866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306213", "Detail": { "ID": 306213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5423902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310387", "Detail": { "ID": 310387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.568326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268031", "Detail": { "ID": 268031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0530159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293022", "Detail": { "ID": 293022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5682687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271844", "Detail": { "ID": 271844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0938717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269477", "Detail": { "ID": 269477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5492463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308798", "Detail": { "ID": 308798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0716975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280202", "Detail": { "ID": 280202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7504579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279120", "Detail": { "ID": 279120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2538784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260419", "Detail": { "ID": 260419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0760543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299304", "Detail": { "ID": 299304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6916912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306829", "Detail": { "ID": 306829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5754879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300505", "Detail": { "ID": 300505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0011703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224206", "Detail": { "ID": 224206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6885016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237951", "Detail": { "ID": 237951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2331338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305654", "Detail": { "ID": 305654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3336723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320033", "Detail": { "ID": 320033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9585018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315811", "Detail": { "ID": 315811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9280683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237179", "Detail": { "ID": 237179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.969153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288864", "Detail": { "ID": 288864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1616625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234299", "Detail": { "ID": 234299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3712862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312914", "Detail": { "ID": 312914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1553289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290202", "Detail": { "ID": 290202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7365561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225279", "Detail": { "ID": 225279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9625404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265739", "Detail": { "ID": 265739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4523948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284179", "Detail": { "ID": 284179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7464225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252153", "Detail": { "ID": 252153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5048882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317256", "Detail": { "ID": 317256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4105834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256682", "Detail": { "ID": 256682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7931772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296948", "Detail": { "ID": 296948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8808777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235414", "Detail": { "ID": 235414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6697284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257716", "Detail": { "ID": 257716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0744682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229259", "Detail": { "ID": 229259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0689422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291070", "Detail": { "ID": 291070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7841777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311553", "Detail": { "ID": 311553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8838233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246866", "Detail": { "ID": 246866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1567489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297620", "Detail": { "ID": 297620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1080229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233805", "Detail": { "ID": 233805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1470917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274963", "Detail": { "ID": 274963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1295885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270049", "Detail": { "ID": 270049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5793469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317737", "Detail": { "ID": 317737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4351946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326492", "Detail": { "ID": 326492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7670136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241350", "Detail": { "ID": 241350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7541407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290462", "Detail": { "ID": 290462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7481125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248164", "Detail": { "ID": 248164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.445841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289230", "Detail": { "ID": 289230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4282759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222523", "Detail": { "ID": 222523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.192623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306918", "Detail": { "ID": 306918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5794806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240925", "Detail": { "ID": 240925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283702", "Detail": { "ID": 283702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7195748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231082", "Detail": { "ID": 231082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3648339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237725", "Detail": { "ID": 237725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2231488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308894", "Detail": { "ID": 308894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2036, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.3", "ID": 6095 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0826549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253099", "Detail": { "ID": 253099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.766743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259260", "Detail": { "ID": 259260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6012022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318738", "Detail": { "ID": 318738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6712955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250260", "Detail": { "ID": 250260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1815367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228426", "Detail": { "ID": 228426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7985078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281128", "Detail": { "ID": 281128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8071819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263058", "Detail": { "ID": 263058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6349579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288115", "Detail": { "ID": 288115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9007286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230551", "Detail": { "ID": 230551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.335277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269301", "Detail": { "ID": 269301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5416164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322473", "Detail": { "ID": 322473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6901494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295903", "Detail": { "ID": 295903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.540774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243091", "Detail": { "ID": 243091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0485249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227043", "Detail": { "ID": 227043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2650293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301054", "Detail": { "ID": 301054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0307927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238395", "Detail": { "ID": 238395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4446893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327006", "Detail": { "ID": 327006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7895407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277554", "Detail": { "ID": 277554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9583295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263932", "Detail": { "ID": 263932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9170048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250954", "Detail": { "ID": 250954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2207158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294818", "Detail": { "ID": 294818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1796717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285409", "Detail": { "ID": 285409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3217951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231345", "Detail": { "ID": 231345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5909318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243627", "Detail": { "ID": 243627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3130367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254357", "Detail": { "ID": 254357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2521156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323459", "Detail": { "ID": 323459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9570935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300661", "Detail": { "ID": 300661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0081832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273106", "Detail": { "ID": 273106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3698387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262637", "Detail": { "ID": 262637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6104148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281766", "Detail": { "ID": 281766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.15672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298514", "Detail": { "ID": 298514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3493987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230632", "Detail": { "ID": 230632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3387554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285835", "Detail": { "ID": 285835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.346582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219622", "Detail": { "ID": 219622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3073236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238166", "Detail": { "ID": 238166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2477707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226686", "Detail": { "ID": 226686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2422148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321987", "Detail": { "ID": 321987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4600187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292686", "Detail": { "ID": 292686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5534644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227650", "Detail": { "ID": 227650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5593591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304618", "Detail": { "ID": 304618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0461293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257866", "Detail": { "ID": 257866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0809781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271189", "Detail": { "ID": 271189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.84628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274344", "Detail": { "ID": 274344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1019703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266418", "Detail": { "ID": 266418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7400078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250683", "Detail": { "ID": 250683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2090821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221150", "Detail": { "ID": 221150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6772088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226442", "Detail": { "ID": 226442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2315856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239728", "Detail": { "ID": 239728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7563774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253202", "Detail": { "ID": 253202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9857636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324792", "Detail": { "ID": 324792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2380246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260966", "Detail": { "ID": 260966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1056573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246057", "Detail": { "ID": 246057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8703483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273557", "Detail": { "ID": 273557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6255317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303661", "Detail": { "ID": 303661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8249179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223164", "Detail": { "ID": 223164, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2313828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245675", "Detail": { "ID": 245675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8536381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223330", "Detail": { "ID": 223330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4532293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308097", "Detail": { "ID": 308097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8645873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272419", "Detail": { "ID": 272419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3345152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245102", "Detail": { "ID": 245102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5920971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315273", "Detail": { "ID": 315273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9014101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247384", "Detail": { "ID": 247384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4014984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275051", "Detail": { "ID": 275051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1390633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255078", "Detail": { "ID": 255078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2962565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277348", "Detail": { "ID": 277348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9443764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254045", "Detail": { "ID": 254045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0321504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278852", "Detail": { "ID": 278852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2370186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325339", "Detail": { "ID": 325339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4944245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231944", "Detail": { "ID": 231944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6224955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311788", "Detail": { "ID": 311788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8943069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233170", "Detail": { "ID": 233170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8998855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267574", "Detail": { "ID": 267574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0257413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313064", "Detail": { "ID": 313064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.162087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294403", "Detail": { "ID": 294403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1368302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319236", "Detail": { "ID": 319236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9113457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306212", "Detail": { "ID": 306212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5423487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310386", "Detail": { "ID": 310386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5682851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268030", "Detail": { "ID": 268030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0529742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293023", "Detail": { "ID": 293023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5683097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271843", "Detail": { "ID": 271843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0938311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269476", "Detail": { "ID": 269476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5492054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308799", "Detail": { "ID": 308799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0717621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280203", "Detail": { "ID": 280203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7505008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279119", "Detail": { "ID": 279119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2538371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260418", "Detail": { "ID": 260418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0760121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299303", "Detail": { "ID": 299303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6916502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306830", "Detail": { "ID": 306830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5755479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300504", "Detail": { "ID": 300504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0011188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224207", "Detail": { "ID": 224207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6886149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237952", "Detail": { "ID": 237952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2331754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305655", "Detail": { "ID": 305655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3337136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320034", "Detail": { "ID": 320034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9585434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315810", "Detail": { "ID": 315810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9280273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237180", "Detail": { "ID": 237180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9691931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288863", "Detail": { "ID": 288863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1616221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234186", "Detail": { "ID": 234186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1703461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312913", "Detail": { "ID": 312913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1552869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290203", "Detail": { "ID": 290203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7366093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225611", "Detail": { "ID": 225611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9827934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265626", "Detail": { "ID": 265626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4473281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284178", "Detail": { "ID": 284178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7463815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252154", "Detail": { "ID": 252154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5049309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317257", "Detail": { "ID": 317257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4106248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256681", "Detail": { "ID": 256681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7931364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296949", "Detail": { "ID": 296949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.880918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235913", "Detail": { "ID": 235913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6983251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255928", "Detail": { "ID": 255928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5629937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229260", "Detail": { "ID": 229260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0690034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289490", "Detail": { "ID": 289490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4394975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311554", "Detail": { "ID": 311554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.883866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246867", "Detail": { "ID": 246867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1567898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297619", "Detail": { "ID": 297619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1079818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233804", "Detail": { "ID": 233804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1470503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274964", "Detail": { "ID": 274964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1296561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270050", "Detail": { "ID": 270050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5793889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317738", "Detail": { "ID": 317738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4352361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326491", "Detail": { "ID": 326491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7669733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241351", "Detail": { "ID": 241351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7541818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290463", "Detail": { "ID": 290463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7481542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248165", "Detail": { "ID": 248165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4458947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289231", "Detail": { "ID": 289231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4283171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222701", "Detail": { "ID": 222701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.200422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306917", "Detail": { "ID": 306917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5794387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240924", "Detail": { "ID": 240924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3882584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283701", "Detail": { "ID": 283701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7195336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231081", "Detail": { "ID": 231081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3647932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247274", "Detail": { "ID": 247274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3965397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308893", "Detail": { "ID": 308893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2037, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 83, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.2", "ID": 6087 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0826139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253100", "Detail": { "ID": 253100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7667856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259261", "Detail": { "ID": 259261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6012433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318737", "Detail": { "ID": 318737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6712554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250259", "Detail": { "ID": 250259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1814953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228427", "Detail": { "ID": 228427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7985497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281129", "Detail": { "ID": 281129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8072228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263059", "Detail": { "ID": 263059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6349993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288114", "Detail": { "ID": 288114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9006868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227476", "Detail": { "ID": 227476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5517973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269300", "Detail": { "ID": 269300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5415737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322474", "Detail": { "ID": 322474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6901907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295904", "Detail": { "ID": 295904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5408143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243092", "Detail": { "ID": 243092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.048566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227042", "Detail": { "ID": 227042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2649879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301055", "Detail": { "ID": 301055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.030844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238394", "Detail": { "ID": 238394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4446479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327007", "Detail": { "ID": 327007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7895829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277555", "Detail": { "ID": 277555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9583701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263931", "Detail": { "ID": 263931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9169637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250953", "Detail": { "ID": 250953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2206757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294817", "Detail": { "ID": 294817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1796293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285410", "Detail": { "ID": 285410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3218363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231346", "Detail": { "ID": 231346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5909733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243626", "Detail": { "ID": 243626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3129968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254356", "Detail": { "ID": 254356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2520739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323460", "Detail": { "ID": 323460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9571346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300660", "Detail": { "ID": 300660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0081422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273107", "Detail": { "ID": 273107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3698796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262638", "Detail": { "ID": 262638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6104741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281765", "Detail": { "ID": 281765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1566792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298515", "Detail": { "ID": 298515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.349458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230631", "Detail": { "ID": 230631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3387138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285836", "Detail": { "ID": 285836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3466238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219623", "Detail": { "ID": 219623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3073655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238165", "Detail": { "ID": 238165, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2477292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226685", "Detail": { "ID": 226685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2421737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321986", "Detail": { "ID": 321986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4599772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292685", "Detail": { "ID": 292685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.553423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227651", "Detail": { "ID": 227651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5594007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304619", "Detail": { "ID": 304619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0461708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257867", "Detail": { "ID": 257867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0810204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271190", "Detail": { "ID": 271190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8463211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274343", "Detail": { "ID": 274343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1019252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266419", "Detail": { "ID": 266419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7400497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250684", "Detail": { "ID": 250684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2091229+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221151", "Detail": { "ID": 221151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6772691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226441", "Detail": { "ID": 226441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2315207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239729", "Detail": { "ID": 239729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7564186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253201", "Detail": { "ID": 253201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9857116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324791", "Detail": { "ID": 324791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2379841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260965", "Detail": { "ID": 260965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1056165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246058", "Detail": { "ID": 246058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8703892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273556", "Detail": { "ID": 273556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6254906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303660", "Detail": { "ID": 303660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8248753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223163", "Detail": { "ID": 223163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2313222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245674", "Detail": { "ID": 245674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8535975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223329", "Detail": { "ID": 223329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4531874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308098", "Detail": { "ID": 308098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8646289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272420", "Detail": { "ID": 272420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3345555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245103", "Detail": { "ID": 245103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5921401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315274", "Detail": { "ID": 315274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9014516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247383", "Detail": { "ID": 247383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.401457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275050", "Detail": { "ID": 275050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1390218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255077", "Detail": { "ID": 255077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2962148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277349", "Detail": { "ID": 277349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9444167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254046", "Detail": { "ID": 254046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0321922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278851", "Detail": { "ID": 278851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2369778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325340", "Detail": { "ID": 325340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.494466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231945", "Detail": { "ID": 231945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6225374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311789", "Detail": { "ID": 311789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8943487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233169", "Detail": { "ID": 233169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8998439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267575", "Detail": { "ID": 267575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.025783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313063", "Detail": { "ID": 313063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1620425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294402", "Detail": { "ID": 294402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1367888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319235", "Detail": { "ID": 319235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9113047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306211", "Detail": { "ID": 306211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5423076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310385", "Detail": { "ID": 310385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5682437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268029", "Detail": { "ID": 268029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0529328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293024", "Detail": { "ID": 293024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5683505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271842", "Detail": { "ID": 271842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0937897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269475", "Detail": { "ID": 269475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5491643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308800", "Detail": { "ID": 308800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0718057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280204", "Detail": { "ID": 280204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7505435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279118", "Detail": { "ID": 279118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2537956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260417", "Detail": { "ID": 260417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0759703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299302", "Detail": { "ID": 299302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6916094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306831", "Detail": { "ID": 306831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5755905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300503", "Detail": { "ID": 300503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0009885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224208", "Detail": { "ID": 224208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.688673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237953", "Detail": { "ID": 237953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2332173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305656", "Detail": { "ID": 305656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3337545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320035", "Detail": { "ID": 320035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9586038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315809", "Detail": { "ID": 315809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9279859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237181", "Detail": { "ID": 237181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9692516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288862", "Detail": { "ID": 288862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1615815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234185", "Detail": { "ID": 234185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1703049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312912", "Detail": { "ID": 312912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1552277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290204", "Detail": { "ID": 290204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7366621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225612", "Detail": { "ID": 225612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9828347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265625", "Detail": { "ID": 265625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4472869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284177", "Detail": { "ID": 284177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7463402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252155", "Detail": { "ID": 252155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5049724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317258", "Detail": { "ID": 317258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.410666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256680", "Detail": { "ID": 256680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7930958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296950", "Detail": { "ID": 296950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.880958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235914", "Detail": { "ID": 235914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6983664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255929", "Detail": { "ID": 255929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.563053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229261", "Detail": { "ID": 229261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0690464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289489", "Detail": { "ID": 289489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.439457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311555", "Detail": { "ID": 311555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8839077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246868", "Detail": { "ID": 246868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1568307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297618", "Detail": { "ID": 297618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1079404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233803", "Detail": { "ID": 233803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1470085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274965", "Detail": { "ID": 274965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1296997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270051", "Detail": { "ID": 270051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5794303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317739", "Detail": { "ID": 317739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.435295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326490", "Detail": { "ID": 326490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7669324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241352", "Detail": { "ID": 241352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7542231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290464", "Detail": { "ID": 290464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7481953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248166", "Detail": { "ID": 248166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4459477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289232", "Detail": { "ID": 289232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.428358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222702", "Detail": { "ID": 222702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2004642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306916", "Detail": { "ID": 306916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5793972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240923", "Detail": { "ID": 240923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3882163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283700", "Detail": { "ID": 283700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7194921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231080", "Detail": { "ID": 231080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3647526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247273", "Detail": { "ID": 247273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3964985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308892", "Detail": { "ID": 308892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2038, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 19, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland – the Best Place to Grow Up", "Reference": "S4M-05934.1", "ID": 6084 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0825727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252672", "Detail": { "ID": 252672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.748642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258878", "Detail": { "ID": 258878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3321037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318740", "Detail": { "ID": 318740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.671375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250262", "Detail": { "ID": 250262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1816197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227783", "Detail": { "ID": 227783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.565452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280786", "Detail": { "ID": 280786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.782344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263056", "Detail": { "ID": 263056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6348755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288084", "Detail": { "ID": 288084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8993581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230513", "Detail": { "ID": 230513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3334144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270149", "Detail": { "ID": 270149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5836573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322471", "Detail": { "ID": 322471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6900647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295901", "Detail": { "ID": 295901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5406924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243089", "Detail": { "ID": 243089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0484418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235213", "Detail": { "ID": 235213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6603447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302462", "Detail": { "ID": 302462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5256098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238397", "Detail": { "ID": 238397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4447708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327000", "Detail": { "ID": 327000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7892675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277552", "Detail": { "ID": 277552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9582476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263934", "Detail": { "ID": 263934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9170869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248746", "Detail": { "ID": 248746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6680101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294820", "Detail": { "ID": 294820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1797538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285407", "Detail": { "ID": 285407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3217098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230750", "Detail": { "ID": 230750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3439243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243629", "Detail": { "ID": 243629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3131167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254472", "Detail": { "ID": 254472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2576094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323453", "Detail": { "ID": 323453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9568448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291308", "Detail": { "ID": 291308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1133535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273104", "Detail": { "ID": 273104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3697545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262278", "Detail": { "ID": 262278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5946133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281954", "Detail": { "ID": 281954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1649239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298172", "Detail": { "ID": 298172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1412974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231154", "Detail": { "ID": 231154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3679291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285914", "Detail": { "ID": 285914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3499825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219415", "Detail": { "ID": 219415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2977924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238548", "Detail": { "ID": 238548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4588336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226688", "Detail": { "ID": 226688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2423149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321989", "Detail": { "ID": 321989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4601251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292688", "Detail": { "ID": 292688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5535678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227141", "Detail": { "ID": 227141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2695832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313283", "Detail": { "ID": 313283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3886343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257864", "Detail": { "ID": 257864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0808779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271269", "Detail": { "ID": 271269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0630105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278091", "Detail": { "ID": 278091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9866228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287358", "Detail": { "ID": 287358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8607923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250681", "Detail": { "ID": 250681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2090004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221148", "Detail": { "ID": 221148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6771263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220228", "Detail": { "ID": 220228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6293603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252786", "Detail": { "ID": 252786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7532239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253860", "Detail": { "ID": 253860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0239621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324798", "Detail": { "ID": 324798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2382853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259693", "Detail": { "ID": 259693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6204541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239348", "Detail": { "ID": 239348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7329546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273559", "Detail": { "ID": 273559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6256136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304024", "Detail": { "ID": 304024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.846118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223166", "Detail": { "ID": 223166, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2314659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245677", "Detail": { "ID": 245677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8537393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223526", "Detail": { "ID": 223526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4622419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308094", "Detail": { "ID": 308094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8644428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272417", "Detail": { "ID": 272417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3344322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245100", "Detail": { "ID": 245100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5919947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315271", "Detail": { "ID": 315271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9013265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247920", "Detail": { "ID": 247920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4340568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274816", "Detail": { "ID": 274816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1229892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255770", "Detail": { "ID": 255770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5561295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277429", "Detail": { "ID": 277429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9530047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253042", "Detail": { "ID": 253042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7643573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276813", "Detail": { "ID": 276813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.682186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325333", "Detail": { "ID": 325333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4941742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233285", "Detail": { "ID": 233285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1174236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311786", "Detail": { "ID": 311786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8942239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230381", "Detail": { "ID": 230381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.327332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267384", "Detail": { "ID": 267384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0175059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313066", "Detail": { "ID": 313066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1621716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295056", "Detail": { "ID": 295056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1903139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319238", "Detail": { "ID": 319238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9114276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306214", "Detail": { "ID": 306214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5424314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310388", "Detail": { "ID": 310388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5683666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268219", "Detail": { "ID": 268219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2539847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286354", "Detail": { "ID": 286354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5752083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271845", "Detail": { "ID": 271845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.093912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263861", "Detail": { "ID": 263861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9139263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308797", "Detail": { "ID": 308797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0716555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279689", "Detail": { "ID": 279689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5184362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279121", "Detail": { "ID": 279121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2539199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260420", "Detail": { "ID": 260420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0760952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299306", "Detail": { "ID": 299306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6917927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306828", "Detail": { "ID": 306828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5754456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300506", "Detail": { "ID": 300506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0012127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224205", "Detail": { "ID": 224205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4971122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237519", "Detail": { "ID": 237519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2143341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305653", "Detail": { "ID": 305653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3336313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320032", "Detail": { "ID": 320032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9584599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315812", "Detail": { "ID": 315812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9281095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236738", "Detail": { "ID": 236738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9379315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288865", "Detail": { "ID": 288865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1617025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234300", "Detail": { "ID": 234300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3713273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312915", "Detail": { "ID": 312915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1553702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290201", "Detail": { "ID": 290201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7365023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225260", "Detail": { "ID": 225260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9617107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265740", "Detail": { "ID": 265740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4524363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283299", "Detail": { "ID": 283299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6944936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251493", "Detail": { "ID": 251493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4660623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317255", "Detail": { "ID": 317255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4105421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256683", "Detail": { "ID": 256683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7932176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296947", "Detail": { "ID": 296947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.880837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235396", "Detail": { "ID": 235396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6687731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257715", "Detail": { "ID": 257715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0685927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229258", "Detail": { "ID": 229258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0688993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291071", "Detail": { "ID": 291071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.784218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311552", "Detail": { "ID": 311552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8837813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246865", "Detail": { "ID": 246865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1567082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297621", "Detail": { "ID": 297621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1080633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234091", "Detail": { "ID": 234091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1662575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274604", "Detail": { "ID": 274604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1137996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269551", "Detail": { "ID": 269551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5525038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317736", "Detail": { "ID": 317736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4351533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326497", "Detail": { "ID": 326497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7672372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241349", "Detail": { "ID": 241349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7540995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290461", "Detail": { "ID": 290461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7480716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247810", "Detail": { "ID": 247810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4294114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287411", "Detail": { "ID": 287411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8630627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222505", "Detail": { "ID": 222505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1918462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306919", "Detail": { "ID": 306919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5795222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240926", "Detail": { "ID": 240926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3883415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283467", "Detail": { "ID": 283467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.70916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232181", "Detail": { "ID": 232181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6383182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237743", "Detail": { "ID": 237743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2239688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308896", "Detail": { "ID": 308896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2035, "AgendaID": 2624, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 81, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05924.1", "ID": 6096 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-14T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0827564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252670", "Detail": { "ID": 252670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7485251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259149", "Detail": { "ID": 259149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3438231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319829", "Detail": { "ID": 319829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9431803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249579", "Detail": { "ID": 249579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9329321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227781", "Detail": { "ID": 227781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5653499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280784", "Detail": { "ID": 280784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7822453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262785", "Detail": { "ID": 262785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6167416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288962", "Detail": { "ID": 288962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1659626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230493", "Detail": { "ID": 230493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3325235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269722", "Detail": { "ID": 269722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5601743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322653", "Detail": { "ID": 322653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.697947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295322", "Detail": { "ID": 295322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5069983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242924", "Detail": { "ID": 242924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0413997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235195", "Detail": { "ID": 235195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4234646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302442", "Detail": { "ID": 302442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.524775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244218", "Detail": { "ID": 244218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5450458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327139", "Detail": { "ID": 327139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8008123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277124", "Detail": { "ID": 277124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7021257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264050", "Detail": { "ID": 264050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.922054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248754", "Detail": { "ID": 248754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6683526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295758", "Detail": { "ID": 295758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5346313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285289", "Detail": { "ID": 285289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3165717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230766", "Detail": { "ID": 230766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3446141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243795", "Detail": { "ID": 243795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3200713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254804", "Detail": { "ID": 254804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2844513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323746", "Detail": { "ID": 323746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.970124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290903", "Detail": { "ID": 290903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.777059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265461", "Detail": { "ID": 265461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4401831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262270", "Detail": { "ID": 262270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5942701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281957", "Detail": { "ID": 281957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1650466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298015", "Detail": { "ID": 298015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1346224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231174", "Detail": { "ID": 231174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3688853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284965", "Detail": { "ID": 284965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.055326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219407", "Detail": { "ID": 219407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2973758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238530", "Detail": { "ID": 238530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4580769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225232", "Detail": { "ID": 225232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9604983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321807", "Detail": { "ID": 321807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4521982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292778", "Detail": { "ID": 292778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5577445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227133", "Detail": { "ID": 227133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.269234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313263", "Detail": { "ID": 313263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3877538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257240", "Detail": { "ID": 257240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0475981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271098", "Detail": { "ID": 271098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8424037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278093", "Detail": { "ID": 278093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9867091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287338", "Detail": { "ID": 287338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8598753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250519", "Detail": { "ID": 250519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1930307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220985", "Detail": { "ID": 220985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6701345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220236", "Detail": { "ID": 220236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6296915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252462", "Detail": { "ID": 252462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7301851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253862", "Detail": { "ID": 253862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0240416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324659", "Detail": { "ID": 324659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2324442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259701", "Detail": { "ID": 259701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6207833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239366", "Detail": { "ID": 239366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7337124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273676", "Detail": { "ID": 273676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6306049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304044", "Detail": { "ID": 304044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8469688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221710", "Detail": { "ID": 221710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9444677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241942", "Detail": { "ID": 241942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7867767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223509", "Detail": { "ID": 223509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4614988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307599", "Detail": { "ID": 307599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8365377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272255", "Detail": { "ID": 272255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3217654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244933", "Detail": { "ID": 244933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5848141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315103", "Detail": { "ID": 315103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.674259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247902", "Detail": { "ID": 247902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4332922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275142", "Detail": { "ID": 275142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1434075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255499", "Detail": { "ID": 255499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5339556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276947", "Detail": { "ID": 276947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6880517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253465", "Detail": { "ID": 253465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9976005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276717", "Detail": { "ID": 276717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.67811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325472", "Detail": { "ID": 325472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5078634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233266", "Detail": { "ID": 233266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1166065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311444", "Detail": { "ID": 311444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8790803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230389", "Detail": { "ID": 230389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3277012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267382", "Detail": { "ID": 267382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0174241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313717", "Detail": { "ID": 313717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4076475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295059", "Detail": { "ID": 295059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1904366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319057", "Detail": { "ID": 319057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6905839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306383", "Detail": { "ID": 306383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5497363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310780", "Detail": { "ID": 310780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5857407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268221", "Detail": { "ID": 268221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2540664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286351", "Detail": { "ID": 286351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5750668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258616", "Detail": { "ID": 258616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3149351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263869", "Detail": { "ID": 263869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9142758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308707", "Detail": { "ID": 308707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0674856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279784", "Detail": { "ID": 279784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5226732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279549", "Detail": { "ID": 279549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.512474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261055", "Detail": { "ID": 261055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1098525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299648", "Detail": { "ID": 299648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7067671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306739", "Detail": { "ID": 306739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5653309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300596", "Detail": { "ID": 300596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0054185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223888", "Detail": { "ID": 223888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.478091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237537", "Detail": { "ID": 237537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2151101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305485", "Detail": { "ID": 305485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3263423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320369", "Detail": { "ID": 320369, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.16344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315979", "Detail": { "ID": 315979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9405297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236753", "Detail": { "ID": 236753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9385906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289752", "Detail": { "ID": 289752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4576129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234474", "Detail": { "ID": 234474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3858048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313549", "Detail": { "ID": 313549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.400181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289342", "Detail": { "ID": 289342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4331257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225278", "Detail": { "ID": 225278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.962498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265760", "Detail": { "ID": 265760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4533064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283203", "Detail": { "ID": 283203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6902964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251485", "Detail": { "ID": 251485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4657101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317590", "Detail": { "ID": 317590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4289898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254644", "Detail": { "ID": 254644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2653597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296243", "Detail": { "ID": 296243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8402366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234928", "Detail": { "ID": 234928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4058211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257695", "Detail": { "ID": 257695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0675879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228173", "Detail": { "ID": 228173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5874848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291557", "Detail": { "ID": 291557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1324281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311072", "Detail": { "ID": 311072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6042231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246394", "Detail": { "ID": 246394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1268396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298045", "Detail": { "ID": 298045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1359017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234075", "Detail": { "ID": 234075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1655565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274596", "Detail": { "ID": 274596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1134523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269549", "Detail": { "ID": 269549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5524221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317414", "Detail": { "ID": 317414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4210932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326358", "Detail": { "ID": 326358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7550526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241186", "Detail": { "ID": 241186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7466749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289678", "Detail": { "ID": 289678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4543272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247802", "Detail": { "ID": 247802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4290709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287508", "Detail": { "ID": 287508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8740139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222522", "Detail": { "ID": 222522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1925816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306967", "Detail": { "ID": 306967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5816052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239937", "Detail": { "ID": 239937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7657404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283792", "Detail": { "ID": 283792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7236524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232183", "Detail": { "ID": 232183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6383989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237751", "Detail": { "ID": 237751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.224326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309240", "Detail": { "ID": 309240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2030, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 63, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Business Motion", "Reference": "S4M-05913", "ID": 12989 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3207939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252671", "Detail": { "ID": 252671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7485997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259142", "Detail": { "ID": 259142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3435348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319828", "Detail": { "ID": 319828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9431384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249578", "Detail": { "ID": 249578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9328916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227782", "Detail": { "ID": 227782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5654099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280785", "Detail": { "ID": 280785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7823031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262786", "Detail": { "ID": 262786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6167823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288939", "Detail": { "ID": 288939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1648462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230494", "Detail": { "ID": 230494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.332565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269729", "Detail": { "ID": 269729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.560478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322568", "Detail": { "ID": 322568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.694299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295323", "Detail": { "ID": 295323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5071055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242925", "Detail": { "ID": 242925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0414397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235101", "Detail": { "ID": 235101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4194214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302443", "Detail": { "ID": 302443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5248161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244217", "Detail": { "ID": 244217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5450048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327140", "Detail": { "ID": 327140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8008543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277125", "Detail": { "ID": 277125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7021671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264049", "Detail": { "ID": 264049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9220133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248661", "Detail": { "ID": 248661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6644042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295757", "Detail": { "ID": 295757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5345916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285290", "Detail": { "ID": 285290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3166317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230767", "Detail": { "ID": 230767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3446546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243794", "Detail": { "ID": 243794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3200315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254803", "Detail": { "ID": 254803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2843881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323747", "Detail": { "ID": 323747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9701651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290912", "Detail": { "ID": 290912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7774377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265462", "Detail": { "ID": 265462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4402242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262363", "Detail": { "ID": 262363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5982346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281956", "Detail": { "ID": 281956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1650058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298016", "Detail": { "ID": 298016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1346629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231173", "Detail": { "ID": 231173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3688438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284988", "Detail": { "ID": 284988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0563998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219503", "Detail": { "ID": 219503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.302087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238284", "Detail": { "ID": 238284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4397666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225231", "Detail": { "ID": 225231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9604325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321892", "Detail": { "ID": 321892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4558298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292777", "Detail": { "ID": 292777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5577041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227228", "Detail": { "ID": 227228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5363737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313264", "Detail": { "ID": 313264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3877952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257241", "Detail": { "ID": 257241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0476392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271121", "Detail": { "ID": 271121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8433819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278092", "Detail": { "ID": 278092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9866643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287339", "Detail": { "ID": 287339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8599225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250520", "Detail": { "ID": 250520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1930711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220986", "Detail": { "ID": 220986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6701751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220141", "Detail": { "ID": 220141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.336109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252463", "Detail": { "ID": 252463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.730226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253861", "Detail": { "ID": 253861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0240019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324658", "Detail": { "ID": 324658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2324036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259608", "Detail": { "ID": 259608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6167851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239459", "Detail": { "ID": 239459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7377213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273675", "Detail": { "ID": 273675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6305648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304043", "Detail": { "ID": 304043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8469287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221709", "Detail": { "ID": 221709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9444272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241941", "Detail": { "ID": 241941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7866219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223414", "Detail": { "ID": 223414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4568433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307600", "Detail": { "ID": 307600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8365791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272256", "Detail": { "ID": 272256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.321806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244934", "Detail": { "ID": 244934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5848547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315104", "Detail": { "ID": 315104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6743359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247502", "Detail": { "ID": 247502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4065816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275119", "Detail": { "ID": 275119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1423993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255506", "Detail": { "ID": 255506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5342612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276970", "Detail": { "ID": 276970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6891785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253459", "Detail": { "ID": 253459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.997333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276726", "Detail": { "ID": 276726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6784953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325473", "Detail": { "ID": 325473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5079049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233267", "Detail": { "ID": 233267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1166476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311445", "Detail": { "ID": 311445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8791224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229676", "Detail": { "ID": 229676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0919054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267383", "Detail": { "ID": 267383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0174649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313462", "Detail": { "ID": 313462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.396417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295058", "Detail": { "ID": 295058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1903962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319141", "Detail": { "ID": 319141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6941923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306382", "Detail": { "ID": 306382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5496956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310779", "Detail": { "ID": 310779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5856815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268220", "Detail": { "ID": 268220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2540251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286352", "Detail": { "ID": 286352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5751079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258615", "Detail": { "ID": 258615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3148942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263774", "Detail": { "ID": 263774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9041481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308708", "Detail": { "ID": 308708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0675262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279775", "Detail": { "ID": 279775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5222882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279548", "Detail": { "ID": 279548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5124335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261054", "Detail": { "ID": 261054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1098115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299647", "Detail": { "ID": 299647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7067267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306740", "Detail": { "ID": 306740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5653719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300595", "Detail": { "ID": 300595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0053783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223889", "Detail": { "ID": 223889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4781337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237916", "Detail": { "ID": 237916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.23162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305486", "Detail": { "ID": 305486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3263822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320129", "Detail": { "ID": 320129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9629251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315978", "Detail": { "ID": 315978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9404656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236754", "Detail": { "ID": 236754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9386311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289751", "Detail": { "ID": 289751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4575731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234473", "Detail": { "ID": 234473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3857609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313548", "Detail": { "ID": 313548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4001398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289343", "Detail": { "ID": 289343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4331658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225373", "Detail": { "ID": 225373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9719168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265759", "Detail": { "ID": 265759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.453264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283212", "Detail": { "ID": 283212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6906799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252039", "Detail": { "ID": 252039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4999412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317351", "Detail": { "ID": 317351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4183815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254643", "Detail": { "ID": 254643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2653169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296244", "Detail": { "ID": 296244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8402789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235482", "Detail": { "ID": 235482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6797496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257696", "Detail": { "ID": 257696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.067629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228174", "Detail": { "ID": 228174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5875251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291556", "Detail": { "ID": 291556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.124446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311073", "Detail": { "ID": 311073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.604265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246395", "Detail": { "ID": 246395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1268803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298044", "Detail": { "ID": 298044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1358618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234074", "Detail": { "ID": 234074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1655162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274692", "Detail": { "ID": 274692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1176031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269550", "Detail": { "ID": 269550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5524638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317415", "Detail": { "ID": 317415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4211351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326357", "Detail": { "ID": 326357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7550118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241187", "Detail": { "ID": 241187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7467265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289679", "Detail": { "ID": 289679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4543675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248048", "Detail": { "ID": 248048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4395277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287499", "Detail": { "ID": 287499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8736243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222617", "Detail": { "ID": 222617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1966311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306966", "Detail": { "ID": 306966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5815462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239936", "Detail": { "ID": 239936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7656998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283769", "Detail": { "ID": 283769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7226717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232182", "Detail": { "ID": 232182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6383584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237356", "Detail": { "ID": 237356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.200671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309239", "Detail": { "ID": 309239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2031, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899.3", "ID": 6069 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3207532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252756", "Detail": { "ID": 252756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.751968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259143", "Detail": { "ID": 259143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3435757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319827", "Detail": { "ID": 319827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9430796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249577", "Detail": { "ID": 249577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9328514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228343", "Detail": { "ID": 228343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.794308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281050", "Detail": { "ID": 281050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8038715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262787", "Detail": { "ID": 262787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6168231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288958", "Detail": { "ID": 288958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.165748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230495", "Detail": { "ID": 230495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.332641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269728", "Detail": { "ID": 269728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5604379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322551", "Detail": { "ID": 322551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6935882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295324", "Detail": { "ID": 295324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5071585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242926", "Detail": { "ID": 242926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0414792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235100", "Detail": { "ID": 235100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4193806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302444", "Detail": { "ID": 302444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5248565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244216", "Detail": { "ID": 244216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.544964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327135", "Detail": { "ID": 327135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.800638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277126", "Detail": { "ID": 277126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.702226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264048", "Detail": { "ID": 264048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9219538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248660", "Detail": { "ID": 248660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6643633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295756", "Detail": { "ID": 295756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5345516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285291", "Detail": { "ID": 285291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3166746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230768", "Detail": { "ID": 230768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.344695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243793", "Detail": { "ID": 243793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3199916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254802", "Detail": { "ID": 254802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2843471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323742", "Detail": { "ID": 323742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9699592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290911", "Detail": { "ID": 290911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7773781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265463", "Detail": { "ID": 265463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4402647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262364", "Detail": { "ID": 262364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5982749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281842", "Detail": { "ID": 281842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1599534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298285", "Detail": { "ID": 298285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3391793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231172", "Detail": { "ID": 231172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3688008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284969", "Detail": { "ID": 284969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0554892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219504", "Detail": { "ID": 219504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3021278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238283", "Detail": { "ID": 238283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4397246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225230", "Detail": { "ID": 225230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9603907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321909", "Detail": { "ID": 321909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4565549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292776", "Detail": { "ID": 292776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5576634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227229", "Detail": { "ID": 227229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5364148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313265", "Detail": { "ID": 313265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3878362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257242", "Detail": { "ID": 257242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0476803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271102", "Detail": { "ID": 271102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8425662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277980", "Detail": { "ID": 277980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9770524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287340", "Detail": { "ID": 287340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8599643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250521", "Detail": { "ID": 250521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1931129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220987", "Detail": { "ID": 220987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6702155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220140", "Detail": { "ID": 220140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3360679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252464", "Detail": { "ID": 252464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7302667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253749", "Detail": { "ID": 253749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0192946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324663", "Detail": { "ID": 324663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2326242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259607", "Detail": { "ID": 259607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.616744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239460", "Detail": { "ID": 239460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7377618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273674", "Detail": { "ID": 273674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6305241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304042", "Detail": { "ID": 304042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8468886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221708", "Detail": { "ID": 221708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9443857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241940", "Detail": { "ID": 241940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7865814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223413", "Detail": { "ID": 223413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4568026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307868", "Detail": { "ID": 307868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8543983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272257", "Detail": { "ID": 272257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3218468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244935", "Detail": { "ID": 244935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5848948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315105", "Detail": { "ID": 315105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6743835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247501", "Detail": { "ID": 247501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4065411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275138", "Detail": { "ID": 275138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1432232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255505", "Detail": { "ID": 255505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5342022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276951", "Detail": { "ID": 276951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.68822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253460", "Detail": { "ID": 253460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9973742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276725", "Detail": { "ID": 276725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6784548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325468", "Detail": { "ID": 325468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5076783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233268", "Detail": { "ID": 233268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.116688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311712", "Detail": { "ID": 311712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8910164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229675", "Detail": { "ID": 229675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0918655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267495", "Detail": { "ID": 267495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0223097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313448", "Detail": { "ID": 313448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3958002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294943", "Detail": { "ID": 294943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1854311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319159", "Detail": { "ID": 319159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6949709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306381", "Detail": { "ID": 306381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5496541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310778", "Detail": { "ID": 310778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5856399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268109", "Detail": { "ID": 268109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0565469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292948", "Detail": { "ID": 292948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5651049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258614", "Detail": { "ID": 258614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3148538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263773", "Detail": { "ID": 263773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9041072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308709", "Detail": { "ID": 308709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0675675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279776", "Detail": { "ID": 279776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5223278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279547", "Detail": { "ID": 279547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5123926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261053", "Detail": { "ID": 261053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1097703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299378", "Detail": { "ID": 299378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6948578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306741", "Detail": { "ID": 306741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.565413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300594", "Detail": { "ID": 300594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0053374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223890", "Detail": { "ID": 223890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4781741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237917", "Detail": { "ID": 237917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2316627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305487", "Detail": { "ID": 305487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.326422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320112", "Detail": { "ID": 320112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9622002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315977", "Detail": { "ID": 315977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9404247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236755", "Detail": { "ID": 236755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9386713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289750", "Detail": { "ID": 289750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4575328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234472", "Detail": { "ID": 234472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3857201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313547", "Detail": { "ID": 313547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4000975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289344", "Detail": { "ID": 289344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4332067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225374", "Detail": { "ID": 225374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9719785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265758", "Detail": { "ID": 265758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4532029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283211", "Detail": { "ID": 283211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6906379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252040", "Detail": { "ID": 252040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4999834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317333", "Detail": { "ID": 317333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4175995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254330", "Detail": { "ID": 254330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.250919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296245", "Detail": { "ID": 296245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8403197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235483", "Detail": { "ID": 235483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6797908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257697", "Detail": { "ID": 257697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0676698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228175", "Detail": { "ID": 228175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5875662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291555", "Detail": { "ID": 291555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1244043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311074", "Detail": { "ID": 311074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6043054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246396", "Detail": { "ID": 246396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1269202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298043", "Detail": { "ID": 298043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1358215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234073", "Detail": { "ID": 234073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1654759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274693", "Detail": { "ID": 274693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1176443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269971", "Detail": { "ID": 269971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5759819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317416", "Detail": { "ID": 317416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4211763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326362", "Detail": { "ID": 326362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7552176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241188", "Detail": { "ID": 241188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7467687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289680", "Detail": { "ID": 289680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4544398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248049", "Detail": { "ID": 248049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4395693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287500", "Detail": { "ID": 287500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8736647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222618", "Detail": { "ID": 222618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1966894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306965", "Detail": { "ID": 306965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5815049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239935", "Detail": { "ID": 239935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7656592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283788", "Detail": { "ID": 283788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7234884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231778", "Detail": { "ID": 231778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.615102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237355", "Detail": { "ID": 237355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2006287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308969", "Detail": { "ID": 308969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2032, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 57, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Police Centralisation", "Reference": "S4M-05899", "ID": 6029 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0858762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252757", "Detail": { "ID": 252757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.752008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259144", "Detail": { "ID": 259144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3436175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319673", "Detail": { "ID": 319673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9364088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249576", "Detail": { "ID": 249576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9328105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228344", "Detail": { "ID": 228344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7943502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281051", "Detail": { "ID": 281051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.803912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262788", "Detail": { "ID": 262788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6168642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288957", "Detail": { "ID": 288957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1657061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230496", "Detail": { "ID": 230496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3326846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269727", "Detail": { "ID": 269727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5603975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322552", "Detail": { "ID": 322552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6936288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295325", "Detail": { "ID": 295325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5072009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242927", "Detail": { "ID": 242927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.041519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235099", "Detail": { "ID": 235099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4193396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302445", "Detail": { "ID": 302445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5248971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244215", "Detail": { "ID": 244215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5449224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327136", "Detail": { "ID": 327136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8006798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277127", "Detail": { "ID": 277127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7022678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264047", "Detail": { "ID": 264047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9219134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248659", "Detail": { "ID": 248659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6643227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295755", "Detail": { "ID": 295755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5345111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285292", "Detail": { "ID": 285292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3167164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230769", "Detail": { "ID": 230769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3447353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243792", "Detail": { "ID": 243792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3199517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254801", "Detail": { "ID": 254801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2843061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323743", "Detail": { "ID": 323743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.97+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290910", "Detail": { "ID": 290910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7773384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265464", "Detail": { "ID": 265464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4403054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262365", "Detail": { "ID": 262365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5983338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281841", "Detail": { "ID": 281841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1599129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298286", "Detail": { "ID": 298286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3392201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231171", "Detail": { "ID": 231171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.368714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284970", "Detail": { "ID": 284970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0555297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219505", "Detail": { "ID": 219505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3021885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238282", "Detail": { "ID": 238282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4396611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225229", "Detail": { "ID": 225229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9603489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321908", "Detail": { "ID": 321908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4565141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292775", "Detail": { "ID": 292775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5576228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227230", "Detail": { "ID": 227230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5364558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313266", "Detail": { "ID": 313266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3879073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257243", "Detail": { "ID": 257243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0477202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271103", "Detail": { "ID": 271103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8426061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277979", "Detail": { "ID": 277979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9769918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287341", "Detail": { "ID": 287341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8600264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250522", "Detail": { "ID": 250522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1931534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220988", "Detail": { "ID": 220988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6702567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220139", "Detail": { "ID": 220139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3360268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252465", "Detail": { "ID": 252465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.730307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253748", "Detail": { "ID": 253748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.019255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324662", "Detail": { "ID": 324662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2325843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259606", "Detail": { "ID": 259606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6167029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239461", "Detail": { "ID": 239461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7378023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273673", "Detail": { "ID": 273673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6304828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304041", "Detail": { "ID": 304041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8468476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221707", "Detail": { "ID": 221707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9443256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241939", "Detail": { "ID": 241939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7865409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223412", "Detail": { "ID": 223412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4567605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307869", "Detail": { "ID": 307869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8544411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272258", "Detail": { "ID": 272258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3219065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244936", "Detail": { "ID": 244936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5849345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315106", "Detail": { "ID": 315106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6744244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247500", "Detail": { "ID": 247500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4065011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275137", "Detail": { "ID": 275137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1431821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255504", "Detail": { "ID": 255504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5341614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276952", "Detail": { "ID": 276952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6883989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253461", "Detail": { "ID": 253461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9974149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276724", "Detail": { "ID": 276724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6784132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325469", "Detail": { "ID": 325469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5077187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233269", "Detail": { "ID": 233269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1167286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311713", "Detail": { "ID": 311713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8910581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229674", "Detail": { "ID": 229674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0918255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267496", "Detail": { "ID": 267496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0223503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313447", "Detail": { "ID": 313447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3957595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294942", "Detail": { "ID": 294942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1853893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319158", "Detail": { "ID": 319158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6949307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306380", "Detail": { "ID": 306380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5495944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310777", "Detail": { "ID": 310777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.585599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268108", "Detail": { "ID": 268108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0565062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292949", "Detail": { "ID": 292949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5651446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258613", "Detail": { "ID": 258613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3148125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263772", "Detail": { "ID": 263772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9040663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308710", "Detail": { "ID": 308710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.067608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279777", "Detail": { "ID": 279777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5223683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279546", "Detail": { "ID": 279546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5123521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261052", "Detail": { "ID": 261052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1097296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299377", "Detail": { "ID": 299377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6948165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306742", "Detail": { "ID": 306742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.565454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300593", "Detail": { "ID": 300593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0052971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223891", "Detail": { "ID": 223891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4782146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237918", "Detail": { "ID": 237918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2317033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305488", "Detail": { "ID": 305488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3264626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320113", "Detail": { "ID": 320113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9622412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315976", "Detail": { "ID": 315976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9403831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236756", "Detail": { "ID": 236756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9387117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289749", "Detail": { "ID": 289749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4574918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234471", "Detail": { "ID": 234471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3856787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313546", "Detail": { "ID": 313546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4000356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289345", "Detail": { "ID": 289345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4332469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225375", "Detail": { "ID": 225375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9720223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265757", "Detail": { "ID": 265757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4531614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283210", "Detail": { "ID": 283210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6905959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252041", "Detail": { "ID": 252041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.500024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317334", "Detail": { "ID": 317334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.41764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254329", "Detail": { "ID": 254329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2508776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296246", "Detail": { "ID": 296246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8403611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235484", "Detail": { "ID": 235484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6798311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257698", "Detail": { "ID": 257698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0677101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228176", "Detail": { "ID": 228176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5876065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291554", "Detail": { "ID": 291554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.124361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311075", "Detail": { "ID": 311075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6043455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246397", "Detail": { "ID": 246397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1269607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298042", "Detail": { "ID": 298042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1357808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234072", "Detail": { "ID": 234072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1654348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274694", "Detail": { "ID": 274694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269972", "Detail": { "ID": 269972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5760254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317417", "Detail": { "ID": 317417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4212167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326361", "Detail": { "ID": 326361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7551767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241189", "Detail": { "ID": 241189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7468103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289681", "Detail": { "ID": 289681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4544895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248050", "Detail": { "ID": 248050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4396187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287501", "Detail": { "ID": 287501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8737056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222619", "Detail": { "ID": 222619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1967301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306964", "Detail": { "ID": 306964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5814644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239934", "Detail": { "ID": 239934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7656187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283787", "Detail": { "ID": 283787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7234474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231777", "Detail": { "ID": 231777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.615062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237354", "Detail": { "ID": 237354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2005687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308968", "Detail": { "ID": 308968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2033, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898.3", "ID": 6067 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0858359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252758", "Detail": { "ID": 252758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7520473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259145", "Detail": { "ID": 259145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3436577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319672", "Detail": { "ID": 319672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9363681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249575", "Detail": { "ID": 249575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9327693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228345", "Detail": { "ID": 228345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7943926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281053", "Detail": { "ID": 281053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8039937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262789", "Detail": { "ID": 262789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6169044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288956", "Detail": { "ID": 288956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1656637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230497", "Detail": { "ID": 230497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3327281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269726", "Detail": { "ID": 269726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5603559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322554", "Detail": { "ID": 322554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6937094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295326", "Detail": { "ID": 295326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5072413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242928", "Detail": { "ID": 242928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0415582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235098", "Detail": { "ID": 235098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4192968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302446", "Detail": { "ID": 302446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5249375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244214", "Detail": { "ID": 244214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5448806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327134", "Detail": { "ID": 327134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8005962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277128", "Detail": { "ID": 277128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7023084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264046", "Detail": { "ID": 264046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9218732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248658", "Detail": { "ID": 248658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6642817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295754", "Detail": { "ID": 295754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5344705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285293", "Detail": { "ID": 285293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3167579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230770", "Detail": { "ID": 230770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3447754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243791", "Detail": { "ID": 243791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3199118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254800", "Detail": { "ID": 254800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2842652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323741", "Detail": { "ID": 323741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9699188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290909", "Detail": { "ID": 290909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7772984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265465", "Detail": { "ID": 265465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4403464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262366", "Detail": { "ID": 262366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5983752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281839", "Detail": { "ID": 281839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1598294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298288", "Detail": { "ID": 298288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3393019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231170", "Detail": { "ID": 231170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3686734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284971", "Detail": { "ID": 284971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0556504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219506", "Detail": { "ID": 219506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3022313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238281", "Detail": { "ID": 238281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4396206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225228", "Detail": { "ID": 225228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9603078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321906", "Detail": { "ID": 321906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4564297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292774", "Detail": { "ID": 292774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5575824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227231", "Detail": { "ID": 227231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5365159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313267", "Detail": { "ID": 313267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3879503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257244", "Detail": { "ID": 257244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0477603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271104", "Detail": { "ID": 271104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8426472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277977", "Detail": { "ID": 277977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9769096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287342", "Detail": { "ID": 287342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8600686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250523", "Detail": { "ID": 250523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1931935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220989", "Detail": { "ID": 220989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6702967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220138", "Detail": { "ID": 220138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3359853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252466", "Detail": { "ID": 252466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7303479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253746", "Detail": { "ID": 253746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0191751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324664", "Detail": { "ID": 324664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2326639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259605", "Detail": { "ID": 259605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6166612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239462", "Detail": { "ID": 239462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7378431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273672", "Detail": { "ID": 273672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6304426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304040", "Detail": { "ID": 304040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8468072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221706", "Detail": { "ID": 221706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9442852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241938", "Detail": { "ID": 241938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7865007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223411", "Detail": { "ID": 223411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4567202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307871", "Detail": { "ID": 307871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8545234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272259", "Detail": { "ID": 272259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3219483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244937", "Detail": { "ID": 244937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5849934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315107", "Detail": { "ID": 315107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6745974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247499", "Detail": { "ID": 247499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4064603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275136", "Detail": { "ID": 275136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.143141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255503", "Detail": { "ID": 255503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5341205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276953", "Detail": { "ID": 276953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6884534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253462", "Detail": { "ID": 253462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9974573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276723", "Detail": { "ID": 276723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6783539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325467", "Detail": { "ID": 325467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5076378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233270", "Detail": { "ID": 233270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1167688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311715", "Detail": { "ID": 311715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8911414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229673", "Detail": { "ID": 229673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0917853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267498", "Detail": { "ID": 267498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0224318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313445", "Detail": { "ID": 313445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3956778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294475", "Detail": { "ID": 294475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1399126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319156", "Detail": { "ID": 319156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6948477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306379", "Detail": { "ID": 306379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5495536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310776", "Detail": { "ID": 310776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5855586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268106", "Detail": { "ID": 268106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0564239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292951", "Detail": { "ID": 292951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5652251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258612", "Detail": { "ID": 258612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3147721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263771", "Detail": { "ID": 263771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9040249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308711", "Detail": { "ID": 308711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0676484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279778", "Detail": { "ID": 279778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5224078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279545", "Detail": { "ID": 279545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.512312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261051", "Detail": { "ID": 261051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1096881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299375", "Detail": { "ID": 299375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6947362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306743", "Detail": { "ID": 306743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5654944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300592", "Detail": { "ID": 300592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0052569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223892", "Detail": { "ID": 223892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4782555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237919", "Detail": { "ID": 237919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2317438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305489", "Detail": { "ID": 305489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3265262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320115", "Detail": { "ID": 320115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9623245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315975", "Detail": { "ID": 315975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9403428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236757", "Detail": { "ID": 236757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9387518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289748", "Detail": { "ID": 289748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4574334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234470", "Detail": { "ID": 234470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3856382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313545", "Detail": { "ID": 313545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3999942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289346", "Detail": { "ID": 289346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4333064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225376", "Detail": { "ID": 225376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9720634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265756", "Detail": { "ID": 265756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4531198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283209", "Detail": { "ID": 283209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6905544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252042", "Detail": { "ID": 252042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5000646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317336", "Detail": { "ID": 317336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4177222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254328", "Detail": { "ID": 254328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.250837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296247", "Detail": { "ID": 296247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8404023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235485", "Detail": { "ID": 235485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6798713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257699", "Detail": { "ID": 257699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0677507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228177", "Detail": { "ID": 228177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5876461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291553", "Detail": { "ID": 291553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1243004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311076", "Detail": { "ID": 311076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6043859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246398", "Detail": { "ID": 246398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1270015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298041", "Detail": { "ID": 298041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1357385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234071", "Detail": { "ID": 234071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.165395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274695", "Detail": { "ID": 274695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1177268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269974", "Detail": { "ID": 269974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5761079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317418", "Detail": { "ID": 317418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4212567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326363", "Detail": { "ID": 326363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7552594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241190", "Detail": { "ID": 241190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7468518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289682", "Detail": { "ID": 289682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.45453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248051", "Detail": { "ID": 248051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4396623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287502", "Detail": { "ID": 287502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8737467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222620", "Detail": { "ID": 222620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1967703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306963", "Detail": { "ID": 306963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5814244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239933", "Detail": { "ID": 239933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7655784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283786", "Detail": { "ID": 283786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7234069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231776", "Detail": { "ID": 231776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6150206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237353", "Detail": { "ID": 237353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2005274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308966", "Detail": { "ID": 308966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2034, "AgendaID": 2163, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 55, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "CAP Reform", "Reference": "S4M-05898", "ID": 6028 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-13T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0857544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252700", "Detail": { "ID": 252700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7498193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258914", "Detail": { "ID": 258914, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3336673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319650", "Detail": { "ID": 319650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9354189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249566", "Detail": { "ID": 249566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9323819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227818", "Detail": { "ID": 227818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5669628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280819", "Detail": { "ID": 280819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7837279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262721", "Detail": { "ID": 262721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6140055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288095", "Detail": { "ID": 288095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8998443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229807", "Detail": { "ID": 229807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0980262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269802", "Detail": { "ID": 269802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5635688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322614", "Detail": { "ID": 322614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6962996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295259", "Detail": { "ID": 295259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5043203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242950", "Detail": { "ID": 242950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.042492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235175", "Detail": { "ID": 235175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4226193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302372", "Detail": { "ID": 302372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5215552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244282", "Detail": { "ID": 244282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5479324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327169", "Detail": { "ID": 327169, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8021517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277060", "Detail": { "ID": 277060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6993636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264269", "Detail": { "ID": 264269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1260123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248711", "Detail": { "ID": 248711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6665372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295731", "Detail": { "ID": 295731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5334984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285225", "Detail": { "ID": 285225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3137633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230702", "Detail": { "ID": 230702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3416174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243769", "Detail": { "ID": 243769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3189884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254874", "Detail": { "ID": 254874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2875063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323776", "Detail": { "ID": 323776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9714275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291269", "Detail": { "ID": 291269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1116181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265397", "Detail": { "ID": 265397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4374225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262314", "Detail": { "ID": 262314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5961441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281921", "Detail": { "ID": 281921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1635144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298205", "Detail": { "ID": 298205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3356321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231231", "Detail": { "ID": 231231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5860603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285869", "Detail": { "ID": 285869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.348047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219454", "Detail": { "ID": 219454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2999475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238512", "Detail": { "ID": 238512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.457304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225220", "Detail": { "ID": 225220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9599403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321846", "Detail": { "ID": 321846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4538611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292813", "Detail": { "ID": 292813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5592137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227179", "Detail": { "ID": 227179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2712278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312732", "Detail": { "ID": 312732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1409648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257254", "Detail": { "ID": 257254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0481933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271224", "Detail": { "ID": 271224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0609828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278058", "Detail": { "ID": 278058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9851907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287267", "Detail": { "ID": 287267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8568343+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250533", "Detail": { "ID": 250533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1936679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220997", "Detail": { "ID": 220997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6706452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220190", "Detail": { "ID": 220190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3382325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252392", "Detail": { "ID": 252392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7271992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253825", "Detail": { "ID": 253825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.022501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324629", "Detail": { "ID": 324629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2311885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259658", "Detail": { "ID": 259658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6189518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239384", "Detail": { "ID": 239384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7344895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273740", "Detail": { "ID": 273740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6336233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304113", "Detail": { "ID": 304113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8502177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221698", "Detail": { "ID": 221698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9439564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241930", "Detail": { "ID": 241930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7861437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223488", "Detail": { "ID": 223488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4605883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307787", "Detail": { "ID": 307787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272269", "Detail": { "ID": 272269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3223809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244960", "Detail": { "ID": 244960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5859874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315130", "Detail": { "ID": 315130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6756116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247884", "Detail": { "ID": 247884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4325413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275016", "Detail": { "ID": 275016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1375271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255734", "Detail": { "ID": 255734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5546225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277383", "Detail": { "ID": 277383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9510213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253077", "Detail": { "ID": 253077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7658749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276775", "Detail": { "ID": 276775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.680573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325502", "Detail": { "ID": 325502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5091264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232896", "Detail": { "ID": 232896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8813238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311478", "Detail": { "ID": 311478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8805652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230344", "Detail": { "ID": 230344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3189501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267418", "Detail": { "ID": 267418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0189706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313531", "Detail": { "ID": 313531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3993869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295022", "Detail": { "ID": 295022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1888514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319095", "Detail": { "ID": 319095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6922257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306356", "Detail": { "ID": 306356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5485694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310815", "Detail": { "ID": 310815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.587233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268186", "Detail": { "ID": 268186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0599188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286387", "Detail": { "ID": 286387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5769758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258602", "Detail": { "ID": 258602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3143375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263823", "Detail": { "ID": 263823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.911948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308517", "Detail": { "ID": 308517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0593428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279727", "Detail": { "ID": 279727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.520044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279612", "Detail": { "ID": 279612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5151426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261028", "Detail": { "ID": 261028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1086942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299613", "Detail": { "ID": 299613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7052669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306703", "Detail": { "ID": 306703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.563765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300631", "Detail": { "ID": 300631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.006914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223900", "Detail": { "ID": 223900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4786038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237862", "Detail": { "ID": 237862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2292738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305512", "Detail": { "ID": 305512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3275396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320331", "Detail": { "ID": 320331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1554095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315952", "Detail": { "ID": 315952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9393508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236688", "Detail": { "ID": 236688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9357947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289816", "Detail": { "ID": 289816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.460309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234545", "Detail": { "ID": 234545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3889179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313211", "Detail": { "ID": 313211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3824866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289307", "Detail": { "ID": 289307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.431635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225299", "Detail": { "ID": 225299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9634041+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265831", "Detail": { "ID": 265831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4563754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283261", "Detail": { "ID": 283261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6928276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251528", "Detail": { "ID": 251528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4675888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317552", "Detail": { "ID": 317552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4273529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254318", "Detail": { "ID": 254318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2503962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296208", "Detail": { "ID": 296208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8386591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235432", "Detail": { "ID": 235432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6775239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257625", "Detail": { "ID": 257625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0645677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228493", "Detail": { "ID": 228493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8014486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291627", "Detail": { "ID": 291627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1354433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311100", "Detail": { "ID": 311100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6054082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246407", "Detail": { "ID": 246407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1273915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298109", "Detail": { "ID": 298109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1386298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234141", "Detail": { "ID": 234141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1684013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274642", "Detail": { "ID": 274642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1154284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269584", "Detail": { "ID": 269584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5539296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317441", "Detail": { "ID": 317441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4222401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326328", "Detail": { "ID": 326328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7537128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241198", "Detail": { "ID": 241198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7472311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290321", "Detail": { "ID": 290321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7417822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247998", "Detail": { "ID": 247998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4373677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287450", "Detail": { "ID": 287450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.864704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222543", "Detail": { "ID": 222543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1934773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307002", "Detail": { "ID": 307002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5830919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239925", "Detail": { "ID": 239925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7652284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283667", "Detail": { "ID": 283667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7181001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231842", "Detail": { "ID": 231842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.617884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237707", "Detail": { "ID": 237707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2223746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309206", "Detail": { "ID": 309206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2027, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.3", "ID": 6034 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3192985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252702", "Detail": { "ID": 252702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7498989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258916", "Detail": { "ID": 258916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3337475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319648", "Detail": { "ID": 319648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.935337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249564", "Detail": { "ID": 249564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9322993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227820", "Detail": { "ID": 227820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5670471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280821", "Detail": { "ID": 280821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7838292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262723", "Detail": { "ID": 262723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6140862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288093", "Detail": { "ID": 288093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8997615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229809", "Detail": { "ID": 229809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0982213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269800", "Detail": { "ID": 269800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5634671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322619", "Detail": { "ID": 322619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6965037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295261", "Detail": { "ID": 295261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5044016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242952", "Detail": { "ID": 242952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0425727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235173", "Detail": { "ID": 235173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4225155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302374", "Detail": { "ID": 302374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5216361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244280", "Detail": { "ID": 244280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.54785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327171", "Detail": { "ID": 327171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8022332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277062", "Detail": { "ID": 277062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6994653+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264267", "Detail": { "ID": 264267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1259305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248709", "Detail": { "ID": 248709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6664564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295729", "Detail": { "ID": 295729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5334162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285227", "Detail": { "ID": 285227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3138726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230704", "Detail": { "ID": 230704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3416987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243767", "Detail": { "ID": 243767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3189088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254872", "Detail": { "ID": 254872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2874251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323778", "Detail": { "ID": 323778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9715082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291267", "Detail": { "ID": 291267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1114952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265399", "Detail": { "ID": 265399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4375048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262316", "Detail": { "ID": 262316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5962251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281919", "Detail": { "ID": 281919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1634327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298207", "Detail": { "ID": 298207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3357809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231229", "Detail": { "ID": 231229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5859553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285875", "Detail": { "ID": 285875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3482926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219456", "Detail": { "ID": 219456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3000344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238510", "Detail": { "ID": 238510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4572215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225218", "Detail": { "ID": 225218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9598444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321841", "Detail": { "ID": 321841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4536386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292811", "Detail": { "ID": 292811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5591331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227181", "Detail": { "ID": 227181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2713101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312734", "Detail": { "ID": 312734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1410471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257256", "Detail": { "ID": 257256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0482758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271230", "Detail": { "ID": 271230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0612984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278056", "Detail": { "ID": 278056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9851082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287269", "Detail": { "ID": 287269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8569155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250535", "Detail": { "ID": 250535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.193749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220999", "Detail": { "ID": 220999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6707265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220188", "Detail": { "ID": 220188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3381494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252394", "Detail": { "ID": 252394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7272815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253823", "Detail": { "ID": 253823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0224217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324627", "Detail": { "ID": 324627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2310879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259656", "Detail": { "ID": 259656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6188522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239386", "Detail": { "ID": 239386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7345709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273738", "Detail": { "ID": 273738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6335423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304111", "Detail": { "ID": 304111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8501371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221696", "Detail": { "ID": 221696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.943851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241928", "Detail": { "ID": 241928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7860616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223486", "Detail": { "ID": 223486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4605061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307790", "Detail": { "ID": 307790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.845024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272271", "Detail": { "ID": 272271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3224642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244962", "Detail": { "ID": 244962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5860715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315132", "Detail": { "ID": 315132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6756946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247882", "Detail": { "ID": 247882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4324395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275010", "Detail": { "ID": 275010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.137278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255732", "Detail": { "ID": 255732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5545223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277389", "Detail": { "ID": 277389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9512862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253079", "Detail": { "ID": 253079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7659579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276773", "Detail": { "ID": 276773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6804933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325504", "Detail": { "ID": 325504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5092272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232898", "Detail": { "ID": 232898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8814048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311482", "Detail": { "ID": 311482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8807524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230342", "Detail": { "ID": 230342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3188347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267420", "Detail": { "ID": 267420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0190515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313527", "Detail": { "ID": 313527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3992237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295020", "Detail": { "ID": 295020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1887697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319091", "Detail": { "ID": 319091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6920616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306354", "Detail": { "ID": 306354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5484879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310813", "Detail": { "ID": 310813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5871505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268184", "Detail": { "ID": 268184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0598367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286389", "Detail": { "ID": 286389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5770577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258600", "Detail": { "ID": 258600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3142555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263821", "Detail": { "ID": 263821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9118303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308519", "Detail": { "ID": 308519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0594257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279729", "Detail": { "ID": 279729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5201258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279610", "Detail": { "ID": 279610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5150629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261026", "Detail": { "ID": 261026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1086097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299611", "Detail": { "ID": 299611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7051855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306705", "Detail": { "ID": 306705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5638699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300629", "Detail": { "ID": 300629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0068143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223902", "Detail": { "ID": 223902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4786877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237864", "Detail": { "ID": 237864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.229374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305514", "Detail": { "ID": 305514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3276219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320335", "Detail": { "ID": 320335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1555815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315950", "Detail": { "ID": 315950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9392693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236690", "Detail": { "ID": 236690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9358773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289814", "Detail": { "ID": 289814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4602111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234543", "Detail": { "ID": 234543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3888348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313209", "Detail": { "ID": 313209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3823871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289309", "Detail": { "ID": 289309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4317171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225301", "Detail": { "ID": 225301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9634865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265829", "Detail": { "ID": 265829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.456294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283259", "Detail": { "ID": 283259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6927435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251530", "Detail": { "ID": 251530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4676722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317556", "Detail": { "ID": 317556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4275371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254316", "Detail": { "ID": 254316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2503127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296210", "Detail": { "ID": 296210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8387638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235434", "Detail": { "ID": 235434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6776083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257627", "Detail": { "ID": 257627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0646719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228495", "Detail": { "ID": 228495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8015314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291625", "Detail": { "ID": 291625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1353643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311102", "Detail": { "ID": 311102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6054897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246409", "Detail": { "ID": 246409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1274728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298107", "Detail": { "ID": 298107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1385476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234139", "Detail": { "ID": 234139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1683189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274644", "Detail": { "ID": 274644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.11551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269586", "Detail": { "ID": 269586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5541237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317443", "Detail": { "ID": 317443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4223208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326326", "Detail": { "ID": 326326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7536311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241200", "Detail": { "ID": 241200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7473127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290323", "Detail": { "ID": 290323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7418831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248000", "Detail": { "ID": 248000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4374488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287452", "Detail": { "ID": 287452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8648046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222545", "Detail": { "ID": 222545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1935593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307000", "Detail": { "ID": 307000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.583009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239923", "Detail": { "ID": 239923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7651458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283507", "Detail": { "ID": 283507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7108782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231840", "Detail": { "ID": 231840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6178025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237705", "Detail": { "ID": 237705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2222935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309203", "Detail": { "ID": 309203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2029, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 9, "VoteAgainst": 74, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.2", "ID": 6030 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3173524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252701", "Detail": { "ID": 252701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7498594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258915", "Detail": { "ID": 258915, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3337073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319649", "Detail": { "ID": 319649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9353785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249565", "Detail": { "ID": 249565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9323409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227819", "Detail": { "ID": 227819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5670056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280820", "Detail": { "ID": 280820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7837681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262722", "Detail": { "ID": 262722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6140457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288094", "Detail": { "ID": 288094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8998027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229808", "Detail": { "ID": 229808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.09807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269801", "Detail": { "ID": 269801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5635264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322618", "Detail": { "ID": 322618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6964634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295260", "Detail": { "ID": 295260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5043607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242951", "Detail": { "ID": 242951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0425322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235174", "Detail": { "ID": 235174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4225762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302373", "Detail": { "ID": 302373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5215959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244281", "Detail": { "ID": 244281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5478913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327170", "Detail": { "ID": 327170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8021926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277061", "Detail": { "ID": 277061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6994232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264268", "Detail": { "ID": 264268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1259718+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248710", "Detail": { "ID": 248710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6664967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295730", "Detail": { "ID": 295730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5334577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285226", "Detail": { "ID": 285226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3138287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230703", "Detail": { "ID": 230703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3416577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243768", "Detail": { "ID": 243768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3189486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254873", "Detail": { "ID": 254873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2874656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323777", "Detail": { "ID": 323777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.971468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291268", "Detail": { "ID": 291268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1115359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265398", "Detail": { "ID": 265398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4374632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262315", "Detail": { "ID": 262315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5961845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281920", "Detail": { "ID": 281920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1634733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298206", "Detail": { "ID": 298206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3356837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231230", "Detail": { "ID": 231230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5860178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285870", "Detail": { "ID": 285870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.348088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219455", "Detail": { "ID": 219455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2999935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238511", "Detail": { "ID": 238511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4572623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225219", "Detail": { "ID": 225219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9598954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321842", "Detail": { "ID": 321842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4536794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292812", "Detail": { "ID": 292812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5591736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227180", "Detail": { "ID": 227180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2712686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312733", "Detail": { "ID": 312733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1410064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257255", "Detail": { "ID": 257255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.048235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271225", "Detail": { "ID": 271225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0610473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278057", "Detail": { "ID": 278057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.98515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287268", "Detail": { "ID": 287268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8568745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250534", "Detail": { "ID": 250534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1937082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220998", "Detail": { "ID": 220998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6706861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220189", "Detail": { "ID": 220189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3381915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252393", "Detail": { "ID": 252393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7272406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253824", "Detail": { "ID": 253824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0224617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324628", "Detail": { "ID": 324628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2311466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259657", "Detail": { "ID": 259657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6188927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239385", "Detail": { "ID": 239385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7345304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273739", "Detail": { "ID": 273739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6335831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304112", "Detail": { "ID": 304112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8501776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221697", "Detail": { "ID": 221697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9438917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241929", "Detail": { "ID": 241929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7861022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223487", "Detail": { "ID": 223487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4605471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307789", "Detail": { "ID": 307789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8449829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272270", "Detail": { "ID": 272270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3224231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244961", "Detail": { "ID": 244961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5860287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315131", "Detail": { "ID": 315131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6756536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247883", "Detail": { "ID": 247883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4324991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275015", "Detail": { "ID": 275015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1374848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255733", "Detail": { "ID": 255733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5545816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277384", "Detail": { "ID": 277384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9510616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253078", "Detail": { "ID": 253078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7659164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276774", "Detail": { "ID": 276774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6805333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325503", "Detail": { "ID": 325503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5091854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232897", "Detail": { "ID": 232897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8813644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311481", "Detail": { "ID": 311481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8807088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230343", "Detail": { "ID": 230343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3189071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267419", "Detail": { "ID": 267419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0190105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313528", "Detail": { "ID": 313528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3992647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295021", "Detail": { "ID": 295021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1888109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319092", "Detail": { "ID": 319092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6921026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306355", "Detail": { "ID": 306355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5485288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310814", "Detail": { "ID": 310814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5871921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268185", "Detail": { "ID": 268185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0598776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286388", "Detail": { "ID": 286388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5770164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258601", "Detail": { "ID": 258601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3142964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263822", "Detail": { "ID": 263822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9119046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308518", "Detail": { "ID": 308518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0593848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279728", "Detail": { "ID": 279728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5200855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279611", "Detail": { "ID": 279611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.515103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261027", "Detail": { "ID": 261027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1086523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299612", "Detail": { "ID": 299612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7052266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306704", "Detail": { "ID": 306704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5638281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300630", "Detail": { "ID": 300630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0068728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223901", "Detail": { "ID": 223901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4786448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237863", "Detail": { "ID": 237863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2293321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305513", "Detail": { "ID": 305513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3275813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320334", "Detail": { "ID": 320334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1555333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315951", "Detail": { "ID": 315951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9393109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236689", "Detail": { "ID": 236689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9358363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289815", "Detail": { "ID": 289815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4602683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234544", "Detail": { "ID": 234544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3888765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313210", "Detail": { "ID": 313210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3824404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289308", "Detail": { "ID": 289308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4316756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225300", "Detail": { "ID": 225300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9634458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265830", "Detail": { "ID": 265830, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4563348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283260", "Detail": { "ID": 283260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6927858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251529", "Detail": { "ID": 251529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4676308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317555", "Detail": { "ID": 317555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4274946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254317", "Detail": { "ID": 254317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2503539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296209", "Detail": { "ID": 296209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8387116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235433", "Detail": { "ID": 235433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6775663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257626", "Detail": { "ID": 257626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0646295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228494", "Detail": { "ID": 228494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8014893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291626", "Detail": { "ID": 291626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1354038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311101", "Detail": { "ID": 311101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6054491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246408", "Detail": { "ID": 246408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1274322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298108", "Detail": { "ID": 298108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1385891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234140", "Detail": { "ID": 234140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1683604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274643", "Detail": { "ID": 274643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1154689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269585", "Detail": { "ID": 269585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5540763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317442", "Detail": { "ID": 317442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4222805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326327", "Detail": { "ID": 326327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7536721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241199", "Detail": { "ID": 241199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7472722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290322", "Detail": { "ID": 290322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.741823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247999", "Detail": { "ID": 247999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4374083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287451", "Detail": { "ID": 287451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8647628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222544", "Detail": { "ID": 222544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.193518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307001", "Detail": { "ID": 307001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5830506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239924", "Detail": { "ID": 239924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.765187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283666", "Detail": { "ID": 283666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7180597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231841", "Detail": { "ID": 231841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6178439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237706", "Detail": { "ID": 237706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2223341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309204", "Detail": { "ID": 309204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2028, "AgendaID": 3025, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Government Food Policy", "Reference": "S4M-05892.1", "ID": 6025 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-12T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3174082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252747", "Detail": { "ID": 252747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7515861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259134", "Detail": { "ID": 259134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3431901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319595", "Detail": { "ID": 319595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9330467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249499", "Detail": { "ID": 249499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9295145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227872", "Detail": { "ID": 227872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5692921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280874", "Detail": { "ID": 280874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7860675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262770", "Detail": { "ID": 262770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.616106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288948", "Detail": { "ID": 288948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.165234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229859", "Detail": { "ID": 229859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.100491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269737", "Detail": { "ID": 269737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5608194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322575", "Detail": { "ID": 322575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6946049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295306", "Detail": { "ID": 295306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5063212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243006", "Detail": { "ID": 243006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0448828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235109", "Detail": { "ID": 235109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4197743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302424", "Detail": { "ID": 302424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5238217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244233", "Detail": { "ID": 244233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5458064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327084", "Detail": { "ID": 327084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7981536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277109", "Detail": { "ID": 277109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.701481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264065", "Detail": { "ID": 264065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.922689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248669", "Detail": { "ID": 248669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6647512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294906", "Detail": { "ID": 294906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1838231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285273", "Detail": { "ID": 285273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3158812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230748", "Detail": { "ID": 230748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3438442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243712", "Detail": { "ID": 243712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3166078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254822", "Detail": { "ID": 254822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2852256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323691", "Detail": { "ID": 323691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9677315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290920", "Detail": { "ID": 290920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7777609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265446", "Detail": { "ID": 265446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4395238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262355", "Detail": { "ID": 262355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5979028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281865", "Detail": { "ID": 281865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1609339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298262", "Detail": { "ID": 298262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3381873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231191", "Detail": { "ID": 231191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3697536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284979", "Detail": { "ID": 284979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.055987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219495", "Detail": { "ID": 219495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3017555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238292", "Detail": { "ID": 238292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4400942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225154", "Detail": { "ID": 225154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7467641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321885", "Detail": { "ID": 321885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4555187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292759", "Detail": { "ID": 292759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5569256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227220", "Detail": { "ID": 227220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5360394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313246", "Detail": { "ID": 313246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3843071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257783", "Detail": { "ID": 257783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0774244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271112", "Detail": { "ID": 271112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.842995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278003", "Detail": { "ID": 278003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9828211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287319", "Detail": { "ID": 287319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8590458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250600", "Detail": { "ID": 250600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.196565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221063", "Detail": { "ID": 221063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.673475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220149", "Detail": { "ID": 220149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3364581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252445", "Detail": { "ID": 252445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7294651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253772", "Detail": { "ID": 253772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0202587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324714", "Detail": { "ID": 324714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2347487+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259616", "Detail": { "ID": 259616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6171356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239451", "Detail": { "ID": 239451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.737374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273691", "Detail": { "ID": 273691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6312586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304061", "Detail": { "ID": 304061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8477737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221631", "Detail": { "ID": 221631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9410503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241862", "Detail": { "ID": 241862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7832387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223422", "Detail": { "ID": 223422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4571938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307845", "Detail": { "ID": 307845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8533788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272335", "Detail": { "ID": 272335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3309231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245017", "Detail": { "ID": 245017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5884432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315185", "Detail": { "ID": 315185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6779909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247510", "Detail": { "ID": 247510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4069292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275128", "Detail": { "ID": 275128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1427909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255514", "Detail": { "ID": 255514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5345915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276961", "Detail": { "ID": 276961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6887855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253451", "Detail": { "ID": 253451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9969826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276734", "Detail": { "ID": 276734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6788183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325417", "Detail": { "ID": 325417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4978016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233249", "Detail": { "ID": 233249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1158626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311690", "Detail": { "ID": 311690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.89007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229684", "Detail": { "ID": 229684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0922467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267472", "Detail": { "ID": 267472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0213144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313471", "Detail": { "ID": 313471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3967893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294966", "Detail": { "ID": 294966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1864165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319134", "Detail": { "ID": 319134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6939061+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306302", "Detail": { "ID": 306302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5462035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310762", "Detail": { "ID": 310762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5849627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268132", "Detail": { "ID": 268132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.057561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286443", "Detail": { "ID": 286443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5794287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258536", "Detail": { "ID": 258536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3114777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263782", "Detail": { "ID": 263782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9045013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308726", "Detail": { "ID": 308726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.06832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279768", "Detail": { "ID": 279768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5218619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279564", "Detail": { "ID": 279564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5131264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260503", "Detail": { "ID": 260503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0796945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299556", "Detail": { "ID": 299556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7025361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306758", "Detail": { "ID": 306758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.566152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300577", "Detail": { "ID": 300577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0045974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223967", "Detail": { "ID": 223967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4862928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237913", "Detail": { "ID": 237913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2314788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305566", "Detail": { "ID": 305566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3299039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320136", "Detail": { "ID": 320136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9632365+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315897", "Detail": { "ID": 315897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9319358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236737", "Detail": { "ID": 236737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9378913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289768", "Detail": { "ID": 289768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4582782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234491", "Detail": { "ID": 234491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.386558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313157", "Detail": { "ID": 313157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1661088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289360", "Detail": { "ID": 289360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4339028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225365", "Detail": { "ID": 225365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9715901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265779", "Detail": { "ID": 265779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4541175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283220", "Detail": { "ID": 283220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6910402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252031", "Detail": { "ID": 252031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4995914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317358", "Detail": { "ID": 317358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4186767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254251", "Detail": { "ID": 254251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2474831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296262", "Detail": { "ID": 296262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8410719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235474", "Detail": { "ID": 235474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6794071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257677", "Detail": { "ID": 257677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0668092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228560", "Detail": { "ID": 228560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8043761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291575", "Detail": { "ID": 291575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1332605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311154", "Detail": { "ID": 311154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6080299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246783", "Detail": { "ID": 246783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1532349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298063", "Detail": { "ID": 298063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1366809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234093", "Detail": { "ID": 234093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1663416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274684", "Detail": { "ID": 274684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269638", "Detail": { "ID": 269638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5565259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317495", "Detail": { "ID": 317495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4248759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326413", "Detail": { "ID": 326413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7574914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241266", "Detail": { "ID": 241266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7505219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290376", "Detail": { "ID": 290376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7442019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248040", "Detail": { "ID": 248040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4391704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287491", "Detail": { "ID": 287491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.866451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222609", "Detail": { "ID": 222609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1963052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306955", "Detail": { "ID": 306955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5810936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239858", "Detail": { "ID": 239858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7620604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283778", "Detail": { "ID": 283778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7230592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231789", "Detail": { "ID": 231789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6155993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237364", "Detail": { "ID": 237364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2009994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308992", "Detail": { "ID": 308992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2026, "AgendaID": 2114, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 41, "VoteAgainst": 73, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Integration of Adult Health and Social Care", "Reference": "S4M-05838.1", "ID": 5990 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0868563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252663", "Detail": { "ID": 252663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.748236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258876", "Detail": { "ID": 258876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3320236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319855", "Detail": { "ID": 319855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9442967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250264", "Detail": { "ID": 250264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1817016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227774", "Detail": { "ID": 227774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.565069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280777", "Detail": { "ID": 280777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7819679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262525", "Detail": { "ID": 262525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6056659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288075", "Detail": { "ID": 288075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8989686+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230511", "Detail": { "ID": 230511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3333317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270151", "Detail": { "ID": 270151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5837398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322646", "Detail": { "ID": 322646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6976656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294756", "Detail": { "ID": 294756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1769626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242898", "Detail": { "ID": 242898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0402902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235215", "Detail": { "ID": 235215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6604283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302460", "Detail": { "ID": 302460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5255283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244475", "Detail": { "ID": 244475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5563683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327213", "Detail": { "ID": 327213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0260597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277020", "Detail": { "ID": 277020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6976375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264309", "Detail": { "ID": 264309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1277924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248748", "Detail": { "ID": 248748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6680913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295785", "Detail": { "ID": 295785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5357838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285185", "Detail": { "ID": 285185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0700989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230663", "Detail": { "ID": 230663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3398514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243821", "Detail": { "ID": 243821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3211663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254474", "Detail": { "ID": 254474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2576919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323820", "Detail": { "ID": 323820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9733497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291310", "Detail": { "ID": 291310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1134361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265357", "Detail": { "ID": 265357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4356871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262276", "Detail": { "ID": 262276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5945303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281964", "Detail": { "ID": 281964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1653529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298008", "Detail": { "ID": 298008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1343378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231156", "Detail": { "ID": 231156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3680097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285931", "Detail": { "ID": 285931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3507033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219413", "Detail": { "ID": 219413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2976665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238550", "Detail": { "ID": 238550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4589147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226690", "Detail": { "ID": 226690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2423983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321814", "Detail": { "ID": 321814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4525031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292690", "Detail": { "ID": 292690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5536481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227139", "Detail": { "ID": 227139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2695011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313281", "Detail": { "ID": 313281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3885513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257862", "Detail": { "ID": 257862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0807975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271286", "Detail": { "ID": 271286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0637312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278100", "Detail": { "ID": 278100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.987019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287356", "Detail": { "ID": 287356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8607119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250679", "Detail": { "ID": 250679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.20892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221146", "Detail": { "ID": 221146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6770442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220230", "Detail": { "ID": 220230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.629444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252784", "Detail": { "ID": 252784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7531258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266096", "Detail": { "ID": 266096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4741756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324585", "Detail": { "ID": 324585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.229317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259695", "Detail": { "ID": 259695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6205366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239346", "Detail": { "ID": 239346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7328538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273780", "Detail": { "ID": 273780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6353398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304026", "Detail": { "ID": 304026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8461989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223168", "Detail": { "ID": 223168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2315467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245679", "Detail": { "ID": 245679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8538197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223528", "Detail": { "ID": 223528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4623258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307592", "Detail": { "ID": 307592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8361605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272415", "Detail": { "ID": 272415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3343514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244907", "Detail": { "ID": 244907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5837228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315077", "Detail": { "ID": 315077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6730852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247922", "Detail": { "ID": 247922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4341364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274799", "Detail": { "ID": 274799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1222526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255772", "Detail": { "ID": 255772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5562102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277446", "Detail": { "ID": 277446, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9537157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253040", "Detail": { "ID": 253040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7642564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276815", "Detail": { "ID": 276815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.682268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325546", "Detail": { "ID": 325546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5110154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233283", "Detail": { "ID": 233283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1173214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311437", "Detail": { "ID": 311437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8787669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230383", "Detail": { "ID": 230383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3274263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267375", "Detail": { "ID": 267375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.016875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313724", "Detail": { "ID": 313724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4079302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295066", "Detail": { "ID": 295066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1907442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319064", "Detail": { "ID": 319064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6908692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306409", "Detail": { "ID": 306409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5508439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310390", "Detail": { "ID": 310390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5684486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268228", "Detail": { "ID": 268228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2543802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286344", "Detail": { "ID": 286344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5747802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271847", "Detail": { "ID": 271847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0939929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263863", "Detail": { "ID": 263863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9140073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308795", "Detail": { "ID": 308795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0715732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279687", "Detail": { "ID": 279687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5183563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279962", "Detail": { "ID": 279962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5303287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261081", "Detail": { "ID": 261081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1109929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299655", "Detail": { "ID": 299655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7070714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306826", "Detail": { "ID": 306826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.575364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300508", "Detail": { "ID": 300508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0012971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224203", "Detail": { "ID": 224203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4970288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237517", "Detail": { "ID": 237517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2142527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305458", "Detail": { "ID": 305458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3248953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320362", "Detail": { "ID": 320362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1631523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316005", "Detail": { "ID": 316005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9417422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236648", "Detail": { "ID": 236648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9340624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291396", "Detail": { "ID": 291396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1175045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234302", "Detail": { "ID": 234302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3714092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313575", "Detail": { "ID": 313575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4012994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290199", "Detail": { "ID": 290199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7363966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225258", "Detail": { "ID": 225258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9616281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265742", "Detail": { "ID": 265742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4525203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283301", "Detail": { "ID": 283301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6945761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251491", "Detail": { "ID": 251491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4659619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317583", "Detail": { "ID": 317583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4286848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256685", "Detail": { "ID": 256685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7933246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296945", "Detail": { "ID": 296945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8807573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235394", "Detail": { "ID": 235394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6686086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257713", "Detail": { "ID": 257713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0685064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228641", "Detail": { "ID": 228641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8078679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291073", "Detail": { "ID": 291073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7842991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311046", "Detail": { "ID": 311046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6030937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246863", "Detail": { "ID": 246863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1566277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298149", "Detail": { "ID": 298149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1403161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234334", "Detail": { "ID": 234334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3727914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274602", "Detail": { "ID": 274602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1136987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269542", "Detail": { "ID": 269542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5521163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317388", "Detail": { "ID": 317388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4199689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326284", "Detail": { "ID": 326284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7518168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241347", "Detail": { "ID": 241347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7540175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289650", "Detail": { "ID": 289650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4531158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247808", "Detail": { "ID": 247808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4293296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287409", "Detail": { "ID": 287409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8629821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222503", "Detail": { "ID": 222503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1917644+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306921", "Detail": { "ID": 306921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5796051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240928", "Detail": { "ID": 240928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3884431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283450", "Detail": { "ID": 283450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7084103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232190", "Detail": { "ID": 232190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6387073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237745", "Detail": { "ID": 237745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2240604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309247", "Detail": { "ID": 309247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2024, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813.2", "ID": 5968 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3211054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252664", "Detail": { "ID": 252664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7482792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258877", "Detail": { "ID": 258877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3320639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318742", "Detail": { "ID": 318742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6714554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250263", "Detail": { "ID": 250263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1816607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227775", "Detail": { "ID": 227775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5651087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280778", "Detail": { "ID": 280778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7820078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262683", "Detail": { "ID": 262683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6123904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288085", "Detail": { "ID": 288085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8993986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230512", "Detail": { "ID": 230512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3333731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270150", "Detail": { "ID": 270150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5836992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322647", "Detail": { "ID": 322647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6977056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294758", "Detail": { "ID": 294758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1770634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242899", "Detail": { "ID": 242899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0403486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235214", "Detail": { "ID": 235214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6603864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302461", "Detail": { "ID": 302461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.525569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244473", "Detail": { "ID": 244473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5562846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326998", "Detail": { "ID": 326998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7891849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277022", "Detail": { "ID": 277022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6977207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264307", "Detail": { "ID": 264307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1276968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248747", "Detail": { "ID": 248747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6680508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294821", "Detail": { "ID": 294821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1797945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285187", "Detail": { "ID": 285187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0701821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230664", "Detail": { "ID": 230664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.339913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243820", "Detail": { "ID": 243820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3211266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254473", "Detail": { "ID": 254473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2576505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323451", "Detail": { "ID": 323451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9567376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291309", "Detail": { "ID": 291309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1133951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265359", "Detail": { "ID": 265359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4357698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262277", "Detail": { "ID": 262277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5945724+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281963", "Detail": { "ID": 281963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1653115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298009", "Detail": { "ID": 298009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1343796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231155", "Detail": { "ID": 231155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3679696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285913", "Detail": { "ID": 285913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3499414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219414", "Detail": { "ID": 219414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2977076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238549", "Detail": { "ID": 238549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4588741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226689", "Detail": { "ID": 226689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2423573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321813", "Detail": { "ID": 321813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4524618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292689", "Detail": { "ID": 292689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5536081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227140", "Detail": { "ID": 227140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2695424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313282", "Detail": { "ID": 313282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3885929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257863", "Detail": { "ID": 257863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0808377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271268", "Detail": { "ID": 271268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0629682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278099", "Detail": { "ID": 278099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9869756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287357", "Detail": { "ID": 287357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.860752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250680", "Detail": { "ID": 250680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2089606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221147", "Detail": { "ID": 221147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.677085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220229", "Detail": { "ID": 220229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6294029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252785", "Detail": { "ID": 252785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7531655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266095", "Detail": { "ID": 266095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4741348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324800", "Detail": { "ID": 324800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2383651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259694", "Detail": { "ID": 259694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6204956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239347", "Detail": { "ID": 239347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7328947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273778", "Detail": { "ID": 273778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6352584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304025", "Detail": { "ID": 304025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8461586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223167", "Detail": { "ID": 223167, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.231506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245678", "Detail": { "ID": 245678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8537803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223527", "Detail": { "ID": 223527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4622839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307593", "Detail": { "ID": 307593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8362014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272416", "Detail": { "ID": 272416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3343919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244908", "Detail": { "ID": 244908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5837631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315269", "Detail": { "ID": 315269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9012195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247921", "Detail": { "ID": 247921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4340966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274817", "Detail": { "ID": 274817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1230309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255771", "Detail": { "ID": 255771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5561699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277428", "Detail": { "ID": 277428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9529441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253041", "Detail": { "ID": 253041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.764315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276814", "Detail": { "ID": 276814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6822271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325331", "Detail": { "ID": 325331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4940928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233284", "Detail": { "ID": 233284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1173806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311438", "Detail": { "ID": 311438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8788279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230382", "Detail": { "ID": 230382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3273834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267376", "Detail": { "ID": 267376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.016916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313723", "Detail": { "ID": 313723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4078903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295065", "Detail": { "ID": 295065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1907028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319063", "Detail": { "ID": 319063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6908283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306216", "Detail": { "ID": 306216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5425389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310389", "Detail": { "ID": 310389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5684073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268227", "Detail": { "ID": 268227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2543396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286345", "Detail": { "ID": 286345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5748208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271846", "Detail": { "ID": 271846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0939518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263862", "Detail": { "ID": 263862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9139672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308796", "Detail": { "ID": 308796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0716147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279688", "Detail": { "ID": 279688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5183961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279960", "Detail": { "ID": 279960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5302458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261080", "Detail": { "ID": 261080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.110952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299654", "Detail": { "ID": 299654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7070315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306827", "Detail": { "ID": 306827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5754049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300507", "Detail": { "ID": 300507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0012546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224204", "Detail": { "ID": 224204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4970714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237518", "Detail": { "ID": 237518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2142937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305651", "Detail": { "ID": 305651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3335471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320363", "Detail": { "ID": 320363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1631934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315814", "Detail": { "ID": 315814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9281906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236650", "Detail": { "ID": 236650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9341455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289854", "Detail": { "ID": 289854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4619059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234301", "Detail": { "ID": 234301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3713679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312917", "Detail": { "ID": 312917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1554525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290200", "Detail": { "ID": 290200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7364503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225259", "Detail": { "ID": 225259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9616694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265741", "Detail": { "ID": 265741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4524781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283300", "Detail": { "ID": 283300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6945353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251492", "Detail": { "ID": 251492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4660031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317584", "Detail": { "ID": 317584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4287247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256684", "Detail": { "ID": 256684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7932819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296946", "Detail": { "ID": 296946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8807973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235395", "Detail": { "ID": 235395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6687212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257714", "Detail": { "ID": 257714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0685507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229257", "Detail": { "ID": 229257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0688578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291072", "Detail": { "ID": 291072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7842584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311550", "Detail": { "ID": 311550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8836988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246864", "Detail": { "ID": 246864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1566679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298147", "Detail": { "ID": 298147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1402339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234332", "Detail": { "ID": 234332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3727088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274603", "Detail": { "ID": 274603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1137396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269543", "Detail": { "ID": 269543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5521572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317734", "Detail": { "ID": 317734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4350732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326499", "Detail": { "ID": 326499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7673206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241348", "Detail": { "ID": 241348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7540587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289651", "Detail": { "ID": 289651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4531573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247809", "Detail": { "ID": 247809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4293711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287410", "Detail": { "ID": 287410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8630223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222504", "Detail": { "ID": 222504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1918057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306920", "Detail": { "ID": 306920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.579564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240927", "Detail": { "ID": 240927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.388401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283468", "Detail": { "ID": 283468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7092021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232189", "Detail": { "ID": 232189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6386659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237744", "Detail": { "ID": 237744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2240118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309246", "Detail": { "ID": 309246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2025, "AgendaID": 2465, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 52, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "NHS Waiting Times", "Reference": "S4M-05813", "ID": 5944 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-03-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3210633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252662", "Detail": { "ID": 252662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7481897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258875", "Detail": { "ID": 258875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3319835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319856", "Detail": { "ID": 319856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9443372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249625", "Detail": { "ID": 249625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.94278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227773", "Detail": { "ID": 227773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5650282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280776", "Detail": { "ID": 280776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7819283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262524", "Detail": { "ID": 262524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6056256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288076", "Detail": { "ID": 288076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8990288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230510", "Detail": { "ID": 230510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.333291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270152", "Detail": { "ID": 270152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5837996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322645", "Detail": { "ID": 322645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6976243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294755", "Detail": { "ID": 294755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1769221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242897", "Detail": { "ID": 242897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0402494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235216", "Detail": { "ID": 235216, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6604698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302459", "Detail": { "ID": 302459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5254881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244476", "Detail": { "ID": 244476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5564107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327212", "Detail": { "ID": 327212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0260079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277019", "Detail": { "ID": 277019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.697597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264310", "Detail": { "ID": 264310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1278353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248749", "Detail": { "ID": 248749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6681314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295786", "Detail": { "ID": 295786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.535824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285184", "Detail": { "ID": 285184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0700576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230662", "Detail": { "ID": 230662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3398111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243822", "Detail": { "ID": 243822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3212063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254475", "Detail": { "ID": 254475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2577344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323819", "Detail": { "ID": 323819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9732797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291311", "Detail": { "ID": 291311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1134769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265356", "Detail": { "ID": 265356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4356467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262275", "Detail": { "ID": 262275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5944714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281965", "Detail": { "ID": 281965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1653936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298007", "Detail": { "ID": 298007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1342794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231157", "Detail": { "ID": 231157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3680493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285930", "Detail": { "ID": 285930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3506621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219412", "Detail": { "ID": 219412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2976244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238551", "Detail": { "ID": 238551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4589741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225432", "Detail": { "ID": 225432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9744797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321815", "Detail": { "ID": 321815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4525434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292691", "Detail": { "ID": 292691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5536882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227138", "Detail": { "ID": 227138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2694594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313280", "Detail": { "ID": 313280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3885101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257194", "Detail": { "ID": 257194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0454837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271285", "Detail": { "ID": 271285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0636905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278101", "Detail": { "ID": 278101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9870597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287355", "Detail": { "ID": 287355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8606713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250472", "Detail": { "ID": 250472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1910187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220939", "Detail": { "ID": 220939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6681614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220231", "Detail": { "ID": 220231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.629486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252783", "Detail": { "ID": 252783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7530861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266097", "Detail": { "ID": 266097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4742159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324586", "Detail": { "ID": 324586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2293591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259696", "Detail": { "ID": 259696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6205774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239345", "Detail": { "ID": 239345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7328133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273781", "Detail": { "ID": 273781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6353802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304027", "Detail": { "ID": 304027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8462389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221756", "Detail": { "ID": 221756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9464324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241989", "Detail": { "ID": 241989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7890344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223529", "Detail": { "ID": 223529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4623669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307591", "Detail": { "ID": 307591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.83612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272413", "Detail": { "ID": 272413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3342697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244906", "Detail": { "ID": 244906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5836824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315076", "Detail": { "ID": 315076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6730444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247923", "Detail": { "ID": 247923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.434177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274800", "Detail": { "ID": 274800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1222933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255773", "Detail": { "ID": 255773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5562564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277445", "Detail": { "ID": 277445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9536755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253039", "Detail": { "ID": 253039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7642149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276816", "Detail": { "ID": 276816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6823094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325545", "Detail": { "ID": 325545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5109569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233282", "Detail": { "ID": 233282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1172812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311436", "Detail": { "ID": 311436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8787246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230384", "Detail": { "ID": 230384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3274684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267374", "Detail": { "ID": 267374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0168335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313725", "Detail": { "ID": 313725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4079702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295067", "Detail": { "ID": 295067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.190785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319065", "Detail": { "ID": 319065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6909111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306410", "Detail": { "ID": 306410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.550884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310391", "Detail": { "ID": 310391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5685078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268229", "Detail": { "ID": 268229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2544208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286343", "Detail": { "ID": 286343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5747394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271849", "Detail": { "ID": 271849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.094092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263864", "Detail": { "ID": 263864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9140476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308794", "Detail": { "ID": 308794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0715317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279686", "Detail": { "ID": 279686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5183163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279963", "Detail": { "ID": 279963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5303885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261082", "Detail": { "ID": 261082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1110341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299656", "Detail": { "ID": 299656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.707112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306825", "Detail": { "ID": 306825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5753235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300509", "Detail": { "ID": 300509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0013377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223688", "Detail": { "ID": 223688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4695341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237516", "Detail": { "ID": 237516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2142113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305457", "Detail": { "ID": 305457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.324854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320361", "Detail": { "ID": 320361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.163111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316006", "Detail": { "ID": 316006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9417833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236647", "Detail": { "ID": 236647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9340222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291397", "Detail": { "ID": 291397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1175455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234303", "Detail": { "ID": 234303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3714504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313576", "Detail": { "ID": 313576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4013399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290198", "Detail": { "ID": 290198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7363407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225257", "Detail": { "ID": 225257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9615872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265743", "Detail": { "ID": 265743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4525614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283302", "Detail": { "ID": 283302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6946791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251490", "Detail": { "ID": 251490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4659202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317582", "Detail": { "ID": 317582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4286438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254691", "Detail": { "ID": 254691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2795115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296944", "Detail": { "ID": 296944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8807175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235393", "Detail": { "ID": 235393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6685669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257712", "Detail": { "ID": 257712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0684582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228127", "Detail": { "ID": 228127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5855086+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291074", "Detail": { "ID": 291074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7843397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311045", "Detail": { "ID": 311045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6030531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246348", "Detail": { "ID": 246348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1248622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298150", "Detail": { "ID": 298150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1403566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234335", "Detail": { "ID": 234335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3728337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274601", "Detail": { "ID": 274601, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1136571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269541", "Detail": { "ID": 269541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5520745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317387", "Detail": { "ID": 317387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4199284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326285", "Detail": { "ID": 326285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7518576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241139", "Detail": { "ID": 241139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4037254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289649", "Detail": { "ID": 289649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4530575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247807", "Detail": { "ID": 247807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4292709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287408", "Detail": { "ID": 287408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8629418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222502", "Detail": { "ID": 222502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.191716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306922", "Detail": { "ID": 306922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.579668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239984", "Detail": { "ID": 239984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7677637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283451", "Detail": { "ID": 283451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.708452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232191", "Detail": { "ID": 232191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.638748+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237746", "Detail": { "ID": 237746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2241015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309248", "Detail": { "ID": 309248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2023, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.2", "ID": 5814 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3211465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252630", "Detail": { "ID": 252630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7377437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258871", "Detail": { "ID": 258871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3318211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319860", "Detail": { "ID": 319860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9444999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249630", "Detail": { "ID": 249630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9430146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227735", "Detail": { "ID": 227735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5633896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280736", "Detail": { "ID": 280736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7802466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262520", "Detail": { "ID": 262520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6054648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288080", "Detail": { "ID": 288080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8991938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230506", "Detail": { "ID": 230506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3331236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270156", "Detail": { "ID": 270156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5839645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322733", "Detail": { "ID": 322733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7013162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294751", "Detail": { "ID": 294751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1767598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242893", "Detail": { "ID": 242893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.040091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235220", "Detail": { "ID": 235220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6606591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302455", "Detail": { "ID": 302455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5253267+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244480", "Detail": { "ID": 244480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5565761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327208", "Detail": { "ID": 327208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0257891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276703", "Detail": { "ID": 276703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6775258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264314", "Detail": { "ID": 264314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1280346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248753", "Detail": { "ID": 248753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6683125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295790", "Detail": { "ID": 295790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5359836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285180", "Detail": { "ID": 285180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.069878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230658", "Detail": { "ID": 230658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3396499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243826", "Detail": { "ID": 243826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3213636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254479", "Detail": { "ID": 254479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2578987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323815", "Detail": { "ID": 323815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9731151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291315", "Detail": { "ID": 291315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1136598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265352", "Detail": { "ID": 265352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4354827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262271", "Detail": { "ID": 262271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5943104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282005", "Detail": { "ID": 282005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1671079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297968", "Detail": { "ID": 297968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1326479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231161", "Detail": { "ID": 231161, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3682096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285926", "Detail": { "ID": 285926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3504987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219408", "Detail": { "ID": 219408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2974534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238555", "Detail": { "ID": 238555, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4591791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225436", "Detail": { "ID": 225436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9746428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321727", "Detail": { "ID": 321727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4488239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292695", "Detail": { "ID": 292695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5538477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227134", "Detail": { "ID": 227134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2692751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313276", "Detail": { "ID": 313276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3883233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257189", "Detail": { "ID": 257189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.827138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271281", "Detail": { "ID": 271281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0635272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278449", "Detail": { "ID": 278449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2192942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287351", "Detail": { "ID": 287351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.860485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250467", "Detail": { "ID": 250467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1907954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220935", "Detail": { "ID": 220935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6679765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220235", "Detail": { "ID": 220235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6296498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252779", "Detail": { "ID": 252779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7529272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266136", "Detail": { "ID": 266136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4758897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324590", "Detail": { "ID": 324590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2295202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259700", "Detail": { "ID": 259700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6207423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239341", "Detail": { "ID": 239341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7326502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273785", "Detail": { "ID": 273785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6355421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304031", "Detail": { "ID": 304031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8464196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221760", "Detail": { "ID": 221760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9466193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241993", "Detail": { "ID": 241993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7891976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223533", "Detail": { "ID": 223533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4625299+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307552", "Detail": { "ID": 307552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8344373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272206", "Detail": { "ID": 272206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3195543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244902", "Detail": { "ID": 244902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.583501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315072", "Detail": { "ID": 315072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6728607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247927", "Detail": { "ID": 247927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4343542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274804", "Detail": { "ID": 274804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1224557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255777", "Detail": { "ID": 255777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5564366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277441", "Detail": { "ID": 277441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9535154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253035", "Detail": { "ID": 253035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7640517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276820", "Detail": { "ID": 276820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.68247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325541", "Detail": { "ID": 325541, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5107962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233278", "Detail": { "ID": 233278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1171186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311399", "Detail": { "ID": 311399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8770499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230388", "Detail": { "ID": 230388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3276596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267335", "Detail": { "ID": 267335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.014999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313762", "Detail": { "ID": 313762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.409568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295414", "Detail": { "ID": 295414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5111527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319008", "Detail": { "ID": 319008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6884679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306414", "Detail": { "ID": 306414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5510458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310395", "Detail": { "ID": 310395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5686728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268268", "Detail": { "ID": 268268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2597404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286303", "Detail": { "ID": 286303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5729952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260678", "Detail": { "ID": 260678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0875424+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263868", "Detail": { "ID": 263868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.914235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308790", "Detail": { "ID": 308790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0713673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279682", "Detail": { "ID": 279682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5180951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279967", "Detail": { "ID": 279967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5305538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261086", "Detail": { "ID": 261086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1111983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299695", "Detail": { "ID": 299695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7186194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306821", "Detail": { "ID": 306821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5751595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300513", "Detail": { "ID": 300513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0015357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223684", "Detail": { "ID": 223684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4693538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237512", "Detail": { "ID": 237512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2139065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305453", "Detail": { "ID": 305453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3246731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320418", "Detail": { "ID": 320418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1655621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316010", "Detail": { "ID": 316010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9419474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236643", "Detail": { "ID": 236643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9338604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291401", "Detail": { "ID": 291401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1177103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234307", "Detail": { "ID": 234307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3716346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313580", "Detail": { "ID": 313580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4015241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290194", "Detail": { "ID": 290194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4831113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225253", "Detail": { "ID": 225253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9614011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265747", "Detail": { "ID": 265747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4527265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283306", "Detail": { "ID": 283306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6948559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251486", "Detail": { "ID": 251486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4657525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317638", "Detail": { "ID": 317638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.431022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254696", "Detail": { "ID": 254696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2797314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296940", "Detail": { "ID": 296940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8805381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234929", "Detail": { "ID": 234929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4058628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257708", "Detail": { "ID": 257708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0681394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228123", "Detail": { "ID": 228123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5853471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291078", "Detail": { "ID": 291078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7845215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311041", "Detail": { "ID": 311041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6028903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246344", "Detail": { "ID": 246344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1246785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298154", "Detail": { "ID": 298154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1405412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234339", "Detail": { "ID": 234339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3730192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274597", "Detail": { "ID": 274597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1134934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269502", "Detail": { "ID": 269502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5504025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317383", "Detail": { "ID": 317383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4197665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326289", "Detail": { "ID": 326289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7520219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241135", "Detail": { "ID": 241135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4035433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289645", "Detail": { "ID": 289645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4528977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247803", "Detail": { "ID": 247803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4291111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287404", "Detail": { "ID": 287404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8627586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222498", "Detail": { "ID": 222498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1915522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306926", "Detail": { "ID": 306926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5798336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239988", "Detail": { "ID": 239988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7679262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283455", "Detail": { "ID": 283455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7086381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232229", "Detail": { "ID": 232229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8457056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237750", "Detail": { "ID": 237750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2242623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309286", "Detail": { "ID": 309286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2019, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 54, "VoteAgainst": 61, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Health", "Reference": "S4M-05654.1", "ID": 5811 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3227641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252659", "Detail": { "ID": 252659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7389712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258872", "Detail": { "ID": 258872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3318621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319859", "Detail": { "ID": 319859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9444596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249629", "Detail": { "ID": 249629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9429746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227770", "Detail": { "ID": 227770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5648852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280773", "Detail": { "ID": 280773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7817886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262521", "Detail": { "ID": 262521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6055053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288079", "Detail": { "ID": 288079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8991532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230507", "Detail": { "ID": 230507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.333166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270155", "Detail": { "ID": 270155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5839235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322735", "Detail": { "ID": 322735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7013959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294752", "Detail": { "ID": 294752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1768003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242894", "Detail": { "ID": 242894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0401308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235219", "Detail": { "ID": 235219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6606172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302456", "Detail": { "ID": 302456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5253667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244479", "Detail": { "ID": 244479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5565339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327209", "Detail": { "ID": 327209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0258501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276704", "Detail": { "ID": 276704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6775657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264313", "Detail": { "ID": 264313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1279873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248752", "Detail": { "ID": 248752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6682723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295789", "Detail": { "ID": 295789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5359439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285181", "Detail": { "ID": 285181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0699184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230659", "Detail": { "ID": 230659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3396901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243825", "Detail": { "ID": 243825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3213241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254478", "Detail": { "ID": 254478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2578572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323816", "Detail": { "ID": 323816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9731568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291314", "Detail": { "ID": 291314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1136006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265353", "Detail": { "ID": 265353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4355236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262272", "Detail": { "ID": 262272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5943506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281968", "Detail": { "ID": 281968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1655147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298004", "Detail": { "ID": 298004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1341591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231160", "Detail": { "ID": 231160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3681698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285927", "Detail": { "ID": 285927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3505395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219409", "Detail": { "ID": 219409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2974992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238554", "Detail": { "ID": 238554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.45913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225435", "Detail": { "ID": 225435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9746017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321725", "Detail": { "ID": 321725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4487434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292694", "Detail": { "ID": 292694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5538079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227135", "Detail": { "ID": 227135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2693161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313277", "Detail": { "ID": 313277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3883642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257190", "Detail": { "ID": 257190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8271793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271282", "Detail": { "ID": 271282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0635677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278413", "Detail": { "ID": 278413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2177116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287352", "Detail": { "ID": 287352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8605477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250468", "Detail": { "ID": 250468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.190836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220936", "Detail": { "ID": 220936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.668018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220234", "Detail": { "ID": 220234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6296084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252780", "Detail": { "ID": 252780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7529671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266100", "Detail": { "ID": 266100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4743378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324589", "Detail": { "ID": 324589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2294803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259699", "Detail": { "ID": 259699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.620701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239342", "Detail": { "ID": 239342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7326906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273784", "Detail": { "ID": 273784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6354998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304030", "Detail": { "ID": 304030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8463794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221759", "Detail": { "ID": 221759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9465788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241992", "Detail": { "ID": 241992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.789157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223532", "Detail": { "ID": 223532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4624891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307588", "Detail": { "ID": 307588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8359989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272207", "Detail": { "ID": 272207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3196059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244903", "Detail": { "ID": 244903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5835412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315073", "Detail": { "ID": 315073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6729015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247926", "Detail": { "ID": 247926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4342967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274803", "Detail": { "ID": 274803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1224152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255776", "Detail": { "ID": 255776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5563774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277442", "Detail": { "ID": 277442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9535552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253036", "Detail": { "ID": 253036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7640925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276819", "Detail": { "ID": 276819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6824296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325542", "Detail": { "ID": 325542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5108364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233279", "Detail": { "ID": 233279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1171592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311433", "Detail": { "ID": 311433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8786006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230387", "Detail": { "ID": 230387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3276162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267371", "Detail": { "ID": 267371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0166641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313728", "Detail": { "ID": 313728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4081109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295070", "Detail": { "ID": 295070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1909074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318975", "Detail": { "ID": 318975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6870496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306413", "Detail": { "ID": 306413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5510058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310394", "Detail": { "ID": 310394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5686319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268232", "Detail": { "ID": 268232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2545433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286340", "Detail": { "ID": 286340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5745962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260677", "Detail": { "ID": 260677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0875016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263867", "Detail": { "ID": 263867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9141947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308791", "Detail": { "ID": 308791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0714082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279683", "Detail": { "ID": 279683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5181801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279966", "Detail": { "ID": 279966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5305133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261085", "Detail": { "ID": 261085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1111573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299659", "Detail": { "ID": 299659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7072328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306822", "Detail": { "ID": 306822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5752007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300512", "Detail": { "ID": 300512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.001494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223685", "Detail": { "ID": 223685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.469394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237513", "Detail": { "ID": 237513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2139477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305454", "Detail": { "ID": 305454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3247144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320606", "Detail": { "ID": 320606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1736381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316009", "Detail": { "ID": 316009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9419055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236644", "Detail": { "ID": 236644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9339016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291400", "Detail": { "ID": 291400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1176695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234306", "Detail": { "ID": 234306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3715941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313579", "Detail": { "ID": 313579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4014819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290195", "Detail": { "ID": 290195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4831726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225254", "Detail": { "ID": 225254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9614625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265746", "Detail": { "ID": 265746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4526848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283305", "Detail": { "ID": 283305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6948151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251487", "Detail": { "ID": 251487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4657939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317825", "Detail": { "ID": 317825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4390007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254695", "Detail": { "ID": 254695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2796897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296941", "Detail": { "ID": 296941, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8805957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235390", "Detail": { "ID": 235390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6684426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257709", "Detail": { "ID": 257709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0681806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228124", "Detail": { "ID": 228124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5853875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291077", "Detail": { "ID": 291077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7844811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311042", "Detail": { "ID": 311042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6029307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246345", "Detail": { "ID": 246345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1247195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298153", "Detail": { "ID": 298153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1404998+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234338", "Detail": { "ID": 234338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3729764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274598", "Detail": { "ID": 274598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1135342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269538", "Detail": { "ID": 269538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5519528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317384", "Detail": { "ID": 317384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4198068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326288", "Detail": { "ID": 326288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7519809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241136", "Detail": { "ID": 241136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4035836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289646", "Detail": { "ID": 289646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4529373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247804", "Detail": { "ID": 247804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4291512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287405", "Detail": { "ID": 287405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8627991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222499", "Detail": { "ID": 222499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1915938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306925", "Detail": { "ID": 306925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5797927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239987", "Detail": { "ID": 239987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7678861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283454", "Detail": { "ID": 283454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7085767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232194", "Detail": { "ID": 232194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6388705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237749", "Detail": { "ID": 237749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2242224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309251", "Detail": { "ID": 309251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2020, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 61, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.2", "ID": 5815 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.321269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252660", "Detail": { "ID": 252660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7390297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258873", "Detail": { "ID": 258873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3319023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319858", "Detail": { "ID": 319858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9444194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249628", "Detail": { "ID": 249628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9429328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227771", "Detail": { "ID": 227771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5649464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280774", "Detail": { "ID": 280774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.781847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262522", "Detail": { "ID": 262522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6055451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288078", "Detail": { "ID": 288078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8991127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230508", "Detail": { "ID": 230508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3332073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270154", "Detail": { "ID": 270154, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5838832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322736", "Detail": { "ID": 322736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7014356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294753", "Detail": { "ID": 294753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1768413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242895", "Detail": { "ID": 242895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0401701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235218", "Detail": { "ID": 235218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6605742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302457", "Detail": { "ID": 302457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.525407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244478", "Detail": { "ID": 244478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.556493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327210", "Detail": { "ID": 327210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.025904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276705", "Detail": { "ID": 276705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6776059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264312", "Detail": { "ID": 264312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1279166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248751", "Detail": { "ID": 248751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6682312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295788", "Detail": { "ID": 295788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5359046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285182", "Detail": { "ID": 285182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0699593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230660", "Detail": { "ID": 230660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3397308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243824", "Detail": { "ID": 243824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3212851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254477", "Detail": { "ID": 254477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2578163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323817", "Detail": { "ID": 323817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9731974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291313", "Detail": { "ID": 291313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1135602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265354", "Detail": { "ID": 265354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4355642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262273", "Detail": { "ID": 262273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5943909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281967", "Detail": { "ID": 281967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1654743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298005", "Detail": { "ID": 298005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1341993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231159", "Detail": { "ID": 231159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3681293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285928", "Detail": { "ID": 285928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.35058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219410", "Detail": { "ID": 219410, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.297541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238553", "Detail": { "ID": 238553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4590853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225434", "Detail": { "ID": 225434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9745609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321724", "Detail": { "ID": 321724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4487025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292693", "Detail": { "ID": 292693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5537679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227136", "Detail": { "ID": 227136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2693775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313278", "Detail": { "ID": 313278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3884262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257191", "Detail": { "ID": 257191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8272202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271283", "Detail": { "ID": 271283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0636083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278412", "Detail": { "ID": 278412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2176696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287353", "Detail": { "ID": 287353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8605896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250469", "Detail": { "ID": 250469, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1908762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220937", "Detail": { "ID": 220937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6680774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220233", "Detail": { "ID": 220233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6295678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252781", "Detail": { "ID": 252781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7530066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266099", "Detail": { "ID": 266099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4742974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324588", "Detail": { "ID": 324588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2294403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259698", "Detail": { "ID": 259698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6206595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239343", "Detail": { "ID": 239343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7327315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273783", "Detail": { "ID": 273783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6354599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304029", "Detail": { "ID": 304029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8463391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221758", "Detail": { "ID": 221758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9465387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241991", "Detail": { "ID": 241991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7891164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223531", "Detail": { "ID": 223531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4624484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307589", "Detail": { "ID": 307589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8360394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272208", "Detail": { "ID": 272208, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.319657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244904", "Detail": { "ID": 244904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5835991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315074", "Detail": { "ID": 315074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6729609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247925", "Detail": { "ID": 247925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4342572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274802", "Detail": { "ID": 274802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1223749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255775", "Detail": { "ID": 255775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5563379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277443", "Detail": { "ID": 277443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9535955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253037", "Detail": { "ID": 253037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7641337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276818", "Detail": { "ID": 276818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6823897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325543", "Detail": { "ID": 325543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5108761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233280", "Detail": { "ID": 233280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1172001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311434", "Detail": { "ID": 311434, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8786419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230386", "Detail": { "ID": 230386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3275494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267372", "Detail": { "ID": 267372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0167055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313727", "Detail": { "ID": 313727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4080695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295069", "Detail": { "ID": 295069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1908667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318974", "Detail": { "ID": 318974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6870091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306412", "Detail": { "ID": 306412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5509652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310393", "Detail": { "ID": 310393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5685902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268231", "Detail": { "ID": 268231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2545023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286341", "Detail": { "ID": 286341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5746366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260676", "Detail": { "ID": 260676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0874601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263866", "Detail": { "ID": 263866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9141538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308792", "Detail": { "ID": 308792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0714494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279684", "Detail": { "ID": 279684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5182336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279965", "Detail": { "ID": 279965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5304723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261084", "Detail": { "ID": 261084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1111168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299658", "Detail": { "ID": 299658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7071926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306823", "Detail": { "ID": 306823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5752417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300511", "Detail": { "ID": 300511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0014509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223686", "Detail": { "ID": 223686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4694525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237514", "Detail": { "ID": 237514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2140921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305455", "Detail": { "ID": 305455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3247547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320607", "Detail": { "ID": 320607, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1736785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316008", "Detail": { "ID": 316008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9418645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236645", "Detail": { "ID": 236645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9339418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291399", "Detail": { "ID": 291399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1176289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234305", "Detail": { "ID": 234305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3715522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313578", "Detail": { "ID": 313578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4014225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290196", "Detail": { "ID": 290196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4832151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225255", "Detail": { "ID": 225255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9615043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265745", "Detail": { "ID": 265745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4526434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283304", "Detail": { "ID": 283304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6947737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251488", "Detail": { "ID": 251488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4658359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317826", "Detail": { "ID": 317826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4390434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254694", "Detail": { "ID": 254694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2796482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296942", "Detail": { "ID": 296942, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8806371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235391", "Detail": { "ID": 235391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6684837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257710", "Detail": { "ID": 257710, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0682217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228125", "Detail": { "ID": 228125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5854278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291076", "Detail": { "ID": 291076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7844407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311043", "Detail": { "ID": 311043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.602972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246346", "Detail": { "ID": 246346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1247603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298152", "Detail": { "ID": 298152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.140457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234337", "Detail": { "ID": 234337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3729162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274599", "Detail": { "ID": 274599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1135747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269539", "Detail": { "ID": 269539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5519936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317385", "Detail": { "ID": 317385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4198478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326287", "Detail": { "ID": 326287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.75194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241137", "Detail": { "ID": 241137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4036246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289647", "Detail": { "ID": 289647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4529769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247805", "Detail": { "ID": 247805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4291913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287406", "Detail": { "ID": 287406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8628391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222500", "Detail": { "ID": 222500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1916345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306924", "Detail": { "ID": 306924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5797512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239986", "Detail": { "ID": 239986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7678452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283453", "Detail": { "ID": 283453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7085348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232193", "Detail": { "ID": 232193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6388297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237748", "Detail": { "ID": 237748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2241816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309250", "Detail": { "ID": 309250, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2021, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653.1", "ID": 5809 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3212286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252661", "Detail": { "ID": 252661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7481228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258874", "Detail": { "ID": 258874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3319432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319857", "Detail": { "ID": 319857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9443783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249627", "Detail": { "ID": 249627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9428606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227772", "Detail": { "ID": 227772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5649877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280775", "Detail": { "ID": 280775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7818885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262523", "Detail": { "ID": 262523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6055856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288077", "Detail": { "ID": 288077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8990712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230509", "Detail": { "ID": 230509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3332495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270153", "Detail": { "ID": 270153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5838417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322644", "Detail": { "ID": 322644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6975655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294754", "Detail": { "ID": 294754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1768817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242896", "Detail": { "ID": 242896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0402096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235217", "Detail": { "ID": 235217, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6605115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302458", "Detail": { "ID": 302458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5254479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244477", "Detail": { "ID": 244477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5564517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327211", "Detail": { "ID": 327211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0259558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276706", "Detail": { "ID": 276706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.677647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264311", "Detail": { "ID": 264311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1278762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248750", "Detail": { "ID": 248750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6681898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295787", "Detail": { "ID": 295787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5358639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285183", "Detail": { "ID": 285183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.07+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230661", "Detail": { "ID": 230661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3397711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243823", "Detail": { "ID": 243823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3212456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254476", "Detail": { "ID": 254476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2577759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323818", "Detail": { "ID": 323818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9732386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291312", "Detail": { "ID": 291312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1135191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265355", "Detail": { "ID": 265355, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4356052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262274", "Detail": { "ID": 262274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5944313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281966", "Detail": { "ID": 281966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1654339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298006", "Detail": { "ID": 298006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1342394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231158", "Detail": { "ID": 231158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3680893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285929", "Detail": { "ID": 285929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3506205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219411", "Detail": { "ID": 219411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2975828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238552", "Detail": { "ID": 238552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4590158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225433", "Detail": { "ID": 225433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9745202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321816", "Detail": { "ID": 321816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4525834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292692", "Detail": { "ID": 292692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5537282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227137", "Detail": { "ID": 227137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2694184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313279", "Detail": { "ID": 313279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3884695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257192", "Detail": { "ID": 257192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8273392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271284", "Detail": { "ID": 271284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0636492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278102", "Detail": { "ID": 278102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9871005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287354", "Detail": { "ID": 287354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8606306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250470", "Detail": { "ID": 250470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1909165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220938", "Detail": { "ID": 220938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.66812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220232", "Detail": { "ID": 220232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6295269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252782", "Detail": { "ID": 252782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7530461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266098", "Detail": { "ID": 266098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4742564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324587", "Detail": { "ID": 324587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2293999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259697", "Detail": { "ID": 259697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6206187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239344", "Detail": { "ID": 239344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7327726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273782", "Detail": { "ID": 273782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6354201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304028", "Detail": { "ID": 304028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8462978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221757", "Detail": { "ID": 221757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9464959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241990", "Detail": { "ID": 241990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7890756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223530", "Detail": { "ID": 223530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4624078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307590", "Detail": { "ID": 307590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8360796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272209", "Detail": { "ID": 272209, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3197102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244905", "Detail": { "ID": 244905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5836408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315075", "Detail": { "ID": 315075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6730036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247924", "Detail": { "ID": 247924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4342171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274801", "Detail": { "ID": 274801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1223337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255774", "Detail": { "ID": 255774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5562979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277444", "Detail": { "ID": 277444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9536351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253038", "Detail": { "ID": 253038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7641745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276817", "Detail": { "ID": 276817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6823498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325544", "Detail": { "ID": 325544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5109165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233281", "Detail": { "ID": 233281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1172405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311435", "Detail": { "ID": 311435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8786833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230385", "Detail": { "ID": 230385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3275087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267373", "Detail": { "ID": 267373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0167859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313726", "Detail": { "ID": 313726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4080106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295068", "Detail": { "ID": 295068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1908261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319066", "Detail": { "ID": 319066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6909702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306411", "Detail": { "ID": 306411, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5509241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310392", "Detail": { "ID": 310392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5685494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268230", "Detail": { "ID": 268230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2544622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286342", "Detail": { "ID": 286342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5746973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260675", "Detail": { "ID": 260675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.087419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263865", "Detail": { "ID": 263865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9141114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308793", "Detail": { "ID": 308793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0714902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279685", "Detail": { "ID": 279685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5182764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279964", "Detail": { "ID": 279964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5304303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261083", "Detail": { "ID": 261083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1110749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299657", "Detail": { "ID": 299657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7071521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306824", "Detail": { "ID": 306824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5752822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300510", "Detail": { "ID": 300510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0013782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223687", "Detail": { "ID": 223687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4694943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237515", "Detail": { "ID": 237515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2141444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305456", "Detail": { "ID": 305456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3248124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320360", "Detail": { "ID": 320360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.163068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316007", "Detail": { "ID": 316007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9418238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236646", "Detail": { "ID": 236646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9339821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291398", "Detail": { "ID": 291398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1175873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234304", "Detail": { "ID": 234304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3714911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313577", "Detail": { "ID": 313577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4013816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290197", "Detail": { "ID": 290197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.73627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225256", "Detail": { "ID": 225256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9615459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265744", "Detail": { "ID": 265744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4526024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283303", "Detail": { "ID": 283303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.694731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251489", "Detail": { "ID": 251489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4658781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317581", "Detail": { "ID": 317581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4286019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254693", "Detail": { "ID": 254693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2796053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296943", "Detail": { "ID": 296943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8806776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235392", "Detail": { "ID": 235392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.668525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257711", "Detail": { "ID": 257711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0683555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228126", "Detail": { "ID": 228126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5854679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291075", "Detail": { "ID": 291075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7843989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311044", "Detail": { "ID": 311044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6030124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246347", "Detail": { "ID": 246347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1248201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298151", "Detail": { "ID": 298151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1403971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234336", "Detail": { "ID": 234336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.372875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274600", "Detail": { "ID": 274600, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1136162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269540", "Detail": { "ID": 269540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.552034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317386", "Detail": { "ID": 317386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.419888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326286", "Detail": { "ID": 326286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7518988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241138", "Detail": { "ID": 241138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4036654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289648", "Detail": { "ID": 289648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4530172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247806", "Detail": { "ID": 247806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4292311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287407", "Detail": { "ID": 287407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222501", "Detail": { "ID": 222501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1916751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306923", "Detail": { "ID": 306923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5797102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239985", "Detail": { "ID": 239985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7678045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283452", "Detail": { "ID": 283452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7084934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232192", "Detail": { "ID": 232192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6387886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237747", "Detail": { "ID": 237747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2241415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309249", "Detail": { "ID": 309249, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2022, "AgendaID": 2637, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Capital Projects", "Reference": "S4M-05653", "ID": 5788 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-20T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3211875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253123", "Detail": { "ID": 253123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7677775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259767", "Detail": { "ID": 259767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6289283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318333", "Detail": { "ID": 318333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6530983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250095", "Detail": { "ID": 250095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9631368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230234", "Detail": { "ID": 230234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3140096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281704", "Detail": { "ID": 281704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1541003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263417", "Detail": { "ID": 263417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.888515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290001", "Detail": { "ID": 290001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.468513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227996", "Detail": { "ID": 227996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5798532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270568", "Detail": { "ID": 270568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.813397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322882", "Detail": { "ID": 322882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7076529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297268", "Detail": { "ID": 297268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0923852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242624", "Detail": { "ID": 242624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0283152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236593", "Detail": { "ID": 236593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9316992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300432", "Detail": { "ID": 300432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9979346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261214", "Detail": { "ID": 261214, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3477319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326767", "Detail": { "ID": 326767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7792111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278244", "Detail": { "ID": 278244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2038481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264835", "Detail": { "ID": 264835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1567288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249159", "Detail": { "ID": 249159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6864339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291231", "Detail": { "ID": 291231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1099471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285634", "Detail": { "ID": 285634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3377009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233396", "Detail": { "ID": 233396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1224096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243252", "Detail": { "ID": 243252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2893811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253362", "Detail": { "ID": 253362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9931292+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321498", "Detail": { "ID": 321498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4386757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300747", "Detail": { "ID": 300747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.017134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273323", "Detail": { "ID": 273323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6103009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263181", "Detail": { "ID": 263181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6404425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282178", "Detail": { "ID": 282178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1793764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299245", "Detail": { "ID": 299245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6891511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230593", "Detail": { "ID": 230593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3370672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286605", "Detail": { "ID": 286605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5929752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219860", "Detail": { "ID": 219860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3177975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238971", "Detail": { "ID": 238971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4772258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226212", "Detail": { "ID": 226212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2148034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322413", "Detail": { "ID": 322413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6872007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291812", "Detail": { "ID": 291812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1435524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228795", "Detail": { "ID": 228795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8144902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304739", "Detail": { "ID": 304739, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.051313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258031", "Detail": { "ID": 258031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0883481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271799", "Detail": { "ID": 271799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0919537+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278934", "Detail": { "ID": 278934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2405656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266789", "Detail": { "ID": 266789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7565834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250836", "Detail": { "ID": 250836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2155568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221301", "Detail": { "ID": 221301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9261018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220794", "Detail": { "ID": 220794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6573036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240099", "Detail": { "ID": 240099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7726897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266910", "Detail": { "ID": 266910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7673025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324204", "Detail": { "ID": 324204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2062517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260262", "Detail": { "ID": 260262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0689595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246549", "Detail": { "ID": 246549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1334788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275713", "Detail": { "ID": 275713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3873588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303821", "Detail": { "ID": 303821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8372522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222227", "Detail": { "ID": 222227, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1737922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242441", "Detail": { "ID": 242441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0134024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224467", "Detail": { "ID": 224467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7060759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308677", "Detail": { "ID": 308677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0661925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272574", "Detail": { "ID": 272574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3412605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244629", "Detail": { "ID": 244629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5714984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314367", "Detail": { "ID": 314367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6366554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251897", "Detail": { "ID": 251897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4938391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276041", "Detail": { "ID": 276041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4079227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256954", "Detail": { "ID": 256954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8170402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282761", "Detail": { "ID": 282761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4329807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254542", "Detail": { "ID": 254542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.260647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278307", "Detail": { "ID": 278307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2065882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325081", "Detail": { "ID": 325081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2553377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232335", "Detail": { "ID": 232335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8503899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313003", "Detail": { "ID": 313003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1592443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231565", "Detail": { "ID": 231565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6060859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267707", "Detail": { "ID": 267707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0315523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314198", "Detail": { "ID": 314198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4339707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296049", "Detail": { "ID": 296049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5470656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319818", "Detail": { "ID": 319818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9427089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305979", "Detail": { "ID": 305979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3537773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309816", "Detail": { "ID": 309816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3461788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268733", "Detail": { "ID": 268733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2803402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294344", "Detail": { "ID": 294344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1343121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271364", "Detail": { "ID": 271364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0726008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268928", "Detail": { "ID": 268928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2961346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307463", "Detail": { "ID": 307463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8305987+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282592", "Detail": { "ID": 282592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.425637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280956", "Detail": { "ID": 280956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7895556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245256", "Detail": { "ID": 245256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8268349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299868", "Detail": { "ID": 299868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.726393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302779", "Detail": { "ID": 302779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5448177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300096", "Detail": { "ID": 300096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.736134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224513", "Detail": { "ID": 224513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7080807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237983", "Detail": { "ID": 237983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2345201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297481", "Detail": { "ID": 297481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1020622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320754", "Detail": { "ID": 320754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1800921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315558", "Detail": { "ID": 315558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9171838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238008", "Detail": { "ID": 238008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2355881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293414", "Detail": { "ID": 293414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8440253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233675", "Detail": { "ID": 233675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1412714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312462", "Detail": { "ID": 312462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1289296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286859", "Detail": { "ID": 286859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6038969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226099", "Detail": { "ID": 226099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0100008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265254", "Detail": { "ID": 265254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4312184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284263", "Detail": { "ID": 284263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0186963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259026", "Detail": { "ID": 259026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3384934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317973", "Detail": { "ID": 317973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4514864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256069", "Detail": { "ID": 256069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5693093+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294523", "Detail": { "ID": 294523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1420881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236457", "Detail": { "ID": 236457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9256983+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256441", "Detail": { "ID": 256441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.782636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229875", "Detail": { "ID": 229875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1011743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290580", "Detail": { "ID": 290580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7630828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310023", "Detail": { "ID": 310023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3611108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247171", "Detail": { "ID": 247171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1701276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298772", "Detail": { "ID": 298772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3715202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235339", "Detail": { "ID": 235339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6662133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275820", "Detail": { "ID": 275820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3923276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274284", "Detail": { "ID": 274284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.093941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316529", "Detail": { "ID": 316529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1520786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325902", "Detail": { "ID": 325902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.526398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241516", "Detail": { "ID": 241516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7681968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287987", "Detail": { "ID": 287987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8951486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248392", "Detail": { "ID": 248392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6439947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289145", "Detail": { "ID": 289145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1793769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222867", "Detail": { "ID": 222867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2080992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306858", "Detail": { "ID": 306858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5767436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240759", "Detail": { "ID": 240759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3810916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284378", "Detail": { "ID": 284378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0237553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233013", "Detail": { "ID": 233013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8863544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246290", "Detail": { "ID": 246290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1223068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309458", "Detail": { "ID": 309458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2018, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 80, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.2", "ID": 5798 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3301861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253124", "Detail": { "ID": 253124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7678186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259768", "Detail": { "ID": 259768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6289699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318341", "Detail": { "ID": 318341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6534262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250094", "Detail": { "ID": 250094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9630966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230235", "Detail": { "ID": 230235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3140521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281705", "Detail": { "ID": 281705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.15414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263418", "Detail": { "ID": 263418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8885552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290000", "Detail": { "ID": 290000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4684723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227997", "Detail": { "ID": 227997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5798938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270567", "Detail": { "ID": 270567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8133561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322883", "Detail": { "ID": 322883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7077202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297269", "Detail": { "ID": 297269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0924261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242501", "Detail": { "ID": 242501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0160115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236592", "Detail": { "ID": 236592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9316579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300433", "Detail": { "ID": 300433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9979759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261213", "Detail": { "ID": 261213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3476911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326769", "Detail": { "ID": 326769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7792935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278245", "Detail": { "ID": 278245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2038893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264834", "Detail": { "ID": 264834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1509811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249158", "Detail": { "ID": 249158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6863928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM293668", "Detail": { "ID": 293668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8638284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285635", "Detail": { "ID": 285635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3377415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233397", "Detail": { "ID": 233397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.12245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243381", "Detail": { "ID": 243381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2952499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253361", "Detail": { "ID": 253361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9930822+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321500", "Detail": { "ID": 321500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4387579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300746", "Detail": { "ID": 300746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0170932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273324", "Detail": { "ID": 273324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6103418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263182", "Detail": { "ID": 263182, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6404834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282177", "Detail": { "ID": 282177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.179335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299246", "Detail": { "ID": 299246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6891917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230592", "Detail": { "ID": 230592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3370271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286606", "Detail": { "ID": 286606, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5930148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219861", "Detail": { "ID": 219861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3178407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238970", "Detail": { "ID": 238970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4771837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226211", "Detail": { "ID": 226211, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2147609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322412", "Detail": { "ID": 322412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6871598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291811", "Detail": { "ID": 291811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1434873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228796", "Detail": { "ID": 228796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8145318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304740", "Detail": { "ID": 304740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0513536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258032", "Detail": { "ID": 258032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.088389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271800", "Detail": { "ID": 271800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0919944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278933", "Detail": { "ID": 278933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2405246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266790", "Detail": { "ID": 266790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7566231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250837", "Detail": { "ID": 250837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2156148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221302", "Detail": { "ID": 221302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9261451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220793", "Detail": { "ID": 220793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6572635+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240100", "Detail": { "ID": 240100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7727311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266909", "Detail": { "ID": 266909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7672617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324202", "Detail": { "ID": 324202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2061213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260261", "Detail": { "ID": 260261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.068918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246550", "Detail": { "ID": 246550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1335199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275712", "Detail": { "ID": 275712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3873183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303820", "Detail": { "ID": 303820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8372112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222226", "Detail": { "ID": 222226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1737511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242440", "Detail": { "ID": 242440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0133605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224466", "Detail": { "ID": 224466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7060354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308678", "Detail": { "ID": 308678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0662326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272575", "Detail": { "ID": 272575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3413019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244343", "Detail": { "ID": 244343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5506033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314359", "Detail": { "ID": 314359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.636307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251896", "Detail": { "ID": 251896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4937985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM276040", "Detail": { "ID": 276040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4078823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256646", "Detail": { "ID": 256646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7916378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282762", "Detail": { "ID": 282762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.433021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254543", "Detail": { "ID": 254543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2606878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278306", "Detail": { "ID": 278306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2065474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325083", "Detail": { "ID": 325083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2554197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232336", "Detail": { "ID": 232336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8504314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313004", "Detail": { "ID": 313004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1592853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231564", "Detail": { "ID": 231564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.606045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267708", "Detail": { "ID": 267708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0315931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314197", "Detail": { "ID": 314197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4339302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296048", "Detail": { "ID": 296048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5470246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319817", "Detail": { "ID": 319817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9426668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305987", "Detail": { "ID": 305987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3541316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309815", "Detail": { "ID": 309815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3461375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268732", "Detail": { "ID": 268732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2802996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294345", "Detail": { "ID": 294345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.134355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271363", "Detail": { "ID": 271363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0725578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268927", "Detail": { "ID": 268927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.296094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307464", "Detail": { "ID": 307464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8306401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282593", "Detail": { "ID": 282593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4256865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280955", "Detail": { "ID": 280955, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7895147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245379", "Detail": { "ID": 245379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8323111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299867", "Detail": { "ID": 299867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7263528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302780", "Detail": { "ID": 302780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5448584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300095", "Detail": { "ID": 300095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7360939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224514", "Detail": { "ID": 224514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7081236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237984", "Detail": { "ID": 237984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2345605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM296894", "Detail": { "ID": 296894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8786084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320755", "Detail": { "ID": 320755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1801749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315566", "Detail": { "ID": 315566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9175297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238009", "Detail": { "ID": 238009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2356294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293413", "Detail": { "ID": 293413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8439846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233674", "Detail": { "ID": 233674, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1412297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312470", "Detail": { "ID": 312470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1292792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286860", "Detail": { "ID": 286860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6039366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226100", "Detail": { "ID": 226100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0100415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265253", "Detail": { "ID": 265253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4311757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284262", "Detail": { "ID": 284262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0185369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259027", "Detail": { "ID": 259027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3385346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317974", "Detail": { "ID": 317974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4515454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256068", "Detail": { "ID": 256068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5692497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294524", "Detail": { "ID": 294524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1421286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236458", "Detail": { "ID": 236458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9257397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256442", "Detail": { "ID": 256442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7826755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229876", "Detail": { "ID": 229876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1012154+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290579", "Detail": { "ID": 290579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7630423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310015", "Detail": { "ID": 310015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3607598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247172", "Detail": { "ID": 247172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.170189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298771", "Detail": { "ID": 298771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3714801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235338", "Detail": { "ID": 235338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6661723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275821", "Detail": { "ID": 275821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.392368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274285", "Detail": { "ID": 274285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0939823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316521", "Detail": { "ID": 316521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1517493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM325900", "Detail": { "ID": 325900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5263135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241517", "Detail": { "ID": 241517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7682395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287857", "Detail": { "ID": 287857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8895316+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248393", "Detail": { "ID": 248393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6440361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289146", "Detail": { "ID": 289146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1794175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222868", "Detail": { "ID": 222868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.20814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306857", "Detail": { "ID": 306857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5767033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240758", "Detail": { "ID": 240758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3810501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284377", "Detail": { "ID": 284377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0237147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233012", "Detail": { "ID": 233012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8863118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246289", "Detail": { "ID": 246289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.122266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309457", "Detail": { "ID": 309457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2016, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 102, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652.1", "ID": 5792 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.330146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253122", "Detail": { "ID": 253122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7677362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259559", "Detail": { "ID": 259559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6143274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318053", "Detail": { "ID": 318053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4549167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250096", "Detail": { "ID": 250096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9631775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM230233", "Detail": { "ID": 230233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3139472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281703", "Detail": { "ID": 281703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1540602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263416", "Detail": { "ID": 263416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8884741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290752", "Detail": { "ID": 290752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7706866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227995", "Detail": { "ID": 227995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5798126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270622", "Detail": { "ID": 270622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8157228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322881", "Detail": { "ID": 322881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7075509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297267", "Detail": { "ID": 297267, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0923425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242623", "Detail": { "ID": 242623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0282754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236594", "Detail": { "ID": 236594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9317402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300431", "Detail": { "ID": 300431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9978933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261215", "Detail": { "ID": 261215, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.347773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326650", "Detail": { "ID": 326650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7739351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278243", "Detail": { "ID": 278243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2038079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264836", "Detail": { "ID": 264836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1567782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249160", "Detail": { "ID": 249160, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6864754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291232", "Detail": { "ID": 291232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1099887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285633", "Detail": { "ID": 285633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3376607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233395", "Detail": { "ID": 233395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1223688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243253", "Detail": { "ID": 243253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2894213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253363", "Detail": { "ID": 253363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9931703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321373", "Detail": { "ID": 321373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4330427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300748", "Detail": { "ID": 300748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0171744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273322", "Detail": { "ID": 273322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6102602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263180", "Detail": { "ID": 263180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6404021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282179", "Detail": { "ID": 282179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1794172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM299091", "Detail": { "ID": 299091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3863704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230594", "Detail": { "ID": 230594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3371261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287207", "Detail": { "ID": 287207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8542276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219859", "Detail": { "ID": 219859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3177373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239024", "Detail": { "ID": 239024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4794967+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226213", "Detail": { "ID": 226213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2148448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322414", "Detail": { "ID": 322414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6872409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291813", "Detail": { "ID": 291813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1435943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228334", "Detail": { "ID": 228334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7884429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304738", "Detail": { "ID": 304738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0512727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258030", "Detail": { "ID": 258030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0882886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271617", "Detail": { "ID": 271617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0839054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278935", "Detail": { "ID": 278935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2406078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266788", "Detail": { "ID": 266788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7565431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250835", "Detail": { "ID": 250835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2155169+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221300", "Detail": { "ID": 221300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9260397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220795", "Detail": { "ID": 220795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6573436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM240098", "Detail": { "ID": 240098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7726492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266911", "Detail": { "ID": 266911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7673623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324328", "Detail": { "ID": 324328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2120226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260263", "Detail": { "ID": 260263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246496", "Detail": { "ID": 246496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1312135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275714", "Detail": { "ID": 275714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3873991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303822", "Detail": { "ID": 303822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8373934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222228", "Detail": { "ID": 222228, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1738334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242442", "Detail": { "ID": 242442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0134437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224468", "Detail": { "ID": 224468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7061167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308675", "Detail": { "ID": 308675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0661115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272573", "Detail": { "ID": 272573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3412184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244628", "Detail": { "ID": 244628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5714579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314649", "Detail": { "ID": 314649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6495101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251950", "Detail": { "ID": 251950, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4961047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275590", "Detail": { "ID": 275590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3820734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257007", "Detail": { "ID": 257007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8193335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283056", "Detail": { "ID": 283056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4458596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254489", "Detail": { "ID": 254489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2583323+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278308", "Detail": { "ID": 278308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2066288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324957", "Detail": { "ID": 324957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2450574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232334", "Detail": { "ID": 232334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8503486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313000", "Detail": { "ID": 313000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1591185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM231566", "Detail": { "ID": 231566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6061268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267706", "Detail": { "ID": 267706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0315118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314201", "Detail": { "ID": 314201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4340915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296051", "Detail": { "ID": 296051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.547147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319819", "Detail": { "ID": 319819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9427498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305862", "Detail": { "ID": 305862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3485402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309817", "Detail": { "ID": 309817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3462412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268734", "Detail": { "ID": 268734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2803815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM294342", "Detail": { "ID": 294342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1342125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271365", "Detail": { "ID": 271365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0726683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268929", "Detail": { "ID": 268929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2961756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307462", "Detail": { "ID": 307462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8305579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282591", "Detail": { "ID": 282591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4255594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280957", "Detail": { "ID": 280957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.789596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245257", "Detail": { "ID": 245257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8268755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299870", "Detail": { "ID": 299870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7264742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302778", "Detail": { "ID": 302778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5447769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300097", "Detail": { "ID": 300097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7361745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224512", "Detail": { "ID": 224512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7080209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237982", "Detail": { "ID": 237982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2344796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297480", "Detail": { "ID": 297480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1020208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320753", "Detail": { "ID": 320753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1800519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315432", "Detail": { "ID": 315432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9117556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238007", "Detail": { "ID": 238007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2355474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293415", "Detail": { "ID": 293415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8440898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233676", "Detail": { "ID": 233676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1413128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312024", "Detail": { "ID": 312024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9104364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286858", "Detail": { "ID": 286858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6038572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226098", "Detail": { "ID": 226098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0099589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265255", "Detail": { "ID": 265255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4312595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284264", "Detail": { "ID": 284264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.01874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259025", "Detail": { "ID": 259025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3384531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317972", "Detail": { "ID": 317972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.451445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256070", "Detail": { "ID": 256070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5693509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294522", "Detail": { "ID": 294522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.142047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236456", "Detail": { "ID": 236456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9256542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256440", "Detail": { "ID": 256440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7825947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229874", "Detail": { "ID": 229874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1011332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290581", "Detail": { "ID": 290581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7631224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310460", "Detail": { "ID": 310460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5718394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247170", "Detail": { "ID": 247170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1700868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298773", "Detail": { "ID": 298773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3715601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235340", "Detail": { "ID": 235340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6662549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275819", "Detail": { "ID": 275819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3922871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274283", "Detail": { "ID": 274283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0939002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316808", "Detail": { "ID": 316808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1643649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326026", "Detail": { "ID": 326026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5320431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241515", "Detail": { "ID": 241515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7681351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287986", "Detail": { "ID": 287986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8951081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248391", "Detail": { "ID": 248391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6439541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289144", "Detail": { "ID": 289144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1793352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222866", "Detail": { "ID": 222866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2080582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306859", "Detail": { "ID": 306859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5767845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240760", "Detail": { "ID": 240760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.381132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284084", "Detail": { "ID": 284084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7423072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM233014", "Detail": { "ID": 233014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8864135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246291", "Detail": { "ID": 246291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1223473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309461", "Detail": { "ID": 309461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2017, "AgendaID": 2397, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 13, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tuition Fees", "Reference": "S4M-05652", "ID": 5787 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-19T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3303698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252746", "Detail": { "ID": 252746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.751546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258945", "Detail": { "ID": 258945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3350128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319596", "Detail": { "ID": 319596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9330883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249500", "Detail": { "ID": 249500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9295569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227871", "Detail": { "ID": 227871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.569251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280873", "Detail": { "ID": 280873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7860274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262769", "Detail": { "ID": 262769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6160452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288947", "Detail": { "ID": 288947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1651932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229858", "Detail": { "ID": 229858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1004501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269772", "Detail": { "ID": 269772, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.562298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322574", "Detail": { "ID": 322574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6945645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295305", "Detail": { "ID": 295305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5062807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243005", "Detail": { "ID": 243005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0448411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235145", "Detail": { "ID": 235145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4213257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302423", "Detail": { "ID": 302423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.523781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244234", "Detail": { "ID": 244234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5458484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327083", "Detail": { "ID": 327083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7981118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277108", "Detail": { "ID": 277108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.70144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264221", "Detail": { "ID": 264221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1239533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248671", "Detail": { "ID": 248671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6648335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294907", "Detail": { "ID": 294907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.183864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285272", "Detail": { "ID": 285272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3158395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230747", "Detail": { "ID": 230747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3438037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243713", "Detail": { "ID": 243713, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3166478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254823", "Detail": { "ID": 254823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2852669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323690", "Detail": { "ID": 323690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9676903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290921", "Detail": { "ID": 290921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7778012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265445", "Detail": { "ID": 265445, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4394828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262354", "Detail": { "ID": 262354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5978611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281866", "Detail": { "ID": 281866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1609745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298261", "Detail": { "ID": 298261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3381274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231192", "Detail": { "ID": 231192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3697938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284980", "Detail": { "ID": 284980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0560279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219493", "Detail": { "ID": 219493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3016536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238481", "Detail": { "ID": 238481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4559691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225155", "Detail": { "ID": 225155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7468044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321886", "Detail": { "ID": 321886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4555596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292760", "Detail": { "ID": 292760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5569663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227218", "Detail": { "ID": 227218, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5359341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313245", "Detail": { "ID": 313245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3842594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257782", "Detail": { "ID": 257782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0773836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271113", "Detail": { "ID": 271113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8430353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278004", "Detail": { "ID": 278004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9828632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287318", "Detail": { "ID": 287318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8590043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250599", "Detail": { "ID": 250599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1965047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221062", "Detail": { "ID": 221062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6734339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220151", "Detail": { "ID": 220151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3365413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252444", "Detail": { "ID": 252444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7294032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253773", "Detail": { "ID": 253773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0202982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324715", "Detail": { "ID": 324715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2347885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259618", "Detail": { "ID": 259618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.617219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239415", "Detail": { "ID": 239415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7358237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273692", "Detail": { "ID": 273692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6313001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304062", "Detail": { "ID": 304062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8478181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221632", "Detail": { "ID": 221632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9410911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241863", "Detail": { "ID": 241863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7832789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223457", "Detail": { "ID": 223457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4588227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307844", "Detail": { "ID": 307844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8533372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272334", "Detail": { "ID": 272334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3308799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245016", "Detail": { "ID": 245016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5884012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315184", "Detail": { "ID": 315184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6779491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247853", "Detail": { "ID": 247853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4312305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275127", "Detail": { "ID": 275127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1427495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255549", "Detail": { "ID": 255549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5360855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276962", "Detail": { "ID": 276962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.688826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253415", "Detail": { "ID": 253415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9954405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276735", "Detail": { "ID": 276735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6788786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325416", "Detail": { "ID": 325416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4977377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233248", "Detail": { "ID": 233248, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1158202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311689", "Detail": { "ID": 311689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8900285+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229686", "Detail": { "ID": 229686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0923283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267471", "Detail": { "ID": 267471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0212741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313472", "Detail": { "ID": 313472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3968509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294967", "Detail": { "ID": 294967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1864581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319135", "Detail": { "ID": 319135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6939469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306303", "Detail": { "ID": 306303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5462445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310763", "Detail": { "ID": 310763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5850037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268133", "Detail": { "ID": 268133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0576047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286442", "Detail": { "ID": 286442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5793875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258537", "Detail": { "ID": 258537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3115185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263783", "Detail": { "ID": 263783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9045423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308725", "Detail": { "ID": 308725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0682789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279767", "Detail": { "ID": 279767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5218191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279565", "Detail": { "ID": 279565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5131684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260504", "Detail": { "ID": 260504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0797362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299557", "Detail": { "ID": 299557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7025779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306757", "Detail": { "ID": 306757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5661108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300578", "Detail": { "ID": 300578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0046392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223966", "Detail": { "ID": 223966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.486252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237885", "Detail": { "ID": 237885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2302751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305565", "Detail": { "ID": 305565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3298634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320135", "Detail": { "ID": 320135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.963194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315898", "Detail": { "ID": 315898, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9319771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236736", "Detail": { "ID": 236736, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9378502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289769", "Detail": { "ID": 289769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4583181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234492", "Detail": { "ID": 234492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3866001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313158", "Detail": { "ID": 313158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1661498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289359", "Detail": { "ID": 289359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4338621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225330", "Detail": { "ID": 225330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9699102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265780", "Detail": { "ID": 265780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4541583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283221", "Detail": { "ID": 283221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6910829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252029", "Detail": { "ID": 252029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4995097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317357", "Detail": { "ID": 317357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4186357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254252", "Detail": { "ID": 254252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2475245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296261", "Detail": { "ID": 296261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8410301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235472", "Detail": { "ID": 235472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6793255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257676", "Detail": { "ID": 257676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0667673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228559", "Detail": { "ID": 228559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8043168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291576", "Detail": { "ID": 291576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1333227+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311153", "Detail": { "ID": 311153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6079878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246782", "Detail": { "ID": 246782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1531758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298064", "Detail": { "ID": 298064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1367232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234094", "Detail": { "ID": 234094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1663827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274683", "Detail": { "ID": 274683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1172106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269637", "Detail": { "ID": 269637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5564842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317494", "Detail": { "ID": 317494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4248351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326414", "Detail": { "ID": 326414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7575327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241265", "Detail": { "ID": 241265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7504804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290375", "Detail": { "ID": 290375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7441607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248038", "Detail": { "ID": 248038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4390885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287490", "Detail": { "ID": 287490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8664097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222574", "Detail": { "ID": 222574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1947867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306956", "Detail": { "ID": 306956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5811361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239859", "Detail": { "ID": 239859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7621116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283777", "Detail": { "ID": 283777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7230182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231790", "Detail": { "ID": 231790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6156394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237366", "Detail": { "ID": 237366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2011016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308993", "Detail": { "ID": 308993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2015, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 37, "VoteAgainst": 64, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Debt Arrangement Scheme", "Reference": "S4M-05586.1", "ID": 5728 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0868977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252629", "Detail": { "ID": 252629, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7377028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258844", "Detail": { "ID": 258844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3303256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319861", "Detail": { "ID": 319861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9445589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249631", "Detail": { "ID": 249631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.943055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227734", "Detail": { "ID": 227734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5633499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280735", "Detail": { "ID": 280735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7802068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262519", "Detail": { "ID": 262519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6054247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288086", "Detail": { "ID": 288086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8994409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230505", "Detail": { "ID": 230505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3330615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270183", "Detail": { "ID": 270183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5851143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322700", "Detail": { "ID": 322700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6999349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294750", "Detail": { "ID": 294750, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1767196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242892", "Detail": { "ID": 242892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0400512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235556", "Detail": { "ID": 235556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6828864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302454", "Detail": { "ID": 302454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5252859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244481", "Detail": { "ID": 244481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5566357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327207", "Detail": { "ID": 327207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0257335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276702", "Detail": { "ID": 276702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6774842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264315", "Detail": { "ID": 264315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1280762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248799", "Detail": { "ID": 248799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6705545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295791", "Detail": { "ID": 295791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5360419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285179", "Detail": { "ID": 285179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0698377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230657", "Detail": { "ID": 230657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3396097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243827", "Detail": { "ID": 243827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3214032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254480", "Detail": { "ID": 254480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.25794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323814", "Detail": { "ID": 323814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9730735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291316", "Detail": { "ID": 291316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1137017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265351", "Detail": { "ID": 265351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4354419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262226", "Detail": { "ID": 262226, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.592369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282006", "Detail": { "ID": 282006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1671495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297967", "Detail": { "ID": 297967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1326082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231162", "Detail": { "ID": 231162, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.36825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285894", "Detail": { "ID": 285894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3491151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219366", "Detail": { "ID": 219366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2955345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238583", "Detail": { "ID": 238583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.460368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225437", "Detail": { "ID": 225437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9746839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321759", "Detail": { "ID": 321759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4501797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292696", "Detail": { "ID": 292696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5538885+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226934", "Detail": { "ID": 226934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2532744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313275", "Detail": { "ID": 313275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.388282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257188", "Detail": { "ID": 257188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.827097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271302", "Detail": { "ID": 271302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0695913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278450", "Detail": { "ID": 278450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2193355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287350", "Detail": { "ID": 287350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8604438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250466", "Detail": { "ID": 250466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1907544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220934", "Detail": { "ID": 220934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6679361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220279", "Detail": { "ID": 220279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6315744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252778", "Detail": { "ID": 252778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.752887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266137", "Detail": { "ID": 266137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4759308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324591", "Detail": { "ID": 324591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.229561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259901", "Detail": { "ID": 259901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6349266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239314", "Detail": { "ID": 239314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7314638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273786", "Detail": { "ID": 273786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.635583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304032", "Detail": { "ID": 304032, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8464601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221761", "Detail": { "ID": 221761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9466595+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241994", "Detail": { "ID": 241994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7892392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223715", "Detail": { "ID": 223715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4706646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307551", "Detail": { "ID": 307551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8343966+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272205", "Detail": { "ID": 272205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3195022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244901", "Detail": { "ID": 244901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5834609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315071", "Detail": { "ID": 315071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6728201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247954", "Detail": { "ID": 247954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.435495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274836", "Detail": { "ID": 274836, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.123855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255804", "Detail": { "ID": 255804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5577974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277409", "Detail": { "ID": 277409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9521449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253008", "Detail": { "ID": 253008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7628743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276821", "Detail": { "ID": 276821, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6825104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325540", "Detail": { "ID": 325540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5107552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233277", "Detail": { "ID": 233277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1170776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311398", "Detail": { "ID": 311398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8770091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230433", "Detail": { "ID": 230433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3296135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267334", "Detail": { "ID": 267334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0149576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313763", "Detail": { "ID": 313763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4096095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295415", "Detail": { "ID": 295415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5111933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319009", "Detail": { "ID": 319009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6885084+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306415", "Detail": { "ID": 306415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.551105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310396", "Detail": { "ID": 310396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.568715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268269", "Detail": { "ID": 268269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2597857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286302", "Detail": { "ID": 286302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5729548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260679", "Detail": { "ID": 260679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0876028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264067", "Detail": { "ID": 264067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9227703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308789", "Detail": { "ID": 308789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0713256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279681", "Detail": { "ID": 279681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5180552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279968", "Detail": { "ID": 279968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5305942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261087", "Detail": { "ID": 261087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1112393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299696", "Detail": { "ID": 299696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7186611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306820", "Detail": { "ID": 306820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5751176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300514", "Detail": { "ID": 300514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0015768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223683", "Detail": { "ID": 223683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4693138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237486", "Detail": { "ID": 237486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.212677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305452", "Detail": { "ID": 305452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3246325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320417", "Detail": { "ID": 320417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1655211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316011", "Detail": { "ID": 316011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.941989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236642", "Detail": { "ID": 236642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9338187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291402", "Detail": { "ID": 291402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1177696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234308", "Detail": { "ID": 234308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3716751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313581", "Detail": { "ID": 313581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.401566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290193", "Detail": { "ID": 290193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4830707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225070", "Detail": { "ID": 225070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7432231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265748", "Detail": { "ID": 265748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4527874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283307", "Detail": { "ID": 283307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.694923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251440", "Detail": { "ID": 251440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4637059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317637", "Detail": { "ID": 317637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4309817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254697", "Detail": { "ID": 254697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2798411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296325", "Detail": { "ID": 296325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8441552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234884", "Detail": { "ID": 234884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4038939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257707", "Detail": { "ID": 257707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.068099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228122", "Detail": { "ID": 228122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5853065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291079", "Detail": { "ID": 291079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7845627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311040", "Detail": { "ID": 311040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6028497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246343", "Detail": { "ID": 246343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1246374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298155", "Detail": { "ID": 298155, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1405824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234340", "Detail": { "ID": 234340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3730613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274554", "Detail": { "ID": 274554, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1116288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269501", "Detail": { "ID": 269501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.55036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317382", "Detail": { "ID": 317382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4197256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326290", "Detail": { "ID": 326290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7520818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241134", "Detail": { "ID": 241134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4035029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289644", "Detail": { "ID": 289644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4528584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247758", "Detail": { "ID": 247758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4271509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287403", "Detail": { "ID": 287403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8627177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222471", "Detail": { "ID": 222471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1903832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306927", "Detail": { "ID": 306927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5798795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239989", "Detail": { "ID": 239989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7679668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283487", "Detail": { "ID": 283487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7100128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232230", "Detail": { "ID": 232230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8457475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237795", "Detail": { "ID": 237795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2264183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309287", "Detail": { "ID": 309287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2013, "AgendaID": 2643, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 68, "VoteAgainst": 56, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05550", "ID": 5684 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-06T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3228233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252745", "Detail": { "ID": 252745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7515059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258944", "Detail": { "ID": 258944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3349726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319597", "Detail": { "ID": 319597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.933129+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249501", "Detail": { "ID": 249501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9295981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227870", "Detail": { "ID": 227870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.569209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280872", "Detail": { "ID": 280872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.785986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262768", "Detail": { "ID": 262768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6160048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288153", "Detail": { "ID": 288153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9092024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229857", "Detail": { "ID": 229857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1004089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269773", "Detail": { "ID": 269773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5623385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322573", "Detail": { "ID": 322573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6945242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295304", "Detail": { "ID": 295304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5062399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243004", "Detail": { "ID": 243004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0448002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235146", "Detail": { "ID": 235146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4213666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302422", "Detail": { "ID": 302422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5237406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244235", "Detail": { "ID": 244235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5458898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327082", "Detail": { "ID": 327082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7980709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277107", "Detail": { "ID": 277107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7013992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264222", "Detail": { "ID": 264222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1239942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248679", "Detail": { "ID": 248679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6651812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294908", "Detail": { "ID": 294908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.183905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285271", "Detail": { "ID": 285271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.315798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230746", "Detail": { "ID": 230746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.343763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243714", "Detail": { "ID": 243714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.316688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254824", "Detail": { "ID": 254824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2853076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323689", "Detail": { "ID": 323689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.967649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290929", "Detail": { "ID": 290929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7781439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265444", "Detail": { "ID": 265444, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4394414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262346", "Detail": { "ID": 262346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5975146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281867", "Detail": { "ID": 281867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1610153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298260", "Detail": { "ID": 298260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3380864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231193", "Detail": { "ID": 231193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.369834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285016", "Detail": { "ID": 285016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0576066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219485", "Detail": { "ID": 219485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3013177+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238482", "Detail": { "ID": 238482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.45601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225156", "Detail": { "ID": 225156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7468444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321887", "Detail": { "ID": 321887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4556005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292761", "Detail": { "ID": 292761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5570307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227210", "Detail": { "ID": 227210, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5355921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313244", "Detail": { "ID": 313244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3841108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257781", "Detail": { "ID": 257781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0773432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271148", "Detail": { "ID": 271148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.844532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278005", "Detail": { "ID": 278005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9829044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287317", "Detail": { "ID": 287317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8589632+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250598", "Detail": { "ID": 250598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1964639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221104", "Detail": { "ID": 221104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6752425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220159", "Detail": { "ID": 220159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3368941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252443", "Detail": { "ID": 252443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7293625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253774", "Detail": { "ID": 253774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0203373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324716", "Detail": { "ID": 324716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2348495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259626", "Detail": { "ID": 259626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6175735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239414", "Detail": { "ID": 239414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7357829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273693", "Detail": { "ID": 273693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6313405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304063", "Detail": { "ID": 304063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.84786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221633", "Detail": { "ID": 221633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9411547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241864", "Detail": { "ID": 241864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7833188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223458", "Detail": { "ID": 223458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4588641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307843", "Detail": { "ID": 307843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8532957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272333", "Detail": { "ID": 272333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3308183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245015", "Detail": { "ID": 245015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5883601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315183", "Detail": { "ID": 315183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.677907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247854", "Detail": { "ID": 247854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4312706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275092", "Detail": { "ID": 275092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1409567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255550", "Detail": { "ID": 255550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5361446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276997", "Detail": { "ID": 276997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6966548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253414", "Detail": { "ID": 253414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9953989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276743", "Detail": { "ID": 276743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6792072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325415", "Detail": { "ID": 325415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4976954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233247", "Detail": { "ID": 233247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1157794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311688", "Detail": { "ID": 311688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8899878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229694", "Detail": { "ID": 229694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0926738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267470", "Detail": { "ID": 267470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0212333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313473", "Detail": { "ID": 313473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3968936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294968", "Detail": { "ID": 294968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1864989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319136", "Detail": { "ID": 319136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6939876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306304", "Detail": { "ID": 306304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5463053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310764", "Detail": { "ID": 310764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5850443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268134", "Detail": { "ID": 268134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0576467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286441", "Detail": { "ID": 286441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5793461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258538", "Detail": { "ID": 258538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3115594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263791", "Detail": { "ID": 263791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9048937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308724", "Detail": { "ID": 308724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.068235+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279759", "Detail": { "ID": 279759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5213835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279566", "Detail": { "ID": 279566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5132091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260505", "Detail": { "ID": 260505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0797769+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299558", "Detail": { "ID": 299558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7026191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306756", "Detail": { "ID": 306756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5660683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300579", "Detail": { "ID": 300579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0046798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223965", "Detail": { "ID": 223965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4862114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237884", "Detail": { "ID": 237884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2302329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305564", "Detail": { "ID": 305564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3298214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320134", "Detail": { "ID": 320134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9631524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315899", "Detail": { "ID": 315899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9320181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236735", "Detail": { "ID": 236735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9378096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289770", "Detail": { "ID": 289770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4583577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234493", "Detail": { "ID": 234493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3866417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313159", "Detail": { "ID": 313159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1662079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289358", "Detail": { "ID": 289358, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4338215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225329", "Detail": { "ID": 225329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9698682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265781", "Detail": { "ID": 265781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4542191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283229", "Detail": { "ID": 283229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6914393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252021", "Detail": { "ID": 252021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4991567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317356", "Detail": { "ID": 317356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4185934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254253", "Detail": { "ID": 254253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2475657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296260", "Detail": { "ID": 296260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8409879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235464", "Detail": { "ID": 235464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6789791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257675", "Detail": { "ID": 257675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0667259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228558", "Detail": { "ID": 228558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8042753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291577", "Detail": { "ID": 291577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1333649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311152", "Detail": { "ID": 311152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.607945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246781", "Detail": { "ID": 246781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1531358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298065", "Detail": { "ID": 298065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1367637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234095", "Detail": { "ID": 234095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1664234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274675", "Detail": { "ID": 274675, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1168567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269636", "Detail": { "ID": 269636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5564438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317493", "Detail": { "ID": 317493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4247947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326415", "Detail": { "ID": 326415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.757574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241264", "Detail": { "ID": 241264, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7504389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290374", "Detail": { "ID": 290374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7441198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248030", "Detail": { "ID": 248030, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4387392+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287482", "Detail": { "ID": 287482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8660609+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222573", "Detail": { "ID": 222573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306957", "Detail": { "ID": 306957, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5811782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239860", "Detail": { "ID": 239860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7621542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283742", "Detail": { "ID": 283742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7215102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231791", "Detail": { "ID": 231791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6156796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237374", "Detail": { "ID": 237374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2014349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308994", "Detail": { "ID": 308994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2014, "AgendaID": 2148, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 72, "VoteAgainst": 36, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Approval of SSI", "Reference": "S4M-05549", "ID": 5683 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "End": "2013-02-07T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0869388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252764", "Detail": { "ID": 252764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7523055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259473", "Detail": { "ID": 259473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6106226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319545", "Detail": { "ID": 319545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.930578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250127", "Detail": { "ID": 250127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9645007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228375", "Detail": { "ID": 228375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7959242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281069", "Detail": { "ID": 281069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8046818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262999", "Detail": { "ID": 262999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6322955+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290691", "Detail": { "ID": 290691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.76811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230558", "Detail": { "ID": 230558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.335565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270708", "Detail": { "ID": 270708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8196755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322537", "Detail": { "ID": 322537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6930004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295382", "Detail": { "ID": 295382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5097842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243054", "Detail": { "ID": 243054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0469516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236975", "Detail": { "ID": 236975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9483714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303102", "Detail": { "ID": 303102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5586791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238454", "Detail": { "ID": 238454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4473027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327040", "Detail": { "ID": 327040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7910102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277494", "Detail": { "ID": 277494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9557771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263991", "Detail": { "ID": 263991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9195207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249320", "Detail": { "ID": 249320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9214996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294857", "Detail": { "ID": 294857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1814467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285349", "Detail": { "ID": 285349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3191875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231287", "Detail": { "ID": 231287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5884539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243664", "Detail": { "ID": 243664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3146005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254426", "Detail": { "ID": 254426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2554452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323492", "Detail": { "ID": 323492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9587019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292427", "Detail": { "ID": 292427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5333346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273046", "Detail": { "ID": 273046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3672394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262869", "Detail": { "ID": 262869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6264834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281823", "Detail": { "ID": 281823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1591334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298304", "Detail": { "ID": 298304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3399738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231133", "Detail": { "ID": 231133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3670309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287177", "Detail": { "ID": 287177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6224655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219699", "Detail": { "ID": 219699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3106974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239108", "Detail": { "ID": 239108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4956243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226245", "Detail": { "ID": 226245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2167991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321923", "Detail": { "ID": 321923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4571755+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292730", "Detail": { "ID": 292730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5553617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228186", "Detail": { "ID": 228186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5880329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313330", "Detail": { "ID": 313330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3906536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257999", "Detail": { "ID": 257999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.086981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271683", "Detail": { "ID": 271683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.086706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277961", "Detail": { "ID": 277961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9762276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288329", "Detail": { "ID": 288329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1301355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250810", "Detail": { "ID": 250810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2144674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221274", "Detail": { "ID": 221274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.922287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226364", "Detail": { "ID": 226364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2281536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252833", "Detail": { "ID": 252833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7552013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253729", "Detail": { "ID": 253729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0184556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324759", "Detail": { "ID": 324759, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.236639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260888", "Detail": { "ID": 260888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1022976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246116", "Detail": { "ID": 246116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8728948+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273617", "Detail": { "ID": 273617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6281015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303977", "Detail": { "ID": 303977, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.84409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222258", "Detail": { "ID": 222258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1751515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245548", "Detail": { "ID": 245548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8399407+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224707", "Detail": { "ID": 224707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7164865+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307886", "Detail": { "ID": 307886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8551611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272547", "Detail": { "ID": 272547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3400933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245065", "Detail": { "ID": 245065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5904997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315234", "Detail": { "ID": 315234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8997114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252497", "Detail": { "ID": 252497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7316832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275622", "Detail": { "ID": 275622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3834557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257093", "Detail": { "ID": 257093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8229992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282870", "Detail": { "ID": 282870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4378846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254103", "Detail": { "ID": 254103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0346364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278774", "Detail": { "ID": 278774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2336887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325372", "Detail": { "ID": 325372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4958453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233320", "Detail": { "ID": 233320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1191442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311730", "Detail": { "ID": 311730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8917957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233093", "Detail": { "ID": 233093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267514", "Detail": { "ID": 267514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0231293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313430", "Detail": { "ID": 313430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.395036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294459", "Detail": { "ID": 294459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1392216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319172", "Detail": { "ID": 319172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.695524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306252", "Detail": { "ID": 306252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.544082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310732", "Detail": { "ID": 310732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5836578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268090", "Detail": { "ID": 268090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.055574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292967", "Detail": { "ID": 292967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5659115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271396", "Detail": { "ID": 271396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0739993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269398", "Detail": { "ID": 269398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5458261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308756", "Detail": { "ID": 308756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0696409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280582", "Detail": { "ID": 280582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7734218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279179", "Detail": { "ID": 279179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.256434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260456", "Detail": { "ID": 260456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.077663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299360", "Detail": { "ID": 299360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6941068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306788", "Detail": { "ID": 306788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5737158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300547", "Detail": { "ID": 300547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0030592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224486", "Detail": { "ID": 224486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7069026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237971", "Detail": { "ID": 237971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2340069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305615", "Detail": { "ID": 305615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3319903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320098", "Detail": { "ID": 320098, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9615833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315848", "Detail": { "ID": 315848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9296717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237123", "Detail": { "ID": 237123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9668126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288922", "Detail": { "ID": 288922, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1641366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234252", "Detail": { "ID": 234252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3690132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313108", "Detail": { "ID": 313108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1639988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289389", "Detail": { "ID": 289389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.435149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225702", "Detail": { "ID": 225702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9867393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265694", "Detail": { "ID": 265694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4502478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283945", "Detail": { "ID": 283945, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7302685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258720", "Detail": { "ID": 258720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3197378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317320", "Detail": { "ID": 317320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4170434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256095", "Detail": { "ID": 256095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5704137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296291", "Detail": { "ID": 296291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8425818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235990", "Detail": { "ID": 235990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7016397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258071", "Detail": { "ID": 258071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0903378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229386", "Detail": { "ID": 229386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0795065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291026", "Detail": { "ID": 291026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7822876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311516", "Detail": { "ID": 311516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8822261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247144", "Detail": { "ID": 247144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1689716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297677", "Detail": { "ID": 297677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1199909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234017", "Detail": { "ID": 234017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1565569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275351", "Detail": { "ID": 275351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3714554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269990", "Detail": { "ID": 269990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5767892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317700", "Detail": { "ID": 317700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4336454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326458", "Detail": { "ID": 326458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7655664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241483", "Detail": { "ID": 241483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7599089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290425", "Detail": { "ID": 290425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7465435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248242", "Detail": { "ID": 248242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6374489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290076", "Detail": { "ID": 290076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4717471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222793", "Detail": { "ID": 222793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2049557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306938", "Detail": { "ID": 306938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5803539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240792", "Detail": { "ID": 240792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3824961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284115", "Detail": { "ID": 284115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7436489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231746", "Detail": { "ID": 231746, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6137517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246744", "Detail": { "ID": 246744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1515622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308951", "Detail": { "ID": 308951, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2011, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.3", "ID": 5666 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0851178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252765", "Detail": { "ID": 252765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7523455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259474", "Detail": { "ID": 259474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6106631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319544", "Detail": { "ID": 319544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9305362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250126", "Detail": { "ID": 250126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9644603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228377", "Detail": { "ID": 228377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.796274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281077", "Detail": { "ID": 281077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8050046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263000", "Detail": { "ID": 263000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6323364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290690", "Detail": { "ID": 290690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7680702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230559", "Detail": { "ID": 230559, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3356055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270707", "Detail": { "ID": 270707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8196345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM323050", "Detail": { "ID": 323050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.719864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295383", "Detail": { "ID": 295383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5098245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243055", "Detail": { "ID": 243055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0469926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236974", "Detail": { "ID": 236974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9483307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303103", "Detail": { "ID": 303103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5587193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238453", "Detail": { "ID": 238453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4471809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327041", "Detail": { "ID": 327041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7910507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277495", "Detail": { "ID": 277495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9558186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263990", "Detail": { "ID": 263990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9194801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249319", "Detail": { "ID": 249319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9214585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294856", "Detail": { "ID": 294856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1813932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285350", "Detail": { "ID": 285350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3192288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231288", "Detail": { "ID": 231288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5884943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243663", "Detail": { "ID": 243663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3145415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254425", "Detail": { "ID": 254425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2554046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323493", "Detail": { "ID": 323493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9587427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292426", "Detail": { "ID": 292426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5332753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273047", "Detail": { "ID": 273047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.36728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262870", "Detail": { "ID": 262870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6265238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282352", "Detail": { "ID": 282352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4091391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298917", "Detail": { "ID": 298917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3779174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231132", "Detail": { "ID": 231132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3669905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287178", "Detail": { "ID": 287178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6225244+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219700", "Detail": { "ID": 219700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3107383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239107", "Detail": { "ID": 239107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.495583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226244", "Detail": { "ID": 226244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2167576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322245", "Detail": { "ID": 322245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6744493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292729", "Detail": { "ID": 292729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5553198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228187", "Detail": { "ID": 228187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5880735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313331", "Detail": { "ID": 313331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3906938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258000", "Detail": { "ID": 258000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0870211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271684", "Detail": { "ID": 271684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0867462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277953", "Detail": { "ID": 277953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9758775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288330", "Detail": { "ID": 288330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.130176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250811", "Detail": { "ID": 250811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2145069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221275", "Detail": { "ID": 221275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9223279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226363", "Detail": { "ID": 226363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2281123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252834", "Detail": { "ID": 252834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7552408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253721", "Detail": { "ID": 253721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0181332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324758", "Detail": { "ID": 324758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.236599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260887", "Detail": { "ID": 260887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1022571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246117", "Detail": { "ID": 246117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8729356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273616", "Detail": { "ID": 273616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.62806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303976", "Detail": { "ID": 303976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8440496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222257", "Detail": { "ID": 222257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1751108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245547", "Detail": { "ID": 245547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8399003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224706", "Detail": { "ID": 224706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7164429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308347", "Detail": { "ID": 308347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0520433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272548", "Detail": { "ID": 272548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3401336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245066", "Detail": { "ID": 245066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.59054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315235", "Detail": { "ID": 315235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.899752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252496", "Detail": { "ID": 252496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7316422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275621", "Detail": { "ID": 275621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.383415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257092", "Detail": { "ID": 257092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8229591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282871", "Detail": { "ID": 282871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4379248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254104", "Detail": { "ID": 254104, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.034677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278773", "Detail": { "ID": 278773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2336485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325373", "Detail": { "ID": 325373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4959044+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233321", "Detail": { "ID": 233321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1191848+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312319", "Detail": { "ID": 312319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1227054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233092", "Detail": { "ID": 233092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8964604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267522", "Detail": { "ID": 267522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.023456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314530", "Detail": { "ID": 314530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.643995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296685", "Detail": { "ID": 296685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8695786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319494", "Detail": { "ID": 319494, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.92838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306251", "Detail": { "ID": 306251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5440416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310731", "Detail": { "ID": 310731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5836163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268082", "Detail": { "ID": 268082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0552404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293709", "Detail": { "ID": 293709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.865571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271395", "Detail": { "ID": 271395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.073958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269397", "Detail": { "ID": 269397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.545785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308757", "Detail": { "ID": 308757, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0696828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280583", "Detail": { "ID": 280583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7734616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279178", "Detail": { "ID": 279178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2563932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260455", "Detail": { "ID": 260455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0776038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM304829", "Detail": { "ID": 304829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0605199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306789", "Detail": { "ID": 306789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5737606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300546", "Detail": { "ID": 300546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0030188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224487", "Detail": { "ID": 224487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7069431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237972", "Detail": { "ID": 237972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2340477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305616", "Detail": { "ID": 305616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3320313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321232", "Detail": { "ID": 321232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4193017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315847", "Detail": { "ID": 315847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9296131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237124", "Detail": { "ID": 237124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9668518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288921", "Detail": { "ID": 288921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1640965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234251", "Detail": { "ID": 234251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3689402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313107", "Detail": { "ID": 313107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1639577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289390", "Detail": { "ID": 289390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4351906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225703", "Detail": { "ID": 225703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9867799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265693", "Detail": { "ID": 265693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4501892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283944", "Detail": { "ID": 283944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7302275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258721", "Detail": { "ID": 258721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3197784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318453", "Detail": { "ID": 318453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6582373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256094", "Detail": { "ID": 256094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5703733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296292", "Detail": { "ID": 296292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8427213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235991", "Detail": { "ID": 235991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7016815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258072", "Detail": { "ID": 258072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0903881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229387", "Detail": { "ID": 229387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0795467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291025", "Detail": { "ID": 291025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7822472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311517", "Detail": { "ID": 311517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8822671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247145", "Detail": { "ID": 247145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1690125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297676", "Detail": { "ID": 297676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.119951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234016", "Detail": { "ID": 234016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1565156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275352", "Detail": { "ID": 275352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3714968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269998", "Detail": { "ID": 269998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5771377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317701", "Detail": { "ID": 317701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4336855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326457", "Detail": { "ID": 326457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7655263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241484", "Detail": { "ID": 241484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7599678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290426", "Detail": { "ID": 290426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7465837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248243", "Detail": { "ID": 248243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6374894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290077", "Detail": { "ID": 290077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4717875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222794", "Detail": { "ID": 222794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2049977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306937", "Detail": { "ID": 306937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5803131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240791", "Detail": { "ID": 240791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3824558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284114", "Detail": { "ID": 284114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.743608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231744", "Detail": { "ID": 231744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6136715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246743", "Detail": { "ID": 246743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1515228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309787", "Detail": { "ID": 309787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2012, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 16, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.2", "ID": 5664 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3449272+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252763", "Detail": { "ID": 252763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.752247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259472", "Detail": { "ID": 259472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6105813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319546", "Detail": { "ID": 319546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9306184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250128", "Detail": { "ID": 250128, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9645415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228374", "Detail": { "ID": 228374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7958554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281068", "Detail": { "ID": 281068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8046396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262998", "Detail": { "ID": 262998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6322548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290693", "Detail": { "ID": 290693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7682068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230557", "Detail": { "ID": 230557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3355247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270709", "Detail": { "ID": 270709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8197171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322536", "Detail": { "ID": 322536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.692958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295381", "Detail": { "ID": 295381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5097437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243053", "Detail": { "ID": 243053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0468927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236976", "Detail": { "ID": 236976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9484115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303101", "Detail": { "ID": 303101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5586382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238455", "Detail": { "ID": 238455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4473535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327039", "Detail": { "ID": 327039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7909695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277493", "Detail": { "ID": 277493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9557179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263992", "Detail": { "ID": 263992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9195614+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249323", "Detail": { "ID": 249323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9216239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294858", "Detail": { "ID": 294858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.18149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285348", "Detail": { "ID": 285348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3191458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231286", "Detail": { "ID": 231286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5884131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243665", "Detail": { "ID": 243665, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3146422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254427", "Detail": { "ID": 254427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2554861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323491", "Detail": { "ID": 323491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9586612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292429", "Detail": { "ID": 292429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5334178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273045", "Detail": { "ID": 273045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3671976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262866", "Detail": { "ID": 262866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6263398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281824", "Detail": { "ID": 281824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1591738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298303", "Detail": { "ID": 298303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3399336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231134", "Detail": { "ID": 231134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3670712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287175", "Detail": { "ID": 287175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.622384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219578", "Detail": { "ID": 219578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3054069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239109", "Detail": { "ID": 239109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4956647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225114", "Detail": { "ID": 225114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7450934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321924", "Detail": { "ID": 321924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4572174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292731", "Detail": { "ID": 292731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.555402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228184", "Detail": { "ID": 228184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5879497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313329", "Detail": { "ID": 313329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.390613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257997", "Detail": { "ID": 257997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0868785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271682", "Detail": { "ID": 271682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0866642+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277962", "Detail": { "ID": 277962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9762683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288328", "Detail": { "ID": 288328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1300949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250809", "Detail": { "ID": 250809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2144281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221102", "Detail": { "ID": 221102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6751604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226366", "Detail": { "ID": 226366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2282361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252832", "Detail": { "ID": 252832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.755161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253730", "Detail": { "ID": 253730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0184949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324760", "Detail": { "ID": 324760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2366964+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260891", "Detail": { "ID": 260891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1024207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246115", "Detail": { "ID": 246115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8728545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273618", "Detail": { "ID": 273618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.628142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303978", "Detail": { "ID": 303978, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8441301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221592", "Detail": { "ID": 221592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9393937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245549", "Detail": { "ID": 245549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8400038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224708", "Detail": { "ID": 224708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7165274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307885", "Detail": { "ID": 307885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8551204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272546", "Detail": { "ID": 272546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3400534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245064", "Detail": { "ID": 245064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5904591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315233", "Detail": { "ID": 315233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8996699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252498", "Detail": { "ID": 252498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7317236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275623", "Detail": { "ID": 275623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3834962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257094", "Detail": { "ID": 257094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8230391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282869", "Detail": { "ID": 282869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4378449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254102", "Detail": { "ID": 254102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0345951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278776", "Detail": { "ID": 278776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2337697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325371", "Detail": { "ID": 325371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4958048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233319", "Detail": { "ID": 233319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1191036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311729", "Detail": { "ID": 311729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.891754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233096", "Detail": { "ID": 233096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8966599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267513", "Detail": { "ID": 267513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0230871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313431", "Detail": { "ID": 313431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3950781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294460", "Detail": { "ID": 294460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1392616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319173", "Detail": { "ID": 319173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6955647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306253", "Detail": { "ID": 306253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5441228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310733", "Detail": { "ID": 310733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5836985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268091", "Detail": { "ID": 268091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0556441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292966", "Detail": { "ID": 292966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5658708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271398", "Detail": { "ID": 271398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0741007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269401", "Detail": { "ID": 269401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5459491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308755", "Detail": { "ID": 308755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0695775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280580", "Detail": { "ID": 280580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7733391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279180", "Detail": { "ID": 279180, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2564751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260457", "Detail": { "ID": 260457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.077706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299361", "Detail": { "ID": 299361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6941473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306787", "Detail": { "ID": 306787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5736434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300548", "Detail": { "ID": 300548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.00313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224006", "Detail": { "ID": 224006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4879706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237970", "Detail": { "ID": 237970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2339646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305614", "Detail": { "ID": 305614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3319498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320097", "Detail": { "ID": 320097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9615422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315849", "Detail": { "ID": 315849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9297131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237122", "Detail": { "ID": 237122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9667734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288923", "Detail": { "ID": 288923, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1641775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234253", "Detail": { "ID": 234253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.369274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313109", "Detail": { "ID": 313109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1640397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289388", "Detail": { "ID": 289388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4350884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225701", "Detail": { "ID": 225701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9866986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265695", "Detail": { "ID": 265695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4502893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283947", "Detail": { "ID": 283947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.73037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258717", "Detail": { "ID": 258717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3196135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317319", "Detail": { "ID": 317319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4170029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256096", "Detail": { "ID": 256096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5704542+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296290", "Detail": { "ID": 296290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.84251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235987", "Detail": { "ID": 235987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7014995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258070", "Detail": { "ID": 258070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0902893+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228599", "Detail": { "ID": 228599, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8060541+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291027", "Detail": { "ID": 291027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7823287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311515", "Detail": { "ID": 311515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8821843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247143", "Detail": { "ID": 247143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1689309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297678", "Detail": { "ID": 297678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1200307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234018", "Detail": { "ID": 234018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1565979+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275348", "Detail": { "ID": 275348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3713303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269989", "Detail": { "ID": 269989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5767486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317699", "Detail": { "ID": 317699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4336053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326459", "Detail": { "ID": 326459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7656067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241304", "Detail": { "ID": 241304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7521672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290424", "Detail": { "ID": 290424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7465031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248239", "Detail": { "ID": 248239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.637324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290074", "Detail": { "ID": 290074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4716431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222792", "Detail": { "ID": 222792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2048951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306939", "Detail": { "ID": 306939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5803941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239667", "Detail": { "ID": 239667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7537772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284116", "Detail": { "ID": 284116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7436894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231747", "Detail": { "ID": 231747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6137916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246747", "Detail": { "ID": 246747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1516836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308952", "Detail": { "ID": 308952, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2010, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521.1", "ID": 5655 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0851593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252762", "Detail": { "ID": 252762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7522073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259159", "Detail": { "ID": 259159, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3442483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319547", "Detail": { "ID": 319547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9306597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249472", "Detail": { "ID": 249472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9281805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228373", "Detail": { "ID": 228373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7958135+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281067", "Detail": { "ID": 281067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8045807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262997", "Detail": { "ID": 262997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6322137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM290692", "Detail": { "ID": 290692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7681492+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230556", "Detail": { "ID": 230556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3354837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269712", "Detail": { "ID": 269712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5597508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322535", "Detail": { "ID": 322535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6928968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295380", "Detail": { "ID": 295380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5097033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243052", "Detail": { "ID": 243052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0468517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235085", "Detail": { "ID": 235085, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4187216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303087", "Detail": { "ID": 303087, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5580461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238456", "Detail": { "ID": 238456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4473959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327038", "Detail": { "ID": 327038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7909282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277492", "Detail": { "ID": 277492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9556773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263993", "Detail": { "ID": 263993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.919602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248646", "Detail": { "ID": 248646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6637735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294859", "Detail": { "ID": 294859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1815322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285347", "Detail": { "ID": 285347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3191046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231285", "Detail": { "ID": 231285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5883715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243666", "Detail": { "ID": 243666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3146835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254440", "Detail": { "ID": 254440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2562051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323490", "Detail": { "ID": 323490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9586203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290895", "Detail": { "ID": 290895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7767159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273044", "Detail": { "ID": 273044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3671557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262533", "Detail": { "ID": 262533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6060215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281825", "Detail": { "ID": 281825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1592147+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298302", "Detail": { "ID": 298302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3398934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231135", "Detail": { "ID": 231135, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3671106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287176", "Detail": { "ID": 287176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6224248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219520", "Detail": { "ID": 219520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3028975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238268", "Detail": { "ID": 238268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4390662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225125", "Detail": { "ID": 225125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7455579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321925", "Detail": { "ID": 321925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4572579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292732", "Detail": { "ID": 292732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5554429+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227245", "Detail": { "ID": 227245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5371264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313314", "Detail": { "ID": 313314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3899784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257810", "Detail": { "ID": 257810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0785645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271090", "Detail": { "ID": 271090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8420612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277963", "Detail": { "ID": 277963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9763099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288316", "Detail": { "ID": 288316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1295797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250627", "Detail": { "ID": 250627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1977026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221091", "Detail": { "ID": 221091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6746899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220124", "Detail": { "ID": 220124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3353538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252818", "Detail": { "ID": 252818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7545742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253731", "Detail": { "ID": 253731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0185342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324761", "Detail": { "ID": 324761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2367383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259593", "Detail": { "ID": 259593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6161326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239474", "Detail": { "ID": 239474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7452768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273619", "Detail": { "ID": 273619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6281827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303993", "Detail": { "ID": 303993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8447826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221603", "Detail": { "ID": 221603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9398641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241835", "Detail": { "ID": 241835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7820792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223398", "Detail": { "ID": 223398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4561639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307884", "Detail": { "ID": 307884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8550794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272362", "Detail": { "ID": 272362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3320666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245063", "Detail": { "ID": 245063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5904182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315232", "Detail": { "ID": 315232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8996289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247487", "Detail": { "ID": 247487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4059493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275150", "Detail": { "ID": 275150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1437409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255489", "Detail": { "ID": 255489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5335232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276939", "Detail": { "ID": 276939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6875841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253475", "Detail": { "ID": 253475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9980345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276709", "Detail": { "ID": 276709, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6777683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325370", "Detail": { "ID": 325370, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.495764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233308", "Detail": { "ID": 233308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1186155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311728", "Detail": { "ID": 311728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8916943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229659", "Detail": { "ID": 229659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0911808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267512", "Detail": { "ID": 267512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.023025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313432", "Detail": { "ID": 313432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3951202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294461", "Detail": { "ID": 294461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1393017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319174", "Detail": { "ID": 319174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6956051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306254", "Detail": { "ID": 306254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5441631+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310734", "Detail": { "ID": 310734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5837391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268092", "Detail": { "ID": 268092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0556853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292965", "Detail": { "ID": 292965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5658306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258509", "Detail": { "ID": 258509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3103209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263758", "Detail": { "ID": 263758, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9034698+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308754", "Detail": { "ID": 308754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0695363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279792", "Detail": { "ID": 279792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.523015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279491", "Detail": { "ID": 279491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5100025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260458", "Detail": { "ID": 260458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0777469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299362", "Detail": { "ID": 299362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6941881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306786", "Detail": { "ID": 306786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5735989+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300549", "Detail": { "ID": 300549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.003176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223995", "Detail": { "ID": 223995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4875017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237929", "Detail": { "ID": 237929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2321829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305613", "Detail": { "ID": 305613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3319094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320096", "Detail": { "ID": 320096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9615+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315850", "Detail": { "ID": 315850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9297534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237121", "Detail": { "ID": 237121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9667336+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288924", "Detail": { "ID": 288924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1642176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234268", "Detail": { "ID": 234268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3699341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313110", "Detail": { "ID": 313110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1640814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289387", "Detail": { "ID": 289387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.435048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225389", "Detail": { "ID": 225389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9726245+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265708", "Detail": { "ID": 265708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4508954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283039", "Detail": { "ID": 283039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.445126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252054", "Detail": { "ID": 252054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5005793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317318", "Detail": { "ID": 317318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4169623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254224", "Detail": { "ID": 254224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2462849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296289", "Detail": { "ID": 296289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8423613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235499", "Detail": { "ID": 235499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6804616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258057", "Detail": { "ID": 258057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0895919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228588", "Detail": { "ID": 228588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8055685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291040", "Detail": { "ID": 291040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7828884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311514", "Detail": { "ID": 311514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8821434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246810", "Detail": { "ID": 246810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1543633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297679", "Detail": { "ID": 297679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1200701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234019", "Detail": { "ID": 234019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.156638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274861", "Detail": { "ID": 274861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1250071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269988", "Detail": { "ID": 269988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.576708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317698", "Detail": { "ID": 317698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.433565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326460", "Detail": { "ID": 326460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7656474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241293", "Detail": { "ID": 241293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.751694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290423", "Detail": { "ID": 290423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7464622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248063", "Detail": { "ID": 248063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4401834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287516", "Detail": { "ID": 287516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8743409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222633", "Detail": { "ID": 222633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1973243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306940", "Detail": { "ID": 306940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5804345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239678", "Detail": { "ID": 239678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7542443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283800", "Detail": { "ID": 283800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7239985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231748", "Detail": { "ID": 231748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6138309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237340", "Detail": { "ID": 237340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1999716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308953", "Detail": { "ID": 308953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2009, "AgendaID": 2442, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Child Benefit", "Reference": "S4M-05521", "ID": 5652 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-31T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0852002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252774", "Detail": { "ID": 252774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7527078+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259191", "Detail": { "ID": 259191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3456074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319540", "Detail": { "ID": 319540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9303527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250275", "Detail": { "ID": 250275, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1821719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228398", "Detail": { "ID": 228398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7972954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281093", "Detail": { "ID": 281093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8057073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262812", "Detail": { "ID": 262812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6240019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288994", "Detail": { "ID": 288994, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1674846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230534", "Detail": { "ID": 230534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3345178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269680", "Detail": { "ID": 269680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.558376+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322513", "Detail": { "ID": 322513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6918431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295349", "Detail": { "ID": 295349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5083854+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243059", "Detail": { "ID": 243059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0471563+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227105", "Detail": { "ID": 227105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2677308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303077", "Detail": { "ID": 303077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5576197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244191", "Detail": { "ID": 244191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.543792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327033", "Detail": { "ID": 327033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7906951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277151", "Detail": { "ID": 277151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.70329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264023", "Detail": { "ID": 264023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9208927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248630", "Detail": { "ID": 248630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6630857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294852", "Detail": { "ID": 294852, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1811348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285316", "Detail": { "ID": 285316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3177597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230792", "Detail": { "ID": 230792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3457107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243659", "Detail": { "ID": 243659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.314381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254451", "Detail": { "ID": 254451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2566918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323485", "Detail": { "ID": 323485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9584085+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290879", "Detail": { "ID": 290879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7760535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273014", "Detail": { "ID": 273014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3658516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262549", "Detail": { "ID": 262549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.606691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281801", "Detail": { "ID": 281801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1581797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298480", "Detail": { "ID": 298480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.347943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231145", "Detail": { "ID": 231145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3675425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284925", "Detail": { "ID": 284925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0535901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219536", "Detail": { "ID": 219536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3035841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238237", "Detail": { "ID": 238237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4377282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225134", "Detail": { "ID": 225134, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7459194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321947", "Detail": { "ID": 321947, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4582773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292662", "Detail": { "ID": 292662, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5524439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227261", "Detail": { "ID": 227261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5378134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313304", "Detail": { "ID": 313304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3895374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257851", "Detail": { "ID": 257851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0803307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271058", "Detail": { "ID": 271058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8407016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274380", "Detail": { "ID": 274380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1035568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287379", "Detail": { "ID": 287379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8616943+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250668", "Detail": { "ID": 250668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.208398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221082", "Detail": { "ID": 221082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6743002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220108", "Detail": { "ID": 220108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3346778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252807", "Detail": { "ID": 252807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7541101+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253239", "Detail": { "ID": 253239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9875022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324766", "Detail": { "ID": 324766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2369411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259421", "Detail": { "ID": 259421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6083805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239506", "Detail": { "ID": 239506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7467234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273649", "Detail": { "ID": 273649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6294674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304003", "Detail": { "ID": 304003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8452198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221612", "Detail": { "ID": 221612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9402511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245691", "Detail": { "ID": 245691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.854322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223391", "Detail": { "ID": 223391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4558592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307908", "Detail": { "ID": 307908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8561153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272404", "Detail": { "ID": 272404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3338837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245070", "Detail": { "ID": 245070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5907247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315239", "Detail": { "ID": 315239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8999393+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247455", "Detail": { "ID": 247455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4045499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275493", "Detail": { "ID": 275493, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3776465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255457", "Detail": { "ID": 255457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5321596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276906", "Detail": { "ID": 276906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6861792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253507", "Detail": { "ID": 253507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9994151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276384", "Detail": { "ID": 276384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6632911+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325365", "Detail": { "ID": 325365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4955494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233297", "Detail": { "ID": 233297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1179806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311752", "Detail": { "ID": 311752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8927486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229643", "Detail": { "ID": 229643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0905196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267538", "Detail": { "ID": 267538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0241454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313408", "Detail": { "ID": 313408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3940935+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294437", "Detail": { "ID": 294437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1382863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319196", "Detail": { "ID": 319196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6965463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306247", "Detail": { "ID": 306247, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.543856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310362", "Detail": { "ID": 310362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.567252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268066", "Detail": { "ID": 268066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0545284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292989", "Detail": { "ID": 292989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5668592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271858", "Detail": { "ID": 271858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0944574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263589", "Detail": { "ID": 263589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8959058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307233", "Detail": { "ID": 307233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8203838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280116", "Detail": { "ID": 280116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5421327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279522", "Detail": { "ID": 279522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5113353+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260451", "Detail": { "ID": 260451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0774373+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299338", "Detail": { "ID": 299338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6931669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301791", "Detail": { "ID": 301791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2834043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300480", "Detail": { "ID": 300480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0000068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223986", "Detail": { "ID": 223986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4871162+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237936", "Detail": { "ID": 237936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2324687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305620", "Detail": { "ID": 305620, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3322161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320074", "Detail": { "ID": 320074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9605511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315843", "Detail": { "ID": 315843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9294482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237090", "Detail": { "ID": 237090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9654331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289725", "Detail": { "ID": 289725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4564727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234279", "Detail": { "ID": 234279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3704168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313103", "Detail": { "ID": 313103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1637719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261305", "Detail": { "ID": 261305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3516629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225396", "Detail": { "ID": 225396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9729346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265719", "Detail": { "ID": 265719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4515252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283023", "Detail": { "ID": 283023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4444566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252070", "Detail": { "ID": 252070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5012744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317296", "Detail": { "ID": 317296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4123179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256696", "Detail": { "ID": 256696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7937941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293362", "Detail": { "ID": 293362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8417545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235516", "Detail": { "ID": 235516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6811919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258046", "Detail": { "ID": 258046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0889994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228579", "Detail": { "ID": 228579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8051793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291050", "Detail": { "ID": 291050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.783319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311520", "Detail": { "ID": 311520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8823932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246851", "Detail": { "ID": 246851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1561254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298018", "Detail": { "ID": 298018, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1347439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234050", "Detail": { "ID": 234050, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1644859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274877", "Detail": { "ID": 274877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1258538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270014", "Detail": { "ID": 270014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5778359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317705", "Detail": { "ID": 317705, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4338476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326465", "Detail": { "ID": 326465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7658728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241335", "Detail": { "ID": 241335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7535063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290430", "Detail": { "ID": 290430, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7467475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248079", "Detail": { "ID": 248079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4410832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287532", "Detail": { "ID": 287532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8750387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222640", "Detail": { "ID": 222640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1976281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306893", "Detail": { "ID": 306893, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5781215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240940", "Detail": { "ID": 240940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3889577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283986", "Detail": { "ID": 283986, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7320517+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231723", "Detail": { "ID": 231723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6127856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237324", "Detail": { "ID": 237324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1992959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308929", "Detail": { "ID": 308929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2005, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506.1", "ID": 5650 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0841746+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252775", "Detail": { "ID": 252775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7527663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259193", "Detail": { "ID": 259193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3456874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319539", "Detail": { "ID": 319539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9303117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250273", "Detail": { "ID": 250273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1820898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228399", "Detail": { "ID": 228399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7973369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281094", "Detail": { "ID": 281094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8057471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262813", "Detail": { "ID": 262813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6240636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288979", "Detail": { "ID": 288979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1668422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230535", "Detail": { "ID": 230535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3345598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269678", "Detail": { "ID": 269678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5582941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322514", "Detail": { "ID": 322514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6919021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295350", "Detail": { "ID": 295350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5084256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243060", "Detail": { "ID": 243060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0471968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227103", "Detail": { "ID": 227103, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.267626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303078", "Detail": { "ID": 303078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5576605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244190", "Detail": { "ID": 244190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.54374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327034", "Detail": { "ID": 327034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7907625+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277152", "Detail": { "ID": 277152, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7033304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264022", "Detail": { "ID": 264022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.920852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248628", "Detail": { "ID": 248628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6630043+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294851", "Detail": { "ID": 294851, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1810937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285317", "Detail": { "ID": 285317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3178014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230793", "Detail": { "ID": 230793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3457506+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243658", "Detail": { "ID": 243658, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3143401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254450", "Detail": { "ID": 254450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2566488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323486", "Detail": { "ID": 323486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.958452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292387", "Detail": { "ID": 292387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5316257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273015", "Detail": { "ID": 273015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3658944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262551", "Detail": { "ID": 262551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.606791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281800", "Detail": { "ID": 281800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1581402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298481", "Detail": { "ID": 298481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.347984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231144", "Detail": { "ID": 231144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3675024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284940", "Detail": { "ID": 284940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.054257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219537", "Detail": { "ID": 219537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3036259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238235", "Detail": { "ID": 238235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4376452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226700", "Detail": { "ID": 226700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2428278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321946", "Detail": { "ID": 321946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4582361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292661", "Detail": { "ID": 292661, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5524034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227569", "Detail": { "ID": 227569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5557828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313305", "Detail": { "ID": 313305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3895782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257853", "Detail": { "ID": 257853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0804132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271057", "Detail": { "ID": 271057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8406611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274379", "Detail": { "ID": 274379, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1035166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287380", "Detail": { "ID": 287380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8617357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250670", "Detail": { "ID": 250670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2084775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221136", "Detail": { "ID": 221136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.676616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220107", "Detail": { "ID": 220107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3346368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252808", "Detail": { "ID": 252808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7541518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253238", "Detail": { "ID": 253238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9874617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324765", "Detail": { "ID": 324765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2369008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259419", "Detail": { "ID": 259419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6082992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239508", "Detail": { "ID": 239508, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7468042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273648", "Detail": { "ID": 273648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6294253+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304002", "Detail": { "ID": 304002, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8451791+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223178", "Detail": { "ID": 223178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2319818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245689", "Detail": { "ID": 245689, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8542416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223390", "Detail": { "ID": 223390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4558179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307909", "Detail": { "ID": 307909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.856156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272405", "Detail": { "ID": 272405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3339239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245071", "Detail": { "ID": 245071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5907658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315240", "Detail": { "ID": 315240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8999808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247453", "Detail": { "ID": 247453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4044667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275478", "Detail": { "ID": 275478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3769869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255455", "Detail": { "ID": 255455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5320784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276921", "Detail": { "ID": 276921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6868315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253509", "Detail": { "ID": 253509, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9994971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276382", "Detail": { "ID": 276382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6632088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325366", "Detail": { "ID": 325366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4955914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233298", "Detail": { "ID": 233298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1180215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311753", "Detail": { "ID": 311753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8927923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229642", "Detail": { "ID": 229642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0904799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267539", "Detail": { "ID": 267539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0241863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313407", "Detail": { "ID": 313407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3940291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294436", "Detail": { "ID": 294436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1382457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319195", "Detail": { "ID": 319195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6965055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306246", "Detail": { "ID": 306246, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5438153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310361", "Detail": { "ID": 310361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5672111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268065", "Detail": { "ID": 268065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0544873+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292990", "Detail": { "ID": 292990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5668999+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271857", "Detail": { "ID": 271857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0944174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263587", "Detail": { "ID": 263587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8958239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307234", "Detail": { "ID": 307234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.820425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280118", "Detail": { "ID": 280118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5422134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279521", "Detail": { "ID": 279521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5112942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260450", "Detail": { "ID": 260450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0773962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299337", "Detail": { "ID": 299337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6931068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301792", "Detail": { "ID": 301792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2834447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300479", "Detail": { "ID": 300479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9999659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224193", "Detail": { "ID": 224193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4965771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237938", "Detail": { "ID": 237938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2325688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305621", "Detail": { "ID": 305621, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3322565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320075", "Detail": { "ID": 320075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9605923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315842", "Detail": { "ID": 315842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9294074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237091", "Detail": { "ID": 237091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9654726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289724", "Detail": { "ID": 289724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4564328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234278", "Detail": { "ID": 234278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3703742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313102", "Detail": { "ID": 313102, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1637307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261306", "Detail": { "ID": 261306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3517037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225397", "Detail": { "ID": 225397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9729774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265718", "Detail": { "ID": 265718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4514772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283905", "Detail": { "ID": 283905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7285554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252072", "Detail": { "ID": 252072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5013559+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317297", "Detail": { "ID": 317297, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4123584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256694", "Detail": { "ID": 256694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7936919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293363", "Detail": { "ID": 293363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8417958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235517", "Detail": { "ID": 235517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6812328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258047", "Detail": { "ID": 258047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0890582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228631", "Detail": { "ID": 228631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8074387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291049", "Detail": { "ID": 291049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7832786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311521", "Detail": { "ID": 311521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8824341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246853", "Detail": { "ID": 246853, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1562059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297708", "Detail": { "ID": 297708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1213932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234049", "Detail": { "ID": 234049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1644448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274879", "Detail": { "ID": 274879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1259562+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270015", "Detail": { "ID": 270015, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5778788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317706", "Detail": { "ID": 317706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4339068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326464", "Detail": { "ID": 326464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7658309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241337", "Detail": { "ID": 241337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7535889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290431", "Detail": { "ID": 290431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7467877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248081", "Detail": { "ID": 248081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4411657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290116", "Detail": { "ID": 290116, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4734816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222641", "Detail": { "ID": 222641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1976693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306892", "Detail": { "ID": 306892, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5780804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240938", "Detail": { "ID": 240938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3888751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283818", "Detail": { "ID": 283818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7247858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231722", "Detail": { "ID": 231722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6127456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237322", "Detail": { "ID": 237322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1992105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308928", "Detail": { "ID": 308928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2006, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 64, "VoteAgainst": 51, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Further Education", "Reference": "S4M-05506", "ID": 5637 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0841145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252776", "Detail": { "ID": 252776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7528068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259198", "Detail": { "ID": 259198, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5983939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319538", "Detail": { "ID": 319538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9302711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250272", "Detail": { "ID": 250272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1820483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228400", "Detail": { "ID": 228400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.797378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281100", "Detail": { "ID": 281100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8059867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262814", "Detail": { "ID": 262814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6241067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288998", "Detail": { "ID": 288998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1676709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230536", "Detail": { "ID": 230536, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3346011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269673", "Detail": { "ID": 269673, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5580868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322506", "Detail": { "ID": 322506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6915591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295351", "Detail": { "ID": 295351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5084666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243061", "Detail": { "ID": 243061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0472377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227078", "Detail": { "ID": 227078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2665473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303079", "Detail": { "ID": 303079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5577009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244189", "Detail": { "ID": 244189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5436869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327035", "Detail": { "ID": 327035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7908047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277153", "Detail": { "ID": 277153, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.703371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264021", "Detail": { "ID": 264021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9208115+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250988", "Detail": { "ID": 250988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2221611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294850", "Detail": { "ID": 294850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1810524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285318", "Detail": { "ID": 285318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.317843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230794", "Detail": { "ID": 230794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3457917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243657", "Detail": { "ID": 243657, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3143003+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254449", "Detail": { "ID": 254449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.256581+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323487", "Detail": { "ID": 323487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9584937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300696", "Detail": { "ID": 300696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0096878+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273016", "Detail": { "ID": 273016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3659357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262604", "Detail": { "ID": 262604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6090213+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281793", "Detail": { "ID": 281793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1578402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298488", "Detail": { "ID": 298488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3482927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231143", "Detail": { "ID": 231143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3674624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284920", "Detail": { "ID": 284920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0533824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219587", "Detail": { "ID": 219587, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3058068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238230", "Detail": { "ID": 238230, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4374382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226699", "Detail": { "ID": 226699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2427861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321954", "Detail": { "ID": 321954, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4585712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292660", "Detail": { "ID": 292660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5523626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227615", "Detail": { "ID": 227615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5577416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313306", "Detail": { "ID": 313306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3896195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257854", "Detail": { "ID": 257854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0804535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271052", "Detail": { "ID": 271052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8404384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274373", "Detail": { "ID": 274373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.103268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287381", "Detail": { "ID": 287381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8617761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250671", "Detail": { "ID": 250671, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2085179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221137", "Detail": { "ID": 221137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6766568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226477", "Detail": { "ID": 226477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2331002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252809", "Detail": { "ID": 252809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7541922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253232", "Detail": { "ID": 253232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9871783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324764", "Detail": { "ID": 324764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2368604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261617", "Detail": { "ID": 261617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3651841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239513", "Detail": { "ID": 239513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7470234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273647", "Detail": { "ID": 273647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6293659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304001", "Detail": { "ID": 304001, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8451384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223177", "Detail": { "ID": 223177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2319402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245688", "Detail": { "ID": 245688, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8542022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223365", "Detail": { "ID": 223365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4547302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307917", "Detail": { "ID": 307917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8565038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272406", "Detail": { "ID": 272406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3339646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245072", "Detail": { "ID": 245072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5908067+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315241", "Detail": { "ID": 315241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9000218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247448", "Detail": { "ID": 247448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4042463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275498", "Detail": { "ID": 275498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3778545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255450", "Detail": { "ID": 255450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.531855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276901", "Detail": { "ID": 276901, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6859762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253514", "Detail": { "ID": 253514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9997025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279192", "Detail": { "ID": 279192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2569855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325367", "Detail": { "ID": 325367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4956322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233299", "Detail": { "ID": 233299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1180634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311761", "Detail": { "ID": 311761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8931411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233205", "Detail": { "ID": 233205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1138807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267545", "Detail": { "ID": 267545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0244697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313399", "Detail": { "ID": 313399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3937015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294429", "Detail": { "ID": 294429, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1379375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319203", "Detail": { "ID": 319203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9096849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306245", "Detail": { "ID": 306245, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5437741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310360", "Detail": { "ID": 310360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5671699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268059", "Detail": { "ID": 268059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0542184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292997", "Detail": { "ID": 292997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5672046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271856", "Detail": { "ID": 271856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.094377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269820", "Detail": { "ID": 269820, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.564331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307235", "Detail": { "ID": 307235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8204663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280170", "Detail": { "ID": 280170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5444379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279520", "Detail": { "ID": 279520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5112521+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260449", "Detail": { "ID": 260449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0773552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299330", "Detail": { "ID": 299330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6928214+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301793", "Detail": { "ID": 301793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2834855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300478", "Detail": { "ID": 300478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9999238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224194", "Detail": { "ID": 224194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.496618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237939", "Detail": { "ID": 237939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2326103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305622", "Detail": { "ID": 305622, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3322975+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320067", "Detail": { "ID": 320067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9602319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315841", "Detail": { "ID": 315841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9293658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237092", "Detail": { "ID": 237092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9655124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289723", "Detail": { "ID": 289723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4563929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234277", "Detail": { "ID": 234277, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3703328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313101", "Detail": { "ID": 313101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1636891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261307", "Detail": { "ID": 261307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3517444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225576", "Detail": { "ID": 225576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9812936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265717", "Detail": { "ID": 265717, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4514295+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284213", "Detail": { "ID": 284213, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0163378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252121", "Detail": { "ID": 252121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.503499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317289", "Detail": { "ID": 317289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4120099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256693", "Detail": { "ID": 256693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7936513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293364", "Detail": { "ID": 293364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8418368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235878", "Detail": { "ID": 235878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6968315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258048", "Detail": { "ID": 258048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.089108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228632", "Detail": { "ID": 228632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8074794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291048", "Detail": { "ID": 291048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7832374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311522", "Detail": { "ID": 311522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8824754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246854", "Detail": { "ID": 246854, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.156246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297707", "Detail": { "ID": 297707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1213533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234048", "Detail": { "ID": 234048, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1644023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274931", "Detail": { "ID": 274931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1282021+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270021", "Detail": { "ID": 270021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5781339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317707", "Detail": { "ID": 317707, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4339483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326463", "Detail": { "ID": 326463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7657694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241338", "Detail": { "ID": 241338, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7536302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290432", "Detail": { "ID": 290432, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7468483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248130", "Detail": { "ID": 248130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4439472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289196", "Detail": { "ID": 289196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1816046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222666", "Detail": { "ID": 222666, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1987301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306891", "Detail": { "ID": 306891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.578039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240937", "Detail": { "ID": 240937, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3888327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283991", "Detail": { "ID": 283991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7322768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231721", "Detail": { "ID": 231721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6127054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247308", "Detail": { "ID": 247308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3979904+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308920", "Detail": { "ID": 308920, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2007, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 104, "VoteAgainst": 0, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.2", "ID": 5651 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0837886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252777", "Detail": { "ID": 252777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7528464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259199", "Detail": { "ID": 259199, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5984462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319537", "Detail": { "ID": 319537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9302297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250271", "Detail": { "ID": 250271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1820074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228401", "Detail": { "ID": 228401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7974198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281101", "Detail": { "ID": 281101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8060459+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263044", "Detail": { "ID": 263044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6343328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288997", "Detail": { "ID": 288997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1676288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230537", "Detail": { "ID": 230537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3346417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269672", "Detail": { "ID": 269672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5580394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322507", "Detail": { "ID": 322507, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6915994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295889", "Detail": { "ID": 295889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5401849+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243062", "Detail": { "ID": 243062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0472783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227077", "Detail": { "ID": 227077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2665062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303080", "Detail": { "ID": 303080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5577412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238409", "Detail": { "ID": 238409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4452867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327036", "Detail": { "ID": 327036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7908457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277540", "Detail": { "ID": 277540, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9577382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263946", "Detail": { "ID": 263946, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9176002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250987", "Detail": { "ID": 250987, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2221194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294849", "Detail": { "ID": 294849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1810109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285395", "Detail": { "ID": 285395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3211703+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230795", "Detail": { "ID": 230795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.345832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243656", "Detail": { "ID": 243656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3142601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254448", "Detail": { "ID": 254448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2565395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323488", "Detail": { "ID": 323488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9585354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300695", "Detail": { "ID": 300695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0096288+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273092", "Detail": { "ID": 273092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3692405+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262605", "Detail": { "ID": 262605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6090798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281792", "Detail": { "ID": 281792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1578004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298489", "Detail": { "ID": 298489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3483328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231142", "Detail": { "ID": 231142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3674204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284921", "Detail": { "ID": 284921, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0534237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219588", "Detail": { "ID": 219588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3058485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238229", "Detail": { "ID": 238229, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4373961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226698", "Detail": { "ID": 226698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2427264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321953", "Detail": { "ID": 321953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4585312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292659", "Detail": { "ID": 292659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5523219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227616", "Detail": { "ID": 227616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5577817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313307", "Detail": { "ID": 313307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3896617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257855", "Detail": { "ID": 257855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0805127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271053", "Detail": { "ID": 271053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8404977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274372", "Detail": { "ID": 274372, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1032075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287382", "Detail": { "ID": 287382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8618163+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250672", "Detail": { "ID": 250672, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2085573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221138", "Detail": { "ID": 221138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6766976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226476", "Detail": { "ID": 226476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2330582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252810", "Detail": { "ID": 252810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7542321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253231", "Detail": { "ID": 253231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9871358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324763", "Detail": { "ID": 324763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2368199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261616", "Detail": { "ID": 261616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3651431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239514", "Detail": { "ID": 239514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7470639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273571", "Detail": { "ID": 273571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6261259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304000", "Detail": { "ID": 304000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8450981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223176", "Detail": { "ID": 223176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2318995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245687", "Detail": { "ID": 245687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.85416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223364", "Detail": { "ID": 223364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4546895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307918", "Detail": { "ID": 307918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8565449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272407", "Detail": { "ID": 272407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.334005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245073", "Detail": { "ID": 245073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5908482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315242", "Detail": { "ID": 315242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9000626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247447", "Detail": { "ID": 247447, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4042057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275497", "Detail": { "ID": 275497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3778136+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255449", "Detail": { "ID": 255449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5318144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276902", "Detail": { "ID": 276902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6860167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253515", "Detail": { "ID": 253515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9997435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279191", "Detail": { "ID": 279191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2569448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325368", "Detail": { "ID": 325368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4956733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233300", "Detail": { "ID": 233300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1181146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311762", "Detail": { "ID": 311762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.893184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233204", "Detail": { "ID": 233204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1138287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267546", "Detail": { "ID": 267546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0245325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313398", "Detail": { "ID": 313398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3936607+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294428", "Detail": { "ID": 294428, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1378914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319202", "Detail": { "ID": 319202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9096122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306244", "Detail": { "ID": 306244, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5437339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310359", "Detail": { "ID": 310359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5671284+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268058", "Detail": { "ID": 268058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0541775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292998", "Detail": { "ID": 292998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5672451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271855", "Detail": { "ID": 271855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0943362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269819", "Detail": { "ID": 269819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5642895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307236", "Detail": { "ID": 307236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8205074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280171", "Detail": { "ID": 280171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5444781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279133", "Detail": { "ID": 279133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2544623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260448", "Detail": { "ID": 260448, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0773134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299329", "Detail": { "ID": 299329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6927802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301794", "Detail": { "ID": 301794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2835258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300323", "Detail": { "ID": 300323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9932339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224195", "Detail": { "ID": 224195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4966599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237940", "Detail": { "ID": 237940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2326512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305623", "Detail": { "ID": 305623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.332338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320068", "Detail": { "ID": 320068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9602952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315840", "Detail": { "ID": 315840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.929325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237093", "Detail": { "ID": 237093, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9655522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288877", "Detail": { "ID": 288877, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1622287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234276", "Detail": { "ID": 234276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3702913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313100", "Detail": { "ID": 313100, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1636479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261308", "Detail": { "ID": 261308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3517847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225577", "Detail": { "ID": 225577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9813346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265716", "Detail": { "ID": 265716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4512887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284212", "Detail": { "ID": 284212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0162963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252122", "Detail": { "ID": 252122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5035418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317290", "Detail": { "ID": 317290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4120507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256692", "Detail": { "ID": 256692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7936103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293365", "Detail": { "ID": 293365, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8418787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235879", "Detail": { "ID": 235879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6968719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258049", "Detail": { "ID": 258049, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0891564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228633", "Detail": { "ID": 228633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8075198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291047", "Detail": { "ID": 291047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7831968+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311523", "Detail": { "ID": 311523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8825164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246855", "Detail": { "ID": 246855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1562866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297632", "Detail": { "ID": 297632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.108532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234047", "Detail": { "ID": 234047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.164327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274932", "Detail": { "ID": 274932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1282618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270022", "Detail": { "ID": 270022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5781747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317708", "Detail": { "ID": 317708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4339882+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326462", "Detail": { "ID": 326462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7657293+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241339", "Detail": { "ID": 241339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7536714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290433", "Detail": { "ID": 290433, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7468902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248131", "Detail": { "ID": 248131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.444025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289197", "Detail": { "ID": 289197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4262974+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222667", "Detail": { "ID": 222667, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1987706+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306890", "Detail": { "ID": 306890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5779958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240936", "Detail": { "ID": 240936, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3887727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283990", "Detail": { "ID": 283990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7322184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231720", "Detail": { "ID": 231720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6126656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247307", "Detail": { "ID": 247307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3979501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308919", "Detail": { "ID": 308919, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2008, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 15, "VoteAgainst": 100, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504.1", "ID": 5647 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0837476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252773", "Detail": { "ID": 252773, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7526675+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259190", "Detail": { "ID": 259190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3455665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319542", "Detail": { "ID": 319542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.930435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249482", "Detail": { "ID": 249482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9287816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228397", "Detail": { "ID": 228397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7972527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281092", "Detail": { "ID": 281092, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8056654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262811", "Detail": { "ID": 262811, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.623961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288992", "Detail": { "ID": 288992, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1674023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230533", "Detail": { "ID": 230533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3344762+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269681", "Detail": { "ID": 269681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5584167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322512", "Detail": { "ID": 322512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6918028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295348", "Detail": { "ID": 295348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5083452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243028", "Detail": { "ID": 243028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0458305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227106", "Detail": { "ID": 227106, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2680127+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303076", "Detail": { "ID": 303076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5575784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244192", "Detail": { "ID": 244192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5438444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327043", "Detail": { "ID": 327043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7911338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277150", "Detail": { "ID": 277150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7032486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264024", "Detail": { "ID": 264024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9209337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248631", "Detail": { "ID": 248631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.663126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294884", "Detail": { "ID": 294884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1828787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285315", "Detail": { "ID": 285315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3177193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230791", "Detail": { "ID": 230791, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3456705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243690", "Detail": { "ID": 243690, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3156866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254452", "Detail": { "ID": 254452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2567335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323495", "Detail": { "ID": 323495, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9588261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290880", "Detail": { "ID": 290880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.776095+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273013", "Detail": { "ID": 273013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3657996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262548", "Detail": { "ID": 262548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6066508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281802", "Detail": { "ID": 281802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1582247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298479", "Detail": { "ID": 298479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.347902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231146", "Detail": { "ID": 231146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.367584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284927", "Detail": { "ID": 284927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0536925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219535", "Detail": { "ID": 219535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3035425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238238", "Detail": { "ID": 238238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4377701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225137", "Detail": { "ID": 225137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7460598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321948", "Detail": { "ID": 321948, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4583249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292663", "Detail": { "ID": 292663, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5524855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227260", "Detail": { "ID": 227260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5377714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313303", "Detail": { "ID": 313303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3894965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257800", "Detail": { "ID": 257800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0781538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271060", "Detail": { "ID": 271060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8407819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274381", "Detail": { "ID": 274381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1035977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287378", "Detail": { "ID": 287378, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.861654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250617", "Detail": { "ID": 250617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1972772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221080", "Detail": { "ID": 221080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6742187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220109", "Detail": { "ID": 220109, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3347192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252806", "Detail": { "ID": 252806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7540519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253240", "Detail": { "ID": 253240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9876493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324756", "Detail": { "ID": 324756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2365182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259422", "Detail": { "ID": 259422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6084208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239505", "Detail": { "ID": 239505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7466841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273650", "Detail": { "ID": 273650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6295081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304004", "Detail": { "ID": 304004, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8452601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221614", "Detail": { "ID": 221614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9403322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241845", "Detail": { "ID": 241845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7825111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223392", "Detail": { "ID": 223392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4558995+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307907", "Detail": { "ID": 307907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8560738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272352", "Detail": { "ID": 272352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3316359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245039", "Detail": { "ID": 245039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5893933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315237", "Detail": { "ID": 315237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8998348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247456", "Detail": { "ID": 247456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4045903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275491", "Detail": { "ID": 275491, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3775423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255458", "Detail": { "ID": 255458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5322009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276908", "Detail": { "ID": 276908, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6862779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253506", "Detail": { "ID": 253506, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9993726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276385", "Detail": { "ID": 276385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6633532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325375", "Detail": { "ID": 325375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4959883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233296", "Detail": { "ID": 233296, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1179371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311751", "Detail": { "ID": 311751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8926918+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229644", "Detail": { "ID": 229644, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0905596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267537", "Detail": { "ID": 267537, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0241053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313409", "Detail": { "ID": 313409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3941352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294438", "Detail": { "ID": 294438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1383266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319197", "Detail": { "ID": 319197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6966059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306281", "Detail": { "ID": 306281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5453065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310363", "Detail": { "ID": 310363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5672925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268067", "Detail": { "ID": 268067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0545692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292988", "Detail": { "ID": 292988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5668184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258519", "Detail": { "ID": 258519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3107379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263590", "Detail": { "ID": 263590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8959475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307232", "Detail": { "ID": 307232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8203426+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280115", "Detail": { "ID": 280115, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5420916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279523", "Detail": { "ID": 279523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5113757+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260481", "Detail": { "ID": 260481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0787484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299339", "Detail": { "ID": 299339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6932088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301790", "Detail": { "ID": 301790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2833622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300481", "Detail": { "ID": 300481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0000473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223984", "Detail": { "ID": 223984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4870328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237935", "Detail": { "ID": 237935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2324277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305586", "Detail": { "ID": 305586, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3307648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320073", "Detail": { "ID": 320073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9605097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315845", "Detail": { "ID": 315845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9295307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237089", "Detail": { "ID": 237089, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9653934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289726", "Detail": { "ID": 289726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4565123+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234280", "Detail": { "ID": 234280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3704584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313105", "Detail": { "ID": 313105, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1638544+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261304", "Detail": { "ID": 261304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3516212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225395", "Detail": { "ID": 225395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9728701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265720", "Detail": { "ID": 265720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4515677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283024", "Detail": { "ID": 283024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4444969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252069", "Detail": { "ID": 252069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5012339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317295", "Detail": { "ID": 317295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4122759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254234", "Detail": { "ID": 254234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2467281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293361", "Detail": { "ID": 293361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8417116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235515", "Detail": { "ID": 235515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6811514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258045", "Detail": { "ID": 258045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0889408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228577", "Detail": { "ID": 228577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.805096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291051", "Detail": { "ID": 291051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7833593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311487", "Detail": { "ID": 311487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8809594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246800", "Detail": { "ID": 246800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1539427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298019", "Detail": { "ID": 298019, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1348019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234051", "Detail": { "ID": 234051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1645268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274876", "Detail": { "ID": 274876, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.125813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270013", "Detail": { "ID": 270013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.577777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317703", "Detail": { "ID": 317703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4337674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326455", "Detail": { "ID": 326455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7654449+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241283", "Detail": { "ID": 241283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7512605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290398", "Detail": { "ID": 290398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7453743+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248078", "Detail": { "ID": 248078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4410399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287531", "Detail": { "ID": 287531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8749977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222639", "Detail": { "ID": 222639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1975694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306894", "Detail": { "ID": 306894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5781621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239841", "Detail": { "ID": 239841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7612007+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283984", "Detail": { "ID": 283984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7319683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231724", "Detail": { "ID": 231724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6128256+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237325", "Detail": { "ID": 237325, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1993368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308930", "Detail": { "ID": 308930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2004, "AgendaID": 2666, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 100, "VoteAgainst": 15, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Cost of Living", "Reference": "S4M-05504", "ID": 5635 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-30T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0842166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252628", "Detail": { "ID": 252628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7376596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258835", "Detail": { "ID": 258835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3299596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319863", "Detail": { "ID": 319863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9446427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249632", "Detail": { "ID": 249632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9430961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227733", "Detail": { "ID": 227733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5633099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280734", "Detail": { "ID": 280734, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7801672+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262518", "Detail": { "ID": 262518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6053843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288065", "Detail": { "ID": 288065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8985526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230504", "Detail": { "ID": 230504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3330206+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270192", "Detail": { "ID": 270192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5855032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322699", "Detail": { "ID": 322699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6998939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294749", "Detail": { "ID": 294749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1766787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242859", "Detail": { "ID": 242859, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0386701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235565", "Detail": { "ID": 235565, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6832732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302453", "Detail": { "ID": 302453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5252453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244482", "Detail": { "ID": 244482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5566792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327205", "Detail": { "ID": 327205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0255858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276701", "Detail": { "ID": 276701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6774242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264316", "Detail": { "ID": 264316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1281175+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248800", "Detail": { "ID": 248800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6705959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295793", "Detail": { "ID": 295793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5361233+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285178", "Detail": { "ID": 285178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0697971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230656", "Detail": { "ID": 230656, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3395691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243860", "Detail": { "ID": 243860, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3230119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254481", "Detail": { "ID": 254481, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2579816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323812", "Detail": { "ID": 323812, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9729744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291359", "Detail": { "ID": 291359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1159145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265350", "Detail": { "ID": 265350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4353993+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262225", "Detail": { "ID": 262225, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5923275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282007", "Detail": { "ID": 282007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1671907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297966", "Detail": { "ID": 297966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1325684+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231163", "Detail": { "ID": 231163, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3682901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285962", "Detail": { "ID": 285962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3520357+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219364", "Detail": { "ID": 219364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2954209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238592", "Detail": { "ID": 238592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4607511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225438", "Detail": { "ID": 225438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.974725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321760", "Detail": { "ID": 321760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4502205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292697", "Detail": { "ID": 292697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5539508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226932", "Detail": { "ID": 226932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2531907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313274", "Detail": { "ID": 313274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3882413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257187", "Detail": { "ID": 257187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.827056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271318", "Detail": { "ID": 271318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0703217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278451", "Detail": { "ID": 278451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2193771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287349", "Detail": { "ID": 287349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8604011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250465", "Detail": { "ID": 250465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1907138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220933", "Detail": { "ID": 220933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6678954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220281", "Detail": { "ID": 220281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6316775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252473", "Detail": { "ID": 252473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7306558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266138", "Detail": { "ID": 266138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4759713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324593", "Detail": { "ID": 324593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2296421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259902", "Detail": { "ID": 259902, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6349688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239305", "Detail": { "ID": 239305, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7310946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273787", "Detail": { "ID": 273787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6356246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304033", "Detail": { "ID": 304033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8465016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221762", "Detail": { "ID": 221762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9467005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241995", "Detail": { "ID": 241995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7892804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223724", "Detail": { "ID": 223724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4710484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307550", "Detail": { "ID": 307550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8343555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272204", "Detail": { "ID": 272204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3194464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244867", "Detail": { "ID": 244867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5820205+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315069", "Detail": { "ID": 315069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6727382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247963", "Detail": { "ID": 247963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4358772+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274768", "Detail": { "ID": 274768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1209105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255813", "Detail": { "ID": 255813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5581761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277477", "Detail": { "ID": 277477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9550453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252999", "Detail": { "ID": 252999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7625034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277175", "Detail": { "ID": 277175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7043126+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325538", "Detail": { "ID": 325538, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5106738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233276", "Detail": { "ID": 233276, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1170367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311397", "Detail": { "ID": 311397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8769677+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230435", "Detail": { "ID": 230435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3296952+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267333", "Detail": { "ID": 267333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0149155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313764", "Detail": { "ID": 313764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4096509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295416", "Detail": { "ID": 295416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5112349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319010", "Detail": { "ID": 319010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6885495+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306417", "Detail": { "ID": 306417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5511875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310397", "Detail": { "ID": 310397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5687567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268270", "Detail": { "ID": 268270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2598297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286145", "Detail": { "ID": 286145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3658334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260680", "Detail": { "ID": 260680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0876457+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264069", "Detail": { "ID": 264069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9228532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308788", "Detail": { "ID": 308788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0712823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279334", "Detail": { "ID": 279334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4976881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279969", "Detail": { "ID": 279969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5306364+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261121", "Detail": { "ID": 261121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1127168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299697", "Detail": { "ID": 299697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7187025+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306819", "Detail": { "ID": 306819, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5750752+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300515", "Detail": { "ID": 300515, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0016183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223682", "Detail": { "ID": 223682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4692734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237477", "Detail": { "ID": 237477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2122819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305450", "Detail": { "ID": 305450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3245502+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320416", "Detail": { "ID": 320416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1654801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316013", "Detail": { "ID": 316013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9420938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236641", "Detail": { "ID": 236641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9337567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291403", "Detail": { "ID": 291403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.117812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234309", "Detail": { "ID": 234309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3717164+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313583", "Detail": { "ID": 313583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.401649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290192", "Detail": { "ID": 290192, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4830302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225061", "Detail": { "ID": 225061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7428425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265749", "Detail": { "ID": 265749, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4528306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283350", "Detail": { "ID": 283350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6969125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251439", "Detail": { "ID": 251439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4636621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317636", "Detail": { "ID": 317636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4309412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254698", "Detail": { "ID": 254698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2798864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296324", "Detail": { "ID": 296324, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8441149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234882", "Detail": { "ID": 234882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4038117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257706", "Detail": { "ID": 257706, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0680585+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228121", "Detail": { "ID": 228121, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5852657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291080", "Detail": { "ID": 291080, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7846038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311038", "Detail": { "ID": 311038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6027665+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246342", "Detail": { "ID": 246342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1245953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298156", "Detail": { "ID": 298156, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1406234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234341", "Detail": { "ID": 234341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3731031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274552", "Detail": { "ID": 274552, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1115455+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269500", "Detail": { "ID": 269500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5502991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317380", "Detail": { "ID": 317380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4196219+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326292", "Detail": { "ID": 326292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7521674+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241133", "Detail": { "ID": 241133, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4034621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289612", "Detail": { "ID": 289612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.45152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247756", "Detail": { "ID": 247756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4270694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284874", "Detail": { "ID": 284874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0514347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222463", "Detail": { "ID": 222463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1900347+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306928", "Detail": { "ID": 306928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5799216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239990", "Detail": { "ID": 239990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.768009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283419", "Detail": { "ID": 283419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6998895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232231", "Detail": { "ID": 232231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8457902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237797", "Detail": { "ID": 237797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2264986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309288", "Detail": { "ID": 309288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2003, "AgendaID": 2782, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 62, "VoteAgainst": 53, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05479", "ID": 5608 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-29T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.322867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252318", "Detail": { "ID": 252318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7239781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258833", "Detail": { "ID": 258833, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3298592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319895", "Detail": { "ID": 319895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9460246+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249634", "Detail": { "ID": 249634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9431777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227731", "Detail": { "ID": 227731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5632282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280732", "Detail": { "ID": 280732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7800867+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262517", "Detail": { "ID": 262517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6053421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288067", "Detail": { "ID": 288067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8986366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229719", "Detail": { "ID": 229719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0937234+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270194", "Detail": { "ID": 270194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5855864+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322697", "Detail": { "ID": 322697, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6997939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294748", "Detail": { "ID": 294748, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1766369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242857", "Detail": { "ID": 242857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0385886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235567", "Detail": { "ID": 235567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6833557+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302127", "Detail": { "ID": 302127, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2982218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244483", "Detail": { "ID": 244483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5567215+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327236", "Detail": { "ID": 327236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0271159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276700", "Detail": { "ID": 276700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6773827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264317", "Detail": { "ID": 264317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1282958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248802", "Detail": { "ID": 248802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6706782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295826", "Detail": { "ID": 295826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5375173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285177", "Detail": { "ID": 285177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0697555+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230172", "Detail": { "ID": 230172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1193327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243862", "Detail": { "ID": 243862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3231113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255269", "Detail": { "ID": 255269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5236479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323871", "Detail": { "ID": 323871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.975976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291361", "Detail": { "ID": 291361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1159982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265349", "Detail": { "ID": 265349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4353498+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262223", "Detail": { "ID": 262223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5922441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282009", "Detail": { "ID": 282009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1672726+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297964", "Detail": { "ID": 297964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1324862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231625", "Detail": { "ID": 231625, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6086558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285960", "Detail": { "ID": 285960, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3519536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219362", "Detail": { "ID": 219362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2953384+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238594", "Detail": { "ID": 238594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4608508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225440", "Detail": { "ID": 225440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9748326+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321762", "Detail": { "ID": 321762, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4503017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292699", "Detail": { "ID": 292699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5540354+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226930", "Detail": { "ID": 226930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2530782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312643", "Detail": { "ID": 312643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.137138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257185", "Detail": { "ID": 257185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.826972+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271316", "Detail": { "ID": 271316, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.070238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278453", "Detail": { "ID": 278453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2194613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286716", "Detail": { "ID": 286716, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5976666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250463", "Detail": { "ID": 250463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1906313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220931", "Detail": { "ID": 220931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6678119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220283", "Detail": { "ID": 220283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6317608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251844", "Detail": { "ID": 251844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4915732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266140", "Detail": { "ID": 266140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4760531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324562", "Detail": { "ID": 324562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2283238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259904", "Detail": { "ID": 259904, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6350514+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239303", "Detail": { "ID": 239303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7309913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273788", "Detail": { "ID": 273788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6356856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304202", "Detail": { "ID": 304202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0281074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221764", "Detail": { "ID": 221764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9468096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241997", "Detail": { "ID": 241997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7893838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223726", "Detail": { "ID": 223726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.471131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307548", "Detail": { "ID": 307548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8342725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272202", "Detail": { "ID": 272202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3192886+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244865", "Detail": { "ID": 244865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5819387+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315037", "Detail": { "ID": 315037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6713596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247965", "Detail": { "ID": 247965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4359592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274770", "Detail": { "ID": 274770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1209934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255815", "Detail": { "ID": 255815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5582578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277475", "Detail": { "ID": 277475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9549629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252997", "Detail": { "ID": 252997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7623982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277177", "Detail": { "ID": 277177, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7043957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325569", "Detail": { "ID": 325569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5119936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232809", "Detail": { "ID": 232809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8771713+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311395", "Detail": { "ID": 311395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8768828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230437", "Detail": { "ID": 230437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3297787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267331", "Detail": { "ID": 267331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0148318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313766", "Detail": { "ID": 313766, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4097416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295418", "Detail": { "ID": 295418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5113167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319012", "Detail": { "ID": 319012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6886511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306450", "Detail": { "ID": 306450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5526036+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310399", "Detail": { "ID": 310399, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5688399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268272", "Detail": { "ID": 268272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.259916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286143", "Detail": { "ID": 286143, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3657504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260682", "Detail": { "ID": 260682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0877302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264071", "Detail": { "ID": 264071, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9229545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308786", "Detail": { "ID": 308786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0711641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279332", "Detail": { "ID": 279332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4976058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279970", "Detail": { "ID": 279970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5306779+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261123", "Detail": { "ID": 261123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1128191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299699", "Detail": { "ID": 299699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7187852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306817", "Detail": { "ID": 306817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5749702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300517", "Detail": { "ID": 300517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0017013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223680", "Detail": { "ID": 223680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4691922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237475", "Detail": { "ID": 237475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2121973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305417", "Detail": { "ID": 305417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.323124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320414", "Detail": { "ID": 320414, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1653778+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316045", "Detail": { "ID": 316045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9435448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236640", "Detail": { "ID": 236640, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9337156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291404", "Detail": { "ID": 291404, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1178534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234938", "Detail": { "ID": 234938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4063337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313615", "Detail": { "ID": 313615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4030289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290190", "Detail": { "ID": 290190, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4829476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225059", "Detail": { "ID": 225059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.742742+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265916", "Detail": { "ID": 265916, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4660991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283352", "Detail": { "ID": 283352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6969954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251437", "Detail": { "ID": 251437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4635588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317634", "Detail": { "ID": 317634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4308586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254700", "Detail": { "ID": 254700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2799719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296322", "Detail": { "ID": 296322, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8440131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234880", "Detail": { "ID": 234880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4037294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257384", "Detail": { "ID": 257384, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0538739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228119", "Detail": { "ID": 228119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5851825+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292024", "Detail": { "ID": 292024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1525923+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310694", "Detail": { "ID": 310694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5820278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246340", "Detail": { "ID": 246340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1245114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298157", "Detail": { "ID": 298157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1406656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234366", "Detail": { "ID": 234366, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.374172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274550", "Detail": { "ID": 274550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1114413+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269498", "Detail": { "ID": 269498, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5502155+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317195", "Detail": { "ID": 317195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1857694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326261", "Detail": { "ID": 326261, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7508237+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241131", "Detail": { "ID": 241131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4033793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289610", "Detail": { "ID": 289610, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4514388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247754", "Detail": { "ID": 247754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4269857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284872", "Detail": { "ID": 284872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0513333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222461", "Detail": { "ID": 222461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1899523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306930", "Detail": { "ID": 306930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5800047+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240146", "Detail": { "ID": 240146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7809351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283421", "Detail": { "ID": 283421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6999735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232233", "Detail": { "ID": 232233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8458958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237799", "Detail": { "ID": 237799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309290", "Detail": { "ID": 309290, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2001, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 60, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.2", "ID": 5586 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3229503+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252319", "Detail": { "ID": 252319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7240188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258834", "Detail": { "ID": 258834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3299001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319894", "Detail": { "ID": 319894, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9459821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249633", "Detail": { "ID": 249633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.943137+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227732", "Detail": { "ID": 227732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5632692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280733", "Detail": { "ID": 280733, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7801269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262516", "Detail": { "ID": 262516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6052824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288066", "Detail": { "ID": 288066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8985954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229721", "Detail": { "ID": 229721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0938037+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270193", "Detail": { "ID": 270193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5855446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322698", "Detail": { "ID": 322698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6998346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294747", "Detail": { "ID": 294747, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1765942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242858", "Detail": { "ID": 242858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0386296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235566", "Detail": { "ID": 235566, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6833146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302451", "Detail": { "ID": 302451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5251425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244484", "Detail": { "ID": 244484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5567638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327237", "Detail": { "ID": 327237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0271579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276699", "Detail": { "ID": 276699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6773423+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264318", "Detail": { "ID": 264318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1283456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248801", "Detail": { "ID": 248801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6706369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295825", "Detail": { "ID": 295825, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.537476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285176", "Detail": { "ID": 285176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0697105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230655", "Detail": { "ID": 230655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3395277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243861", "Detail": { "ID": 243861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3230524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254483", "Detail": { "ID": 254483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2580843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323872", "Detail": { "ID": 323872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9760194+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291360", "Detail": { "ID": 291360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.115957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265348", "Detail": { "ID": 265348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4352871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262224", "Detail": { "ID": 262224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5922857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282008", "Detail": { "ID": 282008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1672317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297965", "Detail": { "ID": 297965, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1325278+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231623", "Detail": { "ID": 231623, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6085736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285961", "Detail": { "ID": 285961, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3519945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219363", "Detail": { "ID": 219363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2953796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238593", "Detail": { "ID": 238593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4607925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225439", "Detail": { "ID": 225439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9747662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321761", "Detail": { "ID": 321761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4502611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292698", "Detail": { "ID": 292698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.553994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226931", "Detail": { "ID": 226931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.253146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313272", "Detail": { "ID": 313272, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3881584+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257186", "Detail": { "ID": 257186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8270142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271317", "Detail": { "ID": 271317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.07028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278452", "Detail": { "ID": 278452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2194196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287347", "Detail": { "ID": 287347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8603058+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250464", "Detail": { "ID": 250464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1906723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220932", "Detail": { "ID": 220932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6678533+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220282", "Detail": { "ID": 220282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6317192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252471", "Detail": { "ID": 252471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7305734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266139", "Detail": { "ID": 266139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.476012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324561", "Detail": { "ID": 324561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2282834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259903", "Detail": { "ID": 259903, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6350102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239304", "Detail": { "ID": 239304, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7310523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273789", "Detail": { "ID": 273789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6357294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304035", "Detail": { "ID": 304035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8465838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221763", "Detail": { "ID": 221763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9467638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241996", "Detail": { "ID": 241996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7893411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223725", "Detail": { "ID": 223725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4710903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307549", "Detail": { "ID": 307549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8343134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272203", "Detail": { "ID": 272203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3193403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244866", "Detail": { "ID": 244866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5819792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315038", "Detail": { "ID": 315038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.671401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247964", "Detail": { "ID": 247964, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4359183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274769", "Detail": { "ID": 274769, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1209516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255814", "Detail": { "ID": 255814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.558217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277476", "Detail": { "ID": 277476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9550032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252998", "Detail": { "ID": 252998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7624612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277176", "Detail": { "ID": 277176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7043545+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325570", "Detail": { "ID": 325570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5120345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232810", "Detail": { "ID": 232810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8772124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311396", "Detail": { "ID": 311396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8769255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230436", "Detail": { "ID": 230436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3297368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267332", "Detail": { "ID": 267332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.014874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313765", "Detail": { "ID": 313765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4096928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295417", "Detail": { "ID": 295417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5112758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319011", "Detail": { "ID": 319011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.688591+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306449", "Detail": { "ID": 306449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5525621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310398", "Detail": { "ID": 310398, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5687986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268271", "Detail": { "ID": 268271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2598719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286144", "Detail": { "ID": 286144, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3657916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260681", "Detail": { "ID": 260681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0876892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264070", "Detail": { "ID": 264070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.922912+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308787", "Detail": { "ID": 308787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.071209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279333", "Detail": { "ID": 279333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4976468+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279971", "Detail": { "ID": 279971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5307193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261122", "Detail": { "ID": 261122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1127767+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299698", "Detail": { "ID": 299698, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7187442+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306818", "Detail": { "ID": 306818, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5750114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300516", "Detail": { "ID": 300516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0016597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223681", "Detail": { "ID": 223681, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4692327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237476", "Detail": { "ID": 237476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2122388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305418", "Detail": { "ID": 305418, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3231657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320415", "Detail": { "ID": 320415, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1654377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316044", "Detail": { "ID": 316044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.943418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236639", "Detail": { "ID": 236639, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9336737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291405", "Detail": { "ID": 291405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.117895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234311", "Detail": { "ID": 234311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.371801+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313614", "Detail": { "ID": 313614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4029877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290191", "Detail": { "ID": 290191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4829892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225060", "Detail": { "ID": 225060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7428012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265751", "Detail": { "ID": 265751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4529141+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283351", "Detail": { "ID": 283351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6969538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251438", "Detail": { "ID": 251438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4636006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317635", "Detail": { "ID": 317635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4308996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254699", "Detail": { "ID": 254699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2799297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296323", "Detail": { "ID": 296323, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8440723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234881", "Detail": { "ID": 234881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4037704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257704", "Detail": { "ID": 257704, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0679758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228120", "Detail": { "ID": 228120, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5852249+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291082", "Detail": { "ID": 291082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7846862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310695", "Detail": { "ID": 310695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5820697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246341", "Detail": { "ID": 246341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1245536+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298158", "Detail": { "ID": 298158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1407064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234342", "Detail": { "ID": 234342, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3731451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274551", "Detail": { "ID": 274551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1115022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269499", "Detail": { "ID": 269499, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5502568+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317196", "Detail": { "ID": 317196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1858104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326260", "Detail": { "ID": 326260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7507828+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241132", "Detail": { "ID": 241132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4034203+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289611", "Detail": { "ID": 289611, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4514793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247755", "Detail": { "ID": 247755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4270281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284873", "Detail": { "ID": 284873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0513932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222462", "Detail": { "ID": 222462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1899939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306929", "Detail": { "ID": 306929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5799637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240145", "Detail": { "ID": 240145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7808926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283420", "Detail": { "ID": 283420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.699931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232232", "Detail": { "ID": 232232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8458519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237798", "Detail": { "ID": 237798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2265575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309289", "Detail": { "ID": 309289, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2002, "AgendaID": 2582, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 51, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Scotland’s Mental Health Strategy", "Reference": "S4M-05444.1", "ID": 5585 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-24T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3229088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252741", "Detail": { "ID": 252741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7513242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259186", "Detail": { "ID": 259186, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3454039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319578", "Detail": { "ID": 319578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.932079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249486", "Detail": { "ID": 249486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9289435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227866", "Detail": { "ID": 227866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5690279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280867", "Detail": { "ID": 280867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7857685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262807", "Detail": { "ID": 262807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.623797+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288990", "Detail": { "ID": 288990, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1673193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230529", "Detail": { "ID": 230529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3343045+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269685", "Detail": { "ID": 269685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5586012+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322591", "Detail": { "ID": 322591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6953133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295344", "Detail": { "ID": 295344, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5081587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243024", "Detail": { "ID": 243024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0456593+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235083", "Detail": { "ID": 235083, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.418639+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302478", "Detail": { "ID": 302478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.526307+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244196", "Detail": { "ID": 244196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5440549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327073", "Detail": { "ID": 327073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7976775+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277146", "Detail": { "ID": 277146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7030655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264028", "Detail": { "ID": 264028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9211171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248635", "Detail": { "ID": 248635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6633088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294888", "Detail": { "ID": 294888, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1830612+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285311", "Detail": { "ID": 285311, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3175335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230787", "Detail": { "ID": 230787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3455098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243694", "Detail": { "ID": 243694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3158452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254456", "Detail": { "ID": 254456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2569001+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323526", "Detail": { "ID": 323526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.960182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290884", "Detail": { "ID": 290884, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7762547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273009", "Detail": { "ID": 273009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3654241+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262544", "Detail": { "ID": 262544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6064887+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281872", "Detail": { "ID": 281872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.161236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298255", "Detail": { "ID": 298255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3378816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231150", "Detail": { "ID": 231150, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3677451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284929", "Detail": { "ID": 284929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0537793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219531", "Detail": { "ID": 219531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3033761+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238242", "Detail": { "ID": 238242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4379543+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225141", "Detail": { "ID": 225141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7462218+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321869", "Detail": { "ID": 321869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4548419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292786", "Detail": { "ID": 292786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5580855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227256", "Detail": { "ID": 227256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5376065+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313299", "Detail": { "ID": 313299, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.389314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257796", "Detail": { "ID": 257796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0779725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271062", "Detail": { "ID": 271062, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8408628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278010", "Detail": { "ID": 278010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9831111+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287374", "Detail": { "ID": 287374, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8614894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250613", "Detail": { "ID": 250613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1971148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221076", "Detail": { "ID": 221076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6740532+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220113", "Detail": { "ID": 220113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3348844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252802", "Detail": { "ID": 252802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7538909+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253779", "Detail": { "ID": 253779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0205583+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324725", "Detail": { "ID": 324725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2352107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259426", "Detail": { "ID": 259426, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6086023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239501", "Detail": { "ID": 239501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7465254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273654", "Detail": { "ID": 273654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6296721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304008", "Detail": { "ID": 304008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8454433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221618", "Detail": { "ID": 221618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9404962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241849", "Detail": { "ID": 241849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7826933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223396", "Detail": { "ID": 223396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4560636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307838", "Detail": { "ID": 307838, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8530902+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272348", "Detail": { "ID": 272348, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3314739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245035", "Detail": { "ID": 245035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.58921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315201", "Detail": { "ID": 315201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6786705+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247460", "Detail": { "ID": 247460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4047524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275489", "Detail": { "ID": 275489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3774606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255462", "Detail": { "ID": 255462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5323803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276910", "Detail": { "ID": 276910, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6863618+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253502", "Detail": { "ID": 253502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9991906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276389", "Detail": { "ID": 276389, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6635171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325406", "Detail": { "ID": 325406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4973251+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233292", "Detail": { "ID": 233292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1177103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311683", "Detail": { "ID": 311683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8897605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229648", "Detail": { "ID": 229648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0907202+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267465", "Detail": { "ID": 267465, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0210066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313478", "Detail": { "ID": 313478, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3971006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294973", "Detail": { "ID": 294973, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1867029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319118", "Detail": { "ID": 319118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6932118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306285", "Detail": { "ID": 306285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5454903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310788", "Detail": { "ID": 310788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5860722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268139", "Detail": { "ID": 268139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0578803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286436", "Detail": { "ID": 286436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5791096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258523", "Detail": { "ID": 258523, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.310924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263594", "Detail": { "ID": 263594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8961922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308544", "Detail": { "ID": 308544, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0604798+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280111", "Detail": { "ID": 280111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5419075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279527", "Detail": { "ID": 279527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5115388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260485", "Detail": { "ID": 260485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0789146+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299563", "Detail": { "ID": 299563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7028255+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306730", "Detail": { "ID": 306730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.564941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300604", "Detail": { "ID": 300604, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0057647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223980", "Detail": { "ID": 223980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4868516+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237931", "Detail": { "ID": 237931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2322647+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305582", "Detail": { "ID": 305582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3305843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320308", "Detail": { "ID": 320308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1544104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315881", "Detail": { "ID": 315881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9312493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236775", "Detail": { "ID": 236775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9395319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289730", "Detail": { "ID": 289730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4566925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234284", "Detail": { "ID": 234284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3706409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313140", "Detail": { "ID": 313140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1653881+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289334", "Detail": { "ID": 289334, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4327793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225391", "Detail": { "ID": 225391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9727068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265724", "Detail": { "ID": 265724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4517324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283028", "Detail": { "ID": 283028, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4446592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252065", "Detail": { "ID": 252065, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5010509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317529", "Detail": { "ID": 317529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4263723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254238", "Detail": { "ID": 254238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2469156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296235", "Detail": { "ID": 296235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8398808+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235511", "Detail": { "ID": 235511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6809696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258041", "Detail": { "ID": 258041, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.088758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228573", "Detail": { "ID": 228573, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.804933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291055", "Detail": { "ID": 291055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7835433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311171", "Detail": { "ID": 311171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6087735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246796", "Detail": { "ID": 246796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1537817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298023", "Detail": { "ID": 298023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1349666+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234055", "Detail": { "ID": 234055, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1646933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274872", "Detail": { "ID": 274872, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1256485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269631", "Detail": { "ID": 269631, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5562378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317512", "Detail": { "ID": 317512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4256102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326424", "Detail": { "ID": 326424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7581223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241279", "Detail": { "ID": 241279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7510961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290394", "Detail": { "ID": 290394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7452116+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248074", "Detail": { "ID": 248074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4407428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287527", "Detail": { "ID": 287527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8748122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222635", "Detail": { "ID": 222635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1974063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306975", "Detail": { "ID": 306975, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5819322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239845", "Detail": { "ID": 239845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7613861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283982", "Detail": { "ID": 283982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7318856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231795", "Detail": { "ID": 231795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6158627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237329", "Detail": { "ID": 237329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1995009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308999", "Detail": { "ID": 308999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1997, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 13, "VoteAgainst": 108, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.3", "ID": 5571 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0871646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252742", "Detail": { "ID": 252742, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7513839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259187", "Detail": { "ID": 259187, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3454456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319577", "Detail": { "ID": 319577, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9320236+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249485", "Detail": { "ID": 249485, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9289033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227867", "Detail": { "ID": 227867, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5690687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280868", "Detail": { "ID": 280868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7858082+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262808", "Detail": { "ID": 262808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6238383+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288989", "Detail": { "ID": 288989, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1672787+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230530", "Detail": { "ID": 230530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3343489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269684", "Detail": { "ID": 269684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5585601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322592", "Detail": { "ID": 322592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6953549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295345", "Detail": { "ID": 295345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5081988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243025", "Detail": { "ID": 243025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0457006+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235082", "Detail": { "ID": 235082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4185978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302479", "Detail": { "ID": 302479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5263476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244195", "Detail": { "ID": 244195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5440031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327074", "Detail": { "ID": 327074, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7977183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277147", "Detail": { "ID": 277147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7031066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264027", "Detail": { "ID": 264027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9210745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248634", "Detail": { "ID": 248634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6632688+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294887", "Detail": { "ID": 294887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1830014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285312", "Detail": { "ID": 285312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3175937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230788", "Detail": { "ID": 230788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3455496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243693", "Detail": { "ID": 243693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3158057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254455", "Detail": { "ID": 254455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2568589+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323527", "Detail": { "ID": 323527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9602228+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290883", "Detail": { "ID": 290883, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7762148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273010", "Detail": { "ID": 273010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.365465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262545", "Detail": { "ID": 262545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6065291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281871", "Detail": { "ID": 281871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1611768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298256", "Detail": { "ID": 298256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3379226+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231149", "Detail": { "ID": 231149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3677048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284930", "Detail": { "ID": 284930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0538208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219532", "Detail": { "ID": 219532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3034173+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238241", "Detail": { "ID": 238241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.437913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225140", "Detail": { "ID": 225140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7461816+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321868", "Detail": { "ID": 321868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4548009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292785", "Detail": { "ID": 292785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5580456+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227257", "Detail": { "ID": 227257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5376483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313300", "Detail": { "ID": 313300, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3893734+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257797", "Detail": { "ID": 257797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0780134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271063", "Detail": { "ID": 271063, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8409031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278009", "Detail": { "ID": 278009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9830702+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287375", "Detail": { "ID": 287375, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8615314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250614", "Detail": { "ID": 250614, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1971548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221077", "Detail": { "ID": 221077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6740963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220112", "Detail": { "ID": 220112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3348425+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252803", "Detail": { "ID": 252803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7539313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253778", "Detail": { "ID": 253778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0205187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324724", "Detail": { "ID": 324724, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2351707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259425", "Detail": { "ID": 259425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6085434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239502", "Detail": { "ID": 239502, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7465651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273653", "Detail": { "ID": 273653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6296313+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304007", "Detail": { "ID": 304007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.845403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221617", "Detail": { "ID": 221617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9404552+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241848", "Detail": { "ID": 241848, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7826525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223395", "Detail": { "ID": 223395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4560231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307839", "Detail": { "ID": 307839, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8531314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272349", "Detail": { "ID": 272349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.331515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245036", "Detail": { "ID": 245036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5892687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315202", "Detail": { "ID": 315202, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8982342+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247459", "Detail": { "ID": 247459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4047122+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275488", "Detail": { "ID": 275488, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3774195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255461", "Detail": { "ID": 255461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5323221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276911", "Detail": { "ID": 276911, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6864026+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253503", "Detail": { "ID": 253503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9992315+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276388", "Detail": { "ID": 276388, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6634765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325407", "Detail": { "ID": 325407, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4973679+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233293", "Detail": { "ID": 233293, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.117751+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311684", "Detail": { "ID": 311684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8898027+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229647", "Detail": { "ID": 229647, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.09068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267466", "Detail": { "ID": 267466, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0210466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313477", "Detail": { "ID": 313477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3970597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294972", "Detail": { "ID": 294972, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1866624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319117", "Detail": { "ID": 319117, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6931714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306284", "Detail": { "ID": 306284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5454493+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310787", "Detail": { "ID": 310787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.586031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268138", "Detail": { "ID": 268138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0578374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286437", "Detail": { "ID": 286437, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.579158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258522", "Detail": { "ID": 258522, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3108818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263593", "Detail": { "ID": 263593, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8960708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308545", "Detail": { "ID": 308545, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0605201+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280112", "Detail": { "ID": 280112, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5419484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279526", "Detail": { "ID": 279526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5114985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260484", "Detail": { "ID": 260484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0788731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299562", "Detail": { "ID": 299562, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7027842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306731", "Detail": { "ID": 306731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5649819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300603", "Detail": { "ID": 300603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0057243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223981", "Detail": { "ID": 223981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4868921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237932", "Detail": { "ID": 237932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2323051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305583", "Detail": { "ID": 305583, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3306247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320309", "Detail": { "ID": 320309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1544515+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315880", "Detail": { "ID": 315880, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9311859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236776", "Detail": { "ID": 236776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9395727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289729", "Detail": { "ID": 289729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4566519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234283", "Detail": { "ID": 234283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3705806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313139", "Detail": { "ID": 313139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1653461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289335", "Detail": { "ID": 289335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4328401+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225392", "Detail": { "ID": 225392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9727471+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265723", "Detail": { "ID": 265723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4516916+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283027", "Detail": { "ID": 283027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4446187+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252066", "Detail": { "ID": 252066, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5011109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317530", "Detail": { "ID": 317530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4264134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254237", "Detail": { "ID": 254237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2468529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296236", "Detail": { "ID": 296236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8399232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235512", "Detail": { "ID": 235512, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6810099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258042", "Detail": { "ID": 258042, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0888182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228574", "Detail": { "ID": 228574, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8049736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291054", "Detail": { "ID": 291054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7835024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311172", "Detail": { "ID": 311172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6088139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246797", "Detail": { "ID": 246797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1538221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298022", "Detail": { "ID": 298022, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1349254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234054", "Detail": { "ID": 234054, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1646513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274873", "Detail": { "ID": 274873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1256901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269632", "Detail": { "ID": 269632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5562786+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317513", "Detail": { "ID": 317513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4256522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326423", "Detail": { "ID": 326423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7580805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241280", "Detail": { "ID": 241280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.751138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290395", "Detail": { "ID": 290395, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7452524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248075", "Detail": { "ID": 248075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4407837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287528", "Detail": { "ID": 287528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8748727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222636", "Detail": { "ID": 222636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1974466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306974", "Detail": { "ID": 306974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5818917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239844", "Detail": { "ID": 239844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.761344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283981", "Detail": { "ID": 283981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7318443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231794", "Detail": { "ID": 231794, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6158014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237328", "Detail": { "ID": 237328, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.19946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308998", "Detail": { "ID": 308998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1998, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 35, "VoteAgainst": 84, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.2", "ID": 5567 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0871239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252744", "Detail": { "ID": 252744, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7514657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259189", "Detail": { "ID": 259189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3455264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319575", "Detail": { "ID": 319575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9318497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249483", "Detail": { "ID": 249483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9288223+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227869", "Detail": { "ID": 227869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5691511+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280870", "Detail": { "ID": 280870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7858868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262810", "Detail": { "ID": 262810, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6239204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288993", "Detail": { "ID": 288993, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1674437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230532", "Detail": { "ID": 230532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3344335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269682", "Detail": { "ID": 269682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.558458+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322571", "Detail": { "ID": 322571, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6944421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295347", "Detail": { "ID": 295347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.508305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243027", "Detail": { "ID": 243027, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0457897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227107", "Detail": { "ID": 227107, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2680827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303075", "Detail": { "ID": 303075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5575372+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244193", "Detail": { "ID": 244193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5438973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327076", "Detail": { "ID": 327076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7978011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277149", "Detail": { "ID": 277149, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7032077+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264025", "Detail": { "ID": 264025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9209745+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248632", "Detail": { "ID": 248632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.663186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294885", "Detail": { "ID": 294885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1829196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285314", "Detail": { "ID": 285314, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3176782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230790", "Detail": { "ID": 230790, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3456302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243691", "Detail": { "ID": 243691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3157262+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254453", "Detail": { "ID": 254453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2567744+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323529", "Detail": { "ID": 323529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9603265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290881", "Detail": { "ID": 290881, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7761352+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273012", "Detail": { "ID": 273012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3656773+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262547", "Detail": { "ID": 262547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6066107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281869", "Detail": { "ID": 281869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1610965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298258", "Detail": { "ID": 298258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3380035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231147", "Detail": { "ID": 231147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3676243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284926", "Detail": { "ID": 284926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0536317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219534", "Detail": { "ID": 219534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3035008+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238239", "Detail": { "ID": 238239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4378297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225138", "Detail": { "ID": 225138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7461002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321889", "Detail": { "ID": 321889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4557042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292664", "Detail": { "ID": 292664, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5525266+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227259", "Detail": { "ID": 227259, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5377303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313302", "Detail": { "ID": 313302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3894558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257799", "Detail": { "ID": 257799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0780945+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271059", "Detail": { "ID": 271059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8407418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278007", "Detail": { "ID": 278007, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9829879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287377", "Detail": { "ID": 287377, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8616138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250616", "Detail": { "ID": 250616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1972366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221079", "Detail": { "ID": 221079, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6741781+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220110", "Detail": { "ID": 220110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3347603+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252805", "Detail": { "ID": 252805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7540118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253776", "Detail": { "ID": 253776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0204178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324722", "Detail": { "ID": 324722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2350907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259423", "Detail": { "ID": 259423, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6084619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239504", "Detail": { "ID": 239504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7466443+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273651", "Detail": { "ID": 273651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6295489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304005", "Detail": { "ID": 304005, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8453004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221615", "Detail": { "ID": 221615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9403736+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241846", "Detail": { "ID": 241846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7825518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223393", "Detail": { "ID": 223393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4559406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307841", "Detail": { "ID": 307841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8532128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272351", "Detail": { "ID": 272351, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3315953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245038", "Detail": { "ID": 245038, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5893522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315204", "Detail": { "ID": 315204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8983611+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247457", "Detail": { "ID": 247457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4046308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275492", "Detail": { "ID": 275492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3775829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255459", "Detail": { "ID": 255459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5322415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276907", "Detail": { "ID": 276907, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6862199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253505", "Detail": { "ID": 253505, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.999314+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276386", "Detail": { "ID": 276386, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6633947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325409", "Detail": { "ID": 325409, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4974496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233295", "Detail": { "ID": 233295, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1178319+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311686", "Detail": { "ID": 311686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8899042+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229645", "Detail": { "ID": 229645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0905996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267468", "Detail": { "ID": 267468, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0211274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313475", "Detail": { "ID": 313475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.396977+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294970", "Detail": { "ID": 294970, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1865812+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319138", "Detail": { "ID": 319138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6940695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306282", "Detail": { "ID": 306282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5453668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310364", "Detail": { "ID": 310364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5673341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268136", "Detail": { "ID": 268136, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0577306+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286439", "Detail": { "ID": 286439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5792416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258520", "Detail": { "ID": 258520, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3107978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263591", "Detail": { "ID": 263591, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8959888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307231", "Detail": { "ID": 307231, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8203004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280114", "Detail": { "ID": 280114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5420494+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279524", "Detail": { "ID": 279524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5114166+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260482", "Detail": { "ID": 260482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0787898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299560", "Detail": { "ID": 299560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7027016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301789", "Detail": { "ID": 301789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2833017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300482", "Detail": { "ID": 300482, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0000884+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223983", "Detail": { "ID": 223983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4869737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237934", "Detail": { "ID": 237934, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2323866+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305585", "Detail": { "ID": 305585, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3307057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320132", "Detail": { "ID": 320132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9630484+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315878", "Detail": { "ID": 315878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9311039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236778", "Detail": { "ID": 236778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9396539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289727", "Detail": { "ID": 289727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4565704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234281", "Detail": { "ID": 234281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3704991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313137", "Detail": { "ID": 313137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1652448+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261303", "Detail": { "ID": 261303, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3515599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225394", "Detail": { "ID": 225394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9728297+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265721", "Detail": { "ID": 265721, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4516091+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283025", "Detail": { "ID": 283025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4445367+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252068", "Detail": { "ID": 252068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5011933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317354", "Detail": { "ID": 317354, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.418505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254235", "Detail": { "ID": 254235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2467699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293360", "Detail": { "ID": 293360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.841651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235514", "Detail": { "ID": 235514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6811097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258044", "Detail": { "ID": 258044, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0889005+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228576", "Detail": { "ID": 228576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8050554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291052", "Detail": { "ID": 291052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7834+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311174", "Detail": { "ID": 311174, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.608895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246799", "Detail": { "ID": 246799, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1539024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298020", "Detail": { "ID": 298020, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1348436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234052", "Detail": { "ID": 234052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1645691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274875", "Detail": { "ID": 274875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1257722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269634", "Detail": { "ID": 269634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5563613+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317670", "Detail": { "ID": 317670, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4323753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326421", "Detail": { "ID": 326421, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7579831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241282", "Detail": { "ID": 241282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7512197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290397", "Detail": { "ID": 290397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.745334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248077", "Detail": { "ID": 248077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4409954+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287530", "Detail": { "ID": 287530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8749567+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222638", "Detail": { "ID": 222638, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1975281+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306895", "Detail": { "ID": 306895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5782028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239842", "Detail": { "ID": 239842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7612422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283985", "Detail": { "ID": 283985, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7320103+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231792", "Detail": { "ID": 231792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6157204+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237326", "Detail": { "ID": 237326, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1993776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308996", "Detail": { "ID": 308996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 2000, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 5, "VoteAgainst": 103, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424.1", "ID": 5566 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0870421+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252743", "Detail": { "ID": 252743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7514254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259188", "Detail": { "ID": 259188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3454863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319576", "Detail": { "ID": 319576, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9318905+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249484", "Detail": { "ID": 249484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9288629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227868", "Detail": { "ID": 227868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5691099+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280869", "Detail": { "ID": 280869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7858476+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262809", "Detail": { "ID": 262809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6238793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288988", "Detail": { "ID": 288988, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1672375+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230531", "Detail": { "ID": 230531, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3343914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269683", "Detail": { "ID": 269683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5585183+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322570", "Detail": { "ID": 322570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6944009+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295346", "Detail": { "ID": 295346, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.508264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243026", "Detail": { "ID": 243026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0457477+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227108", "Detail": { "ID": 227108, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.268128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302480", "Detail": { "ID": 302480, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.526388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244194", "Detail": { "ID": 244194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5439509+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327075", "Detail": { "ID": 327075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7977601+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277148", "Detail": { "ID": 277148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7031656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264026", "Detail": { "ID": 264026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9210148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248633", "Detail": { "ID": 248633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6632282+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294886", "Detail": { "ID": 294886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1829606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285313", "Detail": { "ID": 285313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.317637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230789", "Detail": { "ID": 230789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3455896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243692", "Detail": { "ID": 243692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3157662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254454", "Detail": { "ID": 254454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2568172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323528", "Detail": { "ID": 323528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9602843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290882", "Detail": { "ID": 290882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7761749+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273011", "Detail": { "ID": 273011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3656294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262546", "Detail": { "ID": 262546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6065694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281870", "Detail": { "ID": 281870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1611366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298257", "Detail": { "ID": 298257, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.337963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231148", "Detail": { "ID": 231148, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3676648+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284931", "Detail": { "ID": 284931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0538623+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219533", "Detail": { "ID": 219533, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3034594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238240", "Detail": { "ID": 238240, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.437872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225139", "Detail": { "ID": 225139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7461411+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321890", "Detail": { "ID": 321890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4557478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292784", "Detail": { "ID": 292784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5580059+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227258", "Detail": { "ID": 227258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5376894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313301", "Detail": { "ID": 313301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3894151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257798", "Detail": { "ID": 257798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0780538+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271064", "Detail": { "ID": 271064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8409668+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278008", "Detail": { "ID": 278008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9830294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287376", "Detail": { "ID": 287376, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8615728+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250615", "Detail": { "ID": 250615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1971963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221078", "Detail": { "ID": 221078, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6741369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220111", "Detail": { "ID": 220111, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3348013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252804", "Detail": { "ID": 252804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.753971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253777", "Detail": { "ID": 253777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0204771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324723", "Detail": { "ID": 324723, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2351308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259424", "Detail": { "ID": 259424, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6085024+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239503", "Detail": { "ID": 239503, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7466049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273652", "Detail": { "ID": 273652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6295903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304006", "Detail": { "ID": 304006, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8453605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221616", "Detail": { "ID": 221616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9404142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241847", "Detail": { "ID": 241847, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7826108+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223394", "Detail": { "ID": 223394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4559826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307840", "Detail": { "ID": 307840, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8531721+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272350", "Detail": { "ID": 272350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3315551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245037", "Detail": { "ID": 245037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.589311+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315203", "Detail": { "ID": 315203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8983031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247458", "Detail": { "ID": 247458, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4046719+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275487", "Detail": { "ID": 275487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.377379+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255460", "Detail": { "ID": 255460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5322818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276912", "Detail": { "ID": 276912, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6864431+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253504", "Detail": { "ID": 253504, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9992732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276387", "Detail": { "ID": 276387, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6634355+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325408", "Detail": { "ID": 325408, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4974092+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233294", "Detail": { "ID": 233294, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1177917+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311685", "Detail": { "ID": 311685, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8898621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229646", "Detail": { "ID": 229646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0906394+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267467", "Detail": { "ID": 267467, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0210869+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313476", "Detail": { "ID": 313476, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3970186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294971", "Detail": { "ID": 294971, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1866216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319139", "Detail": { "ID": 319139, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6941102+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306283", "Detail": { "ID": 306283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5454088+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309797", "Detail": { "ID": 309797, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3453575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268137", "Detail": { "ID": 268137, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0577938+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286438", "Detail": { "ID": 286438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5792004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258521", "Detail": { "ID": 258521, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3108403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263592", "Detail": { "ID": 263592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8960296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307636", "Detail": { "ID": 307636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8383622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280113", "Detail": { "ID": 280113, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5419896+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279525", "Detail": { "ID": 279525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5114569+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260483", "Detail": { "ID": 260483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.078831+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299561", "Detail": { "ID": 299561, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7027427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306732", "Detail": { "ID": 306732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.565023+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300602", "Detail": { "ID": 300602, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.005683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223982", "Detail": { "ID": 223982, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4869327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237933", "Detail": { "ID": 237933, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2323462+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305584", "Detail": { "ID": 305584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3306649+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320131", "Detail": { "ID": 320131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9630068+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315879", "Detail": { "ID": 315879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.931145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236777", "Detail": { "ID": 236777, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9396131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289728", "Detail": { "ID": 289728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4566117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234282", "Detail": { "ID": 234282, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3705395+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313138", "Detail": { "ID": 313138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1653038+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289336", "Detail": { "ID": 289336, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4328813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225393", "Detail": { "ID": 225393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.972789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265722", "Detail": { "ID": 265722, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4516507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283026", "Detail": { "ID": 283026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4445766+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252067", "Detail": { "ID": 252067, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5011528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317353", "Detail": { "ID": 317353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.418464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254236", "Detail": { "ID": 254236, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2468118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296237", "Detail": { "ID": 296237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8399837+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235513", "Detail": { "ID": 235513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6810504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258043", "Detail": { "ID": 258043, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0888597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228575", "Detail": { "ID": 228575, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8050151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291053", "Detail": { "ID": 291053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7834604+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311173", "Detail": { "ID": 311173, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6088549+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246798", "Detail": { "ID": 246798, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1538622+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298021", "Detail": { "ID": 298021, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1348846+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234053", "Detail": { "ID": 234053, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1646104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274874", "Detail": { "ID": 274874, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1257312+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269633", "Detail": { "ID": 269633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5563196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317514", "Detail": { "ID": 317514, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4256927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326422", "Detail": { "ID": 326422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7580369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241281", "Detail": { "ID": 241281, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7511788+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290396", "Detail": { "ID": 290396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7452932+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248076", "Detail": { "ID": 248076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.440919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287529", "Detail": { "ID": 287529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8749151+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222637", "Detail": { "ID": 222637, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1974874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306849", "Detail": { "ID": 306849, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5763561+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239843", "Detail": { "ID": 239843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7612841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283980", "Detail": { "ID": 283980, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7318004+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231793", "Detail": { "ID": 231793, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6157606+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237327", "Detail": { "ID": 237327, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1994188+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308997", "Detail": { "ID": 308997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1999, "AgendaID": 2086, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 65, "VoteAgainst": 54, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Tackling Fuel Poverty", "Reference": "S4M-05424", "ID": 5552 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-23T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0870829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252740", "Detail": { "ID": 252740, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7512844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259185", "Detail": { "ID": 259185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3453438+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319579", "Detail": { "ID": 319579, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.932121+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249487", "Detail": { "ID": 249487, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9289853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227865", "Detail": { "ID": 227865, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5689874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280866", "Detail": { "ID": 280866, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7857287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262806", "Detail": { "ID": 262806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.623756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288991", "Detail": { "ID": 288991, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.167361+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230528", "Detail": { "ID": 230528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3342526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269686", "Detail": { "ID": 269686, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5586428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322590", "Detail": { "ID": 322590, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6952522+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295343", "Detail": { "ID": 295343, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5081179+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243023", "Detail": { "ID": 243023, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0456185+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235084", "Detail": { "ID": 235084, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4186803+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302477", "Detail": { "ID": 302477, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5262655+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244197", "Detail": { "ID": 244197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5441064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327072", "Detail": { "ID": 327072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7976369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277145", "Detail": { "ID": 277145, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7030248+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264029", "Detail": { "ID": 264029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9211579+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248636", "Detail": { "ID": 248636, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6633491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294889", "Detail": { "ID": 294889, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1831035+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285310", "Detail": { "ID": 285310, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3174929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230786", "Detail": { "ID": 230786, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3454692+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243695", "Detail": { "ID": 243695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3158851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254457", "Detail": { "ID": 254457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2569415+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323525", "Detail": { "ID": 323525, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9601337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290885", "Detail": { "ID": 290885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7762953+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273008", "Detail": { "ID": 273008, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3653827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262543", "Detail": { "ID": 262543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6064485+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281873", "Detail": { "ID": 281873, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1612793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298254", "Detail": { "ID": 298254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3378402+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231151", "Detail": { "ID": 231151, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3677861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284928", "Detail": { "ID": 284928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0537366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219530", "Detail": { "ID": 219530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3033351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238243", "Detail": { "ID": 238243, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4379959+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225142", "Detail": { "ID": 225142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7462619+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321870", "Detail": { "ID": 321870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4548826+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292787", "Detail": { "ID": 292787, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5581254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227255", "Detail": { "ID": 227255, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5375656+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313298", "Detail": { "ID": 313298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3892731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257795", "Detail": { "ID": 257795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0779318+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271061", "Detail": { "ID": 271061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8408221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278011", "Detail": { "ID": 278011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.983152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287373", "Detail": { "ID": 287373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8614294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250612", "Detail": { "ID": 250612, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1970741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221075", "Detail": { "ID": 221075, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6739933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220114", "Detail": { "ID": 220114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3349254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252801", "Detail": { "ID": 252801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7538512+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253780", "Detail": { "ID": 253780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0205978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324726", "Detail": { "ID": 324726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2352504+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259427", "Detail": { "ID": 259427, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.608645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239500", "Detail": { "ID": 239500, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7464844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273655", "Detail": { "ID": 273655, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6297128+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304009", "Detail": { "ID": 304009, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8454839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221619", "Detail": { "ID": 221619, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9405381+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241850", "Detail": { "ID": 241850, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7827335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223397", "Detail": { "ID": 223397, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4561049+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307837", "Detail": { "ID": 307837, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.853048+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272347", "Detail": { "ID": 272347, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3314333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245034", "Detail": { "ID": 245034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5891696+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315200", "Detail": { "ID": 315200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6786298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247461", "Detail": { "ID": 247461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4047925+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275490", "Detail": { "ID": 275490, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3775016+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255463", "Detail": { "ID": 255463, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5324225+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276909", "Detail": { "ID": 276909, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6863211+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253501", "Detail": { "ID": 253501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9991499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276390", "Detail": { "ID": 276390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6635574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325405", "Detail": { "ID": 325405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4972664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233291", "Detail": { "ID": 233291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1176699+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311682", "Detail": { "ID": 311682, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8897186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229649", "Detail": { "ID": 229649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0907774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267464", "Detail": { "ID": 267464, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0209646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313479", "Detail": { "ID": 313479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3971422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294974", "Detail": { "ID": 294974, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1867437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319119", "Detail": { "ID": 319119, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6932534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306286", "Detail": { "ID": 306286, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5455309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310789", "Detail": { "ID": 310789, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5861133+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268140", "Detail": { "ID": 268140, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0579221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286435", "Detail": { "ID": 286435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5790636+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258524", "Detail": { "ID": 258524, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3109652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263595", "Detail": { "ID": 263595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8962478+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308543", "Detail": { "ID": 308543, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0604391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280110", "Detail": { "ID": 280110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5418662+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279528", "Detail": { "ID": 279528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5115792+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260486", "Detail": { "ID": 260486, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0789554+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299564", "Detail": { "ID": 299564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7028845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306729", "Detail": { "ID": 306729, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5648994+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300605", "Detail": { "ID": 300605, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0058051+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223979", "Detail": { "ID": 223979, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.48681+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237930", "Detail": { "ID": 237930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2322238+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305581", "Detail": { "ID": 305581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3305422+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320307", "Detail": { "ID": 320307, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.154369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315882", "Detail": { "ID": 315882, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9312922+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236774", "Detail": { "ID": 236774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9394907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289731", "Detail": { "ID": 289731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4567329+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234285", "Detail": { "ID": 234285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3706829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313141", "Detail": { "ID": 313141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1654291+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289333", "Detail": { "ID": 289333, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4327385+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225390", "Detail": { "ID": 225390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9726657+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265725", "Detail": { "ID": 265725, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4517733+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283029", "Detail": { "ID": 283029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4446997+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252064", "Detail": { "ID": 252064, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5010106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317528", "Detail": { "ID": 317528, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4263309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254239", "Detail": { "ID": 254239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2469586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296234", "Detail": { "ID": 296234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8398396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235510", "Detail": { "ID": 235510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6809294+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258040", "Detail": { "ID": 258040, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0887171+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228572", "Detail": { "ID": 228572, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8048921+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291056", "Detail": { "ID": 291056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7835842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311170", "Detail": { "ID": 311170, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6087324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246795", "Detail": { "ID": 246795, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1537416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298024", "Detail": { "ID": 298024, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1350076+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234056", "Detail": { "ID": 234056, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1647346+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274871", "Detail": { "ID": 274871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1256072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269630", "Detail": { "ID": 269630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.556197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317511", "Detail": { "ID": 317511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4255491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326425", "Detail": { "ID": 326425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7581652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241278", "Detail": { "ID": 241278, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7510366+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290393", "Detail": { "ID": 290393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7451704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248073", "Detail": { "ID": 248073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4407011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287526", "Detail": { "ID": 287526, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8747711+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222634", "Detail": { "ID": 222634, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1973659+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306976", "Detail": { "ID": 306976, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5819731+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239846", "Detail": { "ID": 239846, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.761452+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283983", "Detail": { "ID": 283983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7319269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231796", "Detail": { "ID": 231796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6159055+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237330", "Detail": { "ID": 237330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1995416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309000", "Detail": { "ID": 309000, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1996, "AgendaID": 2514, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 66, "VoteAgainst": 41, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Budget (Scotland) (No. 2) Bill", "Reference": "S4M-05407", "ID": 5535 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-22T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0872054+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252691", "Detail": { "ID": 252691, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7494332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258913", "Detail": { "ID": 258913, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.333626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319651", "Detail": { "ID": 319651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9354599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249567", "Detail": { "ID": 249567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9324231+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227802", "Detail": { "ID": 227802, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5662565+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280805", "Detail": { "ID": 280805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7831271+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262720", "Detail": { "ID": 262720, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6139651+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288096", "Detail": { "ID": 288096, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8998851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229806", "Detail": { "ID": 229806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0979774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269803", "Detail": { "ID": 269803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5636098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322615", "Detail": { "ID": 322615, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6963406+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295258", "Detail": { "ID": 295258, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5042793+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242949", "Detail": { "ID": 242949, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0424508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235176", "Detail": { "ID": 235176, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4226602+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302371", "Detail": { "ID": 302371, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5215138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244283", "Detail": { "ID": 244283, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5479738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327168", "Detail": { "ID": 327168, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8021105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277059", "Detail": { "ID": 277059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6993221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264270", "Detail": { "ID": 264270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1260528+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248712", "Detail": { "ID": 248712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6665776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295732", "Detail": { "ID": 295732, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5335382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285224", "Detail": { "ID": 285224, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3137216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230701", "Detail": { "ID": 230701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3415771+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243770", "Detail": { "ID": 243770, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.319028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254875", "Detail": { "ID": 254875, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2875467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323775", "Detail": { "ID": 323775, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9713862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291270", "Detail": { "ID": 291270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1116704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265396", "Detail": { "ID": 265396, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4373814+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262313", "Detail": { "ID": 262313, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5961039+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281935", "Detail": { "ID": 281935, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1641079+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298191", "Detail": { "ID": 298191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1424399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231232", "Detail": { "ID": 231232, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5861017+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285868", "Detail": { "ID": 285868, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3480052+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219453", "Detail": { "ID": 219453, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2998971+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238513", "Detail": { "ID": 238513, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.457345+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225221", "Detail": { "ID": 225221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9599819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321845", "Detail": { "ID": 321845, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4538195+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292814", "Detail": { "ID": 292814, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5592722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227178", "Detail": { "ID": 227178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2711855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312731", "Detail": { "ID": 312731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1409064+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257253", "Detail": { "ID": 257253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0481523+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271223", "Detail": { "ID": 271223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0609419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278072", "Detail": { "ID": 278072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9857931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287266", "Detail": { "ID": 287266, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8567931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250532", "Detail": { "ID": 250532, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.193627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220996", "Detail": { "ID": 220996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6706046+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220191", "Detail": { "ID": 220191, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.338273+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252391", "Detail": { "ID": 252391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.727156+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253841", "Detail": { "ID": 253841, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0231628+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324630", "Detail": { "ID": 324630, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2312298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259659", "Detail": { "ID": 259659, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6189942+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239383", "Detail": { "ID": 239383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7344486+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273741", "Detail": { "ID": 273741, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6336633+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304114", "Detail": { "ID": 304114, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8502587+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221699", "Detail": { "ID": 221699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9439996+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241931", "Detail": { "ID": 241931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7861841+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223489", "Detail": { "ID": 223489, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4606298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307788", "Detail": { "ID": 307788, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8449417+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272268", "Detail": { "ID": 272268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3223192+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244959", "Detail": { "ID": 244959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.585944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315129", "Detail": { "ID": 315129, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6755685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247885", "Detail": { "ID": 247885, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.432582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275017", "Detail": { "ID": 275017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1375868+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255735", "Detail": { "ID": 255735, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5546626+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277382", "Detail": { "ID": 277382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9509806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253076", "Detail": { "ID": 253076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7658321+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276776", "Detail": { "ID": 276776, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6806131+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325501", "Detail": { "ID": 325501, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5090856+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232895", "Detail": { "ID": 232895, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8812817+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311479", "Detail": { "ID": 311479, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8806066+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230345", "Detail": { "ID": 230345, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3189927+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267403", "Detail": { "ID": 267403, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0183261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313530", "Detail": { "ID": 313530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3993464+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295037", "Detail": { "ID": 295037, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1894894+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319094", "Detail": { "ID": 319094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6921851+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306357", "Detail": { "ID": 306357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5486106+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310816", "Detail": { "ID": 310816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5872732+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268200", "Detail": { "ID": 268200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2531105+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286373", "Detail": { "ID": 286373, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5761322+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258603", "Detail": { "ID": 258603, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3143785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263824", "Detail": { "ID": 263824, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9119897+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308516", "Detail": { "ID": 308516, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0592833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279726", "Detail": { "ID": 279726, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5199844+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279613", "Detail": { "ID": 279613, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5151824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261029", "Detail": { "ID": 261029, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1087363+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299627", "Detail": { "ID": 299627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7058627+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306702", "Detail": { "ID": 306702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5637239+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300632", "Detail": { "ID": 300632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0069547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223899", "Detail": { "ID": 223899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4785624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237861", "Detail": { "ID": 237861, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.229232+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305511", "Detail": { "ID": 305511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3274986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320332", "Detail": { "ID": 320332, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1554508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315953", "Detail": { "ID": 315953, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9393919+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236687", "Detail": { "ID": 236687, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.935753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289817", "Detail": { "ID": 289817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4603491+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234546", "Detail": { "ID": 234546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3889596+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313212", "Detail": { "ID": 313212, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3825645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289306", "Detail": { "ID": 289306, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4315944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225298", "Detail": { "ID": 225298, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9633616+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265832", "Detail": { "ID": 265832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4564174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283262", "Detail": { "ID": 283262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6928949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251527", "Detail": { "ID": 251527, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4675475+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317553", "Detail": { "ID": 317553, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4273937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254319", "Detail": { "ID": 254319, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2504382+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296207", "Detail": { "ID": 296207, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8386056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235431", "Detail": { "ID": 235431, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6774804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257624", "Detail": { "ID": 257624, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0645269+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228492", "Detail": { "ID": 228492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8014073+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291628", "Detail": { "ID": 291628, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1354835+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311099", "Detail": { "ID": 311099, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6053678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246406", "Detail": { "ID": 246406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1273505+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298110", "Detail": { "ID": 298110, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.138671+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234142", "Detail": { "ID": 234142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1684419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274641", "Detail": { "ID": 274641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1153871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269570", "Detail": { "ID": 269570, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.553324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317440", "Detail": { "ID": 317440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4221986+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326329", "Detail": { "ID": 326329, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7537539+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241197", "Detail": { "ID": 241197, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7471891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290320", "Detail": { "ID": 290320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7417418+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247997", "Detail": { "ID": 247997, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4373263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287449", "Detail": { "ID": 287449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8646634+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222542", "Detail": { "ID": 222542, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1934356+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307003", "Detail": { "ID": 307003, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5831332+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239926", "Detail": { "ID": 239926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7652689+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283668", "Detail": { "ID": 283668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7181416+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231858", "Detail": { "ID": 231858, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6185621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237708", "Detail": { "ID": 237708, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2224149+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309205", "Detail": { "ID": 309205, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1995, "AgendaID": 2816, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 52, "VoteAgainst": 62, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Planning Reform, Next Steps", "Reference": "S4M-05358.2", "ID": 5499 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-15T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3192377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252668", "Detail": { "ID": 252668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7484444+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258869", "Detail": { "ID": 258869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3317371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319862", "Detail": { "ID": 319862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9446013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249581", "Detail": { "ID": 249581, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9330132+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227779", "Detail": { "ID": 227779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5652695+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280782", "Detail": { "ID": 280782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7821663+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262783", "Detail": { "ID": 262783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6166605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288082", "Detail": { "ID": 288082, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8992763+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229768", "Detail": { "ID": 229768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0961978+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270158", "Detail": { "ID": 270158, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5840467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322651", "Detail": { "ID": 322651, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6978669+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295320", "Detail": { "ID": 295320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5069161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242890", "Detail": { "ID": 242890, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0399715+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235222", "Detail": { "ID": 235222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6610599+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302439", "Detail": { "ID": 302439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5246289+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244220", "Detail": { "ID": 244220, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5451497+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327206", "Detail": { "ID": 327206, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0256403+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277122", "Detail": { "ID": 277122, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7020451+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264052", "Detail": { "ID": 264052, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9221359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248756", "Detail": { "ID": 248756, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6684335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295792", "Detail": { "ID": 295792, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5360829+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285287", "Detail": { "ID": 285287, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3164891+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230764", "Detail": { "ID": 230764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3445331+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243829", "Detail": { "ID": 243829, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.321546+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254807", "Detail": { "ID": 254807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2845758+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323813", "Detail": { "ID": 323813, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9730152+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291318", "Detail": { "ID": 291318, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1137845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265459", "Detail": { "ID": 265459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4401002+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262268", "Detail": { "ID": 262268, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5941889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281959", "Detail": { "ID": 281959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1651469+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298013", "Detail": { "ID": 298013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1345419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231578", "Detail": { "ID": 231578, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6066588+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285924", "Detail": { "ID": 285924, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3504165+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219405", "Detail": { "ID": 219405, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2972924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238557", "Detail": { "ID": 238557, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4592624+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225234", "Detail": { "ID": 225234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9605824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321809", "Detail": { "ID": 321809, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4522804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292780", "Detail": { "ID": 292780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5578261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227131", "Detail": { "ID": 227131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2691513+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313260", "Detail": { "ID": 313260, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3876275+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257238", "Detail": { "ID": 257238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0475159+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271279", "Detail": { "ID": 271279, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0634433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278095", "Detail": { "ID": 278095, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9867907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287335", "Detail": { "ID": 287335, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8597529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250517", "Detail": { "ID": 250517, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1929488+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220983", "Detail": { "ID": 220983, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6700525+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220238", "Detail": { "ID": 220238, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6297753+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252352", "Detail": { "ID": 252352, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7254853+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266091", "Detail": { "ID": 266091, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4739526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324592", "Detail": { "ID": 324592, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2296011+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259703", "Detail": { "ID": 259703, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6208863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239339", "Detail": { "ID": 239339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7325685+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273678", "Detail": { "ID": 273678, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6306863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304047", "Detail": { "ID": 304047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8470914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221712", "Detail": { "ID": 221712, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.944548+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241944", "Detail": { "ID": 241944, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7868735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223535", "Detail": { "ID": 223535, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4626119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307597", "Detail": { "ID": 307597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8364434+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272253", "Detail": { "ID": 272253, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3216842+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244899", "Detail": { "ID": 244899, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5833795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315070", "Detail": { "ID": 315070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6727794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247929", "Detail": { "ID": 247929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.434436+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274806", "Detail": { "ID": 274806, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1225621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255779", "Detail": { "ID": 255779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5565184+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277439", "Detail": { "ID": 277439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9534153+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253033", "Detail": { "ID": 253033, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7639693+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276823", "Detail": { "ID": 276823, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6826117+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325539", "Detail": { "ID": 325539, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5107145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232857", "Detail": { "ID": 232857, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8795937+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311442", "Detail": { "ID": 311442, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8789981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230391", "Detail": { "ID": 230391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.327784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267380", "Detail": { "ID": 267380, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0173144+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313719", "Detail": { "ID": 313719, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4077287+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295061", "Detail": { "ID": 295061, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1905199+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319059", "Detail": { "ID": 319059, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6906658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306416", "Detail": { "ID": 306416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5511465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310782", "Detail": { "ID": 310782, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5858242+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268223", "Detail": { "ID": 268223, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2541727+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286349", "Detail": { "ID": 286349, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5749845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258618", "Detail": { "ID": 258618, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3150806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263871", "Detail": { "ID": 263871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9143571+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308550", "Detail": { "ID": 308550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0607428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279679", "Detail": { "ID": 279679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5179739+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279551", "Detail": { "ID": 279551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5125553+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261088", "Detail": { "ID": 261088, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1112809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299650", "Detail": { "ID": 299650, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7068682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306737", "Detail": { "ID": 306737, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5652481+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300598", "Detail": { "ID": 300598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0055186+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223886", "Detail": { "ID": 223886, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4779901+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237510", "Detail": { "ID": 237510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2137754+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305451", "Detail": { "ID": 305451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3245915+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320367", "Detail": { "ID": 320367, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1633578+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316012", "Detail": { "ID": 316012, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9420304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236751", "Detail": { "ID": 236751, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9385083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289754", "Detail": { "ID": 289754, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4576928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234584", "Detail": { "ID": 234584, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3905913+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313582", "Detail": { "ID": 313582, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4016074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289340", "Detail": { "ID": 289340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4330445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225251", "Detail": { "ID": 225251, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9613189+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265763", "Detail": { "ID": 265763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4534309+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283309", "Detail": { "ID": 283309, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.695014+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251483", "Detail": { "ID": 251483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4656263+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317588", "Detail": { "ID": 317588, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.428908+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254646", "Detail": { "ID": 254646, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2654433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296241", "Detail": { "ID": 296241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8401529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234926", "Detail": { "ID": 234926, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.405717+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257692", "Detail": { "ID": 257692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0674654+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228171", "Detail": { "ID": 228171, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5873838+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291560", "Detail": { "ID": 291560, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1325973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311039", "Detail": { "ID": 311039, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6028087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246392", "Detail": { "ID": 246392, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1267572+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298047", "Detail": { "ID": 298047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1359827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234077", "Detail": { "ID": 234077, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1656389+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274594", "Detail": { "ID": 274594, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1133697+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269547", "Detail": { "ID": 269547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5523399+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317381", "Detail": { "ID": 317381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4196832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326291", "Detail": { "ID": 326291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7521247+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241184", "Detail": { "ID": 241184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7465465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289643", "Detail": { "ID": 289643, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4528182+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247800", "Detail": { "ID": 247800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4289906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287401", "Detail": { "ID": 287401, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8626358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222496", "Detail": { "ID": 222496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.191453+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306969", "Detail": { "ID": 306969, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5816874+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239939", "Detail": { "ID": 239939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7658398+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283457", "Detail": { "ID": 283457, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7087222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232185", "Detail": { "ID": 232185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6384805+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237753", "Detail": { "ID": 237753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2244134+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309242", "Detail": { "ID": 309242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1993, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 53, "VoteAgainst": 63, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319.2", "ID": 5461 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3208759+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252669", "Detail": { "ID": 252669, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7484845+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258870", "Detail": { "ID": 258870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3317802+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319831", "Detail": { "ID": 319831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9432629+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249580", "Detail": { "ID": 249580, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9329723+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227780", "Detail": { "ID": 227780, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5653097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280783", "Detail": { "ID": 280783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7822056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262784", "Detail": { "ID": 262784, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6167013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288081", "Detail": { "ID": 288081, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8992349+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230492", "Detail": { "ID": 230492, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3324804+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270157", "Detail": { "ID": 270157, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5840057+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322652", "Detail": { "ID": 322652, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6979071+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295321", "Detail": { "ID": 295321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5069573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242891", "Detail": { "ID": 242891, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0400109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235221", "Detail": { "ID": 235221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.660701+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302441", "Detail": { "ID": 302441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5247328+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244219", "Detail": { "ID": 244219, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5450889+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327138", "Detail": { "ID": 327138, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8007704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277123", "Detail": { "ID": 277123, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7020857+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264051", "Detail": { "ID": 264051, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9220951+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248755", "Detail": { "ID": 248755, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6683928+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295760", "Detail": { "ID": 295760, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5347335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285288", "Detail": { "ID": 285288, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3165301+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230765", "Detail": { "ID": 230765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3445738+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243828", "Detail": { "ID": 243828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3214428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254805", "Detail": { "ID": 254805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2844934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323745", "Detail": { "ID": 323745, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9700833+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291317", "Detail": { "ID": 291317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1137435+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265460", "Detail": { "ID": 265460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4401408+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262269", "Detail": { "ID": 262269, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5942296+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281958", "Detail": { "ID": 281958, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1650877+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298014", "Detail": { "ID": 298014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.134582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231175", "Detail": { "ID": 231175, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3689499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285925", "Detail": { "ID": 285925, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3504577+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219406", "Detail": { "ID": 219406, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.297334+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238556", "Detail": { "ID": 238556, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4592212+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225233", "Detail": { "ID": 225233, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9605409+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321808", "Detail": { "ID": 321808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4522388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292779", "Detail": { "ID": 292779, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5577852+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227132", "Detail": { "ID": 227132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2691936+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313262", "Detail": { "ID": 313262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.387712+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257239", "Detail": { "ID": 257239, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0475573+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271280", "Detail": { "ID": 271280, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0634855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278094", "Detail": { "ID": 278094, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9867501+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287337", "Detail": { "ID": 287337, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8598344+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250518", "Detail": { "ID": 250518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1929899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220984", "Detail": { "ID": 220984, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.670094+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220237", "Detail": { "ID": 220237, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6297333+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252461", "Detail": { "ID": 252461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7301446+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266090", "Detail": { "ID": 266090, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4739119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324660", "Detail": { "ID": 324660, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2324843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259702", "Detail": { "ID": 259702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6208258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239340", "Detail": { "ID": 239340, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7326097+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273677", "Detail": { "ID": 273677, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.630645+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304045", "Detail": { "ID": 304045, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8470096+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221711", "Detail": { "ID": 221711, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9445074+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241943", "Detail": { "ID": 241943, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.78683+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223534", "Detail": { "ID": 223534, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4625707+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307598", "Detail": { "ID": 307598, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8364963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272254", "Detail": { "ID": 272254, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.321725+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244900", "Detail": { "ID": 244900, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5834198+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315101", "Detail": { "ID": 315101, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6741777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247928", "Detail": { "ID": 247928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4343958+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274805", "Detail": { "ID": 274805, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1225191+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255778", "Detail": { "ID": 255778, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5564785+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277440", "Detail": { "ID": 277440, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9534747+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253034", "Detail": { "ID": 253034, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7640104+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276822", "Detail": { "ID": 276822, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6825704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325471", "Detail": { "ID": 325471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5078216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233265", "Detail": { "ID": 233265, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1165643+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311443", "Detail": { "ID": 311443, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8790391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230390", "Detail": { "ID": 230390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3277428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267381", "Detail": { "ID": 267381, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0173824+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313718", "Detail": { "ID": 313718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4076879+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295060", "Detail": { "ID": 295060, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1904776+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319058", "Detail": { "ID": 319058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6906252+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306385", "Detail": { "ID": 306385, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.549818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310781", "Detail": { "ID": 310781, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.585783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268222", "Detail": { "ID": 268222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2541081+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286350", "Detail": { "ID": 286350, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5750259+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258617", "Detail": { "ID": 258617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.314976+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263870", "Detail": { "ID": 263870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9143168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308551", "Detail": { "ID": 308551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0607843+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279680", "Detail": { "ID": 279680, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5180143+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279550", "Detail": { "ID": 279550, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5125145+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261057", "Detail": { "ID": 261057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1099358+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299649", "Detail": { "ID": 299649, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7068072+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306738", "Detail": { "ID": 306738, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5652899+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300597", "Detail": { "ID": 300597, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0054592+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223887", "Detail": { "ID": 223887, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.478032+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237511", "Detail": { "ID": 237511, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2138617+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305483", "Detail": { "ID": 305483, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3262605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320368", "Detail": { "ID": 320368, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1633992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315981", "Detail": { "ID": 315981, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9406148+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236752", "Detail": { "ID": 236752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9385496+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289753", "Detail": { "ID": 289753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4576529+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234475", "Detail": { "ID": 234475, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3858463+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313551", "Detail": { "ID": 313551, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4002646+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289341", "Detail": { "ID": 289341, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4330847+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225252", "Detail": { "ID": 225252, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9613605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265761", "Detail": { "ID": 265761, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4533479+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283308", "Detail": { "ID": 283308, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6949708+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251484", "Detail": { "ID": 251484, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4656682+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317589", "Detail": { "ID": 317589, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4289489+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254645", "Detail": { "ID": 254645, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2654018+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296242", "Detail": { "ID": 296242, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8401946+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234927", "Detail": { "ID": 234927, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4057582+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257694", "Detail": { "ID": 257694, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0675472+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228172", "Detail": { "ID": 228172, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5874432+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291558", "Detail": { "ID": 291558, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1325053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311070", "Detail": { "ID": 311070, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6041158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246393", "Detail": { "ID": 246393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1267982+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298046", "Detail": { "ID": 298046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1359419+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234076", "Detail": { "ID": 234076, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1655973+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274595", "Detail": { "ID": 274595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Abstain", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1134114+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269548", "Detail": { "ID": 269548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5523809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317412", "Detail": { "ID": 317412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4209926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326359", "Detail": { "ID": 326359, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7550944+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241185", "Detail": { "ID": 241185, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7466172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289676", "Detail": { "ID": 289676, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4542473+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247801", "Detail": { "ID": 247801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4290308+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287402", "Detail": { "ID": 287402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8626768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222497", "Detail": { "ID": 222497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1914931+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306968", "Detail": { "ID": 306968, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5816467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239938", "Detail": { "ID": 239938, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7657807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283456", "Detail": { "ID": 283456, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7086811+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232184", "Detail": { "ID": 232184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6384397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237752", "Detail": { "ID": 237752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2243722+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309241", "Detail": { "ID": 309241, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1994, "AgendaID": 2366, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 67, "VoteAgainst": 34, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Action to Support Youth Employment", "Reference": "S4M-05319", "ID": 5449 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-10T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3208348+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252699", "Detail": { "ID": 252699, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7497794+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258831", "Detail": { "ID": 258831, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3297774+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319897", "Detail": { "ID": 319897, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9461069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249668", "Detail": { "ID": 249668, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9446992+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227816", "Detail": { "ID": 227816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5668796+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280730", "Detail": { "ID": 280730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7800029+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262470", "Detail": { "ID": 262470, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6033261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288069", "Detail": { "ID": 288069, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8987196+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229256", "Detail": { "ID": 229256, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0688161+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270196", "Detail": { "ID": 270196, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5857527+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322695", "Detail": { "ID": 322695, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6997138+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294701", "Detail": { "ID": 294701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1746013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242855", "Detail": { "ID": 242855, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0385069+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235569", "Detail": { "ID": 235569, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.683461+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302125", "Detail": { "ID": 302125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2981396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244530", "Detail": { "ID": 244530, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5587526+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327234", "Detail": { "ID": 327234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0270324+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276653", "Detail": { "ID": 276653, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6753883+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264364", "Detail": { "ID": 264364, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1303176+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248804", "Detail": { "ID": 248804, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6707784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295828", "Detail": { "ID": 295828, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5375985+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285131", "Detail": { "ID": 285131, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0677855+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230146", "Detail": { "ID": 230146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.118217+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243864", "Detail": { "ID": 243864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3231949+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255271", "Detail": { "ID": 255271, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5237305+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323869", "Detail": { "ID": 323869, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9758907+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291363", "Detail": { "ID": 291363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1160806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265146", "Detail": { "ID": 265146, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1704691+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262221", "Detail": { "ID": 262221, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5921586+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282011", "Detail": { "ID": 282011, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1673551+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297962", "Detail": { "ID": 297962, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1323861+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231627", "Detail": { "ID": 231627, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6087369+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285956", "Detail": { "ID": 285956, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3517906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219360", "Detail": { "ID": 219360, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2952556+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238596", "Detail": { "ID": 238596, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4609339+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225472", "Detail": { "ID": 225472, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.976208+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321764", "Detail": { "ID": 321764, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4503836+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292701", "Detail": { "ID": 292701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5541167+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226928", "Detail": { "ID": 226928, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2529934+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312641", "Detail": { "ID": 312641, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.137056+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257183", "Detail": { "ID": 257183, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8268892+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271312", "Detail": { "ID": 271312, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0700597+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278455", "Detail": { "ID": 278455, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2195445+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286714", "Detail": { "ID": 286714, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5975862+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250461", "Detail": { "ID": 250461, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1905483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220743", "Detail": { "ID": 220743, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6551261+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220285", "Detail": { "ID": 220285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6347031+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251842", "Detail": { "ID": 251842, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4914903+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253826", "Detail": { "ID": 253826, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0225414+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324564", "Detail": { "ID": 324564, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2284243+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259906", "Detail": { "ID": 259906, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6351338+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239301", "Detail": { "ID": 239301, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7309087+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273835", "Detail": { "ID": 273835, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6377216+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304204", "Detail": { "ID": 304204, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0281941+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221796", "Detail": { "ID": 221796, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9481956+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242031", "Detail": { "ID": 242031, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7908441+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223728", "Detail": { "ID": 223728, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4712124+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307546", "Detail": { "ID": 307546, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8341906+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272200", "Detail": { "ID": 272200, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3191818+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244863", "Detail": { "ID": 244863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5818564+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315035", "Detail": { "ID": 315035, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6712756+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247967", "Detail": { "ID": 247967, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4360391+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274774", "Detail": { "ID": 274774, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1211782+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255817", "Detail": { "ID": 255817, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5583378+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277471", "Detail": { "ID": 277471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9547799+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252995", "Detail": { "ID": 252995, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7623168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277179", "Detail": { "ID": 277179, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7044784+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325567", "Detail": { "ID": 325567, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5119098+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232807", "Detail": { "ID": 232807, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.877089+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311393", "Detail": { "ID": 311393, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8767807+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230439", "Detail": { "ID": 230439, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3298621+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267417", "Detail": { "ID": 267417, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0189303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313768", "Detail": { "ID": 313768, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4098254+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295420", "Detail": { "ID": 295420, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5113981+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319014", "Detail": { "ID": 319014, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6887341+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306452", "Detail": { "ID": 306452, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5526858+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310402", "Detail": { "ID": 310402, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5689832+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268274", "Detail": { "ID": 268274, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2600019+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286141", "Detail": { "ID": 286141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3656667+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260684", "Detail": { "ID": 260684, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0878118+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264073", "Detail": { "ID": 264073, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9230371+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308783", "Detail": { "ID": 308783, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0709158+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279330", "Detail": { "ID": 279330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4975221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280017", "Detail": { "ID": 280017, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5378638+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261125", "Detail": { "ID": 261125, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1129022+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299701", "Detail": { "ID": 299701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7188664+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306815", "Detail": { "ID": 306815, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5748859+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300519", "Detail": { "ID": 300519, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0017839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223648", "Detail": { "ID": 223648, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4678264+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237473", "Detail": { "ID": 237473, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2121125+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297862", "Detail": { "ID": 297862, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1281806+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320412", "Detail": { "ID": 320412, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1652957+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316047", "Detail": { "ID": 316047, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9436439+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236284", "Detail": { "ID": 236284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9097735+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291450", "Detail": { "ID": 291450, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1198397+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234940", "Detail": { "ID": 234940, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4064209+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313617", "Detail": { "ID": 313617, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4031112+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290188", "Detail": { "ID": 290188, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4828652+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225057", "Detail": { "ID": 225057, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7426608+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265918", "Detail": { "ID": 265918, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4661819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283510", "Detail": { "ID": 283510, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7110207+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251435", "Detail": { "ID": 251435, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4634741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317632", "Detail": { "ID": 317632, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4307768+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254702", "Detail": { "ID": 254702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2800558+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296320", "Detail": { "ID": 296320, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8439304+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234878", "Detail": { "ID": 234878, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4036465+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257382", "Detail": { "ID": 257382, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0537914+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228086", "Detail": { "ID": 228086, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.58374+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292026", "Detail": { "ID": 292026, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1526795+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310692", "Detail": { "ID": 310692, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5819265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245999", "Detail": { "ID": 245999, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8678482+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298357", "Detail": { "ID": 298357, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.342258+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234391", "Detail": { "ID": 234391, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3752474+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274548", "Detail": { "ID": 274548, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1113576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269496", "Detail": { "ID": 269496, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5501327+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317193", "Detail": { "ID": 317193, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.185687+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326263", "Detail": { "ID": 326263, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7509075+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241097", "Detail": { "ID": 241097, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3959566+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289608", "Detail": { "ID": 289608, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4513574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247752", "Detail": { "ID": 247752, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4268863+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284870", "Detail": { "ID": 284870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0512524+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222459", "Detail": { "ID": 222459, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1898694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306932", "Detail": { "ID": 306932, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5800871+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240181", "Detail": { "ID": 240181, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7824467+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283425", "Detail": { "ID": 283425, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7001574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231844", "Detail": { "ID": 231844, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6179678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237801", "Detail": { "ID": 237801, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2266813+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309292", "Detail": { "ID": 309292, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1991, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Defeated", "VoteFor": 2, "VoteAgainst": 118, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310.3", "ID": 5446 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.323033+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252317", "Detail": { "ID": 252317, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1926, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian", "DisplayName": "Brian Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7239368+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258832", "Detail": { "ID": 258832, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2615, "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George", "DisplayName": "George Adam", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3298181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319896", "Detail": { "ID": 319896, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4940, "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare", "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9460658+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249635", "Detail": { "ID": 249635, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2641, "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair", "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9432962+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227730", "Detail": { "ID": 227730, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1783, "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie", "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5631876+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280731", "Detail": { "ID": 280731, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2633, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire", "DisplayName": "Claire Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7800454+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262471", "Detail": { "ID": 262471, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2603, "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Baker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6033676+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288068", "Detail": { "ID": 288068, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5038, "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne", "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.898678+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229718", "Detail": { "ID": 229718, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1759, "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia", "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0936823+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270195", "Detail": { "ID": 270195, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3751, "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5857013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322696", "Detail": { "ID": 322696, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5109, "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco", "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6997534+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294702", "Detail": { "ID": 294702, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5060, "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1746427+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242856", "Detail": { "ID": 242856, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1866, "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah", "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0385483+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235568", "Detail": { "ID": 235568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1943, "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic", "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6834197+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302126", "Detail": { "ID": 302126, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2595, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin", "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298181+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244529", "Detail": { "ID": 244529, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2103, "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith", "DisplayName": "Keith Brown", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5587113+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327235", "Detail": { "ID": 327235, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5108, "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0270737+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276654", "Detail": { "ID": 276654, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3775, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6754286+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264363", "Detail": { "ID": 264363, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2673, "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick", "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.130277+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248803", "Detail": { "ID": 248803, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2678, "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson", "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6707193+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295827", "Detail": { "ID": 295827, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2123, "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm", "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5375576+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285132", "Detail": { "ID": 285132, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3907, "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0678279+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230147", "Detail": { "ID": 230147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1735, "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela", "DisplayName": "Angela Constance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1182594+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243863", "Detail": { "ID": 243863, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1932, "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce", "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3231535+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255270", "Detail": { "ID": 255270, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1863, "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna", "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5236898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323870", "Detail": { "ID": 323870, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4976, "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth", "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9759335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291362", "Detail": { "ID": 291362, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5107, "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1160396+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265147", "Detail": { "ID": 265147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3743, "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel", "DisplayName": "Nigel Don", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1705109+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262222", "Detail": { "ID": 262222, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3771, "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob", "DisplayName": "Bob Doris", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5922015+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282010", "Detail": { "ID": 282010, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2826, "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James", "DisplayName": "James Dornan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1673142+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297963", "Detail": { "ID": 297963, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3812, "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia", "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1324274+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231626", "Detail": { "ID": 231626, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1778, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen", "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6086963+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285959", "Detail": { "ID": 285959, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4955, "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3519119+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219361", "Detail": { "ID": 219361, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1742, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle", "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2952965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238595", "Detail": { "ID": 238595, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1994, "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus", "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4608933+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225441", "Detail": { "ID": 225441, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1814, "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda", "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.974875+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321763", "Detail": { "ID": 321763, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5059, "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Fee", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4503433+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292700", "Detail": { "ID": 292700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1853, "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia", "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5540765+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226929", "Detail": { "ID": 226929, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1892, "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2530359+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312642", "Detail": { "ID": 312642, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5054, "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil", "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1370961+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257184", "Detail": { "ID": 257184, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4947, "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John", "DisplayName": "John Finnie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8269303+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271315", "Detail": { "ID": 271315, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3901, "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe", "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0701947+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278454", "Detail": { "ID": 278454, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2394, "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo", "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2195028+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286715", "Detail": { "ID": 286715, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2110, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth", "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5976265+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250462", "Detail": { "ID": 250462, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2675, "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob", "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1905898+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220930", "Detail": { "ID": 220930, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1741, "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel", "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.66777+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220284", "Detail": { "ID": 220284, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1756, "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine", "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6346412+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251843", "Detail": { "ID": 251843, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1860, "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda", "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.491531+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266141", "Detail": { "ID": 266141, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2033, "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain", "DisplayName": "Iain Gray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4760939+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324563", "Detail": { "ID": 324563, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5042, "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2283827+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259905", "Detail": { "ID": 259905, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2892, "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick", "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6350924+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239302", "Detail": { "ID": 239302, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2029, "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh", "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7309499+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273834", "Detail": { "ID": 273834, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3758, "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6376809+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304203", "Detail": { "ID": 304203, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4086, "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim", "DisplayName": "Jim Hume", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0281518+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221765", "Detail": { "ID": 221765, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1773, "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9468508+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241998", "Detail": { "ID": 241998, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1882, "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam", "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7894257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223727", "Detail": { "ID": 223727, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1893, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4711716+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307547", "Detail": { "ID": 307547, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "No", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4934, "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone", "PartyAbbreviation": "Green", "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8342317+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272201", "Detail": { "ID": 272201, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4956, "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin", "DisplayName": "Colin Keir", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3192351+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244864", "Detail": { "ID": 244864, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2059, "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James", "DisplayName": "James Kelly", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5818969+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315036", "Detail": { "ID": 315036, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3129, "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6713172+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247966", "Detail": { "ID": 247966, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2080, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann", "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4359991+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274771", "Detail": { "ID": 274771, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4016, "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John", "DisplayName": "John Lamont", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.121034+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255816", "Detail": { "ID": 255816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2180, "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.558298+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277474", "Detail": { "ID": 277474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4938, "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9549222+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252996", "Detail": { "ID": 252996, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2112, "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny", "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7623575+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277178", "Detail": { "ID": 277178, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4939, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus", "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.704437+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325568", "Detail": { "ID": 325568, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5074, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon", "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5119519+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232808", "Detail": { "ID": 232808, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1828, "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo", "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8771302+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311394", "Detail": { "ID": 311394, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4948, "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike", "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8768224+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230438", "Detail": { "ID": 230438, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2117, "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis", "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.329821+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267330", "Detail": { "ID": 267330, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2108, "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken", "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0147895+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313767", "Detail": { "ID": 313767, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4966, "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek", "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4097839+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295419", "Detail": { "ID": 295419, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3101, "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala", "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5113574+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319013", "Detail": { "ID": 319013, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5034, "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny", "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6886929+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306451", "Detail": { "ID": 306451, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2159, "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Martin", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5526447+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310400", "Detail": { "ID": 310400, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5110, "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John", "DisplayName": "John Mason", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5688815+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268273", "Detail": { "ID": 268273, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2133, "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2599598+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286142", "Detail": { "ID": 286142, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2876, "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3657083+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260683", "Detail": { "ID": 260683, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4951, "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan", "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0877709+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264072", "Detail": { "ID": 264072, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3896, "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam", "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9229965+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308785", "Detail": { "ID": 308785, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5080, "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0711053+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279331", "Detail": { "ID": 279331, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4964, "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark", "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4975637+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280016", "Detail": { "ID": 280016, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3824, "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.537789+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261124", "Detail": { "ID": 261124, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2066, "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie", "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1128605+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299700", "Detail": { "ID": 299700, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4080, "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison", "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7188257+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306816", "Detail": { "ID": 306816, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3759, "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina", "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5749276+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300518", "Detail": { "ID": 300518, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2487, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen", "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0017428+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223679", "Detail": { "ID": 223679, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1775, "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona", "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4691507+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237474", "Detail": { "ID": 237474, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1961, "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David", "DisplayName": "David McLetchie", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2121547+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305416", "Detail": { "ID": 305416, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2134, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3230819+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320413", "Detail": { "ID": 320413, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5041, "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan", "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.165337+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316046", "Detail": { "ID": 316046, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3763, "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart", "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9435888+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236285", "Detail": { "ID": 236285, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1986, "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan", "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9098157+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291449", "Detail": { "ID": 291449, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5047, "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne", "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1197988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234939", "Detail": { "ID": 234939, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1845, "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette", "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4063783+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313616", "Detail": { "ID": 313616, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3061, "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret", "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4030704+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290189", "Detail": { "ID": 290189, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1768, "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4829062+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225058", "Detail": { "ID": 225058, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1894, "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Neil", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7427013+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265917", "Detail": { "ID": 265917, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2010, "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil", "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4661404+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283353", "Detail": { "ID": 283353, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5057, "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme", "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6970362+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251436", "Detail": { "ID": 251436, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2853, "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John", "DisplayName": "John Pentland", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4635168+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317633", "Detail": { "ID": 317633, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5009, "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie", "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4308178+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254701", "Detail": { "ID": 254701, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3745, "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis", "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2800139+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296321", "Detail": { "ID": 296321, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1870, "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona", "DisplayName": "Shona Robison", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8439714+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234879", "Detail": { "ID": 234879, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2135, "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael", "DisplayName": "Michael Russell", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4036872+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257383", "Detail": { "ID": 257383, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1895, "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex", "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0538325+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228118", "Detail": { "ID": 228118, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1839, "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary", "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5851221+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292025", "Detail": { "ID": 292025, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2345, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John", "DisplayName": "John Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1526388+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310693", "Detail": { "ID": 310693, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2223, "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish", "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott", "PartyAbbreviation": "LD", "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats", "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5819673+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246339", "Detail": { "ID": 246339, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2182, "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard", "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1244694+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298356", "Detail": { "ID": 298356, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5079, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew", "DisplayName": "Drew Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3422174+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234390", "Detail": { "ID": 234390, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1769, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine", "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3752063+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274549", "Detail": { "ID": 274549, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4014, "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz", "DisplayName": "Liz Smith", "PartyAbbreviation": "Con", "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1113988+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269497", "Detail": { "ID": 269497, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2215, "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart", "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5501741+00:00" }, { "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317194", "Detail": { "ID": 317194, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Not Voted", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 3806, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David", "DisplayName": "David Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab", "PartyName": "Scottish Labour", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1857283+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326262", "Detail": { "ID": 326262, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5106, "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin", "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7508661+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241130", "Detail": { "ID": 241130, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1848, "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola", "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4033377+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289609", "Detail": { "ID": 289609, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2098, "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John", "DisplayName": "John Swinney", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4513984+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247753", "Detail": { "ID": 247753, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2674, "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave", "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4269268+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284871", "Detail": { "ID": 284871, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5075, "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David", "DisplayName": "David Torrance", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0512926+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222460", "Detail": { "ID": 222460, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1793, "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean", "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1899107+00:00" }, { "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306931", "Detail": { "ID": 306931, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "No" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 5078, "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill", "DisplayName": "Bill Walker", "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind", "PartyName": "Independent", "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5800466+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240147", "Detail": { "ID": 240147, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1841, "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen", "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7809764+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283422", "Detail": { "ID": 283422, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4952, "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul", "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7000335+00:00" }, { "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232234", "Detail": { "ID": 232234, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 1865, "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra", "DisplayName": "Sandra White", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8459386+00:00" }, { "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237800", "Detail": { "ID": 237800, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 2610, "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John", "DisplayName": "John Wilson", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.226641+00:00" }, { "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309291", "Detail": { "ID": 309291, "MotionAgendaItemID": 1992, "AgendaID": 2518, "Decision": "Division", "DecisionID": 3, "VoteMSP": "Yes", "VoteResult": "Carried", "VoteFor": 118, "VoteAgainst": 2, "VoteCasting": null, "MSPSharesParty": "Yes" }, "Motion": { "Title": "Oil and Gas, The Success and Opportunities", "Reference": "S4M-05310", "ID": 5439 }, "Person": { "ID": 4941, "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza", "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf", "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP", "PartyName": "Scottish National Party", "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow" }, "Time": { "Start": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "End": "2013-01-09T00:00:00", "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2", "Session": "S4" }, "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3229913+00:00" } ]